Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
PEPSI
Goa Bottling Company Pvt. Ltd.
[Type text]
SELF DECLARATION
(signature)
2 | Page
EXAMINER CERTIFICATION
3 | Page
COLLEGE CERTIFICATION
Certified
4 | Page
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
Firstly, I would like to thank ‘God’ for his cordial and merciful
blessings which have enabled me to complete this project.
This project is an outcome of effort, guidance and channelization of
my teachers and parents.
I wish to extend my deepest regards and obligation to Mr. Anil
Agrawal (CEO, Sky Automobiles, Raipur) who has guided me in this
project and helped me in all possible ways to collect and analyse all
the data.
Also, without the help, kind support and valuable time given by my
elder brother Uday, this project could not have been possible.
I am obliged and grateful to my Professor Mr. Dinesh Kumar Soni
for his help and guidance in completing the project.
Last but not the least, my special gratitude goes to my friends and
classmates who indirectly assisted me in the successful completion of
this project. Thank you all for teaching me endlessly how to become
a better person, friend and student.
5 | Page
TABLE OF CONTENTS
1. Introductive Summary 7
1.1 Problem Introduction 9
2. Industry Introduction Profile 10
2.1 About Carbonated Soft Drinks 11
2.2 Global CSD Market 13
2.3 Indian CSD Market 21
2.4 Major Players in Indian CSD Industry 25
2.5 Porter’s Force Model 29
3. Introduction and Marketing Strategies of Goa 32
Bottling Factory Pvt. Ltd.
4. Research Methodology 39
4.1 Methodology 40
4.2 Sample Size 41
5. Data Analysis 43
5.1 Volume Analysis 44
5.2 SKU Mix Analysis 48
5.3 Bills Cut Analysis 51
5.4 Survey Analysis 54
6. Survey Findings 56
6.1 Present Study About GTM 62
6.2 Summary and Suggestions 82
7. Scope For Further Research 88
8. Learning Outcomes 90
9. Bibliography & Reference 92
10. Annexure 94
[Type text]
INTRODUCTIVE SUMMARY
The Indian FMCG industry is increasingly following the international trend and
convenient packaging has been a part of the overall change in the consumer
preference. The Indian carbonated soft drink (CSD) industry, which is highly
dominated by the returnable glass bottles, is also witnessing a gradual shift
towards the non-returnable mode of packaging. The primary cause for the
evolution of this trend is the change in consumer tastes and preferences. The
urban population is more attracted towards the packaging in PET and Cans.
This project entitled the “Study on the Customized Hybrid Sell” Go To Market,
was undertaken at the Goa Bottling Factory Pvt. Ltd. (GBCL), the company is
located in Arlem area of the Margao city in Goa. The company is a Franchisee
Owned Bottling Operation (FOBO) for manufacturing and marketing PepsiCo
brand of Stock Keeping Units (SKU’s).
The study was carried out mainly in the “Fringe SKU” (PET, Cans and Tetra
Pack) segment of products and the main objective was to gain a clear
understanding on the selling and distribution of this fringe SKU’s. The study
conducted was carried out in two phases. The first phase of the project was to
get an overview of the entire selling and distribution process of fringe SKU’s and
the other SKU’s. Consequently, the second phase comprised of collecting
information and related data in order to evaluate the efficiency of operations in
the customized hybrid GTM system that was followed by GBCL.
7 | Page
The main aim of this project on the hybrid system at GBCL was to study the
process in details and understand the process of carrying out a particular
marketing function (i.e. sales & distribution). The second aim was to provide
GBCL with valuable inputs and information on the efficiency of the system.
The objective of this project is to relate the theory to concepts learnt in the
classroom and to find out whether theoretical knowledge is really applied in the
practical business world.
Looking at this opportunity Goa Bottling Factory Pvt. Ltd. during the period of my
project assigned me the task of gathering information about the customized
hybrid GTM system and compare with the actual Hybrid GTM as per PepsiCo
standards. The information pertaining to the function was collected through
various methods such as questionnaires, interviews, outlet surveys and
conducting route rides along with the salesman.
8 | Page
1.1 PROBLEM INTRODUCTION
The problem/issue to be studied at the GBCL was concerned with the strategic
business unit (SBU). The SBU was started by GBCL in the year 2002 to support
its selling and distribution activities for its Stock-keeping units (SKUs). The
company had three distribution depots under the SBU, which, catered exclusively
to the Margao and Panjim market, which are very important markets in the North
and South Goa for the company.
The company till 9th May, 2006 followed a “Pre-sell Hybrid” GTM method to
distribute its fringe SKU’s (PET, Cans and Tetra Packs) in the Margao market but
after the following date it made certain changes to the system, to make it more
efficient. The changes were made to the system by also keeping the follwing
objectives that had to be achieved.
Increase the market share to 60 per cent from the current 48 per cent.
Increase the fringe SKU’s share in the total product mix for the Margao
market.
Increase the penetration of fringe SKUs in the market.
Therefore the focus of the study was to understand and analyze whether the
modified hybrid GTM system, benefited the company in attaining the efficiency or
not.
9 | Page
CHAPTER – 2
10 | P a g e
2.1 About “Carbonated Soft Drink”
CSD (Carbonated Soft Drink) is also popularly called as Cold drinks, it is a non-
alcoholic, flavored and carbonated beverage commercially prepared and sold in
bottles and cans. Water accounts to nearly 86-96% in a soft drink. A CSD is
prepared by injecting carbon dioxide into the flavored drink at a pressure of
several atmospheres. In cold beverages carbon dioxide dissolves readily at
atmospheric pressure. When the CSD is exposed it releases the carbon dioxide
to the atmosphere forming numerous bubbles. After some time when the entire
carbon dioxide is released from the drink the drink is termed as flat. The CSD
taste “Fizzy” is due to carbonic acid inducing a burning sensation and indirectly
resulting in bubbles in the soft drinks.
