Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
Module 1:
WELCOME TO THE WORLD
OF MULTILATERAL
CONFERENCES
__________________________________________________________________________________________________________
United Nations Institute for Training and Research (UNITAR)
Copyright © 2006 IAM/UNITAR
www.unitar.org/diplomacy
Disclaimer and copyright
The opinions expressed in this course publication or in any other information resource
provided with this material are those of the contributors and do not necessarily reflect the
views of the United Nations Institute for Training and Research (UNITAR), any of the other
United Nations organs, bodies and agencies, or other organizations.
The designation employed and the presentation of material in this course publication by the
contributors or in any other information resource provided with this course publication do not
imply the expression of any opinion whatsoever on the part of the United Nations Institute for
Training and Research (UNITAR) concerning the legal status of any country, territory, city or
area or its authorities, or concerning the delimitation of its frontiers and boundaries.
Material in this course publication may be freely quoted if properly acknowledged. A paper or
electronic copy of the publication containing the quotation or reprint should be sent to the
Multilateral Diplomacy and International Affairs Management Programme, United Nations
Institute for Training and Research (UNITAR), Palais des Nations, CH-1211 Geneva 10,
Switzerland. E-mail: diplomacy@unitar.org
The following organizations provided information resources to enhance this training course
material: British Broadcasting Corporation; Earth Negotiations Bulletin/IISD; International
Committee of the Red Cross; International Telecommunications Union; United Nations
Information Services; United Nations Photo; Voice of America. Information resources provided
by the above-mentioned organizations and contained in this training material may not be used
or reproduced without their permission.
___________________________________________________________________________________________________
United Nations Institute for Training and Research (UNITAR)
Copyright © 2006 IAM/UNITAR
www.unitar.org/diplomacy
2
PERFORMING EFFECTIVELY IN MULTILATERAL
CONFERENCES AND DIPLOMACY
Contents
1. Objectives
2. Introduction
2.1 Many conferences and many kinds
2.2 Systems of conferences
2.3 Functions of conferences
2.4 Real-world outcomes
Annexes
Glossary of Terms / Definitions
Further Readings and External Links
Video and Audio Transcripts
_________________________________________________________________________________________________________
_
United Nations Institute for Training and Research (UNITAR)
Copyright © 2006 IAM/UNITAR
www.unitar.org/diplomacy
Performing Effectively in Multilateral Conferences and Diplomacy
Module 1 - Welcome to the World of Multilateral Conferences
Key to Icons
Warning… exception to
general rules or common
errors
Audio clip
Questions
Document to download
___________________________________________________________________________________________________
United Nations Institute for Training and Research (UNITAR)
Copyright © 2006 IAM/UNITAR
www.unitar.org/diplomacy
4
Performing Effectively in Multilateral Conferences and Diplomacy
Module 1 - Welcome to the World of Multilateral Conferences
1. Objectives
___________________________________________________________________________________________________
United Nations Institute for Training and Research (UNITAR)
Copyright © 2006 IAM/UNITAR
www.unitar.org/diplomacy
5
Performing Effectively in Multilateral Conferences and Diplomacy
Module 1 - Welcome to the World of Multilateral Conferences
Video 1
Mr. Marcel Boisard, United Nations Assistant
Secretary General and Executive Director, UNITAR,
speaking on Geneva: A Hub of International
Organizations and Multilateral Conferences and
Diplomacy.
Video courtesy of United Nations Office at Geneva (UNOG) and
UNITAR
___________________________________________________________________________________________________
United Nations Institute for Training and Research (UNITAR)
Copyright © 2006 IAM/UNITAR
www.unitar.org/diplomacy
6
Performing Effectively in Multilateral Conferences and Diplomacy
Module 1 - Welcome to the World of Multilateral Conferences
This video requires “Real Video” player. Please make sure your computer
has the player and that your speakers are properly configured and switched on.
Video Transcript: A transcript of this video can be read at the end of this module. Please
see Annex, Video 1.
Some of the most noteworthy conferences are the recurring sessions of the
UN General Assembly (GA) and the Economic and Social Council (ECOSOC),
as well as the meetings of the Security Council, the G8 Summit, the Council
of Ministers of the European Union, the Assembly of the African Union and
other regional organizations, etc. The great multitude and diversity of
conferences enables us to identify different categories:
Expert Meetings. At the other extreme, in that they have a much lower
public profile and are far less solemn, are meetings at which the
participants are individuals selected for their scientific or technical expertise
on the subject matter of the conference. Because of this, they are not
called upon to represent the political preferences of their governments and
such meetings usually do not attempt to make decisions which engage
governments, although they may decide to recommend a technical
measure or standard to another conference which is capable of making
such decisions. Many of the UN specialized agencies and other
organizations and programmes organize expert meetings regularly to
further their work programmes and activities.
