Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
- 75 -
Ma{instvo 2(8), 75 – 84, (2004) M.Zatarain: NEW TECHNOLOGIES IN MACHINE TOOLS
- 76 -
Ma{instvo 2(8), 75 – 84, (2004) M.Zatarain: NEW TECHNOLOGIES IN MACHINE TOOLS
small ceramic ball bearings. These give the also required, which pushes up the cost of this
highest speeds for a given spindle diameter, but solution still further.
their load capacity is somewhat lower. CNC driven slides commit errors when trying to
Electro spindles are designed to produce high perform the required trajectories. The distance from
power at high speeds, but the power they can the set position to the actual position depends on
provide at low speeds is limited. Maximum power the trajectory and the dynamic behaviour of the
is usually provided in a speed range of 1 to 4. drive. This latter factor is limited by the natural
That means that a spindle able to give maximum frequencies of the mechanics combined with the
power at 25000 rpm will be able to maintain that tuning of the control loop parameters (mainly the
maximum power down to 6000 rpm. Below that proportional and integral gains of the velocity loop
speed power will be reduced in proportion to and the proportional gain of the position loop).
speed, with the available torque being maintained. Selecting the 'best' parameter set for a particular
Power available at low speeds is therefore much drive is no easy matter. Each tuning expert will
lower than that provided by conventional spindles. probably select different values for the
Conventional spindles have a much lower aforementioned gains. That is why the most
maximum speed, and are usually combined with a sophisticated CNC models incorporate self-tuning
gear box, giving a double transmission rate. This tools. Some of these are good, but others seem
enables them to provide maximum power at to be the result of a worst value search process
speeds as low as 300 rpm. Work with large rather than a search for the best possible solution.
diameter face mills can be done easily with Even with a good set of control loop parameters
conventional spindles, but is not possible with and very good mechanics, trajectory errors appear.
high speed electro spindles. To offset these errors techniques such as 'feed
The highest possible rotation speeds are obtained forward' and 'look ahead' are included in modem
with magnetic bearings. The absence of material CNCs. Each CNC builder has defined their own
contact minimises friction, so that the only energy parameters and functionalities, specially those
losses are those due to Foucault current. Barring concerned with 'look ahead' functions. Tuning of
accidents, magnetic spindles should last these parameters tends to be very difficult, with
indefinitely. Their high cost currently prevents them the added problem that they are not transferrable
from being used in most cases, but in the future from one make of CNC to another. Difficulties are
more applications will be found. increased still further by the poor quality of the
manuals and explanations given to CNC users.
3.1.2. High speed drives Very stiff, light drive systems, and also linear motor
systems, sometimes come up against the limitation
High speed milling machines require interpolation of the sampling frequency of the CNC. This
with high feed speeds. These range from 5 to 15 frequency further limits the gains that can be
m/min as a general rule. Contouring at these selected for the velocity and position loops. This
speeds gives rise to high accelerations and high limitation is not important for conventional drives
inertia forces. but becomes predominant in high dynamic drives.
The slides of conventional machines are usually Nowadays all commercially available CNC systems
very heavy, which results in high torque use a conventional control system based on three
requirements and major drive chain deformation, loops: current, velocity and position. Other
though there are improved designs with lighter alternatives are being considered in an attempt to
moving parts, and stiff mechanical chains. Ball improve the behaviour of drive systems. Feedback
feed screws tend to have longer pitch than usual, of acceleration makes loops more stable and can
20 to 40 mm instead of the more conventional 10 increase position loop gain two or three fold. This
mm. The transmission from the motor to the ball technique is being developed at several research
screw is as direct as possible, with gear boxes, institutes, and has been included in a
pulleys/belts and even couplings being avoided commercially available CNC by Fidia, under the
whenever possible. denomination of 'active damping'.
The simplest drives are those found with linear Research into more sophisticated control
motors: the motor produces a direct linear techniques is ongoing. For the moment there is
movement rather than the more conventional no clear expectation that an alternative to the
rotating movement. Mechanical transmission is aforementioned PI loops will be used in practical
avoided, which results in better dynamic behaviour. applications in the short term. One of the
The drawback is that the force multiplication problems could be difficulty in adapting the
obtained in conventional systems is lost, so that parameters of these alternative control strategies to
motors are very large, heavy and expensive each particular machine.
