Drain-4 Size 1.0X1.25

MUNICIPAL CORPORATION, SONEPAT, HARYANA
Rehabilitation of Drain No.6 into RCC Strom Water Drain

along with its covering and Construction of other City Drains
in Sonepat Town under AMRUT Program
Design Note No : INFRA/SON/DR/004
Revision : R1
Date : 27/12/2017
Title : Design of City Drain Type-4 (Section Size 1.0 X 1.25)
Submitted By:
Contractor/Executing Agency : M/s MSKEL-GARG (JV)
Structural Consultant :
Infrastructure Technologies
Innovative infrastructure engineering through cutting edge technologies
187, Block-III, Ganga Shopping Complex, Sector -29,
Noida -201301, Uttar Pradesh, India
Tele Fax : +91 120 4253207
Email : info@infratech.org.in
Web : www.infratech.org.in
Project Rehabilitation of Drain No.6 into RCC Strom Water Drain alongwith its covering and Construction of Infrastructure Technologies
other City Drains in Sonepat Town under AMRUT Program Consultant: Innovative infrastructure engineering through cutting edge technologies
Client Municipal Corporation, Sonepat, Haryana
Contractor M/s MSKEL-GARG (JV) Calc by : TK Design Note No & Revision INFRA/SON/DR/004-R1
Title Design of City Drain Type-4 (Section Size 1.0 X 1.25) Checked by: PK Date 27-12-2017
1.0 GEOMETRIC DATA FOR MODELING

No L_Part
Length of top Slab 1.15 m 8 0.14375
0.2
Length of bot Slab 1.15 m 8 0.14375
Length of bot Cantilever 0.175 m 2 0.0875
Height of side wall 1.625 8 0.203125 0.15 1.0 0.15
Width of Strip 1 m
Free Board 0.15 m
1.45
1.2 GEOTECHNICAL DATA
3
Modulus of subgrde Reaction for Loose sand 1.5 Kg/cm
3
15000 kN/m
Spring 0.1 0.1
Point No width
Dist To Next Constant
0.15
1 0.0875 1 656
2 0.0875 1 1313
3 0.14375 1 1734
4 0.14375 1 2156
5 0.14375 1 2156
6 0.14375 1 2156
7 0.14375 1 2156
8 0.14375 1 2156
9 0.14375 1 2156
10 0.14375 1 2156
11 0.0875 1 1734
12 0.0875 1 1313
13 1 656
Page 1 of 35
1.3 LOADS
1.3.1 Self Weight SW
Selfweight is applied directly in STAAD

3
Unit Weight of Concrete Taken 25 kN/m
1.3.2 Load Of Finishes LOF

Thickness 0.056 m
1.4 KN/m 0.15 1.0 0.15
1.3.3 CLASS - A Wheel Load CALL
Only One wheel of the axle can come on top slab 0.5
Only Two heaviest adjecent axle of 11.4 T considered
Axle Load (maximum) 114 KN
0.362 85.5
Wheel Load 57 KN
Impact Factor 0.5
Wheel Load Including Impact 85.5 KN 0.194 0.612 1.2
W 0.5 m
B 0.25 m
85.5
Thickness of Finishes 0.056 m
Wt 0.612 m
Bt 0.362 m
bredth of concentration area b1 0.362 m
Ellective Span lo 1 m
width of slab b 20 m
b/lo 20
α 2.6
a 0.5 m
beff 1.012 m No. Overlap
Effective Load for width of strip 84.486166 KN
Effective Load per m length 138.04929 kN/m For Structural Design of Members
Page 2 of 35
For Base Pressure check this load is further Dispersed through Height of Box at an angle of 45 deg
Effective width 4.612 m Overlap
Overlap width 3.412 m
Effective width for two loads 5.812 m
Effective Load for width of strip 29.421886 KN
Effective Load per m length 48.074977 KN/m
load start distance 0.444 m

Load End Distance 1.056 m
D1 D2
Load start Member no 14 0.12525 0.14375
Load End Member no 19 0 0.019
Intermidiate Member No 15 To 18
1.3.4 Weight of Water on base slab in Drain Running Full Condition WWBSDRFC
3
Density of water 1 T/m
3
γW 9.81 kN/m
Total Weight of Water 12.753 kN
Weight of water on Bottom slab per m 12.753 kN/m
Page 3 of 35
0.15 1.0 0.15

1.3.5 Water Pressure on Walls in Drain Running Full Condition WPWDRFC
0.2
2
Water Pressure at top Node 0 kN/m
2
Water Pressure at Bottom Node 15.94125 kN/m
Total Height 1.625
Height Incriment 0.203125
Pressure Increment 1.9926563
POINT Pressure 1.45
1 0.000
2 1.993
3 3.985
4 5.978
5 7.971 0.1 0.1
6 9.963
0.15
7 11.956
8 13.949
9 15.941
1.3.6 Uplift Pressure Due to water table at Ground Level UPBSWTGL
Total Height 1.8 m

2
Uplift Pressure 17.658 kN/m
Uplift Pressure per unit length of base 17.658 kN/m
Page 4 of 35
1.3.7 Water Pressure Due to water Table at Ground Level WPWWTGL 0.981 0.981
0.2
2
Water Pressure at top Node 0.981 kN/m
2
Water Pressure at Bottom Node 16.92225 kN/m 0.15 1.0 0.15
Total Height 1.625
POINT Pressure 1.45
1 0.981
2 2.974
3 4.966
4 6.959
5 8.952 0.1 0.1
6 10.944
0.15
7 12.937 16.922 16.922
8 14.930
9 16.922
1.3.8 Weight of Water on Cant. slab water Table at Ground Level WWCSWTGL
Total Weight of Water 1.619 kN

Weight of water on Bottom slab per m 16.187 kN/m
1.3.9 Weight of Dry Soil on Cantilever Slab WDSCS
3
Density of Dry Soil 1.8 T/m
3
γDRY 17.658 kN/m
Total Weight of Soil 2.914 kN
Weight of soil on Cant. slab per m 29.136 kN/m
Page 5 of 35
1.3.10 Weight of Saturated Soil on Cantilever Slab WSSCS
3
Density of Dry Soil 0.8 T/m
3
γSAT 7.848 kN/m
Total Weight of Soil 1.295 kN
Weight of soil on Cant. slab per m 12.949 kN/m
1.3.11 Earth Pressure At Rest of Saturated Soil EPRSS
Angle of Internal Frict φ 30

Coeff of Earth Pressure at Rest KR 0.5
2
Earth Pressure at top Node 0.3924 kN/m
2
Earth Pressure at Bottom Node 6.7689 kN/m
Total Height 1.625
POINT Pressure
1 0.392
2 1.189
3 1.987
4 2.784
5 3.581
6 4.378
7 5.175
8 5.972
9 6.769
1.3.12 Live load Surcharge At Rest of Saturated Soil LLSSS
Heq 1.2 m
2
Horrizantal Pressure 4.7088 kN/m
4.7088 KN/m 4.7088
Page 6 of 35
17.8 6621.60 5064.78
1.3.13 Diffrential Temparature Rise DTR 2 1
0.06
h 0.2 m -68.82
h1 0.06 m 4.0 3 1488.00
0.06
h2 0.06 m -1556.82
0.2
h3 0.06 m 0 0 + = -1556.82
0.02
Calculation of forces to be applied 0 0 -1556.82
2
Modulus of Elasticity of concrete Ec 3.10E+07 KN/m
o 0.06
Coeff of Thermal Expansion α 1.20E-05 per C 4
Restraint Compressive Force/Stress 2.1 781.20 -775.62
Part No Avj Str Force KN
Restraint Moment
1 2566.80 154.008 Temperature Rise Compression
Locked in stresses & Primary residual
2 1488.00 89.28 Diagram Release Stress
stress
3 744.00 44.64
4 390.60 23.436
311.364 KN 5064.78 -2638 2426.56
Releasing Force -311.364 KN 0.05920 1
2 0.06
Compression Release Stress -1556.82 KN/m 0.00080 -68.82 2 -1055.29 -1124.11
Restraint Moment 3
0.06
Dist from Mom 4
Part Avj Str Force about 0.2
CG -1556.82 + 527.645 -1029.18
CG 0.02 5
1 2532.39 149.906 0.080 12.033 -1556.82 1055.29 -501.53
2 -34.41 -0.028 0.040 -0.001 7
0.06
3 -68.82 -4.1292 0.010 -0.041 6
4 -744.00 -44.64 0.000 0.000 -775.62 2638 1862.60
5 -1556.82 -31.1364 -0.030 0.934
Restraint Moment
6 -775.62 -46.5372 -0.070 3.258 Moment Primary Residual
& Primary residual
7 -390.60 -23.436 -0.060 1.406 Release Stress
stress
17.588 KN-m
Release Moment -17.588 KN-m
3
Section Modulus 0.0067 m
2
Relesing stress at top -2638 KN/m
2
Relesing stress at Bottom 2638 KN/m
Page 7 of 35
1.3.14 Diffrential Temparature Fall DTF
h 0.2 m -10.6 -3943.20 -3177.81
h1, h4 0.04 m 1 2
0.04
h2,h3 0.05 m
Calculation of forces to be applied -0.7 -260.40 3 504.99
2 0.05
Modulus of Elasticity of concrete Ec 3.10E+07 KN/m
o
Coeff of Thermal Expansion α 1.20E-05 per C 0 + 765.39 = 765.39
0.2 0.02
Restraint Tensile Force/Stress 765.39
Part No Avj Str Force KN
0.05
1 -1841.40 -73.656 -0.8 -297.60 4 467.79
2 -260.40 -10.416
0.04
3 -130.20 -6.51 6 5
4 -148.80 -7.44 -6.6 -2455.20 -1689.81
5 -297.60 -11.904
Tension Restraint Moment
6 -1078.80 -43.152 Temperature Fall
Locked in stresses Release & Primary residual
-153.078 KN Diagram
Stress stress
Releasing Force 153.078 KN
2
Tension Release Stress 765.39 KN/m
Restraint Moment -3177.81 373 -2805.16
Dist from Mom 0.035 1
Part Avj Str Force about 0.04
CG 0.005 2
CG
1 -1588.905 -54.841 0.088 -4.853 504.99 223.591 728.58
0.05
2 252.495 1.385 0.062 0.086 3 4
3 504.99 25.250 0.035 0.884 5 765.39 + 37.265 802.66
0.2 0.02
4 130.20 6.510 0.027 0.174 765.39 -37.2651 728.12
5 765.39 15.308 0.000 0.000 6 7
0.05
6 467.79 23.390 -0.035 -0.819 467.79 -223.591 244.20
7 148.80 7.440 -0.027 -0.198 0.009 8
0.04
8 233.895 2.028 -0.063 -0.128 0.031 9
9 -844.905 -26.469 -0.090 2.370 -1689.81 -373 -2062.46
-2.484 KN-m
Restraint Moment
Release Moment 2.484 KN-m Moment Primary Residual
3 & Primary residual
Section Modulus 0.0067 m Release Stress
2 2 stress
Relesing stress at top & Bot 373 KN/m -373 KN/m
Page 8 of 35
1.3.15 Uniform Temparature Rise UTR
Uniform Temperature Rise 33 deg C
1.3.16 Uniform Temparature Fall UTF
Uniform Temperature Fall -33 deg C
Page 9 of 35
Project
Rehabilitation of Drain No.6 into RCC Strom Water Drain alongwith its covering and Construction Infrastructure Technologies
of other City Drains in Sonepat Town under AMRUT Program Consultant: Innovative infrastructure engineering through cutting edge technologies
Contractor M/s MSKEL-GARG (JV) Calc by : TK Design Note No./Revision INFRA/SON/DR/004-R1
2.1 Check of Box for Uplift (Drain Running Empty and water table at ground)
2
Area Of Top Slab 0.260 m
2
Area Of Bottom Slab 0.225 m
2
Area of Wall 0.435 m
2
Total Concrete area 0.920 m
3
Volume of 1m strip 0.920 m
3
Unit Weight of Concrete 25.000 KN/m
Total Self weight 23.000 KN
Weight of Saturated soil on cantilever Slab 2.590 KN

Weight of Water on cantilever Slab 3.237 KN
Total Weight 28.827 KN
3
Volume of Cant slab 0.030 m
3
Volume of Box 2.340 m
3
Total Volume of Water Displaced 2.370 m
3
unit weight of water 9.810 kN/m
Boyant Force 23.250 kN
Check for Uplift OK
Page 10 of 35
Project
Rehabilitation of Drain No.6 into RCC Strom Water Drain alongwith its covering and Infrastructure Technologies
Construction of other City Drains in Sonepat Town under AMRUT Program Consultant: Innovative infrastructure engineering through cutting edge technologies
3.1 Base Pressure Check
Assumed allowable Bearing Capacity 8 T/m2
F (KN) from Base Pressure

Spring No width Area
STAAD Dist To Next T/m2
1 2.348 0.0875 1.000 0.04375 5.367 OK

2 4.686 0.0875 1.000 0.0875 5.355 OK
3 6.169 0.14375 1.000 0.115625 5.335 OK
4 7.624 0.14375 1.000 0.14375 5.304 OK
5 7.581 0.14375 1.000 0.14375 5.274 OK
6 7.551 0.14375 1.000 0.14375 5.253 OK
7 7.541 0.14375 1.000 0.14375 5.246 OK
8 7.551 0.14375 1.000 0.14375 5.253 OK
9 7.581 0.14375 1.000 0.14375 5.274 OK
10 7.624 0.14375 1.000 0.14375 5.304 OK
11 6.169 0.0875 1.000 0.115625 5.335 OK
12 4.686 0.0875 1.000 0.0875 5.355 OK
13 2.348 1.000 0.04375 5.367 OK
Page 11 of 35
Project
4.1 Design Conditions
C1 Drain Empty Water Table at Ground + Temp Rising

C2 Drain Empty Water Table at Ground + Temp Falling
C3 Drain Running Full and No soil Outside + Temp Rising
C4 Drain Running Full and No soil Outside + Temp Falling
4.2 Load Combinations for Design Conditions

ULSBC SLSRC SLSQPC
LC Type Description
C1 C2 C3 C4 C1 C2 C3 C4 C1 C2 C3 C4
1.35 1.35 1.35 1.35 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1
1 SW Self Weight
1.75 1.75 1.75 1.75 1.2 1.2 1.2 1.2 1.2 1.2 1.2 1.2
2 LOF Load Of Finishes
1.5 1.5 1.5 1.5 0.75 0.75 0.75 0.75 0 0 0 0

3 CALL CLASS - A Wheel Load
Weight of Water on base slab in 0 0 1.5 1.5 0 0 1 1 0 0 1 1

4 WWBSDRFC
Drain Running Full Condition
Water Pressure on Walls in Drain 0 0 1.5 1.5 0 0 1 1 0 0 1 1
5 WPWDRFC
Running Full Condition
Uplift Pressure Due to water table at 0.15 0.15 0 0 0.15 0.15 0 0 0.15 0.15 0 0
6 UPBSWTGL
Ground Level
Water Pressure Due to water Table at 1.5 1.5 0 0 1 1 0 0 1 1 0 0
7 WPWWTGL
Ground Level
Weight of Water on Cant. slab water 1.5 1.5 0 0 1 1 0 0 1 1 0 0
8 WWCSWTGL
Table at Ground Level
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
9 WDSCS Weight of Dry Soil on Cantilever Slab
Weight of Saturated Soil on Cantilever 1.5 1.5 0 0 1 1 0 0 1 1 0 0

10 WSSCS
Slab
1.5 1.5 0 0 1 1 0 0 1 1 0 0
11 EPRSS Earth Pressure At Rest of Saturated Soil
Page 12 of 35
Project
ULSBC SLSRC SLSQPC
LC Type Description
C1 C2 C3 C4 C1 C2 C3 C4 C1 C2 C3 C4
Live load Surcharge At Rest of 1.2 1.2 0 0 0.8 0.8 0 0 0.8 0.8 0 0
12 LLSSS
Saturated Soil
0.9 0 0.9 0 1 0 1 0 0.5 0 0.5 0
13 DTR Diffrential Temparature Rise
0 0.9 0 0.9 0 1 0 1 0 0.5 0 0.5

14 DTF Diffrential Temparature Fall
0.9 0 0.9 0 1 0 1 0 0.5 0 0.5 0

15 UTR Uniform Temparature Rise
0 0.9 0 0.9 0 1 0 1 0 0.5 0 0.5

16 UTF Uniform Temparature Fall
Page 13 of 35
Project Infrastructure Technologies
Rehabilitation of Drain No.6 into RCC Strom Water Drain alongwith its covering and Construction of other City Drains in Sonepat Town under AMRUT Program Consultant: Innovative infrastructure engineering through cutting edge technologies
4.3 Load Combination Results