___________________________________________________________________________________________________
United Nations Institute for Training and Research (UNITAR)
Copyright © 2006 IAM/UNITAR
www.unitar.org/diplomacy
7
Performing Effectively in Multilateral Conferences and Diplomacy
Module 1 - Welcome to the World of Multilateral Conferences
the International Conference of the Red Cross and Red Crescent and the
Council of the International Organization for Migration (IOM).
Video 2
Donor Conferences: Responding to the Threat of
Bird Flu.
Video courtesy of VOA news
This video requires “Real Video” player. Please make sure your computer
has the player and that your speakers are properly configured and switched on.
Video Transcript: A transcript of this video can be read at the end of this module. Please
see Annex, Video 2.
___________________________________________________________________________________________________
United Nations Institute for Training and Research (UNITAR)
Copyright © 2006 IAM/UNITAR
www.unitar.org/diplomacy
9
Performing Effectively in Multilateral Conferences and Diplomacy
Module 1 - Welcome to the World of Multilateral Conferences
___________________________________________________________________________________________________
United Nations Institute for Training and Research (UNITAR)
Copyright © 2006 IAM/UNITAR
www.unitar.org/diplomacy
10
Performing Effectively in Multilateral Conferences and Diplomacy
Module 1 - Welcome to the World of Multilateral Conferences
The numbers and types of conferences taking place in both standing bodies
and in ad hoc arrangements can easily give rise to a system of conferences
(and negotiations). Although (and indeed because) each conference has a
specific purpose, several conferences often deal with different aspects or
stages of the same broad or narrow topic, and texts produced by one
conference are later taken up in one or more other conferences. In various
thematic areas, such as trade, human rights, environment and sustainable
development, this conference system is quite extensive with meetings and
their products intricately linked. In many cases, linkages across
conferences are mutually reinforcing, in the sense that each conference
helps the others to achieve their objectives. This is the case in the area of
criminal trade in narcotic drugs, where at least three dozen conferences are
___________________________________________________________________________________________________
United Nations Institute for Training and Research (UNITAR)
Copyright © 2006 IAM/UNITAR
www.unitar.org/diplomacy
11
Performing Effectively in Multilateral Conferences and Diplomacy
Module 1 - Welcome to the World of Multilateral Conferences
organized yearly to deal with this topic in a variety of ways. It is also the
case where global conferences require the organization of regional
conferences (or vice versa) to give practical effect to the implementation of
a conference outcome.
While there are many instances of conferences (and their products) being
mutually reinforcing, conferences can also appear to run against each other
in terms of mandates, objectives and approaches. This happens, for
example, when an issue that has been considered from one perspective is
subsequently re-examined from another. To provide just one example, the
Working Group on Access to Genetic Resources and Benefit-sharing,
established as a follow-up negotiating conference of the Convention on
Biological Diversity (CBD) and convened under the auspices of UNEP, is
confronted with complex linkages to the outcomes of previous negotiations,
such as the WTO Agreement on Trade-related Aspects of Intellectual
Property Rights (TRIPS), the FAO International Treaty on Plant and Genetic
Resources for Food and Agriculture and the World Intellectual Property
Organization (WIPO) Patent Cooperation Treaty.
1
Most international conferences are composed (at least in part) by delegates who are
formally representatives of States but, in practice, are answerable to their respective
governments. However, at a number of conferences the delegates represent specific
government agencies, as in the case, for example, of Interpol, where membership may be
delegated by a country to its official police body.
___________________________________________________________________________________________________
United Nations Institute for Training and Research (UNITAR)
Copyright © 2006 IAM/UNITAR
www.unitar.org/diplomacy
13
Performing Effectively in Multilateral Conferences and Diplomacy
Module 1 - Welcome to the World of Multilateral Conferences
Conferences can set norms, rules and standards in at least three ways:
These do not have the force of law because governments have not made formal
commitments to enforce them, but they do respond to a widespread need for
international standards in many fields. For this reason, they tend to be adopted
voluntarily and are often incorporated or other wise reflected in national
legislation, the rules of professional bodies and general practice. In this way
they become norms or international standards which are often just as effective
as those codified in treaties.
The third way in which a conference can help standards to become established
is by repeated exhortation. If conferences repeatedly applaud and encourage a
particular course of action or pattern of behaviour, and if they denounce
infractions against these, the majority of the world’s governments are in effect
making a statement as to what action or behaviour is correct and permissible:
in other words, they are expressing, reinforcing or some times creating
standards.
___________________________________________________________________________________________________
United Nations Institute for Training and Research (UNITAR)
Copyright © 2006 IAM/UNITAR
www.unitar.org/diplomacy
14
Performing Effectively in Multilateral Conferences and Diplomacy
Module 1 - Welcome to the World of Multilateral Conferences
This observation prompts the question: how can you change the world, to
make it better for all humankind, including your country? One example of
how this has been done is given in the following video which, although
filmed as an animated version of events that took place some 150 years
ago, has important parallels in what takes place today.
