Вы находитесь на странице: 1из 8

Volume 4, Issue 12, December – 2019 International Journal of Innovative Science and Research Technology

ISSN No:-2456-2165

The Influence of Efficiency, Reliability, and


Responsiveness towards E-Customer
Satisfaction on Redkendi Application
Faishal Haq Junaidi Mudji Sabar
Master of Management, Mercu Buana University Lecturer of Postgraduate, Mercu Buana University
Jakarta, Indonesia Jakarta, Indonesia

Abstract:- This research aims to analyze and evaluate


the influence of efficiency, reliability, and
responsiveness on E-Satisfaction in users of application
redkendi. The population in this research is 33
companies that have made transactions through the
online platform of PT Redkendi Andalan Mitra with 99
respondents. The data analysis technique used is
multiple linear regression analysis using SPSS 25. The
results showed that all X variables (efficiency, reliability
and responsiveness partially had a positive and
significant effect on the Y variable (e-satisfaction) and
all X variables (efficiency, reliability, and
responsiveness) simultaneously have a positive and
significant effect on the variable y (e-satisfaction) The
results of this research could be considered by
companies to determine policies that can be taken to Fig 1:- Redkendi Active User Target Achievement
increase customer satisfaction. Source: Secondary Data (2019)
Keywords:- Efficiency, Reliability, Responsiveness, e- From Figure 1 shows that overall in the second quarter
Satisfaction. (Q2) active users of the RedKendi application can be said
to be far from the expected target despite an increase. There
I. INTRODUCTION was a gap of > 30% from the expected target in the second
quarter (Q2).
PT. Redkendi Andalan Mitra (Redkendi) is a B2B E-
Catering Marketplace, a company that aims to help catering
SMEs to gathering both catering and customers who need
catering services. Redkendi committed to always partnering
with catering companies that promote hygiene, quality
standards, timeliness, and training of waiter services so
could provide satisfaction to the customer. PT Redkendi
Andalan Mitra as the first B2B E-Catering market place in
Indonesia, has a caterer partner with a production capacity
of 60,000 servings per day. With its current production
capacity, PT Redkendi Andalan Mitra is the first B2B E-
Catering market place market leader in Indonesia.
However, in reality the company has a lot of challenges and
constraints faced problem to achieved the target portion of
the active portion of the Redkendi application and also
target achievement of using the Redkendi application. At
present the achievement of the Redkendi application can be
Fig 2:- Recapitulation of Target Achievement of Portions
said to be very far from what has been set by the company.
on Service
Following the recapitulation of Target Achievement set by
Source: Secondary Data (2019)
the company, namely Active Users and Portion on Service
in the Redkendi application.
From Figure 2 above it can be seen that the target
achievement of portions on service Redkendi partners has
decreased every month in the Second Quarter (Q2). In July
the real achievement was around 48% of the targeted
portion. and in August the real achievement was around

IJISRT19DEC628 www.ijisrt.com 1057


Volume 4, Issue 12, December – 2019 International Journal of Innovative Science and Research Technology
ISSN No:-2456-2165
30% of the target, so there was a decreased of around 18% Redkendi platform is very low and far from the the
from July while in September the real achievement was company expectation. To find out more about this
around 18% from the target where there was a decrease of satisfaction in conducting online transactions, as a first step
around 12% from August and around 30% from July. It can of this research, the researchers has to conduct a
be said that the actual amount of portions on service of preliminary research of the factors that allegedly influenced
Redkendi partners does not reach the target every month. the satisfaction of Redkendi application users, such as:
From the results of the company data in Q2 it shows that application systems, trust, vendor quality, social and
the company is facing problems in achieving the marketing cultural environment, efficiency, reliability, responsive,
targets. This is certainly not fits with the company's safety and quality. From all these factors the efficiency
marketing target to increase portions on service with Daily becomes the main factor that makes customers feeling not
active users. It could be concluded that there is a gap fully satisfied with theirs expectations in doing transactions
between the achievement of the application and the through platforms with a percentage of 80.6% then
achievement of the portion of the expected target. sequencely there has reliability (77.4%) and Responsive
with a percentage of 71%.
This phenomenon clearly shows that the customer
satisfaction whom conducted the transactions through the

