HUMU 310 Peer Review Outline Rubric

Criteria Unacceptable Needs improvement Exceeds Expectations Excellent

0-19 points 20-34points 35-44 points 45-50 points
Quality of 0-4 5-9 10-14 15-20
Outline Assignment not Assignment written in Assignment written in Assignment written in very
written in outline outline format, but only detailed outline format, detailed outline format,
format; short of 2- includes broadest including major headings including major headings,
page minimum. No subject headings; short and subheadings. Meets or subheadings, subpoints.
sources cited. of 2 page minimum. exceeds 2 page minimum More than four sources
Fewer than four sources requirement. cited.
cited. Four sources cited.

Response to 0 1-4 5-9 10-15

Other Does not respond to Responds to at least 1 or Responds to 2 students’ Responds to more than 2
Students’ any student’s 2 student’s outlines. outlines. Responses are students’ outlines.
Outlines outlines. Responses are not thorough and helpful. Responses are vey
thorough and helpful. thorough and helpful.

Own Blog 0 1-2 3-6 7-10

Activity Does not reply to Replies once to blog Replies twice to blog Replies three or more
any blog comments comment left by peers. comments left by peers. times to blog comments
left by peers. left by peers.
Writing 0-1 2 3-4 5
Mechanics Utilizes poor Writing is somewhat Writing is clear with only Writing is clear and easily
spelling and clear, but occasional rare grammar and spelling understandable. No
grammar errors in spelling and errors. grammar or spelling
throughout. Writing grammar. errors.
is consistently
unclear.