Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
Many teachers throughout the world are, no doubt, familiar with the experience of
presenting dialogues to their students which have an air of artificiality about them.
The method of the investigation was about taking the transcripts from some
textbooks.
EX. In a hotel: Information giver: Start a discussion about the elevators and
excutive rooms versus standard rooms ensues, there are no rooms in the first
floor…
Information receiver: According to the options starts questioning for the options.
Carter (1998: 47) real life is not as simple and straightforward as textbooks often
suggest.
If the main aim of the text is to present new structural or functional language by
simplifying the texts, learners are encouraged to focus on the target language
presented , to “notice it”, and hopefully acquire the structures more quickly as a
result.
María Antonia
There is a danger in authentic text such as “Appendix 3 line 50, page 374”
Those factors will confuse students and obstruct acquisition of the target language.
Another reason for simplifying texts is to make listening comprehension activities
easier. If a conversation runs along predictable lines, learners are aware of what
might be said next.
The higher lexical density found in the coursebook data is more consistent with
written text than the spoken text.
Another possible explanation for the difference in lexical density may be that
textbooks writers use more explicit language that is normal in natural speech;
reading a concrete noun, for example, rather than using a pronoun (a noun would
be recorded as a lexical word whereas and a pronoun would be recorded as a
grammatical word).
If this were the explanation, then perhaps the textbook dialogues would be easier
to comprehend, but we would be depriving learners of an opportunity to develop
their listening skills in term of identifying the reference of pronouns.
Terminal overlap and latching: it occurs when to interlocutors try to speak at the
same time while latching refers to a point in conversation when there is no pause
between turns, And even a slight overlap. Both are a natural feature of
conversation and demonstrate our sensitivity to transition relevance places
(T.R.P.s). As speakers we know when the other is about to finish to take the turn to
talk.
Hesitation devices: (erm, er) they are extremely frequent in natural spoken
discourse, this is done in order to formulate next utterance. They are important in
terms of production and in helping learners hold the floor while they struggle with
what to say next. Ex in Spanish: “Lo que pasa es que… este….”. if textbooks
dialogues included hesitation devices more often, it would be easier for learner to
get them quickly.
Back-channles: “Noises” which are not full words) (Carter and McCarthy 1997)
• Mm
• Uhum
• Yeah
• No Found in authentic data
• Right
• Oh
Conclusion: The fact that textbooks have not accurately reflected authentic
interactions in the past, is understandable when we bear in mind that materials
writers have traditionally tended to use dialogues as a medium to reinforce
particular grammar points or to present vocabulary and functional language.
They had also have structural/functional pedagogic aims, and it is these that they
focused on rather than any issues of authenticity.
Authenticity can only be achieved when there is agreement between the material
writer´s intention and the learners´ interpretation.
Authentic non-textbook materials will not necessarily be learner authentic and that
unauthentic textbook materials will not necessarily be learner unauthentic.
(Young 1980:224): From the learners´ point of view, authentic materials are
motivating, interesting, and useful with content that does not culture shock or
discomfort.
(Krashen 1982): when learners read an authentic text, their prior knowledge,
interest, and curiosity make it easier for them to engage with it.
Learner-authentic materials are mainly learner-centered and that they can serve
affectively to promote learners´ interest in language learning.
(Bacon and Finneman 1990): The majority of the student prefer non-textbook
materials to textbook materials.
(Thorp 1991 and Tudor 1993) teachers who are friendly, understanding, and
sensitive to learners´ needs, and who also have high cultural awareness, will be
more likely to create a good learning atmosphere, and to hold discussions with
learners on material content, teaching methodology, and evaluation.
Design Stages:
Task selection: students are not ready to struggle with long text so try to choose
article which are related to teenager´ problems so they can get involved by them.
They have to be interesting and useful materials, readable, accessible, to give
learners the change to practice what they would face in the future.
Task design:
• Role-play activity
• Report writing
• Project
• Short oral presentation
María Antonia