Fig 3:- The Factors that Influence user Satisfaction Redkendi Application
Source: Pre-survey Results (2019)

The results obtained in pre-survey show the three the site, the better performance of a website in providing
main variables selected by the customer which are the main the data, the more often customer would use the online site.
factors that influence customer satisfaction in any kind of
transactions using the Redkendi application. So the B. Reliability
researchers conducted a research entitled to "The Influence Zeithaml (2002) stated that Reliability technically has
of Efficiency, Reliability, and Responsiveness Towards E- influences to the functions of an application or website
Customer Satisfaction on Redkendi Application". where it can be function as it should consistently and
reliably. According to Tjiptono and Chandra (2016: 137)
II. THEORITICAL REVIEW Reliability relates to the ability to provide an accurate
services from the first time without giving any errors and
A. Efficiency delivering services according to the agreed time.
Zeithaml (2002) states that efficiency is the ability of Furthermore Tjiptono and Chandra (2016: 178) state that
customers to be able to access a website and can easily find Reliability relates to the technical functionalist of the site,
the desired product and able to log in or log out very easily especially the extent to which the site is available and
without requiring a lot of effort. Parasuraman, et.al. (2005) functioning as it should without the constraints or attacks
conceptualized the service quality as an ESERVQUAL from a virus.
model that includes seven dimensions, one of which is
Efficiency which relates to how easily users find C. Responsiveness
information on a website without interaction with Zeithaml (2002) states that Responsiveness is the
customers, online customers need to find any information ability of a website or application to provide appropriate
about the product or service that they're looking for. In information exactly when there is a problem in its
addition beside those convenience factor, the speed factor is use. According to Tjiptono (2012: 174) Responsiveness is
also very influential to attracting customer interest in using the ability to help customers quickly to meet their needs.

IJISRT19DEC628 www.ijisrt.com 1058


Volume 4, Issue 12, December – 2019 International Journal of Innovative Science and Research Technology
ISSN No:-2456-2165
While Parasuraman and Barry (2005) state that (2006) states that "Customer Satisfaction is a person's
Responsiveness is a fast response and the ability to help if feeling of pleasure or disappointment resulting from
there are problems or questions. The responsiveness of an comparing a product's perceived performance (or outcome)
online site is needed to increase the number of users, in relation to his or her expectations". The quality of
several ways that can be maintained by providing an online electronic services / e-service is defined as "the extent to
customer service with an automated system without A which the website facilitates shopping, purchasing and
human assistance. A site is also expected to handle shipping of products and services effectively and
complaints quickly and appropriately so that users do not efficiently" (Bressolles & Durrieu, 2011, p.4). Anderson
have other reasons to access other sites and there would be and Srinivasan (2003) further state that e-satisfaction is
no similiar complaints that occur repeatedly in future described as gratification from customers that comes from
previous real buying experiences with certain electronic
D. E-Satisfaction trading companies (in Ting et al, 2016, p. 4). According to
According to Zeithaml (2002) identified seven Ranjbarian et al (2012, p. 1502-1504), there are 4 (four)
dimensions that make up the scale of "core online service" main dimensions that affect e-satisfaction: Convenience,
and scale of "recovery online service". The three main Merchandising, Site Design, and Security.
dimensions (efficiency, Reliability, and fulfillment) are the
core e-service quality scales used to measure customer E. Conceptual Framework
perceptions of the quality of services delivered by online From the explanation previously stated, Efficiency,
retailers. Meanwhile, the other 4 dimensions (privacy, Reliability, and Responsiveness to E-Satisfaction in theory
responsiveness, compensation, and contact) are the scale of and support of the results of previous research, the
e-service quality recovery. According to Kotler and Keller framework of thought in this research as it follows:

Fig 1:- Conceptual Framework


Source: Theoretical Review

F. Hypothesis H4: Efficiency, Reliability, Responsiveness simultaneously


Based on the research background, literature review influences E-Customer Satisfaction in the Redkendi
and the research framework that has been described above, Application
the research hypothesis is as follows:
H1: Efficiency affects E-Customer Satisfaction in the III. METHODOLOGY
Redkendi Application
H2: Reliability affects the E-Customer Satisfaction in the This research is a qualitative verification with a
Redkendi application survey explanatory research method conducted to examine
H3: Responsiveness influences E-Customer Satisfaction on a particular population or sample. Data obtained through
the Redkendi application questionnaire surveys and structured interviews. The
method of data analysis uses multiple linear regression
analysis with the help of SPSS version 25 to test

IJISRT19DEC628 www.ijisrt.com 1059


Volume 4, Issue 12, December – 2019 International Journal of Innovative Science and Research Technology
ISSN No:-2456-2165
hypotheses. The variables in this research are efficiency IV. RESULT AND DISCUSSION
(X1), reliability (X2), responsiveness (X3), and e-
satisfaction (Y). The population in this research is 33 A. Validity and Reliability Test
companies that have made transactions through the online The results of validity test for all items of the
platform PT Redkendi Andalan Mitra. The sample in this questionnaire statement on the variables efficiency (X1),
research amounted to 99 respondents from 33 companies reliability (X2), responsiveness (X3), and e-customer
that are currently actively using the Redkendi application. satisfaction (Y) have the value of r count > r table (0.198)
at the level of α = 0.05, so that it can be concluded that all
statement items are declared valid.

Num. rcount X1 rtable Info rcount X2 rtable Info rcount X3 rtable Info rcount Y rtable Info
1 .496** 0.198 Valid .765** 0.198 Valid .707** 0.198 Valid .592** 0.198 Valid
2 .506** 0.198 Valid .714** 0.198 Valid .755** 0.198 Valid .641** 0.198 Valid
3 .679** 0.198 Valid .780** 0.198 Valid .831** 0.198 Valid .568** 0.198 Valid
4 .656** 0.198 Valid .795** 0.198 Valid .832** 0.198 Valid .570** 0.198 Valid
5 .505** 0.198 Valid .759** 0.198 Valid .828** 0.198 Valid .556** 0.198 Valid
6 .636** 0.198 Valid
7 .425** 0.198 Valid
8 .357** 0.198 Valid
9 .346** 0.198 Valid
10 .447** 0.198 Valid
11 .423** 0.198 Valid
12 .370** 0.198 Valid
13 .499** 0.198 Valid
14 .411** 0.198 Valid
15 .361** 0.198 Valid
Table 1:- Validity Test
Source: Analysis Results Using SPSS version 25

Reliability test results of variable efficiency (X1), reliability (X2), responsiveness (X3), and e-customer satisfaction (Y) have
a Cronbach's Alpha value > the specified conditions are 0.6. Thus could be means that all variables in this research were declared
reliable.

Variable Cronbach's Alpha Term Info


Efficiency 0.714 > 0.6 Reliable
Reliability 0.797 > 0.6 Reliable
Responsiveness 0.803 > 0.6 Reliable
E-Customer Satisfaction 0.715 > 0.6 Reliable
Table 2:- Reliability Test
Source: Analysis Results Using SPSS version 25

B. Classic Assumption Test


The normality test results using the Kolmogorov-Smirnov Test, then get results obtained Sig of the four variables above
more than the value of α = 0.05, and the calculated KS value < KS value of the table (1.35 / √99 = 0.136). This can be concluded
that the data tested has a normal data distribution.

One-Sample Kolmogorov-Smirnov Test


Efficiency Reliability Responsiveness E-Customer Satisfaction
N 99 99 99 99
Normal Mean 3.368 3.218 3.335 3.599
Parametersa,b Std. Deviation 0.472 0.655 0.732 0.371
Test Statistic 0.089 0.084 0.081 0.065
c c
Asymp. Sig. (2-tailed) .051 .081 .108c .200c,d
Table 3:- Normality Test
Source: Analysis Results Using SPSS version 25

The multicollinearity test results showed that all VIF values of each variable had a value <10, so it can be concluded that the
tested data did not occur multicollinearity.

