Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
www.elsevier.com/locate/urbwat
Case study
Abstract
After the disastrous ¯ood of 1988, Dhaka Integrated Flood Protection Project (DIFPP) was undertaken as a part of the national
Flood Action Plan (FAP). However, DIFPP focused primarily on the structural measures for ¯ood damage mitigation. When the
city was hit by another major ¯ood in 1998, it became evident that non-structural measures contributed signi®cantly to ¯ood
damage reduction. This paper explores existing and proposed non-structural measures as a part of the long-term ¯ood mitigation
strategies for Dhaka City. The options examined in this paper include ¯ood forecasting and warning, preservation of retention
ponds, land use planning, ¯ood zoning, emergency services, shelters, ¯ood proo®ng, ¯ood ®ghting and post-¯ood rehabilitation
measures. Moreover, experiences from 1998 ¯ood indicate that coordination between agencies responsible for ¯ood protection and
drainage of the city can signi®cantly reduce the ¯ood damage. Ó 2000 Elsevier Science Ltd. All rights reserved.
Keywords: Non-structural measures; Flood forecasting and warning; Retention pond; Flood proo®ng; Flood ®ghting; Flood zoning; Flood
insurance; Inter-agency coordination; Integrated ¯ood protection; Dhaka City
1462-0758/00/$ - see front matter Ó 2000 Elsevier Science Ltd. All rights reserved.
PII: S 1 4 6 2 - 0 7 5 8 ( 0 0 ) 0 0 0 0 4 - 2
146 I.M. Faisal et al. / Urban Water 1 (1999) 145±153
Fig. 1. Rivers surrounding Dhaka City and average ¯ooding pattern before 1988.
2. Causes of ¯ooding in Dhaka and the ®rst two weeks of September. Flood peaks of
1987, 1988 and 1998 followed the same pattern as shown
The historic reason of ¯ooding in Dhaka City is the in Figs. 2±5. However, the rivers may cross the danger
rise in water levels of the rivers bordering the city and level early on due to the heavy onrush of water from the
heavy seasonal rainfall. Recently Dhaka City experi- upstream areas and concurrent heavy rainfall. This may
enced two major ¯oods, one in 1988 and the other in prolong the duration of ¯ood and considerably increase
1998. The former was primarily caused by excessive the ¯ood damage, which was the case in 1998.
transboundary in¯ow and lack of any ¯ood protection The main dierence between the major ¯oods of 1988
structure for the city. The latter was primarily caused by and 1998 is that the former peaked very quickly and had
heavy rainfall all over the catchment areas of the major a duration of about three weeks whereas the latter
rivers ¯owing through Bangladesh. showed a smaller early peak which prevailed until the
In addition, internal drainage congestion induced by second peak that arrived in the second week of Sep-
heavy rainfall, leakage through buried pipes, culverts tember. Thus, duration of the 1998 ¯ood was more than
and ¯oodwalls, untimely gate operation, inadequate two months making it the longest ¯ood in the history of
pumping and lack of institutional coordination have Dhaka City. In terms of ¯ood height, 1988 ¯ood peaks
signi®cantly contributed to worsening the ¯ood situa- were higher compared to the same of 1998. Essential
tion. statistics of the ¯oods of 1987, 1988 and 1998 are sum-
marized in Table 1, where the ¯ood duration is mea-
2.1. Rise in river water level sured by the number of days a river remained above its
danger level. The entry ÔNAÕ means that danger level
In the recent past (between 1979 and 1998), rivers of was not de®ned as in the case of Balu, which ¯ows along
Dhaka approached their danger levels in the second half the low-lying ¯oodplains.
of July and receded in the last 10 days of September. Another noticeable dierence between the ¯oods of
Peak ¯ows occurred typically in the last week of August 1988 and 1998 aecting Dhaka City is that the former
I.M. Faisal et al. / Urban Water 1 (1999) 145±153 147
Table 1
Floods peak and duration in the rivers surrounding Dhaka City
crossing of the danger levels by all the rivers surround- The second type of leakage occurred due to the entry
ing Dhaka City in 1998. of ¯oodwater through open underground pipes and
open culverts in the northern part of the city (Nikunja,
2.2. Internal drainage congestion Cantonment and Baridhara area). These pipes were not
monitored or maintained by any particular authority.