ULS BC SLSRC SLSQPC
Beam Node C1 C2 C3 C4 C1 C2 C3 C4 C1 C2 C3 C4
Fx Fy Mz Fx Fy Mz Fx Fy Mz Fx Fy Mz Fx Fy Mz Fx Fy Mz Fx Fy Mz Fx Fy Mz Fx Fy Mz Fx Fy Mz Fx Fy Mz Fx Fy Mz
1 1 0.00 5.09 0.00 0.00 5.08 0.00 0.00 5.45 0.00 0.00 5.43 0.00 0.00 2.80 0.00 0.00 2.78 0.00 0.00 3.07 0.00 0.00 3.06 0.00 0.00 0.92 0.00 0.00 0.91 0.00 0.00 1.19 0.00 0.00 1.18 0.00
2 0.00 -1.06 0.27 0.00 -1.04 0.27 0.00 -5.00 0.46 0.00 -4.99 0.46 0.00 -0.15 0.13 0.00 -0.14 0.13 0.00 -2.75 0.25 0.00 -2.73 0.25 0.00 1.73 -0.04 0.00 1.74 -0.04 0.00 -0.86 0.09 0.00 -0.85 0.09
2 2 0.00 11.23 -0.27 0.00 11.20 -0.27 0.00 15.86 -0.46 0.00 15.83 -0.46 0.00 5.75 -0.13 0.00 5.71 -0.13 0.00 8.87 -0.25 0.00 8.84 -0.25 0.00 0.11 0.04 0.00 0.09 0.04 0.00 3.23 -0.09 0.00 3.21 -0.09
3 0.00 -7.20 1.08 0.00 -7.16 1.07 0.00 -15.42 1.83 0.00 -15.38 1.82 0.00 -3.10 0.52 0.00 -3.07 0.51 0.00 -8.55 1.02 0.00 -8.51 1.01 0.00 2.54 -0.14 0.00 2.56 -0.14 0.00 -2.91 0.36 0.00 -2.89 0.36
3 3 26.54 -56.27 -8.93 25.62 -56.33 -10.08 -10.89 -47.19 -3.73 -11.81 -47.24 -4.88 18.84 -31.13 -5.32 17.82 -31.19 -6.60 -6.11 -25.01 -1.85 -7.13 -25.07 -3.13 17.90 -10.03 -3.14 17.39 -10.06 -3.78 -7.05 -3.91 0.33 -7.56 -3.94 -0.31
4 -26.54 56.62 0.82 -25.62 56.67 1.96 10.89 50.66 -3.31 11.81 50.72 -2.16 -18.84 31.29 0.83 -17.82 31.35 2.10 6.11 27.38 -1.92 7.13 27.44 -0.65 -17.90 10.19 1.69 -17.39 10.22 2.32 7.05 6.28 -1.06 7.56 6.31 -0.43
4 4 26.54 -40.05 -0.82 25.62 -40.10 -1.96 -10.89 -33.07 3.31 -11.81 -33.12 2.16 18.84 -22.17 -0.83 17.82 -22.22 -2.10 -6.11 -17.45 1.92 -7.13 -17.51 0.65 17.90 -7.14 -1.69 17.39 -7.17 -2.32 -7.05 -2.43 1.06 -7.56 -2.46 0.43
5 -26.54 40.39 -4.97 -25.62 40.45 -3.83 10.89 36.55 -8.31 11.81 36.60 -7.17 -18.84 22.32 -2.37 -17.82 22.38 -1.11 6.11 19.83 -4.60 7.13 19.88 -3.34 -17.90 7.30 0.65 -17.39 7.33 1.28 7.05 4.80 -1.58 7.56 4.83 -0.95
5 5 26.54 -23.91 4.97 25.62 -23.95 3.83 -10.89 -19.09 8.31 -11.81 -19.13 7.17 18.84 -13.25 2.37 17.82 -13.29 1.11 -6.11 -9.96 4.60 -7.13 -10.01 3.34 17.90 -4.25 -0.65 17.39 -4.28 -1.28 -7.05 -0.97 1.58 -7.56 -0.99 0.95
6 -26.54 24.26 -8.43 -25.62 24.30 -7.29 10.89 22.56 -11.30 11.81 22.60 -10.17 -18.84 13.40 -4.28 -17.82 13.45 -3.03 6.11 12.34 -6.20 7.13 12.38 -4.94 -17.90 4.41 0.03 -17.39 4.43 0.65 7.05 3.35 -1.89 7.56 3.37 -1.26
6 6 26.54 -7.85 8.43 25.62 -7.86 7.29 -10.89 -5.19 11.30 -11.81 -5.20 10.17 18.84 -4.36 4.28 17.82 -4.37 3.03 -6.11 -2.52 6.20 -7.13 -2.54 4.94 17.90 -1.36 -0.03 17.39 -1.37 -0.65 -7.05 0.47 1.89 -7.56 0.46 1.26
7 -26.54 8.19 -9.58 -25.62 8.21 -8.45 10.89 8.67 -12.30 11.81 8.68 -11.17 -18.84 4.52 -4.92 -17.82 4.53 -3.66 6.11 4.90 -6.74 7.13 4.91 -5.48 -17.90 1.52 -0.18 -17.39 1.53 0.45 7.05 1.90 -2.00 7.56 1.91 -1.37
7 7 26.54 8.19 9.58 25.62 8.21 8.45 -10.89 8.67 12.30 -11.81 8.68 11.17 18.84 4.52 4.92 17.82 4.53 3.66 -6.11 4.90 6.74 -7.13 4.91 5.48 17.90 1.52 0.18 17.39 1.53 -0.45 -7.05 1.90 2.00 -7.56 1.91 1.37
8 -26.54 -7.85 -8.43 -25.62 -7.86 -7.29 10.89 -5.19 -11.30 11.81 -5.20 -10.17 -18.84 -4.36 -4.28 -17.82 -4.37 -3.03 6.11 -2.52 -6.20 7.13 -2.54 -4.94 -17.90 -1.36 0.03 -17.39 -1.37 0.65 7.05 0.47 -1.89 7.56 0.46 -1.26
8 8 26.54 24.26 8.43 25.62 24.30 7.29 -10.89 22.56 11.30 -11.81 22.60 10.17 18.84 13.40 4.28 17.82 13.45 3.03 -6.11 12.34 6.20 -7.13 12.38 4.94 17.90 4.41 -0.03 17.39 4.43 -0.65 -7.05 3.35 1.89 -7.56 3.37 1.26
9 -26.54 -23.91 -4.97 -25.62 -23.95 -3.83 10.89 -19.09 -8.31 11.81 -19.13 -7.17 -18.84 -13.25 -2.37 -17.82 -13.29 -1.11 6.11 -9.96 -4.60 7.13 -10.01 -3.34 -17.90 -4.25 0.65 -17.39 -4.28 1.28 7.05 -0.97 -1.58 7.56 -0.99 -0.95
9 9 26.54 40.39 4.97 25.62 40.45 3.83 -10.89 36.55 8.31 -11.81 36.60 7.17 18.84 22.32 2.37 17.82 22.38 1.11 -6.11 19.83 4.60 -7.13 19.88 3.34 17.90 7.30 -0.65 17.39 7.33 -1.28 -7.05 4.80 1.58 -7.56 4.83 0.95
10 -26.54 -40.05 0.82 -25.62 -40.10 1.96 10.89 -33.07 -3.31 11.81 -33.12 -2.16 -18.84 -22.17 0.83 -17.82 -22.22 2.10 6.11 -17.45 -1.92 7.13 -17.51 -0.65 -17.90 -7.14 1.69 -17.39 -7.17 2.32 7.05 -2.43 -1.06 7.56 -2.46 -0.43
10 10 26.54 56.62 -0.82 25.62 56.67 -1.96 -10.89 50.66 3.31 -11.81 50.72 2.16 18.84 31.29 -0.83 17.82 31.35 -2.10 -6.11 27.38 1.92 -7.13 27.44 0.65 17.90 10.19 -1.69 17.39 10.22 -2.32 -7.05 6.28 1.06 -7.56 6.31 0.43
11 -26.54 -56.27 8.93 -25.62 -56.33 10.08 10.89 -47.19 3.73 11.81 -47.24 4.88 -18.84 -31.13 5.32 -17.82 -31.19 6.60 6.11 -25.01 1.85 7.13 -25.07 3.13 -17.90 -10.03 3.14 -17.39 -10.06 3.78 7.05 -3.91 -0.33 7.56 -3.94 0.31
11 11 0.00 -7.20 -1.08 0.00 -7.16 -1.07 0.00 -15.42 -1.83 0.00 -15.38 -1.82 0.00 -3.10 -0.52 0.00 -3.07 -0.51 0.00 -8.55 -1.02 0.00 -8.51 -1.01 0.00 2.54 0.14 0.00 2.56 0.14 0.00 -2.91 -0.36 0.00 -2.89 -0.36
12 0.00 11.23 0.27 0.00 11.20 0.27 0.00 15.86 0.46 0.00 15.83 0.46 0.00 5.75 0.13 0.00 5.71 0.13 0.00 8.87 0.25 0.00 8.84 0.25 0.00 0.11 -0.04 0.00 0.09 -0.04 0.00 3.23 0.09 0.00 3.21 0.09
12 12 0.00 -1.06 -0.27 0.00 -1.04 -0.27 0.00 -5.00 -0.46 0.00 -4.99 -0.46 0.00 -0.15 -0.13 0.00 -0.14 -0.13 0.00 -2.75 -0.25 0.00 -2.73 -0.25 0.00 1.73 0.04 0.00 1.74 0.04 0.00 -0.86 -0.09 0.00 -0.85 -0.09
13 0.00 5.09 0.00 0.00 5.08 0.00 0.00 5.45 0.00 0.00 5.43 0.00 0.00 2.80 0.00 0.00 2.78 0.00 0.00 3.07 0.00 0.00 3.06 0.00 0.00 0.92 0.00 0.00 0.91 0.00 0.00 1.19 0.00 0.00 1.18 0.00
13 14 13.19 68.65 4.38 14.11 68.65 7.02 -8.54 68.65 -1.45 -7.62 68.65 1.20 7.65 35.52 0.61 8.66 35.52 3.55 -6.84 35.52 -3.27 -5.82 35.52 -0.33 8.58 3.84 0.62 9.09 3.84 2.09 -5.90 3.84 -3.26 -5.39 3.84 -1.79
15 -13.19 -67.33 5.39 -14.11 -67.33 2.75 8.54 -67.33 11.22 7.62 -67.33 8.58 -7.65 -34.56 4.42 -8.66 -34.56 1.48 6.84 -34.56 8.30 5.82 -34.56 5.37 -8.58 -2.88 -0.14 -9.09 -2.88 -1.61 5.90 -2.88 3.74 5.39 -2.88 2.28
14 15 13.19 67.33 -5.39 14.11 67.33 -2.75 -8.54 67.33 -11.22 -7.62 67.33 -8.58 7.65 34.56 -4.42 8.66 34.56 -1.48 -6.84 34.56 -8.30 -5.82 34.56 -5.37 8.58 2.88 0.14 9.09 2.88 1.61 -5.90 2.88 -3.74 -5.39 2.88 -2.28
16 -13.19 -62.18 14.95 -14.11 -62.18 12.30 8.54 -62.18 20.77 7.62 -62.18 18.13 -7.65 -31.69 9.30 -8.66 -31.69 6.37 6.84 -31.69 13.19 5.82 -31.69 10.25 -8.58 -1.92 0.21 -9.09 -1.92 -1.26 5.90 -1.92 4.09 5.39 -1.92 2.62
15 16 13.19 62.18 -14.95 14.11 62.18 -12.30 -8.54 62.18 -20.77 -7.62 62.18 -18.13 7.65 31.69 -9.30 8.66 31.69 -6.37 -6.84 31.69 -13.19 -5.82 31.69 -10.25 8.58 1.92 -0.21 9.09 1.92 1.26 -5.90 1.92 -4.09 -5.39 1.92 -2.62
17 -13.19 -31.09 21.65 -14.11 -31.09 19.00 8.54 -31.09 27.47 7.62 -31.09 24.83 -7.65 -15.84 12.72 -8.66 -15.84 9.78 6.84 -15.84 16.60 5.82 -15.84 13.67 -8.58 -0.96 0.41 -9.09 -0.96 -1.05 5.90 -0.96 4.30 5.39 -0.96 2.83
16 17 13.19 31.09 -21.65 14.11 31.09 -19.00 -8.54 31.09 -27.47 -7.62 31.09 -24.83 7.65 15.84 -12.72 8.66 15.84 -9.78 -6.84 15.84 -16.60 -5.82 15.84 -13.67 8.58 0.96 -0.41 9.09 0.96 1.05 -5.90 0.96 -4.30 -5.39 0.96 -2.83
18 -13.19 0.00 23.88 -14.11 0.00 21.24 8.54 0.00 29.71 7.62 0.00 27.06 -7.65 0.00 13.86 -8.66 0.00 10.92 6.84 0.00 17.74 5.82 0.00 14.80 -8.58 0.00 0.48 -9.09 0.00 -0.99 5.90 0.00 4.37 5.39 0.00 2.90
17 18 13.19 0.00 -23.88 14.11 0.00 -21.24 -8.54 0.00 -29.71 -7.62 0.00 -27.06 7.65 0.00 -13.86 8.66 0.00 ### -6.84 0.00 -17.74 -5.82 0.00 -14.80 8.58 0.00 -0.48 9.09 0.00 0.99 -5.90 0.00 -4.37 -5.39 0.00 -2.90
19 -13.19 31.09 21.65 -14.11 31.09 19.00 8.54 31.09 27.47 7.62 31.09 24.83 -7.65 15.84 12.72 -8.66 15.84 9.78 6.84 15.84 16.60 5.82 15.84 13.67 -8.58 0.96 0.41 -9.09 0.96 -1.05 5.90 0.96 4.30 5.39 0.96 2.83
18 19 13.19 -31.09 -21.65 14.11 -31.09 -19.00 -8.54 -31.09 -27.47 -7.62 -31.09 -24.83 7.65 -15.84 -12.72 8.66 -15.84 -9.78 -6.84 -15.84 -16.60 -5.82 -15.84 -13.67 8.58 -0.96 -0.41 9.09 -0.96 1.05 -5.90 -0.96 -4.30 -5.39 -0.96 -2.83
20 -13.19 62.18 14.95 -14.11 62.18 12.30 8.54 62.18 20.77 7.62 62.18 18.13 -7.65 31.69 9.30 -8.66 31.69 6.37 6.84 31.69 13.19 5.82 31.69 10.25 -8.58 1.92 0.21 -9.09 1.92 -1.26 5.90 1.92 4.09 5.39 1.92 2.62
19 20 13.19 -62.18 -14.95 14.11 -62.18 -12.30 -8.54 -62.18 -20.77 -7.62 -62.18 -18.13 7.65 -31.69 -9.30 8.66 -31.69 -6.37 -6.84 -31.69 -13.19 -5.82 -31.69 -10.25 8.58 -1.92 -0.21 9.09 -1.92 1.26 -5.90 -1.92 -4.09 -5.39 -1.92 -2.62
21 -13.19 67.33 5.39 -14.11 67.33 2.75 8.54 67.33 11.22 7.62 67.33 8.58 -7.65 34.56 4.42 -8.66 34.56 1.48 6.84 34.56 8.30 5.82 34.56 5.37 -8.58 2.88 -0.14 -9.09 2.88 -1.61 5.90 2.88 3.74 5.39 2.88 2.28
20 21 13.19 -67.33 -5.39 14.11 -67.33 -2.75 -8.54 -67.33 -11.22 -7.62 -67.33 -8.58 7.65 -34.56 -4.42 8.66 -34.56 -1.48 -6.84 -34.56 -8.30 -5.82 -34.56 -5.37 8.58 -2.88 0.14 9.09 -2.88 1.61 -5.90 -2.88 -3.74 -5.39 -2.88 -2.28
22 -13.19 68.65 -4.38 -14.11 68.65 -7.02 8.54 68.65 1.45 7.62 68.65 -1.20 -7.65 35.52 -0.61 -8.66 35.52 -3.55 6.84 35.52 3.27 5.82 35.52 0.33 -8.58 3.84 -0.62 -9.09 3.84 -2.09 5.90 3.84 3.26 5.39 3.84 1.79
21 3 76.88 26.54 7.85 76.88 25.62 9.01 76.88 -10.89 1.90 76.88 -11.81 3.06 41.62 18.84 4.80 41.62 17.82 6.08 41.62 -6.11 0.83 41.62 -7.13 2.11 9.94 17.90 3.28 9.94 17.39 3.92 9.94 -7.05 -0.69 9.94 -7.56 -0.05
23 -75.85 -18.60 -3.29 -75.85 -17.68 -4.63 -75.85 6.34 -3.64 -75.85 7.25 -4.99 -40.86 -13.55 -1.52 -40.86 -12.53 -3.01 -40.86 3.08 -1.76 -40.86 4.09 -3.25 -9.17 -12.61 -0.19 -9.17 -12.10 -0.94 -9.17 4.02 -0.43 -9.17 4.52 -1.17
22 23 75.85 18.60 3.29 75.85 17.68 4.63 75.85 -6.34 3.64 75.85 -7.25 4.99 40.86 13.55 1.52 40.86 12.53 3.01 40.86 -3.08 1.76 40.86 -4.09 3.25 9.17 12.61 0.19 9.17 12.10 0.94 9.17 -4.02 0.43 9.17 -4.52 1.17
24 -74.82 -11.50 -0.24 -74.82 -10.59 -1.77 -74.82 2.39 -4.52 -74.82 3.31 -6.05 -40.09 -8.82 0.74 -40.09 -7.80 -0.96 -40.09 0.45 -2.11 -40.09 1.46 -3.80 -8.41 -7.88 1.88 -8.41 -7.37 1.03 -8.41 1.38 -0.97 -8.41 1.89 -1.82
Page 14 of 35
ULS BC SLSRC SLSQPC
Beam Node C1 C2 C3 C4 C1 C2 C3 C4 C1 C2 C3 C4
23 24 74.82 11.50 0.24 74.82 10.59 1.77 74.82 -2.39 4.52 74.82 -3.31 6.05 40.09 8.82 -0.74 40.09 7.80 0.96 40.09 -0.45 2.11 40.09 -1.46 3.80 8.41 7.88 -1.88 8.41 7.37 -1.03 8.41 -1.38 0.97 8.41 -1.89 1.82
25 -73.80 -5.26 1.45 -73.80 -4.35 -0.27 -73.80 -0.95 -4.65 -73.80 -0.03 -6.37 -39.33 -4.66 2.10 -39.33 -3.64 0.20 -39.33 -1.78 -1.96 -39.33 -0.76 -3.87 -7.65 -3.72 3.05 -7.65 -3.21 2.10 -7.65 -0.84 -1.02 -7.65 -0.33 -1.97
24 25 73.80 5.26 -1.45 73.80 4.35 0.27 73.80 0.95 4.65 73.80 0.03 6.37 39.33 4.66 -2.10 39.33 3.64 -0.20 39.33 1.78 1.96 39.33 0.76 3.87 7.65 3.72 -3.05 7.65 3.21 -2.10 7.65 0.84 1.02 7.65 0.33 1.97
26 -72.77 0.13 1.95 -72.77 1.04 0.05 -72.77 -3.68 -4.17 -72.77 -2.77 -6.07 -38.57 -1.06 2.67 -38.57 -0.05 0.56 -38.57 -3.60 -1.41 -38.57 -2.59 -3.52 -6.89 -0.13 3.43 -6.89 0.38 2.37 -6.89 -2.66 -0.66 -6.89 -2.16 -1.71
25 26 72.77 -0.13 -1.95 72.77 -1.04 -0.05 72.77 3.68 4.17 72.77 2.77 6.07 38.57 1.06 -2.67 38.57 0.05 -0.56 38.57 3.60 1.41 38.57 2.59 3.52 6.89 0.13 -3.43 6.89 -0.38 -2.37 6.89 2.66 0.66 6.89 2.16 1.71
27 -71.74 4.67 1.45 -71.74 5.58 -0.63 -71.74 -5.80 -3.20 -71.74 -4.89 -5.29 -37.81 1.96 2.57 -37.81 2.98 0.25 -37.81 -5.02 -0.53 -37.81 -4.00 -2.85 -6.13 2.90 3.14 -6.13 3.41 1.98 -6.13 -4.08 0.04 -6.13 -3.57 -1.12
26 27 71.74 -4.67 -1.45 71.74 -5.58 0.63 71.74 5.80 3.20 71.74 4.89 5.29 37.81 -1.96 -2.57 37.81 -2.98 -0.25 37.81 5.02 0.53 37.81 4.00 2.85 6.13 -2.90 -3.14 6.13 -3.41 -1.98 6.13 4.08 -0.04 6.13 3.57 1.12
28 -70.71 8.36 0.11 -70.71 9.27 -2.16 -70.71 -7.32 -1.86 -70.71 -6.41 -4.13 -37.05 4.42 1.91 -37.05 5.44 -0.61 -37.05 -6.03 0.60 -37.05 -5.01 -1.92 -5.36 5.36 2.29 -5.36 5.87 1.03 -5.36 -5.09 0.98 -5.36 -4.58 -0.29
27 28 70.71 -8.36 -0.11 70.71 -9.27 2.16 70.71 7.32 1.86 70.71 6.41 4.13 37.05 -4.42 -1.91 37.05 -5.44 0.61 37.05 6.03 -0.60 37.05 5.01 1.92 5.36 -5.36 -2.29 5.36 -5.87 -1.03 5.36 5.09 -0.98 5.36 4.58 0.29
29 -69.68 11.20 -1.89 -69.68 12.12 -4.34 -69.68 -8.23 -0.27 -69.68 -7.32 -2.72 -36.29 6.32 0.81 -36.29 7.34 -1.92 -36.29 -6.64 1.89 -36.29 -5.62 -0.84 -4.60 7.26 1.00 -4.60 7.77 -0.37 -4.60 -5.70 2.08 -4.60 -5.19 0.71
28 29 69.68 -11.20 1.89 69.68 -12.12 4.34 69.68 8.23 0.27 69.68 7.32 2.72 36.29 -6.32 -0.81 36.29 -7.34 1.92 36.29 6.64 -1.89 36.29 5.62 0.84 4.60 -7.26 -1.00 4.60 -7.77 0.37 4.60 5.70 -2.08 4.60 5.19 -0.71
14 -68.65 13.19 -4.38 -68.65 14.11 -7.02 -68.65 -8.54 1.45 -68.65 -7.62 -1.20 -35.52 7.65 -0.61 -35.52 8.66 -3.55 -35.52 -6.84 3.27 -35.52 -5.82 0.33 -3.84 8.58 -0.62 -3.84 9.09 -2.09 -3.84 -5.90 3.26 -3.84 -5.39 1.79
29 11 76.88 -26.54 -7.85 76.88 -25.62 -9.01 76.88 10.89 -1.90 76.88 11.81 -3.06 41.62 -18.84 -4.80 41.62 -17.82 -6.08 41.62 6.11 -0.83 41.62 7.13 -2.11 9.94 -17.90 -3.28 9.94 -17.39 -3.92 9.94 7.05 0.69 9.94 7.56 0.05
30 -75.85 18.60 3.29 -75.85 17.68 4.63 -75.85 -6.34 3.64 -75.85 -7.25 4.99 -40.86 13.55 1.52 -40.86 12.53 3.01 -40.86 -3.08 1.76 -40.86 -4.09 3.25 -9.17 12.61 0.19 -9.17 12.10 0.94 -9.17 -4.02 0.43 -9.17 -4.52 1.17
30 30 75.85 -18.60 -3.29 75.85 -17.68 -4.63 75.85 6.34 -3.64 75.85 7.25 -4.99 40.86 -13.55 -1.52 40.86 -12.53 -3.01 40.86 3.08 -1.76 40.86 4.09 -3.25 9.17 -12.61 -0.19 9.17 -12.10 -0.94 9.17 4.02 -0.43 9.17 4.52 -1.17
31 -74.82 11.50 0.24 -74.82 10.59 1.77 -74.82 -2.39 4.52 -74.82 -3.31 6.05 -40.09 8.82 -0.74 -40.09 7.80 0.96 -40.09 -0.45 2.11 -40.09 -1.46 3.80 -8.41 7.88 -1.88 -8.41 7.37 -1.03 -8.41 -1.38 0.97 -8.41 -1.89 1.82
31 31 74.82 -11.50 -0.24 74.82 -10.59 -1.77 74.82 2.39 -4.52 74.82 3.31 -6.05 40.09 -8.82 0.74 40.09 -7.80 -0.96 40.09 0.45 -2.11 40.09 1.46 -3.80 8.41 -7.88 1.88 8.41 -7.37 1.03 8.41 1.38 -0.97 8.41 1.89 -1.82
32 -73.80 5.26 -1.45 -73.80 4.35 0.27 -73.80 0.95 4.65 -73.80 0.03 6.37 -39.33 4.66 -2.10 -39.33 3.64 -0.20 -39.33 1.78 1.96 -39.33 0.76 3.87 -7.65 3.72 -3.05 -7.65 3.21 -2.10 -7.65 0.84 1.02 -7.65 0.33 1.97
32 32 73.80 -5.26 1.45 73.80 -4.35 -0.27 73.80 -0.95 -4.65 73.80 -0.03 -6.37 39.33 -4.66 2.10 39.33 -3.64 0.20 39.33 -1.78 -1.96 39.33 -0.76 -3.87 7.65 -3.72 3.05 7.65 -3.21 2.10 7.65 -0.84 -1.02 7.65 -0.33 -1.97
33 -72.77 -0.13 -1.95 -72.77 -1.04 -0.05 -72.77 3.68 4.17 -72.77 2.77 6.07 -38.57 1.06 -2.67 -38.57 0.05 -0.56 -38.57 3.60 1.41 -38.57 2.59 3.52 -6.89 0.13 -3.43 -6.89 -0.38 -2.37 -6.89 2.66 0.66 -6.89 2.16 1.71
33 33 72.77 0.13 1.95 72.77 1.04 0.05 72.77 -3.68 -4.17 72.77 -2.77 -6.07 38.57 -1.06 2.67 38.57 -0.05 0.56 38.57 -3.60 -1.41 38.57 -2.59 -3.52 6.89 -0.13 3.43 6.89 0.38 2.37 6.89 -2.66 -0.66 6.89 -2.16 -1.71
34 -71.74 -4.67 -1.45 -71.74 -5.58 0.63 -71.74 5.80 3.20 -71.74 4.89 5.29 -37.81 -1.96 -2.57 -37.81 -2.98 -0.25 -37.81 5.02 0.53 -37.81 4.00 2.85 -6.13 -2.90 -3.14 -6.13 -3.41 -1.98 -6.13 4.08 -0.04 -6.13 3.57 1.12
34 34 71.74 4.67 1.45 71.74 5.58 -0.63 71.74 -5.80 -3.20 71.74 -4.89 -5.29 37.81 1.96 2.57 37.81 2.98 0.25 37.81 -5.02 -0.53 37.81 -4.00 -2.85 6.13 2.90 3.14 6.13 3.41 1.98 6.13 -4.08 0.04 6.13 -3.57 -1.12
35 -70.71 -8.36 -0.11 -70.71 -9.27 2.16 -70.71 7.32 1.86 -70.71 6.41 4.13 -37.05 -4.42 -1.91 -37.05 -5.44 0.61 -37.05 6.03 -0.60 -37.05 5.01 1.92 -5.36 -5.36 -2.29 -5.36 -5.87 -1.03 -5.36 5.09 -0.98 -5.36 4.58 0.29
35 35 70.71 8.36 0.11 70.71 9.27 -2.16 70.71 -7.32 -1.86 70.71 -6.41 -4.13 37.05 4.42 1.91 37.05 5.44 -0.61 37.05 -6.03 0.60 37.05 -5.01 -1.92 5.36 5.36 2.29 5.36 5.87 1.03 5.36 -5.09 0.98 5.36 -4.58 -0.29
36 -69.68 -11.20 1.89 -69.68 -12.12 4.34 -69.68 8.23 0.27 -69.68 7.32 2.72 -36.29 -6.32 -0.81 -36.29 -7.34 1.92 -36.29 6.64 -1.89 -36.29 5.62 0.84 -4.60 -7.26 -1.00 -4.60 -7.77 0.37 -4.60 5.70 -2.08 -4.60 5.19 -0.71
36 36 69.68 11.20 -1.89 69.68 12.12 -4.34 69.68 -8.23 -0.27 69.68 -7.32 -2.72 36.29 6.32 0.81 36.29 7.34 -1.92 36.29 -6.64 1.89 36.29 -5.62 -0.84 4.60 7.26 1.00 4.60 7.77 -0.37 4.60 -5.70 2.08 4.60 -5.19 0.71
22 -68.65 -13.19 4.38 -68.65 -14.11 7.02 -68.65 8.54 -1.45 -68.65 7.62 1.20 -35.52 -7.65 0.61 -35.52 -8.66 3.55 -35.52 6.84 -3.27 -35.52 5.82 -0.33 -3.84 -8.58 0.62 -3.84 -9.09 2.09 -3.84 5.90 -3.26 -3.84 5.39 -1.79
4.4 Result Segregation into First Node & second Node Results
Beam First Node Result
ULS BC SLSRC SLSQPC
First
Beam C1 C2 C3 C4 C1 C2 C3 C4 C1 C2 C3 C4
Node
1 1 0.00 5.09 0.00 0.00 5.08 0.00 0.00 5.45 0.00 0.00 5.43 0.00 0.00 2.80 0.00 0.00 2.78 0.00 0.00 3.07 0.00 0.00 3.06 0.00 0.00 0.92 0.00 0.00 0.91 0.00 0.00 1.19 0.00 0.00 1.18 0.00
2 2 0.00 11.23 -0.27 0.00 11.20 -0.27 0.00 15.86 -0.46 0.00 15.83 -0.46 0.00 5.75 -0.13 0.00 5.71 -0.13 0.00 8.87 -0.25 0.00 8.84 -0.25 0.00 0.11 0.04 0.00 0.09 0.04 0.00 3.23 -0.09 0.00 3.21 -0.09
3 3 26.54 -56.27 -8.93 25.62 -56.33 -10.08 -10.89 -47.19 -3.73 -11.81 -47.24 -4.88 18.84 -31.13 -5.32 17.82 -31.19 -6.60 -6.11 -25.01 -1.85 -7.13 -25.07 -3.13 17.90 -10.03 -3.14 17.39 -10.06 -3.78 -7.05 -3.91 0.33 -7.56 -3.94 -0.31
4 4 26.54 -40.05 -0.82 25.62 -40.10 -1.96 -10.89 -33.07 3.31 -11.81 -33.12 2.16 18.84 -22.17 -0.83 17.82 -22.22 -2.10 -6.11 -17.45 1.92 -7.13 -17.51 0.65 17.90 -7.14 -1.69 17.39 -7.17 -2.32 -7.05 -2.43 1.06 -7.56 -2.46 0.43
5 5 26.54 -23.91 4.97 25.62 -23.95 3.83 -10.89 -19.09 8.31 -11.81 -19.13 7.17 18.84 -13.25 2.37 17.82 -13.29 1.11 -6.11 -9.96 4.60 -7.13 -10.01 3.34 17.90 -4.25 -0.65 17.39 -4.28 -1.28 -7.05 -0.97 1.58 -7.56 -0.99 0.95
6 6 26.54 -7.85 8.43 25.62 -7.86 7.29 -10.89 -5.19 11.30 -11.81 -5.20 10.17 18.84 -4.36 4.28 17.82 -4.37 3.03 -6.11 -2.52 6.20 -7.13 -2.54 4.94 17.90 -1.36 -0.03 17.39 -1.37 -0.65 -7.05 0.47 1.89 -7.56 0.46 1.26
7 7 26.54 8.19 9.58 25.62 8.21 8.45 -10.89 8.67 12.30 -11.81 8.68 11.17 18.84 4.52 4.92 17.82 4.53 3.66 -6.11 4.90 6.74 -7.13 4.91 5.48 17.90 1.52 0.18 17.39 1.53 -0.45 -7.05 1.90 2.00 -7.56 1.91 1.37
8 8 26.54 24.26 8.43 25.62 24.30 7.29 -10.89 22.56 11.30 -11.81 22.60 10.17 18.84 13.40 4.28 17.82 13.45 3.03 -6.11 12.34 6.20 -7.13 12.38 4.94 17.90 4.41 -0.03 17.39 4.43 -0.65 -7.05 3.35 1.89 -7.56 3.37 1.26
9 9 26.54 40.39 4.97 25.62 40.45 3.83 -10.89 36.55 8.31 -11.81 36.60 7.17 18.84 22.32 2.37 17.82 22.38 1.11 -6.11 19.83 4.60 -7.13 19.88 3.34 17.90 7.30 -0.65 17.39 7.33 -1.28 -7.05 4.80 1.58 -7.56 4.83 0.95
10 10 26.54 56.62 -0.82 25.62 56.67 -1.96 -10.89 50.66 3.31 -11.81 50.72 2.16 18.84 31.29 -0.83 17.82 31.35 -2.10 -6.11 27.38 1.92 -7.13 27.44 0.65 17.90 10.19 -1.69 17.39 10.22 -2.32 -7.05 6.28 1.06 -7.56 6.31 0.43
11 11 0.00 -7.20 -1.08 0.00 -7.16 -1.07 0.00 -15.42 -1.83 0.00 -15.38 -1.82 0.00 -3.10 -0.52 0.00 -3.07 -0.51 0.00 -8.55 -1.02 0.00 -8.51 -1.01 0.00 2.54 0.14 0.00 2.56 0.14 0.00 -2.91 -0.36 0.00 -2.89 -0.36
12 12 0.00 -1.06 -0.27 0.00 -1.04 -0.27 0.00 -5.00 -0.46 0.00 -4.99 -0.46 0.00 -0.15 -0.13 0.00 -0.14 -0.13 0.00 -2.75 -0.25 0.00 -2.73 -0.25 0.00 1.73 0.04 0.00 1.74 0.04 0.00 -0.86 -0.09 0.00 -0.85 -0.09
Page 15 of 35
ULS BC SLSRC SLSQPC
First
Node
13 14 13.19 68.65 4.38 14.11 68.65 7.02 -8.54 68.65 -1.45 -7.62 68.65 1.20 7.65 35.52 0.61 8.66 35.52 3.55 -6.84 35.52 -3.27 -5.82 35.52 -0.33 8.58 3.84 0.62 9.09 3.84 2.09 -5.90 3.84 -3.26 -5.39 3.84 -1.79
14 15 13.19 67.33 -5.39 14.11 67.33 -2.75 -8.54 67.33 -11.22 -7.62 67.33 -8.58 7.65 34.56 -4.42 8.66 34.56 -1.48 -6.84 34.56 -8.30 -5.82 34.56 -5.37 8.58 2.88 0.14 9.09 2.88 1.61 -5.90 2.88 -3.74 -5.39 2.88 -2.28
15 16 13.19 62.18 -14.95 14.11 62.18 -12.30 -8.54 62.18 -20.77 -7.62 62.18 -18.13 7.65 31.69 -9.30 8.66 31.69 -6.37 -6.84 31.69 -13.19 -5.82 31.69 -10.25 8.58 1.92 -0.21 9.09 1.92 1.26 -5.90 1.92 -4.09 -5.39 1.92 -2.62
16 17 13.19 31.09 -21.65 14.11 31.09 -19.00 -8.54 31.09 -27.47 -7.62 31.09 -24.83 7.65 15.84 -12.72 8.66 15.84 -9.78 -6.84 15.84 -16.60 -5.82 15.84 -13.67 8.58 0.96 -0.41 9.09 0.96 1.05 -5.90 0.96 -4.30 -5.39 0.96 -2.83
17 18 13.19 0.00 -23.88 14.11 0.00 -21.24 -8.54 0.00 -29.71 -7.62 0.00 -27.06 7.65 0.00 -13.86 8.66 0.00 ### -6.84 0.00 -17.74 -5.82 0.00 -14.80 8.58 0.00 -0.48 9.09 0.00 0.99 -5.90 0.00 -4.37 -5.39 0.00 -2.90
18 19 13.19 -31.09 -21.65 14.11 -31.09 -19.00 -8.54 -31.09 -27.47 -7.62 -31.09 -24.83 7.65 -15.84 -12.72 8.66 -15.84 -9.78 -6.84 -15.84 -16.60 -5.82 -15.84 -13.67 8.58 -0.96 -0.41 9.09 -0.96 1.05 -5.90 -0.96 -4.30 -5.39 -0.96 -2.83
19 20 13.19 -62.18 -14.95 14.11 -62.18 -12.30 -8.54 -62.18 -20.77 -7.62 -62.18 -18.13 7.65 -31.69 -9.30 8.66 -31.69 -6.37 -6.84 -31.69 -13.19 -5.82 -31.69 -10.25 8.58 -1.92 -0.21 9.09 -1.92 1.26 -5.90 -1.92 -4.09 -5.39 -1.92 -2.62
20 21 13.19 -67.33 -5.39 14.11 -67.33 -2.75 -8.54 -67.33 -11.22 -7.62 -67.33 -8.58 7.65 -34.56 -4.42 8.66 -34.56 -1.48 -6.84 -34.56 -8.30 -5.82 -34.56 -5.37 8.58 -2.88 0.14 9.09 -2.88 1.61 -5.90 -2.88 -3.74 -5.39 -2.88 -2.28
21 3 76.88 26.54 7.85 76.88 25.62 9.01 76.88 -10.89 1.90 76.88 -11.81 3.06 41.62 18.84 4.80 41.62 17.82 6.08 41.62 -6.11 0.83 41.62 -7.13 2.11 9.94 17.90 3.28 9.94 17.39 3.92 9.94 -7.05 -0.69 9.94 -7.56 -0.05
22 23 75.85 18.60 3.29 75.85 17.68 4.63 75.85 -6.34 3.64 75.85 -7.25 4.99 40.86 13.55 1.52 40.86 12.53 3.01 40.86 -3.08 1.76 40.86 -4.09 3.25 9.17 12.61 0.19 9.17 12.10 0.94 9.17 -4.02 0.43 9.17 -4.52 1.17
23 24 74.82 11.50 0.24 74.82 10.59 1.77 74.82 -2.39 4.52 74.82 -3.31 6.05 40.09 8.82 -0.74 40.09 7.80 0.96 40.09 -0.45 2.11 40.09 -1.46 3.80 8.41 7.88 -1.88 8.41 7.37 -1.03 8.41 -1.38 0.97 8.41 -1.89 1.82
24 25 73.80 5.26 -1.45 73.80 4.35 0.27 73.80 0.95 4.65 73.80 0.03 6.37 39.33 4.66 -2.10 39.33 3.64 -0.20 39.33 1.78 1.96 39.33 0.76 3.87 7.65 3.72 -3.05 7.65 3.21 -2.10 7.65 0.84 1.02 7.65 0.33 1.97
25 26 72.77 -0.13 -1.95 72.77 -1.04 -0.05 72.77 3.68 4.17 72.77 2.77 6.07 38.57 1.06 -2.67 38.57 0.05 -0.56 38.57 3.60 1.41 38.57 2.59 3.52 6.89 0.13 -3.43 6.89 -0.38 -2.37 6.89 2.66 0.66 6.89 2.16 1.71
26 27 71.74 -4.67 -1.45 71.74 -5.58 0.63 71.74 5.80 3.20 71.74 4.89 5.29 37.81 -1.96 -2.57 37.81 -2.98 -0.25 37.81 5.02 0.53 37.81 4.00 2.85 6.13 -2.90 -3.14 6.13 -3.41 -1.98 6.13 4.08 -0.04 6.13 3.57 1.12
27 28 70.71 -8.36 -0.11 70.71 -9.27 2.16 70.71 7.32 1.86 70.71 6.41 4.13 37.05 -4.42 -1.91 37.05 -5.44 0.61 37.05 6.03 -0.60 37.05 5.01 1.92 5.36 -5.36 -2.29 5.36 -5.87 -1.03 5.36 5.09 -0.98 5.36 4.58 0.29
28 29 69.68 -11.20 1.89 69.68 -12.12 4.34 69.68 8.23 0.27 69.68 7.32 2.72 36.29 -6.32 -0.81 36.29 -7.34 1.92 36.29 6.64 -1.89 36.29 5.62 0.84 4.60 -7.26 -1.00 4.60 -7.77 0.37 4.60 5.70 -2.08 4.60 5.19 -0.71
29 11 76.88 -26.54 -7.85 76.88 -25.62 -9.01 76.88 10.89 -1.90 76.88 11.81 -3.06 41.62 -18.84 -4.80 41.62 -17.82 -6.08 41.62 6.11 -0.83 41.62 7.13 -2.11 9.94 -17.90 -3.28 9.94 -17.39 -3.92 9.94 7.05 0.69 9.94 7.56 0.05
30 30 75.85 -18.60 -3.29 75.85 -17.68 -4.63 75.85 6.34 -3.64 75.85 7.25 -4.99 40.86 -13.55 -1.52 40.86 -12.53 -3.01 40.86 3.08 -1.76 40.86 4.09 -3.25 9.17 -12.61 -0.19 9.17 -12.10 -0.94 9.17 4.02 -0.43 9.17 4.52 -1.17
31 31 74.82 -11.50 -0.24 74.82 -10.59 -1.77 74.82 2.39 -4.52 74.82 3.31 -6.05 40.09 -8.82 0.74 40.09 -7.80 -0.96 40.09 0.45 -2.11 40.09 1.46 -3.80 8.41 -7.88 1.88 8.41 -7.37 1.03 8.41 1.38 -0.97 8.41 1.89 -1.82
32 32 73.80 -5.26 1.45 73.80 -4.35 -0.27 73.80 -0.95 -4.65 73.80 -0.03 -6.37 39.33 -4.66 2.10 39.33 -3.64 0.20 39.33 -1.78 -1.96 39.33 -0.76 -3.87 7.65 -3.72 3.05 7.65 -3.21 2.10 7.65 -0.84 -1.02 7.65 -0.33 -1.97
33 33 72.77 0.13 1.95 72.77 1.04 0.05 72.77 -3.68 -4.17 72.77 -2.77 -6.07 38.57 -1.06 2.67 38.57 -0.05 0.56 38.57 -3.60 -1.41 38.57 -2.59 -3.52 6.89 -0.13 3.43 6.89 0.38 2.37 6.89 -2.66 -0.66 6.89 -2.16 -1.71
34 34 71.74 4.67 1.45 71.74 5.58 -0.63 71.74 -5.80 -3.20 71.74 -4.89 -5.29 37.81 1.96 2.57 37.81 2.98 0.25 37.81 -5.02 -0.53 37.81 -4.00 -2.85 6.13 2.90 3.14 6.13 3.41 1.98 6.13 -4.08 0.04 6.13 -3.57 -1.12
35 35 70.71 8.36 0.11 70.71 9.27 -2.16 70.71 -7.32 -1.86 70.71 -6.41 -4.13 37.05 4.42 1.91 37.05 5.44 -0.61 37.05 -6.03 0.60 37.05 -5.01 -1.92 5.36 5.36 2.29 5.36 5.87 1.03 5.36 -5.09 0.98 5.36 -4.58 -0.29
36 36 69.68 11.20 -1.89 69.68 12.12 -4.34 69.68 -8.23 -0.27 69.68 -7.32 -2.72 36.29 6.32 0.81 36.29 7.34 -1.92 36.29 -6.64 1.89 36.29 -5.62 -0.84 4.60 7.26 1.00 4.60 7.77 -0.37 4.60 -5.70 2.08 4.60 -5.19 0.71
Beam Second Node Result