compared to traditional ones. Very high current is
- 77 -
Ma{instvo 2(8), 75 – 84, (2004) M.Zatarain: NEW TECHNOLOGIES IN MACHINE TOOLS
- 78 -
Ma{instvo 2(8), 75 – 84, (2004) M.Zatarain: NEW TECHNOLOGIES IN MACHINE TOOLS
Figure 3. Parallel kinematics machine by ISW Figure 4. Hybrid kinematics machine by DMG
- 79 -
Ma{instvo 2(8), 75 – 84, (2004) M.Zatarain: NEW TECHNOLOGIES IN MACHINE TOOLS
- 80 -
Ma{instvo 2(8), 75 – 84, (2004) M.Zatarain: NEW TECHNOLOGIES IN MACHINE TOOLS
Still more concentrated laser pulses are obtained reproducing the tool electrode shape in the
in femtolaser machines, in which pulse length is workpiece. The combination of the two methods
around 100 femtoseconds (100*10-15 seconds) and has been shown to blend the benefits of both,
instantaneous power is around 10 GW with a provided that the parameters of the combined
period of 1 ms. Mean power is in the range of 1 process are properly selected.
W, which means that productivity is low. These Significant experiments have also taken place in
machines are used to produce very small parts heat treatment by means of the grinding process.
with excellent accuracy. The parameters of the grinding process are
selected in such a way that the part obtains the
6. HYBRlD PROCESSES required hardness by the heating/cooling produced
by the material removing process.
There seem to be no major advances on the
horizon in single processes such as milling and 7. PROCESS INTEGRATION
turning. If productivity increases are to be obtained,
hybrid processes could be the way to go. From the oldest machine tools, able to perform
Experiments in this direction have already taken only a single type of process, we progressed to
place: examples include laser aided turning for modern machines which can handle more and
hard-to-machine materials, oil jet aided machining, more processes on the same machine. The
ultrasonic vibration aided machining, and ELID ultimate aim is, as far as possible, to obtain
grinding. finished parts from a single machine.
Laser and plasma beams have been used to heat The trend seems to be to continue to incorporate
material just before tools remove it. When material still more processes into machine tools. In the
is heated its characteristics change and cutting future there may well be machines that are able
forces and too wear are reduced. The advantages to grind and handle chip removal operations. This
of this system are greatest when machining would involve heat treatment being performed on
difficult materials. the machine itself, perhaps by the aforementioned
Many other process combinations have been or technique of exploiting the heat produced by the
are being developed, among them electrochemical grinding process.
discharge machining, which combines Very interesting process integration work is being
electrochemical machining with electrical discharge done in grinding machines for turbine blades of
machining [1]. The former is characterised by high jet aircraft engines. These large machines are able
surface integrity, improved surface finish, high to leave workpieces in a semi free situation that
machining rates and the absence of tool-electrode enables them to be balanced without removing
wear, but it is less accurate than EDM in them from the machine.
- 81 -
Ma{instvo 2(8), 75 – 84, (2004) M.Zatarain: NEW TECHNOLOGIES IN MACHINE TOOLS
The welding process is another candidate for concemed about the consequences of this for the
incorporation into metal cutting machines. It seems near future.
that laser welding might be combined with chip Less pollutant production processes, lower power
removing processes in a single machine. consumption, recyclable materials and so on are
Processes of forming by material displacement aspects that have to be considered in next
may be difficult to combine with cutting processes, generation machines [7].
due to practical limitations. Cutting processes have traditionally used cutting
fluids. Once the lifetime of such fluids ends, they
must be disposed of, which poses problems as
8. FLEXIBILITY, RECONFIGURABILITY they tend to be highly pollutant. Less polluting
fluids, and dry or minimum quantity lubrication
Long production runs were obtained in the past (MQL) techniques are now being investigated.
by dedicated transfer lines. The high cost of such EDM machines are also a pollution source, as
lines was offset by the very large amount of parts once the dielectric liquid is spent it needs to be
produced during their lifetimes. The clear tendency disposed of without contaminating the environment.
now is to produce shorter runs, for example in Less polluting, higher performing liquids are
the automotive industry. This means that production therefore being sought, as are better filtering
lines must be dedicated not to a particular part systems.
but to a range of similar parts, or even to Noise and vibration also impact on the environment.
different parts. Work to produce less noisy machines is ongoing,
CNC machines are a good example of but vibration/noise generating processes must be
incorporating agility, as they can produce different replaced by quieter ones if any significant change is
parts merely by changing the CNC program. to be made.
