Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
PART-B
1. Is Management Art or Science? Discuss. (APRIL/MAY 2019)(13 Marks)
The controversy with regard to the nature of management, as to whether it is an art or a
science, is very old. This controversy, however, is not very much in the air now though
the controversy is yet to be settled.
It is to be noted that the learning process in art differs from that of science.
Learning of art involves its continuous practice while learning of science basically
involves the assimilation of principles.
Much of the controversy of management being as art or science is on account of the
fact that the earlier captains of industry and managers have used intuition, hunches,
commonsense, and experience in managing organizations.
They were not trained professional managers, although they were very brilliant and
had developed commonsense through which they managed well. However,
commonsense and science differ considerably in solving the problems.
MANAGEMENT AS AN ART
Art is defined as the use of skills to bring a desired result. Skills refer to one’s proficiency
to do a specific work. Thus, art has the following features:
1. Practical Knowledge
Knowledge refers to possession of facts and techniques of a particular field.
Knowledge can be acquired through study and/or practical experience.
Generally, in art, more emphasis is given on acquiring knowledge through practical
experience. In management, knowledge is acquired both through study and
experience. Thus, management is an art.
2. Personalized Application of Knowledge
In art, there is personalized application of knowledge to achieve the desired results.
This is possible because the same set of results can be achieved through a number
of alternative ways.
Feels Proves
Guesses Predicts
Describes Defines
Opines Measures
Expresses Impresses
It can be seen that management uses both scientific knowledge and art in
managing an organization. As the science of management increases so should the
art of management. A balance between the two is needed. Neither should be over-
weighed or slighted.
Some feel that further gains in science of management will restrict art more and
more. This is true to a limited extent only. The fact remains that to be useful,
knowledge of science must be applied, that is, art must be present. Therefore, the
old saying that ‘knowledge is power‘is partially true.
The correct saying should be ‘applied knowledge is power‘. People having abundant
knowledge may have little use if they do not know how to use knowledge. This is
particularly true for management which is a situational phenomenon.