ULS BC SLSRC SLSQPC
2nd
Node
1 2 0.00 -1.06 0.27 0.00 -1.04 0.27 0.00 -5.00 0.46 0.00 -4.99 0.46 0.00 -0.15 0.13 0.00 -0.14 0.13 0.00 -2.75 0.25 0.00 -2.73 0.25 0.00 1.73 -0.04 0.00 1.74 -0.04 0.00 -0.86 0.09 0.00 -0.85 0.09
2 3 0.00 -7.20 1.08 0.00 -7.16 1.07 0.00 -15.42 1.83 0.00 -15.38 1.82 0.00 -3.10 0.52 0.00 -3.07 0.51 0.00 -8.55 1.02 0.00 -8.51 1.01 0.00 2.54 -0.14 0.00 2.56 -0.14 0.00 -2.91 0.36 0.00 -2.89 0.36
3 4 -26.54 56.62 0.82 -25.62 56.67 1.96 10.89 50.66 -3.31 11.81 50.72 -2.16 -18.84 31.29 0.83 -17.82 31.35 2.10 6.11 27.38 -1.92 7.13 27.44 -0.65 -17.90 10.19 1.69 -17.39 10.22 2.32 7.05 6.28 -1.06 7.56 6.31 -0.43
4 5 -26.54 40.39 -4.97 -25.62 40.45 -3.83 10.89 36.55 -8.31 11.81 36.60 -7.17 -18.84 22.32 -2.37 -17.82 22.38 -1.11 6.11 19.83 -4.60 7.13 19.88 -3.34 -17.90 7.30 0.65 -17.39 7.33 1.28 7.05 4.80 -1.58 7.56 4.83 -0.95
5 6 -26.54 24.26 -8.43 -25.62 24.30 -7.29 10.89 22.56 -11.30 11.81 22.60 -10.17 -18.84 13.40 -4.28 -17.82 13.45 -3.03 6.11 12.34 -6.20 7.13 12.38 -4.94 -17.90 4.41 0.03 -17.39 4.43 0.65 7.05 3.35 -1.89 7.56 3.37 -1.26
6 7 -26.54 8.19 -9.58 -25.62 8.21 -8.45 10.89 8.67 -12.30 11.81 8.68 -11.17 -18.84 4.52 -4.92 -17.82 4.53 -3.66 6.11 4.90 -6.74 7.13 4.91 -5.48 -17.90 1.52 -0.18 -17.39 1.53 0.45 7.05 1.90 -2.00 7.56 1.91 -1.37
7 8 -26.54 -7.85 -8.43 -25.62 -7.86 -7.29 10.89 -5.19 -11.30 11.81 -5.20 -10.17 -18.84 -4.36 -4.28 -17.82 -4.37 -3.03 6.11 -2.52 -6.20 7.13 -2.54 -4.94 -17.90 -1.36 0.03 -17.39 -1.37 0.65 7.05 0.47 -1.89 7.56 0.46 -1.26
8 9 -26.54 -23.91 -4.97 -25.62 -23.95 -3.83 10.89 -19.09 -8.31 11.81 -19.13 -7.17 -18.84 -13.25 -2.37 -17.82 -13.29 -1.11 6.11 -9.96 -4.60 7.13 -10.01 -3.34 -17.90 -4.25 0.65 -17.39 -4.28 1.28 7.05 -0.97 -1.58 7.56 -0.99 -0.95
9 10 -26.54 -40.05 0.82 -25.62 -40.10 1.96 10.89 -33.07 -3.31 11.81 -33.12 -2.16 -18.84 -22.17 0.83 -17.82 -22.22 2.10 6.11 -17.45 -1.92 7.13 -17.51 -0.65 -17.90 -7.14 1.69 -17.39 -7.17 2.32 7.05 -2.43 -1.06 7.56 -2.46 -0.43
10 11 -26.54 -56.27 8.93 -25.62 -56.33 10.08 10.89 -47.19 3.73 11.81 -47.24 4.88 -18.84 -31.13 5.32 -17.82 -31.19 6.60 6.11 -25.01 1.85 7.13 -25.07 3.13 -17.90 -10.03 3.14 -17.39 -10.06 3.78 7.05 -3.91 -0.33 7.56 -3.94 0.31
11 12 0.00 11.23 0.27 0.00 11.20 0.27 0.00 15.86 0.46 0.00 15.83 0.46 0.00 5.75 0.13 0.00 5.71 0.13 0.00 8.87 0.25 0.00 8.84 0.25 0.00 0.11 -0.04 0.00 0.09 -0.04 0.00 3.23 0.09 0.00 3.21 0.09
12 13 0.00 5.09 0.00 0.00 5.08 0.00 0.00 5.45 0.00 0.00 5.43 0.00 0.00 2.80 0.00 0.00 2.78 0.00 0.00 3.07 0.00 0.00 3.06 0.00 0.00 0.92 0.00 0.00 0.91 0.00 0.00 1.19 0.00 0.00 1.18 0.00
13 15 -13.19 -67.33 5.39 -14.11 -67.33 2.75 8.54 -67.33 11.22 7.62 -67.33 8.58 -7.65 -34.56 4.42 -8.66 -34.56 1.48 6.84 -34.56 8.30 5.82 -34.56 5.37 -8.58 -2.88 -0.14 -9.09 -2.88 -1.61 5.90 -2.88 3.74 5.39 -2.88 2.28
14 16 -13.19 -62.18 14.95 -14.11 -62.18 12.30 8.54 -62.18 20.77 7.62 -62.18 18.13 -7.65 -31.69 9.30 -8.66 -31.69 6.37 6.84 -31.69 13.19 5.82 -31.69 10.25 -8.58 -1.92 0.21 -9.09 -1.92 -1.26 5.90 -1.92 4.09 5.39 -1.92 2.62
15 17 -13.19 -31.09 21.65 -14.11 -31.09 19.00 8.54 -31.09 27.47 7.62 -31.09 24.83 -7.65 -15.84 12.72 -8.66 -15.84 9.78 6.84 -15.84 16.60 5.82 -15.84 13.67 -8.58 -0.96 0.41 -9.09 -0.96 -1.05 5.90 -0.96 4.30 5.39 -0.96 2.83
16 18 -13.19 0.00 23.88 -14.11 0.00 21.24 8.54 0.00 29.71 7.62 0.00 27.06 -7.65 0.00 13.86 -8.66 0.00 10.92 6.84 0.00 17.74 5.82 0.00 14.80 -8.58 0.00 0.48 -9.09 0.00 -0.99 5.90 0.00 4.37 5.39 0.00 2.90
17 19 -13.19 31.09 21.65 -14.11 31.09 19.00 8.54 31.09 27.47 7.62 31.09 24.83 -7.65 15.84 12.72 -8.66 15.84 9.78 6.84 15.84 16.60 5.82 15.84 13.67 -8.58 0.96 0.41 -9.09 0.96 -1.05 5.90 0.96 4.30 5.39 0.96 2.83
Page 16 of 35
ULS BC SLSRC SLSQPC
2nd
Node
18 20 -13.19 62.18 14.95 -14.11 62.18 12.30 8.54 62.18 20.77 7.62 62.18 18.13 -7.65 31.69 9.30 -8.66 31.69 6.37 6.84 31.69 13.19 5.82 31.69 10.25 -8.58 1.92 0.21 -9.09 1.92 -1.26 5.90 1.92 4.09 5.39 1.92 2.62
19 21 -13.19 67.33 5.39 -14.11 67.33 2.75 8.54 67.33 11.22 7.62 67.33 8.58 -7.65 34.56 4.42 -8.66 34.56 1.48 6.84 34.56 8.30 5.82 34.56 5.37 -8.58 2.88 -0.14 -9.09 2.88 -1.61 5.90 2.88 3.74 5.39 2.88 2.28
20 22 -13.19 68.65 -4.38 -14.11 68.65 -7.02 8.54 68.65 1.45 7.62 68.65 -1.20 -7.65 35.52 -0.61 -8.66 35.52 -3.55 6.84 35.52 3.27 5.82 35.52 0.33 -8.58 3.84 -0.62 -9.09 3.84 -2.09 5.90 3.84 3.26 5.39 3.84 1.79
21 23 -75.85 -18.60 -3.29 -75.85 -17.68 -4.63 -75.85 6.34 -3.64 -75.85 7.25 -4.99 -40.86 -13.55 -1.52 -40.86 -12.53 -3.01 -40.86 3.08 -1.76 -40.86 4.09 -3.25 -9.17 -12.61 -0.19 -9.17 -12.10 -0.94 -9.17 4.02 -0.43 -9.17 4.52 -1.17
22 24 -74.82 -11.50 -0.24 -74.82 -10.59 -1.77 -74.82 2.39 -4.52 -74.82 3.31 -6.05 -40.09 -8.82 0.74 -40.09 -7.80 -0.96 -40.09 0.45 -2.11 -40.09 1.46 -3.80 -8.41 -7.88 1.88 -8.41 -7.37 1.03 -8.41 1.38 -0.97 -8.41 1.89 -1.82
23 25 -73.80 -5.26 1.45 -73.80 -4.35 -0.27 -73.80 -0.95 -4.65 -73.80 -0.03 -6.37 -39.33 -4.66 2.10 -39.33 -3.64 0.20 -39.33 -1.78 -1.96 -39.33 -0.76 -3.87 -7.65 -3.72 3.05 -7.65 -3.21 2.10 -7.65 -0.84 -1.02 -7.65 -0.33 -1.97
24 26 -72.77 0.13 1.95 -72.77 1.04 0.05 -72.77 -3.68 -4.17 -72.77 -2.77 -6.07 -38.57 -1.06 2.67 -38.57 -0.05 0.56 -38.57 -3.60 -1.41 -38.57 -2.59 -3.52 -6.89 -0.13 3.43 -6.89 0.38 2.37 -6.89 -2.66 -0.66 -6.89 -2.16 -1.71
25 27 -71.74 4.67 1.45 -71.74 5.58 -0.63 -71.74 -5.80 -3.20 -71.74 -4.89 -5.29 -37.81 1.96 2.57 -37.81 2.98 0.25 -37.81 -5.02 -0.53 -37.81 -4.00 -2.85 -6.13 2.90 3.14 -6.13 3.41 1.98 -6.13 -4.08 0.04 -6.13 -3.57 -1.12
26 28 -70.71 8.36 0.11 -70.71 9.27 -2.16 -70.71 -7.32 -1.86 -70.71 -6.41 -4.13 -37.05 4.42 1.91 -37.05 5.44 -0.61 -37.05 -6.03 0.60 -37.05 -5.01 -1.92 -5.36 5.36 2.29 -5.36 5.87 1.03 -5.36 -5.09 0.98 -5.36 -4.58 -0.29
27 29 -69.68 11.20 -1.89 -69.68 12.12 -4.34 -69.68 -8.23 -0.27 -69.68 -7.32 -2.72 -36.29 6.32 0.81 -36.29 7.34 -1.92 -36.29 -6.64 1.89 -36.29 -5.62 -0.84 -4.60 7.26 1.00 -4.60 7.77 -0.37 -4.60 -5.70 2.08 -4.60 -5.19 0.71
28 14 -68.65 13.19 -4.38 -68.65 14.11 -7.02 -68.65 -8.54 1.45 -68.65 -7.62 -1.20 -35.52 7.65 -0.61 -35.52 8.66 -3.55 -35.52 -6.84 3.27 -35.52 -5.82 0.33 -3.84 8.58 -0.62 -3.84 9.09 -2.09 -3.84 -5.90 3.26 -3.84 -5.39 1.79
29 30 -75.85 18.60 3.29 -75.85 17.68 4.63 -75.85 -6.34 3.64 -75.85 -7.25 4.99 -40.86 13.55 1.52 -40.86 12.53 3.01 -40.86 -3.08 1.76 -40.86 -4.09 3.25 -9.17 12.61 0.19 -9.17 12.10 0.94 -9.17 -4.02 0.43 -9.17 -4.52 1.17
30 31 -74.82 11.50 0.24 -74.82 10.59 1.77 -74.82 -2.39 4.52 -74.82 -3.31 6.05 -40.09 8.82 -0.74 -40.09 7.80 0.96 -40.09 -0.45 2.11 -40.09 -1.46 3.80 -8.41 7.88 -1.88 -8.41 7.37 -1.03 -8.41 -1.38 0.97 -8.41 -1.89 1.82
31 32 -73.80 5.26 -1.45 -73.80 4.35 0.27 -73.80 0.95 4.65 -73.80 0.03 6.37 -39.33 4.66 -2.10 -39.33 3.64 -0.20 -39.33 1.78 1.96 -39.33 0.76 3.87 -7.65 3.72 -3.05 -7.65 3.21 -2.10 -7.65 0.84 1.02 -7.65 0.33 1.97
32 33 -72.77 -0.13 -1.95 -72.77 -1.04 -0.05 -72.77 3.68 4.17 -72.77 2.77 6.07 -38.57 1.06 -2.67 -38.57 0.05 -0.56 -38.57 3.60 1.41 -38.57 2.59 3.52 -6.89 0.13 -3.43 -6.89 -0.38 -2.37 -6.89 2.66 0.66 -6.89 2.16 1.71
33 34 -71.74 -4.67 -1.45 -71.74 -5.58 0.63 -71.74 5.80 3.20 -71.74 4.89 5.29 -37.81 -1.96 -2.57 -37.81 -2.98 -0.25 -37.81 5.02 0.53 -37.81 4.00 2.85 -6.13 -2.90 -3.14 -6.13 -3.41 -1.98 -6.13 4.08 -0.04 -6.13 3.57 1.12
34 35 -70.71 -8.36 -0.11 -70.71 -9.27 2.16 -70.71 7.32 1.86 -70.71 6.41 4.13 -37.05 -4.42 -1.91 -37.05 -5.44 0.61 -37.05 6.03 -0.60 -37.05 5.01 1.92 -5.36 -5.36 -2.29 -5.36 -5.87 -1.03 -5.36 5.09 -0.98 -5.36 4.58 0.29
35 36 -69.68 -11.20 1.89 -69.68 -12.12 4.34 -69.68 8.23 0.27 -69.68 7.32 2.72 -36.29 -6.32 -0.81 -36.29 -7.34 1.92 -36.29 6.64 -1.89 -36.29 5.62 0.84 -4.60 -7.26 -1.00 -4.60 -7.77 0.37 -4.60 5.70 -2.08 -4.60 5.19 -0.71
36 22 -68.65 -13.19 4.38 -68.65 -14.11 7.02 -68.65 8.54 -1.45 -68.65 7.62 1.20 -35.52 -7.65 0.61 -35.52 -8.66 3.55 -35.52 6.84 -3.27 -35.52 5.82 -0.33 -3.84 -8.58 0.62 -3.84 -9.09 2.09 -3.84 5.90 -3.26 -3.84 5.39 -1.79
Page 17 of 35
4.5 Bottom Slab Design Cases
Bottom Slab First Node Results Shear Fy taken as absolute value -ve Mz indicate Sagging (Tension at Bot) +ve Mz indicate Hogging (Tension at Top) +ve Fx indicate comp. -ve Fx indicate tens.
ULS BC SLSRC SLSQPC
First
Node
1 1 0.00 5.09 0.00 0.00 5.08 0.00 0.00 5.45 0.00 0.00 5.43 0.00 0.00 2.80 0.00 0.00 2.78 0.00 0.00 3.07 0.00 0.00 3.06 0.00 0.00 0.92 0.00 0.00 0.91 0.00 0.00 1.19 0.00 0.00 1.18 0.00
2 2 0.00 11.23 -0.27 0.00 11.20 -0.27 0.00 15.86 -0.46 0.00 15.83 -0.46 0.00 5.75 -0.13 0.00 5.71 -0.13 0.00 8.87 -0.25 0.00 8.84 -0.25 0.00 0.11 0.04 0.00 0.09 0.04 0.00 3.23 -0.09 0.00 3.21 -0.09
3 3 26.54 56.27 -8.93 25.62 56.33 -10.08 -10.89 47.19 -3.73 -11.81 47.24 -4.88 18.84 31.13 -5.32 17.82 31.19 -6.60 -6.11 25.01 -1.85 -7.13 25.07 -3.13 17.90 10.03 -3.14 17.39 10.06 -3.78 -7.05 3.91 0.33 -7.56 3.94 -0.31
4 4 26.54 40.05 -0.82 25.62 40.10 -1.96 -10.89 33.07 3.31 -11.81 33.12 2.16 18.84 22.17 -0.83 17.82 22.22 -2.10 -6.11 17.45 1.92 -7.13 17.51 0.65 17.90 7.14 -1.69 17.39 7.17 -2.32 -7.05 2.43 1.06 -7.56 2.46 0.43
5 5 26.54 23.91 4.97 25.62 23.95 3.83 -10.89 19.09 8.31 -11.81 19.13 7.17 18.84 13.25 2.37 17.82 13.29 1.11 -6.11 9.96 4.60 -7.13 10.01 3.34 17.90 4.25 -0.65 17.39 4.28 -1.28 -7.05 0.97 1.58 -7.56 0.99 0.95
6 6 26.54 7.85 8.43 25.62 7.86 7.29 -10.89 5.19 11.30 -11.81 5.20 10.17 18.84 4.36 4.28 17.82 4.37 3.03 -6.11 2.52 6.20 -7.13 2.54 4.94 17.90 1.36 -0.03 17.39 1.37 -0.65 -7.05 0.47 1.89 -7.56 0.46 1.26
7 7 26.54 8.19 9.58 25.62 8.21 8.45 -10.89 8.67 12.30 -11.81 8.68 11.17 18.84 4.52 4.92 17.82 4.53 3.66 -6.11 4.90 6.74 -7.13 4.91 5.48 17.90 1.52 0.18 17.39 1.53 -0.45 -7.05 1.90 2.00 -7.56 1.91 1.37
8 8 26.54 24.26 8.43 25.62 24.30 7.29 -10.89 22.56 11.30 -11.81 22.60 10.17 18.84 13.40 4.28 17.82 13.45 3.03 -6.11 12.34 6.20 -7.13 12.38 4.94 17.90 4.41 -0.03 17.39 4.43 -0.65 -7.05 3.35 1.89 -7.56 3.37 1.26
9 9 26.54 40.39 4.97 25.62 40.45 3.83 -10.89 36.55 8.31 -11.81 36.60 7.17 18.84 22.32 2.37 17.82 22.38 1.11 -6.11 19.83 4.60 -7.13 19.88 3.34 17.90 7.30 -0.65 17.39 7.33 -1.28 -7.05 4.80 1.58 -7.56 4.83 0.95
10 10 26.54 56.62 -0.82 25.62 56.67 -1.96 -10.89 50.66 3.31 -11.81 50.72 2.16 18.84 31.29 -0.83 17.82 31.35 -2.10 -6.11 27.38 1.92 -7.13 27.44 0.65 17.90 10.19 -1.69 17.39 10.22 -2.32 -7.05 6.28 1.06 -7.56 6.31 0.43
11 11 0.00 7.20 -1.08 0.00 7.16 -1.07 0.00 15.42 -1.83 0.00 15.38 -1.82 0.00 3.10 -0.52 0.00 3.07 -0.51 0.00 8.55 -1.02 0.00 8.51 -1.01 0.00 2.54 0.14 0.00 2.56 0.14 0.00 2.91 -0.36 0.00 2.89 -0.36
12 12 0.00 1.06 -0.27 0.00 1.04 -0.27 0.00 5.00 -0.46 0.00 4.99 -0.46 0.00 0.15 -0.13 0.00 0.14 -0.13 0.00 2.75 -0.25 0.00 2.73 -0.25 0.00 1.73 0.04 0.00 1.74 0.04 0.00 0.86 -0.09 0.00 0.85 -0.09
Bottom Slab 2nd Node Results Shear Fy taken as absolute value Sign of Mz and Fx changed to match First Node sign Convension
ULS BC SLSRC SLSQPC
2nd
Node
1 2 0.00 1.06 -0.27 0.00 1.04 -0.27 0.00 5.00 -0.46 0.00 4.99 -0.46 0.00 0.15 -0.13 0.00 0.14 -0.13 0.00 2.75 -0.25 0.00 2.73 -0.25 0.00 1.73 0.04 0.00 1.74 0.04 0.00 0.86 -0.09 0.00 0.85 -0.09
2 3 0.00 7.20 -1.08 0.00 7.16 -1.07 0.00 15.42 -1.83 0.00 15.38 -1.82 0.00 3.10 -0.52 0.00 3.07 -0.51 0.00 8.55 -1.02 0.00 8.51 -1.01 0.00 2.54 0.14 0.00 2.56 0.14 0.00 2.91 -0.36 0.00 2.89 -0.36
3 4 26.54 56.62 -0.82 25.62 56.67 -1.96 -10.89 50.66 3.31 -11.81 50.72 2.16 18.84 31.29 -0.83 17.82 31.35 -2.10 -6.11 27.38 1.92 -7.13 27.44 0.65 17.90 10.19 -1.69 17.39 10.22 -2.32 -7.05 6.28 1.06 -7.56 6.31 0.43
4 5 26.54 40.39 4.97 25.62 40.45 3.83 -10.89 36.55 8.31 -11.81 36.60 7.17 18.84 22.32 2.37 17.82 22.38 1.11 -6.11 19.83 4.60 -7.13 19.88 3.34 17.90 7.30 -0.65 17.39 7.33 -1.28 -7.05 4.80 1.58 -7.56 4.83 0.95
5 6 26.54 24.26 8.43 25.62 24.30 7.29 -10.89 22.56 11.30 -11.81 22.60 10.17 18.84 13.40 4.28 17.82 13.45 3.03 -6.11 12.34 6.20 -7.13 12.38 4.94 17.90 4.41 -0.03 17.39 4.43 -0.65 -7.05 3.35 1.89 -7.56 3.37 1.26
6 7 26.54 8.19 9.58 25.62 8.21 8.45 -10.89 8.67 12.30 -11.81 8.68 11.17 18.84 4.52 4.92 17.82 4.53 3.66 -6.11 4.90 6.74 -7.13 4.91 5.48 17.90 1.52 0.18 17.39 1.53 -0.45 -7.05 1.90 2.00 -7.56 1.91 1.37
7 8 26.54 7.85 8.43 25.62 7.86 7.29 -10.89 5.19 11.30 -11.81 5.20 10.17 18.84 4.36 4.28 17.82 4.37 3.03 -6.11 2.52 6.20 -7.13 2.54 4.94 17.90 1.36 -0.03 17.39 1.37 -0.65 -7.05 0.47 1.89 -7.56 0.46 1.26
8 9 26.54 23.91 4.97 25.62 23.95 3.83 -10.89 19.09 8.31 -11.81 19.13 7.17 18.84 13.25 2.37 17.82 13.29 1.11 -6.11 9.96 4.60 -7.13 10.01 3.34 17.90 4.25 -0.65 17.39 4.28 -1.28 -7.05 0.97 1.58 -7.56 0.99 0.95
9 10 26.54 40.05 -0.82 25.62 40.10 -1.96 -10.89 33.07 3.31 -11.81 33.12 2.16 18.84 22.17 -0.83 17.82 22.22 -2.10 -6.11 17.45 1.92 -7.13 17.51 0.65 17.90 7.14 -1.69 17.39 7.17 -2.32 -7.05 2.43 1.06 -7.56 2.46 0.43
10 11 26.54 56.27 -8.93 25.62 56.33 -10.08 -10.89 47.19 -3.73 -11.81 47.24 -4.88 18.84 31.13 -5.32 17.82 31.19 -6.60 -6.11 25.01 -1.85 -7.13 25.07 -3.13 17.90 10.03 -3.14 17.39 10.06 -3.78 -7.05 3.91 0.33 -7.56 3.94 -0.31
11 12 0.00 11.23 -0.27 0.00 11.20 -0.27 0.00 15.86 -0.46 0.00 15.83 -0.46 0.00 5.75 -0.13 0.00 5.71 -0.13 0.00 8.87 -0.25 0.00 8.84 -0.25 0.00 0.11 0.04 0.00 0.09 0.04 0.00 3.23 -0.09 0.00 3.21 -0.09
12 13 0.00 5.09 0.00 0.00 5.08 0.00 0.00 5.45 0.00 0.00 5.43 0.00 0.00 2.80 0.00 0.00 2.78 0.00 0.00 3.07 0.00 0.00 3.06 0.00 0.00 0.92 0.00 0.00 0.91 0.00 0.00 1.19 0.00 0.00 1.18 0.00
Mid Span 26.54 8.19 9.58 25.62 8.21 8.45 -10.89 8.67 12.30 -11.81 8.68 11.17 18.84 4.52 4.92 17.82 4.53 3.66 -6.11 4.90 6.74 -7.13 4.91 5.48 17.90 1.52 0.18 17.39 1.53 -0.45 -7.05 1.90 2.00 -7.56 1.91 1.37
End Span 26.54 56.27 -8.93 25.62 56.33 -10.08 -10.89 47.19 -3.73 -11.81 47.24 -4.88 18.84 31.13 -5.32 17.82 31.19 -6.60 -6.11 25.01 -1.85 -7.13 25.07 -3.13 17.90 10.03 -3.14 17.39 10.06 -3.78 -7.05 3.91 0.33 -7.56 3.94 -0.31
ULS BC SLS RC SLS QPC

