Вы находитесь на странице: 1из 5

See discussions, stats, and author profiles for this publication at: https://www.researchgate.

net/publication/323144319

This Garden of the Sun: A Report on Almería’s Miracle Economy

Chapter · January 2013

CITATIONS READS

0 131

1 author:

Melissa Cate Christ


The Hong Kong Polytechnic University
13 PUBLICATIONS   3 CITATIONS   

SEE PROFILE

Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:

Hong Kong Stair Archive View project

Seattle stairs View project

All content following this page was uploaded by Melissa Cate Christ on 13 February 2018.

The user has requested enhancement of the downloaded file.


This Garden of the Sun: A Report on Almería’s Miracle Economy
by Melissa Cate Christ

fig. 4
When viewed from a satellite, the ex­panse strong Mediterranean winds, and an aver-
of greenhouses in Almería resembles a age of 18 degrees Celsius in the winter, its
monochromatic patchwork quilt, stitched climate is a formidable lure for mass agri­
together by roads and punctuated by the cultural production. As these optimal cli­-
rectangular balsas (swimming pool-like res- matic coincidences were matched with rel­-
ervoirs) that hold pumped groundwater atively simply greenhouse construction
in reserve for on-demand irrigation. From tech­niques, an accessible groundwater sup­
the ground, however, this apparent conti­ ply to offset the less than 300mm average
nuity disappears, revealing instead a land- annual rainfall, a precarious immigrant la­-
scape of stark contrasts, exemplified by bour force, and the continuing appropria-
fig. 2 the route I followed from the 2249m-high, tion and deployment of advanced techno-
goat-strewn Sierra de Gádor mountains, logical innovations, the so-called el milagro
through fields of reflective white plas­t ic de Almería (the miracle of Almería) has
on the Campo de Dalías, a burgeon­i ng emerged in less than 40 years.
company town called El Ejido, boom-era With nearly 27,000 hectares of green-
condos and high-end golf cours­es, and end- houses, located primarily in the low-alti-
ing at the glistening blue of the Medi­terran- tude plains of the Campo de Dalías, and in
ean. While this area can easily be mistaken the higher Campo de Níjar, this so-called
as one giant vegetable factory due to the “plastic sea” produces almost 3 million tonnes
greenhouses’ dramatic aesthe­tic figuration of vegetables per year (2009), half of which
fig. 1 on what was once a barren desert back- are exported.3 These exports comprise 50
ground, the totalizing view from the sky un- per cent of the peppers, 25 per cent of the
fig. 3

der estimates the heterogeneous, con­ti­nuous, tomatoes and cucumbers, and significant
and intensive human agency required on the quantities of eggplants, zucchini, green
ground in order to produce tender crops like beans, and melons for the major supermar-
tomatoes, even with the unique geographical ket chains in Europe.4 Such a scale of pro-
When the human desire to have the food we want whenever we and climatic conditions specific to Almería. duction is praised for contributing almost
want it is coupled with industrial production processes that benefit 2 billion euros per year to the struggling
El Milagro de Almería
the world’s most af­fluent, a global chain of political, economic, so- Spanish economy.5 In total, the 13,500 fam-
Before visiting, I was confronted during ily-owned greenhouse operations directly
cial, and environmental causalities is set in motion. At this moment my research with a wealth of superlative employ 40,000 people, while their agri-
of extravagant consumption, we often forget that food was once claims: Almería is, by turns, home to the business cluster of over 500 supporting
largest concentration of greenhouses in industries, such as plastic manufacturing
intimately and precariously tied to seasonal avail­ability, local cli- the world, the driest area of Europe, the and recycling, vegetable packaging and dis­
mate, and cultural heritage; it is only recently that food itself began primary source of Europe’s winter salads, tribution, and seed production and seed-
to appear as just another commodity, delivered by way of refrig- home to the largest population of foreign- ling breeding employs 19,000.6 In addition,
born residents in Spain, and the site of the the area provides itinerant employment
erated containers in a logistically optimized global transportation largest desalination plant in Europe. This for an estimated 100,000 migrant workers,
network. In re­sponse to the technopolitical advances in optimized collection of descriptive extremes—scalar, primarily from northern and sub-Saharan
geographical, industrial, economic, tech- Africa.7 The rapid expansion of this vege­
yields and maximized capacities, many regions have moved to in­- nological—nevertheless allow Almería to table economy is reflected in the 75 per cent
crease the exploitation of natural and human resources to further be compared with other industrial land- increase in the province’s population since
scapes of extraction and production devel- 1981, when there were only 7,000 hectares
capitalize on their localized advantages for industrial food produc­ oped to exploit a region’s natural resources. of greenhouses and the province was one
tion.1 Because of global market transformations, such local produc- What is especially unique to Almería, how- of the poorest in Spain;8 comparatively, in
tion is required to satisfy out-of-season desire. Exemplary of an ever, is that the foundation of the explo- 2012, Almería’s GDP per capita ranked
sive growth of the horticulture industry is third in the country.9
area marked by this global shift towards omni-seasonal availabil- the climate itself. With anywhere between
ity is the province of Almería in Andalucía, southern Spain. 3,200 and 3,500 hours of sunlight per year,2

