Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
net/publication/327020163
CITATIONS READS
0 1,586
1 author:
Saverio Massaro
Sapienza University of Rome
23 PUBLICATIONS 2 CITATIONS
SEE PROFILE
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
All content following this page was uploaded by Saverio Massaro on 14 August 2018.
01
2018
Abstract
seconda serie
This paper examines the issue of solid waste management in urban contexts, by an architectur-
al perspective. In light of the emerging waste crisis, this paper proposes to redesign and grad-
ually reintroduce waste management facilities in the urban tissue. The capacity to learn from
trash can help to design a new generation of facilities, aiming to recover suburban areas and to
re-establish a lost ecological balance.
The paper underlines the need to radically reconsider the spatial articulation and the organiza-
tional structure of the current waste management infrastructure, through an integrated ap-
proach aiming to define a decentralized and distributed urban model. Finally, the paper explores
heuristic potentials for architectural design, identifying hybrid figures and finding key actions
to intervene in the contemporary city, inspired by the notion of ‘unblackboxing’.
Keywords
Architecture, Waste Management, Urban Metabolism, Strategic Design, Unblackboxing
01
2018
seconda serie
Fig. 1 — Madrid, aerial photograph. Relationship between the Valdemingomez landfill site and the city. (Photo: GoogleEarth 2014).
The capacity to learn from trash can help to design posting, disassembling, fixing, upcycling, dispos-
a new generation of facilities and spaces, aiming to ing) and various additional equipment (vehicle park-
recover suburban areas and to re-establish a lost ing spaces, temporary storage warehouses, spac-
ecological balance. es for the promotion of reuse and upcycling, repair
Current environmental policy is generally founded centres and creative recycling laboratories, spaces
on the principles of the ‘waste management hierar- to house compaction or composting units).
chy’, aimed to improve the selective collection and The combination of the activities previously men-
make it more efficient through the application of tioned delineates new locational geographies,
the proximity and self-sufficiency principles. which tend to be spatially organized according to
Prevention is the hierarchically superior goal in fundamental principles:
waste management strategy, according to the in- • Convergence: defined as a strategy pointing to one
verted pyramid scheme. It is followed by prepara- side to catalyse existing flows, hybridizing them
tion for reuse, recycling, recovery of various kinds, together with functions and spaces, and on the
and finally disposal. Each stage corresponds to other to establish points of contact between the
physical spaces to be designed and integrated with- life of the building, the urban waste cycle and a
in the existing fabric, including different activities more efficient use of existing infrastructures.
120 (selecting, compacting, vending, transporting, com- • Synergy: establishing a network of simultane-
Massaro
Fig. 2 — Top view of the Issean plant. Below, the unloading deck on the river Seine. Source: Syctom.
opposite page
Fig. 1 —The top view of the former landfill close to the city centre. Credits: IBA Hamburg GmbH.
ous and reciprocal relations between systems; management facilities in the urban tissue, through
• Intermodality: incorporating multiple modes of an interscalar, incremental and adaptive approach,
transportation in order to capitalize advantages based on different phases that correspond to dif-
and to determine impacts. ferent times and scales of intervention.
• Hybridization: primary functions are connected to The incremental model proposes a period of choices
a system of relations and complementary func- based on the constant search for a balance between
tions that will activate metabolic cycles. the actors involved from time to time in decisions
• Adaptivity: each configuration founds its own bal- that will no longer be called upon to respect their ac-
ance dealing with the typology of urban tissue, tions with a rigid design ex ante, but they will also
public spaces networks, infrastructures. compete to its very definition. Each partial result
accomplished in one phase becomes the starting
It is clear how these needs and goals set up parame- point for the subsequent phase. Defining new spac-
ters for a new inter-scalar infrastructure, both phys- es for waste management requires three phases of
ical and social, adaptive in relation to the contexts intervention, taking as a reference the Cityform-
and to the specific functions required. ing© Protocol (Carta & Lino, 2015), a planning proto-
In light of the emerging waste issue, here is pro- col aimed to reactivate the metabolism of an area.
posed to redesign and gradually reintroduce waste The first step involves micro-interventions and ur- 121
seconda serie
2018
01
ri-vista
122
Fig. 5 — View of the rooftop garden. Source: Maag
Massaro
Recycling.
opposite page
Fig. 3 — Street view of the recycling and sorting
centre at Porte de Pantin (Paris), DATA Architectes,
2016. (Image © DATA Architectes).
