Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
by
Michael Costantino
MASTERS OF ARCHITECTURE
/ Date
K List of Illustrations 1
Abstract 7
Chapter 1
Introduction 9
n Chapter II
Thesis Statement 10
Architectural Epistemology 12
Case Studies
The Florida Aquarium 14
Ocean's Pavilion 19
Aquarium of the Pacific 24
Monterey Bay Aquarium 28
Context and Site 32
Client Profile 37
Chapter III
Facility Program 39
Site and Context 76
Architectural Technologies 82
Special Architectural Issues 84
Preliminary Cost Estimate 86
Chapter IV
Hypothesis 89
Chapter V
Design Process 94
Design Development 95
Preliminary Review 98
Qualifying Review 100
Final Design Response 103
Chapter VI
Conclusion 124
TABLE OF CONTENTS
List of Illustrations
Figure
1. Example of Goldfish from early breeding. (Algone. The History of the Aquarium. 2004. Internet on-line
http://www.alqone.com/aquarium history pf.htm [10 February 2004].
2. Example of Goldfish from early breeding. (Algone. The History of the Aquarium. 2004. Internet on-line
http://www.alqone.com/aquarium history pf.htm flO February 2004].
3. Drawing of Boston Aquarial Gardens. (The Aquarial Gardens, Bromfield Street, Boston. 2004. Internet on-line
http://www.butlerart.com/Web Shows/homer/Paqes/aquarial aardens.htm [10 February 2004].
4. The Florida Aquarium exterior at night. (Pearson, Clifford A. "Total Immersion." Architectural Record, June 1995,
page 80.)
5. Interior view showing fake trees covering duct work. {Architectural Record, June 1995, page 85.)
6. The Florida Aquarium exterior view. {Architectural Record, June 1995, page 81.)
7. Exterior Public Space. {Architectural Record, June 1995, page 82.)
8. The Florida Aquarium exterior at night. {Architectural Record, June 1995, page 81.)
9. Interior View of Lobby. {Architectural Record, June 1995, page 82.)
10. Floor Plans. {Architectural Record, June 1995, page 84.)
11. Interior wall of glass for tank. {Architectural Record, June 1995, page 83.)
12. Interior cave like exhibit hall. {Architectural Record, June 1995, page 85.)
13. Oceans Pavilion Exterior View. (The Sunday Times Syndication Website. Gabion: Chermayeff at Lisbon. 2003.
Internet on-line http://www.huqhpearman.com/articles/cwa20.htm [5 February 2004].
14. Oceans Pavilion Exterior View. (The Sunday Times Syndication Website. Gabion: Chermayeff at Lisbon. 2003.
Internet on-line http://www.huqhpearman.com/articles/cwa20.htm [5 February 2004].
LIST OF ILLUSTRATIONS
List of Illustrations
Figure
15. Oceans Pavilion Exterior View. (Lisbon Oceanarium. Oceans Pavilion. 2000. Internet on-line
http://lrm.isr.ist.utl.pt/isqm/albuns/expo98/pavoceanos en.html [5 February 2004].
16. Oceans Pavilion Exterior View. (Lisbon Oceanarium. Oceans Pavilion. 2000. Internet on-line
http://lrm.isr.ist.utl.pt/jsqm/albuns/expo98/pavoceanos en.html [5 February 2004].
17. Cross Sections showing clear spans. (Ivy, Robert. "Oceans Pavilion: Lisbon, Portuga\." Architectural Record,
August 1998, page 108.)
18. Cross Sections showing clear spans. {Architectural Record, August 1998, page 108.)
19. Oceans Pavilion, Site Plan. {Architectural Record, August 1998, page 106.)
20. Oceans Pavilion Floor Plans. {Architectural Record, August 1998, page 111.)
21. Oceans Pavilion Floor Plans. {Architectural Record, August 1998, page 112.)
22. Entrance to Aquarium of the Pacific. (Aquarium of the Pacific: Visitor Information. Aquarium Architecture. 2004.
Internet on-line http://wvtfw.aquariumofpacific.orq/VISITOR INFO/aqua arch.html [12 February 2004].
23. Exterior View of Aquarium from across the bay. (Aquarium of the Pacific. 2004. Internet on-line
http://www.aquariumofpacific.orq/VISITOR INFO/aqua arch.html [12 February 2004].
24. Aerial view of aquarium with the bay. (visit-Los-Angeles.com. The Long Beach Aquarium of the Pacific. 2004.
Internet on-line http://lonq-beach-aquarium-of-the-pacific.visit-los-anqeles.com/ [13 February 2004].
25. Interior aquarium viewing wall. (visit-Los-Angeles.com. The Long Beach Aquarium of the Pacific. 2004.
Internet on-line http://lonq-beach-aquarium-of-the-pacific.visit-los-anqeles.com/ [13 February 2004].
26. Interior view of acrylic tunnel under the sea lion and seal exhibit. (University of California, Irvine: School of
Information and Computer Science. Long Beach Aquarium. 2003. Internet on-line
http://wvtfw.ics.uci.edu/~eppstein/pix/lbaq2/ [14 February 2004].
