Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
Tribological Performance
Analysis of Aluminum
Based Hydrodynamic
Journal Bearing.
Vaibhav Jadhav1, Prof. P. P.Ritapure2
Fig. 1 Journal Bearing
Abstract—The aluminum based materials are widely used in Journal bearing surfaces are divided into three lubrication
highly performance bearings application. In the present work, regimes corresponding to the Stribeck Curve shown in figure 2.
New Aluminum based Al-25Zn-5Cu alloy material is produced by The curve represents the minimum value of friction torque
metal mould stir casting technique. The aim of research work to between large fluid separation and contact of two surfaces. The
investigate tribological performance of hydrodynamic journal highest friction occurred in boundary lubrication region, which
bearing made of Al-25Zn-5Cu alloy material were analyzed represents contact between the two surfaces also the
experimentally and a comparative study between two different hydrodynamic lubrication region represents a load supported
hydrodynamic journal bearing made of materials Al-25Zn-5Cu by the lubricating oil with no contact of surfaces. At the end the
and Brass were analyzed. The oil temperature rise, pressure mixed lubrication region represents mean load support from
distribution, surface roughness, weight loss were calculated for
lubricating oil and some of load support from contact.
different loads, speed and times range. It was found that pressure
distribution were developed more in Al-25Zn-5Cu alloy material
as compare to brass material journal bearing. At the end wear
analysis of two different hydrodynamic journal bearing
investigated by using surface roughness and weight loss. Further
the weight loss, surface roughness and oil temperature rise were
observed less in Al-25Zn-5Cu alloy bearing as compare to brass
bearing. As experimental results shows that aluminum based
hydrodynamic journal bearing can be an alternative for the
existing brass bearing with improving tribological properties and
performance of journal bearing.
1Vaibhav
T. Jadhav, PG student, Mechanical Engineering Department, ZES’s, Prof. P. P. Ritapure, Professor, Mechanical Engineering Department , ZES’s,
ZEAL College of Engineering & Research, Narhe, Pune-41. ZEAL College of Engineering & Research, Narhe, Pune-41.
2
Experimental Tribological Performance Analysis of Aluminum Based Hydrodynamic Journal Bearing.
direction of rotation. A Pieces of bearing material may spread wear resistance as compared to the bronze.Smearing type of
out also pulled away in direction of rotation of journal. The adhesion appeared to be the most effective wear mechanism for
cracks extend toward the bearing material bonding particles. the Al-25Zn-3Cu alloy. Al-Zn alloy containing small amounts
Fatigues can develop due to because of misalignment, of copper are increasing the importance as a bearing material
imbalance, bent shaft, journal eccentricity, and vibration. The also Zinc and aluminum based alloy containing 40%Al and 2%
Corrosion damage is a removal of the bearing surface lining by Cu exhibited better tribological properties. Zn-Al based alloy
chemical attack. Corrosive materials were get in contact with had better seizure resistance at load less than 175N.A excellent
lubricating oil due to decomposition of oil additives, acid embeddability and good running-in properties were
oxidation, water in lube oil, corrosive contamination. Erosion demonstrated for bearing.H.C.Patel.et.al. [7] investigated the
damage developed in material voids with smooth edges in the performance of ferrofluid based hydrodynamic journal bearing
direction of rotational moment. Most of the time damage system considering different combination of shaft and bearing
occurred in stationary component. Cavitation damage is material. Film pressure and temperature rises were measured
developed due to the formation of vapour bubbles in areas of for varying speeds and loads also wear analysis was carried out
rapid pressure differences. using microscopic observation of the bearing surface, weight
loss. The life of hydrodynamic journal bearing life when the
II.RESEARCH BACKGROUND contacting surface occurs at bearing surface studied by David
The journal bearing are operating under steady subjected to sander et.al. [8].The results show that wear is caused by metal-
wear during start-up and start-down, contamination with metal contact due to the elastic bending of shaft also maximum
abrasive debris and misalignment of shaft also working under contact pressure in mixed lubrication decrease with adapted
high temperature and overload would be wear under load surfaces. The adapted surface is due to shaft speed, surface
reported by M.M.Khonsari et.al.[1].The major problem of roughness and temperature. The main reason for more
white metal is seiziure when lubricating film is broken under innovation in the journal bearing is the set of specific properties
heavy load studied by D.G.lee.et.al.[2].Therefore there is scope to which material has to withstand the load. If we consider from
for research on journal bearing material to improve mechanical chemical point of view, material have to be corrosion resistant,
and triabological properties. From recent study reported that toxicity. A high thermal conductivity is important to transport
Osman Bican et.al. [3] developed aluminum–zinc-based a new the heat dissipated, a low coefficient of expansion is
alloy for tribological application. A new Al-25Zn-5Cu was advantageous in journal bearing and a high melting point is
prepared by mould casting and their microstructure and required to maintain sustainable strength at the operating
mechanical properties were investigated. The sliding friction temperature studied by A. E. Bravo et.al. [9]. To reduce power
and wear properties Al-25Zn-5Cu alloys were found out using loss and increase load carrying capacity of journal bearing a
a pin-on-disc machine. The highest hardness and tensile various approaches focus on journal bearing design.