364 Project 365


tonnes per year—and garbage plastic are
collected for “recycling,” which tends to
include various combinations of compost-
ing, burning, and shredding. In actuality,
substantial amounts of these waste prod-
ucts often end up illegally dumped in the
Norias Lagoon, vacant lots, or ramblas
(stream beds) to be washed into the sea 13
by the infrequent but often devastating

fig. 6
autumn gota fría (torrential downpours);
much of what is not washed into the sea is

fig. 9
left instead to slowly leach toxins into the
groundwater.14 Aside from the excessive production of
As the industry has grown, plot sizes solid waste, which stubbornly refuses to
and the number of crop turnovers per year be dreamt away, the most pressing issue
have increased two- to three-fold, forcing in Almería is the dwindling supply of fresh,
the traditionally family-run farms to rely clean water. In addition to the 700m-deep
more heavily on paid labour, which is both confined aquifer well drilled in 1985,19 and
their highest cost (46 per cent as of 200515) the Benínar Reservoir, the largest source

fig. 8
and the area where they can most increase of fresh water is the desalination plant
fig. 5 profits by paying lower wages to legal and in Carboneras, completed in 2005 on the
ing practices of over-exploitation. Exces- illegal migrant workers. Almería has the eastern coast of the province, in the mid-
sive extraction has led to a 15m drop in highest population of immigrants in Spain, dle of the Cabo de Gata-Níjar Natural Park.
groundwater levels in 15 years, and helped over half of whom work in intensive, horti­- Although this desalination plant is current-
produce an average rate of 5mm of subsid- culture-related industries.16 Some of the ly working at only 15 per cent capacity, it
ence per year in some areas of the prov- social and political economic consequences meets the needs of all the greenhouses in
ince.11 In the Campo de Dalías, where the of this demographic shift reported in recent the Campo de Níjar (some 7,000 hectares)
majority of the oldest and least technolo­ years include the sub-standard working and in so doing suggests that the seeming-
gically advanced greenhouses are concen­ conditions and subsistence-level wages ly infinite supply of the Mediterranean it-
trated, horticultural practices have led to of many underpaid migrant workers.17 The self is yet to be fully exploited. The Carbon­
the Norias lagoon, which emerged as early influx of migrant settlements has also led eras plant has positioned the desalinated
as 1998 in a lutite quarry. This remarkable to labour disputes and race riots, parti­ water supply as the miraculously “sustain­
site is assumed to be the result of a com- cularly in 2000 and 2008. Worker illnes­ able” future of the region, despite a cost of
fig. 7

