Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
SELF drunkard.”
• Socrates and Plato: The Soul is Immortal • But reason is a powerful tool, enabling the soul
to free itself from the corrupting imperfection of
• St. Augustine: Plato and Christianity the physical realm and achieve “communion
with the unchanging.”
• Rene Descartes: A Modern Perspective on the
Self • The unexamined life is not worth living
• John Locke: The Self is Consciousness • What is truly remarkable about these ideas is
how closely they parallel modern Western
• David Hume: There is No Self consciousness.
• Immanuel Kant: We Construct the Self • A finite body, an immortal soul, a perfect,
• Sigmund Freud: There are Two Selves, One eternal realm with which the soul seeks
Conscious, One Unconscious communion and eternal bliss: all of the basic
elements of Western (and some Eastern)
• Gilbert Ryle: The Self is How you Behave religions are present.
• Maurice Merleau-Ponty: The Self is Embodied • Even on a secular level, the ideas resonate with
Subjectivity modern concepts of the self: the notion that the
thinking, reasoning self and the physical body
SOCRATES are radically distinct entities that have a
complicated and problematic relationship with
• Know thyself-cornerstone of his philosophy one another.
• First thinker in recorded history to focus the full PLATO: THE SOUL IS IMMORTAL
power of reason on the human self: who we are,
who we should be, and who we will become. • Who is Plato?
• He explored this subject with his friends in the – Along with his mentor, Socrates, and his
days following his trial and before his sentence student, Plato helped to lay the
of death was executed, a time in his life when foundations of Western philosophy and
the question of immortality no doubt had a science
special immediacy and significance.
• Elaborated his concept of the soul (psyche)-
• Reality is dualistic, comprised of two
dichotomous realms: – Reason—our divine essence that
enables us to think deeply, make wise
• changeable, transient, and imperfect (the choices, and achieve a true
physical realm--the physical world) understanding of eternal truths.
• Our bodies belong to the physical realm: they – Spirit or Passion—our basic emotions
change, they’re imperfect, they die. such as love, anger, ambition,
aggressiveness, empathy.
• Our souls, however, belong to the ideal realm:
they are unchanging and immortal, surviving the • These 3 elements are in a dynamic relationship
death of the body. with one another, sometimes working in concert,
sometimes in bitter conflict.
• Although a close relationship exists between our
souls and our bodies, they are radically different • When conflict occurs – it is the responsibility of
entities. Reason to sort things out and exert control.
• Our souls strive for wisdom and perfection, and • Believed that genuine happiness can only be
reason is the soul’s tool to achieve this exalted achieved by people who consistently make sure
state. that their Reason is in control of their Spirits and
Appetites.
• But as long as the soul is tied to the body, this
quest for wisdom is inhibited by the • This harmonious integration under the control of
imperfection of the physical realm, as the soul is Reason is the essence of Plato’s concept of
“dragged by the body into the region of the justice at the individual, social and political
changeable,” where it “wanders and is confused” levels.
ST. AUGUSTINE • It was no longer appropriate to accept without
question the “knowledge” handed down by
• Plato and Christianity authorities.
• More than 500 years after Plato died, a Roman • We need to use our own thinking abilities to
Philosopher named Plotinus spearheaded investigate, analyze, experiment and develop our
Neoplatonism own well-reasoned conclusions, supported by
compelling proof.
• Plotinus: fervently committed to his Platonic
ideas regarding the imperfection of his physical • Doubting things – the only way for you to
body, in contrast to the perfection of his eternal develop beliefs that are truly yours.
soul.
• For if you are not willing to question all that you
• Plotinus’ ideas had a profound influence on St. have been asked to accept “on faith”, then you
Augustine. will never have the opportunity to construct a
rock-solid foundation for your beliefs about the
• St. Augustine integrated the philosophical world and your personal philosophy of life.
concepts of Plato with the tenets of Christianity.
• Cogito, ergo sum – “I think, therefore I am”
• Augustine was convinced that Platonism and
Christianity were natural partners. • The essence of existing as a human identity is
the possibility of being aware of our selves –
Plato integral to having a personal identity.
• Ultimate reality (eternal realm of the Forms) • Conversely, it would be impossible to be self-
• Immortal souls striving to achieve union with conscious if we did not have a personal identity
the eternal realm through intellectual of which to be conscious.
enlightenment • You are a “thinking thing”
St. Augustine • You understand situations in which you
• Transcendent God find yourself.