LIST OF ILLUSTRATIONS
'^^t^B- Sm/sm^
List of Illustrations
Figure
27. Interior view of one of the large porthole display windows. (University of California, Irvine: School of Information
and Computer Science. Long Beach Aquarium. 2003. Internet on-line
http://www.ics.uci.edu/~eppstein/pix/lbaq2/ [14 February 2004].
28. View of lobby with lifesize whale. (Aquarium of the Pacific: Visitor Information. Aquarium Architecture. 2004.
Internet on-line http://www.aquariumofpacific.orq/FACILITIES RENTAL/fac rent info.htm [12 February
2004].
29. View of exterior children's courtyard. (Aquarium of the Pacific: Visitor Information. Aquarium Architecture. 2004.
Internet on-line http://vtfww.aquariumofpacific.orq/VISITOR INFO/aqua arch.html [12 February 2004].
30. View of Monterey Bay Aquarium from across bay. (Monterey Bay Aquarium. Visitor Guide. 2004. Internet on-line
http://www.mbayaq.orq/vi/vi aquarium/vi aq visit.asp [16 February 2004].
31. View of outdoor spaces. (Wylson, Anthony and Particia. Theme Parks. Leisure Centres, Zoos and Aquaria , New
York: Longman Singapore Publishers Ltd., 1994, page 130.)
32. View of interior display areas. (Wylson, Anthony and Particia. Theme Parks. Leisure Centres. Zoos and Aquaria ,
New York: Longman Singapore Publishers Ltd., 1994, page 129.)
33. Viewof three story kelp tank. (Monterey Bay Aquarium. Aquarium Exhibits: Kelp Forest Exhibit. 2004. Internet on-
line httBl//wywvjTibayaa,^^ [16 February 2004].
34. Floor Plan.(Wylson, Anthony and Particia. Theme Parks. Leisure Centres. Zoos and Aquaria , New York: Longman
Singapore Publishers Ltd., 1994, page 126.)
35. Floor Plan. (Wylson, Anthony and Particia. Theme Parks. Leisure Centres. Zoos and Aquaria , New York: Longman
Singapore Publishers Ltd., 1994, page 127.)
36. Building Sections. (Wylson, Anthony and Particia. Theme Parks, Leisure Centres. Zoos and Aquaria , New
York: Longman Singapore Publishers Ltd., 1994, page 127.)
LIST OF ILLUSTRATIONS
List of Illustrations
Figure
37. Design Development Sketches
38. Design Development Floor Plan Schemes
39. Design Development Floor Plan Schemes Continued
40. Preliminary Review Floor Plans
41. Preliminary Review Elevations and Axonimetric
42. Preliminary Review Building Sections
43. Qualifying Review Site Plan
44. Qualifying Review Second Floor Plan
45. Qualifying Review First Floor and Basement Plans
46. Qualifying Review Perspectives: (Clockwise from Top Left: Upstairs Interior Mezzanine, Exterior Front Fagade,
Interior Corridor, Exterior Approach)
47. Qualifying Review Building Sections and Construction Details
48. Final Site Plan
49. Final First Floor Plan
50. Final Second Floor Plan
51. Final Basement Plan
52. Final South Elevation
53. Final East Elevation
54. Final North Elevation
LIST OF ILLUSTRATIONS
List of Illustrations
Figure
LIST OF ILLUSTRATIONS
List of Illustrations
Figure
LIST OF ILLUSTRATIONS
n
ABSTRACT
CHAPTER
The purpose of this project is to develop an
environment in which the public can learn about
ecological systems that may be foreign to them. The
San Antonio Hill Country is one of the fastest growing
areas in the nation. This great population increase
creates a need for buildings of necessity and those of
leisure. The aquarium will be a place where all people
can learn about species from waters around the world.
The location of the aquarium is in the Hill Country, due
north of downtown San Antonio. The site overlooking a
valley, allows for excellent design opportunities. The
hills, covered with cedar trees and limestone rock, can
also be used to influence the design. Other than the
swimming pools in the surrounding neighborhoods, the
aquarium will be the only source of water in this region;
therefore, the aquarium is a literal and metaphorical
oasis in the Hill Country. Not only will it provide a
needed area of water, but it will also establish a place of
refuge for the San Antonio population. Located on the
downside of hill and visible from a distance, the oasis
will draw people in for its aesthetic beauty and its
educational opportunities.
INTRODUCTION
This hesis /viii use erfec:ive circuJationand;
programmaiic space ! eauirements^ while^utilizingrth^
natural aspects of *he siie, o craai^an^oasis^in'th^Hill
Country.