IJISRT19DEC628 www.ijisrt.com 1060


Volume 4, Issue 12, December – 2019 International Journal of Innovative Science and Research Technology
ISSN No:-2456-2165
Coefficientsa
Collinearity Statistics
Model
Tolerance VIF
(Constant)
Efficiency 0.785 1.274
Reliability 0.691 1.446
Responsiveness 0.677 1.476
Table 4:- Multicollinearity Test
Source: Analysis Results Using SPSS version 25

Heteroscedasticity test results using scatterplot diagrams show that the points spread up and down the number 0 on the Y
axis, and do not form certain patterns. So it could be concluded that the data tested are free from heteroscedasticity symptoms.

Fig 2:- Heteroscedasticity Test


Source: Analysis Results Using SPSS version 25

C. Hypothesis Test
The results of hypothesis test in this research used the t test, F test and the determination coefficient test. The results of
hypothesis test in this research can be seen in table 5 below.

Coefficientsa
Unstandardized Coefficients
Model B Std. Error t Sig.
(Constant) 1.271 0.121 10.469 0.000
Efficiency 0.302 0.038 7.906 0.000
Reliability 0.154 0.029 5.274 0.000
Responsiveness 0.244 0.026 9.240 0.000
F 149.169 .000b
Adjusted R2 Square 0.819
Table 5: - Hypothesis Test
Source: Analysis Results Using SPSS version 25

From Table 5 above, it can be seen that all t count values of the independent variables has t count values > t table (1.98) and
Sig. = 0,000, so it could be concluded that H1, H2, and H3 in this research were accepted and tested. The regression equation is

Y = 1,271 + 0,302 X1 + 0,154 X2 + 0,244 X3 + e

In F test shows that the calculated F value > F table (2.7) with an Adjusted R2 Square value of 0.819, thus the H4 in this
research was tested, therefore the Efficiency variable (X1), Reliability variable (X2), and the Responsiveness variable (X3) ) has
simultaneously significant effect on the variable E-Customer Satisfaction (Y) of 81.9%.

IJISRT19DEC628 www.ijisrt.com 1061


Volume 4, Issue 12, December – 2019 International Journal of Innovative Science and Research Technology
ISSN No:-2456-2165
D. Correlation between Dimensions
The level of relationship between variables in this research can be seen as in Table 6 below.

Correlations
E-Satisfaction (Y)
Variable Dimension Y.1 Y.2 Sales Y.3 Site Y.4
Convenience Promotions Design Security
X1.1 Easy use .522** .420** .377** .401**
Efficiency (X1) ** **
X1.2 Fastest use .515 .259 .331** .412**
** **
X2.1 Accurate .621 .350 .475** .490**
Reliability (X2) ** **
X2.2 Minimum Error/Zero Mistake .522 .312 .443** .307**
** **
X3.1 Auto Reply System .707 .479 .514** .559**
Responsiveness (X3)
X3.2 Quick Response Facility .654 **
.469 **
.426** .552**
Table 6:- Correlation between Dimensions
Source: Analysis Results Using SPSS version 25