Beverages
Alcoholic Non-Alcoholic
Hot Beverages
Cold Beverages
11 | P a g e
Carbonated Water:
12 | P a g e
2.2 Global CSD Market
13 | P a g e
The global market for soft drinks has grown steadily over the past five years and
is set to continue in the coming future. Globally Carbonated soft drinks are the
third most consumed beverages and the leading source of revenue for the global
soft drink market is the sale of carbonated soft drinks. Per-capita consumption of
CSD is four times more then compared to per capita consumption of fruit
beverages. Soft drink consumption is growing by nearly 5 per cent a year. In the
year 2001 the global per capita consumption of soft drinks was 67.5 litres per
year. North America is the largest consumer of the CSD, it is also the worlds
largest soft drink market with 27 per cent of the total world soft drink sales and
consumptions of 48 gallons per person per year (192 litres/person/year). The
European market accounts for 21 per cent, with a per capita consumption of 12.7
gallons per year (50.8litres/person/year). Globally the supermarkets and hyper
markets form the most significant distribution channels, sales through this
channels accounts approximately 34.7% of the market volume, On-trade sales,
which refers to retail of drinks for consumption on premise, form a further 18.8%
of the market, and the remaining 46.3% of sales in the market is through a range
of other channels.
The five fastest growing soft drink markets are from Asia, East Europe, and the
Middle East. Amongst the Asian countries Pakistan is expected to have the
highest percentage growth rate while India is expected to make sizeable volume
gains, as affluence spreads to more of its vast population. Globally Europe is
the largest regional market, accounting for 38.50%, followed by US with a share
of 29.40% of the global market value.
14 | P a g e
Fig 2. World Market Share of Soft Drinks.
12.10%
20.00% 38.50%
29.40%
15 | P a g e
Table 2. Global Market Volume Table
Total 100.0%
Source: Datamonitor
16 | P a g e
Fig 2. Global market Segmentation based on Product Category
4 .0 0 %
7 .60 %
8 .7 0 % 4 5.9 0 %
1 4 .7 0 %
19 .1 0 %
Carbonated B ottled W ater
Juic es R TD Tea & Coffee
F unc tional drink s C onc entrates
The global market is segmented into 3 major geographical regions, which are
Europe, US and Asia Pacific. The largest market for CSDs in year 2005 was in
Europe whereas Asia-Pacific had a share f 20 percent. The market for soft drinks
in Asia-Pacific region has fluctuated over the past five years, however the growth
rates has been consistently positive, and this is set to continue. Market revenues
have grown by 10.60 percent during the period between 2001 – 2005, and set to
grow further by a further 20 percent by 2010. In terms of value growth, Asia –
Pacific market performed worse than that of Europe, which grew at 2.3 percent
CAGR.
17 | P a g e
2.2.1 Asia – Pacific Soft Drink Market
Looking ahead, the Asia-Pacific CSD market is expected to accelerate from its
current growth rate. A CAGR of 3.7 percent is anticipated over 2005-2010 period
and the market consumption volumes are forecasted to reach a total of 85.5
billion liters by the end of 2010, which will make a CAGR of 4.9 percent between
2005-2010.
Total 100.0%
Source:Datamonitor
18 | P a g e
Future Challenge
Functional
Drinks
18% CSD
27%
19 | P a g e
In the future the trend in the consumption of the CSD will see a change; primary
cause for this change would be the growing health concerns and demographic
changes in many countries. Markets like the USA have already started to
experience this change where the aging U.S. population has cut down on the
consumption of carbonated beverages. With such change in the consumption
pattern, the beverage industry will have to gear up to face the competition from
other substitutes and particularly the bottled water category and the health juices.
20 | P a g e
2.3 Indian CSD Market
21 | P a g e
The Indian CSD industry has been showing an impressive growth, the market
growth rate in the 80s was around 2-3% which increased to 5-6% in the early 90s
and is presently 7-8% per annum. The per capita consumption in India is among
the lowest in the world at 8 bottles per annum compared to 80 bottles in Thailand
ad 800 bottles in USA. The Delhi market has the highest per capita consumption
in the country with 50 bottles per annum. The market preference is highly
regional based. The cola drinks have the main market in the metro cities and
northern states of UP, Punjab, Haryana etc. Orange flavored drinks have their
main markets in the southern states. Soda also comprises in major sales in the
southern states besides sale through bars. Mango flavored drinks attract more of
the Western markets. The Indian CSD consumer are also getting health
conscious and are opting more towards DIET CSD which currently accounts to
0.7 per cent of the total carbonated beverage market,
The soft drink market until early 1990s was in hands of domestic players like
Campa cola, Thumps up, Limca tc. But with the opening of the economy and
coming of MNC players like Pepsi and Coke the market has come totally under
their control, with the acquisition of the major brands.
For the promotion of the soft drink industry the Government has adopted
liberalized policies for soft drink trade to boast and promote Indian brands
internationally. With the entry of big companies like PepsiCo and Coke local
brands are bleeding as this MNC’s do extensive advertising, provide good quality
an at low cost.
The Indian soft drink beverage market can be divided into fruit drinks and soft
drinks. Soft drinks are further divided into carbonated and non-carbonated drinks.
Cola, lemon and orange are carbonated drinks while mango drinks come under
non-carbonated category. The market can be segmented on the basis of types of
22 | P a g e
products into cola products and non-cola products. Cola products account nearly
61-62 per cent of the total soft drinks market. The brands that fall in this category
are Pepsi, Coca-Cola, Thumps Up, Diet Coke, and Diet Pepsi etc. The non-cola
segment constitutes 36 per cent and can be divided into four categories based
on the types of flavors available, namely: Orange, Cloudy Lime, Clear Lime and
Mango.
Per Capita Consumption in major Asian Markets
6 5
0 5
5
0
4
0
3
0 1
2 1 8
0 8 3
1
00
Indi Pakist Sr Chin
a an Lanka a
Source: GBCL
23 | P a g e
Fig 3. Beverage Consumption Per Capita Comparison between
India & World Average
50
45 W orld Average India
40
35
30
25
20
15
10
5
0
Juice Water Soft Coffee Tea
(Bottled) Drinks
Source: GBCL
Opportunity: As we can see from both the above given figures that India has the
lowest Per capita consumption of CSD in comparison with major Asian countries
as well the lowest in comparison with the world average, this also means that
there is a opportunity for the industry to grow in the country, and as the Indian
demographic (age of the population) is expected to change in the near future,
there is ample scope for the industry to grow and increase the per capita
consumption of CSD.
