Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
Since last reporting on group psycho- of him in furthering his own treatment.
therapy in 1942(1), we have greatly widened Part of the success of physical methods can
the scope of our methods. Further, we have be attributed to the fact that an organised
attempted to treat not only effort syndrome treatment r#{233}gimeis being carried out; and
(E. S.) patients but a group of 90 patients although the patient is passive, a definite
of whom about one-third are E. S. patients health goal is envisaged and during his treat-
and the remaining two-thirds mixed neu- ment he is working towards that goal. A
roses; mainly anxiety states and mild depres- similar programme, without a medicinal
sions. The patients are all in the British r#{233}gime, but in its place employing the pa-
armed forces, practically all army cases, and tient as a positive collaborator who partici-
represent the more chronic constitutionally pates in a definite programme of treatment
poorly endowed material, the ‘better’ neu- occupying many hours a week, and with a
roses going to the military neuroses centres. positive goal of recovery in view, is one of
Approximately o per cent of the cases re- the aims. Anyone working in a neuroses
turn to army service and the average dura- centre in war-time must have been struck by
tion of treatment in hospital is 6 weeks. the lack of insight into his neurosis of the
We have aimed at 2 separate goals: (i) average patient leaving hospital; such pa-
To develop specific teaching on the C. N. S. tients typically say they feel somewhat better
so that neurotic patients with somatic symp- for the rest and that they enjoyed the oc-
toms are enabled to evaluate their symptoms cupations or social activities, but seldom give
correctly and so avoid misinterpretation. any evidence of increased insight into their
(2) To give a general education in normal illness since being ‘treated,’ nor indeed do
and abnormal psychology with particular they seem to understand the general aims of
reference to the methods of handling every- psychiatric treatment. Surely such a state of
day problems so that normal standards of affairs cannot be reconciled with an adequate
living can be upheld and the general prin- treatment programme?
ciples of social psychiatry explained.
METHOD
In developing our methods we have had
as our primary aim the treatment of the The group of 8o to 90 patients in the
patients’ neuroses. It is hoped that by gain- wards meet for 6 hours a week-9 to I I a.m.
ing some degree of insight into the somatic on Monday, Wednesday and Friday. The
significance of symptoms and the more ob- activities may be discussed under three head-
vious psychological mechanisms involved in ings (i) Group talks-instruction on the
the production of mental ill-health, the in- structure and function of the central ner-
dividual not only feels that he is given a vous system with particular reference to the
positive role to play in his treatment, but somatic symptoms of anxiety. (2) Group
may be more competent to deal with future projection methods-dramatisation of actual
emotional problems. So far, short term case histories or common and important
in-patient treatment in neuroses centres in social problems. (3) General organization
England has frequently failed to achieve of nurses, patients, etc.
its maximal usefulness because the patient I. Group Talks.-One hour 3 times a week
is devoted to the study of the central nervous
has never really grasped what was demanded
system and its normal and abnormal func-
1 From Mill Hill Emergency Hospital, London, tioning. These talks have been given for the
England. A film of the hospital organization and past 2 years and we are satisfied that they
general plan of treatment was recently shown in
have a positive value. A course of 12 talks
America by Dr. W. S. Maclay, the medical super-
intendent. is given and as this takes i month and the
292
‘944] MAXWELL JONES 293
average length of stay in hospital is 6 weeks ately called by the patients. Each study
there are always some men in the group who indicates the main topic of one talk, e.g.,
have had the complete course. This makes it for talk 6 on nervous tension, ‘Nervy Ned’
possible to set the goal to be arrived at by is seen in the consulting room sitting uncom-
discussion, at the beginning of the meeting, fortably on the edge of his chair with all his
and to let the men work out the solution muscles tensed, anxious expression, staring
for themselves with a minimum of help. eyes, etc., and by contrast a composed con-
The subjects of the talks are the following: fident looking doctor, talking to him. The
i. The understanding of the voluntary lectures work from the normal to the abnor-
nervous system and its functions in main- mal (clockwise round the room), while the
taining external harmony, e.g., you find a ‘story of Nervy Ned’ of course goes in the
room too noisy so you get out. counter clockwise direction ending with him
2. The understanding of the internal milieu achieving internal and external harmony.
and the function of the involuntary nervous Captions below the pictures summarise the
system in maintaining harmony. talks and at the same time tell the story of
3. The two parts of the involuntary ner- ‘Nervy Ned.’ The main advantages derived
vous system and possible combinations, i.e., from these talks would appear to be:
the sympathetic acting as a whole and the I. The patient is given an idea of anatomy
para-sympathetic acting in part. and physiology sufficient to allow him to
4. Application of the previous two talks objectify his symptoms.
on external and internal harmony, e.g., it is 2. The discussion of symptoms (which
a hot day so what happens (a) in the think- he may or may not have) in an impersonal
ing part of your brain? and (b) in the auto- manner also tends to produce an objective
matic part? attitude towards his symptoms.
