net/publication/320894280
Design and Analysis of Ultrasonic Welding Horn using Finite Element Analysis
CITATION READS
1 2,490
3 authors, including:
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
All content following this page was uploaded by Manikandan N. on 07 November 2017.
CITATIONS READS
0 104
1 author:
SEE PROFILE
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
All content following this page was uploaded by suresh kumar Padmanaban on 08 July 2017.
74
Ultrasonic welding involves the use of high frequency sound energy to soften or melt the thermoplastic at the joint. Parts
to be joined are held together under pressure and are then subjected to ultrasonic vibrations usually at a frequency of 20,
30 or 40 kHz. The ability to weld a component successfully is governed by the design of the equipment and the
mechanical properties of the material to be welded and the design of the components. Since ultrasonic welding is very fast
(weld times are typically less than 1 second) and easily automated, it is a widely used technique. In order to guarantee the
successful welding of any parts careful design of components and fixtures is required and for this reason the technique is
best suited for mass production. An ultrasonic welding machine consists of four main components: a power supply, a
converter, an amplitude modifying device (commonly called a Booster) and an acoustic tool known as the horn (or
sonotrode). The power supply changes mains electricity at a frequency of 50-60Hz, into high frequency electrical supply
operating at 20, 30 or 40 kHz. This electrical energy is supplied to the converter. Within the converter, discs of
piezoelectric material are sandwiched between two metal sections. These discs are clamped tightly together and are
always held in compression. The converter changes the electrical energy into mechanical vibratory energy at ultrasonic
frequencies.
Most ultrasonic welding machines operate at 20 kHz. This is above the highest frequency generally detected by the human
ear. The vibratory energy is then transmitted through the booster. The booster increases the amplitude of the sound wave.
The sound waves are then transmitted to the horn. The horn is an acoustic tool that transfers the vibratory energy directly
to the parts being assembled, and it also applies a welding pressure. The vibrations are transmitted through the work piece
to the joint area. Here the vibratory energy is converted to heat through friction then softens or melts the thermoplastic and
joins the parts together.
2. Ultrasonic Horn Design
2.1. Different Shapes of Horn
A welding horn, also known as a sonotrode, is an acoustical tool that transfers the mechanical vibrations to the work
piece, and is custom-made to suit the requirements of the application. The traditional methods for the design of an
acoustic horn are based on the equilibrium of an Infinitesimal element under elastic action, inertia forces, and integration
over the horn length to attain resonance. Equilibrium leads to the following differential equation.
Horns are designed as long resonant bars with a half wavelength. By changing the cross sectional shape of a horn, it is
possible to give it a gain factor, increasing the amplitude of the vibration it receives from the transducer – booster
combination. Three common horn designs are the step, exponential, and adenoidal, Step horns consist of two sections with
different but uniform cross-sectional areas. The transition between the sections is located near the nodal point. Due to the
abrupt change in cross-section in the nodal plane, step horns have a very high stress concentration in this area and can fail
if driven at excessive.
75
Page
Exponential horns have a cross-sectional area that changes exponentially with length. The smooth transition distributes
the stress over a greater length, thus offering lower stress concentrations than that found in step horns. They generally
have lower gain factors, so are used for applications requiring low forces and adenoidal horns are basically step horns
with a more gradual transition radius through the nodal point. They offer high gains with low stress concentrations.
Fig.1.3: Schematic of the horn with the length L and the widths W1 and W2 of the back and front ends.
76
Page
The applied force vector app will include all external forces and the internal forces applied by the constraint equations. In
this case there will be no external forces and the internal forces will be equal and opposite forces applied to each pair of
nodes linked by a constraint equation. Solution methods will not be discussed here (for information see the Ansys
Theoretical Manual (Kohnke [20]) but the result is the derivation of u the displacement vector which defines the
displacement of each node and fet the element force vector from which the nodal forces and hence stresses are derived.
Hence the result of a static analysis is a deflected shape and the stress state of the material. The deflected shape is
important if the inside diameter of the die is tightly tolerance - the insert can be machined to a diameter slightly larger
than the required value to allow for the slight shrinkage when the insert is fitted. The stress state is important in
determining how well the die performs and its lifetime. This must be considered in conjunction with the stress state
caused by the vibrations.