• Immortal souls striving to achieve union with • You doubt the accuracy of ideas
God through faith and reason presented to you.
• As his thinking matured, Augustine came to • You affirm the truth of a statement made
view the body as the “spouse” of the soul, with about you.
both attached to one another by a “natural • You deny an accusation that someone
appetite”. has made.
• The body is united with the soul so that man • You will yourself to complete a task you
may be entire and complete. Nevertheless, the have begun.
body and soul remain irreconcilably divided, the
body to die, the soul to live eternally in a • You refuse to follow a command that
transcendent realm of Truth and Beauty. you consider to be unethical.
• In melding philosophy and religious beliefs • You imagine a fulfilling career for
together, Augustine has been characterized as yourself.
Christianity’s first theologian (theos – God;
logos – study of) – the study of God. • You feel passionate emotions toward
another person.
RENE DESCARTES
What about your body?
• French philosopher
• Physical body is secondary to your personal
• Founder of Modern Philosophy identity.
• Concerned with understanding the thinking • You can conceive of yourself existing
process we use to answer questions (e.g. what is independently of your body.
the nature of reality?, what is the nature of the
soul?) • Thinking self (soul) – non-material, immortal,
conscious being, independent of the physical
• Descartes wanted to penetrate the nature of our laws of the universe.
reasoning process and understand its relation to
the human self. • Physical body – material, mortal, non-thinking
entity, fully governed by the physical laws of
• Genuine knowledge needed to be based on nature.
independent rational inquiry and real-world
experimentation.
JOHN LOCKE impressions through a variety of
relationships, but because they are
• English philosopher and physician derivative copies of impressions, they
are once removed from reality.
• Descartes (Rationalist) : our reasoning ability
provides the origin of knowledge and final court • They form a fleeting stream of sensations in our
of judgement in evaluating the accuracy and mind, and that nowhere among them is the
value of ideas produced. sensation of a “constant and invariable” self that
exists as a unified identity over the course of our
• Locke (Empiricist): all knowledge originates in lives.
our direct sense experience, which acts as the
final court of judgement in evaluating the • All of our experiences are perceptions and none
accuracy and value of ideas. of these perceptions resemble a unified and
permanent self-identity that exists over time.
• Rationalism : the view that reason is the primary
source of all knowledge. • When we are not experiencing our perceptions
(when we sleep), there is no reason to suppose
• Empiricism : the view that sense experience is that our self exists in any form.
the primary source of all knowledge
• What is the self we experience according to
Locke’s points Hume?
• To discover the nature of personal identity, • A bundle or collection of different
we’re going to have to find out what it means to perceptions, which succeed each other
be a person. with an inconceivable rapidity and are in
• A person is a thinking, intelligent being who has a perpetual flux and movement.
the abilities to reason and to reflect. • What we call the self is an imaginary creature,
• A person is also someone who considers himself derived from a succession of impermanent states
to be the same thing in different times and and events.
different places. IMMANUEL KANT
• Consciousness – being aware that we are • German philosopher
thinking – always accompanies thinking and is
an essential part of the thinking process. • Our primary experience of the world is not in
terms of a disconnected stream of sensations.
• Consciousness is what makes possible our belief
that we are the same identity in different times • We perceive and experience an organized world
and different places. of objects, relationships and ideas, all existing
within a fairly stable framework of space and
• Self-consciousness is a necessary part of having time.
a coherent self-identity.
• Our minds actively sort, organize, relate and
• Consciousness accompanies thinking and makes synthesize the fragmented, fluctuating collection
possible the concept we have of a self that of sense data that our sense organs take in.
remains the same at different times and in
different places. • It’s our self that makes experiencing an
intelligible world possible, because it’s the self
David Hume that is responsible for synthesizing the discreet
• Scottish philosopher data of sense experience into a meaningful
whole.
• Empiricist
• You are at the center of your world, and you
• If we carefully examine our sense experience view everything in the world from your
through the process of introspection, we perspective.
discover that there is no self.
• The self is not a content of consciousness but
• 2 DISTINCT ENTITIES: rather the invisible “thread” that ties the contents
of consciousness together.
• Impressions: the basic sensations of our
experience, the elemental data of our SIGMUND FREUD
minds: pain, pleasure, heat, cold,
happiness, grief, fear, exhilaration, and • Psychologist
so on. These impressions are “lively” • Founder of the school of psychoanalysis
and “vivid”.
• The self is multilayered.