Fig. 4 — Main front view of the Maag Recycling
Centre (Winterthur, Switzerland), OOS Architects,
2004. Source: Maag Recycling.
ban ecology tactics supported by the use of vari- tegic framework that stands for a dual design action,
ous mobile devices for waste collection and citizen operating simultaneously on the ‘urban hardware’
awareness. Services and processes triggered have a (buildings, infrastructures, systems) and on the ‘ur-
connection role, intervening on the public space and ban software’ (tactics, protocols, processes).
at a social level. The inherent link between waste production and
Subsequently, a second intermediate step is en- human activities leads to consider the relevance
visaged, characterized by a series of permanent in- of new forms of social performativity, active citi-
terventions. These are architectural additions to zenship and prosumership (Timmeren, 2015). It is
the urban fabric for the grafting of multifunctional not for sure that increasing separate collection will
equipment as the first outposts of the chain to start guarantee lower levels of consumption and waste
reducing waste streams and disassembling and re- production. There is a real risk that efficiency could
covery phases. Collection and reuse centres are the be understood as a factor that legitimates a further
spaces that at this scale play a key role. Within the increase of consumption. Furthermore recycling
second step also increases the accessibility of the make disposables new naturalized commodities in-
area. The third step carries out the completion of stead of foregrounding waste redesign or reduction
the chain at the urban scale through the realization (MacBride 2011).
of buildings-hubs at the municipal scale or supra, in A broader degree of citizens must to be involved in
which a number of further uses and flows converge. waste management practices, as remarked in the
latest report ‘World Cities 2016’ (UN-Habitat 2016).
Hardware and Software: a Proposal for a Strategic Among the five key principles to guide the urban
Framework development, citizens’ empowerment is indicated.
An effective strategy for waste reduction resides in According to that, the second action foresees to in-
the adoption of integrated scenarios, in which a de- tervene on the urban software.
sign capacity expressed in a plural and collective way In the so-called Anthropocene’s era, the reduction
(Manzini, 2015) determines the testing of models for of the waste stream cannot only depend from nei-
localized urban ecologies at different scales. In order ther technological innovation nor industrial effi-
to achieve the ambitious goal of a circular society, as ciency, but it has required a rethinking of the rela-
indicated by the European Union, it’s required a stra- tions with things and waste, calling for a less pas- 123
opposite page
ri-vista
01
2018
sive human agency (Bonneuil & Fressoz, 2016) to be Isseane: a circular factory
seconda serie
involved through civic engagement. At Issy les Moulineaux, the Paris Metropolitan
Waste Agency Syctom, decided in 2008 to replace
Program and Aesthetic: an On-Going Metamor- the previous incineration plant with a new one,
phosis housing a sorting centre and a valorisation unit. It is
Waste facilities are increasingly facing a spatial also a productive hub for a widespread district heat-
and aesthetic metamorphosis, allowing to say that ing network. Waste transport on barge and urban
waste management spaces and facilities, starting proximity allow reducing polluting emissions, vehic-
to be simple technical rooms, are invested by a pro- ular traffic and transportation costs.
cess of transformation. This transformation sees Aesthetically speaking, the dynamic wooden façade
them taking on the role of real places for meeting, makes the plant looks like an office building or a
exchange, access to knowledge and finally, where shopping mall. The integration with the context is
new forms of experience are developed, good civ- achieved thanks also to the invisible chimney en-
ic practices are involved, and finally new forms of capsulated in the 2/3 grounded building. This allows
economy can emerge. reducing noise and airing pollution. Isseane acti-
In this perspective, these facilities should also to be vates synergies with the river, promotes a culture of
characterized by functional hybridization and spa- environmental sustainability and energy efficiency
tial quality, to be aesthetically recognizable and to by opening its spaces to educational initiatives.