3.6 Modal Analysis
Modal analysis calculates the natural frequencies and mode shapes of an object. By definition this technique will consider
only the mass and stiffness of the object to arrive at theoretical natural frequencies and mode shapes. Damping (which is
present in all real systems) is ignored. Therefore the results of this type of analysis must be treated with some caution. The
effect of damping on a real system is to change the resonant frequencies and modify the mode shapes. When two modes
appear at similar frequencies in the presence of damping the observed mode shapes will appear as combinations of the two
natural modes, with the degree of distortion of each mode dependent on the amount of damping present. The effect on the
resonant frequencies is to increase the separation between the modes. If there is a large frequency separation between a
pair of vibration modes then there will be no significant effect on the mode shapes, and the resonant frequency will be
lowered slightly by the effect of the damping. The materials from which the ultrasonic horn are made have been chosen
for their low damping properties (Section 3.7) and so damping does not in this case significantly change the resonant
frequencies. Also the separation between resonant frequencies in the area of interest must be fairly large (1-2 kHz) for the
80
Page
die to function correctly (Section 3.3). Therefore damping does not have a significant effect on the results in this case, and
the modal analysis technique is extremely useful.
Modal analysis solves equations of the form:
(K - M) =0
M = Mass matrix
= Mode-shape vector of mode i
Solution involves calculating the eigenvalues , and eigenvectors for this equation. The user may select the range of
i or specify a frequency range in which the eigenvectors and eigenvalues are to be calculated. Hence the results of modal
analysis are a set of natural frequencies and their associated mode shapes (the distorted shape of the object at one extreme
of its movement). There is no information about the magnitude of the distortion so an arbitrary value is normally assigned
and stresses caused by vibration are not usually calculated. However it is possible for the user to specify an amplitude
value to which the modeshapes (where possible) will be scaled. In this case the stress state can also be calculated for each
modeshape. The stresses must be considered in conjunction with the static stress caused by the interference fit to ensure
that the die does not separate or fatigue in service.
M +C +Ku=f
Where M = Mass matrix
81
Page
= Acceleration vector
C = Damping matrix
= Velocity vector
K = Stiffness matrix
u = Displacement vector
f = Harmonic forcing function
This is the basic equation of steady state motion. It can be solved directly at a si1ngle frequency to give the response u to
the given force f. This can be extended to give the response over a range of frequencies by repeating the analysis. To
accurately predict the response over a wide frequency range may require a large number of frequency steps and so will
often use much more computer time than for the other types of analysis described above. The analysis is usually run in
two stages: First the solution of the equation above over a range of frequencies to produce response spectra for any chosen
nodes. Second the equation of section is used to derive the complete stress state at only one or two chosen frequencies,
typically the resonance peaks (full calculation of the stress state at every frequency would require excessive computer
time). This type of analysis has been used particularly for the design and optimization of the tuned ultrasonic mounting.
3.8. Procedure
• Pre Processing
• Solution
• Post Processing
Start - All Programs – Ansys 10 - Mechanical APDL Product Launcher – Set the Working Directory– Click Run.
Preprocessing
1. Preprocessor - Element type - Add/Edit/Delete – Add – Solid, 10 node 82 – Ok – Option – Choose Plane stress
w/thk - Close.
2. Real constants - Add/Edit/Delete – Add – Ok – THK 0.5 – Ok - Close.
3. Material props - Material Models – Structural – Linear – Elastic – Isotropic - EX 2e5, PRXY 0.3 - Ok.
4. Modeling – Create – Key points – Solid, Ok.
5. Meshing - Mesh Tool – Area – Set - Select the object – Ok – All key points – Ok - Mesh Tool - Select TRI or QUAD
Free/Mapped – Mesh - Select the object - Ok
3.9. Modal Analysis
As modal displacements in the actual horn occur in the x, y and z directions it is better to consider a 3D horn model with a
suitable element. The horn was meshed using 10node tetrahedral – ’10 solid 92’. The element is defined by ten nodes
having three degrees of freedom at each node: translations in the nodal x, y, and z directions and is well suited to model
82
irregular meshes (such as produced from various CAD/CAM systems). An element mesh size of 3 (manual) was selected
Page
to carry out the meshing. Below this element size there was no improvement in the results as the FE model has reached
convergence. Mode extraction is carried out in the frequency range 19– 21 kHz using Block Lanchoz option. Five mode
shapes are extracted in the given frequency range with pre-stress results turned on. Some of the horns have a single mode
in the given frequency range which is desirable. Two or more modes, close to the axial mode will result in modal
coupling, which reduces the efficiency of the horn and is to be avoided. Two different modes obtained for Stepped profile
are longitudinal or axial mode is the required mode shape. The natural frequency of the longitudinal mode obtained in the
modal analysis for the different profile horns.
