Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
A B S T R A C T R I~ S U M I~
Milled bituminous concrete and crushed limestone On a m~lang~ en laboratoire du b&on bitumineux et des
aggregates were combined in the laboratory in various granulats calcaires concasse's, dans des proportions vari&s,
proportions to simulate some of the combinations of afin de simuler quelques unes des combinaisons de mat&iaux
materials that can be obtained when the method of mix- qubn pent obtenir en utilisant la re&bode de recyclage sur
in-place recycling with cement is used. The influence of place par malaxage avec du ciment. O n a examin8
the milled bituminous concrete content of the various l'influence de la teneur en b~ton bitumineux broy~ des diff,-
mixes is examined in terms of compressive strength rents m~langes vis-a-vis de la re'sistance a la compression
(equivalent cubes, uniaxial prism strength), tensile (cubes 8quivalents, r&istance uniaxiale du prisme), la r&t's-
strength (flexural and cylinder splitting strength) and tance a la traction (r&istance en flexion et r&istance au fen-
modulus of elasticity (quasi-static, electrodynamic reso- dage du cyh'ndre) et le module dlasticit~ (quasi statique, r&o-
nance). The effect of these mechanical properties on the nance 8lectro-dynamique). On discute l'effet de ces propriSt&
traffic and temperature induced stresses as well as on the me'caniques sur les contraintes g~n&e'es par le trafic et la tem-
crack susceptibility of these materials is discussed. It is p&ature, et sur la fissurabilit~ de ces mat&iaux. On conclut
concluded that the incorporation of milled bituminous que l'addition de b~ton bitumineux broy~ a des mat&iaux
concrete in cement-stabilised granular materials imparts granulaires stabilis& par le ciment communique des propri~t&
interesting properties in these materials, yet further int&essantes aces mat&iaux mais que, toutefois, une
research is needed, including fatigue tests as well as ten- recherche ult&ieure dolt &re conduite, comprenant des essais
sile strength and modulus of elasticity determinations at de fatigue et la d&ermination de la r&istance a la traction et
~l , , ! .1
early ages (1-2 days). du module d elastlate aux jeunes ages (1-2 jours).
7Z1711
Editorial note
Dr. Stelios Kolias is a R I L E M Senior Member. He is the R I L E M Delegate in Greece.
412
Kolias
5.03 5.97 6.07 5.11 7.17 1.87 0.43 0.71 7.33 6.40 15.55 16.77
MBC 100% n 3 3 3 2 3 3 2 3 3 3 6 3
CLA0% c.v.% 3.3 7.8 2.5 4.9 9.4 9.1l 7.9 1.6 4.9 5.5
III 8.40 10.74 7.16 8.10 1.67 0.56 0.87 14.00 12.55 2 0 . 3 0 19.90
MBC 50% n 3 3 3 2 1 3 3 2 2 1 2
CLA50% c.v.% 1.4 2.5 10.3 5.4 5.4
v :~ 15.96 1 9 . 5 6 18.52 13.43 19.44 3.21 0.75 1.32 1.77 32.17 3 6 . 5 3 41.38 44.37
MBC 0% n 3 3 3 2 3 3; 3 3 3 3 3 6 3
CLA 100% c.v.% 3.5 3.4 5.0 8.2 5.1 0.8 10.2 13.8 7.9 6.4 3.1 2.9
1 MPa/s and 0.2 MPa/s, respectively. Finally, a loading up content of 25%. Similarly, the influence of MBC con-
to failure was carried out at a stressing rate of 0.2 MPa/s. tent on the modulus of elasticity is shown in Figs. 3 and
All tests were carried out at 20 ___1 ~ except the 1-year 4 for the static (secant modulus at 30% of the failure
dynamic modulus determinations which were also carried load) and the dynamic (resonance) values, respectively.