• Ideas: copies of impressions and as a
result they are less “lively” and “vivid”. – Conscious
Ideas include thoughts and images that
are built up from our primary – Preconscious
– Unconscious • Our physical bodies are just the opposite of our
minds.
• Consciousness : mental processes of which we
are aware. • Their movements are available to
everyone
• Unconsciousness: mental processes which are
not easily accessible to our awareness. • Can be observed, photographed,
measured, analyzed, & movements can
• Preconscious: Everything unconscious that can be recorded.
easily exchange the unconscious condition for
the conscious one (capable of entering • Minds: completely private
consciousness).
• Bodies: completely public
Unconscious Self
• Ryle believes that the mind is a concept that
• Basic instinctual drives: sexuality, expresses the entire system of thoughts,
aggressiveness and self-destruction; traumatic emotions, actions and so on that make up the
memories; unfulfilled wishes and childhood human self.
fantasies; thoughts and feelings that would be
considered socially taboo. • The self is best understood as a pattern of
behavior, the tendency or disposition for a
• Governed by “pleasure principle” person to behave in a certain way in certain
circumstances
• Can be found in the content of our dreams,
inadvertent “slips of the tongue”, neurotic • How you behave is “who” you are.
symptoms.
PAUL CHURCHLAND
Conscious Self
• American philosopher
• Governed by “reality principle”
• Materialism: the self is inseparable from the
• Behavior and experience are organized in ways substance of the brain and the physiology of the
that are rational, practical and appropriate to the body.
social environment.
• Since history, humans have known of the close,
• Takes into account the realistic demands of the intimate relationship between the mind and the
situation, the consequences of various actions body.
and the overriding need to preserve the
equilibrium of the entire psychodynamic system. – Dimensions of the physical self – affects
mental & emotional functioning
• The conscious self has the task of controlling the
constant pressures of the unconscious self, as its – Dimensions of mental self – affects
primitive impulses continually seek for physical condition
immediate discharge.
• Modern science is now able to use advanced
Why does the unconscious self remain inaccessible to equipment and sophisticated techniques to
conscious awareness? unravel and articulate the complex web of
connections that binds consciousness and body
• Repression : used to help contain the potentially together into an integrated self.
disruptive aspects of unconscious functioning,
and as a consequence it is usually the main – To fully understand the nature of the
defense mechanism for maintaining the ego mind, we have to fully understand the
boundaries necessary for normal conscious nature of the brain.
functioning.
• The ultimate goal of exploring the
• The purpose of psychotherapy is to enable the neurophysiology of the brain is to link the self
patient to acknowledge the conflicts, emotions (thoughts, passions, personality traits) to the
and memories at the root cause of his or her physical wiring and physiological functioning of
disorder. the brain.
• Although each person has direct knowledge of – This unity is our primary experience of
his or her mind, it is impossible for us to have our selves, and we only begin to doubt it
any direct knowledge of other minds. when we use our minds to concoct
abstract notions of a separate “mind” Being that culture is diverse, self and identity
and “body”. may have different meanings in different
cultures.
• Our “living body” is a natural synthesis of mind
and biology and any attempts to divide them into ETHNIC IDENTITY
separate entities are artificial and nonsensical.
> sameness of the self with others, that is, to a
• It’s the moments of direct, primal experience consciousness of sharing certain characteristics
that are the most real (Lebenswelt or “lived (e.g., language, culture, etc.) within a group.
world”) which is the fundamental ground of our
being and consciousness. > This identity makes a human being a person
and an acting individual.
• Phenomenology : all knowledge of our selves
and our world is based on the “phenomena” of > Peacock believes that the individual is neither
our experience. a robot nor an entirely independent self-willed
little god but is a cultural individual– existing in
• When we examine our selves at this fundamental freedom but also embodying that cultural mold
level of direct human experience, we discover in which he/she is cast in his/her particular
that our mind and body are unified, not separate. society and historical epoch.
SOCIOCENTRIC VIEW
this emphasizes that it is an academic field
for understanding the interconnections and o the self is viewed as contingent on a situation or
interdependence of biological and cultural social setting.
aspects of the human experience in all times
and places. o view of the self that is context dependent.; there
is no intrinsic self that can possess enduring
“NATURE” – refers to genetic inheritance qualities.
which sets the individual’s potential
o focuses on one’s own social group; socially
“NURTURE” – refers to sociocultural oriented.
environment
o For anthropologist Christie Kiefer, THE
Anthropology considers human experience JAPANESE POSSESS A SOCIOCENTRIC
as an interplay of “nature” and “nurture”. VIEW OF THE SELF.