Incorporating CNC into special purpose machines,
such as those typically used in transfer lines, 10. ULTRAPRECISION MACHINING
makes them more flexible. But the tendency is to
improve flexibility till further by replacing special Ultraprecision machining has grown out of
purpose machines by machining centres. conventional precision machining in response to
Productivity will not be as high, but the gain in new needs. The trend towards miniaturization in
flexibilty offsets the resulting loss. many fields has brought with it new, tighter
Another example of increased flexibility is the precision requirements.
replacement of conventional CNC external grinding For example the electronics industry, computer
machines by contouring grinding machines. Again peripherals, sensor miniaturization, surgical and
some productivity is lost, but the time required to biotechnology applications, optics, scientific
change from producing one part to the next one instrumentation and vehicle and domestic
is much lower. appliances sensors all require ever smaller, more
Reconfigurability is a hot topic at the moment, precise parts.
albeit one about which more has been written That in turn requires smaller, more accurate
than actually done. The idea is to rebuild machines with special architectures, designed on
machines by intensive use of modular units. the basis of precision engineering principles,
Perhaps the clearest picture of its potential to date sometimes working in controlled atmospheres,
has been obtained from the use of PKM machines capable of offsetting deformation, particularly heat
in different configurations [4]. There is still a great deformation.
deal to be done before practical applications are Highly stable materials, specially designed tools,
obtained. controls and drives, and many other specialised
components are required to build these machines.
9. ENVIRONMENTAL ASPECTS Repeatability is the key, and that means that
friction has to be minimised and stiffness
Sustainability is another of the chief topics of the optimised at the same time. Repeatable errors are
moment. Human beings have had a huge impact on usually offset by the electronic/computing system.
their environment over many centuries, and are now
- 82 -
Ma{instvo 2(8), 75 – 84, (2004) M.Zatarain: NEW TECHNOLOGIES IN MACHINE TOOLS
11. MICROMACHINING
Production of micro- or nanometre size parts calls microinjection, hot embossing or other replication
for production equipment such as that mentioned procedures.
in the previous section. There are production The smallest, most accurate moulds can be
technologies derived from machine tools which obtained by these techniques deriving from
involve increased precision and reduced size: microelectronic technologies [8]. Tipically there are
micromilling, microdrilling, micropunching, micro processes of deposition of thin layers [9],
EDM, micro laser machining, etc. are all possible. combined with processes of removing material by
These technologies are joining those used to dry and wet etching. These last two processes
produce microelectronic products, such as the require photolithography, which is similar to the
manufacturing processes for silicon wafers [6]. process used for producing printed circuit boards,
Making single, highly accurate microparts is very but on a much more precise level. Production of
expensive, replication systems must be relied on. masks in particular is a very demanding process
This means making a single, very expensive part which requires machines capable of working with
(mould) by a complicated, costly production a precision well below the micrometre level.
process, and afterwards making many parts by
- 83 -
Ma{instvo 2(8), 75 – 84, (2004) M.Zatarain: NEW TECHNOLOGIES IN MACHINE TOOLS
[1] J. Kozak, K. P. Rajurkar.: Hybrid Machining [7] E. Westkämper, L. Alting e.a.: Life Cycle
Process Evaluation and Development, University management and assessment: approaches
of Nebraska, Lincoln, USA, and visions towards sustainable
http://www.unl.edu/nmrc/hvbrid/hvbrid_machining. Manufacturing, Annals of the CIRP, 2000.
htm
[8] J. Corbett, P.A. McKeown e.a.: Nanotechnology:
[2] T. Plunkett.: 3D Laser Machining, 3T RPD Ltd. International developments and emerging
products, Annals of the CIRP, 2000.
[3] H. Van Brussel.: Key Technologies for Machine
Design and Control. DNA Eureka cluster [9] J. A. McGeough, M. Leu e.a.: Electroforming
programme report Process and Application to Micro/Macro
Manufacturing, Annals of the CIRP, 2001.
[4] Y. Koren, U. Heisel, e. a.: Reconfigurable
Manufacturing Systems, Annals of the CIRP, 1999. [10] J. Meijer, K. Du e.a.: Laser Machining by
short and ultrashort pulses, state of the art
[5] K.P. Rajurkar, D. Zhu e.a.: New Developments and new opportunities in the age of the
in Electro-Chemical Machining, Annals ofthe photons, Annals of the CIRP, 2002.
CIRP, 1999.
[11] M. Weck, D. Staimer.: Parallel Kinematic
[6] T. Masuzawa: State-of -the-art on Machines Tools - Current State and Future
Micromachining, Annals of the CIRP, 2000. Potentials, Annals of the CIRP, 2002.
- 84 -