Internal drainage congestion is usually caused by After completion of about 80% of Phase I of DIFPP,
heavy short-duration rainfall. Fig. 7 shows daily rain- areas such as Banani, Gulshan, Baridhara and Tejgaon
falls for the months of July±September 1998. Periods of should not have been ¯ooded in 1998. Field investiga-
sharp peaks in this ®gure were the ones that caused short tors of DWASA and Bangladesh Water Development
duration ¯ooding in dierent parts of Dhaka. Board (BWDB) found that there are four drainage pipes
The areas particularly vulnerable to waterlogging of about 4 feet diameter near the Cantonment Railway
include Shantinagar, Nayapaltan, Rajarbag, Dhan- Station. These pipes connect the Nikunja area with the
mondi, Azimpur and Greenroad. Dhaka Water and ¯ood plain on the eastern side. Divers veri®ed that these
Sewerage Authority (DWASA) has taken initiatives to pipes were buried under 15 feet of water during the peak
alleviate this problem by renovating and constructing ¯ood. The Roads and Highways Department placed
box culverts and installing pumps of sucient capacity these pipes sometime in 1978 and these were supposedly
to drain out the storm water. The problem of internal open during the ¯ood allowing ¯oodwater to enter in-
¯ooding and drainage congestion is further exacerbated side the protected area. Lakes of Banani and Gulshan
by poor maintenance of the surface and underground are hydraulically connected to the low-lying areas of
drainage network of the city. Nikunja and water eventually back ¯owed into these
areas causing ¯ood. DWASA ocials indicated that
2.3. Leakage of ¯oodwater there may be a few other open pipes and culverts along
the Biswa Road that have to be identi®ed and closed
During the disastrous ¯ood of 1998, several leakage before the next ¯ood season to provide better ¯ood
points, which contributed to the partial ¯ooding of the protection to the Baridhara±Gulshan±Mohakhali area.
western (protected) part of the city, have been identi®ed.
Two types of leakage were identi®ed in 1998. The ®rst
one was due to incomplete construction of the ¯oodwall 3. Current ¯ood management practices
along the Buriganga River in the southern part of the
city. During implementation of Phase I of Dhaka Inte- 3.1. Institutions
grated Flood Protection Project (DIFPP), some existing
structures could not be removed due to public pressure Flood protection and drainage of Dhaka City is
or other diculties. One such prominent structure is the provided by a number of organizations, which include
inland river port of Dhaka at Sadarghat. During high BWDB, DWASA and DCC.
¯ood, water entered into the protected area through this BWDB is responsible for ¯ood protection and miti-
facility. In a number of places, people removed parts of gation for the entire country, including Dhaka. It con-
the ¯oodwall for easy movement creating openings for structs and maintains embankments, ¯oodwalls,
¯oodwater. It was also noticed during ®eld visit that regulators and pumping stations. BWDB also provides
there were many buried sewerage pipes that passed under ¯ood forecasting and warning through the Flood
the ¯oodwall disposing domestic sewage directly into the Forecasting and Warning Center (FFWC). DWASA is
river. During ¯ood, water ¯owed back through these primarily responsible for water supply and drainage. A
pipes into the city. All these openings have to be sealed small part of the drainage network in the southern part
o to ensure complete ¯ood protection in this area. of the city is maintained by DCC.
4. Non-structural measures
proposed retention ponds in Dhaka City are shown in business, industrial and natural uses. Developed coun-
Fig. 9. tries such as the US have introduced the concept of
An important reason for internal ¯ooding of the city ¯ood zoning where land is categorized based on risk of
in 1998 was that the drainage network in many parts of inundation. This is followed by appropriate regulations
the city was silted up (to as much as 70%) and was to ensure that highly ¯ood prone areas are spared from
unable to carry the design discharge. This was due to intensive capital investments and dwellers of that area
indiscriminate disposal of solid waste in both the surface are covered through ¯ood insurance. In the US, ¯ood
and subsurface drains and runo from construction sites insurance program is federally funded and provided
heavily loaded with sediments. Fig. 10 shows a couple through large private companies such as AARP Insur-
of city drains nearly clogged and the approach canal ance Program, AmericaÕs Flood Services, Fidelity
almost ®lled up due to indiscriminate disposal of National Flood, and Proctor Financial Insurance
solid waste. Only public awareness and active public Company, to name a few.
participation can help eliminate this problem in future. In the context of Dhaka City, RAJUK can make two
important contributions through land use planning. One,
4.3. Land use planning RAJUK, with the help of BWDB, can locate and protect
the potential sites for retention ponds in the eastern part
Land use planning is carried out to optimize the use of Dhaka. RAJUK has already prepared the guidelines
of land based on its geographical, topographical, cli- for minimum ground level elevation of the land®ll and
matic and soil characteristics. In the context of city de- development ranging from 4.5 to 6.0 m (PWD datum).
velopment, it means delineating land for residential, Additionally, RAJUK can carefully design the drainage
Fig. 9. Location of retention ponds in the Dhaka City Master Plan (shown as circles).
