OBLICON CASES

2020 25/3 EXAM COVERAGE

ARTICLES 1226 -1229 OBLIGATIONS WITH A PENAL CLAUSE

Equitable reduction of penalty even if there is non-performance
-LIGUTAN V. CA 376 S 560

Other eases:
PRYCE CORP. V. PAGCOR 458 S 164

FLORENTINO V. SUPERVALUE 533 S 156

DIAMOND BUILDERS v. COUNTRY BANKERS 540 5 194

RIVERA v. SPS. CHU A 746 S 1

BUENAVENTURA V. METROPOLITAN BANK 799 S 239

1231- 1232 PAYMENT

1. MULTI-INTERNATTIONAL V. MARTINEZ 774 S 574

CINCO v. CA 603 108

 4 ONG BUN v. BPI 859 S 80 (PERALTA)

EFFECT of DEATH - STRONGHOLD INSURANCE V. REPUBLIC-ASAHI

492 S 179

1234 -1235 - EXCEPTIONS TO COMPLETE DELIVERY OR SERVICE TO

EXTINGUISH AN OBLIGATION (IIRU PAYMENT/PERFORMANCE

WERR CORPORATION v. HIGHLANDS PRINO: 817 S 145 (JARDELEZA)

1236 - 1237 - EFFECTS OF PAYMENT MADE BY A THIRD PERSON

JALANDONI V. ENCOMTENDA 819 S 43 (PERALTA)

1240 -TO WHOM PAYMENT SHALL BE MADE

PNB V. TAN 256 S 44

CULA BA v. CA 427 S 721

ALLIED BANKING V. LIM SIO WAN 549 S 504

DELA CRUZ v. CONCEPCION 684 S 74

1241 - PAYMENT TO AN INCAPACITATED; TO A TII1RD PERSON
-EFFECTS AND ITS EXCEPTIONS

1242- PAYMENT MADE IN GOOD FAITH

NATIONAL POWER CORP. v. IBRAHIM 750 S 711

1245-DATION IN PAYMENT
-What law governs dation in payment upon perfection

CASES:
ESTANTSLAO v. EAST WEST BANKING GR4178537 02/11/08

TAN SHUY v. MAULAWIN 665 S 604

VILLARTA v. TALAVERA. JR. 783 5 242

DALISAY INVESTMENTS v. SOCIAL SECURITY SYSTEM 8611 S 554

(VELASCO, JR.)

KAREN NUNEZ ET. AL v. PALMA GR4224466 MARCH 27, 2019

(CAGUIOA)

1249 - PAYMENT RV DELIVERY OF PROMISSORY NOTES/BILLS OF

EXCHANGE/OTHER MERCANTILE DOCUMENTS; EXCEPTIONS

EVANGELISTA v. SCREEN EX, INC. 845 S 131 (SERENO)

1250 EXTRAORDINARY INFLATION/DEFLATION

EQUITABLE PCI v. NG SHEUNG NGOR 541 S 223

ALMEDA V. BATHALA MARKETING 542 5 470

1251- PLACE OF PAYMENT

1252- APPLICATION OF PAYMENT

PREMIERE DEV. RANK V. CENTRAL SURETY 579 S 359

ESPINA V. CA 06/22/ 2000

TAN v. CHINA BANKING 800 5 635

SINAMBAN V. CHINA BANKING 752 S 621

TAN V. CHINA BANKING 8110 S 635 (PEREZ)

1253- 1254 ABSENCE OF STIPULATION WHERE PAYMENT BE APPLIED

 MARQUEZ v. ELISAN CREDIT 755 5 31

1255 PAYMENT BY CESSION OR ASSIGNMENT

- DISTINGUISHED FROM DATION IN PAYMENT

VILLALUZ V. LAND BANK 814 5 466 (JARDELEZA)

1256- 1261 TENDER OF PAYMENT AND CONSIGNATION

- REQUISITES

-EXCEPTIONS TO PRIOR TENDER

CASES:
PABUGAIS v. SAHIJWANI 423 S 509

BENOS V. LAWILAO 509 S 549

CACAYORIN V. ARMED FORCES AND POLICE 696 S 311

PHILIPPINE NATIONAL BANK v. CHAN 820 S 161 (DEL CASTILLO)

1262 -12665 LOSS OF THE THINGS DUE

EFFECTS: EXCEPTIONS
1266 -1267 DOCTRINE OF UNFORESEEN EVENTS IN OBLIGATIONS TO DO
-EFFECTS; REQUSITES

1. PHILIPPINE NATIONAL CONSTRUCTION V. CA 272 S 183

2. MAGAT, JR. V. CA 337 S 298

3. TAGAYTAY REALTY v. GACUTAN 761 S 87

COMGLASCO CORP v SANTOS CAR CHECK CENTER CORP. 754 S

481 (REYES)

POON v. PRIME SAVINGS BANK 793 S.141 (SERENO)

ILOILO JAR x COMGLASCO 815 S 1 (MENDOZA)

1270 -1274 CONDONATION OR REMISSION OF THE DEBT

-CONCEPT; KINDS

-IF EXPRESS- REQUISITES

1275- 1278 MERGER OR CONFUSION

1279 -1290 - COMPENSATION
-CONCEPT; KINDS

- REQUISITES - LEGAL COMPENSATION

- EFFECTS OF ASSIGNMENT

- INSTANCES WHEN COMPENSATION IS PROHIBITED

CASES:
BPI V. CA 255 5 571

PNB v. CA 259 S 174

EGV REALTY v. CA 310 S 657

METROPOLITAN BANK v. TONDA 338 S 254

PHILTRUST v. ROXAS 772 S 323

MARPHIL EXPORT v. ALLIED BANKING 803 S 627

 CALIFORNIA MANUFACTURING V. ADVANCED TECHNOLOGY
SYSTEM 824 S 295 (SERENO)

1291- 1304 NOVATION

CONCEPT; KINDS; REQUISITES

LICAROS v. GATMAITAN G118142838 09/09/01

GARCIA v. LLAMAS 417 $292

RICARZE v. CA 515 S 302

LEDONIO v. CAPITOL DEVELOPMENT 526 5 379

BPI v. DOMINGO 754 S 245

INTERPORT RESOURCES V. SECURITIES SPECIALIST 792 5 155

FIGUERA v. ANG 795 S 175

 PARDIGM DEVELOPMENT V. BPI 826 5 267 (REYES)

SPOUSES CELONES v. METROPOLITAN BANK GRE215691 NOVEMBER

21, 2018 (TIJAM)

FOOD FEST, INC V. ROMUALDO SIAPNO, ET. AL. GR:7226088

FEBRUARY 27, 2019 (PERALTA)

AVICENTE HENSON V. UCPB INSURANCE (EN BANC) G101223134

AUGUST 14, 2019 (PERLAS-BERNABE)

12. MODOMO v. SPS. LAYUG G110197722 AUGUST 14, 2919 (CAGUIOA)