Case Id. Fx Fy Mz Case Id. Fx Fy Mz Case Id. Fx Fy Mz
Mid Span Max Hogging moment Case MS-ULS-HOG -10.89 8.67 12.30 MS-SLSRC-HOG -6.11 4.90 6.74 MS-SLSQP-HOG -7.05 1.90 2.00
Mid Span Max Direct Tension Case MS-ULS-DT -11.81 8.68 11.17 MS-SLSRC-DT -7.13 4.91 5.48 MS-SLSQP-DT -7.56 1.91 1.37
End Span Max Saging moment Case ES-ULS-SAG 25.62 56.33 -10.08 ES-SLSRC-SAG 17.82 31.19 -6.60 ES-SLSQP-SAG 17.39 10.06 -3.78
End Span Max Direct Tension Case ES-ULS-DT1 -10.89 47.19 -3.73 ES-SLSRC-DT1 -6.11 25.01 -1.85 ES-SLSQP-DT1 -7.05 3.91 0.33
End Span Max Direct Tension Case ES-ULS-DT2 -11.81 47.24 -4.88 ES-SLSRC-DT2 -7.13 25.07 -3.13 ES-SLSRC-DT2 -7.56 3.94 -0.31
Page 18 of 35
4.6 Top Slab Design Cases
Top Slab First Node Results Shear Fy taken as absolute value -ve Mz indicate Sagging (Tension at Bot) +ve Mz indicate Hogging (Tension at Top) +ve Fx indicate comp. -ve Fx indicate tens.
ULS BC SLSRC SLSQPC
First
Node
13 14 13.19 68.65 4.38 14.11 68.65 7.02 -8.54 68.65 -1.45 -7.62 68.65 1.20 7.65 35.52 0.61 8.66 35.52 3.55 -6.84 35.52 -3.27 -5.82 35.52 -0.33 8.58 3.84 0.62 9.09 3.84 2.09 -5.90 3.84 -3.26 -5.39 3.84 -1.79
14 15 13.19 67.33 -5.39 14.11 67.33 -2.75 -8.54 67.33 -11.22 -7.62 67.33 -8.58 7.65 34.56 -4.42 8.66 34.56 -1.48 -6.84 34.56 -8.30 -5.82 34.56 -5.37 8.58 2.88 0.14 9.09 2.88 1.61 -5.90 2.88 -3.74 -5.39 2.88 -2.28
15 16 13.19 62.18 -14.95 14.11 62.18 -12.30 -8.54 62.18 -20.77 -7.62 62.18 -18.13 7.65 31.69 -9.30 8.66 31.69 -6.37 -6.84 31.69 -13.19 -5.82 31.69 -10.25 8.58 1.92 -0.21 9.09 1.92 1.26 -5.90 1.92 -4.09 -5.39 1.92 -2.62
16 17 13.19 31.09 -21.65 14.11 31.09 -19.00 -8.54 31.09 -27.47 -7.62 31.09 -24.83 7.65 15.84 -12.72 8.66 15.84 -9.78 -6.84 15.84 -16.60 -5.82 15.84 -13.67 8.58 0.96 -0.41 9.09 0.96 1.05 -5.90 0.96 -4.30 -5.39 0.96 -2.83
17 18 13.19 0.00 -23.88 14.11 0.00 -21.24 -8.54 0.00 -29.71 -7.62 0.00 -27.06 7.65 0.00 -13.86 8.66 0.00 ### -6.84 0.00 -17.74 -5.82 0.00 -14.80 8.58 0.00 -0.48 9.09 0.00 0.99 -5.90 0.00 -4.37 -5.39 0.00 -2.90
18 19 13.19 31.09 -21.65 14.11 31.09 -19.00 -8.54 31.09 -27.47 -7.62 31.09 -24.83 7.65 15.84 -12.72 8.66 15.84 -9.78 -6.84 15.84 -16.60 -5.82 15.84 -13.67 8.58 0.96 -0.41 9.09 0.96 1.05 -5.90 0.96 -4.30 -5.39 0.96 -2.83
19 20 13.19 62.18 -14.95 14.11 62.18 -12.30 -8.54 62.18 -20.77 -7.62 62.18 -18.13 7.65 31.69 -9.30 8.66 31.69 -6.37 -6.84 31.69 -13.19 -5.82 31.69 -10.25 8.58 1.92 -0.21 9.09 1.92 1.26 -5.90 1.92 -4.09 -5.39 1.92 -2.62
20 21 13.19 67.33 -5.39 14.11 67.33 -2.75 -8.54 67.33 -11.22 -7.62 67.33 -8.58 7.65 34.56 -4.42 8.66 34.56 -1.48 -6.84 34.56 -8.30 -5.82 34.56 -5.37 8.58 2.88 0.14 9.09 2.88 1.61 -5.90 2.88 -3.74 -5.39 2.88 -2.28
Top Slab 2nd Node Results Shear Fy taken as absolute value Sign of Mz and Fx changed to match First Node sign Convension
ULS BC SLSRC SLSQPC
2nd
Node
13 15 13.19 67.33 -5.39 14.11 67.33 -2.75 -8.54 67.33 -11.22 -7.62 67.33 -8.58 7.65 34.56 -4.42 8.66 34.56 -1.48 -6.84 34.56 -8.30 -5.82 34.56 -5.37 8.58 2.88 0.14 9.09 2.88 1.61 -5.90 2.88 -3.74 -5.39 2.88 -2.28
14 16 13.19 62.18 -14.95 14.11 62.18 -12.30 -8.54 62.18 -20.77 -7.62 62.18 -18.13 7.65 31.69 -9.30 8.66 31.69 -6.37 -6.84 31.69 -13.19 -5.82 31.69 -10.25 8.58 1.92 -0.21 9.09 1.92 1.26 -5.90 1.92 -4.09 -5.39 1.92 -2.62
15 17 13.19 31.09 -21.65 14.11 31.09 -19.00 -8.54 31.09 -27.47 -7.62 31.09 -24.83 7.65 15.84 -12.72 8.66 15.84 -9.78 -6.84 15.84 -16.60 -5.82 15.84 -13.67 8.58 0.96 -0.41 9.09 0.96 1.05 -5.90 0.96 -4.30 -5.39 0.96 -2.83
16 18 13.19 0.00 -23.88 14.11 0.00 -21.24 -8.54 0.00 -29.71 -7.62 0.00 -27.06 7.65 0.00 -13.86 8.66 0.00 ### -6.84 0.00 -17.74 -5.82 0.00 -14.80 8.58 0.00 -0.48 9.09 0.00 0.99 -5.90 0.00 -4.37 -5.39 0.00 -2.90
17 19 13.19 31.09 -21.65 14.11 31.09 -19.00 -8.54 31.09 -27.47 -7.62 31.09 -24.83 7.65 15.84 -12.72 8.66 15.84 -9.78 -6.84 15.84 -16.60 -5.82 15.84 -13.67 8.58 0.96 -0.41 9.09 0.96 1.05 -5.90 0.96 -4.30 -5.39 0.96 -2.83
18 20 13.19 62.18 -14.95 14.11 62.18 -12.30 -8.54 62.18 -20.77 -7.62 62.18 -18.13 7.65 31.69 -9.30 8.66 31.69 -6.37 -6.84 31.69 -13.19 -5.82 31.69 -10.25 8.58 1.92 -0.21 9.09 1.92 1.26 -5.90 1.92 -4.09 -5.39 1.92 -2.62
19 21 13.19 67.33 -5.39 14.11 67.33 -2.75 -8.54 67.33 -11.22 -7.62 67.33 -8.58 7.65 34.56 -4.42 8.66 34.56 -1.48 -6.84 34.56 -8.30 -5.82 34.56 -5.37 8.58 2.88 0.14 9.09 2.88 1.61 -5.90 2.88 -3.74 -5.39 2.88 -2.28
20 22 13.19 68.65 4.38 14.11 68.65 7.02 -8.54 68.65 -1.45 -7.62 68.65 1.20 7.65 35.52 0.61 8.66 35.52 3.55 -6.84 35.52 -3.27 -5.82 35.52 -0.33 8.58 3.84 0.62 9.09 3.84 2.09 -5.90 3.84 -3.26 -5.39 3.84 -1.79
Mid Span 13.19 0.00 -23.88 14.11 0.00 -21.24 -8.54 0.00 -29.71 -7.62 0.00 -27.06 7.65 0.00 -13.86 8.66 0.00 ### -6.84 0.00 -17.74 -5.82 0.00 -14.80 8.58 0.00 -0.48 9.09 0.00 0.99 -5.90 0.00 -4.37 -5.39 0.00 -2.90
End Span 13.19 68.65 4.38 14.11 68.65 7.02 -8.54 68.65 -1.45 -7.62 68.65 1.20 7.65 35.52 0.61 8.66 35.52 3.55 -6.84 35.52 -3.27 -5.82 35.52 -0.33 8.58 3.84 0.62 9.09 3.84 2.09 -5.90 3.84 -3.26 -5.39 3.84 -1.79