I.M. Faisal et al. / Urban Water 1 (1999) 145±153 151
network for the eastern part so that the problems 4.5. Other non-structural activities
encountered in the western part are not repeated.
Individuals, groups of people, NGOs and the gov-
ernment practice a variety of other non-structural means
4.4. Insurance
to mitigate ¯ood damage. Limited information is
available on the extent of use of these means, which are
Introducing ¯ood insurance in developing countries is
summarized in Table 2.
dicult for a number of reasons. First, accurate ¯ood
zoning and depth-damage relationship have to be pre-
pared to determine the risk of ¯ood damage and cor-
responding premium. Second, insurance agencies are 5. Feedback from experts and general public
not well developed in the LDCs and these companies
face the `adverse location' problem. What it means is In order to incorporate views on long-term ¯ood
that if only ¯ood insurance is provided by a company, it mitigation strategies from dierent sectors of the society,
is likely to receive many claims after a particular ¯ood, several key professionals, public representatives and a
which will make its operation ®nancially impossible. random sample of general public were interviewed after
Thus, ¯ood insurance has to be provided by large in- the ¯ood of 1998. The key professionals are with
surance companies, which have the leverage of diverting DWASA, BWDB, Bangladesh University of Engineer-
funds from other forms of insurance policies. The loss is ing and Technology (BUET) and Dhaka University
thereby distributed across dierent communities and (DU). This group was involved in planning and imple-
regions. Another problem, common to all locations is mentation of various ¯ood mitigation activities and their
the `moral hazard' issue, where the clients make exag- opinions are summarized in Table 3.
gerated and false claims. This is partly related to the It is evident from Table 3 (answer to question 5) that
education and awareness of the community being in- non-structural measures such as ¯ood forecasting and
sured and may cause serious monitoring and assessment warning, ¯ood zoning and ¯ood shelter have been
diculties. Finally, due to voluntary nature of the so- identi®ed as important means of ¯ood mitigation by all
lution, its eectiveness is always somewhat doubtful. In the experts interviewed. Additionally, inter-agency
short, it is unlikely that private companies of Bangla- coordination has been strongly emphasized. In fact, one
desh will introduce ¯ood insurance in the near future. of the reasons for ¯ooding of the western part of Dhaka
The government may collect special ¯ood protection tax was miscommunication between DWASA, BDWB and
and use the money for compensation. Such initiative is Bangladesh Agricultural Development Corporation
practically the same as imposing additional tax for (BADC). Speci®cally, the lack of coordination between
public bene®t. DWASA and BWDB had contributed to a month-long
152 I.M. Faisal et al. / Urban Water 1 (1999) 145±153
Table 2
Non-structural activities practiced by various groups
Emergency services Medical care (water born diseases, Hospitals, DWASA, Red Widely practiced. Usually limited
snake bite, etc.), potable water, food, Crescent, GOB, NGOs, to accessible places
candle, fuel, clothing, temporary Defense forces, Political
housing, shelter groups and general public
Flood proo®ng Raising the plinth level of the house, Individuals and some RAJUK has proposed minimum
building on tall pillars, ¯ood walls businesses and industries, ground elevations for the eastern
along properties, raising important GOB part of Dhaka City
roads and some power stations above
the 1988 ¯ood level, special embank-
ment for the international airport
Flood ®ghting Temporary ¯oodwall (brick or sand Individuals and some People try to ®ght ¯oods till they
bags), pumping, moving assets to businesses and industries are forced to evacuate
upper ¯oors, roof or dry places such
as high roads and embankments
Flood shelter Community centers, schools, Flood victims, community Facilities used as shelters are not
colleges, public buildings, roads, volunteers, emergency service designed as such and do not have
embankments providers sucient capacity
Recovery and Vulnerable group feeding, food for GOB, NGOs, banks and Aected group have very limited
reconstruction work, building materials, soft or private initiatives access to such help. Pilferage of
interest-free loans for business and relief and rehabilitation material
agriculture or fund
Table 3
Summary of opinions of the key professionalsa
1. What are the main causes of 1998 ¯ood? HR, PS, HT, TBF HR, SM, Tsu HR HR, TBF
2. What do you think are the main causes of IP, DC, HL HL, GOF, IP DC DC, HL, GOF, IP
¯ooding in Dhaka City?
3. What major damages were caused by 1998 Rd, Em Rd, H H, Rd, I Rd, H, I
¯ood to Dhaka City?