___________________________________________________________________________________________________
United Nations Institute for Training and Research (UNITAR)
Copyright © 2006 IAM/UNITAR
www.unitar.org/diplomacy
15
Performing Effectively in Multilateral Conferences and Diplomacy
Module 1 - Welcome to the World of Multilateral Conferences
Video 3
The Story of an Idea.
Video courtesy of International Committee of the Red Cross (ICRC)
This video requires “Real Video” player. Please make sure your computer
has the player and that your speakers are properly configured and switched on.
Video Transcript: A transcript of this video can be read at the end of this module. Please
see Annex, Video 3.
In this short video, we see how an idea originated in the mind of one
individual, Henry Dunant, and how the idea was disseminated (through his
book, A Memory of Solferino, and the groups that were formed to develop
and promote his ideas) and found a receptive public and hence was taken
up by governments, leading to the adoption of the First Geneva Convention
of 1864 on the laws of war and the International Committee for the Relief
to the Wounded (later to become the International Committee of the Red
Cross). The point of special interest to us is that once governments became
interested in the idea, an international conference was organized to discuss
it and, subsequently, a second conference, the Diplomatic Conference, to
finalize the text of the Convention.
Parallel processes lie behind all the international organizations, treaties and
programmes that exist today. In each case, first came the idea; then its
wide discussion, development and ultimate acceptance (sometimes starting
outside government, often confined to official instances), followed by a
succession of international conferences to further explore and refine the
concept and to transform it into an internationally agreed text. This is one
of the most effective ways of changing the world, far more so than anything
most governments can do on their own or exclusively through bilateral
diplomacy.
___________________________________________________________________________________________________
United Nations Institute for Training and Research (UNITAR)
Copyright © 2006 IAM/UNITAR
www.unitar.org/diplomacy
16
Performing Effectively in Multilateral Conferences and Diplomacy
Module 1 - Welcome to the World of Multilateral Conferences
It is easy for conference delegates to get heavily involved in their work and
in matters whose importance is largely confined to the conference room
(e.g. who prevails in negotiations over a small detail or who gets elected to
a prestigious position), and they run the risk of forgetting the real-world
consequences of what is done (or more often not done) in the conference
room. Quite literally human lives are often at stake, as is the general
security and well being of countries. Conferences in the UN system are
mainly directed at addressing the woes of humankind: poverty, disease,
underdevelopment, environmental degradation, oppression, insecurity, etc.
The exchange of information among governments, constructive discussion
of the relevant issues, well
You can
formulated standards, effective
international programmes and wise,
well informed and efficient decision-
This is the most basic reason why conference diplomats need to be well
versed in the skills of their trade so that they can use them to produce a
better world for all of humankind, including the portion thereof which they
represent.
___________________________________________________________________________________________________
United Nations Institute for Training and Research (UNITAR)
Copyright © 2006 IAM/UNITAR
www.unitar.org/diplomacy
17
Performing Effectively in Multilateral Conferences and Diplomacy
Module 1 - Welcome to the World of Multilateral Conferences
3.1 Mandates
We have listed above some of the functions which conferences can serve. It
follows that the purpose of each conference is likely to be one or more of
these. The purpose of each conference will have been decided before
governments are invited to send representatives. Very often in the UN
system the decision to hold a conference for a particular purpose is taken
by a prior conference. Two examples are:
___________________________________________________________________________________________________
United Nations Institute for Training and Research (UNITAR)
Copyright © 2006 IAM/UNITAR
www.unitar.org/diplomacy
18
Performing Effectively in Multilateral Conferences and Diplomacy
Module 1 - Welcome to the World of Multilateral Conferences
In one of the decisions of the first COP of the UNFCCC, in 1995, Parties
decided to further discussions on commitments for industrialized countries,
referred to in Annex 1 of the Convention. This decision, known as the Berlin
Mandate, paved negotiations for the adoption of the Kyoto Protocol in 1997.
Agrees to begin a process to enable it to take appropriate action for the period
beyond 2000, including the strengthening of the commitments of the Parties
included in Annex I to the Convention (Annex I Parties) in Article 4, paragraph
2(a) and (b), through the adoption of a protocol or another legal instrument: …
II.
___________________________________________________________________________________________________
United Nations Institute for Training and Research (UNITAR)
Copyright © 2006 IAM/UNITAR
www.unitar.org/diplomacy
19
Performing Effectively in Multilateral Conferences and Diplomacy
Module 1 - Welcome to the World of Multilateral Conferences
Question 1
Permissive and limiting conference mandates
In the section quoted, the mandate is permissive in that it clearly invites the
COP to elaborate policies and measures, as well as to set quantified limitation
and reduction objectives within specific timeframes for Annex 1 Parties under
the Convention. It also indicates a readiness to receive recommendations that
involve departures from the paragraphs it describes as inadequate.
