Crippling load, P

E
I

From Staad, Max lateral load

Moment of Inertia Calculation for Hollow Tube

Outer Dia 114 mm
Outer radius 57 mm
Thickness 4.5 mm
Inner radius 52.5 mm
Moment of Inertia 2324061 mm^4

Crippling Load (KN)

As per Sheet Calculation 20.39
As per Table 1 of code 2713 2.22

Why there is difference in Crippling Load ?

Circular Pipe 114 (Stepped Pole Designation 540 TP26 )

π2 EI / L2

With Imax With Imin

200000 N/mm2 E 200000 N/mm2
232.406 cm4 I 460 cm4
2324060 mm4 4600000 mm4
7.5 m (Cantilever L = 2L) L 9.8 m
7500 mm 9800 mm
2.04E+04 N 2.36E+04 N
20.3889358261 kN 23.63607884 kN

5 kN
 HB150

Crippling load, P π2 EI / L2

With Imax
E 200000 N/mm2 E
I 1540 cm4 I
15400000 mm4
L 9.8 m (Cantilever L = 2L) L
9800 mm
P 7.91E+04 N
79.12948 kN

From Staad, Max lateral load 5 kN

HB200

Crippling load, P π2 EI / L2

With Imax
E 200000 N/mm2 E
I 3600 cm 4
I
36000000 mm 4

L 9.8 m (Cantilever L = 2L) L

9800 mm
P 1.85E+05 N
184.978 kN

From Staad, Max lateral load 7.625 kN

With Imin
200000 N/mm2
460 cm4
4600000 mm4
9.8 m
9800 mm
2.36E+04 N
23.63608 kN

With Imin
200000 N/mm2
967 cm4
9670000 mm4
9.8 m
9800 mm
4.97E+04 N
49.68715 kN