5. The understanding of fear (a) its 3. The conversation being on the patient’s
psychic and somatic aspects; (b) its teleo- favourite topic, i.e., Health, is of great inter-
logical value; (c) its ‘ordinariness.’ est to him.
6. “Nerves.” Nervous tension. Muscle 4. The situation is an informal one, and
tension.
the patients may be less tense than when be-
7. Relaxation. Anxious face. Awkward ing interviewed individually, and may there-
attitude. Restlessness in bed. Action poten-
fore be presumed to be more receptive.
tials and thinking.
5. The group acceptance of a point has a
8. Left chest pain and breathlessness.
strong suggestive value.
9. Circulation, cold blue hands, giddiness,
6. The patient’s self-respect is considered;
fainting, blanching, blushing, etc. Homeo-
to give up his organ neurosis would entail
stases and the efficient distribution of blood.
a loss of prestige in his own eyes and in those
io. Nervous dyspepsia.
of the outside world. This is countered if he
I i. Fatigue, nervous and muscular; f a-
can give a reasonable explanation of the
tigue of activity and of inactivity.
meaning of nervousness, and has a realisa-
12. Depression and insomnia.
tion of the enormous importance of this
The common room in which the talks are
factor in medicine.
held is important. It has been made into the
7. If he genuinely wants help he will be
most attractive room in the unit and com-
relieved to learn that no serious conse-
pletely redecorated and given bright cur-
quences need result from his symptoms.
tains, etc., by the patients and nurses them-
8. The opportunity for raising health prob-
selves. The walls are entirely covered by
15 paintings done by 2 nurses (both fully lems three times a week in open discussion
trained artists) and i patient. Three are leads to less health talk amongst the patients
2 X I yard anatomical studies illustrating themselves and, more important, leads to a
the voluntary and involuntary nervous sys- more critical and informed attitude by his
tems as though ramifying over a transparent audience in the ward.
glass man. The remaining 12 paintings tell 9. After a time the patients come to ap-
the story of ‘Nervy Ned’ as he is affection- preciate the ‘ordinariness’ of their symptoms.
294 GROUP TREATMENT [Nov.
3 had done so. The clinic has it seems to us personality comes to the clinic because of
all the prerequisites for satisfactory group depression. Her husband has been discharged
treatment. The setting is authentic and actual from the Army with a neurosis and he now
case histories may be portrayed. The prob- demands that she give up her interesting
lems and personality types are familiar and and profitable work to look after him. This
the patients have no difficulty in projecting she does willingly but the husband next de-
themselves into the situations presented. The mands that she give up her recently acquired
whole machinery of general psychiatry can friends whom he regards with suspicion al-
be condensed and brought into view within though he has never consented to meet them.
the space of a few minutes; case taking, The wife consents because she would do
interviewing with relatives, probation officers almost anything to help him but he does not
and social workers, letters to the court and improve and simply becomes more suspicious
to factory doctors and administrative heads and possessive. She is depressed and the
and all the ramifications of psychiatry into reason is obvious. When however the hus-
education, social life and the home can be band can be induced to come to the clinic
brought out. The progress of a case can for an interview to help his wife, he proves
be followed each fortnight and the audience to be unreasonable and uncooperative. The
given a glimpse of what goes on in the doc- need to treat the husband too then becomes
tor’s mind, as well as what passes at the apparent.
actual interview; this can be done by the 3. General Organization of Nurses, Pa-
doctor chatting with the clinic nurse during tients, Etc.-The unit of 90 beds is made up
the interval between the ushering in of each of 8 wards (one for modified insulin treat-
clinic patient. This is important because ment, one for continuous narcosis treatment
such information can be imparted in play and the remaining 6 for mixed neurotic
form but would be impossible to indicate in material). Ten nurses are divided into two
the course of the usual individual psycho- shifts and all but two of the nurses are
theurapeutic situation. Thus, a woman of probationers. We have been greatly im-
ability who had held a responsible post in pressed by the high standard of work done
her father’s business before his death and by some girls within comparatively few weeks
was called up by the Ministry of Labour of their starting training. Each nurse is
and given factory work to do, might develop given two wards to look after and is ex-
an anxiety state which was treated at the pected to read the doctor’s case notes and
clinic by sedative, discussion and rehabilita- grasp the therapeutic aim in each of her
tion. The situational difficulty could be dis- cases. She is encouraged to spend all the
cussed with her at length but it might be time she can in the ward and, if possible,
desirable to withhold certain aspects of the become an integral part of the ward group.