24 | P a g e
2.4 Major Players in the CSD industry
The carbonated soft drink industry is dominated by three major players, which
together contribute nearly 90 per cent of the global market. Coco – Cola is the
king of the soft drink-empire and boasts a global market share of around 36 per
cent, followed closely by PepsiCo at about 35 per cent, and Cadbury Schweppes
at 17 per cent. For many years now the CSD has centered on the power struggle
between Cola War principals Coke and Pepsi.
About Coca-Cola
The Coca-Cola Company was established in the year 1886; the company has
invested over US$ 1 billion in India and has employed nearly 5000 people. The
Coca-Cola system in India comprises 25 wholly owned bottling operations and
another 35 franchisee-owned bottling operations.
Coca-Cola is a leading player in the Indian beverage market with nearly 60 per
cent share in the carbonated soft drink segment, 36 per cent in the fruit drink
segment and 33 percent share in the packaged water segment.
In keeping with its goal of emerging as the single largest entity in the beverage
market, Coca-Cola has a presence in multiple segments.
• In CSD (Coke, Diet Coke, Fanta, Thumps Up, Sprite and Limca), fruit juice
based drinks (Maaza), powdered soft drink (Sunfill) and coffee and tea
(Georgia), bottled water (Kinley) and bottled soda (Kinley Soda)
25 | P a g e
• The company leverages this comprehensive portfolio, which includes a
mix of its global brands as well as the locally acquired brands like Thumps
Up, Limca and Mazaa.
• It sells these beverages in multiple volumes of 200 ml, 300 ml, 1500 ml,
600 ml, Cans, Tetra Packs as well as through vendors (fountain machine)
Future Plans
26 | P a g e
About PepsiCo
PepsiCo stated its operations in India from the year 1989. PepsiCo and its
partners have invested more than US$ 700 million in India – building businesses,
which today provide direct or indirect employment to more than 60,000 people.
PepsiCo products portfolio of beverage brands in India includes the flagship cola
brand Pepsi; Diet Pepsi; two flavors of Mirinda – Orange and Lemon; 7Up;
Mountain Dew; packaged drinking water – Aquafina; variants of the fruit drink
brand Slice; the 100 per cent fruit juice brand Tropicana in several variants and
the worlds leading sorts drink Gatorade. It also includes the local brands Lehar
Evervess Soda. Through its tie-up with Hindustan Lever Limited, the company
also markets and distributes ready to drink beverages such as iced tea, green
teas and herbal teas.
27 | P a g e
To produce its beverages PepsiCo has 37 bottling plants and 20owned by
franchisee partners. The flavour concentrates used to make soft drinks are
produced at separate state-of-art plant at Channo in the Sangrur district of
Punjab and supplied across South Asia.
• Coco – Cola stayed in the soft drinks, fruit juice, sports drinks and bottled
water, while PepsiCo ventured beyond beverages into snack foods and
breakfast cereals.
• PepsiCo invested in fast-food restaurants that have since spun off.
Quaker Oats with its subsidiary Gatorade is part of the PepsiCo domain.
PepsiCo also expanded into other marketing channels – particularly
restaurants.
• Both PepsiCo and Coco – Cola relied on licensing and special bottling
agreement to establish markets abroad. PepsiCo, for instance, bottles for
Dole juice, Starbucks coffee drinks and canned iced tea.
28 | P a g e
2.5 PORTER’S FIVE-FORCE MODEL
In CSD industry there are four parties that are involved in the process of
production and distribution, namely, concentrate producer, bottlers, retail
channels, and suppliers. Porter’s 5 forces analysis reveals the following
characteristics of the CSD industry:
29 | P a g e
1. A fierce competition exists among very few players: The industry is an
oligopoly, or even duopoly, given the intense rivalry between Coke and
Pepsi.
30 | P a g e
Competition Intensity:
The competition in the CSD market is very much high, especially between
Coke and Pepsi. This fierce competition often creates a pressure on the
product price, which can affect profitability, and substantial investment in
marketing and advertising campaigns to strengthen the brand image and
loyalty. In addition to price the competition is also to grab the retail space in
order to broaden the customer base, as there are many distribution channels
in the industry. Pepsi attempted to differentiate its products from Coke’s by
targeting a different category of consumers as Pepsi focused on the teen’s
market segment. The competition goes beyond the domestic borders where
Coke and Pepsi have fought over international market to increase sales and
market share.
31 | P a g e
CHAPTER – 3
Introduction and Marketing Strategies of Goa
Bottling Company Limited
(GBCL)
[Type text]
3.1 Introduction
The GBCL commenced its operations activities from the year 1965, with soft
manufacturing. Initially it operated a small “Fuski” a hand operated machine used
for filling bottles. The unit in its inception had the capacity to produce 200 cases
of 200ml bottles per 8 hours.
In the year 1985-86 the company saw a financial downfall, primarily because of
the introduction of the “Fanta” in the market by the competitors which turned to
be a leading brand in the orange segment and which lead to a fall in the demand
of companies “Gold Spot” which was a product of the company and produced in
that year. In the year 1972 the GBCL entered the franchise business by signing a
franchisee agreement with “Parle” who then renovated the plant and introduced
its popular brand “Limca” in the Goan market followed by “Thumps Up” in the
year 1978. After this start the company never looked back, and kept growing, in
the later stages it also introduced some other brands in different packaging.
In the last decade, GBCL has experienced revolutionary changes in its business
with major up gradations of its plant and machinery.
Pepsi was introduced in the Goan market on the 23rd November 1997, and in the
year 2000 GBCL was take over by the “bottling king of India” Mr. Ravi Kant
Jaipuria from the “Fomento Group” owned by the Timblo’s. The company
continued its operations under the same “Manufacturing Franchisee” with Pepsi.
GBCL is a private company owned wholly by Mr.Jaipuria now.
[Type text]
Today Mr. Jaipuria owns eight soft drink companies sending out millions of Pepsi
bottles into the market annually. Mr. Jaipuria controls nearly 10 per cent to 15 per
cent of the soft drink production in the country, i.e. nearly 450 million cases.