bination of subsidence, increased waste- ses linked to long hours in excessive heat 1.5–4 times above that of pumped water20
water discharge, the shallowness of the breath­ing chemically tainted air in insuf- and the enormous amount of energy need­
unconfined aquifer below and the de­crease ficiently ventilated greenhouses have also ­ed for industrial processing.21
Water, Waste, and Labour
in extraction due to the decline in the water dramatically increased. Undoubtedly, technical innovations in
The success of this solar-enabled, desire- quality because of saltwater contamina­ In response to these attendant realities water recycling processes have been im­-
fueled horticultural production is not with­ tion.12 The lagoon is currently being pumped accompanying the miracle economy, a num­- plemented as partial solutions to the dwin-
out attendant costs— externalities riddled for treatment and reuse, as well to reclaim ber of corporate, academic, governmental, dling, and therefore increasingly expen-
with contradictions and violence. The most flooded land formerly home to makeshift and community programs have been ini- sive, water supply. In the most technically
serious impacts to the environment in­clude housing for workers, ramshackle greenhous- tiated, spinning off other new industries, advanced, multi-tunnel, rigid plastic green­
the depletion of the region’s aquifers and es, and industries such as waste manage- products, and research. The dream of trans­ houses, computer-controlled passive ven-
their contamination through polluted waste- ment; it is also used as an informal dumpsite forming these social and environmental tilation and water recycling systems are
water discharge and salt-water intrusion. for construction, and plastic and vegetable contingencies into neoliberal opportuni- employed to monitor and control nutrient
Although the adoption of drip irrigation, waste. Ironically, it is the only “naturally” ties for profit has many variations here, and salinity levels, adding fresh water and
enarenado artificial soil layering, and soil- vegetated area amidst hectares of closely including the development of the saline fertilizer depending upon the needs of the
less substrates such as perlite or coco-peat, packed greenhouses, with successional water-tolerant “RAF tomato,” a French vari­ plants. To promote the adoption of new
were intended to reduce water use through vegetation filling the abandoned parral ety developed in 1969 and sold as a luxury techniques and the potential of the indus-
decreased evaporation and direct applica­ structures and water edges. Because it product to high-end restaurants for 10–15 try to become more productive and sus-
tion of water and fertilizer to the plant roots, remains somewhat secluded, this postnat- euros per kilo. Another variation of this tainable, the Andalusian Medal-winning
these effects have not been fully realized.10 ural site has become a popular fishing spot dream is vegetable waste being used to vegetable producer Clisol Agro stocks their
In­stead, the reliance on vernacular practi­ for migrant workers and home to a diverse generate energy by being processed into show greenhouse with over twenty variet-
ces of overwatering and the high cost of population of local and migrating birds. fuel briquettes, assuming that the entan- ies of colorful tomatoes and provides tours
using deep-well (confined aquifer) water, Officially, the increasing amounts of pest­ gled plastic from the twining vines can be and educational talks to tourists. Accord-
recycled wastewater, or desalinated water icides and chemical fertilizers, contami­ efficiently removed to prevent the release ing to my guide, Lola Gómez Ferrón, who
from Carboneras, contributes to continu- nated vegetable waste— over 700,000 toxic fumes when it is subsequently burned.18 is also the founder of the company, in the

