Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
The right of Markus Venzin, Carsten Rasner, and Volker Mahnke to be identified as the
authors of this work has been asserted by them in accordance with the Copyright, Designs
and Patents Act 1988.
A CIP record for this book is available from the British Library
ISBN 1-904879-11-X
Contents
4. Market Analysis . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 61
What are the uses of a careful analysis of the market? . . . . . . 62
How are relevant markets defined? . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 64
What influence do general segment factors exercise? . . . . . . . 71
How can the industry structure be described? . . . . . . . . . . . . 75
How can the future development of the market be described? 85
How can conclusions be drawn from market analysis? . . . . . 92
110423 Cyan Strat Pro 01 8/3/05 1:18 PM Page 6
6 Contents
5 Company Analysis . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 97
Why is the resource-based approach attracting
more attention? . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 98
What kinds of resources and capabilities can be
distinguished? . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 100
How can the strategic value of resources and capabilities
be established? . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 102
How can knowledge be systematically analyzed? . . . . . . . . . 106
Which tools are relevant? That is, what is both academically sound
and viable in practice?
When does analysis deliver the right results, and what must be
watched out for when doing it?
110423 Cyan Strat Pro 01 8/3/05 1:18 PM Page 8
This book will provide you with comprehensive answers and constitutes
a guide to the challenges of everyday management. We are convinced
that entrepreneurial practice can benefit greatly from academically
sound methods, so we have also included the theoretical basis and the
categorization and systematization of our recommendations.
What we want to pass on to you is knowledge in process management.
When you have finished reading, you should be able to manage
strategy processes systematically. You should know what strategic alter-
natives are available to you, which tools you should employ in which
phase, and how to deal intelligently and responsibly with the “human
factor.” The strategy process is the central theme of this book. In
practice, it will provide you with a logical structure for developing and
implementing strategic initiatives. “What do I do when?” and “What
results should I expect to achieve?” are the questions determining each
individual stage. This is why at the beginning of each chapter you will
find a short introduction summarizing the formulation of the main
processes. At the end of each stage, we set out the results you should
have achieved.
To a certain extent, this book is also intended to provide an
alternative to the “management escapades” of the recent past. As we
see it, bankruptcies, stock-exchange scandals, and management errors
running into billions of dollars have created a false impression of
management. The swiftest possible growth, product designs that are
not what the customer wants, and unfounded equity stories generating
enormous media coverage have taken the place of sound management
practice. People who are permanently occupied in keeping investors
happy often have no time to think situations through, try out alterna-
tives to the current trend, or implement strategies in a logical way. It is
certainly not an intellectual problem for most managers to manage
strategically. It is much more of a mental problem. Strategic manage-
ment requires patience, realism, and logic. Patience, because strategies
take time to develop within the market and particularly within the
company itself. Realism, because 100 percent growth per quarter and
returns that are permanently above the market average break all the
laws of economics. Logic, because strategy processes represent a
demanding management task that involves convincing people and
110423 Cyan Strat Pro 01 8/3/05 1:18 PM Page 9
Developing a
corporate
strategy
Market
analysis
Company
analysis
Developing
functional
strategies
Performance monitoring
Initiating the strategy process. Initiating the strategy process (Table 1.2)
means recognizing relevant themes, setting priorities, and persuading
the company to get to grips with these themes. Business or industry
blindness, personal interests, increased market complexity, and opera-
tional time pressure make it more difficult to identify and set priorities
for strategic themes. Many companies overburden their employees
with strategic projects, and do not understand how to evaluate themes
and relate them to one another. The mission statement offers a good
basis for differentiating between what is important and what is un-
important. The mission statement contains a description of the
company’s purpose and system of values. A good mission statement
also clearly describes the markets in which the company intends to be
active. In this first phase, besides developing clear strategic themes, the
rules of the strategic process will be laid down. The discussions and
experiences that take place during the strategy process are usually
more important than the actual output – the strategic plan. “Plans are
nothing – planning is everything,” so the maxim says.