be conceived not as mere storage spaces, but as
productive and generative places, such as laborato- Infrastructural intersections: the network of dechet-
ries or factories, where a continuous transformation terie in Paris
of matter and data can be driven by research and in- Paris is redefining its relationship with subur-
novation. ban areas beyond the Peripherique. A series of civ-
Some case studies are presented below. The selec- ic-amenity called CVAE (Centre de valorisation et
tion underlines strategic, locational, programmatic d’apport des encombrants) are provided, where col-
and aesthetic values. lect bulky waste, WEEE, green and garden waste,
hazardous wastes as well as paper, cardboard, plas-
124 tic, metal and glass.
Massaro
Many sorting centres are located along the infra- The building represents a convergence node that in-
structure, filling the voids under the overpass. Par- cludes a collection centre, a lab, offices and services.
ticularly relevant is the recycling and sorting centre Spaces and equipment for compacting and treating
at Porte de Pantin, built in a former traffic rounda- waste are placed on the other side of the parking lot.
bout. An elegant white curtain made of staggered The green surface-rooftop put together a parking ar-
white brickwork, alternating with glass bricks, iden- ea and a community garden made by recyclables.
tifies the sorting centre. Aesthetic value accompa-
nies locational advantages, given by the presence A multitasking ramp
of the Parc de la Villete, the Cité de la Musique and, In 2003, the architect Gonzalo Arias Recalde real-
most recently, the Philharmonie. ized Ecoparque, a waste collection centre in Grana-
It is noted how interstitial spaces transformed in- da. The building is located at the edge of a produc-
to a collection centre turns from forgotten space tion area and shares the access to the lot with a fu-
into a place of collective recognition: the overpass el station. For this reason, different flows are inter-
becomes the covering of a new metropolitan pub- cepted, ensuring proximity and synergies between
lic space. different activities. Below the ramp there are three
blocks hosting a seminar room and temporary de-
A recycling garden in Winterthur posits. Finally a third vertical block is located near-
The German word hof means court, courtyard. This by the entrance, to host offices and services. After-
inspired the Recy-hof project in Winterthur (Swit- wards the functional program has also included an
zerland), a waste collection centre conceived by Mr. employment centre.
Werner Maag as a welcoming place for temporarily As an artificial landscape trail, Ecoparque is a porous
useless objects and materials. Designed by the OOS and crossable border that separates vehicle trails and
Open Operative System, in collaboration with land- leaves open views of the surrounding landscape.
scape designers Stefan Rotzler and Matthias Krebs,
the building fits in a strategic location, in a hinged Towards a Distributed and Decentralized Model
area between the residential area and the industri- Looking at fragility and inefficiency shown by cur-
al area of the city, with a high Degree of accessibility, rent waste management infrastructures, the shift
and close to the railway line. from a model based on few concentrated mac- 125
ri-vista
01
2018
seconda serie
ro-plants, to a distributed and decentralized one, lines different intervention strategies starting from
made by small-medium size facilities, represents a the identification of nine streams (goods / goods,
real trend reversal that will enable cities and territo- people, waste, animals and plants, energy, food, wa-
ries to exit from an emergency condition, to finally ter, land and sand, air). The four design proposals
get to an ordinary state (Mamì, 2014). From a linear converge on the common goal of optimizing meta-
model that meant opacity, distance between con- bolic flows. The strategy adopted on Rotterdam de-
sumption and production, analytical separation and clines according to an adaptive logic, resulting into a
infinite circulation, we are approaching a new phase multitude of medium/small-scale interventions on
based on transparency, proximity, coexistence, sys- the medium small scale that are the points of activa-
temic integration and circularity. tion or switching of the metabolic flows.