THESIS STAlByEINIT
CHAPTER II
The practice of taking care of fish in captivity dates back
to the Sumerians in 2500 B.C., which they would keep
the fish until they were ready to eat them. It is also
known, in Egyptian, Greek, and Roman times, that
^^^^^1
people kept fish for other reasons than eating. The
Romans kept eels for a culinary treat, as well as for
pets. The first, and most popular, fish that was kept in
captivity was the Goldfish. By 968-975, in the Sung
i
Dynasty, ponds were stocked with Goldfish and the
eating of them was strictly prohibited. At this point in
time keeping gold fish was something that was primarily
for the privileged. However, by 1510 Goldfish were
beginning to be bred and were now a commonality for
Wm k ^
ARCHITECTURAL EPISTEMOLOGY
In 1855-1856, the first American Aquarium was
opened by Phineas T. Barnum at the American
Museum in New York. In 1871-1872, public aquariums
were opened successfully in England and Germany.
Since Barnum's introduction of the aquarium in the
United States, there have been many revolutionary
ideas that have been applied to the aquarium. One of
the first aquariums other than the American Museum
was the Boston Aquariual Gardens. It was opened in
1859, and contained many ideas taken from the
American Museum. In the 1950's the underground
filter was finally perfected and applied to aquariums.
The introduction of the filter allowed filtration and
cleaning of the aquariums to be easier. Prior to 1952,
all aquariums had been using live food for the fish. At
this time, Dr. Baensch Atlas invented food flakes, and
thus revolutionized the way that fish were fed. ^ Figure 3: Drawing of Boston Aquarial Gardens.
ARCHITECTURAL EPISTEMOLOGY
Basic Project Data
•Location: Tampa, Florida
•Owner: The Florida Aquarium, Inc.
•Architects: Hellmuth, Obata & Kassabaum, Inc. and Esherick,
Homsey, Dodge & Davis
•Structural Engineering Consultants: Walter P. Moore &
Associates
•Mechanical Engineering Consultants: Syska & Hennessy
•Civil Engineering Consultants: Geiner
•Exhibit Design Consultant: Joseph A. Wetzel & Associates
•Building Size: 152,000 Square Feet
•Budget/Cost: $84 Million
vs
IS
Oceans Pavilion
CASE STUDY Lisbon, Portugal
Figure 18: Floor Plans
• •
• B Jl •
'.}:m n\:^\:n
•I *.
• • •
n
K }
Oceans Pavilion
CASE STUDY Lisbon, Portugal
Basic Project Data
•Location: Long Beach, California
•Owner: City of Long Beach
•Architects: Hellmuth, Obata, & Kassanbaum and Esherick,
Homsey, Dodge, and Davis
•General Contractor: Turner/Kajima
•Developer: Kajima International
•Exhibit Consultant: Joseph A. Wetzel Associates
•Building Size: 156,735 Square Feet
•Budget/Cost: $117 Million
Figure 20: Entrance to Aquarium of the Pacific
|||KHS?|||B
^BI^y^*!B?|^" Paa
Figure 24: Interior view of acrylic tunnel under sea lion and seal exhibit.
Figure 25: Interior view of one of the large porthole display windows.
4 T t « 1 f L.
\
I
I
.
tJamn •mwri
.
f'"" ~ —
MMATM MA
» T 7—'
SECOND FLOOR
I Highs
I Lows
I Rainfall
/ / /
Month
CLIENT PROFILE
This facility will provide people with an interactive,
educational experience. People will be able to see and
learn about fish and mammals that they otherwise might
not be able to come into contact with. Aquariums tend to
be environments that are relaxed in nature and soothing
to the visitors. Water in itself is a soothing element of
design, so I would hope that this facility is going to prove
to be a place where its patrons can come into a stress
free environment. In the same manner I would like for the
different areas and types offish to evoke different
feelings, or auras. For instance small bright "fun fish"
would evoke feeling of comfort, whereas the larger
sharks would create a deep sea, and almost mysterious
feeling. All joining together to provide an enjoyable
experience. It would also be an environment in which
learning would be stimulated.
Using architectural precedents and previous theses as a
guide, a rough facility program of spaces has been
compiled. These spaces will allow the public, private,
and service spaces to act separately, as well as together
as a cohesive unit. The spaces can be divided up into
five major areas: public space, administrative space,
exhibition space, service spaces, and educational space.
The public spaces include the lobby, ticket booth,
information and security desk, restaurant, and the rest
rooms. These spaces are those that will be experienced
by all who enter the facility. The administrative spaces
will contain all of the offices where the business itself
FACILITY PROGRAM
takes place. This is where all of the people who maintain
the facility will work and do their business. The exhibition
space will house the numerous aquariums, the petting
pool, and aviary. These spaces will be accessible to only
those who have purchased a ticket into the aquarium.
The most private of the spaces will be the service
spaces. These are the shipping and receiving, shop,
kitchen, mechanical room, and pump and filter room.
These are the spaces which actually allow the building to
function. The last set of spaces is the educational
space. These are the spaces that will consist of
classrooms, laboratories, and the theater. These will be
used for classes and lectures for the public. People will
only be allowed into these spaces with appointments and
ticket purchases.