___________________________________________________________________________________________________
United Nations Institute for Training and Research (UNITAR)
Copyright © 2006 IAM/UNITAR
www.unitar.org/diplomacy
20
Performing Effectively in Multilateral Conferences and Diplomacy
Module 1 - Welcome to the World of Multilateral Conferences
Question 2
Why is it incoherent to say: “I am not very interested in global
or regional conferences, my focus is the needs of my own
country”? Think about the answer and to see below our
suggested response.
___________________________________________________________________________________________________
United Nations Institute for Training and Research (UNITAR)
Copyright © 2006 IAM/UNITAR
www.unitar.org/diplomacy
21
Performing Effectively in Multilateral Conferences and Diplomacy
Module 1 - Welcome to the World of Multilateral Conferences
___________________________________________________________________________________________________
United Nations Institute for Training and Research (UNITAR)
Copyright © 2006 IAM/UNITAR
www.unitar.org/diplomacy
22
Performing Effectively in Multilateral Conferences and Diplomacy
Module 1 - Welcome to the World of Multilateral Conferences
___________________________________________________________________________________________________
United Nations Institute for Training and Research (UNITAR)
Copyright © 2006 IAM/UNITAR
www.unitar.org/diplomacy
23
Performing Effectively in Multilateral Conferences and Diplomacy
Module 1 - Welcome to the World of Multilateral Conferences
In the next section we will learn how these three different categories of
purposes interact, but before we turn to that question, we need to dispel a
widely believed fallacy. This is the idea that the outcome of an international
conference is largely determined by the relative power of the countries
represented.
The general rule is that the leading delegations are those which
contribute most to determining the outcome of the conference. Many
factors can come into such a leadership role but the most obvious one is
not the power of the country represented but the ability to develop
proposals which attract widespread support because they meet the
objectives of many delegations. There is also power, in a conference, in a
willingness to consult widely and take account of the views of other
delegations and in the ability to operate within the rules of procedure and
more generally to understand the sometimes arcane conference process.
This course aims to increase your power in these respects.
___________________________________________________________________________________________________
United Nations Institute for Training and Research (UNITAR)
Copyright © 2006 IAM/UNITAR
www.unitar.org/diplomacy
24
Performing Effectively in Multilateral Conferences and Diplomacy
Module 1 - Welcome to the World of Multilateral Conferences
Later modules will take us in detail through the various aspects of the work
of a conference, but at this stage we will introduce eleven basic elements
which are common to all conferences and quite fundamental to
understanding how they work.
4.1 Mandate
4.2 Delegates
In the UN system, the term NGO applies not only to not-for-profit, civil society
organizations, but also to business associations, the private sector and
academia. In many conferences and particularly those organized to discuss
economic and social development, the environment, labor, health and human
rights issues, NGOs have become highly visible. In fact, NGO delegates
accredited to some conferences outnumber government delegates by a margin
of 4 to 1.
In some cases, NGOs are full members of conferences and, as such, send
delegates who participate alongside the delegates representing States. This is
the case in the annual International Labour Conference and in the meetings of
the ILO’s Executive Council.
At some conferences, duly accredited NGOs are invited to send observers. This
was the case with the former Commission on Human Rights (now the Human
Rights Council) and is the case with many conferences on the environment and
sustainable development. Some NGOs are also implementing partners for
various UN agencies and programmes. They can be represented at some
conferences in that capacity (e.g. some donor conferences).
Some national delegations include members of NGOs (it is the sovereign right of
any State to determine the composition of its own delegation). And some
governments at times engage an NGO to act as their representative in an
international conference (for example where that NGO has particular skills or
knowledge).
___________________________________________________________________________________________________
United Nations Institute for Training and Research (UNITAR)
Copyright © 2006 IAM/UNITAR
www.unitar.org/diplomacy
26
Performing Effectively in Multilateral Conferences and Diplomacy
Module 1 - Welcome to the World of Multilateral Conferences
Credentials
1. that they represent the State or other entity which they claim to
represent; and
2. that that entity is entitled to send a representative to the conference.
Any delegate can at any time query the credentials of another delegation. A
frivolous or quarrelsome query could be costly to the delegation raising it,
as a majority of delegations would see this as inappropriate and inimical to
their objectives. However, there are some situations in which a challenge is
unavoidable. For example, if (as has occurred) two governments or two
delegations claim to represent the same State; or if there are grounds for
questioning a State’s right to participate in the conference (e.g. following
the break up of the Federal Socialist Republic of Yugoslavia and the demise
of that State, several UN members objected to the Federal Republic of
Yugoslavia’s claim that as successor State, it automatically inherited the
FRSY membership.)
The final and perhaps most important observation about delegates (and
other participants) is this: these are the people who actually perform the
conference. Everything that happens there is in their hands and hostage to
their individual abilities and frailties. You, and your fellow delegates, have
___________________________________________________________________________________________________
United Nations Institute for Training and Research (UNITAR)
Copyright © 2006 IAM/UNITAR
www.unitar.org/diplomacy
28
Performing Effectively in Multilateral Conferences and Diplomacy
Module 1 - Welcome to the World of Multilateral Conferences
centre stage and personal responsibility for the course and outcome of the
conference.