366 Scapegoat 367 This Garden of the Sun: A...


Clisol show greenhouse, recycled water ing within a limited economy. Harnessed receives: water to calm her eternal thirst.
comprises 30 per cent of the total irriga- by global capitalism, omni-seasonal desires The shocking satellite image of green-
tion requirement, with the remaining 70 have enabled the extreme manipula­tion of houses in Southern Spain may stand in well
per cent made up from groundwater (in Almería’s landscape; reading such a land- for the processes playing out in and among
this case extracted from the confined aqui­ scape requires an equally dramatic shift them. However, when seen as a source and
fer well).22 The company also employs inte­- in logic—a movement from a restricted (no solution to problems such as seasonal in­-
grated pest management, as well as “nat- matter how it is traded-off ) to a general consistency, economic instability, global
ural” chemicals such as sulphur dust, to economy. The transformation of the prov- climate change, and environmental deg-
manage the spread of tomato diseases. ince—from a poor, under-populated desert radation, industrial-scale food production
The proliferation of unintended extern- to one of the most economically produc- is far more than an image; this intensive
alities is essential to consider for under- tive regions in Spain—through the expe- human, mineral, and vegetable assemblage
standing Almería’s peculiar overdevelop­ dited exploitation of its natural resources reproduces social and environmental re­la-
ment. As an especially telling example, the demonstrates the potential to capitalize tions, normalizing the processes and prac­ti­-
vernacular tradition of whitewashing the on localized climate conditions and har- ces that characterize industrial hor­ti­cul­ture
plastic roofs of the greenhouses in the sum­ ness all adjacent industries to intensely ex­- and the standing-reserve of commo­dities it
mer to reduce solar gain inside has been pand the horticulture industry. While each affords. Devotion to the Ar­gentin­ean popu­-
linked to a three-degree Celsius decrease component of the process has been iso- list saint Difunta Correa—whose shine it-
in the areas’ median temperature. In this lated, mechanized, and streamlined, there self is made up of the twin necessities of
regard, the dense expanse of greenhouses, is no escaping the essential fact: such an the milagro de Almería, namely, water and
capable of harnessing the energy of the investment must be spent within a general plastic—speaks to the hopes of a re­g ion
sun to produce vast quantities of vegeta- economy, either gloriously or catastrophi- both blessed and tortured with over 300
bles, could also be credited for their role cally. My experience in Almería—witness- days of sunshine every year. Her desire
in countering the effects of global climate ing the struggles of immigrant labourers for devotees to quench her eternal thirst
change.23 Yet, for each example of a positive, who work for such low wages to deliver is indelibly related to her suffering under
if unintended, externalized outcome, there perfect tomatoes to the tables of Europe’s the solar resource powering Alme­ría's mi­-
is a nagging caveat to be reported as well. most affluent consumers—suggests little racle economy; how long she can sustain
For example, the use of expensive, desal- in the way of glorious expenditure; instead, her own miraculous sating of the parched
inated water and recycled water has only I witnessed vast quantities of light, labour, desire for earthly, maternal plentitude is
reduced, rather than replaced, the amount and land squandered for the production strictly a matter of faith. 
of groundwater bought from the govern- of an image, and a taste, of the omni-sea-
ment or pumped from small and sometimes sonal salad.
illegal wells. The combined effect of such
Gracias Difunta Correa
practices is that the full extent of water
scarcity is not acknowledged, let alone Situated at the edge of a carbonate cliff
fully known, and a long-term management dividing the windsurfer destination of Al­-
plan for the province’s water resources has merimar from the greenhouse-engulfed
yet to be completed.24 Although there have town of El Ejido, a tiny shrine sits behind
been several efforts to engage stakeholders a pile of two-litre plastic bottles filled with
and the local community through educa- water. It is the lone human construction in
tional publications and GIS-enabled on­line a land­scape of tough native plants capable
mapping and documentation initiatives, of sur­viving, without human intervention,
budget cuts associated with Spanish aus- the harshest of conditions. A sign, now
terity measures have slashed the funding knocked to the ground, provides the shrine’s
for these pedagogical projects.25 dedication: “Gracias Difunta Correa.” Pat-
When viewed on a global scale, cover- ron saint of farmers, travellers, and the
ing the ground with plastic and drawing desert, the historical figure of Difunta Cor-
water from the sea could be seen as “pro- rea is reputed to have followed her abduct=
gressive” moves because these practices ed husband into the deserts of Argentina
reduce the heat island effect and the con- with her infant son. Although she was found
sumption of irreplaceable water resources dead by soldiers some time afterwards, her
from confined aquifers. Read more care- infant was still alive, sucking her still full
fully, however, “progress” is simply the act breast even after her torturous death in the
of exchanging one finite resource for an- desert sun. There can be no better pa­tron
other; even if the Mediterranean is rarely of the desire that fuels Almería’s develop­
conceived as a finite natural resource, the ment, and series of superlatives that ac-

fig. 10

fig. 11
energy required to desalinate its water company its growth than, Difunta Correa,
must inevitably be understood as a operat- especially considering the offerings she