4. How can Dhaka City be freed from Phase I, II, TGO, HL, TGO, AP, Phase II Phase I and II, IDE
¯ooding in future? AP, IDE IDE, Phase II
5. What other things can be done to FW, FZ, IAC, FSh PAA, IAC FW, FSh FZ, FSh, FW, IAC
minimize ¯ood damage in Dhaka City?
6. How can the costs of ¯ood protection for FA, SL, GOB LDT, DSr GOB GOB, LDT
Dhaka City be ®nanced?
a
Notes: AP: adequate pumping; DC: drainage congestion; DSr: drainage surcharge; Em: embankment; FA: foreign aid; FSh: ¯ood shelter; FW:
forecasting and warning; FZ: ¯ood zoning; GOB: government of Bangladesh; GOF: gate operation failure; H: housing; HL: hydraulic leakage; HR:
heavy rainfall; HT: high tide; I: industry; IAC: inter-agency coordination; IDE: improved drainage eciency; IP: inadequate pumping; LDT: land
development tax; PAA: public awareness and activism; Phase I and II: phases of DIFPP; PS: Peak synchronization; Rd: road; SL: soft loan; SM:
snow melt; TBF: transboundary ¯ow; TGO: timely gate operation; Tsu: tsunami.
delay in closing the regulator at Rampura Bridge during Opinions expressed by the general public (100 ran-
which ¯oodwater entered into the city. Moreover, de- domly selected individuals) were similar to the opinions
ployment of pumps was also delayed, as pumps had to expressed by the experts. According to this group,
be brought from BADC. Many of these pumps were in ¯ood proo®ng and improved ¯ood warning system are
the storage for nearly 10 years (since the ¯ood of 1988) the most eective means of minimizing ¯ood damage.
and were inoperative. Pump operators complained that Moreover, individual preparedness has been mentioned
sucient fuel was not allocated to operate these pumps as the best way to minimize personal loss due to
on continuous basis. Eventually, when the problems ¯ooding. This re¯ects people's preference for self-reli-
were taken care of by mid-August, a large part of the ance in combating the ¯ood and the inadequacy of
city was already under water (Faisal, Kabir & Nishat, GOB and NGO measures in helping out the ¯ood
1999). victims.
I.M. Faisal et al. / Urban Water 1 (1999) 145±153 153
Ward Commissioners (public representatives) em- City. It appears that non-structural methods have not
phasized on preserving the natural depressions and lakes received due attention compared to the structural ap-
within the city that serve as retention ponds for holding proaches of ¯ood protection and mitigation. Since
water from rain and internal drainage. They speci®cally structural methods are very expensive and may not
mentioned that people living in slums had been badly provide 100% ¯ood protection, non-structural methods
aected by ¯ooding. This group suggested that more have a very important role to play. A well-coordinated
and better shelters could signi®cantly reduce human and balanced combination of both structural and non-
suerings and loss of life due to ¯ooding. structural measures is recommended as the long-term
¯ood mitigation strategy for Dhaka City.
6. Conclusion
References
This paper has examined the non-structural measures
Faisal, I. M., Kabir, M. R., & Nishat, A. (1999). Development of long-
that are currently used or can be used in future as part of term strategies for loss minimization and ¯ood management of
the long-term ¯ood mitigation strategies for Dhaka Dhaka City. Report submitted to the Department of Environment,
City. Non-structural measures that require institutional Dhaka, Bangladesh.
planning encompassing the entire city include improved FAP-8A. (1991). JICA master plan study for greater Dhaka. Japan
digital elevation model based real-time ¯ood forecasting International Cooperation Agency, Dhaka Oce.
FAP-8B. (1991). ADB Dhaka Integrated Flood Protection Project
and warning, preservation of adequate number of re- (DIFPP). Louis Berger International, Dhaka Oce.
tention ponds and land use planning, including ¯ood GOB. (1998). Dhaka integrated ¯ood control-cum-eastern bypass road
zoning. Other ¯ood damage mitigation measures prac- multipurpose project. Working Paper (5 November 1998) of the
ticed by individuals, groups and organizations include Project Steering Committe. Government Of Bangladesh, Dhaka.
Kachic, A. S. (1998). The ¯ood forecasts and warning programme in
provision of emergency services and shelters, ¯ood
Bangladesh. In Bangladesh ¯oods: views from home and abroad.
proo®ng, ¯ood ®ghting and post-¯ood rehabilitation. Dhaka: The University Press.
Collectively, these measures signi®cantly reduce the RAJUK. (1995). Dhaka metropolitan development plan (1995±2015),
¯ood damage for the 8 million inhabitants of Dhaka vols. I and II. Dhaka: RAJUK.