4.3 Bureau
Every conference needs to be managed, which means it needs a manager
(known as chairman) or management team. Usually in the UN system, this
team is elected by the conference; but it is appointed in some
circumstances (mainly for some working groups, expert groups, contact
groups, etc.)
___________________________________________________________________________________________________
United Nations Institute for Training and Research (UNITAR)
Copyright © 2006 IAM/UNITAR
www.unitar.org/diplomacy
29
Performing Effectively in Multilateral Conferences and Diplomacy
Module 1 - Welcome to the World of Multilateral Conferences
4.4 Secretariat
Every conference has one other conference officer: the secretary, who
heads the conference secretariat. The secretary and secretariat staff are
not elected; instead, they are international civil servants (often
members of the secretariat of an international organization or an ad hoc
body mandated to service a conference, sometimes a team specially
recruited from a variety of sources for a particular conference). As such,
they do not represent any State or party participating in the conference.
The informal role of the secretariat is much wider. They are a storehouse of
knowledge of precedent and procedure and as such well placed to advise
the chairman and delegations. More generally, they have a very important
role in disseminating information to delegations. Although they are
supposed to be impartial, in practice they are often committed to the
mandate of the conference and, as such, are natural allies of the chairman
and all delegations that do not want the conference to fail. In both their
formal and informal roles, the secretariat can be very helpful to
delegations.
___________________________________________________________________________________________________
United Nations Institute for Training and Research (UNITAR)
Copyright © 2006 IAM/UNITAR
www.unitar.org/diplomacy
31
Performing Effectively in Multilateral Conferences and Diplomacy
Module 1 - Welcome to the World of Multilateral Conferences
Wise delegates not only make full use of the assistance the secretariat can
give them, they also go out of their way to help the secretariat in every
way they can.
In December 2001, prior to the first phase of the World Summit on the
Information Society (WSIS), Switzerland (host of the Summit’s Geneva Phase)
organized in close cooperation with the ITU (secretariat of the Summit) the
Coppet Workshop to assist in identifying possible themes for discussion at the
Summit and the most effective way to prepare the Summit as a result of this
content. Following this workshop, Switzerland undertook a number of diplomatic
preparations, including organizing with the host of the Summit’s second phase,
Tunisia, informal consultations and information sessions on the concrete issues.
___________________________________________________________________________________________________
United Nations Institute for Training and Research (UNITAR)
Copyright © 2006 IAM/UNITAR
www.unitar.org/diplomacy
32
Performing Effectively in Multilateral Conferences and Diplomacy
Module 1 - Welcome to the World of Multilateral Conferences
Plenary
Drafting Committee
___________________________________________________________________________________________________
United Nations Institute for Training and Research (UNITAR)
Copyright © 2006 IAM/UNITAR
www.unitar.org/diplomacy
33
Performing Effectively in Multilateral Conferences and Diplomacy
Module 1 - Welcome to the World of Multilateral Conferences
In the following video, you will see the chairman of sub-committee 2 of the
third and final session of the Preparatory Committee of the first phase of
the World Summit on the Information Society (WSIS) propose the creation
of a working group to continue the negotiations on the draft Declaration of
Principles, which was one of the Summit’s principal outcomes.
Video 4
Organization of Work, Establishment of a Working
Group
H.E Mr. Asko Numminen, Ambassor, Finland,
Chairman, Sub‐committee 2, PrepCom 3 of the World
Summit for the Information Society. Geneva, 22
September 2003
Video courtesy of International Telecommunication Union (ITU)
This video requires “Real Video” player. Please make sure your computer
has the player and that your speakers are properly configured and switched on.
Video Transcript: A transcript of this video can be read at the end of this module. Please
see Annex, Video 4.
___________________________________________________________________________________________________
United Nations Institute for Training and Research (UNITAR)
Copyright © 2006 IAM/UNITAR
www.unitar.org/diplomacy
34
Performing Effectively in Multilateral Conferences and Diplomacy
Module 1 - Welcome to the World of Multilateral Conferences
But the committees and other subsidiary bodies do not take decisions on
behalf of the parent conference. Instead, they report to and can make
recommendations to the plenary. The plenary considers these reports and
recommendations and takes all the decisions (which usually follow the
committee’s recommendations but can depart from them). From this
relationship and division of work between the plenary and its subsidiaries, it
follows that subsidiary bodies tend to do more detailed work and more
negotiation and to be less formal and less open to the public than their
parent conferences. This is least pronounced in the case of large,
important, long established subsidiaries, such as the Main Committees of
the GA and the functional commissions of ECOSOC (which are very formal
and public); but it remains true of their subsidiary bodies.
