Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
Eliot
"Journey of the Magi"
Contents
T. S. Eliot's Struggle and Conversion: The Making of "Journey of the Magi"
The Text of "Journey of the Magi" with Anchors for Primary Symbols and
Images
Nature and Conversion Imagery in T. S. Eliot's "Journey of the Magi": A Review
of Criticism in
Books
Journeying Towards Affirmation of Faith: A Review of Criticism of T. S. Eliot's
"Journey of the
Magi"
The Magi's Human Conversion Experience: A Review of Selections on T. S.
Eliot's "Journey of
the Magi"
Works Cited
Alice Lombardo
T. S. Eliot was born on September 26, 1888, in St. Louis, Missouri, with a
congenital hernia which kept him quiet as a child and out of school until he
was seven or eight years old. Eliot remembers these years and the years that
he attended Smith Academy and then Milton Academy in New England as
happy times. After this, Eliot concentrated on philosophy, especially Hindu
and Buddhist philosophy, as a student at Harvard University in order to
know the truth not only of the age but of life as a whole (Pinion 9-12). After
his studies at Harvard were complete, Eliot transferred to Merton College in
Oxford, England, where he met Vivienne Haigh-Wood, whom he married
on June 26, 1915. But by the end of 1915, Vivienne took ill, an event that
was the beginning of health problems for both of them (Pinion 15-26).
In the early years of his first marriage, Eliot would visit churches to admire
their beauty; in later years, he visited them for the sake of peace,
contemplation, and spiritual refreshment (Pinion 31). Ambition seemed to
deepen his sense of marital guilt and, in 1926, while visiting Rome with his
brother and sister-in-law, Eliot surprised everyone by kneeling before
Michelango's "Pieta." "Here was a spiritually humble, contrite man
ritualizing his acceptance of a higher authority" (Pinion 34). According to
Peter Ackroyd, Eliot had a sense of tradition and an instinct for order within
himself and found the church and faith gave him this security within a life of
frustrations and struggles (159-160). "He was aware of what he called 'the
void' in all human affairs--the disorder, meaninglessness, and futility which
he found in his own experience; it was inexplicable intellectually . . . and
could only be understood or endured by means of a larger faith" (Ackroyd
160). Eliot's faith continued to grow and on June 29, 1927, he was baptized
in the Anglican-Catholic church. This great event in Eliot's life was done
privately and behind closed doors. On the next day Eliot was confirmed by
the Bishop (Ackroyd 162).
"Journey of the Magi," the first in a series of poems Eliot later grouped
together as the Ariel Poems, was published in August of 1927 shortly after
his baptism. Caroline Behr suggests that this poem reflects Eliot's state of
mind in transition between his old and new faiths (33). As Lyndall Gordon
suggests, "Journey of the Magi" is one part of Eliot's conversion story in that
it tells about his being "ill-at-ease in the 'old dispensation' after his
conversion" (37).
It has been reported that Vivienne was against his conversion and this added
to their marital problems (Sharpe 116). In 1933, Eliot separated from
Vivienne and then, in 1949, while working for Faber and Faber, Eliot met
Valerie Fletcher, whom he would later marry. After hearing a recording of
"Journey of the Magi," Fletcher had been drawn to Eliot and knew she had
to get to know him (Ackroyd 298). From 1957 to his death on January 4,
1965, Eliot's life with Valerie Fletcher was happy and peaceful.
Return to Top
First Five Lines: The first five lines were "lifted from Lancelot Andrewes's
Nativity Sermon of 1622, and modified"; Eliot happened to be himself
steeped in Andrewes at the time . . . but basically he used them because he
needed a second voice to precipitate the poetic drama. They must be
understood as being read by, or to, the magus and thereby occasioning his
own flow of memory" (Barbour 190-91). Return to Text.
Cities Hostile: According to Dean, these are "all places which remind the
travellers, by their violent contrast, of the place of contentment they have
deserted" ("Confrontation with Christianity" 76). Traveling through these
forboding places, "Eliot's Magus hastens to end an unpleasant journey; what
he 'regretted' is the vanishing of 'the silken girls bringing sherbet'" (Harris
840). Return to Text.