What kind of urban facilities do we imagine for this In a distributed and decentralized system, the role
scenario? To this question tried to answer the vision of these physical intermediate nodes related to
Urban Metabolism: sustainable development of Rot- waste management becomes meaningful in order
terdam presented in 2014 at the Biennale of Architec- to embed and to steer flows. These new glocal ar-
ture, Urban by Nature, in Rotterdam. The proposal, eas of ‘friction’ stimulate a civic attitude to change.
co-ordinated by Fabric together with a multidiscipli- The challenge that contemporary design faces is to
126 nary team, presents a systematic approach and out- apply the principles of proximity, self-sufficiency
Fig. 7 — Circular utility facilities for Rotterdam
Massaro
(2014). Proposal by FABRIC. Source: Urban
metabolism: sustainable development of
Rotterdam, IABR, Rotterdam, 2014, pp. 85, 90.
and environmental sustainability, combining them foregoes the rooftop. Depending on site conditions,
with improved living conditions and daily habits. on the roof can be produced food, within the com-
The relations between these principles are well ex- munity organic garden, and generated on-site ener-
pressed by the prototype for a neighbourhood com- gy with photovoltaic solar panels.
munity hub proposed by Sepia Design for the city Mapping urban intersection points of flows (humans
of Honk Kong. It is a multi-story building combin- and non-human) helps to identify new spatial con-
ing together recycling, community, leisure and edu- ditions and locational patterns to build a distribut-
cational activities. According to the scheme, an on- ed infrastructure of small/medium sized waste fa-
site composting centre and a waste treatment cen- cilities. Mid-size facilities are, in this design strategy,
tre are located in the basement, in order to ensure elements able to produce new urbanity, along with a
odour and noise prevention. At the ground level, ve- wide range of functions. What are the conventional
hicles can access to a material sorting and process- points of connection between various urban systems
ing area. Three upper floors host flea&food markets where a design strategy can promote a more circular
(with a food waste recovery centre) and repair & up- metabolism? The strategy proposes to redefine the
cycling laboratories next to a retail gallery. A level spatial organization of waste infrastructure through
providing multi-purpose function room for commu- identifying three urban systems: infrastructures;
nity meetings, educational events and exhibitions knowledge networks; production and commerce. 127
seconda serie
2018
01
ri-vista
128
opposite page
Massaro
Fig. 8 — Prototype for a Neighbourhood Recycling
Centre in Honk Kong. Source: Sepia Design.
Fig. 9 — The Cringle Dock’s waste transfer station
along the river Thames, London. Project by arch.
Rafael Vinoly, 2015. Source: www-wrwa.gov.uk.
01
2018
seconda serie
(Acebillo, 2013). Markets, supermarkets and com- manufacturing laboratories (see FabLab and Mak-
mercial districts are convergence nodes where de- ersSpace), is an incentive factor for reviewing the
veloped local synergies and close metabolic loops. symbolic and functional status of collecting cen-
Locating everyday places as ‘producer’ spaces leads tres and transfer stations. By leveraging on hybridi-
to waste management being regarded as a system zation, digitization and service delivery, they can be
similar to the proximity economy and solidarity net- considered part of a wider ecosystem.
works. Moreover, going to the market citizens can
simultaneously confer waste and buy new goods, Unblackboxing: an Architectural Agenda for
and thanks to reverse vending services, they shift Waste
attitude from users to active prosumers. Waste management model is easily associable with
The evolution of territorial chains, along with the a ‘black box’ model: the composition of flows is
130 rapid diffusion of innovation spaces and digital not known exactly and the behaviour of the man-
Fig. 10 — Top view of an UVA project (Medellin),
Massaro
2015. Predominant are pedestrian paths and the
use of artificial lighting, Source: www.epm.com.co
01
2018
of a shared imaginary through participatory process- til the scale of the building, where communal areas
seconda serie
es with locals and stakeholders. can be reconfigured to welcome new devices for the
daily waste collection.