34 | P a g e
3.2 The Company Vision
“Produce the best quality products at lower cost through optimization of
resources, better discipline, team-work and multi-skilling and achieve higher
customer satisfaction.”
GBCL is an organization that has distinct characteristics like any well planned
and laid out organization.
A Distinct Purpose: The purpose of the company is clearly stated in its vision
statement. In brief, it is to produce to meet the demand and expectations of every
customer or consumer.
The People: Like any other organization, GBCL also considers its human
resources as its assets and not just only employees. The company has a total
employee strength of 125 people, who work with perfect coordination and
cooperation to achieve its vision.
35 | P a g e
Systematic Structure: The organization chart of the company depicts that it has a
systematic structure; this structure can be diagrammatically represented in the
conventional in pyramidcal form.
36 | P a g e
3.3 The Franchisee Agreement
The nature of franchisee agreement is such that Pepsi assumes responsibility for
supplying the essential ingredients of the products and it assumes the bottler of
exclusive right of sales within their specified geographical franchisee areas. The
franchisee company works with the supplier firms to assure the availability of
quality packaging, merchandising and other related equipments made for the
standard specification. The companies under this agreement are called as FOBO
i.e Franchise owned bottling operator. PepsiCo under this agreement provides
advertising campaigns and a medium support and also conducts suitable
promotional campaigns and marketing strategies. It offers aid impersonal training
for sales & production staff. It provides quality control facilities and technicians. It
develops national publicity efforts and offers aid in formulating local level
community relations project, in addition to this Pepsi offers service through large
field force including specialist in a number of technical and marketing skills.
Today there are 400 Pepsi Cola bottlers in U.S.A and more than 600
internationally. Furthermore GBCL today produces nearly 500 cases of 300ml in
8 hours shift, which has doubled from its inception.
37 | P a g e
• Consumer Marketing Channel
•
GBCL
•
•
• 0 – Level 1 – Level 2 – Level 3–
Level
Manufacturer Manufacturer Manufacturer Manufacturer
•
•
•
•
•
• Wholeseller Wholeseller
•
•
•
•
•
• Jobber
•
Retailer
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
• Retailer Retailer
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
Consumer Consumer Consumer Consumer
•
•
38 | P a g e
CHAPTER – 4
Research Methodology
39 | P a g e
4.1 METHODOLOGY
The methodology used to collect information and data about the customized
hybrid GTM process for the project was mainly analytical and quantitative in
nature. Allotted time was spent with the Territory Development manager
(TDM), the Customer Executive (CE) and the other sales team members to
understand how the functions of sales and distribution are carried out in the
customized hybrid system. The data collection was done in the following
manner:
40 | P a g e
4.2 SAMPLE SIZE
The population for the survey done was for 88 outlets, and all the outlets
were in close proximity of the city, and hence the sample size taken is 88
outlets. The outlets were chosen as per the list provided by the company.
41 | P a g e
Objective:
The survey was carried out to understand the perception about the
outlets, which were serviced by the “Customized Hybrid Sell”. The survey was
carried out on 88 outlets in the Margao Market, and data was collected through
an informal discussion. The survey was carried out also to understand the
performance of the salesman and also verify some of the KPI’s.
Stock Out Position: This parameter was helped to understand the frequency of
the salesmen’s visit to a particular outlet, the response “never” was given by
outlets which were visited very often, the response “rarely” meant that the
salesman was needed to be called to the outlet through the R.A. who sold GRB’s
and “frequently” was the response given by outlets where the salesman never
visited.
Service Quality: The parameter helped to determine if there were any changes
in the salesmen’s performance after making the modifications. The modifications
were done in order to improve the efficiency of the salesman and so that he
could be more focused on the fringe SKU’s.
42 | P a g e
CHAPTER – 5
Data Analysis
[Type text]
Route Schedule Analysis:
All the P.S.R given below are on the direct sell GTM distribution system except
for Sanjay who is on the customized hybrid sell GTM distribution system and who
sells only the fringe SKU’s of the company.
The outlets, outlined differ from one week day to the next day for many R.A’s,
(wherein some R.A’s visit the same outlets everyday but whereas some RA’s
have to visit the outlets on alternate days.)
Route Schedule – I
[Type text]
Route Schedule – II
It was observed that R.A. Shashikant, R.A. Ramesh, R.A. Santosh and P.S.R
Sanjay had to visit outlets on alternate days and it was found that altogether the
number of outlets was 669. As per the company limits each R.A or a P.S.R could
be given a maximum of 60 – 65 outlet for each day.
45 | P a g e
The data related to the various schemes was collected through observation and
with interviews with the P.S.R of the company.
The following table shows us the different schemes that the company has to offer
to its retail outlets, the scheme are given to promote the low selling SKU and to
increase the overall sales. The Promo Packs are special promotional packs,
which are designed along with the scheme, to promote the entire pack.
TETRA PACK
600 ml 1 Case + 2 Tetra Pack 20.00
Free
Slice 1 Case + 3 Tetra Pack 30.00
Free
PACKAGED DRINKING
WATER
Aquafina 1000 ml 5 Case + 1 Case Free of 240.00
1000 ml
PROMO PACK
Cans 330 ml 5 Cans + 1 Can Free of 15.00
330 ml
46 | P a g e
The cost per case is calculated by adding the scheme amount to the bill amount
and then by dividing it with the respective product on which the scheme is given.
TETRA PACK
600 ml 1 Case + 2 Tetra Pack 462.91
Free
Slice Tetra Pack 1 Case + 3 Tetra Pack 232.91
Free
PACKAGED DRINKING
WATER
Aquafina 1000 ml 5 Case + 1 Case Free of 248.40
1000 ml
Volume Analysis: -
47 | P a g e
If we look at the above given table we can see that there has been a significant
decline in the sales from the year 2005 to year 2006, but the decline it could be
due to decline in the outlets being covered. In the year 2005 the total number of
outlets where sales was done were 392 which in the modified hybrid sell were
schemed to 96, which were the high volume accounts amongst the 392.