FACILITY PROGRAM
ACTIVITY
The lobby will serve as the area in which visitors will
be welcomed and able to orient themselves within
the aquarium. This will be the main entrance for all
public activities at the aquarium
SPATIAL QUANTITIES
Square Footage: 4225 sq ft. p^>^
SPATIAL QUALITIES
The lobby will be a large volume space, with
excellent acoustical qualities due to the large space
and the high traffic of the area. This space will be
bathed in both natural and artificial light. By taking
advantage of the south facing front of the building,
there will be an abundance of filtered natural light. \^j\H)V-h^
There will be a 30 foot cylindrical aquarium in this
^rc'r\&^
space in order to welcome the visitors into the space
with a dramatic element.
SPATIAL RELATIONSHIPS
The lobby will be the central hub from which all other
spaces come off. The administration, restaurant, gift
shop, ticket booth, public restrooms, and information
desk will all be located directly off of the lobby.
There will be a main entrance leading in from the
parking lots to the south of the building. A
second story balcony of the aquarium will also be
accessible from the lobby by way of either stairs or
elevator.
—FACILITY PROGRAM
ACTIVITY
The ticket booth will serve as a space in which
visitors may purchase admittance into the exhibits,
including the aquarium, IMAX and aviary.
SPATIAL QUANTITIES
Square Footage: 200 sq ft.
SPATIAL QUALITIES
The ticket booth will be a small enclosed space,
which 1-4 ticket vendors may sit and sell tickets.
This space will have four windows at which people
'^t^"
may purchase tickets.
SPATIAL RELATIONSHIPS
The ticket booth will be located on an exterior wall
so that two windows may be on the exterior and two
on the interior of the lobby. This will allow for there
to be less congestion in the lobby, but also give a
place where people can buy tickets during inclement
weather. The ticket booth will be located directly
next to the lobby. Located at the back of the ticket
booth will be a small room that will be used as
display either for upcoming attractions or the latest
merchandise at the gift shop.
^^
FACILITY PROGRAM
ACTIVITY
The directors office will be used for the chief
administration of the aquarium. This is where
business will take place concerning the operation of
the aquarium and its finances.
SPATIAL QUANTITIES
Square Footage: 300 sq ft.
SPATIAL QUALITIES
The directors office will have space for the directors
desk, as well as space and seating for visitors. This
might be a space that is a little more formal than
most of the other spaces in the aquarium, primarily
because this is where business deals will be
conducted.
SPATIAL RELATIONSHIPS
The directors office will be located off of the lobby in
the administrative area of the aquarium. It will be
directly located next to a secretary, which will
provide a buffer to prevent direct access to the
directors office. The other administrative offices will
be located adjacent to the directors office. This will
allow for easier communication between the
administration. Also located near the directors office
is the conference room.
FACILITY PROGRAM
ACTIVITY
The storage room will be used for keeping old files,
office supplies, and other materials the
administrators might need.
SPATIAL QUANTITIES
Square Footage: 500 sq ft.
SPATIAL QUALITIES
The storage room will be plain space that will be
outfitted with shelves, cabinets, copiers, and file
cabinets. There will be only artificial light, as this
space will be entirely internal.
SPATIAL RELATIONSHIPS
The storage room will be located adjacent to all of
the administrative spaces. It will be accessible to
he administrative staff only.
OG R A I V I LABORATORY
ACTIVITY
The IMAXDome Theater is to be used for
educational as well as recreational films.
SPATIAL QUANTITIES
Square Footage: 11000 sq. ft.
SPATIAL QUALITIES
The IMAX will seat 330 people in a stadium format
as suggested by the IMAX Company. It will have a
dome screen suspended from the structure as to
create the IMAXDome theater. All acoustic, lighting,
and material choices will meet the design criteria set
by the IMAX Company.
SPATIAL RELATIONSHIPS
The IMAXDome Theater will be located off of the
main lobby, accessible by a corridor. Located in
front of the IMAX is a lobby/staging area for the
theater lines. There will also be a small office for the
person who runs the theater located just off of the
lobby. Outside of the IMAX area is the concession
stand which may be used by the patrons of the
theater. There will also be a gate that may close off
the aquarium after hours while the IMAX may remain
open to increase revenue. There are entrance and
exit doors from the corridor just outside the lobby.
FACILITY PROGRAM
ACTIVITY
The kitchen will be primarily used for cooking and
storing food which will be used in the restaurant. It
will also serve provide the food services for any
banquets which might be held in the lobby.
SPATIAL QUANTITIES
Square Footage: 4,250 sq ft.
SPATIAL QUALITIES
The kitchen will have dry storage space, cold
storage space, food preparation spaces, and space
for dish washing. It will be a space that can be
easily cleaned and highly functional for the workers.
This space will have to be acoustically sound so that
the noise does not interfere with the dining
experience.
SPATIAL RELATIONSHIPS
The kitchen will be located towards the back of the
restaurant. There will also be exits located into the
restaurant as well. The kitchen will be connected to
the service elevator in order to more efficiently get
the goods to the kitchen.