This does not mean that the strategy process has to degenerate into
an esoteric exchange of ideas. The development of a strategy can be
considered as a learning process, and what counts at the end of this
process are the experiences acquired and the discoveries made:
strategy as “learning by doing” (Mintzberg 1999). By contrast, a
written record of the strategic plan often interferes with the learning
process. Other managers and academics describe the development of a
strategy as a planning process (Ansoff 1965): not “learning by doing”
but “learning before doing.” In their view, strategy development is an
objective and rational procedure. Arbitrary experiments should be
avoided as far as possible. So, not surprisingly, experience gained in
practice shows that the optimum strategy process has something of
both: “learning before, by, and after doing.” Finding the right approach
to the process, one that will both present managers with new experi-
Table 1.2: Summary of questions and management tools for initiating the
strategy process
110423 Cyan Strat Pro 01 8/3/05 1:18 PM Page 15
ences and make specific use of their previous experience, is the main
objective in this phase.
The schematic structure of this book and the presentation of the
strategic process in nine stages may give the impression that the
authors are for the most part following the arguments of Igor Ansoff.
This is not true. We are convinced that strategy work is largely a
creative act, not a purely analytical procedure.We are conscious that in
practice you will rarely find the analytical distinction between the
various stages in its pure form. However, the process scheme will help
you to understand and manage strategic processes. Just as artists first
learn to depict objects in a recognizable way before being allowed to
devote themselves to abstract art, managers must learn the tools of
strategic management in order to become “strategy virtuosi.”
Market analysis. After the strategic themes have been identified and
classified, they are worked on. If the market has been analyzed first, the
phrase “market-based approach to strategic management” is used.The
company tries to gain the best possible understanding of the market
in order to define its own position in a way that will maximize profit.
So the management is clearly market-oriented, and adapts its own
resources and capabilities to suit. This approach works best in relatively
stable markets.The first stage of a market analysis (Table 1.3) is there-
fore the clear segmentation of the markets. If we generalize about
markets that differ too widely, we risk only getting superficial or false
results, as different strategies are recommended for different market
segments.
After the market segmentation, the general market environment is
analyzed.This includes describing trends from the political, economic,
sociocultural, and technological fields. After that, the structure of the
specific segment is examined. Despite its age, the five-forces model
(Porter 1980) is probably still the most commonly used tool for this.
After the current market situation has been recorded, it is used to think
about the future development of the market segment. Methods such as
the scenario technique, regression analysis, the game-theory approach,
or the working-out of analogies could be used here. Experience shows
that, at this point in the strategy process, many companies get lost in a
jumble of data and have difficulty structuring the information. Hence
our tip: When doing the analysis, just concentrate on one strategic
question and only collect data that can help you improve the quality of
110423 Cyan Strat Pro 01 8/3/05 1:18 PM Page 16
Table 1.3: Summary of questions and management tools for market analysis
the answer to this question. In addition, you should try to present the
market analysis in summary form in a few key statements. It is often
presented in the form of key success factors.Take care to see that these
success factors are formulated in such a way as not to contain any
110423 Cyan Strat Pro 01 8/3/05 1:18 PM Page 17
Table 1.4: Summary of questions and management tools for company analysis
110423 Cyan Strat Pro 01 8/3/05 1:18 PM Page 18
is to exploit these resources and capabilities in such a way that the firm
can be actively involved in shaping the market or even to develop a
new market.
strategic option are worked out before strategies are developed. This
creates a “fair process,” or to put it another way: The decision-makers
agree with the selection procedures, even though they may not be
happy with the content of the decision.
Developing a business strategy. At the business unit level (Table 1.7), the
question is how a market segment can be worked on successfully:
“How can the business unit stand out in contrast to the competition
and provide a unique value-added output (product or service)?” The
business unit is directly exposed to the competition. The main objective
of a business is to develop competitive advantages that will last as
long as possible. The nature of these competitive advantages will be
determined both by the capabilities and resources of the company and by
customer requirements and market structures. If a lower price influences
the customer in your favor, it is called a cost-leadership strategy. If
the customer is prepared to pay a price premium, it is known as a
differentiation strategy.
The competitive advantages of a cost-leadership strategy arise
mainly from the ability to produce large numbers of items. A business
unit opts for differentiation if the product on offer is distinguished
from the competition by special features such as design, image, quality,
or functionality. Once this basic strategy has been determined, unique