Compared to the decline in the number of outlets there has been an
improvement in the sales efficiency, this could be either due to the increasing
trend in the industry towards PET and other fringe SKU’s or due to improved
skills and more focused selling by the salesman Sanjay.
Can 15 0 N.A
48 | P a g e
Comparative Sales Volumes 2005-06
800
In Cases
600
Jun-05
400
Jun-06
200
0
Flavored Soda Pet Soda Pet Flavored Can Aquafina
Pet 600ml 1500ml Pet
600ml 2000ml
Similar to the previous chart of Volume analysis, in this table we can see a
decline in the percentage mix of fringe SKU from the year 2005 – year 2006,
except for Soda PET 600ml which has shown a marginal increase of .06 per
cent. This decline in the product mix could be correlated with the decline in sales
year on year due to decrease in the number of outlets and modifications of the
hybrid sell strategy.
49 | P a g e
4
3.5
3
% C o n t rib u t io n 2 0 0 5
2.5
2
1.5 % C o n t rib u t io n in
2006
1
0.5
0
Aq n
Ca
a
fin
l
l
Fla da P 00m
ua
So Pet 6 l
0m
ml
m
da 00
00
0
ure t 15
So et 6
20
e
et
P
dP
re d
v ou
vo
Fla
KPI Analysis
50 | P a g e
Scheduled Call 2592 1560
Completed Calls N.A N.A
No. of Orders Booked 587 476
No. of Orders delivered 587 476
Strike Rate 22% 31%
Lines Per Cash Memo 1.41 3.63
Drop Size N.A N.A
Total Mix 9% 7%
Analysis:
The above given table shows us the different KPI which are tracked at GBCL to
measures the efficiency of the “Hybrid Sell” GTM. The above given KPI’s weer
tracked before (June 2005) and after (June 2006) making the changes to the
“Hybrid Sell” GTM.
The changes were made where the number of scheduled calls was reduced from
2592 to 1560, this was done by filtering the key accounts that made regular
purchases and were mainly bulk buyers. The decrease was done with regards to
manpower re-sourcing too, as there were two PSR before customization, which
was know reduced to one salesman, with merging the functions of PSR and a
RA. But if we look at the Number of orders booked, we can see although there
has been a decrease in the total from 587 to 486 there has been an increase in
the strike rate which was 22.64 percent in 2005, which increased to 30.50%, thus
showing us that the number of outlets covered and bills made after the changes
were made was higher and thus showing that there has been a positive change.
The number of orders delivered has remained the same, as the orders have
been booked. The Lines Per Cash Memo (LPCM) also has increased from 1.41
to 3.63 which indicates that the salesman is doing range selling and the
penetration has increased, with the number of SKU kept by the outlets also.
51 | P a g e
Finally the total mix of Fringe SKU’s has reduced from 9% to 7%, thus we can
say that the mix has declined due to poor sales or because there has been an
increase in RGB sale.
52 | P a g e
05/06/ 161 555 39 7%
06
06/06/ 200 552 57 10%
06
07/06/ 210 630 25 4%
06
08/06/ 202 478 23 5%
06
09/06/ 216 706 32 4%
06
10/06/ 231 683 64 9%
06
12/06/ 212 659 113 17%
06
13/06/ 206 505 55 11%
06
14/06/ 222 479 23 5%
06
15/06/ 226 602 32 5%
06
16/06/ 208 573 28 5%
06
17/06/ 233 518 48 9%
06
19/06/ 252 807 42 5%
06
20/06/ 178 713 56 8%
06
21/06/ 184 513 41 8%
06
22/06/ 217 500 56 11%
06
23/06/ 222 556 41 7%
06
24/06/ 208 610 49 8%
06
26/06/ 128 370 16 4%
06
27/06/ 99 239 9 3%
06
28/06/ 147 343 20 5%
06
29/06/ 137 290 14 4%
06
30/06/ 196 472 36 7%
53 | P a g e
06
Total 13500 984 7.28%
Bill cuts analysis is being done in order to understand the percentage of outlets
being done and to get an idea on percentage of outlets that are purchasing the
fringe SKU’s. Below we can see that although product mix percentage was high
in the initial period of the month, the bill cuts were less, which means that outlets
which bought large quantities were only attended and by the end of the month all
the outlets were attended and therefore bill cuts has increased, another
influencing factor for this phenomenon could be achievement of targets which
has driven the increase in bill cuts by the end of the month.
54 | P a g e
Bills Cut Analysis
55 | P a g e
6
24/06/0 50 23 46%
6
26/06/0 46 15 30%
6
28/06/0 50 15 30%
6
29/06/0 46 10 21%
6
30/06/0 50 21 42%
6
Total 1202 446 37%
CHAPTER – 6
56 | P a g e Survey Findings
Merchandising: As it is popularly known “Jo Dikhta hein, woh bikta hein”,
merchandising was a parameter which also influenced the sales of the fringe
SKU’s therefore it was important to make an observation on the merchandising
of the outlet. Data for this was merely collected through the process of
observations at the outlets. The outlets which displayed the full range of SKU’s
was graded under “Dominant”, the outlets that kept 7-8 SKU’s were graded as
“Average” and the outlets that displayed only 3-4 SKU’s was graded “Below
Average”.
The survey for the following research project was conducted through a structured
questionnaire, the values or the characteristics of the questions were derived
from the respondent through a discussion and not through mere filling of the
questionnaire or neither by asking direct questions. The total respondents for the
survey were from 88 outlets in the Margao market. The questionnaire and data
has been analyzed below.
Salesman Quality
23% 25%
19%
30%
57 | P a g e
From the 88 respondents of the survey it was found that 27 outlets were satisfied
with the service provided by the salesman, 22 of the respondents felt that the
service quality of the salesman was excellent and had no complains against the
salesman. 21 of the respondents said that the salesman quality was bad and
were unhappy with the salesman and finally 17 outlets graded the salesman as
just good.
15%
35%
49%
This response was taken with respect to the frequency of visits to the outlets, to
find out whether the salesman visits the outlets thrice or not. But it was found out
that 43 respondents gave the response of rarely being out of stock which also
meant that
58 | P a g e
Q4. Did you observe any change in the service quality over a period of 1
month?