Question 3
Negotiating v. Decision-making Forums
It seems likely that the main reason that this tradition became established is
that detailed discussion and especially negotiation often involve a degree of
discord, whereas decision-making is a matter of agreement or accord. The
prospects for agreement are enhanced if the venue in which it is to take place is
segregated from the arena of discord.
4.7 Venues
conferences behind the desk or table and, in large rooms, a microphone. All
the desks face a raised podium at which there are seats, nameplates and
microphones for the chairman, secretary and rapporteur. A variation on this
arrangement is used in conferences where the chairmanship rotates
monthly (examples are the Security Council where the table is a broken
circle and the Conference on Disarmament where it is a hollow square).
___________________________________________________________________________________________________
United Nations Institute for Training and Research (UNITAR)
Copyright © 2006 IAM/UNITAR
www.unitar.org/diplomacy
36
Performing Effectively in Multilateral Conferences and Diplomacy
Module 1 - Welcome to the World of Multilateral Conferences
In addition to these large conference rooms (which are used for plenary
and the main committees) there is a need for several smaller conference
rooms (the smallest often have desks arranged in a hollow square, no
nameplates and no microphones or interpretation) and extensive lobbies or
wide corridors. The uses which delegates make of these rooms will be
explained in Module 2.
___________________________________________________________________________________________________
United Nations Institute for Training and Research (UNITAR)
Copyright © 2006 IAM/UNITAR
www.unitar.org/diplomacy
37
Performing Effectively in Multilateral Conferences and Diplomacy
Module 1 - Welcome to the World of Multilateral Conferences
Just as a conference needs a manager it also needs a rule book. The rules
of procedure have been called the highway code of the conference. They
are a set of rules, which describe in detail how the conference should
operate. One of the main functions of the chairman is to apply the rules
and when necessary enforce them. Each conference has its own rules of
procedure, which it has adopted or received from a parent body (e.g.
ECOSOC has adopted a set of rules of procedure which apply to all of its
subsidiary bodies). In Module 2, Section 1, we will learn more about the
rules of procedure and how they impact on conferences and delegations.
4.9 Sovereignty
___________________________________________________________________________________________________
United Nations Institute for Training and Research (UNITAR)
Copyright © 2006 IAM/UNITAR
www.unitar.org/diplomacy
38
Performing Effectively in Multilateral Conferences and Diplomacy
Module 1 - Welcome to the World of Multilateral Conferences
2
In theory this means a conference could act beyond its mandate – but any such act is
likely to be futile as States are likely to refuse to give them any standing, since they would
be inconsistent with the terms under which States agreed to participate in the conference.
3
Except in so far as that State has given the conference authority to direct it, e.g. as the
signatories to the UN Charter have given to the Security Council in specified circumstances
and the parties to the statute of the World Health Organization give it in some respects.
___________________________________________________________________________________________________
United Nations Institute for Training and Research (UNITAR)
Copyright © 2006 IAM/UNITAR
www.unitar.org/diplomacy
39
Performing Effectively in Multilateral Conferences and Diplomacy
Module 1 - Welcome to the World of Multilateral Conferences
4
Consent and agreement are virtually synonymous, although more precisely, to agree is “to
say yes” and to consent is “not to say no when the time comes to make a decision.” Either
way, a State which agrees or consents to a decision, allows it to be made.
___________________________________________________________________________________________________
United Nations Institute for Training and Research (UNITAR)
Copyright © 2006 IAM/UNITAR
www.unitar.org/diplomacy
40
Performing Effectively in Multilateral Conferences and Diplomacy
Module 1 - Welcome to the World of Multilateral Conferences
Yet another set of consequences flow from the observation that conferences
can only act by agreement and that the only way you can achieve your
objectives is by the conference agreeing to a proposal which advances
those objectives. Anything which impedes agreement impedes your
achieving your objective. Conversely, if the conference is moving towards
agreement on a proposal contrary to your objectives, anything which
impedes agreement could help frustrate that proposal. But since the
proposal is one on which the conference was approaching agreement, that
means it is seen by most delegations as helpful to their objectives. They
will be resentful of any attempt to sabotage agreement and they will work
against the perpetrator. Impeding agreement or attempting to do so is not
only selfish, it can be costly. And the overwhelming majority will always be
on the side of agreement – as long as they are lucid. You have many
potential allies.
___________________________________________________________________________________________________
United Nations Institute for Training and Research (UNITAR)
Copyright © 2006 IAM/UNITAR
www.unitar.org/diplomacy
41
Performing Effectively in Multilateral Conferences and Diplomacy
Module 1 - Welcome to the World of Multilateral Conferences
___________________________________________________________________________________________________
United Nations Institute for Training and Research (UNITAR)
Copyright © 2006 IAM/UNITAR
www.unitar.org/diplomacy
42
Performing Effectively in Multilateral Conferences and Diplomacy
Module 1 - Welcome to the World of Multilateral Conferences
ANNEXES
Glossary of Terms / Definitions
ad hoc
contact group
parallel events
The head of a permanent mission. For some organizations the title may be
different (e.g. for the IAEA, the head is a resident representative).