FACILITY PROGRAM
ACTIVITY
The filter/pump room is a room in which the main
pump and filter for the aquarium tanks.
SPATIAL QUANTITIES
Square Footage: 3,200 sq. ft.
SPATIAL QUALITIES
The filter/pump room will be a space that is in the
basement and that will prepare the water for all of
the tanks. It would be a service space which the
employees would be able to maintain the water and
the filter. It prepares and cycle the water constantly
through the tanks. This would help to ensure the
system stability within the tanks themselves.
SPATIAL RELATIONSHIPS
The filter/pump room will be located in the
basement. There also should be ample ventilation
for all of the machines that are needed to filter the
water. All of the drain pipes from the tanks will go
into this space and be filtered and disposed of if
needed. There will also be direct lines from the
exterior water storage tanks into this space for water
to then be distributed into the tanks.
1,790 sq ft.
•Restaurant/Cafe 4.000 sa ft.
13,215 sq ft.
EXHIBITION SPACES
• Aquariums 25,600 sq ft.
• Petting Pool 1,600 sq ft.
• Small Aviary 11,000 sq ft.
• IMAXDome Theater and Support 11.000 sq ft.
49,200 sq ft.
FACILITY PROGRAM
EDUCATIONAL SPACES
• Classrooms (2 at 800 sq ft ea.) 1,600 sq ft.
• Library 4,300 sq ft.
• Laboratory 2.550 sq ft.
8,450 sq ft.
SERVICE SPACES
• Shipping, Receiving, andOpen Storage 5,000 sq ft.
• Shop 3,200 sq ft.
• Kitchen/Food Storage 4,250 sq ft.
• Mechanical 3,000 sq ft.
• Food/Supply Storage 5,760 sq ft.
• Animal Examination/Treatment Room 1,440 sq ft.
• Pump/Filter Room 3.200 sa ft.
25,850 sq ft
FACILITY PROGRAM
•• 1
ADMINISTRATIVE SPACES
• Directors Office 300 sq ft.
• Coordinators Office 200 sq ft.
• Curators Office 200 sq ft.
• Aquarist Office 250 sq ft.
• Biologist Office 250 sq ft.
•Shipping Offices (2) 400 sq ft.
•Secretarial Spaces (2) 200 sq ft.
• Storage Room 500 sq ft.
s c;
•Conference Room 500 sq ft.
• Break Room/Lounge 1.200 sq ft.
4,000 sq ft.
FACILITY PROGRAM
The site is located almost due north of the main city
of San Antonio. The area in which it is located is
highly wooded with the Cedar tree which is native to
the area. The site is located east of Interstate 10 and
west of US Highway 281. It is also located north of
Anderson Loop 1604, which is the outer loop in the
city of San Antonio.
The terrain of the area is rolling hills made up
primarily of limestone. The limestone will provide for
a very sturdy foundation. It will also allow for there to
be ample rock that may not only be used on the
exterior of the building, but also in the landscaping,
exhibits and interior finishes. There is little natural
water in this area aside from a few natural springs.
Therefore having the aquarium in this area would be
an oasis in the middle of the hill country.
The dual duct variable air volume system has two air
streams at each zone with are proportioned to meet
the desired room temperature. The major components
of this system are a boiler and chimney, chilled water
plant, cooling tower, fan room, vertical supply and
return ducts.
Hoi water or steam
FACILITY PROGRAM TS
t«dbya
fluid under
it its use to
ELEVATOR SYSTEM
The elevator system which will be used is a hydraulic
elevator system. Hydraulic elevators consist of a car
supported by a piston that is moved by or moves
against a fluid under pressure. A penthouse is not
required, but the hydraulic elevator's lower speed and
piston length limit its use to buildings up to six stories
in height, which is suitable for this facility with three
floors. Machine room houses the hoisting machinery,
control equipment, and sheaves for raising and
lowering an elevator car. The maximum dimensions
for the shaft would be 5'8" by 8'9". This will help with
the ADA compliance of the building.
linary
icturer
FACILITY PROGRAM
PRIVACY (ELECTRIC) GLASS OUTERLAVER
GLASS OR INSULA! r C
POLYCARBONATE CLASS
The privacy glass, also known as electric glass, will be LlOUlO
riLM
used in the conference room as well as the stage in CRYSTAL SPACER
LAYER
crystal film laminated between two double panes of
window. This then can be switched from clear to
opaque in a matter of seconds.
For exterior use, the curtain wall system has a photo
eye that enables it to change clear to opaque as the
sun rises and sets. This is ideal for large expanses of
glass that may not necessarily be on the north fagade.
At any time one can override the photo eye in order to
see out of the glass. There is also a highly water tight
frame which may be used not only at the top of the
aquarium, but also outside to prevent rain from
entering. Overall this is a unique product that will allow
a little more versatility within this facility.
FACILITY PROGRAM
AQUARIUM SPACE REQUIREMENTS
This Facility
$746 per sq foot x 100,715 sq feet = $75,133,390
FACILITY PROGRAM
[I] Algone, p. 1.