Based on Table 6 above, it is known that the greatest Based on Table 7 above, the results can be obtained
correlation value between the dimensions in the Efficiency that the varable dimension (X3), which is the auto reply
(X1) variable and the E-Satisfaction (Y) variable is the system has the highest score when compared to the other
X1.1 Easily use with the Y.1 Convenience dimension, variable dimension (X1), ease and variable dimensions
0.522, and included in the level category moderate (X2) accuracy. This shows that the auto reply system can
influence. This explains that the dimension X1.1 Easily be used as the main development priority in the application
Use in the Efficiency variable is required for every increase or the Redkendi website.
in E-Satisfaction (Y) especially in the Y.1 Convenience
dimension. F. Discussion
Hypothesis results show that H1 is accepted and
Based on Table 6 above, it is known that the greatest concluded that Efficiency has a positive and significant
correlation value between the dimensions in Reliability effect on E-Satisfaction, meaning that the better Efficiency
(X2) variable and the E-Satisfaction (Y) variable is the in redkendi applications will increase the E-Satisfaction
X2.1 Accurate dimension with Y.1 convinience dimension customers of PT Redkendi Andalan Mitra. This shows that
namely 0.621 and could be said the strong one. This the ease and speed of the redkendi application will increase
explains that the accurate dimension X2.1 in the Reliability online customer satisfaction. From the results of the
variable is indispensable for any increase in E-Satisfaction correlation between dimensions obtained the highest value
(Y) especially in the Y.1 dimension of Convenience. of the most dominant is the user convenience
dimension. Eating catering easily in the application,
Based on Table 6 above it is known that the greatest finding a suitable food menu and the availability of
correlation value between the dimensions in complaint assistance is the main focus in creating
Responsiveness (X3) variable against the E-Satisfaction convenience for customers in using the Redkendi
(Y) variable is the X3.1 Autoreply System dimension with application so as to increase customer satisfaction. This
the Y.1 Convenience dimension which is 0.707, and result is in line with previous research conducted by Sepni
belongs to the level strong influence catagory. This Lorena (2018) which states that the quality of e-service
explains that the dimension X X3.1 Autoreply System in quality, one of which is Efficiency influences online
the Efficiency variable is indispensable for any increase in consumer satisfaction.
E-Satisfaction (Y) especially in the Y.1 dimension of
Convenience. Hypothesis results show that H2 is accepted and
concluded that Reliability has a positive and significant
E. Priority Scale effect on E-Satisfaction, meaning that the better reliability
The results of the calculation of this priority scale will given to the customer, the higher E-Satisfaction of the
be very helpful in developing the Redkendi application customers PT Redkendi Andalan Mitra. From the results of
especially to increase customer satisfaction. Calculation of correlation between dimensions has obtained the highest
the priority scale dimension of variable X as it follows: value and the most dominant is the accurate dimension. The
accuracy of the available information on the RedKendi
Correlation coefficient application is the main focus in efforts to increase customer
Dimensions Score satisfaction. With adding any information about the
x Regression coefficient
Easy use 0.522 x 0.302 0.157 nutritional value of food accurately will makes customers
Accurate 0.621 x 0.154 0.095 easily know the intake of food obtained and also has a
Auto Reply System 0.707 x 0.244 0.172 positive impact on the performance of employees in
Table 7: Priority Scale Calculation companies that are predominantly factory
Source: Analysis Results Using SPSS version 25 workers. Accurate information on applications must be
maintained even better so that online customer satisfaction

