Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
135]
Review Article
Abstract
In today’s world, it is very necessary to understand the importance of being eco‑friendly in every facet of our lives. The color “green” has
healing power and denotes renewal, growth, and hope. “Eco‑friendly dentistry” attempts to reduce the detrimental impact of dental practices
on the environment and promote environmental awareness and sustainability to patients. This paper attempts to cover all possible aspects of
making a dental practice eco‑friendly, both in a dental perspective as well as a general perspective. While establishing an eco‑friendly dental
workplace, the dentist needs to assess his choices in planning the infrastructure and purchasing of equipment and dental materials. Eco‑friendly
dentistry is a newly evolving practice of dentistry, which encompasses a simultaneous devotion to sustainability, prevention, precaution,
and a minimally invasive patient‑centric, as well as global‑centric treatment. There are two main avenues for implementing eco‑friendly
dentistry: (1) appropriate policy development and implementation and (2) dentists taking responsibility/ownership in the absence of policies
and regulations. Although in some cases, it may take a little extra effort or money; dentists throughout the world are doing their best to reduce
the environmental impact of the dental practice. Although the commitment of one small dental office cannot save the planet, certainly, the
collective efforts of many small offices as well as large dental hospitals/colleges can ensure that dentists, at least, will not be responsible for
destroying it. This article discusses various factors that can be incorporated into dental practice that can help make dentistry eco‑friendly.
22 © 2017 Journal of Dental and Allied Sciences | Published by Wolters Kluwer - Medknow
[Downloaded free from http://www.jdas.in on Tuesday, May 2, 2017, IP: 41.85.161.135]
health including control of environmental pollution by the • Lead‑containing wastes‑lead aprons and lead foils in the
way of X‑ray films
• Adopting clean technology • Mercury‑containing wastes‑element mercury, scrap
• Recycling and reuse of waste material amalgam
• Installation of pollution control equipment • Chemicals‑disinfectants and sterilizing agents.
• Better housekeeping and work practices including of waste
minimization techniques.
Waste Management
The term biomedical waste has been defined as “any
Why Green Dentistry? waste that is generated during the diagnosis, treatment, or
The color “green” denotes renewal, growth, and hope. Green immunization of human beings or animals, or in the research
dentistry is not only environment‑friendly but also conserves activities pertaining to or in the production or testing of
money and time by reducing waste, conserving energy biological and includes categories mentioned in Schedule I
and decreasing pollution with the use of latest techniques of the Biomedical Waste (Management and Handling) rules
and procedures. Green dentistry, therefore, protects the 1998.” These rules make it mandatory for the health care
environment and humanity from the hazards of rapid establishments to segregate, disinfect, and dispose of their
urbanization, especially in the developing countries.[5] waste in an eco‑friendly manner. There may be increased
risk of nosocomial infections in patients due to poor waste
The Four r’s of Being Eco‑Friendly management. The best disposal options are to prevent or
minimize disposal of toxic substances from dental clinics into
The four R’s include reduce, reuse, recycle, and rethink. It is
the environment.[4]
common to think that “recycle” is the best eco‑friendly way.
However, “rethink” is the first step to being eco‑friendly and The World Bank’s health‑care waste management guidance,
“reduce” and “reuse” are more effective than “recycle.”[2] note lists four steps to health‑care waste management:[4]
• To “reduce” is to minimize the amount of waste sent to 1. Segregation
landfills. One can reduce waste production by reusing and 2. Transportation
recycling maximum amount of materials. Packages constitute 3. Treatment
30% of the garbage. Thus, purchase of products with minimal 4. Final disposal.
packaging and use of plastic containers can help
• To “reuse,” single use items should be replaced by reusable All the generators of biomedical waste should adopt universal
items precautions and appropriate safety measures while doing
• To “recycle,” paper, metal, and gypsum can be recycled. therapeutic and diagnostic activities. The plastic bags which
Identification of existing recycling programs is necessary are used for waste disposal are special nonchlorinated bags
• Most importantly, rethinking at every step is the key to which are incinerable and are color coded according to the
an eco‑friendly practice. Before buying any material for waste to be disposed in them [Table 1].
your clinic, think of environmentally better options. While
The chemical hazards in dental sector include:
using any material during a procedure, use the material
• Dental amalgam
judicially and dispose it off following proper protocols or
• X‑ray cleaner
prefer recycling.