Temperate valley: Dean points out that the early morning descent into a
"temperate valley" evokes three significant Christian events: "The nativity
and all the attendant ideas of the dawning of a new era . . . the empty tomb
of Easter . . . as well the image of the Second Coming and the return of
Christ from the East, dispelling darkness as the Sun of Righteousness"
("Confrontation with Christianity" 77). Wohlpart adds that the Magi's dawn
arrival is "symbolic of the new life attained from their penance" (57). Return to
Text.
Beating the darkness: Dean notes Elizabeth Drew's view that "'beating the
darkness' can refer to the triumph and victory of Christ, a conquering that
could occur in the events of Christ's earthly life, or in His resurrection, or in
His return in glory at the end of time" (Quoted in Dean, "Confrontation with
Christianity" 77). Return to Text.
Three trees: To Dean, the image of the three trees "seems clearly to be a
reference to the crosses of Calvary" ("Confrontation with Christianity" 78).
Barbour writes, "It is appropriate that his [the Magus'] language . . .
unwittingly evoke [sic] the Crucifixion" (195). Return to Text.
White horse: Dean refers to Robert Kaplan and Richard Wall's suggestion
that "the white horse is 'perhaps a reference to the militaristic and
conquering Christ of Revelation . . .'"; "However," he continues, "there is
nothing in the poem to indicate that the horse is being ridden; on the
contrary, it seems more natural to assume that the horse is riderless . . ."
("Confrontation with Christianity" 78). Dean also quotes Kaplan and Wall's
speculation that the horse is symbolic of the "death of paganism under the
onslaught of Christianity," and notes Nancy Hargrove's suggestion that "the
horse's 'being old . . . perhaps represents the old dispensation that will fade
away with Christ's birth'" (78). Return to Text.
Satisfactory: R. D. Brown writes that "the obvious meaning [of the word
"satisfactory"] is 'expiatory,' payment for a debt or sin" (137). Barbour,
however, sees a more complex connotation: "The parenthetical
remark/gesture dramatizes a certain drawing back at the end into something
between understatement and velleity. The key word is the ambiguous
'satisfactory,' emphasized by rhythm and position, which for us, though not
the magus, evokes the Thirty Nine Articles, expiation, and the Atonement"
(194). In addition, E. F. Burgess sees the word "satisfactory" as evidence
that "every condition of prophecy was met, leaving the alienated magus . . .
stranded, suspended between the realization and the consummation of God's
plan" (36). Return to Text.
Old dispensation: Dean quotes Geneviene Foster's comment that "The birth
of the new era involves the destruction of the old" ("Confrontation with
Christianity" 79). Barbour writes that "The Birth he [the magus] saw began
the death of his old world, old life, but did not, with the same certainty, give
him anything new"; the magus is therefore "alienated from everything 'in the
old dispensation'" (195). Return to Text.
Return to Top
Preston D. Finley
"Journey of the Magi," "A Song for Simeon" and "Animula" . . . are
all poems of the Christian perspective, they are all poems of
acceptance and of resignation to a destiny which is the only
possible answer, but which seems to the protagonists, as human
beings, almost impossibly hard and painful. They are purgatorial
poems. (145)
Here, Lucy uses "acceptance" in the same sentence as "hard," "painful,"
and "resignation" to demonstrate the grayness of the world. Nothing is
black and white; even the glory of the birth of Christ may have negative
consequences to some people: "'The Magi' and 'A Song for Simeon'
show little of that high joy which the birth of Our Lord can often inspire
even in the most austere artists" (148). The Magi don't feel any of that
"high joy" because their comfortable place in the world has been
changed and they no longer feel at peace.
Martin Scofield, in T. S. Eliot: The Poems, makes note of the fact that the
three Ariel Poems, which includes "Journey of the Magi," should be read in
the context of Eliot's baptism and confirmation. This poem is an attempt to
describe, poetically, what this experience means:
As many critics point out, the three trees foreshadow Christ's crucifixion--on
the one hand, a negative image relating to Christ's death but, on the other, a
positive image relating to Christ's sacrifice for humanity. Many critics have
demonstrated that the ambiguity of the nature and conversion imagery in
"Journey of the Magi" is reflective of the author's view of the world as an
inexact place.