out at 0.5, 15 and 29 ~ In addition, a number of speci- In this case too, the modulus values decrease as the
mens, which were not tested up to failure, were subjected MBC content increases, with the maximum drop of the
to ramp and sinusoidal loading tests at an age of 2 years modulus value taking place between MBC contents of
[12]. For these tests, a servo-hydraulic testing machine 0% and 25%. The decrease of the strength and the mod-
was used. In this paper, the results of the tests at 20 ~ and ulus of elasticity could be attributed to the fact that the
at a stressing rate of 0.2 MPa/s will be presented. mixes I to IV consist of: a) aggregates which are coated
A number of creep tests were also carried out involv- with bitumen and therefore exhibit lower adhesion
ing mixes with proportions (by mass) of 100% MBC properties with the cement paste allowing greater defor-
(mix I), 50% MBC (mix III) and 0% MBC (mix V). mation or slip, and b) agglomerations of fine grains
The load was raised up to approximately 30% of the fail- bonded together with bitumen which form a kind of
ure load, and it was kept constant for 1 hour while "aggregate" in the mix with low modulus and strength.
strains were measured at regular time intervals. As the content of this type of aggregates in the mix
increases, the strength and modulus values decrease. The
maximum percentage of decrease takes place at relatively
6. PRESENTATION AND DISCUSSION low contents of MBC. It is also noted that while the 1-
OF THE RESULTS year strength values are slightly greater than the 28-day
values for all mixes, the 1-year modulus of elasticity val-
Table 2 summarises all the test results. The values of ues seem practically the same as the 28-day values for
the coefficient of variation are also given as an indication MBC contents higher than about 50%.
of the variability encountered, although the number of It can be seen from Table 2 that as the content of
results for each case is limited in many instances. MBC in the mix is increased, the ratio of the modulus of
The influence of the milled bituminous concrete elasticity (dynamic or static) to flexural (ff) or split-cylin-
(MBC) content on the compressive strength (uniaxial der (fsp) tensile strength is also increased. Since the traf-
prism strength and equivalent cube strength) and on the fic-induced stresses are significantly influenced by the
tensile strength (cylinder splitting and flexural) is shown value of the modulus of elasticity, the ratio of the modu-
in Figs. 1 and 2, respectively. It can be seen that the lus of elasticity to the flexural strength is, as an initial
strength is decreasing as the MBC content is increasing, approximation, related to the ratio of applied stress to
with the maximum decrease taking place for an MBC strength, which is a major factor determining the fatigue
413
25 3.5
I
(2a)
20
3.0
\
\ (la)
~ 2.5 \
f
1 Year
15
\ ~ 2.0 =
\
\ ,,a., 1 Year "~ 1.5
10
rn
~ 1.0
28 Days
0.5
0.0
,], ,
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100
MBC % by mass MBC% by mass
(2b)
C1b.
\. F
/
28 Days
1 Year
I
,~-- 28 Days . . . . .
/
I t
7 Days
i
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100
MBC % by mass MBC % by mass
Fig. 1 - The influence of milled bituminous concrete content Fig. 2 - The influence of milled bituminous concrete content
(MBC) on the prism (la) and on the cube (lb) compressive (MBC) on the flexural (2a) and on the cylinder splitting (2b)
strengths. strengths.
5O
!\
~, 45
~4o
1 Year
35 /
t
30
1 Year o 25 I1,%
./
28 Days
I
f
-tl
28 Days
~s
0 10 20 30 40
i
50 60 70
[]
80 90 100
0 1 ,
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100
MBC % by mass MBC % by mass
Fig. 3 - The influence of MBC content on the static modulus of Fig. 4 - The influence of MBC content on the dynamic
elasticity. resonance modulus of elasticity.
414
Kolias
0.9 1200
1100
0.8 I ( I i / I
0.7 I 28 Days 1000
900
_ ~
0.6 8O0
700 I ,b -/ : I !
0.5
i~ = 600
/I ! I li
0.4
.~ 500
/i I P ."'l t i i(
LU
0.3 1 Year 400
300
0.2
200
"Ii I
/
_ _ . _
v:i i iL : -
0.1
100
r i i i [ i j,i i i i
.... 1......... [ . . . . [ . . . . ~. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . , ........ , .....