[2]NEAqHistory, p.1.
[3] Architectural Record, 1995, p. 80.
[4] Ibid, p. 80.
[5] Ibid, p. 80.
[6] Ibid, p.84.
[7] Architectural Record, 1998, p 106.
[8] Ibid, p. 106.
[9] Ibid, p. 108.
[10]lbid, p. 111.
[ I I ] Aquarium Architecture, p. 1.
[12] Long Beach Aquarium of the Pacific, p. 1
[13] Aquarium Architecture, p. 2.
[14] Ibid, p. 4.
[15] Wylson, 1994, p. 128.
[16] Ibid, p. 128.
[17] Ibid, p. 129.
END NOTES
CHAPTER IV
The purpose of this thesis is to show that this Public Aquarium,
located on Wilderness Oak Drive in San Antonio, Texas, can fuse
effective circulation and the programmatic space requirements,
while utilizing the natural aspects of the site itself, to create an
oasis in the hill country.
By fusing these variables into one, a cohesive facility will result.
Circulation which is highly important in any facility, should be paid
careful attention in this design. This facility is divided up into five
different areas of operation: public, administrative, educational,
exhibition, and service. All of the spaces, yet quite different in
their functions, must all still flow together as one cohesive plan.
The circulation issues may be addressed by having the large
central lobby with the individual activities radiating off of it. Also
by having like spaces adjacent to each other, it will increase the
effectiveness of the spatial planning. In the history of aquariums,
there were two types of circulation. One consisted of a single
path in which the visitor could go, and the other was more of a
wandering way, where the visitor could go and view as they
please. In this design a combination of the two will be tested to
see if that in fact would be a better design.
The programmatic space requirements as discussed in Chapter
III, will determine greatly the shape in which the building will take
on. By using these spaces and the natural shape and contour of
the site, the facility will begin to take shape. The facility will have
multiple floors to increase the circulation, as well as to
accommodate all of the spaces. The mechanical room, loading
dock, and other service spaces may end up being on a basement
level that is in a service pit. Thus from the street level one would
not see the service spaces, but yet they will be located in an
appropriate space. The large space that is allowed
HYPOTHESIS
for the restaurant would be ideally located on the portion of the
site which can take advantage of the site beyond. By using
glazing, possibly the privacy glass, the space could be utilized at
all times of the day, and could continually take advantage of the
view. Through the use of vertical circulation, such as elevators,
escalators, and stairs, the different levels of the aquarium will be
easily linked.
The idea of creating an Oasis in the hill country stems from the
fact that in the area this is located there is not an abundance of
water sources. Thus by having an aquarium in this area, it will be
like an oasis in the desert. This will be someplace that will attract
people from miles around, and it is something that people will look
forward to coming to. Once inside it will be as if they are
energized to explore the exhibits and learn about areas that are
unknown to them. All of the applications of knowledge will help to
create this facility and along with all of the other secondary issues,
a functional and beautiful building will result.
The architectural design methods which will be used to solve this
design problem will vary in many different ways. Some will look at
space requirements and adjacencies. Others will look at the
surrounding built context and help this facility to use those
characteristics in its design. To help with the spatial design
problem many different diagrams can be used to decide upon the
correct adjacencies and locations for spaces. Bubble diagrams,
as used in the previous chapter, can show very quickly and easily
spatial relationships. This will allow the design to flow better
between the parts and to have a more effective circulation pattern.
This will also help to show the access patterns from space to
space, and allow the design to keep separate the public from
HYPOTHESIS
private space. These bubble diagrams will begin to show patterns
for effective egress as well. In the event of a fire, there needs to
be clear and effective paths of egress, by planning out roughly
where spaces are going to go, the design can then reflect this in
the paths to the exits. Once the spaces are roughly laid out in the
bubble diagrams, the square footages can be applied, and the
spaces can actually begin to take their form.
Another method of solving the spatial organization is through a
building matrix. This will be able to show the direct, indirect, or
lack of relation between spaces. This will help the design, once
again, to have a very strong and effective circulation pattern. This
will most definitely show which spaces it is imperative that they
are adjacent, and which spaces it is not necessary at all if they are
next to each other. Being that this project has five different areas
of operation, this method will help to keep these areas separate,
but also allow some connection so that the building is a cohesive
whole.
Another method in which will help the facility to fit in with the
surrounding context and site, is the use of site analysis. This
method will allow the design to conform to the slope of the site, to
take advantage of the views, as well as to incorporate all of the
natural surroundings into the design. As discussed previously, the
area of this site is primarily of limestone, and that is reflected in
the existing built context. Therefore using the site information,
and the surrounding built context, the design itself can incorporate
these elements which will tie it to this site directly.
Site analysis will also be able to show where the best place for the
entrance to the parking lot is to be, as well as the direction and
orientation of the spaces themselves. For example, it would be an
HYPOTHESIS
optimum choice to have the restaurant overlooking the view of the
hill country, and to have the spaces, such as the aquariums,
which do not have any windows to face the west to block the heat.