Mid Span Max Saging moment Case MS-ULS-SAG -8.54 0.00 -29.71 MS-SLSRC-SAG -6.84 0.00 -17.74 MS-SLSQP_SAG -5.90 0.00 -4.37
Mid Span Max Direct Tension Case MS-ULS-DT -7.62 0.00 -27.06 MS-SLSRC-DT -5.82 0.00 -14.80 MS-SLSQP-DT -5.39 0.00 -2.90
End Span Max Hogging moment Case ES-ULS-HOG 14.11 68.65 7.02 ES-SLSRC-HOG 8.66 35.52 3.55 ES-SLSQP-HOG 9.09 3.84 2.09
End Span Max Direct Tension Case ES-ULS-DT -7.62 68.65 1.20 ES-SLSRC-DT -5.82 35.52 -0.33 ES-SLSQP-DT -5.39 3.84 -1.79
Page 19 of 35
4.6 Left Wall Design Cases
Left Wall First Node Results Shear Fy taken as absolute value -ve Mz indicate Tension at Right Face +ve Mz indicateTension at left face +ve Fx indicate comp. -ve Fx indicate tens.
ULS BC SLSRC SLSQPC
First
Node
21 3 76.88 26.54 7.85 76.88 25.62 9.01 76.88 10.89 1.90 76.88 11.81 3.06 41.62 18.84 4.80 41.62 17.82 6.08 41.62 6.11 0.83 41.62 7.13 2.11 9.94 17.90 3.28 9.94 17.39 3.92 9.94 7.05 -0.69 9.94 7.56 -0.05
22 23 75.85 18.60 3.29 75.85 17.68 4.63 75.85 6.34 3.64 75.85 7.25 4.99 40.86 13.55 1.52 40.86 12.53 3.01 40.86 3.08 1.76 40.86 4.09 3.25 9.17 12.61 0.19 9.17 12.10 0.94 9.17 4.02 0.43 9.17 4.52 1.17
23 24 74.82 11.50 0.24 74.82 10.59 1.77 74.82 2.39 4.52 74.82 3.31 6.05 40.09 8.82 -0.74 40.09 7.80 0.96 40.09 0.45 2.11 40.09 1.46 3.80 8.41 7.88 -1.88 8.41 7.37 -1.03 8.41 1.38 0.97 8.41 1.89 1.82
24 25 73.80 5.26 -1.45 73.80 4.35 0.27 73.80 0.95 4.65 73.80 0.03 6.37 39.33 4.66 -2.10 39.33 3.64 -0.20 39.33 1.78 1.96 39.33 0.76 3.87 7.65 3.72 -3.05 7.65 3.21 -2.10 7.65 0.84 1.02 7.65 0.33 1.97
25 26 72.77 0.13 -1.95 72.77 1.04 -0.05 72.77 3.68 4.17 72.77 2.77 6.07 38.57 1.06 -2.67 38.57 0.05 -0.56 38.57 3.60 1.41 38.57 2.59 3.52 6.89 0.13 -3.43 6.89 0.38 -2.37 6.89 2.66 0.66 6.89 2.16 1.71
26 27 71.74 4.67 -1.45 71.74 5.58 0.63 71.74 5.80 3.20 71.74 4.89 5.29 37.81 1.96 -2.57 37.81 2.98 -0.25 37.81 5.02 0.53 37.81 4.00 2.85 6.13 2.90 -3.14 6.13 3.41 -1.98 6.13 4.08 -0.04 6.13 3.57 1.12
27 28 70.71 8.36 -0.11 70.71 9.27 2.16 70.71 7.32 1.86 70.71 6.41 4.13 37.05 4.42 -1.91 37.05 5.44 0.61 37.05 6.03 -0.60 37.05 5.01 1.92 5.36 5.36 -2.29 5.36 5.87 -1.03 5.36 5.09 -0.98 5.36 4.58 0.29
28 29 69.68 11.20 1.89 69.68 12.12 4.34 69.68 8.23 0.27 69.68 7.32 2.72 36.29 6.32 -0.81 36.29 7.34 1.92 36.29 6.64 -1.89 36.29 5.62 0.84 4.60 7.26 -1.00 4.60 7.77 0.37 4.60 5.70 -2.08 4.60 5.19 -0.71
Left Wall 2nd Node Results Shear Fy taken as absolute value Sign of Mz and Fx changed to match First Node sign Convension
ULS BC SLSRC SLSQPC
2nd
Node
21 23 75.85 18.60 3.29 75.85 17.68 4.63 75.85 6.34 3.64 75.85 7.25 4.99 40.86 13.55 1.52 40.86 12.53 3.01 40.86 3.08 1.76 40.86 4.09 3.25 9.17 12.61 0.19 9.17 12.10 0.94 9.17 4.02 0.43 9.17 4.52 1.17
22 24 74.82 11.50 0.24 74.82 10.59 1.77 74.82 2.39 4.52 74.82 3.31 6.05 40.09 8.82 -0.74 40.09 7.80 0.96 40.09 0.45 2.11 40.09 1.46 3.80 8.41 7.88 -1.88 8.41 7.37 -1.03 8.41 1.38 0.97 8.41 1.89 1.82
23 25 73.80 5.26 -1.45 73.80 4.35 0.27 73.80 0.95 4.65 73.80 0.03 6.37 39.33 4.66 -2.10 39.33 3.64 -0.20 39.33 1.78 1.96 39.33 0.76 3.87 7.65 3.72 -3.05 7.65 3.21 -2.10 7.65 0.84 1.02 7.65 0.33 1.97
24 26 72.77 0.13 -1.95 72.77 1.04 -0.05 72.77 3.68 4.17 72.77 2.77 6.07 38.57 1.06 -2.67 38.57 0.05 -0.56 38.57 3.60 1.41 38.57 2.59 3.52 6.89 0.13 -3.43 6.89 0.38 -2.37 6.89 2.66 0.66 6.89 2.16 1.71
25 27 71.74 4.67 -1.45 71.74 5.58 0.63 71.74 5.80 3.20 71.74 4.89 5.29 37.81 1.96 -2.57 37.81 2.98 -0.25 37.81 5.02 0.53 37.81 4.00 2.85 6.13 2.90 -3.14 6.13 3.41 -1.98 6.13 4.08 -0.04 6.13 3.57 1.12
26 28 70.71 8.36 -0.11 70.71 9.27 2.16 70.71 7.32 1.86 70.71 6.41 4.13 37.05 4.42 -1.91 37.05 5.44 0.61 37.05 6.03 -0.60 37.05 5.01 1.92 5.36 5.36 -2.29 5.36 5.87 -1.03 5.36 5.09 -0.98 5.36 4.58 0.29
27 29 69.68 11.20 1.89 69.68 12.12 4.34 69.68 8.23 0.27 69.68 7.32 2.72 36.29 6.32 -0.81 36.29 7.34 1.92 36.29 6.64 -1.89 36.29 5.62 0.84 4.60 7.26 -1.00 4.60 7.77 0.37 4.60 5.70 -2.08 4.60 5.19 -0.71
28 14 68.65 13.19 4.38 68.65 14.11 7.02 68.65 8.54 -1.45 68.65 7.62 1.20 35.52 7.65 0.61 35.52 8.66 3.55 35.52 6.84 -3.27 35.52 5.82 -0.33 3.84 8.58 0.62 3.84 9.09 2.09 3.84 5.90 -3.26 3.84 5.39 -1.79
Bottom 76.88 26.54 7.85 76.88 25.62 9.01 76.88 10.89 1.90 76.88 11.81 3.06 41.62 18.84 4.80 41.62 17.82 6.08 41.62 6.11 0.83 41.62 7.13 2.11 9.94 17.90 3.28 9.94 17.39 3.92 9.94 7.05 -0.69 9.94 7.56 -0.05
Mid Height 72.77 0.13 -1.95 72.77 1.04 -0.05 72.77 3.68 4.17 72.77 2.77 6.07 38.57 1.06 -2.67 38.57 0.05 -0.56 38.57 3.60 1.41 38.57 2.59 3.52 6.89 0.13 -3.43 6.89 0.38 -2.37 6.89 2.66 0.66 6.89 2.16 1.71
Top 68.65 13.19 4.38 68.65 14.11 7.02 68.65 8.54 -1.45 68.65 7.62 1.20 35.52 7.65 0.61 35.52 8.66 3.55 35.52 6.84 -3.27 35.52 5.82 -0.33 3.84 8.58 0.62 3.84 9.09 2.09 3.84 5.90 -3.26 3.84 5.39 -1.79