S e rv ic e Q u a lity Im p ro v e m e `n t
Y es
23 %
No
77 %
Y es N o
This parameter was used to check if there was a change in the performance of
the salesman after making the changes to the hybrid GTM, the question was an
open ended, with only two options either yes or no. The results of the survey
were that nearly 66 of the outlets i.e. more than 75% of the total surveyed outlets
felt that there was no significant change, and that the performance was the same
as before, and nearly 22 of the outlets observed certain changes in the
performance.
59 | P a g e
Q5. Level of Outlet Merchandising:
S tore Merchandisin g
Dom ina nt
22%
Be low
Ave ra ge
54% Ave ra ge
24%
Dominant
Average
Below Average
The survey on merchandising shows us that nearly 54% of the outlets had a
merchandising level of below average i.e. only 3-4 SKU’s were on display,
around 24% of the outlets had average merchandising level with 7-8 SKUs on
display, and 22% had merchandising level of dominant. The outlets at the
dominant level of merchandising were in the category of modern trade, and the
outlets in the category of below average were the convenience stores, which had
space constraints, and make the display of the SKUs.
60 | P a g e
Conclusion:
The survey finding reveled that from the 88 outlets surveyed 30 per cent of the
respondents were just satisfied by the salesman quality, which meant that there
was no significant change in the salesman’s quality with respect to the sales
performance, 49 per cent of the respondents went out of stock position “Rarely’
which meant that the salesman’s visits to these outlets was not very frequently
and therefore the R.A. carrying Glass Bottles had to be asked for the service.
The most significant response showed 75 per cent of the respondents did not
notice any significant change in the salesman’s behavior after making the
modifications to the hybrid sell, which meant that the quality of the service
rendered remained unchanged from the customer perspective and lastly the
merchandising at 53 per cent of the outlets was below average, which meant that
only 19 outlets kept full range of SKU’s and nearly 75 per cent of the outlets had
poor merchandising.
61 | P a g e
The Present Study
“About GTM”
62 | P a g e
Introduction
The below given information was collected after conducting an interview with the
Territory Development Manager, Mr. Matheu Diniz at the Goa Bottling Factory
Pvt. Ltd.
Given below are the standard form in which PepsiCo expects its marketing and
distribution partners to carry out the operations related to marketing and
distribution of its SKUs:
PepsiCo India has different methods in which it distributes its SKUs and
all this are clubbed under the term “Go to market” (GTM). The GTM also
includes the process of marketing its product portfolio, the basic intent for this is
to establish an efficient and cost effective marketing operations. The GTM are
based on market dynamics and retail relevance that will deliver sustainable
competitive advantage and executional excellence at the optimal cost.
GTM
[Type text]
GTM Strategic Intent
To establish an efficient cost effective Go To Market system based on
market dynamics and retail relevance that would deliver sustainable competitive
advantage and executional excellence at optimal cost
1. Tele Sell:
Tele sell GTM is a technique used by PepsiCo, to book orders over the phone,
without making a visit to the outlets, this is the cheapest form of GTM amongst all
the four distribution systems, as the salesman or RA only visits only those
outlets. Tele-sell also increases the depth of sale through planned quality order
taking. This also increases the selling time that is required at every outlet, and it
eliminates the process of range selling, in other words the selling capability is
low. It reduces the transaction time, and increases the number of outlets on the
route. This sell type is used when the market share is high and when the storage
capacity at the outlet is high. This selling technique is used for institutional clients
such as hotel, cinema halls and modern trade.
2. Pre – Sell:
This is a GTM technique where the PSR (Pre-sell Representative) personally
visits every outlet and books the order, which then delivered to the outlet on the
next day. This is a very time consuming technique, which is not commonly used
in India. This technique increases the in-store execution time, where the PSR
gets ample time to merchandise the store, this technique also improves the
quality of sale, and there can be focused sales on the entire portfolio of products.
The purchase frequency is low, for this technique. Selling skills required for this
type of sales is very high, this type of selling is required at groceries shops,
railway stations, and other small outlets.
64 | P a g e
3. Direct Sell:
In this selling the salesman carries the full range of SKU’s en route, there is no
order taking in advance, orders are taken on the spot and delivered at the same
time. This is used when the sales ratio of glass bottles is more, and this is the
most widely used GTM method in India. This GTM is used frequently and in
cases of intense competition in the market. This GTM also requires high selling
capability. This type of GTM is used at convenience store, restaurants and bars,
etc.
4. Hybrid Sell:
Hybrid sell is a GTM technique, which is used for products, which require more
focused selling. This reduces the cost of sales (taxi rates), hybrid sell also
reduces the problem of improper load outs, which is common in direct sell GTM.
Hybrid sell aims at targeting the niche markets. GTM is used the SKU has a low
percentage of sale. This technique can be used across channels.
65 | P a g e
“Hybrid Sell” GTM in details:
Hybrid Sell is a sales & distribution strategy, which is a very focused way of
marketing only one range of product, which are called “Fringe SKUs”. The fringe
SKU’s are those products that a very small share of the entire sales of the
company. The Hybrid Sell strategy does not stress on marketing and selling
other SKUs that are fast moving.
(Ex. The PSR in this case will exclusively sell PET Bottles, Cans and the Tetra
pack range of products as these range of SKUs constitute the ‘fringe SKU’)
66 | P a g e
• Compromise on main SKU load outs, loss of sale
Hybrid system also eliminates the problem of loss of sale, wherein in a
conventional system the RA carried only SKU which sold more and did not carry
other SKUs, whereas in a Hybrid system the orders are booked on the previous
day and there a very chances of losing on sales.
This system is specially designed to target the niche segments of the market
where there is more focus on a particular segment.
67 | P a g e
The Hybrid system of selling is used by PepsiCo India when the SKUs require
more selling skills to sell a product.
A Hybrid sell strategy cannot be used in all the market places, it can be
implemented for niche SKUs as per outlet consumer profile. The hybrid system is
used at all the potentially penetrable outlets.