This then begins to have some interaction with the bubble
diagrams which were previously discussed in order to effectively
arrange the spaces, and take full advantage of the site itself.
Once the spatial relationships have been determined, the design
will begin to take a more rigid shape. This will then lend itself to
the creation of the structural system, aesthetic qualities, and
operation of the building design. By doing all of these in a
progressive pattern an effective design solution will evolve.
HYPOTHESIS
CHAPTER V
94
DESIGN PROCESS
These are just a few examples of the numerous sketches
that took place to come up with the final exterior and
interior form. Along with numerous floor plan schemes, as
seen in the following two pages, there were many fagade
schemes that were developed as well. This idea of
creating an exterior plaza was one that was important to
the design, and is shown in some of these sketches.
Once the idea of using the primal forms, the cube, sphere,
and pyramid, this was developed as the primary design
strategy. There were also many studies done with
concentrating the center of the dome in plan as the center
of the entire building. All of these sketches as well as
many others eventually led up to the design of the final
project.
This was the earliest plan in the design, showing the detailed This plan began to address egress, and placing the service
planning of the aquarium spaces. However this plan did not area at the center of the behind the scenes action. This
address egress within the facility. allowed for the service corridors to all come from one point.
This plan further addressed egress and the classroom This plan, much like the previous plan, reduced further the
awkward angles. It also added in the appropriate amount of
spaces began to develop. This plan also began to square off
restrooms, and other service areas.
and simplify some of the awkward angles.
Figure 38: Process Drawings: Various Floor Plan Schemes
ig;^^
This plan, although not fully developed was the point in which
it was discovered that the completely organic shape of the
aquarium exhibit space might not be the correct way to go This is when the final plan began to take shape. The center
about the design. of the aquarium exhibits became the central point in the
building. The aviary and IMAX were designed, and the office
spaces, as well as other support spaces were organized.
/ /
service spaces. Thus increasing the ease of circulation and g-Aquarium Exhibits
10-IMAX TTieater
clarity of spaces. 11-Aviary
PRELIMINARY REVIEW
other suggestions that came out of this review was that of
increasing the service spaces for the IMAX area. In the
plans previously there were no restrooms, concessions, or
lobby space for the IMAX itself. Therefore, so that the IMAX
could function as a separate entity apart from the aquarium.
It was also discussed to allow the IMAX to have its own
entrance so that it may be used after hours, to increase the
revenue for the facility. The other main suggestion was to
develop the facades of the building. Up to this point the
facades were merely solids, as shown to the right. The next
logical step was to put glazing and other forms to articulate
the exterior fa9ade. It was suggested that the entry lobby
and the gift shop have glazing that would allow for window
shopping to occur. Also to allow this space to be flooded Figure 41: Preliminary Elevations and Axonimetric
with natural light.
The next step after this review that was taken was to
simplify the floor plan, unify the structure, and work on the
exterior facades.
PRELIMINARY REVIEW
After numerous intermediate informal reviews, the qualifying
review was the next design review. The month that was
between the preliminary review and the qualifying review
was spent taking into consideration all the suggestions, as FUTURE BUSINESS PARK
The biggest, and most evident change was in the floor plan
and site orientation. As can be seen in the images to the
right and the images on the following page, the floor plan
was simplified from the previous review, and orientation on
the site was reversed. The floor plans were developed
much further and in much more detail than previously. Still
keeping with the circulation issue, the aquarium space was
redesigned around a central point in the middle of this large
geodesic dome structure. This central point provided an Figure 43: Qualifying Site Plan
organizing feature for the building. Where the building
previously faced north, it now faces south with a service pit
on the north of the building. By repositioning the building to
face the south, it took greater advantage of the natural
aspects of the site. This allowed for sheet draining of water
away from the building. It also increased the visibility of the
building from approaching roads. Whereas previously the
building had its back facing the approaching traffic from
Hardy Oak and Wilderness Oak and the front facing the
intersection, the building now faces the two most traveled 1-Kitchen/Food Storage
pit on the north of the building. Due to the slope of the site, 5-Library
6-Classroom
aquariums.
During the review, the evaluators also suggested that the S-Concessions/lnfo/Securir /Ticket Booth
QUALIFYING REVIEW
f '
vA^x'
\XX>
V-^'s^'v^
J^^i
Figure 47: Qualifying Building Sections and Construction Details
QUALIFYING REVIEW
This thesis is based upon circulation, space requirements,
and the natural site. Therefore, these three aspects
prevailed as the primary concerns for the project. When
beginning the design of this facility, all of the spaces were
drawn out to scale in block form. This then allowed for the
issue of circulation to be addressed. By starting first with
these two issues, the plan was able to take shape and like
spaces were able to be grouped together. By keeping
spaces that have primarily the same use, this increased
the effectiveness of the spaces, as well as keeping the
service circulation separate from the public circulation.