Return to Top
Rena Braun
T.S. Eliot's poem "Journey of the Magi" describes the journey of the "Wise
men from the East" towards Christ and thus, symbolically, towards
Christianity. Many critics parallel the Magi's journey with Eliot's own
journey in search of "satisfaction" in Christianity. Critics suggest that Eliot's
"Journey of the Magi" focuses on the affirmation of Christ that comes from
the Magi's journey towards faith through birth, death, and rebirth, a journey
that parallels Eliot's own struggles with his faith.
T.S. Eliot's journey to faith is like that of the magus, a purposeful struggle to
attain faith in God's power to save sinners. Michael Dean, in "'T.S. Eliot's
'Journey of the Magi': Confrontation with Christianity" focuses on a
confrontation that Eliot creates between the reader and the theme. Dean
begins with the "Christian allusions in the poem and will conclude with an
examination of the purpose behind Eliot's use of these allusions: the creation
of a confrontation between the reader and Eliot's affirmation of the truth
revealed in Jesus Christ" (75). The imagery suggests that a "difficulty arises
from the mixing of the old and new dispensations, as the Magus,
transformed by the revelation at the end of his journey, lives on
uncomfortably as a man of the new dispensation among people of the old"
(79). T.S. Eliot, just like the old Magus, knows the difficult road one must
travel in a spiritual pursuit of faith against those who scorn along the way.
In Eliot's poem the magus tells us "I would do it again" in the same way
Eliot would make that same bold statement (84). Dean goes on to say that he
believes Eliot "challenges others, in such ways as writing 'Journey of the
Magi,' to join him in that affirmation" (84).
At the end of Eliot's long and difficult journey he concludes his poem with
"I should be glad of another death," thus bringing"satisfactory" to his search
for a life of faith. The spiritual perplexity of the meaning of birth, death, and
rebirth is the journey that the magi and Eliot himself underwent in their
attempt to find a new faith. In the end, the magi moved to the center of
Christian faith and found that death is the way to rebirth.
Return to Top
Mitzi Streeter
T. S. Eliot's "Journey of the Magi" was first published in 1927, the same
year that "Eliot was received by baptism into the Anglican Church" (Basu
15). Critics suggest that the significance of Eliot's religious conversion
cannot be understated for an analysis of "Journey of the Magi," as it
recounts Eliot's personal conversion experience. While analyzing different
aspects of the poem, the critics agree that Eliot's "Journey of the Magi" is
about his own personal and spiritual conversion experience.
Regardless of the specific focus, critics agree that Eliot's "Journey of the
Magi" is about the personal and spiritual aspects of his religious conversion
experience. In "Journey of the Magi," Eliot displays the depth to which his
journey affected his life by relating his own conflicts with conversion to the
struggles of the original Magi on the first journey to Christ.
Return to Top
Works Cited
Preston D. Finley
Ackroyd, Peter. T. S. Eliot: A Life. New York: Simon and Schuster, 1984.
Basu, Tapan Kumar. "T. S. Eliot: In His Time and In Ours." T. S. Eliot: An
Anthology of Recent
Criticism. Ed. Tapan Kumar Basu. Delhi: Pencraft Intl., 1993. 7-25.
Behr, Caroline. T. S. Eliot: A Chronology of his Life and Works. New York:
St.Martin's P,
1983.
1 (1980-81): 75-84.
Drew, Elizabeth. T. S. Eliot: The Design of His Poetry. New York: Charles
Scribner's
Sons, 1949.
---. Poetry: A Modern Guide to its Understanding and Enjoyment. New
York: Norton, 1959.
Gordon, Lyndall. Eliot's New Life. New York: Oxford UP, 1988.
838-856.
Lucy, Sean. T. S. Eliot and the Idea of Tradition. New York: Barnes &
Noble, 1960.
Sharpe, Tony. T. S. Eliot: A Literary Life. New York: St. Martin's P, 1991.