• Lead foil and shields
• Cements containing zinc phosphate
Categories of Dental Waste • Acids and caustics
• Fluorescent and mercury vapor light bulbs
The four possible waste sources in dental offices include
• X‑ray fixer and developer solutions
(a) mercury‑containing dental material (b) X‑ray developer
• Batteries.
and fixer solutions, lead foil of X‑ray film, (c) infection control
barriers including disinfectants and disposable barriers, and
Teeth without amalgam restorations and other tissues can be
(d) conventional vacuum saliva ejector systems.[5]
placed directly into a biohazard bag or a sharps container,
Thus, various dental wastes can be divided into these which can then be sterilized. Teeth with amalgams could
categories: release mercury vapor during sterilization, thus, they should
• Biomedical waste be neutralized through disinfection ideally, immersion for
• Nonanatomic waste such as gloves, and dental 30 min in a fresh solution of a tuberculocidal disinfectant
materials held within a sealed container. Items heavily soiled with
• Anatomic wastes including extracted teeth blood/saliva can be placed into sharps containers. However,
• Sharps it may be easier to store them in small biohazard bags
• Silver‑containing waste including used fixer solution and until treated. Used anesthetic capsules should be placed
unused X‑ray films into sharps containers. Impression compound, agar, dental
Legislations and Regulations for Hazardous (90% more efficient), reduced maintenance costs and
higher safety. A LED bulb lasts 2–4 times longer than
Waste a CFL, is more energy efficient due to minimal wasted
Hazardous Waste (Management and Handling) Rules, 1989, energy, has a smaller size, greater durability, and reliability
were notified in India under the Environment Protection Act, • Save energy: Set a main switch for the whole dental
1986 for management and handling of hazardous wastes in office so that all electrical switches can be turned off after
the country. These rules were further amended in 2000 and working hours with a single switch
2003 to bring these in line with the Basel Convention and to • Use tinted glasses for windows to avoid heating up of the
improve and update them according to the practical needs. office[3,5]
Apart from MoEFs, Central Pollution Control Board, State • Utilizing the authoritative benchmarks set forth by the
Pollution Control Boards/Pollution Control Committees have Green Guide for Health Care and the EDA. Offsetting
been delegated powers for control and regulation of hazardous carbon dioxide with certified carbon offsets and
wastes. The MoEFs is the nodal agency for environmental investment into reforestation campaigns. Formulating a
matters in India. It also exercises control over imports of green team with designated responsibilities and goals.[9]
hazardous wastes under the Hazardous Waste Management
and Handling Rules.
The Basel Convention deals with the trans‑boundary transport
Switch to Reusables Over Disposables
and hazardous waste disposal as well as other chemical wastes • Use gowns made of cloth instead of disposable gowns
by regulating and keeping in check of transport of hazardous • Use cloth patient bibs instead of plastic ones
wastes. India ratified this convention in 1992, showing its • Use stainless steel glasses instead of plastic glasses
commitment to solve the problem of transboundary export • Use glass syringes for irrigation instead of plastic ones
and import as well as dumping of hazardous wastes through • Use autoclaving cassettes and cloth pouches instead of
international cooperation. The Hon’ble Supreme Court of sterilization pouches made of paper on one side and
India has been playing a very important role for proper polythene on the other
environmental safeguarding in India. • Use autoclavable stainless steel suction tips instead of
disposable plastic ones
After the Bhopal Gas Tragedy, in 1984, USA enacted the • Use reusable stainless steel prophy cups instead of
“Emergency Planning and Community Right to Know Act” disposable ones
1986, which is considered a pioneering legislation. As in USA, • Use autoclavable stainless steel impression trays instead
in India also Toxic Release Inventory should be made available of plastic disposable ones
to the common people by way of printed reports, computer • Use instrument sharpening stones instead of disposing
discs, and telephone support and services.[8] dull instruments.[9]
Dental impressions soluble nitrates of silver and copper are produced. If pure
Sectional trays and dual arch impression trays are to copper or any other metal having lower electrode potential is
minimize wastage of impression material. Nowadays, added to this silver nitrate solution, silver gets displaced and
trays made of biodegradable material are also available. is easily recovered.[10]
Digital optical impressions eliminate the need to make
Dental instruments
impressions with the conventional method. Conventional
Since many years, Hu‑Friedy has been running a program
dental impressions do not provide adequate detail reproduction
called “environ‑dent” in which dentists can recycle old hand
and might require remaking at times, leading to wastage
instruments and receive free new instruments. Instruments
of material. Digital impressions significantly increase
should be sharpened regularly, thus, reducing the need for
accuracy and productivity, and the impression can be sent
discarding old instruments.[10]
through e‑mail to the dental laboratories. Combined with
computer‑aided design/computer‑aided manufacturing, Gypsum:
digital impressions/models are helpful to minimize wastage It is a universally accepted fact now that gypsum when
of material and provide high accuracy.[3] discarded in landfills, the reduction of its sulfate cause
production of hydrogen sulfide, having a characteristic rotten
Recycling of Dental Materials egg smell. The respiratory tract and nervous system are
the most sensitive targets of hydrogen sulfide toxicity. Few
Dental waxes symptoms include irritation to the eyes, nose, or throat. It
Waxes are widely used in dentistry in so many forms such
may also cause difficulty in breathing for some asthmatics.