___________________________________________________________________________________________________
United Nations Institute for Training and Research (UNITAR)
Copyright © 2006 IAM/UNITAR
www.unitar.org/diplomacy
43
Performing Effectively in Multilateral Conferences and Diplomacy
Module 1 - Welcome to the World of Multilateral Conferences
specialized agency
standard setting
treaty
For its specific legal meaning, see UN Treaty Collection – Treaty Reference
Guide. http://untreaty.un.org
UN system
The UN itself, together with all its main organs, subsidiary bodies, programs
and specialized agencies.
working language
___________________________________________________________________________________________________
United Nations Institute for Training and Research (UNITAR)
Copyright © 2006 IAM/UNITAR
www.unitar.org/diplomacy
44
Performing Effectively in Multilateral Conferences and Diplomacy
Module 1 - Welcome to the World of Multilateral Conferences
Zyss, Witold. “The International Civil Servant.” In M.A. Boisard and E.M.
Chossudovsky, Multilateral Diplomacy: The United Nations System at
Geneva, A Working Guide. The Hague: Kluwer Law International, 1998.
___________________________________________________________________________________________________
United Nations Institute for Training and Research (UNITAR)
Copyright © 2006 IAM/UNITAR
www.unitar.org/diplomacy
45
Performing Effectively in Multilateral Conferences and Diplomacy
Module 1 - Welcome to the World of Multilateral Conferences
3. Internet Links
Video Transcript 1
Geneva: A Hub of International Organizations and Multilateral Conferences and
Diplomacy, Marcel A. Boisard, Assistant Secretary General and Executive Director,
UNITAR
TEXT:
“With the largest concentration of inter‐governmental organizations in the world, the
city of Geneva is one of most important venues for multilateral conferences and
diplomacy. Today, Geneva is the home to over 30 such organizations, including the
United Nations Office at Geneva and a number of other important bodies, such as the
Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights and the Office of the UN High
Commissioner for Refugees. Geneva is also the headquarters of five of the UN
specialized agencies:
• the International Labour Organization,
• the World Health Organization,
• the International Telecommunications Union,
• the World Meteorological Organization, and
• the World Intellectual Property Organization.
In addition to the specialized agencies, Geneva also hosts a number of organizations,
including the World Trade Organization and the International Committee of the Red
Cross. The largest and most extensive office and conference complex in Geneva is the
Palais des Nations. Originally built for the League of Nations, the Palais houses today
the United Nations Office at Geneva and a number of other bodies, including
• the United Nations Economic Commission for Europe;
• the Conference on Disarmament, established in 1979 as the world’s single
multilateral negotiating forum on disarmament; and
• the United Nations Conference on Trade and Development.
___________________________________________________________________________________________________
United Nations Institute for Training and Research (UNITAR)
Copyright © 2006 IAM/UNITAR
www.unitar.org/diplomacy
46
Performing Effectively in Multilateral Conferences and Diplomacy
Module 1 - Welcome to the World of Multilateral Conferences
Beyond its secretariat role, the United Nations Office at Geneva has become the focal
point for multilateral diplomacy. It services over 8,000 meetings every year, ranging
from summits and ministerial conferences down to expert meetings, attracting over
28,000 delegates from around the world.
Among the different Geneva‐based specialized agencies, the ILO is particularly unique
in several respects. It emerged from the Treaty of Versailles in 1919 and then became
the first specialized agency in 1946 after the UN was founded. The ILO’s tripartite
structure clearly sets it aside from other organizations, with representatives from its
177 Member States and delegates representing workers and employers.
With Geneva’s complex horizontal network of intergovernmental organizations and
the presence of over 100 international NGOs, the city has clearly become a centre for
world discussion and debate on issues as broad as peace and security, disarmament,
human rights, humanitarian affairs, labour standards, health, telecommunications,
intellectual property, environment, trade and development. All told, some 15,000
meetings and conferences take place annually under the auspices of the various
organizations located in this important city and UN venue.”
Video Transcript 2
Donor Conferences: Responding to the Threat of Bird Flu
TEXT:
“Bird flu experts are urging wealthier countries to contribute some or all of the US $ 1.5
billion they say are needed to slow the spread of bird flu and to prepare for a potential
pandemic. Proceeds from the two‐day meeting sponsored by the European
Commission, the World Bank and the Government of China will allow poor countries
to carry out national programmes to control the disease. Experts say the battle against
bird flu needs more information sharing, access to vaccines and broad research.