Deformation Shape
84
20800
20600
20400
20200
20000
19800
19600
19400 Frequency
19200
19000
18800
The Modeling using Ansys Software proves to be very important in order to highlight the behavior of the ultrasonic
welding horn. The displacement amplification of the proposed horn is 19% higher than that of the traditional stepped horn
with the same length and end surface widths. M.Roopa Ravi and Rudramoorthy [4] from the modal analysis of the horns
as well as Analysis Results of natural Frequency of Horn are studied. The von-Mises stresses for the stepped horn has the
largest stress concentration near the nodal region compared to the other horns. This is due to the sudden change in cross-
section. The stepped horn which is preferred by the industry.
5. Conclusions
In this Paper, the modal and harmonic analyses for Stepped horns and horns designed by equation have been carried out,
and their results have been presented and discussed. From the results of the analyses, conclusions may be summarized as
follows:
85
Page
1. The natural frequency of the horn designed by equation is more close to the operating frequency of the machine. Since
it can be operated more easily at the resonance frequency with the machine, the horns will be more energy effective than
commercial horns.
2. The work provides a new approach for the Stepped horn design by two ends and three Sections.
3. The von Mises stress of the Stepped horn is more than the other profile horns and The Stepped horns have high
displacement amplitude.
4. In overall Progress the New Stepped Horn is 19 % of Natural frequency increased by Existing Other Horns.
5. Proposed Horn Manufactured by CNC Machine for using Different Ultrasonic Application.
6. References
[1]. Amin, Ahamed, Yousef, Computer-aided design of acoustic horns for ultrasonic machining using finite element
analysis, Journal of Materials Processing Technology 55 (1995) 254–260.
[2]. K-J Bathe, Finite-element procedures in engineering analysis. Prentis-Hall, 1982.
[3]. A. Benatar, Z. Cheng, Ultrasonic welding of thermoplastics in the far field, Polymer Engineering and Science 29 (23)
(1989) 1699–1704.
[4]. Constantin radu, Gheorghe amza, Finite Element Modelling and Analysis of Ultrasonic horn, Proceedings of the
st
1 WSEAS International Conference on Visualization, Imaging and Simulation (VIS'08) -960.
[5]. N. Cretu, Acoustic measurements and computational results on material specimens with harmonic variation of the
cross section, Ultrasonic 43 (2005), 547- 550.
[6]. B. Gourley, A. Rushton, Solve ultrasonic horn problems with finite element analysis, Plastics Technology 52 (11)
(2006) 49–50.
[7]. Hai-Dang Tam Nguyen, Dung-An Wang, Design of an Ultrasonic steel horn with a Bézier profile, International
Conference on Green Technology and Sustainable Development September 29-30, 2012,149-154.
[8]. Jiromaru Tsujino, Misugi Hongoh, Ryoko Tanaka, Rie Onoguchi, Tetsugi Ueoka, Ultrasonic plastic welding using
fundamental and higher frequencies, Ultrasonics 40 (2002) 375–378.
[9]. M. Nad, Ultrasonic horn design for ultrasonic machining technologies, Applied and Computational Mechanics 4
(2010) 79–88.
[10]. K. Nakamura, K. Kakihara, M. Kawakam, Measuring vibration characteristics at large amplitude region of
materials for high power ultrasonic vibration system, Ultrasonics 38 (2000) 122–126.
[11]. S. Sherrit, S.A. Askins, M. Gradziol, Novel horn designs for ultrasonic/sonic cleaning, welding, soldering, cutting
and drilling, in: Proceedings of the SPIE Smart Structures Conference, San Diego, vol. 4701, 2002 (Paper 34).
[12]. Shuyu Lin, Study on the longitudinal-torsional composite mode exponential ultrasonic horns, Ultrasonics 34 (1996)
757–762.
[13]. M.N. Tolunay, P.R. Dawson, K.K. Wang, Heating and bonding mechanism in ultrasonic welding, Polymer
Engineering and Science 23 (13) (2004) 726–733.
[14]. D.-A. Wanga, W.-Y. Chuang, Design of a Bézier-Profile Horn for High Displacement Amplification, (2010),1-38.
86
Page
[15]. D.A. Wang, W.Y. Chuang, K. Hsu, H.T. Pham, Design of a Bezier-profile horn for high displacement
amplification, Ultrasonics 51 (2011) 148–156.
[16]. M.Roopa Ravi and Rudramoorthy, Computational Modeling and Experimental Studies of the dynamic Performance
of ultrasonic horn profiles used in Plastic Welding, Ultrasonics 53 (2013) 763–772.
87
Page