Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
Amber Parker
Comparing and Contrasting Between the Textbook Material and my Field Experience
I was surprised at how much the content from the textbook differs from the special
education classroom in reality. This semester I was assigned to read the textbook Special
Education in Contemporary Society: Sixth Edition by Richard M. Gargiulo and Emily C Bouk.
Throughout the course of reading this textbook, as well as from my peers, I was able to learn
about many different disorders, disabilities, and behavior issues that are often seen in the special
education classroom. Not only was I able to learn about different disorders and disabilities, but I
was also able to increase my knowledge about the field of special education. Regardless of how
much I learned from the textbook, I was unable to compare most of what I learned from the
There is a vast amount of information about different disorders and aspects of special
education that can be found within the textbook. There were not a lot of subjects from the
textbook that I was able to use during my observation. The class to which I was assigned to only
consisted of eight students in it, half of which participate in resource for the majority of the day.
As a result, there were usually no more than four students in the room at one time. The students
that stayed in the classroom did not show any signs of apparent behavior issues, and for the most
part, respected their teachers and fellow classmates. Thus, it was quite difficult for me to
compare the textbook material to the reality of my observation. However, I was able to observe
two students who had down syndrome and one who was an English learner, which related to the
extended period of time. A student who is classified as an English learner means that English is
SPED OBSERVATION 3
the student’s second language. Jessica primarily speaks Spanish and struggles to understand
English when reading or writing with the language. She is, however, able to speak English quite
fluently and successfully communicate with those around her. On page 86 of the textbook, the
term English learners (Els) is defined as, “students whose primary language is not English and
who have yet to achieve proficiency in English.” With Jessica being comfortable and fluent when
speaking English, I suspect that she has had a few years to learn and practice the language prior
Page 86 of the textbook reports that because an English learner’s primary language is not
English, “they are unable to profit fully from instruction provided in English.” I think that this
statement is partially untrue in Jessica’s case. During the ten hours that I observed the class, I
noticed that Jessica had little to no problems understanding the oral instructions that she was
given. When given instructions, Jessica is able to comprehend what she is being told and carry
out the instructions almost to the letter. On the other hand, however, Jessica does struggle with
comprehending and following written instructions that are in English. Based on what I observed
and comparing it to the textbook, Jessica is able to fully benefit from English instruction if given
orally but not when the instruction is written down. For example, on March 7, 2019, Ms. Taylor
played word bingo with Jessica by telling her a word and tasking her with finding that word on
the bingo board. Jessica was able to understand the word she was being told and repeat it back to
Ms. Taylor, but she was unable to correctly match the word she heard to its proper spelling on the
bingo board.
While Jessica had a hard time matching a spoken word to its correct spelling, she does
know the words she was being told and is able to understand Ms. Taylor when she talks to her.
Jessica is a wonderful student and I had a fun time observing her because it gave me insight to
SPED OBSERVATION 4
what it is like teaching an English learner. Jessica has a lot of potential and I believe that with
more help, practice, and more one-on-one time with her teachers, that she will be able to more
fully learn English and be successful in her education as she grows up.
During my last two hours of observation on March 15, 2019, I took the time to carefully
observe both Addie and Jose, both of which have Down syndrome, for an extended period of
time. The textbook defines Down syndrome on page 174 as “a chromosomal abnormality
was immediately able to determine that both Addie and Jose had Down syndrome because of
their facial features. Both Addie and Jose had a short stature, their faces appeared more flat than
normal, and short fingers, all of which are common physical characteristics of individuals with
Down syndrome.
On page 176 of the textbook it states, “Down syndrome most often results in mild to
moderate intellectual disability. In some instances, however, individuals may have a severe
intellectual disability, and in other situations, near normal intelligences is possible.” As far as
intellectual disabilities go, Addie seems to have a near normal intelligence and is much more
functional than Jose. Jose has a more severe intellectual disability and struggles to effectively
interact with his peers. During my observation, I noticed that Addie knows a good amount of
words, and for the most part, can effectively converse her feelings, wants, and needs. Jose, on the
other hand, seemed to only know enough words needed to communicate basic responses. While
observing Jose, I noticed that he has a hard time learning and retaining new information. Ms.
Taylor has to repeat herself multiple times when giving instructions to Addie and Jose before
either of them are able to understand what is being said. Despite both having to be told what to
SPED OBSERVATION 5
do multiple times, Addie is able to grasp the concept she is being told much quicker than Jose
can.
What I Learned
Through observing, I learned that special education is a whole other reality compared to what I
had imagined. Before beginning my observation, I was under the impression that the special
education classroom would have a ton of students with behavior issues, or kids throwing
tantrums when they don’t get their way. While this may be true for many special education
classes, it was not at all true for the class that I was assigned. The students that I observed were
always respectful to each other and there were no serious tantrums or behavior issues present.
I was surprised by the fact that the class was so well behaved and so I talked to Ms.
Taylor about what her classes were like in previous years. Ms. Taylor has been teaching special
education for five years and was a special education teacher’s aid for two years before she
became a teacher. When I asked her about groups she taught in previous years, she told me that
no two groups of students are the same and every year is different. Last year she had a student
who would yell, scream, and rebel against everyone and everything. Ms. Taylor told me that this
student did not like changes, and as a result, had a hard time adjusting to his new aid. Ms. Taylor
teaches kindergarten through second grade and she told me that by the time the student was in
second grade, he had adjusted to his new aid and became both respectful and comfortable to
those around him. This story taught me that every child is different and comes with their own
issues, and that we as teachers have to persevere through these situations the best we can until we
education teacher. It only took five hours of observation for that intention to change. Before
observing, I thought that teaching special education would be way too difficult for me to teach
and quite miserable. After observing I now know that special education is a very important
profession. Being inside the classroom and seeing what special education was about changed my
views of the profession. Special educators are responsible for making sure those with disabilities
have an equal opportunity to learn as those who are not disabled. I have a deeper understanding
and greater appreciation for the profession. Special education teachers volunteer to teach gifted
and talented children who would, more likely than not, be quickly turned away from general
career.
There are a few key reasons that influenced my decision to not only to become a teacher,
but to go the extra mile and become a special education teacher. A main factor for my decision, is
the size of the class. According to Ms. Taylor, there are typically only a maximum of sixteen
students in a single special education class, and most of the time the class size doesn’t reach
above eleven students. The class size is reduced even more since a lot of the students will most
likely have resource for the majority of the day. I think having a smaller class size would be
beneficial for me because I think that it will be easier for me to get to know my students better,
and if I know my students, I will be able to better help them succeed. Another reason I want to
major in special education is because there is typically at least one teacher aid in the classroom
ready to help when needed. Having another adult in the classroom would be helpful when there
are behavior problems that occur. A teacher’s aid would also be handy during group work. As the
SPED OBSERVATION 7
teacher, I would be able to wok with a small group of students one-on-one while the rest of the
class works on their assignments. If the students get distracted and stop working, or if they are
being loud, the teacher’s aid can help calm them down and get them back on task. The last thing
that helped me decide to be a special education teacher, is the fact that I can relate to the
student’s hardships and disabilities on a personal level. I have a lot of cousins in my extended
family and there are some with different disorders and disabilities. I can draw upon what I have
learned from these particular cousins, as well as what I have seen them go through, to relate to
my students. I can also rely on my own hardships and learning disabilities to understand the
References
Bouck, Emily C., Gargiulo, Richard M. (2017). Special Education in Contemporary Society: an
Publications.