strength were obtained with the Al–25Zn-5Cu alloy among D.A.Bompos et.al.[10] investigated performance of multistep
tested among standard material. Addition of copper to this alloy journal bearing. A maximum friction coefficient improvement
increase hardness with increasing copper content. The highest of 38% is obtained with simultaneous 9.7% improvement of
tensile and compressive strengths and wear resistance and load capacity as compare to plain bearing. F.M.Meng et.al.[11]
lowest friction coefficient were obtained in Al–25Zn–5Cu alloy studied tribological performance for the bearing with
also Al-25Zn-5Cu alloy were found superior as compared to compound dimple and simple dimple. The results shows that
SAE 660 bronze for mechanical and sliding wear compound dimple supply larger load carrying capacity and
properties.Nehir et.al.[4] investigated the performance of Al- lower friction coefficient due to its twice hydrodynamic action
based material studied experimentally. The Al-based bearing in comparison with the simple dimple. Hydrodynamic Journal
materials have higher fatigue strength than white metal bearings bearing are used in different rotating machine. This type of
and can be used at high working temperature. The aluminum bearing working under large load at mean rotational speed but
based alloys have good material properties like resistance to in some cases the machine fitted with these bearing can operate
corrosive effects, low cost, high thermal conductivity, lightness at very high rotation speed condition. So when bearing is
and workability. The aluminum based alloys are developed to working at high rotation speed there is possibility of failure.
use in high performance engine bearings. The main factor Therefore this limits the load acting on bearing surface and
improving the efficiency of the internal combustion engine is working speed of journal. Therefore it is significant to know the
usage of aluminum alloy. Yasin alemdag et.al.[5] examined the load and speed above which bearing will failure. The frictional
microstructure of Al-40Zn-Cu alloy consists of aluminum rich force plays important role in journal bearing design. Frictional
surrounded by CuAl2 particles. Hardness of alloy increases force decreases the rotation speed, load carrying capacity and
continuously with increasing copper content. The Al-40Zn-Cu surface finish which cause failure of journal bearing.
alloy were found to much superior than SAE65 bronze for wear Most of existing studies are deal with journal bearing
resistance and higher strength. Temel savaskan [6] investigated lubrication parameters, journal bearing design. In addition,
friction wear properties of Al-25Zn-3Cu alloy over a range of none of us focused on to studied journal bearing performance
oil flow rate, pressure and sliding speed using pin on disc made up of Al-25Zn-5Cu material having better properties as
machine. The obtained results were compared with compared to other classical bearing material so that the aim of
conventional bearing material SAE65 bronze. The friction proposed work was to investigate the performance of
coefficient and wear volume of the alloy decreases with hydrodynamic journal bearing made up of Al-25Zn-5Cu
increasing oil flow rate. The Al-25Zn-3Cu alloy has higher material experimentally using journal bearing test rig under
3
Experimental Tribological Performance Analysis of Aluminum Based Hydrodynamic Journal Bearing.
different parameter such as load, rotational speed, surface will be placed in the range of 200N to 800N.To the other side
roughness, pressure distribution, oil rise in temperature, weight is mounted a ball bearing through which normal load is applied
loss. In the proposed work performance analysis of to the bearing surface. Lever is located to get 1:5 loading ratio.
hydrodynamic journal bearing is carried out of dimension (L/D The oil filling system is provided on the top of base plate to
=1),speed range of 800 to 1400rpm and load range of 200 to gravity feed the bearing by using a flexible tube before start of
800 N on a journal bearing test rig. A New Hydrodynamic testing to remove any trapped air. An oil sump is mounted to
journal bearing made of Al-25Zn-5Cu MMC material is supply continuous lubrication for the journal bearing system.
developed to improve tribological properties and results were The oil sump is placed on bottom base plate, which is fixed on
compare with brass material journal bearing. to the supporting structure member.
The Testing parameter such as disc speed can be set using front
III. EXPERIMENTAL PROCEDURE panel settings on the controller. The load is applied by dead
A. Description of Experimental Setup weights through loading lever assembly. The pressure and
torque readings are displayed along with indexing angle during
The hydrodynamic journal bearing test rig is known for found testing. Pressure and angle readings are processed and
out the film pressure distribution in a lubricating oil under transmitted through data acquisition cable. The Port’s for signal
different load condition also measure frictional torque. This is input cable and data acquisition cable MS connector for control
a vertical machine which helps to find out pressure at respective cable and fuse. Data acquisition software having data
angular position of pressure sensor with the load chain. The acquisition cable and one CD containing winducom 2004
Hydrodynamic journal bearing machine contains a vertical software.
journal and driven under different speed by motor. A bellow
made up of metal joints journal bearing material at top and Table 1 Specifications of Al-25Zn and brass bearing systems.