Through the Hybrid system for the fringe SKU’s, GBCL has attempted to use the
Michael Porters third generic strategy i.e. FOCUS. GBCL through the new
customized hybrid GTM focuses on a narrow market segments.
Objective of PepsiCo for implementing “Hybrid Sell” GTM strategy for its
fringe SKU’s
Market Penetration
68 | P a g e
The growth strategy used by GBCL as per the Igor Ansof Market
Expansion Grid:
The chart provides the management with information on the current mix of the
product and the expected mix of the product in the market. This analysis helps
the company to know about its product mix concentration in the market.
The chart also helps the marketing department to determine the current market
penetration, and compare it with the expected market penetration. The current
market penetration is derived from the sales figures of each SKUs divided by the
number of outlets done in a particular month and the expected market
69 | P a g e
penetration is calculated by analyzing the last years sales figures for the month
and the growth trend in the industry. The chart also has a column, which
specifies the level of selling skills required by the PSR for each of the SKUs and
finally the projected sale figure can only be achieved if the expected market
penetration is achieved as per expected.
Number of PSR = 2
70 | P a g e
In the Hybrid distribution system the Pilot Sales Representative (PSR) gets a
monthly Execution Plan, which a salesman has to follow, and also achieve the
Stock Keeping Unit (SKU) target, which is set by the company.
6.3 Hybrid Sell Process
PSR Outlet
71 | P a g e
A functional description of a PSR at work in a “Hybrid Sell” system:
The key person in the hybrid process is the PSR, the PSR plays a very crucial
role in the selling of the SKUs, The hybrid distribution can be best understood
from the point of view of the PSR and if understand his role in the distribution
system.
1. The PSR would start his day by first arriving at the Depot and ensuring
that the scoreboard has been updated and review the previous day’s route
sale. Then he would have a discussion over the tactical marketing plan
with the C.E and the Route Assistant and discuss individual performance.
The discussion with the C.E would be in respect to the progress and the
status of any specific account, the P.S.R would also ask the C.E about the
scheme and different promotion strategies for any specific SKU. The
discussion a with the R.A. would be in respect to the previous days order
deliveries, bills and discuss with him if there are any discrepancies, the
PSR would also ask the R.A for any specific issues.
2. The next step for the PSR would be to plan his day’s operations, he will
have to decide on his sales target to be achieved and plan for activities
that need to be executed.
3. The PSR should also do a pre-check the list of outlets, and understand
the outlets that have not purchased for a long period, and understand the
cause of not purchasing.
72 | P a g e
At Outlet Level (En Route):
1. The PSR on the route carries a route book (annexure 1) along with the
bill book before going on the route. The route book would consist the
names of the outlets in the rows and would consist the different SKUs
brands in the columns, the PSR would then record the sales of each SKU
in the respective row for the particular purchase made by the outlet. It also
helps the PSR to now which outlet had bought which SKU and the
frequency of his purchase over a period. The PSR also has to take the
signature of the customer as he visits the outlets on the route book and
has to mention about any remarks if there are any.
To follow this steps the PSR first goes to the outlet and greets the
customer, the next step in sequence is to check for field stock and the
SKUs that are out of stock.
Then it is the PSR responsibility to inform the customer about the stock
status at the outlet, after which he has to do the range selling i.e. he asks
for all the full range of SKUs,
After range - selling the PSR does the promotion of the low selling SKU
and explains the customer about the different schemes that the company
is offering.
73 | P a g e
After the selling is over the PSR does the visi-cooler charging wherein he
is to check the cooler for charging and that there are sufficient SKUs in the
cooler and are being displayed properly. The PSR does the
merchandising at the outlet wherein he puts the PET bottles, cans and
tetra packs on display (racks, hanger table stands etc) wherein it is clearly
visible at outlets to the consumers.
The last and the final step of a PSR at the outlet is to do the billing for the
purchases made by the customer and do the settlement of payment.
74 | P a g e
basis. It is mandatory for the PSR to record his daily report on this board,
which is placed at the depot.
2. The PSR then conducts a discussion with the “Customer Executive” (CE)
on any market issues at makes a note of it in his execution plan for the
next days visit.
3. Finally, the PSR closes the day by segregating all the orders from the
order-booking sheet and forwards the same along with two copies of the
bill to the R.A who then does the delivery on the next day.
75 | P a g e
Key Performing Indicators (KPI) which, need to be recorded on the
“Territory Score Board” (TSB).
76 | P a g e
Number of Orders Delivered: This cell on the scoreboard consists
the number of orders delivered in respect to the number of the
orders taken on the previous day, this also helps the R.A to know
his delivery status and plan his route.
Strike Rate: These are calls, which result in a sale, i.e. such calls
where an invoice has been raised (any flavour, any SKU).
Strike Rate = Strike Calls___
Scheduled Calls
Sales made / invoices cut for Route Jump and Misc. calls are not
considered as 'Strike Calls'
Lines Per Cash Memo: LPCM are the average SKUs purchased by
the outlet per day.
LPCM = __Total SKUs Sold____
Total No. of Bill Cuts.
Drop Size: Total sales for the route / Total Invoices made for the
route
77 | P a g e
In the research process, it was observed that the following changes had
been made to the actual process of Hybrid sell GTM market strategy by
GBCL:
78 | P a g e
The above given changes were done to overcome the following problems:
High workload on R.A.: Under the hybrid system the R.A. had to
deliver to the orders that were booked by both the P.S.R on the
previous day and do both the routes and complete all the orders.
Outlets Scheming: The route plan given to the P.S.R contained the
names of all the outlets (392 outlets), it included outlets, which
bought very less quantities, or even outlets which did not sell fringe
outlets. Therefore, the high-end outlets were identified and given to
currently functional salesman.
79 | P a g e
Customized Hybrid Sell GTM system followed by GBCL.
In the modified hybrid process the functions and roles of a P.S.R and R.A were
merged together and which were carried out by one salesman. The new system
was more of a direct distribution where the process of pre-selling was eliminated
and direct sales and distribution was implemented.