Conclusions The current reflection outlines how crucial is to pro-
In the intermediate spaces identified by the map- vide a combinations of activities and functions, in
ping, there happens a conflict between an industri- order to avoid marginalization and failure of waste
al model and a civic approach to the issue of waste. management infrastructure. Its architectural and
There a transition takes place. Architecture is called social legitimation comes across the assimilation
to define new hybrid models and to find new urban of waste utility facilities to any other kind of pub-
coexistences, enabling relations and changing cul- lic facilities.
tural patterns previously considered incompatible.
The proposed scenario shifts the terms of the dis-
course from the building as a solution to an opera-
tional strategy that identifies the fields of interven-
tion, where flows and vectors are the elements that
regulate the joint and the use of urban space. The
intention to operate in terms of fields and flows is
guided by the precise intent to reconnect interrupt-
ed ties, reactivating cycles, reduce inefficiencies and
generate new values. A focus on waste as a driv-
er for urban changes introduces in the architecture
discipline significant innovation aspects, whose
singularity emerges to the different design scales.
Starting from territorial level, where infrastructure
and facilities affect the value of the landscape, to
urban settlements scale, where the redevelopment
of abandoned or marginal areas can help to regen-
132 erate physically and socially some urban fields, un-
Massaro
References
Aa.Vv. 2014, Urban Metabolism: sustainable development of Massaro S., 2016, La raccolta dei rifiuti solidi urbani nella città
Rotterdam, Mediacenter, Rotterdam. dispersa, in Drosscape: progetti di trasformazione nel territorio
Acebillo J. 2013, A new urban metabolism: Barcelona / Luga- dal mare a Roma, ed. R. Secchi, M. Alecci, A. Bruschi, P. Guari-
no, Actar, New York. ni, Aracne, Roma. pp. 287-295.
Alba Ramis I. 2015, Los paisajes del desecho: reactivación de Timmeren A. van, 2014, The concept of Urban Metabolism
los lugares del deterioro, PhD dissertation, Universidad Po- (UM), TU Delft. <https://urbanmetabolism.weblog.tudelft.
litecnica de Madrid, Escuela Tecnica Superior de Arquitectura. nl/files/2016/07/05a_UrbanMetabolism_VanTimmeren.
Bonneuil C., Fressoz J.B. 2016, The shock of the Anthropocene: pdf> (10/16).
the Earth, history and us, Versobooks. Miflin C., Spertus J., Miller B., Grace C. (eds) 2017, Zero waste
Carta M., Lino B., 2015, Urban hyper-metabolism, Aracne, Ro- design guidelines. Design Strategies and Case Studies for a
ma. Zero-Waste City, The Center for Architecture <http://www.
zerowastedesign.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/10/Ze-
Domínguez Rubio and Fogué U. 2015, Unfolding the political
roWasteDesignGuidelines2017_Web.pdf> (04/18).
capacities of design. In What is cosmopolitical design? Design,
nature and the built environment, ed. A. Yaneva, A. Zaera-Po- UN-Habitat 2016, World Cities Report. <http://wcr.unhabi-
lo, Ashgate, pp. 143-160. tat.org/main-report/> (12/16).
Graham S. Thrift N., 2007, Out of order: understanding repair
and maintenance, «Theory Culture Society», 24 (3):1-25, Sage
Publications, London, pp. 1-25.
Graham S. 2010, Disruptive cities: when infrastructure fails,
Routledge, New York.
Lindner C. Meissner M., 2016, Global garbage: urban imaginar-
ies of waste, excess, and abandonment, Routledge, New York.
MacBride S. 2011, Recycling reconsidered. The present fail-
ure and future promise of environmental action in the United
States, MIT Press, Cambridge.
Mamì A. 2014, Circular processes for a new urban metabolysm:
the role of municipal solid waste in the sustainable requalifica-
tion, «Techne: Journal of Technology for Architecture and En-
vironment», 08, Firenze University Press, pp. 171-180.
Manzini E. 2015, Design when everybody design, MIT Press,
Cambridge.
Marvin S., Medd W. 2010, Clogged cities: sclerotic infrastruc-
tures, in Disruptive cities: when infrastructure fails, ed. S. Gra-
ham, Routledge, New York, pp. 85-96.
133