INTERDEPENDENCE BETWEEN THE
In other words, both biological and cultural PERSON AND THE GROUP IS MORE
factors have significant influence in the VALUED THAN INDEPENDENCE.
development of self-awareness among
individuals within the society. o Chinese American anthropologist Francis Hsu
attributes A SOCIOCENTRIC VIEW OF THE
The cultural construction of self and identity SELF TO THE CHINESE. CHINESE
PRIORITIZE KIN TIES AND
CULTURE – “… complex whole which
COOPERATION.
includes knowledge, belief, art, morals, law,
custom, and any other capabilities and habits o AMERICANS TEND TO BE EGOCENTRIC.
acquired by man as a member of society.” THEY BELIEVE THAT THEY SHOULD BE
(Edward Tylor) ASSERTIVE AND INDEPENDENT.
Anthropologists have emphasized that culture is o IDENTITY TOOLBOX- refers to the “features
not behavior itself but the shared understandings of a person’s identity that he or she chooses to
that guide behavior and are expressed in emphasize in constructing a social self.”
behavior.
PERSONAL NAMING
Culture provides patterns of “ways of life”
-- a universal practice with numerous cross- • Humans are considered as cultural animals as
cultural variations establishes a child’s birthright they create the meanings of objects, persons,
and social identity. behaviors, emotions, and events, and then
behave in accordance to those meanings they
-- a NAME is an important device to assumed as true.
individualize a person and at the same time
becomes legitimate member of the group. GEERTZ’S TWO (2) IMPORTANT IDEAS IN HIS
ATTEMPT TO ILLUSTRATE AN ACCURATE
-- Personal names in all societies are intimate IMAGE OF MAN:
markers of the person, differentiating individuals
from others. 1. “Culture should not be perceived only as
“complexes of concrete behavior patterns-
-- There is no self if the individual is without customs, usages, traditions, habit clusters- as
name. has, by and large, been the case up to now, but
as a set of control mechanisms- plans, recipes,
ONE’S IDENTITY IS NOT INBORN rules, instructions- for governing behavior and,
It is something people continuously acquire in 2. man is precisely the animal most desperately
life. dependent upon such extragenetic, outside-the-
ARNOLD VAN GENNEP’S THREE-PHASED skin control mechanisms, such cultural
RITE OF PASSAGE: programs, for ordering his behavior.”
1. Separation – people detach from their former identity SOCIOLOGICAL PERSPECTIVE: THE SELF AS
to another. A PRODUCT OF SOCIETY
2. Liminal – one has left one identity but has not yet “WHO YOU ARE” AND “WHAT YOU ARE”
entered or joined the next. Sociological Perspective of the self is based on
3. Incorporation – the changes are incorporated into a the assumption that human behavior is
new identity to elaborate rituals and ceremonies like influenced by group life.
church weddings, debutant balls, and college A particular view of oneself is formed through
graduations. interactions with other people, groups, or social
-- Individuals acquire their identities through institutions.
rites of passage or initiation ceremonies. For Cooley and Mead, the self is NOT
-- Initiation rituals make a person readily accept dependent on biological predispositions; rather,
new wars of looking at him/herself and others. it is a PRODUCT OF SOCIAL
INTERACTION.
IDENTITY STRUGGLES > Anthony Wallace and
Raymond Fogelson For French sociologist Baudrillard, in the
postmodern society, the self is found in the
> “characterized interaction in which there is a prestige symbols of goods consumed by man.
discrepancy between the identity a person claims
to possess and the identity attributed to that SOCIOLOGY
person by others.” -- a scientific study of social groups and human
Golubovic suggests that in order to attain self- relationships, generates new insights to the
identification, individuals have to overcome interconnectedness between the self and other
many obstacles such as traditionally established people.
habits and parental imposed self-image. -- Sociologists offer theories to explain how the
On the other hand, cognitive anthropologists self emerges as a product of social experience.
suggest that in order to maintain a relatively
stable and coherent self, the members of the o Looking-Glass Self by Charles
multicultural society have no choice but to Horton Cooley
internalize divergent cultural models and should
reject or suppress identifications that may o The Theory of Social Self by George
conflict with other self-presentations. Herbert Mead
Katherine Ewing’s ‘Illusion of Wholeness”
WORK ON YOURSELF THE LOOKING-GLASS SELF (Charles Horton
Cooley)
THE SELF AS EMBEDDED IN CULTURE
believed that the people whom a person interacts
CULTURE become a mirror in which he views himself.