as modeling wax, inlay wax, utility wax, casting wax,
Headaches, poor memory, tiredness, and balance problems may
beading and boxing wax, baseplate wax, sticky wax, and
also occur. Permanent or long‑term effects include headaches,
bite registration wax. Some of the waxes are naturally
poor attention span, poor memory, and poor motor function. In
obtained (carnauba, Candela, and beeswax) and some are
the UK, gypsum to gypsum recycling projects has been started
petroleum products (ceresin and paraffin wax). In most of the
which include demolition waste and other gypsum products.
procedures, Maximum amount of wax is not consumed, but
It is claimed that the recycled gypsum powder is 99% as good
used and rejected. About 80%–90% of wax can be recycled
as virgin gypsum.[11]
without affecting their properties using a simple laboratory
procedure of removing the impurities. As this is an in vitro
procedure, no biocompatibility issues exist.[10] Conclusion
An eco‑friendly dentist need not be an environmentalist, just
Casting alloys
a rethinker. It is a matter of choice for the dentist to choose
In dentistry, alloys are used in fabrication of metal copings,
eco‑friendly products and practices and save as much paper,
crowns, and bridges, cast partial denture frameworks, metal
water, material, and energy as possible. Dentistry is such a
denture bases and implant‑supported frameworks and
noble profession that our efforts should always aim toward
crowns. 50%–60% of the alloy remains as wastage in the
the betterment of the society and not harm it. In developing
form of buttons and sprues in this process. The remaining
countries like India, it is important that we realize the
wasted materials can be effectively reused for fabricating
importance of being environment‑friendly and understand that
new restorations or appliances by proper cleaning techniques
the efforts of each individual count. More research and funds
(sand blasting, electropolishing). There is only 5%–10%
are required to regulate and promote eco‑friendly practices.
decrease in their mechanical properties even after 20th recast.
Dental practitioners should be trained in Workplace Hazardous
However, the only concern is biocompatibility. Thus, these
Materials Information System.[7]
materials can be redirected to other engineering areas for the
fabrication of cutting tools, oil well drilling bits, dredging Financial support and sponsorship
cutters, hot trimming dies, internal combustion engine valves, Nil.
gas turbine vanes, buckets, etc., These alloys are termed as
super alloys in engineering fields due to their high strength Conflicts of interest
and high corrosion resistance.[10] There are no conflicts of interest.
Silver amalgam
From the amalgam scrap, it is possible to separate mercury
References
1. Chadha GM, Panchmal GS, Shenoy RP, Siddique S, Jodalli P.
and silver by laboratory procedures, and thus, they can be Establishing an eco‑friendly dental practice: A review. IJSS Case Rep
redirected for use. Almost 100% of silver amalgam is discarded Rev 2015;1:78‑81.
in dental teaching institutes, and 25% is discarded in dental 2. Avinash B, Avinash BS, Shivalinga BM, Jyothikiran S, Padmini MN.
clinics. Mercury can be recovered by heating the waste Going green with eco‑friendly dentistry. J Contemp Dent Pract
2013;14:766‑9.
amalgam at temperature higher than 4500°C. Eventually, the 3. Dixit K, Dixit KK, Kapoor N. Eco‑friendly dentistry: A reality. J Dent
evaporated mercury condenses and comes out of the mix. The Sci Oral Rehabil 2013;1:5‑6.
remaining mix is dissolved in concentrated HNO3, after which 4. Thota MM, Bathala LR, Theruru K, Shaik S, Jupidi B, Rayapati S.
“There’s plenty of room at the bottom”: The biomedical waste 8. Dutta SK, Upadhyay VP, Sridharan U. Environmental management of
management in dentistry. J NTR Univ Health Sci 2014;3:149‑55. industrial hazardous wastes in India. J Environ Sci Eng 2006;48:143‑50.
5. Rastogi V, Sharma R, Yadav L, Satpute P, Sharma V. Green 9. Passi S, Bhala S. Go green dentistry. J Educ Ethics Dent 2012;2:10‑2.
dentistry, a metamorphosis towards an eco‑friendly dentistry: A short 10. Thopegowda NB, Shenoy K, Shankarnarayana RK, Kukkila J,
communication. J Clin Diagn Res 2014;8:ZM01‑2. Vaddya SB, Gingipalli K. Recycling of Materials used in dentistry with
6. Hiltz M. The environmental impact of dentistry. J Can Dent Assoc reference to its economical and environmental aspects. Int J Health
2007;73:59‑62. Rehabil Sci 2013;2:140‑5.
7. Singh H, Bhaskar DJ, Dalai DR, Rehman R, Khan M. Dental biomedical 11. Fairweather RJ, Barlaz MA. Hydrogen sulfide production during
waste management. Int J Sci Stud 2014;2:66‑8. decomposition of landfill inputs. J Environ Eng 1998;124:353‑61.