368 Excess 369 ...Report on Almería’s Miracle...


Figures Endnotes substrates such as bags of perlite or planters of shred­- 20 Elena López-Gunn, Marta Rica and Nora van Cau-
ded coconut fiber (commonly sourced from India) in wenbergh, “Taming the Groundwater Chaos,” in
1 “Taster” tomatoes at Clisol’s show greenhouse. Special thanks to Balbino Fernández Revuelta, Issac order to reduce soil-borne diseases. Water, Agriculture and the Environment in Spain:
2 1.5ha plots, each with a balsa to store pumped Frances Herrera, Lola Gómez Ferron and Jesus Contre­ 11 Antonio Pulido-Bosch et al., “Identification of Poten- Can We Square the Circle? ed. Lucia De Stefano
groundwater. Image: Jesus Contraras ras for their hospitality and generous conversations tial Subsidence Related to Pumping in the Almería and Manuel Ramón Llamas  (Leiden: CRC Press/
3 A parral-type greenhouse growing melon in spring. during my stay in Almería. Basin (SE Spain),” Hydrological Processes 26, no. 5 Balkema, 2012), 237.
4 Campo de Dalias and El Eijido (2012): 739. 21 Although increasingly supplied by renewable re-
5 Drip irrigation system at Clisol 1 Historian of science Paul Edwards describes “techno­ 12 A . Vallejos et al., “The Intensive Exploitation of Aqui­ sources such as wind or solar power (e.g. as pro-
6,7 Anthropogenic Norias lagoon. politics” in the following terms: “Engaging in techno­- fers and Its Implications for Sustainable Water Mana­- moted by ACCONIA, the supplier to Acuamed, who
Image: Jesus Contraras politics means designing or using technology strate­ gement in a Semi-Arid Zone,” Groundwater Inter- runs the desalination plant at Carboneras [Acconia,
8 Worker housing. Image: Jesus Contraras gically to achieve politic ends. Symmetrically, it also national IAHR Symposium: Flow And Transport In “ACCIONA Will Supply Electricity to Acuamed for
9 Carboneras desalination plant. means using political power strategically to achieve Heterogeneous Subsurface Formations: Theory the Third Year Running,” ACCONIA Press Release,
Image: Jesus Contraras technical or scientific aims.” See Paul Edwards, A Modeling And Applications  (Istanbul: Bogaziçi 19 June 2013, http://www.acciona.com/news/
10, Shrine to Difunta Correa Vast Machine: Computer Models, Climate Data, and Universitesi, 2008), 661, http://nevada.ual.es/
­
acciona-will-supply-electricity-to-acuamed-for-
11
the Politics of Global Warming (Cambridge and Lon- proyectoexcelencia/docs/23.pdf. the-third-year-running]), energy requirements for
don: MIT Press, 2010), 215. 13 In March 2013, one of 1,000 remaining sperm whales seawater desalination range from 12,000–18,000
2 José A. Aznar-Sánchez and Emilio ­Galdeano­- ­­Gómez, in the Mediterranean was found washed up on a beach kWh per million gallons. See Heather Cooley and
“Territory, Cluster and Competitiveness of the Inten- on the southern coast of Spain with 17kg of plastic Matthew Heberger, Key Issues for Seawater Desali-
­sive Horticulture in Almería (Spain),” The Open Geo- waste clogging its stomach, the majority polyester nation in California Energy and Greenhouse Gas
graphy Journal 4 (2011): 103–114. sheeting, speculated by scientists to have origin­ Emissions (Oakland: Pacific Institute, 2013), 8,
3 Ibid, 103. ated from the “plastic sea” in Almería. Giles Trem- http://www.pacinst.org/reports/desalination_
4 Robert Tyrell, El Milagro de Almería, España: lett, “Spanish Sperm Whale Death Linked to UK 2013/energy/energy_full_report.pdf.
A Poli­tical Ecology of Landscape Change and Green- Supermarket Supplier’s Plastic,” The Guardian, 22 Lola Gómez Ferrón (founder of Agro Clisol) in
house Agriculture (2008, unpublished thesis), 39. 8 March 2013, http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/ ­discussion with the author, March 2013.
5 Junta de Andalucía, Consejería de agricultura y 2013/mar/08/spain-sperm-whale-death-swallowed- 23 Pablo Campra, Monica Garcia, Yolanda Canton and
pesca memoria anual: 2009 (Sevilla: Servicio de plastic. Alicia Palacios-Orueta, “Surface Temperature Cool-
Publicaciones y Divulgación, 2012), 12. 14 Luis Molina-Sánchez et al., “Agricultural Waste ing Trends and Negative Radiative Forcing Due to
6 Aznar-Sánchez and Galdeano-Gómez, “Territory, Management and Groundwater Protection,” (paper Land Use Change toward Greenhouse Farming in
Cluster and Competitiveness,” 110. presented at the 38th IAH Congress, Groundwater Southeastern Spain,” Journal of Geophysical Re-
7 Although there is no official census of migrant work- Quality Sustainability Conference, Krakow, Poland, search: Atmospheres 113 (2008).