Bottom Max Positive moment Case BOT-ULS-PM 76.88 25.62 9.01 BOT-SLSRC-PM 41.62 17.82 6.08 BOT-SLSQP-PM 9.94 17.39 3.92
Mid Height Max Negetive moment Case MH-ULS-NM 72.77 0.13 -1.95 MH-SLSRC-NM 38.57 1.06 -2.67 MH-SLSQP-NM 6.89 0.13 -3.43
Top Max Negetive moment Case TOP-ULS-NM 68.65 8.54 -1.45 TOP-SLSRC-NM 35.52 6.84 -3.27 TOP-SLSQOP-NM 3.84 5.90 -3.26
Page 20 of 35
Project Rehabilitation of Drain No.6 into RCC Strom Water Drain alongwith its covering and
Consultant:
Construction of other City Drains in Sonepat Town under AMRUT Program Innovative infrastructure engineering through cutting edge technologies
5 DESIGN CODE (IRC:112-2011) CHECKS FOR MEMBERS
5.1 Dimension & Design Cases
MEMBER BOTTOM SLAB TOP SLAB WALL

LOCATION MID SPAN END SPAN MID SPAN END SPAN BOT MID TOP
Design case HOG DT SAG DT1 DT2 SAG DT HOG DT PM NM NM
Width of Member (m) 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1
Thk Of Member (mm) 150.000 150.000 150.000 150.000 150.000 200.000 200.000 200.000 200.000 150.000 150.000 150.000
Cover 70.000 70.000 70.000 70.000 70.000 30.000 30.000 30.000 30.000 70.000 70.000 70.000
5.2 ULS Design Forces/Moments
5.2.1 Longitudinal Moments ULS

MaxM(KN-m) 12.300 11.170 10.084 3.729 4.880 29.706 27.062 7.021 1.196 9.010 1.953 1.447
MaxM per m (KN-m/m) 12.300 11.170 10.084 3.729 4.880 29.706 27.062 7.021 1.196 9.010 1.953 1.447
5.2.2 ULS Shear