IJISRT19DEC628 www.ijisrt.com 1062


Volume 4, Issue 12, December – 2019 International Journal of Innovative Science and Research Technology
ISSN No:-2456-2165
can be increased. The results of this research had support V. CONCLUSIONS AND SUGGESTIONS
previous research conducted by Riand et al (2016) which
proves that Reliability influences e-satisfaction. This result A. Conclusions
is also in line with the most recent research conducted by Based on the results of the analysis and discussion
Faruq Ulum and Rinaldi Muchtar (2018) which states that which described in the previous chapter, then following
there is a positive influence of Reliability on e-customer conclusions can be drawn:
satisfaction.  Efficiency has a positive and significant effect on E-
Customer Satisfaction at PT. Redkendi Andalan Mitra.
Hypothesis results show that H3 is accepted and This means that the better Efficiency owned by the
concluded that Responsiveness has a positive and Redkendi application platform, it will increase the
significant effect on E-Satisfaction, meaning that the better customer E-Satisfaction of PT. Redkendi Andalan
Responsiveness in the application will increase the E- Mitra. To increase customer satisfaction using the
Satisfaction customers of PT Redkendi Andalan Mitra. application can built by increasing performance
From the results of correlation between dimensions application quickly and easily.
obtained the highest value of the most dominant is  Reliability has a positive and significant effect on E-
Autoreply system dimension. Responsiveness or fast Satisfaction customers of PT. Redkendi Andalan Mitra.
response to the application is the main focus that needs to This can be means that the better reliability given to the
be maintained or even improved. The existence of a 24- customer, the higher E-Satisfaction to PT.Redkendi
hour online custumer service is very helpful to meet Andalan Mitra.To increase customer satisfaction in
customer needs in redkendi application. Food services using applications can be realized by increasing the
carried out by catering in the company can run 24 hours accuracy of the application and could carry out of its
with work system of employees per shift, thus catering functions without errors or minimal errors.
services must be in accordance with the order on the  Responsiveness has a positive and significant effect on
redkendi application. The existence of standby customer E-Satisfaction customers of PT. Redkendi Andalan
service in the RedKendi application can help the work of Mitra. It means that the better Responsiveness, it will
the customers so that increasing responsiveness in this increase the E-Satisfaction of PT. Redkendi Andalan
application will increase customer e-satisfaction. The Mitra. To increase customer satisfaction in using the
results of this research has support previous research application could be achieved by maximizing the use of
conducted by Puspa Chairunnisa Chesanti and Retno auto reply and quick response facilities that could help
Setyorini (2016) which proves that e-service quality is one customers to respond to orders or handling complaints
of the Responsiveness dimension which has a significant that occur quickly.
effect on online customer satisfaction.  Efficiency, Reliability and Responsiveness
simultaneously have a significant effect on E-
Hypothesis results show that H4 is accepted and Satisfaction PT. Redkendi Andalan Mitra. This means
concluded that Efficiency, Reliability, and Responsiveness that the better Efficiency, Reliability and
have a significant effect together on E-Satisfaction, Responsiveness, it will increase the E-Satisfaction of
meaning that the better Efficiency, Reliability, and PT. Redkendi Andalan Mitra.
Responsiveness will increase E-Satisfaction customers of
PT Redkendi Andalan Mitra. Easily use of the application B. Suggestions
is very helpful in process of running the steps in the Based on the results of research and discussion also
application. Menu information and nutritional values listed conclusions that have been described above, the researchers
in the application are important in supporting the put forward some suggestions that can be used as an advice
implementation of food in the company's canteen so that as follows:
the accuracy of the information presented in the application  Correlation between dimensions test results show that
must be appropriate and constantly updated. In addition, the dimensions of user convenience on the efficiency
fast responsiveness with the implementation of an variable has the highest correlation to the convenience
automated customer service system that functions for 24 dimension on the e-satisfaction variable, it can be
hours will become the main focus in increasing customer improved through application development to facilitate
satisfaction. So that the application development features customers, such as: catering features search take
ease, accuracy and fast response will increase e-satisfaction precedence spot in applications, food menus are
in the Redkendi application. The results of this research are summarized, methods payment and complaint
in line with previous research conducted by Shinta assistance is provided.
Sekaring Wijiutami and Damayanti Octavia (2017) which  Correlation between dimensions test results show that
states that there is a direct influence between electronic the accurate dimensions of the user on the reliability
service quality variables on electronic satisfaction with variable has the highest correlation with the
Efficiency, Reliability and Responsiveness variables. convenience dimension on the e-satisfaction variable it
could be develop by increasing the actual information
such as nutritional intake value of food in a profesional
way by weighing the food and used as a standard. A
special team is needed to provide the actual calculate
of nutritional content in food.