total situation and these would come to light Up to a point she is prepared to “mother”
during the doctor’s conversation with the the men, buying cake for their evening cup of
clinic nurse after the patient had left. To her tea, etc. No attempt is made to hide the fact
he might indicate that the work recom- that the nurse has a loyalty to the doctor and
mended for her when writing to the factory hospital as well as to the ward group; no
doctor was fairly responsible private secre- difficulty has ever been experienced in this
tarial work, preferably under one of the direction and when, as frequently happens,
company’s minor officials, so that her need a patient is asked to attend a nurses’ ward
for a prop and some form of father figure lecture so that they may learn from his
could be met and at the same time her self- case, he invariably does so willingly. Two
esteem bettered by giving her higher grade nurses’ ward lectures are held each week-
work of a familiar kind. An opportunity is one is purely for teaching, case problems
given for demonstrating failures in treat- being discussed, while the other is a general
ment due to lack of cooperation on the part meeting primarily concerned with policy. At
of the patient. The harmful effect that a the latter meeting constant revision and scru-
neurotic may have on his healthy contacts tiny of group methods by the nurses and
can be demonstrated. Thus a girl of excellent doctors concerned are carried out. The
296 GROUP TREATMENT [Nov.
doctor must be prepared to give in to the value of such methods properly applied to
wishes of the nurses when occasion arises the teaching of school children in the prophy-
because it is keenly felt by all that unless laxis of psychiatric disorders. But even here
the staff morale is high the whole practice the resulting benefit might prove to be dis-
of group treatment must fail no matter how appointingly small; e.g., there is no reason
sound the method. The nurses conduct a to think that adolescents at secondary schools
dancing class for beginners twice a week but are less prone to neuroses than adolescents
no pressure is brought to bear on non-danc- who have had only an elementary schooling;
ers whose temperament makes them unfitted education, by widening the subject’s horizon,
for this type of social activity; every fort- at the same time increases his personal re-
night the men act as hosts at a dance given sponsibilities and increases potential sources
in the ward to a group of 30 girls from a of conflict. In connexion with ‘prophylactic
nearby instrument factory and it is inter- teaching’ in schools, it must also be borne
esting to note how much better the men in mind that the adolescent is not ready
respond to these “normal” girls than they for certain information, e.g., while a certain
do when in the company of the female amount of sex education might profitably
neuroses patients at the weekly hospital be given to adolescents there is much teach-
dance. ing which is better withheld until the infor-
Redecorating the wards with the .iurses, mation is needed; only then can it be prop-
the nurses’ visits to the patients’ occupa- erly assessed by the individual. To teach
tions departments, the informal discussion contraception to an adolescent girl might
of the morning’s group talk or play in the invite harmful emotional conflicts and later
wards that evening and the active interest frigidity, whereas such information given
shown in the patients’ home life by the at the right time might have just the opposite
nurses, all contribute to a positive group effect. Adult education is a problem which
atmosphere in the wards. The group spirit no country has yet tackled seriously in a
is confined mainly to the ward and does not coordinated way. We believe that school
noticeably extend to the unit as a whole. education and adult education are both neces-
Lastly, one hour a week is set aside for sary if the fullest possible attempt at pro-
a general meeting of the entire ward-pa- phylactic psychiatry is to be made at the
tients, nurses and doctors. The men are present time; whether the need for adult
encouraged to suggest improvements in the education in this sphere will ever be elimi-
ward organisation, raise criticisms, and if nated is an open question. It is fully realised
possible their suggestions and difficulties are that a psychiatrist has far less qualification
dealt with on the spot, so that they are given for adult education than an educationist but
an immediate feeling of accomplishment, or he has his own specific contribution to make.
their idea is rejected without delay. Such a The system of group treatment outlined
meeting of the ward group with everyone above does not lend itself to an analysis into
present and decisions quickly made and acted its various component parts. Needless to
on does something to combat the patients’ say it has a different significance for differ-
inertia, which in a neurotic ward is the big- ent patients depending on their intelligence,
gest single obstacle to treatment. This oc- interest, personality and nature of their emo-
casion is also used for raising any difficulties tional difficulties. The following is the gen-
the nursing staff may be having with the eral aim of this form of treatment bearing
patients, and for making announcements of in mind that it in no way obviates the need
general interest. for individual psychotherapy.
The group talks developed in response to
DISCUSSION a definite need for factual education on the
The methods of group treatment described C. N. S. and the nature of vegetative symp-
aim at educating the subject. The question toms. The patients were at first all effort
immediately arises as to what are the pos- syndrome patients and they appear to us to
sibilities of educational methods in the treat- form the group ‘par excellence’ for this type
ment of the neuroses. None would deny the of explanatory approach; their vegetative
‘9441 MAXWELL JONES 297