1. The salesman starts his day by coming to the Depot where his duty
started with
a. Preparing the load out slip and giving it to the helpers who would
load the delivery van.
b. Then he has to update the KPI’s on the Territory Score Board for
the reference of the TDM and the CE.
c. By the time the delivery van would get loaded the salesman should
have a brief discussion on the tactical marketing plan with the C.E
and discuss if any issues with regards to any of the outlets done by
the salesman on the previous day. The salesman would also ask
for any schemes that could be offered to the outlets.
80 | P a g e
Post Work (Day Close):
1. At the end of the day, the salesman prepares a
load-in-slip to give a report on the stock that is unsold in the vehicle to the
store-keeper, and notes the daily sales on a sale register, and should
make an analysis of the route book and calculate the necessary KPIs to
be recorded. He then debrief the CE about the days functioning.
81 | P a g e
Summary and Suggestions
82 | P a g e
Summary:
The research analysis carried out proves to us that there has not been significant
change in the sales and distribution of fringe SKU’s through the modified hybrid
sell GTM strategy.
We can see that except for Aquafina all the other SKUs have shown a de-growth
from the year 2005 to year 2006. The percentage of mix of fringe SKU’s from the
total sales have decreased, except for Soda 600ml. The overall percentage mix
of the SKU’s has been 7 per cent of the total sales volumes, which is significantly
low. The bills cut also has been around 37 per cent for the month of June – 2006,
which is quite low.
The outcome of the analysis with regards to the salesman quality also was not
satisfactory in terms of service improvement for sales and distribution. Another
significant observation which was made was that the company used the “Push
strategy” wherein the intermediary was induced to sell the fringe SKU because of
the schemes that were offered to him.
83 | P a g e
Suggestions:
84 | P a g e
• Range Selling: The salesman also failed to do range
selling at the outlet level and would only do selling for the products that were
fast moving. The observation made was that the salesman did not ask for
Cans and Tetra Packs at many outlets, this were only offered when a
customer asked for it. Hence it would be suggested that the salesman does
range selling at all the outlets which would also result in increased LPCS.
85 | P a g e
salesman is doing the range selling of the SKU’s. The Bill cuts of a particular
outlet could be estimated
from the column designated under the title “Bill” wherein the salesman will
have to record the “Bill No” for the purchase made by the outlet. The
maintenance of the report can also be done at the Depot as it was observed
that it is not possible for the salesman to keep the records on the route,
mainly due to limited time constraints. At the end of the month the salesman,
the customer and the CE would have to sign the record, which further can be
analyzed by the higher officials.
• Creating Pull Strategy: GBCL should create a PULL Strategy for its
fringe SKU’s like PET and Cans, because this are products that allow the
company to earn more margins. If it is financially viable the company should
carry out more advertising and promotion to persuade consumers to ask the
outlets for these fringe SKU’s and thus inducing the intermediaries to order
for it.
86 | P a g e
LIMITATIONS
1. Time Scope: As the “PET HYBRID” system was implemented for the past
two months, data analysis was limited by time and seasonal scope.
2. Communication: The state of Goa is divided into North Goa and South
Goa the Konkani language spoken differs to a very large accent and so
during the research process language was a problem.
3. Confidentiality: Due to confidentiality aspect only non-classified
information and data was provided.
4. Owner Availability: In the process of survey due to unavailability of the
proprietor the data was collected from the employees, so information was
not provided very openly.
87 | P a g e
CHAPTER 7
88 | P a g e
Scope for Research:
Since the Customized Hybrid GTM has been implemented recently, 2-3
months back, the study can be carried out again to review the status later, after
making the suggested changes to the system.
As this system of sales and distribution is relatively new to GBCL old GTM of
Hybrid sell, it is not possible to determine whether the new customized GTM is
better than the old GTM, because of the time constraint.
For making a more precise judgment the Customized GTM should be carried out
for a period of one year or more so that a comparative analysis of both the
systems can be done.
89 | P a g e
Chapter 8
Learning Outcomes
90 | P a g e
Learning Outcomes:
The learning outcome derived from the project was valuable and many
new things about the CSD industry were learned. It was also learned that Cola
wars are not won on Televisions through commercial but in reality Cola wars are
won and lost at the door of every cooler and doorstep of every outlet.
In the process of my SIP I have also understood the practical aspects and
importance of the various concepts of marketing like importance of assessing
market potential, customer retention, and the need for promoting a brand by
delivering the right message to the customer which helped me in understanding
the research problem clearly.
During the process of data collection I had to communicate with many outlets of
different categories such as modern trades, convience stores, hotels and small
restaurants and have a brief discussion over the issue of customized Hybrid
GTM their feedback was then recorded in the questionnaire these process
helped me to understand the attitude of a customers towards the company and
how different customers responded differently to same product and same GTM
The data collection process also helped me improve my communication skills.
While preparing the plan of research and during the analysis of data collected, I
had applied the concepts learned in Research Methodology which gave me an
insight on practical application and importance of the subject learned.
91 | P a g e
Bibliography & Reference
92 | P a g e
BIBLIOGRAPHY
REFERENCE
While making of this report information was taken from various sources
and used as a reference. Information was taken from various websites and
many research reports.
93 | P a g e
ANNEXURE
94 | P a g e
Questionnaire I
Objective:
2. Why was there a need for a new system like “PET HYBRID” at GBF?
95 | P a g e
Questionnaire II
Objective:
To understand the quality of salesman and his functioning, in order
to analyze if the salesman are following the specified steps as per
standards lay down by PepsiCo India, which are very essential for the
success of “Hybrid” distribution system.
Category:
2. Salesman quality:
4. Did you observe any change in the service quality over a period of 1
month?
Yes No
96 | P a g e
Annexure 1 - Hybrid Model for Fringe SKUs
Peps 2000 ml
i
600 ml
330 ml
Mou 2000 ml
ntain
Dew
600 ml
330ml
Mirin 2000 ml
da
600 ml
330 ml
7 Up 2000 ml
600 ml
330 ml
Slice 1200 ml
500 ml
Tetra
Diet 250 ml
330 ml
Tee 1500 ml
m
Soda
600 ml
8
SKU
s
97 | P a g e
World Renowned PepsiCo Brand of Products
98 | P a g e
99 | P a g e