3. How he/she creates an image of his/herself • The postmodern individuals achieve self-
identity through prestige symbols that they
THEORY OF THE SOCIAL SELF (GEORGE consume.
HERBERT MEAD)
• The cultural practices of advertising and mass
Theory of Social Self: based on the perspective media greatly influence individuals to consume
that the self emerges from social interaction. goods not or their primary value and utility but
to give them a feeling of goodness and power
Mead argues that the self is not there from birth when compared with others.
but develops over time through social activities
and interactions. Therefore, the self may be a never ending search
for prestige in the postmodern society.
o He explained that the self has 2 divisions:
PSYCHOLOGICAL PERSPECTIVE OF THE SELF
The “I”
The development of self-understanding in
> The subjective element and the active side of the adolescence involves numbers about the self,
self. identity, and personality.
It represents the spontaneous, and unique traits Theories provide the individual with a sense of
of the individual. identity and a source of orientation to the world.
If society tells me to act in a certain way, I can According to Carl Roger’s theory of the self, an
either act the same or maybe I will do something important aspect of understanding the self is
different. self-awareness.
The “me” WILLIAM JAMES’ CONCEPT OF THE SELF
> The objective element of the self. 2 Categories of the Self
It represents the internalized attitudes and ● The “I-Self”
demands of other people and the individual’s
awareness of those demands. - Refers to the self that knows who he or she is.
developed through knowledge of society and - The thinking self
social interactions.
- Reflects the soul of a person or what is now
The full development of the self is attained thought of as a mind and is called the PURE
when the “I” and the “me” are united. EGO.
Since there is meaning in human actions, he The “Me-Self”
infers people’s intention or direction of action,
which may lead him to understand the world - The empirical self
from others’ point of view – a process that Mead
labelled as ROLE-TAKING. - Refers to describing the person’s personal
experiences
No matter how much the world shapes him, he
will always remain a creative being, and be 1. MATERIAL SELF
able to react to the world around him.
- Consists of things that belong to a person such as
THE SELF AS A PRODUCT OF MODERN AND the body, family, clothes, money, house etc. that
POSTMODERN SOCIETIES contributes to one’s self-image.
Humans have the ability to act and make things SIGMUND FREUD’S CONSTRUCTION OF SELF
happen. AND PERSONALITY
• Anal Expulsive: Disorderly, messy, ● As children learn to do things well, they develop
destructive, or cruel a sense of industry. Especially when children
are encouraged in their efforts. But if children
• Erogenous zone: anus receive little or no encouragement from parents
or teachers, they acquire a sense of inferiority.
Phallic Stage: Ages 3-6. Child now notices and is
physically attracted to opposite sex parent. Can lead to: 5. IDENTITY VERSUS IDENTITY
CONFUSION
● Oedipus Conflict: For boys only. Boy feels
rivalry with his father for his mother’s affection. ● Adolescence ( 12 - 18 years )
Boy may feel threatened by father (castration
anxiety). To resolve, boy must identify with his ● Adolescence is an adaptive phase of personality
father (i.e., become more like him and adopt his development, a period of trial and error.
heterosexual beliefs).
● They are confronted with many roles and
● Electra Conflict: Girl loves her father and responsibilities
competes with her mother. Girl identifies with
her mother more slowly because she already 6. INTIMACY VERSUS ISOLATION
feels castrated. ● Early Adulthood ( 18 - 40 years )
Erogenous zone: phallus/genital organ ● Erikson believed that it is vital for people to
● Latency: Ages 6-Puberty. Psychosexual develop intimate relationship with others.
development is dormant. Same sex friendships ● Those who are successful at this stage will form
and play occur here. relationships that are stable and successful. If
● Genital Stage: Puberty-on. Realization of full not, mistrust and isolation may develop.
adult sexuality occurs here; sexual urges re- 7. GENERATIVITY VERSUS STAGNATION
awaken.
● Adulthood ( 40 - 65 years )
THE ROLE OF ERIK ERIKSON’S THEORY IN
UNDERSTANDING THE SELF ● The time when people begin to take their place
in society and assume responsibility for
To achieve INDIVIDUAL IDENTITY, one whatever society produces.
must create a vision of the self that is authentic,
that is, a sense of having hold of one’s destiny in ● Those who fail to attain generativity will feel
an effort to reach goals that are personally worthless.
meaningful.
1. TRUST VERSUS MISTRUST 8. INTEGRITY VERSUS DESPAIR