bottom is fixed to friction torque load cell. The hydrodynamic Al-25Zn-5Cu Brass
journal Bearing made of Al-25Zn-5Cu and brass material which Specifications bearing bearing
covered the journal lower portion also these bearing is dipped system systems
into oil sump. The speed sensor disc is located on the driven Material
Al-25Zn-5Cu Brass
pulley to calculate the revolution of the journal per minute. A
stepper motor rotate the hydrodynamic journal bearing in the Journal bearing roughness
direction of the rotation of the journal up to 180° in steps of (Ra) 0.5 0.6
9°.A pressure sensor is fixed on the journal bearing which
calculate the film pressure distributed in the lubricating oil film Journal Material
AISI410 AISI410
layer. The Radial load is applied to journal bearing by dead
weights through a lever chain mechanism. The assembly of the Journal surface roughness
journal and the bearing is dipped into oil sump to have (Ra) 0.3µm 0.3µm
continuous lubrication. The journal bearing machine is
connected to the controller. The controller shows reading values Inner diameter of bearing
40.12mm 40.12mm
of rotating position of pressure sensor with reference to the load
and the respective pressure values. The perpendicular load, Diameter of journal
39.97mm 39.97mm
speed can increase as per testing load case data. The Frictional
force value can also be showed on the controller. The output Length of bearing
40.00mm 40.00mm
data obtained are transfer to computer through data acquisition
cable line. Clearance 0.07mm 0.07mm
B. Material for Journal Bearing System
The importance of the use of aluminum metal matrix composite
reinforced with Zinc in engineering application lies in the
excellent characteristics such as light weight, increases strength
also reduce ductility and corrosion resistance. The Stir casting
is a liquid state method of composite material fabrication in
which a dispersed phase is mixed with a molten matrix metal
by means of mechanical stirring.
Fig. 3 Journal bearing test rig.
The journal bearing test rig consists of bearing assembly,
journal shaft assembly, lubricating oil system, sensors, loading
assembly, controller, data acquisition software and cables.
Journal is inserted in spindle housing supported on bearing.
Spindle housing is fixed to base plate. Journal shaft is rotated
by an AC motor through pulley chain arrangement. The rpm
sensor disc is mounted on top of spindle to measure speed. A
lever is provided having a lever ratio of 1:5.The one end of the
lever a loading pan is attached on which the different weights
4
Experimental Tribological Performance Analysis of Aluminum Based Hydrodynamic Journal Bearing.
D. Test Procedure
The fabricated hydrodynamic journal bearing made of Al-
25Zn-5Cu and Brass material is mounted on Journal bearing
test rig alternatively for testing. The experimental analysis was
carried out on both bearing system for different loading
conditions at different journal speed. Firstly pressure
distribution was measured at different loads and speeds then
wear analysis was conducted for journal bearing under
lubricated condition with frequent starts and stops because
maximum wear occur in journal bearing while starting and
stopping. The Wear loss, surface roughness in both journal
bearing measured after 50 cycles of starts and stops based upon
Fig. 4 Stir casting process of Al-25Zn-5Cu material researcher works. The oil temperature rise is measured under
The preparation of metal matrix composites by stir casting different speed and constant load for continuous run of 1hours
process some of the parameter that need to be attention is to time.
achieve uniform distribution of the reinforcement material and
obtain sufficient wettability between the two main substances E. Taguchi Method
also reduce porosity in the cast metal matrix composite. A 10kg Standard orthogonal L16 array was used to conduct the
of pure aluminum is melted at 660.3 degree in furnace then 2kg experiments for selection of speed and load range values. The
700gm of pure Zinc is melted at 419.5degree in same furnace number of speed and load range values will get from the
after that 300gm of pure copper is melted at 1085 degree. The researcher work on journal bearing.Taguchi method
process parameter of stir casting should be properly controlled considerably less the total of experiments that are necessary to
to obtain best metallurgical properties of material are stirrer
model the reaction function compare with the full factorial
design, stirrer speed, stirring temperature ,stirring time ,preheat
design of experiments. The main profit of this method is to sort
temperature of reinforcement ,preheated temperature of mould,
out the possible interface between the parameters. The Taguchi
reinforcement feed rate, wettability-promoting agent, Pouring
of melt. procedure is originate for procedure optimization and
identification of optimal associated of the elements for a given
C. Production of Al-based Journal Bearing response. But the design-of-experiments (DOE) is a scientific
approach to effectively design and developed experiments
The Al-25Zn-5Cu metal matrix composite material is prepared
by stir casting technique. Once molding material is prepared using statistics. In such designs, the combination of each
then its material is removed by turning operation to get desired element at every stage is studied to determine the combination
dimension of diameter and height. The exact desired that would yield the finest outcome. DOE is a significant
dimension work piece is fitted on fixture of vertical milling investigation tool for modeling and evaluating the influence of
center (VMC) machine. control elements on performance output. The most important
phase in the DOE lies in the selection of the control factors.
Therefore, a large number of factors are initially included so
that the less significant variables can be identified at the earliest
opportunity.