Max SF (KN) 8.668 8.682 56.326 47.186 47.239 0.000 0.000 68.655 68.655 25.624 0.126 8.538
Max SF per m (KN/m) 8.668 8.682 56.326 47.186 47.239 0.000 0.000 68.655 68.655 25.624 0.126 8.538
Cores.Axial Force Ned (KN) +ve Com -ve Tension -10.892 -11.806 25.624 -10.892 -11.806 -8.538 -7.623 14.106 -7.623 76.881 72.768 68.655
Axial Force Ned per m width (KN/m) -10.892 -11.806 25.624 -10.892 -11.806 -8.538 -7.623 14.106 -7.623 76.881 72.768 68.655
LL SF (KN) (Including Impact) 3.990 3.990 28.140 28.140 28.140 0.000 0.000 42.243 42.243 0.424 0.424 0.424
Load Factor on LL SF 1.5 1.5 1.5 1.5 1.5 1.5 1.5 1.5 1.5 1.5 1.5 1.5
Factored LL SF (KN) 5.985 5.985 42.210 42.210 42.210 0.000 0.000 63.365 63.365 0.636 0.636 0.636
Factored LL SF per m (KN/m) 5.985 5.985 42.210 42.210 42.210 0.000 0.000 63.365 63.365 0.636 0.636 0.636
SF Excluding Factored LL SF per m 2.683 2.697 14.116 4.976 5.029 0.000 0.000 5.290 5.290 24.988 -0.510 7.902
Page 21 of 35
Consultant:
5.3 SLS Design Moments
5.3.1 Longitudinal Moments at Mid Span (SLS Rare Combination)

Max MRC (KN-m) 6.736 5.480 6.596 1.847 3.126 17.741 14.804 3.552 0.331 6.083 2.672 3.268
Max MRC per m (KN-m/m) 6.736 5.480 6.596 1.847 3.126 17.741 14.804 3.552 0.331 6.083 2.672 3.268
5.3.4 Longitudinal Moments at Mid Span (SLS Quasi-Permanent Combination)

Max Mqp (KN-m) 1.996 -1.368 3.779 0.331 0.309 4.366 2.897 2.089 1.794 3.922 3.429 3.262
Max Mqp per m (KN-m/m) 1.996 -1.368 3.779 0.331 0.309 4.366 2.897 2.089 1.794 3.922 3.429 3.262
Page 22 of 35
Consultant:
5.4 Material Data
5.4.1 Concrete
Grade of Concrete (Standard Concrete) = M30 IRC:112 Cl 6.4.1

Characteristic Cube Strength (28 days) f ck = 30 Mpa IRC:112 Table 6.5
Coefficient for Stress Block α = 0.67 IRC:112-Cl 6.4.2.8
Partial safety factor for Material (Basic and seismic) γm = 1.5 IRC:112-Cl 6.4.2.8
Design value of concrete compressive strength f cd = 13.400 Mpa IRC:112-Cl 6.4.2.8

Rectangular Stress Block Strength Factor η = 1.0 IRC:112-CL A2.9(2)
Rectangular Stress Block Shape Factor λ = 0.8 IRC:112-CL A2.9(2)
β=λ/2 = 0.4
f av =η.λ.f cd = 10.720 Mpa
Mean tensile strength of concrete fctm = 3.000 Mpa IRC:112 Table 6.5
Secent Modulus of Elasticity of Concrete E cm 33000 Mpa IRC:112 Table 6.5
= 33 Gpa
Ultimate Strain in Concrete for Rectangular Stress block ε cu3 = 0.0035 IRC:112 Table 6.5
5.4.2 Steel
Minimum Yeild Stress/0.2% proof stress f yk = 500 Mpa IRC:112 Table 18.1
Modulus of Elasticity of Steel Es 200000 Mpa IRC:112 Cl 6.2.2
= 200 Gpa
Partial factor of safety for basic and seismic γs = 1.150 IRC-112 Fig 6.3 (Note)
Clear Cover = 70.0 mm
Page 23 of 35
Consultant:
5.5 DESIGN OF DECK SLAB FOR ULS BASIC COMBINATION LONGITUDINAL DIRECTION
5.5.1 Longitudnal Reinforcement Calculation
A Reinforcement Required for Direct Tension if Present

Design Tension KN per m width 10.892 11.806 0.000 10.892 11.806 8.538 7.623 0.000 7.623 0.000 0.000 0.000
Reinforcement Req for DT 25.0508 27.15392 0 25.0508 27.15392 19.6371 17.5339 0 17.5339 0 0 0
B Reinforcement Required for Moment + A above if Present

Design Moment (M) per m Width (KN-m/m) 12.30 11.17 10.08 3.73 4.88 29.71 27.06 7.02 1.20 9.01 1.95 1.45
Width of comp. zone-b / width of Tens. Zone bt (mm) 1000 1000 1000 1000 1000 1000 1000 1000 1000 1000 1000 1000
Effective Depth d (mm) 75.000 75.000 75.000 75.000 75.000 165.000 165.000 165.000 165.000 75.000 75.000 75.000
Kav = M / (bd2f av) 0.2040 0.1852 0.1672 0.0618 0.0809 0.1018 0.0927 0.0241 0.0041 0.1494 0.0324 0.0240
x= (1-sqrt(1-4βKav)/(2*β))*d (mm) 16.8047 15.11031 13.5165 4.75864 6.279922 17.54 15.9137 4.00842 0.67733 11.9714 2.46078 1.81762
x/d 0.22406 0.201471 0.18022 0.06345 0.083732 0.1063 0.09645 0.02429 0.00411 0.15962 0.03281 0.02423
x/d lim = 1/( f yk / (γsEsεcu3)+1) 0.61686 0.616858 0.61686 0.61686 0.616858 0.61686 0.61686 0.61686 0.61686 0.61686 0.61686 0.61686
Chk for x/d < x/d.lim to ensure that Steel Yeilds OK OK OK OK OK OK OK OK OK OK OK OK
Lever Arm z=d-βx (mm) 68.278 68.956 69.593 73.097 72.488 157.984 158.635 163.397 164.729 70.211 74.016 74.273
As required.long =(Mγm)/(f ykZ) (mm^2) 439.4 399.7 333.3 142.4 182.0 452.1 409.9 98.8 34.2 295.2 60.7 44.8
dia of Bar (mm) 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10
Spacing (mm) 150 150 150 150 150 150 150 150 150 200 200 200
As Provided.Long (mm^2) 524 524 524 524 524 524 524 524 524 393 393 393
Check on As provided Ok Ok Ok Ok Ok Ok Ok Ok Ok Ok Ok Ok
Page 24 of 35
Consultant:
5.5.2 Check for minimum and Maximum Limits for Longitudiinal Reinforcement

AS.min1=0.26 (f ctm / f yk) bt d (mm^2) 117 117 117 117 117 257 257 257 257 117 117 117 IRC:112-CL 16.5.1.1 (1)
AS.min2=0.0013 bt d (mm^2) 98 98 98 98 98 215 215 215 215 98 98 98 IRC:112-CL 16.5.1.1 (1)
AS.min = max(AS.min1, AS.min2) (mm^2) 117 117 117 117 117 257 257 257 257 117 117 117 IRC:112-CL 16.5.1.1 (1)
Cross-sectional Area of Concrete Ac (mm^2) 150000 150000 150000 150000 150000 200000 200000 200000 200000 150000 150000 150000
As max tension rein =0.025 Ac (mm^2) 3750 3750 3750 3750 3750 5000 5000 5000 5000 3750 3750 3750 IRC:112-CL 16.5.1.1 (2)
5.5.3 Transverse Reinforcement Calculation

As required.Trans =20% of As Provided.Long (mm^2) 104.72 104.7198 104.72 104.72 104.7198 104.72 104.72 104.72 104.72 78.5398 78.5398 78.5398 IRC:112-CL 16.6.1.1 (3)
dia of Bar (mm) 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10
Spacing (mm) 200 200 200 200 200 200 200 200 200 200 200 200
Page 25 of 35
Consultant:
5.5.4 Surface Reinforcement in Both Direction

cover 70.000 70.000 70.000 70.000 70.000 30.000 30.000 30.000 30.000 70.000 70.000 70.000
Act.ext 70000 70000 70000 70000 70000 30000 30000 30000 30000 70000 70000 70000
As.sur =0.01*Act.ext Not Req Not Req Not Req Not Req Not Req Not Req Not Req Not Req Not Req Not Req Not Req Not Req IRC:112-CL 16.5.4 (4)
dia of Bar (mm) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Spacing (mm) 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10
As Provided 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
5.5.5 Check for Maximum Limits for Total Long Reinforcement

As max Long rein =0.04 Ac (mm^2) 6000 6000 6000 6000 6000 8000 8000 8000 8000 6000 6000 6000 IRC:112-CL 16.5.1.1 (2)
Page 26 of 35
Consultant:
5.5.6 ULS Shear Check at effective depth d as per clause IRC:112 Clause 10.2.3(1) and Check is carried out as per Clause RC:112 Clause 10.3

SF Excluding Factored LL SF per m 2.6833 2.6968 14.1161 4.97585 5.02895 0 0 5.29 5.29 24.9878 -0.5102 7.90185
Factored LL SF per m (KN/m) 5.985 5.985 42.21 42.21 42.21 0 0 63.3645 63.3645 0.636 0.636 0.636
Total VEd calculated without Red factor β (KN/m) 8.6683 8.6818 56.3261 47.1859 47.23895 0 0 68.6545 68.6545 25.6238 0.12585 8.53785
Strength reduction Factor for concrete cracked in
0.542 0.542 0.542 0.542 0.542 0.542 0.542 0.542 0.542 0.542 0.542 0.542 IRC:112-CL 10.3.2(5) Eq 10.6
Shear ν =0.6(1-f ck/310)
Limit For Application of Red to LL SF 0.5bwdνf cd 272.32 272.32 272.32 272.32 272.32 599.11 599.11 599.11 599.11 272.32 272.32 272.32
Chk Limit For Application of Reduction to LL SF

APP APP APP APP APP APP APP APP APP APP APP APP IRC:112-CL 10.3.2(5) Eq 10.5
Ved<=0.5bwdνfcd
αv is d and is within 0.5d to 2d 75.000 75.000 75.000 75.000 75.000 165.000 165.000 165.000 165.000 75.000 75.000 75.000 IRC:112-CL 10.3.2(5)
if Limit for Application is APP then β=αv/2d else if NA
0.5 0.5 0.5 0.5 0.5 0.5 0.5 0.5 0.5 0.5 0.5 0.5
then β=1
Design Shear Force per m VEd (KN/m)
=SF Excluding Factored LL SF +β*Factored 5.676 5.689 35.221 26.081 26.134 0.000 0.000 36.972 36.972 25.306 -0.192 8.220 IRC:112-CL 10.3.2 (5)
LL SF
Applied Longitudinal Force Ned (KN/m) -10.892 -11.806 25.624 -10.892 -11.806 -8.538 -7.623 14.106 -7.623 76.881 72.768 68.655
Min Breadth bw (mm) 1000 1000 1000 1000 1000 1000 1000 1000 1000 1000 1000 1000
Effective Depth d (mm) 75.000 75.000 75.000 75.000 75.000 165.000 165.000 165.000 165.000 75.000 75.000 75.000
1+Sqrt( 200/d) 2.6330 2.6330 2.6330 2.6330 2.6330 2.1010 2.1010 2.1010 2.1010 2.6330 2.6330 2.6330
Coefficent K=min(1+Sqrt( 200/d), 2.0) 2.0000 2.0000 2.0000 2.0000 2.0000 2.0000 2.0000 2.0000 2.0000 2.0000 2.0000 2.0000 IRC:112-CL 10.3.2 Eq 10.2
νmin=0.031 K(3/2) fck(1/2) 0.4802 0.4802 0.4802 0.4802 0.4802 0.4802 0.4802 0.4802 0.4802 0.4802 0.4802 0.4802 IRC:112-CL 10.3.2 Eq 10.3
Cross-sectional Area of Concrete Ac (mm^2) 150000 150000 150000 150000 150000 200000 200000 200000 200000 150000 150000 150000
Ned / Ac -0.073 -0.079 0.171 -0.073 -0.079 -0.043 -0.038 0.071 -0.038 0.513 0.485 0.458
0.2 f cd 2.680 2.680 2.680 2.680 2.680 2.680 2.680 2.680 2.680 2.680 2.680 2.680
Compressive stress in con σcp = min (Ned / Ac , 0.2 f cd) -0.073 -0.079 0.171 -0.073 -0.079 -0.043 -0.038 0.071 -0.038 0.513 0.485 0.458 IRC:112-CL 10.3.2
Area of tensile reinforcement Asl (mm^2) 524 524 524 524 524 524 524 524 524 393 393 393
Asl / (bwd) 0.0070 0.0070 0.0070 0.0070 0.0070 0.0032 0.0032 0.0032 0.0032 0.0052 0.0052 0.0052
ρ1 = min( Asl / (bwd) , 0.02 ) 0.0070 0.0070 0.0070 0.0070 0.0070 0.0032 0.0032 0.0032 0.0032 0.0052 0.0052 0.0052 IRC:112-CL 10.3.2
Page 27 of 35
Consultant:
VRd.c1 = (vmin + 0.15σcp)bwd 35.202 35.133 37.941 35.202 35.133 78.185 78.298 80.987 78.298 41.785 41.476 41.168 IRC:112-CL 10.3.2 Eq 10.1
VRd.c2 = (0.12 K(80 ρ1.f ck)0.33+ 0.15σcp)bwd 45.243 45.174 47.982 45.243 45.174 76.855 76.969 79.658 76.969 47.614 47.306 46.997 IRC:112-CL 10.3.2 Eq 10.1
design Shear Resistance VRd.c = Max (VRd.c1 , VRd.c2) 45.243 45.174 47.982 45.243 45.174 78.185 78.298 80.987 78.298 47.614 47.306 46.997 IRC:112-CL 10.3.2 Eq 10.1
Shear Reinforcement Requirement Not Req Not Req Not Req Not Req Not Req Not Req Not Req Not Req Not Req Not Req Not Req Not Req IRC:112-CL 10.3.2 (1)
if VRd.c >= Ved then "Not Req" else "Req"
5.6 SLS STRESS CHECK OF DECK SLAB FOR SLS RARE COMBINATION LONGITUDINAL DIRECTION (Mid Span)
SLS Stress check has to be carried out for service life as per IRC:112 clause 12.1(1). Hence stress is checked at bridge opening as well as 70yrs when all of creep has taken place
5.6.1 SLS Stress Chexk Under Rare Combuination At Bridge Opening
1. Check whether concrete is Cracked or Uncracked in Rare Combination

Design Moment (MRC) per m Width (KN-m/m) 6.736 5.480 6.596 1.847 3.126 17.741 14.804 3.552 0.331 6.083 2.672 3.268
b 1000 1000 1000 1000 1000 1000 1000 1000 1000 1000 1000 1000
D 150.000 150.000 150.000 150.000 150.000 200.000 200.000 200.000 200.000 150.000 150.000 150.000
Uncracked I = (bD^3) / 12 (mm^4) 2.8E+08 2.8E+08 2.8E+08 2.8E+08 2.8E+08 6.7E+08 6.7E+08 6.7E+08 6.7E+08 2.8E+08 2.8E+08 2.8E+08
Y=Ytop = Ybot = D/2 75.000 75.000 75.000 75.000 75.000 100.000 100.000 100.000 100.000 75.000 75.000 75.000
σtop = σbot = MRC *Y/I 1.796 1.461 1.759 0.493 0.834 2.661 2.221 0.533 0.050 1.622 0.713 0.872
Mean Flexural tensile Strength
4.350 4.350 4.350 4.350 4.350 4.200 4.200 4.200 4.200 4.350 4.350 4.350 IRC:112-CL 6.4.2.3 (3) Eq 6.6
f ctm.fl = max( (1.6-h/1000)f ctm , f ctm )
if σbot > f ctm.fl then "Cracked" else "Uncracked" UncrackedUncrackedUncrackeUncrackeUncracked UncrackeUncrackeUncrackedUncrackeUncrackeUncrackeUncrackedIRC:112-CL 12.1(2)
Allowable Compressive Stress = 0.48 f ck 14.4000 14.4000 14.4000 14.4000 14.4000 14.4000 14.4000 14.4000 14.4000 14.4000 14.4000 14.4000 IRC:112-CL 12.2.1(1)
Chk on Comp stress if section is Uncracked else

OK OK OK OK OK OK OK OK OK OK OK OK
blank(-) and Chk for Cracked section to follow
Page 28 of 35
Consultant:
2. Cracked Section Stress Check at 0 days after construction