<y
i 6-ANIMAL EXAMINATION
7-SUPPLY/FOOD STORAGE
8-AQUARIST OFFICE
15-LOBBY
16-GIFTSHOP
17-PETTING POOL
9-BIOLOGIST OFFICE 18-AVIARY
Figure 49: Final First Floor Plan
i 22-ROOF BELOW
23-SERVICE CLOSET
24-STORAGE
31-LOBBY BALCONY
32-CAFE./RESTAURANT
33-OPEN TO BELOW
25-CONFERENCE ROOM 34-MEZZANINE
Figure 50: Final Second Floor Plan 26-DIRECTOR'S SECRETARY 35-LIBRARY
27-SECRETARY 36-CLASSROOMS
T
1^ Iffl-ffliyra
D I D
38
=MD ,, D
37
39
G 37-IMAX THEATER
38-SHOP
i
39-MECHANICAL ROOM
40-SHIPPING OFFICES
41-SHIPPING AND RECEIVING
42-TANK DRAINAGE SERVICE SPACE
43-PUMP/FILTER ROOM
Figure 51: Final Basement Floor Plan
WHH^^lllfffi
Figure 52: South Elevation
Ventilated Cavity-
Aliimlmim miillinn
fixed to bracket w/ screws
Figure 61
;^
Glazing
Glazing Bracket
Cap Flashing
Site r-.ggf (-.nncrptp retaining
wall and column footing
Base flashing
Metal RooLDeck.
BUILDING SECTION
FINAL DESIGN RESPONSE AND DETAILS
Figure 64
Snap on Cap
Hip Rafter
"Rafter
I Connection
BUILDING SECTIONS
FINAL DESIGN RESPONSE AND DETAILS
_i 1* « «=* « tJ « o "
EXHIBITION SPACE
H E D U C A T I O N A L SPACE
PUBLIC SPACE
ADMINISTRATIVE SPACE
i SERVICE SPACE
- .PUBLIC CIRCULATION
—. 6ERVICE CIRCULATION
Figure 66: First Floor Circulation and Building Use Plan
I EDUCATIONAL SPACE
PUBLIC SPACE
ADMINISTRATIVE SPACE
I SERVICE SPACE
• PUBLIC CIRCULATION
6ERVICE CIRCULATION
Figure 67: Second Floor Circulation and Building Use Plan
?^ -N^B
2.
EXHIBITION SPACE
H EDUCATIONAL SPACE
H PUBLIC SPACE
^ADMINISTRATIVE SPACE
^ S E R V I C E SPACE
I 4...
- .PUBLIC CIRCULATION
—. 6ERVICE CIRCULATION
Figure 68: Basement Circulation and Building Use Plan
CONCLUSION
Also within the space, the service circulation and space
was kept entirely separate from the public circulation.
This was achieved by a series of corridors behind the
scenes in which the aquariums can be accessed. This
helps to increase the experience and relieve the stresses
of the people if they do not have to see the maintenance
going on.
CONCLUSION
Works Cited
Algone. The History of the Aquarium. 2004. Internet on-line http://vtfww.alqone.com/aquarium historv pf.htm \
Aquarial Gardens, Bromfield Street, Boston. 2004. Internet on-line
http://www.butlerart.com/Web Shows/homer/Pages/aquarial qardens.htm
Aquarium of the Pacific. Visitor Information: History of Aquariums. 2004. Internet on-line
http://www.aquariumofpacific.orq/VISITOR INFO/historv aop.html
Ivy, Robert. "Oceans Pavilion: Lisbon, Portugal." Arc/7/tecfwra/f?ecorcf, August 1998.
Lisbon Oceanarium. Oceans Pavilion. 2000. Internet on-line http://lrm.isr.ist.utl.pt/isqm/albuns/3xpo98/pavoceanos en.html
Monterey Bay Aquarium. Visitor Guide. 2004. Internet on-line http://www.mbavaq.orq/vi/vi aquarium/vi aq visit.asp
New England Aquarium. Aquarium History: Old Aquariums: Boston Aquarial Gardens. 2001. Internet on-line
http://vtfww.neaq.orq/about/historv/1885.html
Pearson, Clifford A. "Total Immersion." Architectural Record, June 1995.
Pettibone, Martin. "Lubbock Aquarium". Thesis , Texas Tech University, Lubbock, Texas. 1996.
The Sunday Times Syndication Website. Gabion: Chermayeff at Lisbon. 2003. Internet on-line
http://www.huqhpearman.com/articles/cwa20.htm
University of California, Irvine: School of Information and Computer Science. Long Beach Aquarium. 2003. Internet on-line
http://www.ics.uci.edu/~eppstein/pix/lbaq2/
visit-Los-Angeles.com. The Long Beach Aquarium of the Pacific. 2004. Internet on-line
http://lonq-beach-aquarium-of-the-pacific.visit-los-anqeles.com/
Wylson, Anthony and Particia. Theme Parks. Leisure Centres. Zoos and Aquaria , New York: Longman Singapore
Publishers Ltd., 1994.
WORKS CITED