ers, this number is an estimate based on ­c alculating 12–17 September 2010). 24 See N. Font and J. Subirats, “Water Management in
that 40,000 greenhouses need 2–3 outside labour- 15 Nicolas Castilla and Hernadez Jaquan, “The Plastic Spain: The Role of Policy Entrepreneurs in Shaping
ers each. The portion of this number made up by legal Greenhouse Industry of Spain,” Chronica Horticul- Change,” Ecology and Society  15, no. 2 (2010):
immigrants is estimated to be betwen 10,000 and ture 45, no. 3 (2005): 18. 25, http://www.ecologyandsociety.org/vol15/
40,000 of the total. See George Prior, “The Green- 16 Estimate calculated from Quinn, “Almería Exceeds iss2/art25 for an account of the history of water
house Effect in Andalucia,” SUR in E ­ nglish, http:// Population,” 2011, and Felicity Lawrence, “Spain’s ­policy development in Spain, and López-Gunn et al.,
www.surinenglish.com/20110609/news/andalu- Salad Growers Are Modern-Day Slaves, Say Chari- “­Taming the Groundwater Chaos,” for a discussion
cia/greenhouse-effect-almeria-20110609 ties,” The Guardian, 7 February 2011, http://www. specifically about the status and management of
1703.html. guardian.co.uk/business/2011/feb/07/spain-salad- the aquifers in Almería.
8 Almería’s population has increased from 405,000 in growers-slaves-charities. 25 T he Universidad de Almería’s Centro Andaluz para
1981 to 704,000 in 2012, 155,000 of which are prim­ 17 See Ibid., and the Belgian documentary El Ejido, la la Evaluación y Seguimiento del Cambio Global 
arily immigrants from northern and sub-Saharan loi du profit, directed by Jawad Rhalib (France: Arte, (Andalusian Centre for Assessment and Monitoring
Africa. The exponential growth is relatively recent: 2006), for recent accounts of the working conditions of Global Change), directed by Hermelindo Castro
close to 200,000 people were added in just the last of migrants in Almería. Nogueira, is still in existence, but significant projects
10 years. By contrast. Spain’s population as a whole 18 A . J. Callejón-Ferre and J. A. López-Martínez, “Bri- including community engagement and outreach act­
only increased 25 per cent, from 37,741,000 in 1981 quettes of Plant Remains from the Greenhouses of ivities (such as CAMP, see http://camplevantedeal-
to 47,190,000 in 2011. See Instituto Nacional de Almería (Spain),” Spanish Journal of Agricultural meria.com/en/content/camp-levante-de-almeria)
Estadistica (Spanish Office of Statistics), http:// Research 7, no. 3 (2009): 525–534. have been put on hold over the last three years due
www.ine.es/en/inebmenu/mnu_cifraspob_en.htm, 19 Tyrell, El Milagro de Almería, 26. to budget cuts. See http://www.caescg.org for the
and Gemma Quinn, “Almeria Exceeds Population of Centre’s objectives and ongoing projects.
700,000 for First Time,” Leader.info, 10 April 2011,
http://www.theleader.info/362/article/28168/
almeria-exceeds-population-of-700000-for-first-
time.
9 Cynthia Giagnocavo, “The Almería Agricultural Co­-
operative Model: Creating Successful Economic
and Social Communities,” (paper presented at the
50th Session of the Commission for Social Develop-
ment, UNHQ, New York, NY, 1–10 February 2012), ii.
10 In the 1960s the industry began its transformation
through the adaptation of basic technological im­- Bio
provements. Existing grape trellises (parral) were
covered in newly available polyethylene sheeting Melissa Cate Christ OALA, CSLA, ASLA is an Assistant Professor of Landscape Archi-
in order to insulate the enarenado soil, a layering tecture at the University of Hong Kong and a founding principal of transverse ­s tudio.
technique first employed in the 1920s. Still in use by A registered landscape architect, her design research and practice concentrates on
over 80 per cent of the region’s 1.5-hectare parcels, contemporary mechanisms of urban intervention at the juncture of landscape, culture,
the native soil is topped by a 15cm layer of clay, a urbanism, and infrastructure. Prior to teaching at HKU, Melissa was a designer and
5cm layer of compost and then a 10cm layer of sand. project manager at Gustafson Guthrie Nichol Ltd; an urban designer at DuToit Allsop
This technique reduces evaporation and salt uptake, Hillier; and an instructor and design critic at the University of Toronto and University of
as well as water loss through the rocky, nutrient-poor ­Washington. Melissa has a Master of Landscape Architecture from the University of
soils. The other 20 per cent of the greenhouses use Toronto and a Bachelor of Liberal Arts from St. John’s College. (transversestudio.com)

370 Scapegoat 371 The Garden of the Sun: A...


View publication stats

Вам также может понравиться