Effective Modulus of Elasticity of concrete Ec,eff =
33000 33000 33000 33000 33000 33000 33000 33000 33000 33000 33000 33000
short term Modulu s= Ecm (Mpa)
Modulus of Elasticity of Steel Es (Mpa) 200000 200000 200000 200000 200000 200000 200000 200000 200000 200000 200000 200000
Area of Steel As (mm^2) 524 524 524 524 524 524 524 524 524 393 393 393
b 1000 1000 1000 1000 1000 1000 1000 1000 1000 1000 1000 1000
d 75.000 75.000 75.000 75.000 75.000 165.000 165.000 165.000 165.000 75.000 75.000 75.000
Depth of Concrete in Compression(mm)
19 19 19 19 19 29 29 29 29 17 17 17
dc=(-AsEs+Sqr((AsEs)^2 +2bAsEsEc,effd))/(bEc,eff)
Cracked I = As(d-dc)^2 +(1/3)(Ec,eff/Es)*bdc^3 (mm^4) 2.0E+06 2.0E+06 2.0E+06 2.0E+06 2.0E+06 1.1E+07 1.1E+07 1.1E+07 1.1E+07 1.6E+06 1.6E+06 1.6E+06
zc = I / dc (mm^3) 1.1E+05 1.1E+05 1.1E+05 1.1E+05 1.1E+05 3.8E+05 3.8E+05 3.8E+05 3.8E+05 9.5E+04 9.5E+04 9.5E+04
zs = I / (d-dc) (mm^3) 3.6E+04 3.6E+04 3.6E+04 3.6E+04 3.6E+04 8.1E+04 8.1E+04 8.1E+04 8.1E+04 2.7E+04 2.7E+04 2.7E+04
Design Moment (MEd = MRC) 6.736 5.480 6.596 1.847 3.126 17.741 14.804 3.552 0.331 6.083 2.672 3.268
Stress in conc σc = (MEd / zc)*(Ec,eff / Es) 10.388 8.451 10.173 2.849 4.821 7.790 6.501 1.560 0.145 10.513 4.618 5.648
Check on Concrete Stress OK OK OK OK OK OK OK OK OK OK OK OK
Stress in Steel σs = (MEd / zs) 187.228 152.316 183.35 51.340 86.892 218.288 182.151 43.704 4.075 223.051 97.979 119.839 IRC:112-CL 12.2.1(1)
Allowable Tensile Stress = 0.8 f yk 400.000 400.000 400.000 400.000 400.000 400.000 400.000 400.000 400.000 400.000 400.000 400.000 IRC:112-CL 12.2.2
Check on Steel Stress OK OK OK OK OK OK OK OK OK OK OK OK
Page 29 of 35
Consultant:
5.6.2 Cracked Section Stress Check at end of service life (70 Yrs)
1. Check whether Linear Creep or Non-linear Creep is applicable for Quasi-Permanent load

Design Moment MQP 1.996 -1.368 3.779 0.331 0.309 4.366 2.897 2.089 1.794 3.922 3.429 3.262
Stress in conc σc = (MQP / zc)*(Ec,eff / Es) 3.079 -2.110 5.828 0.510 0.477 1.917 1.272 0.917 0.788 6.778 5.925 5.638
Stress limit for considering linear creep = 0.36 f ck 10.800 10.800 10.800 10.800 10.800 10.800 10.800 10.800 10.800 10.800 10.800 10.800 IRC:112-CL 12.2.1(1)
Creep Model: if σc <=0.36 fck then "Linear" else
Linear Linear Linear Linear Linear Linear Linear Linear Linear Linear Linear Linear
"Non-Linear"
2. Find Creep Coeff Φ(70 Yrs) considering RH -80% and Age at loading as 28 days

b 1000 1000 1000 1000 1000 1000 1000 1000 1000 1000 1000 1000
D 150.000 150.000 150.000 150.000 150.000 200.000 200.000 200.000 200.000 150.000 150.000 150.000
Ac 150000 150000 150000 150000 150000 200000 200000 200000 200000 150000 150000 150000
u=2b for P2 To P13 and 2b+D for P1 2150 2000 2000 2000 2000 2000 2000 2000 2000 2000 2000 2000
Notional Size 70 75 75 75 75 100 100 100 100 75 75 75
Φ(70 Yrs) 1.736 1.733 1.733 1.733 1.733 1.722 1.722 1.722 1.722 1.733 1.733 1.733 Interpolation from
IRC:112-CL 6.4.2.7(2) Table 6.9
Page 30 of 35
Consultant:
3. Calculation for Ec,eff for combination of Short Term and Long Term Effects

Short term Modulus Ecm 33000 33000 33000 33000 33000 33000 33000 33000 33000 33000 33000 33000
Long term Modulus Ecm/(1+Φ) 12063 12073 12073 12073 12073 12122 12122 12122 12122 12073 12073 12073 IRC:112-CL 6.4.2.5(4)(iii)
Total Moment MRC 6.736 5.480 6.596 1.847 3.126 17.741 14.804 3.552 0.331 6.083 2.672 3.268
Moment Due to Quasi-Permanent Loads MQP 1.996 -1.368 3.779 0.331 0.309 4.366 2.897 2.089 1.794 3.922 3.429 3.262
Moment Due to Transient (short term) Loads
4.740 6.848 2.817 1.517 2.817 13.375 11.907 1.463 -1.463 2.161 -0.757 0.006
MST=MRC-MQP
Effective Modulus Ec,eff = (
21791 58179 16557 25188 28173 23177 24681 16394 3195 15584 10235 12087
MQP + MST ) Ecm / ( MST + (1+Φ)MQP )
4 Cracked Section Stress Check at 70 Years

21791 58179 16557 25188 28173 23177 24681 16394 3195 15584 10235 12087
as calculated above
b 1000 1000 1000 1000 1000 1000 1000 1000 1000 1000 1000 1000
d 75 75 75 75 75 165 165 165 165 75 75 75
22 15 25 21 20 34 33 40 76 23 27 25
Design Moment (MEd = MRC) 6.736 5.480 6.596 1.847 3.126 17.741 14.804 3.552 0.331 6.083 2.672 3.268
Stress in conc σc = (MEd / zc)*(Ec,eff / Es) 8.881 10.615 7.883 2.569 4.537 6.726 5.759 1.172 0.062 7.882 2.988 3.869
Page 31 of 35
Consultant:
Check on Concrete Stress OK OK OK OK OK OK OK OK OK OK OK OK
Stress in Steel σs = (MEd / zs) 190.553 149.314 189.078 51.916 87.449 220.665 183.758 44.725 4.531 229.948 103.151 125.079 IRC:112-CL 12.2.1(1)
Allowable Tensile Stress = 0.8 f yk 400.000 400.000 400.000 400.000 400.000 400.000 400.000 400.000 400.000 400.000 400.000 400.000 IRC:112-CL 12.2.2
Check on Steel Stress OK OK OK OK OK OK OK OK OK OK OK OK
5.7 SLS CRACK WIDTH OF DECK SLAB FOR SLS QUASI-PERMANENT COMBINATION LONGITUDINAL DIRECTION (Mid Span)
Allowable Crack width wk 0.3 mm For moderate exposure condition and Reinforced Concrete members from IRC:112 Clause 12.3.2(1) Table 12.1
5.7.1 Minimum Reinforcement for Crack Control (IRC:112 Clause 12.3.3)

b 1000 1000 1000 1000 1000 1000 1000 1000 1000 1000 1000 1000
h=D 150.000 150.000 150.000 150.000 150.000 200.000 200.000 200.000 200.000 150.000 150.000 150.000
Depth of section in tension before crack forms h/2 75.000 75.000 75.000 75.000 75.000 100.000 100.000 100.000 100.000 75.000 75.000 75.000
Area of concrete in tension just before crack formation
75000 75000 75000 75000 75000 100000 100000 100000 100000 75000 75000 75000
Act =b*h/2
f ct,eff = max( f ctm , 2.9) 3.000 3.000 3.000 3.000 3.000 3.000 3.000 3.000 3.000 3.000 3.000 3.000
Coeff for effect of non uniform self equilibrating

1.000 1.000 1.000 1.000 1.000 1.000 1.000 1.000 1.000 1.000 1.000 1.000
stresses which lead to reduction of restraint forces k
Axial Forces in Quasi perm. Combination NEd 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000
mean stress of concrete σc = NEd / (bh) 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000
h* = h for h<1000 else h* =1000 150.000 150.000 150.000 150.000 150.000 200.000 200.000 200.000 200.000 150.000 150.000 150.000
Coeff for considering effect of Axial force Ned on
stress distribution k1 = 1.5 for compressive and (2h*) / 1.500 1.500 1.500 1.500 1.500 1.500 1.500 1.500 1.500 1.500 1.500 1.500
(3h) for Tensile
Page 32 of 35
Consultant:
Coeff to take into account stress distribution just prior
to cracking and change of Lever Arm kc = 0.4 ( 0.400 0.400 0.400 0.400 0.400 0.400 0.400 0.400 0.400 0.400 0.400 0.400
1 - σc / ( k1( h / h* ) f ct,eff ) ) <= 1
bar dia 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10
Spacing 150 150 150 150 150 150 150 150 150 200 200 200
Permited σs from bar dia 320 320 320 320 320 320 320 320 320 320 320 320 Interpolated From IRC:112 Table 12.2
Permited σs from bar spacing 280 280 280 280 280 280 280 280 280 240 240 240 Interpolated From IRC:112 Table 12.3
Permited σs = min of above 2 values 280 280 280 280 280 280 280 280 280 240 240 240
As.min = kckf ct,effAct / σs 321 321 321 321 321 429 429 429 429 375 375 375
Provided steel 524 524 524 524 524 524 524 524 524 393 393 393
Chk on Proovided Steel for Crack Control OK OK OK OK OK OK OK OK OK OK OK OK
5.7.2 Crack Width Check Under Quasi Permanent Load Combination
1. Analysis of section for Quasi-Permanent loads at 70 Years

21791 58179 16557 25188 28173 23177 24681 16394 3195 15584 10235 12087
as calculated above
b 1000 1000 1000 1000 1000 1000 1000 1000 1000 1000 1000 1000
d 75 75 75 75 75 165 165 165 165 75 75 75
22 15 25 21 20 34 33 40 76 23 27 25
Page 33 of 35
Consultant:
Design Moment (MEd = MQP) 1.996 -1.368 3.779 0.331 0.309 4.366 2.897 2.089 1.794 3.922 3.429 3.262
Stress in conc σc = (MEd / zc)*(Ec,eff / Es) 2.632 -2.650 4.516 0.460 0.448 1.655 1.127 0.689 0.337 5.082 3.834 3.862
Stress in Steel σs = (MEd / zs) 56.472 -37.282 108.329 9.290 8.644 54.300 35.961 26.306 24.546 148.257 132.355 124.859 IRC:112-CL 12.2.1(1)
2. Calculation of Crack Width w k

b 1000 1000 1000 1000 1000 1000 1000 1000 1000 1000 1000 1000
h=D 150.000 150.000 150.000 150.000 150.000 200.000 200.000 200.000 200.000 150.000 150.000 150.000
d 75 75 75 75 75 165 165 165 165 75 75 75
x = dc calculated Above 22 15 25 21 20 34 33 40 76 23 27 25
hc,eff = min( 2.5(h-d) , (h-x)/3, h/2 ) 43 45 42 43 43 55 56 53 41 42 41 42
Ac,eff = b hc,eff 42510 45090 41627 42947 43271 55214 55528 53344 41244 42362 40963 41536
As 524 524 524 524 524 524 524 524 524 393 393 393
ρp,eff = As / Ac,eff 0.01232 0.011612 0.01258 0.01219 0.0121 0.00948 0.00943 0.00982 0.0127 0.00927 0.00959 0.00945 IRC:112 Clause 12.3.4 Eq 12.7
Coeff for Bond Properties k1 (0.8 for deformed bars) 0.8 0.8 0.8 0.8 0.8 0.8 0.8 0.8 0.8 0.8 0.8 0.8
Coeff for strain dist k2 (0.5 for bending) 0.5 0.5 0.5 0.5 0.5 0.5 0.5 0.5 0.5 0.5 0.5 0.5
Clear Cover to Long Reinf c (mm) 70 70 70 70 70 30 30 30 30 70 70 70
Dai of Bar Φ 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10
Spacing of Reinf. Sp 150 150 150 150 150 150 150 150 150 200 200 200
5(c+Φ/2) 375 375 375 375 375 175 175 175 175 375 375 375
Max crack Spacing For Sp <=5(c+Φ/2)
Sr.max= 3.4c + 0.425 k1k2Φ / ρp,eff and For
376.02 384.3967 373.153 377.439 378.4913 281.266 282.287 275.196 235.908 421.387 415.331 417.811 IRC:112 Clause 12.3.4 Eq 12.8/12.12
Sp <=5(c+Φ/2) Sr.max = 1.3*( h-
x)
Page 34 of 35
Consultant:
Factor dependent on duration of loading kt
0.5 0.5 0.5 0.5 0.5 0.5 0.5 0.5 0.5 0.5 0.5 0.5
(taken as 0.5)
Stress in tension Reinforcement σsc 56 -37 108 9 9 54 36 26 25 148 132 125
Short term Modulus Ecm 33000 33000 33000 33000 33000 33000 33000 33000 33000 33000 33000 33000
αe = Es/Ecm 6.061 6.061 6.061 6.061 6.061 6.061 6.061 6.061 6.061 6.061 6.061 6.061
f ct,eff = max( f ctm , 2.9) 3.000 3.000 3.000 3.000 3.000 3.000 3.000 3.000 3.000 3.000 3.000 3.000
( εsm - εsm ) is >= 0.6 σsc / Es 0.00017 -0.00011 0.00032 0.00003 0.00003 0.00016 0.00011 0.00008 0.00007 0.00044 0.00040 0.00037 IRC:112 Clause 12.3.4 Eq 12.6
εsm - εsm = ( σsc - ( k1fct,eff / ρp,eff )( 1- αeρp,eff ) )/Es -0.0004 -0.0009 -0.0001 -0.0006 -0.0006 -0.0006 -0.0007 -0.0007 -0.0005 -0.0001 -0.0002 -0.0002 IRC:112 Clause 12.3.4 Eq 12.7
εsm - εsm = max of above two values 0.00017 -0.00011 0.00032 0.00003 0.00003 0.00016 0.00011 0.00008 0.00007 0.00044 0.00040 0.00037 IRC:112 Clause 12.3.4 Eq 12.8
Calculated Crack width wk = Sr,max( εsm - εsm ) 0.064 -0.043 0.121 0.011 0.010 0.046 0.030 0.022 0.017 0.187 0.165 0.157 IRC:112 Clause 12.3.4 Eq 12.5
Allowable Crack Width (mm) 0.300 0.300 0.300 0.300 0.300 0.300 0.300 0.300 0.300 0.300 0.300 0.300
Chk on allowable Crack Width OK OK OK OK OK OK OK OK OK OK OK OK
Page 35 of 35

Drain-4 Size 1.0X1.25

Загружено:

Сведения о документе

Авторское право

Доступные форматы

Поделиться этим документом

Поделиться или встроить документ

Параметры публикации

Этот документ был вам полезен?

Это неприемлемый материал?

Авторское право:

Доступные форматы

Drain-4 Size 1.0X1.25

Загружено:

Авторское право:

Доступные форматы

MUNICIPAL CORPORATION, SONEPAT, HARYANA

Rehabilitation of Drain No.6 into RCC Strom Water Drain

Design Note No : INFRA/SON/DR/004

Title : Design of City Drain Type-4 (Section Size 1.0 X 1.25)

Contractor/Executing Agency : M/s MSKEL-GARG (JV)

1.0 GEOMETRIC DATA FOR MODELING

1.3.1 Self Weight SW

Selfweight is applied directly in STAAD

1.3.2 Load Of Finishes LOF

1.3.3 CLASS - A Wheel Load CALL

load start distance 0.444 m

0.15 1.0 0.15

1.3.6 Uplift Pressure Due to water table at Ground Level UPBSWTGL

Total Height 1.8 m

Total Weight of Water 1.619 kN

1.3.9 Weight of Dry Soil on Cantilever Slab WDSCS

1.3.10 Weight of Saturated Soil on Cantilever Slab WSSCS

1.3.11 Earth Pressure At Rest of Saturated Soil EPRSS

Angle of Internal Frict φ 30

1.3.12 Live load Surcharge At Rest of Saturated Soil LLSSS

1.3.15 Uniform Temparature Rise UTR

Uniform Temperature Rise 33 deg C

1.3.16 Uniform Temparature Fall UTF

Uniform Temperature Fall -33 deg C

Weight of Saturated soil on cantilever Slab 2.590 KN

Total Weight 28.827 KN

Check for Uplift OK

3.1 Base Pressure Check

Assumed allowable Bearing Capacity 8 T/m2

F (KN) from Base Pressure

1 2.348 0.0875 1.000 0.04375 5.367 OK

C1 Drain Empty Water Table at Ground + Temp Rising

4.2 Load Combinations for Design Conditions

1.5 1.5 1.5 1.5 0.75 0.75 0.75 0.75 0 0 0 0

Weight of Water on base slab in 0 0 1.5 1.5 0 0 1 1 0 0 1 1

Weight of Saturated Soil on Cantilever 1.5 1.5 0 0 1 1 0 0 1 1 0 0

0 0.9 0 0.9 0 1 0 1 0 0.5 0 0.5

0.9 0 0.9 0 1 0 1 0 0.5 0 0.5 0

0 0.9 0 0.9 0 1 0 1 0 0.5 0 0.5

4.3 Load Combination Results

Beam Second Node Result

ULS BC SLS RC SLS QPC

ULS BC SLS RC SLS QPC

ULS BC SLS RC SLS QPC

5.1 Dimension & Design Cases

MEMBER BOTTOM SLAB TOP SLAB WALL

5.2 ULS Design Forces/Moments

5.2.1 Longitudinal Moments ULS

5.2.2 ULS Shear

5.3 SLS Design Moments

5.3.1 Longitudinal Moments at Mid Span (SLS Rare Combination)

5.3.4 Longitudinal Moments at Mid Span (SLS Quasi-Permanent Combination)

5.4 Material Data

Grade of Concrete (Standard Concrete) = M30 IRC:112 Cl 6.4.1

Design value of concrete compressive strength f cd = 13.400 Mpa IRC:112-Cl 6.4.2.8

5.5.1 Longitudnal Reinforcement Calculation

A Reinforcement Required for Direct Tension if Present

MEMBER BOTTOM SLAB TOP SLAB WALL

B Reinforcement Required for Moment + A above if Present

MEMBER BOTTOM SLAB TOP SLAB WALL

Chk for x/d < x/d.lim to ensure that Steel Yeilds OK OK OK OK OK OK OK OK OK OK OK OK

MEMBER BOTTOM SLAB TOP SLAB WALL

5.5.3 Transverse Reinforcement Calculation

MEMBER BOTTOM SLAB TOP SLAB WALL