0
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100 0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 45 50 55 60
MBC% by mass Loading time [rain]
Fig. 6 - The influence of MBC content on the ratio of static to Fig. 7 - 1-hour creep tests. Sustained load 30 % of the ultimate
dynamic modulus of elasticity. load. I / III / V : MBC content 100 / 50 / 0 % by mass,
respectively.
415
Materials and Structures/Mat6riaux et Constructions, Vol. 29, August/September 1996
416
Kolias
10. REFERENCES [9] Kolias, S., and Vagdadis, V., 'Recycling with cement of failed
bituminous pavement', 11th Greek Conference on Concrete,
Coffu, Greece, (in Greek.) (1994).
[1] Alcoke, W.H., Robbins, E.G. and Taylor, J.E., 'Cold recycling of [10] Fossberg, P.E., Mitchell, J.K., and Monismith, C.L., 'Load
failed flexible pavements with cement', TRB Record 734 (1979). deformation characteristics of a pavement with cement-stabilised
[2] Kennedy, J., and Clark, A., 'Reconstruction trial for East Sussex base and asphalt surfacing', Proc. of the 3rd Int. Conf. on the
County Council of mix-in-place recycling with cement and Structural Design of Asphalt Pavements, Vol. 1, London (1994).
glassfibre-reinforced surface dressing', Cement and Concrete [11] Kolias, S. and Williams, R.I.T., 'Cement-bound Road
Association, Technical Report No 556, (March 1986). Materials: Strength and Elastic Properties Measured in the
[3] Leykauf, G. and Moss, T., 'Laborversuche mit hydraulisch gebun- Laboratory', TRRL Supplementary Report 344, Transport and
denem Asphaltgranulat und Auswirkung auf die Bemessung', Road Research Laboratory, Crowthorn, UK (1978).
Strasse und Autobahn, Heft 11 (1987). [12] Kolias, S., 'The influence of type of loading and temperature on
[4] Baroux, R.., Morel, G. and Valeux, J.C., 'Retraitement au ciment the modulus of elasticity of cement-bound mixes of milled bitu-
d'anciennes chauss&s. Etude de l'atelier de reconditionnement minous concrete and crushed aggregates' (paper in preparation).
de chauss&s ARC 600', Revue G~n&al des Routes et des [13] Williams, R.I.T. and Patankar, V.D., 'The effect of cement type,
A&odromes, 651, (Avril 1988). aggregate type and mix water content on the properties of lean
[5] Prat, A., Abelle, J.p., Benabe, J.P. and Sianton, J.P., concrete mixes', Roads and Road Construction, 46 (542) and 46
'Retraitement au ciment de la RN 124 dans le Gers', Revue (543) (1968).
Gdndral des Routes et des A&odromes, 633, (Mai 1989). [14] Schmidt, M., 'Stoffliche und konstructive Eigenschaften
[6] Meunier,Y., 'In-situ road retread in France and overseas using the hydraulisch gebundener Tragschichten', Schriftenreihe der
ARC 700 process', Revue Gdndrale des Routes et des Zementindustrie, Heft 51, Verein Deutscher Zementwerke e.V.,
A&odromes, No 669 (1989). Dusseldorf, Germany (1991).
[7] Sainton, A., 'The road retreatment plant ARC 700', 6th [15] Williams, R.I.T., 'Cement-Treated Pavement', (Elsevier
Int.Symp.on Concrete Roads, Vol A II Madrid, (8-10 Oct Applied Science Publishers, London, 1986).
1990). [16] Patankar, V.D. and Williams, R,I.T., 'Bitumen in dry lean con-
[8] Kolias, S., Vassiliou, C. and Yotis, A., 'Pavement rehabilitation by crete', Highways & TrafficEngineering38 (1721) (Jan. 1970)
cold in-place recycling of bituminous mixes with cement',
Bulletin of the Public Works Research Center No 3-4, Jul-Dec.
1983, (in Greek).
:!!iiiiiijll
417