China’s deputy foreign minister, Qiao Zonghuai, underscored the stakes for wealthy
and poor countries alike: “Facing as we are the avian flu situation, no country can
really maintain its integrity against the flu by itself.” Human cases of this deadly
disease are tied to contact with infected birds. Therefore, some of the funds raised at
the conference would be devoted to improvement of veterinary medicines and to
detection of the disease in poultry. That, in turn, could reduce the chances the virus
will mutate into a form that spreads directly between people, which might cause a
pandemic. Margaret Chan, the World Health Organization’s Asia Regional
Representative, says even delaying a pandemic is important: “Delaying it has two
advantages: number one would be that countries would be getting early warning, so
that they can gear up with their plans to prepare for the pandemic and the second
advantage is WHO, working with the collaborating centres, can gear up pandemic
___________________________________________________________________________________________________
United Nations Institute for Training and Research (UNITAR)
Copyright © 2006 IAM/UNITAR
www.unitar.org/diplomacy
47
Performing Effectively in Multilateral Conferences and Diplomacy
Module 1 - Welcome to the World of Multilateral Conferences
vaccine production.” The current outbreak of bird flu first appeared in Asia and has
spread to portions of Europe. The disease has claimed the lives of at least 79 people.
Peter Fedynsky, VOA news.”
Video Transcript 3
The Birth of an Idea: Henry Dunant’s Appeal that led to the Geneva International
Conference of 1863
TEXT:
“It was June 1859. A lone carriage struggled across Northern Italy. The gentleman
inside, the Geneva merchant Henry Dunant, was on important business. He was
determined to be given an audience by Napoleon III, the powerful emperor of France.
Dunant knew that Napoleon was now somewhere nearby with his troops. Dunant
suddenly found himself in the midst of a battlefield. Dunant was horrified. Outside the
normally quiet village of Solferino, the French and Austrian armies were fighting a
terrible battle. By evening, thousands lay dead, dying and wounded. But the medical
troops simply could not cope and the weary and bloodied soldiers on both sides had
enough to do just saving themselves and were fighting their way back to their lines.
Dunant forgot all else. Help was crucially needed. Resolutely, he set up a makeshift
hospital in a church in the village, where the dying and wounded could receive
attention and care in peace and quiet. He was joined by the villagers, the women, the
elderly, who tried to help as best they could. They treated the French and Austrians
alike, even taking care take to record and send their last goodbye to loved ones. Day
and night, they worked tirelessly, nursing the victims. Dunant finally returned to
Switzerland but he could not forget. His book, A Memory of Solferino, was published in
1862. Dunant proposed the establishment in every country of a neutral, independent
body of helpers who could provide protection and care for the wounded in case of war,
regardless of side. The idea was revolutionary and had found willing ears. Shortly
afterwards, Dunant and four other men, formed the International Committee of the
Red Cross (ICRC). In 1864, an international diplomatic conference in Geneva was
called. The result was the adoption of the first Geneva Convention for neutral
humanitarian aid and protection for wounded soldiers. Many years later, following the
First and Second World War, other visionaries added more Geneva conventions. These
help protect wounded, sick or shipwrecked sailors, prisoners of war, and civilians
affected by war. But it was Henry Dunant’s whose initiative and enterprise which
paved the way and made a difference, showing humanity amidst inhumanity. ”
___________________________________________________________________________________________________
United Nations Institute for Training and Research (UNITAR)
Copyright © 2006 IAM/UNITAR
www.unitar.org/diplomacy
48
Performing Effectively in Multilateral Conferences and Diplomacy
Module 1 - Welcome to the World of Multilateral Conferences
Video Transcript 4
Organization of Work, Establishment of a Working Group
H.E. Mr. Asko Numminen, Ambassor, Finland, Chairman, Sub‐committee 2, PrepCom
3 of the World Summit for the Information Society, Geneva, 22 September 2003
TEXT:
“Distinguished delegates, the meeting of the Subcommittee 2 is called to order. You
heard my report in Plenary, a moment ago, and as I said, I would like to discuss, firstly,
in this meeting, the organization of work. I would like thereafter to take appropriate
action. As you know we have still tremendous work to do in this Subcommittee. On
the Declaration, we have made good progress and we have a new text which is
available, but it contains a lot of square brackets. It has to be negotiated and agreed
upon. On the Plan of Action, you will have the English version of the new draft which
will be distributed in my name. Now, we have to consider how we organize the work
effectively. In my view it is absolutely necessary that we work separately on the
Declaration and the Plan of Action. My proposal is that our able facilitator, Lyndall
Shope‐Mafole (South Africa) will continue the work on the Declaration and she will
take the lead in the negotiations on that document. And my proposal is that this
Subcommittee will form a Working Group where Lyndall Shope‐Mafole will have the
chairmanship. This is the same modality that we used in PrepCom 2. And I hope that
we can decide on this matter in this meeting soon and, actually, when these
organizational matters have been considered in this Plenary, we can turn this Plenary
of the Subcommittee into the Working Group and Lyndall can start working with you
on the Declaration already this morning.”
___________________________________________________________________________________________________
United Nations Institute for Training and Research (UNITAR)
Copyright © 2006 IAM/UNITAR
www.unitar.org/diplomacy
49