IJISRT19DEC628 www.ijisrt.com 1063


Volume 4, Issue 12, December – 2019 International Journal of Innovative Science and Research Technology
ISSN No:-2456-2165
 Correlation between dimensions test results show that Malaysia. IOP Cof. Series: Materials Science and
the dimensions of the user autoreply system on Engineering.
responsiveness variables have the highest correlation to [11]. Tjiptono, Fandy dan Gregorius Chandra. (2016).
the convenience dimension on e-satisfaction variables, Service, Quality & satisfaction. Yogyakarta. Andi.
it can be improved through the development of a feature [12]. Tjiptono, Fandy dan Gregorius Chandra. (2012).
in Redkendi applications such as customer service auto Service, Quality Satisfaction. Jogjakarta: Andi Offset.
reply feature that could be handling all kinds of [13]. Ulum, Faruq dan Rinaldi Muchtar. (2018). “Pengaruh
complaints from customers in the application quickly, E-Service Quality terhadap E-Customer Satisfaction
precisely and automatically 24 hours without any Website Start-Up Kaosyay”. Vol. 12, No. 2, 2018
manpower handling or standby within 24 hours. ISSN 1412-9663.
 To support the improvement of this knowledge also to [14]. Wijiutami, Shinta Sekaring dan Damayanti Octavia.
improving this research, it is recommended for the (2017). “Pengaruh E-Service Quality terhadap E-
next researchers to conduct this research with other Satisfaction serta dampaknya pada E-Loyalty
variables such as vendor catering quality and safety or pelanggan E-Commerce C2C Di Kota Jakarta dan
security to obtain better research results. Future research Bandung”. E-Proceding of Management: Vo.4, No.3,
could use the additional Y variables, namely Customer pp 2212.
Loyalty so that research will be better with an increased [15]. Zeithaml V. (2002). Service Excellence in Electronic
level of E-Satisfaction. Channels, Managing Service Quality, 12, 3, 135-139.

REFERENCES

[1]. Anderson, R. E., dan Srinivasan, S. S. (2003). E-


Satisfaction and E-Loyalty: A Contingency
Framework. Psychology & Marketing, Vol. 20, No. 2,
123-137.
[2]. Bressolles, Gregory and Durrieu Francois. (2011).
Service Quality, Customer Value and Satisfaction
Relationship Revisited for Online Wine Websites.
AWBR International Conference 9 – 10 June 2011.
Bordeaux Management School – BEM – France.
[3]. Chesanti, Puspa Chairunnisa, dan Retno Setyorini.
(2016). “Pengaruh E-Service Quality Terhadap
Kepuasan Pelanggan sebagai Pengguna Aplikasi PLN
Mobile”. Jurnal Penelitian Pendidikan, ISSN: 1412-
565X.
[4]. Kotler, Philip dan Kevin L. Keller. (2006).
Manajemen Pemasaran edisi ke 12 Jilid ke 1. New
Jersey, Indeks.
[5]. Lorena, Sepni (2018). “Pengaruh E-ServICE Quality
terhadap E-Satisfaction yang berdampak pada E-
Loyality”. Digital Repository Unila. Fakultas
Ekonomi dan Bisnis. Universitas Lampung.
[6]. Parasuraman, dkk. (2005). E-S-QUAL A MultipleItem
Scale for Assessing Electronic Service Quality.
Volume 7, No. X. Hal 1- 21.
[7]. Parasuraman and L. Berry. (2005). Delivering Quality
Service: balancing customer perceptuons and
expectations, The Free Press, New York.
[8]. Ranjbarian, Bahram et al. (2012). An Analysis Of
Brand Image, Perceived Quality, Customer
Satisfaction and Re-Purchase Intention in Iranian
Department Stores. Journal of Business and
Management Vol. 7, No. 6; March 2012 ISSN 1833-
3850 E-ISSN 1833-8119.
[9]. Riand et al. (2016). “Pengaruh E-Service Quality
Aplikasi Garuda Indonesia Terhadap Customer
Satisfaction Garuda Indonesia”. Vol.3, No.3
December 2016 ISSN 2355-9375.
[10]. Ting. O.S, et.al. (2016). E-Service Quality, E-
Satisfaction and E-Loyalty of Online Shoppers in
Business to Consumer Market; Evidence form

IJISRT19DEC628 www.ijisrt.com 1064

Вам также может понравиться