Вы находитесь на странице: 1из 56

T

H
E Original Internist
C•O•N•T•E•N•T•S
CALENDAR OF EVENTS ................................................................................................... 178

FROM THE EDITOR’S DESK ........................................................................................... 179


Jack Kessinger, DC, ND, DABCI

FUNCTIONAL ENDOCRINOLOGY PHILOSOPHY


FOR THE PRACTICING INTERNIST ............................................................................ 180
Datis Kharrazian, DC, DHSc, MS, MNeuroSci, FAACP, DACBN, DIBAK, CNS

THE LEGACY CONTINUES .............................................................................................. 183


A. Jay Kessinger IV, DC, ND, DABCI

THE TOXICITY OF METALS ........................................................................................... 185


E. Blaurock-Busch, PhD

IMMUNE BOOSTING COMPONENTS TO ARREST COLDS AND FLU ................... 189


Rachel Olivier, MS, ND, PhD

LIVER FLUSH: HELP OR HOAX ...................................................................................... 193


E. W. McDonagh, DO

UTILITY OF AN ORAL PRESENTATION OF HCG


(HUMAN CHORIOGONADOTROPIN) FOR THE MANAGEMENT
OF OBESITY: A DOUBLE BLIND STUDY ....................................................................... 197
Daniel Oscar Belluscio, MD, Leonor Ripamonte, MD, Marcelo Wolansky, PhD

BLOOD TRANSFUSIONS ARE VERY DANGEROUS.................................................... 211


Dr. James A. Howenstine

CLINICAL RELEVANCE OF NEUROTRANSMITTER TESTING .............................. 218


Dr. Scott Theirl

ABSTRACTS OF INTEREST .............................................................................................. 222

DABCIs AND WHERE THEY ARE ................................................................................... 227

CLINT PUBLICATIONS

VOL. 16, NO. 4 · ISSN 1529-4722 · DECEMBER 2009


Bio-D-Mulsion Forte ®

from Biotics Research Corporation


Proven Safe and Effective
in the Treatment of Hypovitaminosis D
Bio-D-Mulsion Forte® from Biotics Research Corporation supplies vitamin D3 as
a micro-emulsion for enhanced absorption and utilization, which is particularly important
for those with malabsorption conditions. Clinical use of Biotics’ micro-emulsified vita-
min D provides significant improvements in serum levels of 25-OH-vitamin D following
supplementation.

* Safe - Conservative regimen of Bio-D-Mulsion Forte supplies necessary vitamin D ®

(as emulsified D3) without the increased risk of hypercalcemia commonly associated
with single, large dose therapies – especially important in an outpatient setting.
* Effective - One (1) drop daily of Bio-D-Mulsion Forte (2,000 IU) increased ®

25(OH)D concentrations in vitamin D deficient children 202% in six weeks, effectively


tripling 25(OH)D levels.

* Easy to Administer for Greater Compliance - Simply dispense


one (1) drop from the bottle directly onto the tongue each day.
* Gordon CM, et al.Treatment of Hypovitaminosis D in Infants and Toddlers J. Clin. Endocrin. Metab.
First published ahead of print April 15, 2008 as doi:10.1210/jc.2007-2790

Additionally, Bio-D-Mulsion Forte® contains no artificial colorants or


flavorings and no propylene glycol.
Cost Effective - Of the three regimens tested, the one using
Bio-D-Mulsion Forte® is by far the most cost effective.
(less than a nickel per day - less than $1.50 per month!)

© Copyright 2009

For additional information please contact us:


Biotics Research Corporation • (800) 231-5777
6801 Biotics Research Drive • Rosenberg, TX 77471
Email: biotics@bioticsresearch.com
These statements have not been evaluated by the Food and Drug Administration. This product is not intended to diagnose, treat, cure, or prevent any disease.
THE ORIGINAL INTERNIST
Clint Publications Editor-in-Chief

720 Oak Knoll Jack Kessinger, DC, ND, DABCI

Rolla, MO 65401 Managing Editor


Production Manager
Telephone: (573) 341-8448 Virginia Kessinger
Fax: (573) 341-8494
E-mail: virginia@drkessinger.com Director of Advertising & Marketing
Annette Copeland
www.clintpublications.com
Editorial Staff
The Original Internist is published quarterly. Publication
months are March, June, September and December, barring Jay Kessinger, DC, ND, DABCI
any unusual or unforeseen circumstances. Kimberly Foster
News items and/or letters pertaining to natural health care
are welcome. The editorial staff reserves the right to edit
and/or reject all material received. Letters to the editor Research Editors
may be condensed in order to fit the allotted space. An
Debasis Bagchi, PhD, FACN
address and telephone number where the author may be
Paul Basile, DC
reached during normal business hours should also be
Scott Bautch, DC, SC, DACBOH
included for verification purposes. Deadline for article
Daniel Beeson, DC, DABCI
submission is the 15th of the month preceding publication.
Eleonore Blaurock-Busch, PhD
SUBSCRIPTION & ADDRESS CHANGES Jerome Block, MD, FACP
A subscription to The Original Internist is $50. A free one- Harold M. Chalker, DC, DABCI
year subscription will be given to anyone who submits a Dallas Clouatre, PhD
case study or scientific article which is accepted for John W. Jones, MD, MPH, FAAO, HNS
publication. (This does not include letters to the editor.) Shari Lieberman, PhD, CNS, FACN
Please notify Clint Publications if you change your address Charlyn Marcusen, PhD
or office name, or we cannot be responsible for proper Duane Marquart, DC, DACBR
delivery of your journal. Edward W. McDonagh, DO
Terry Nelson, DC, DABCI
ADVERTISING Doran Nicholson, DC, DACBR
Advertising deadline is the 5th of the month preceding Harry G. Preuss, MD, FACN, CNS
publication. For advertising rates or information, contact Oscar Rasmussen, PhD
Clint Publications. Timothy Ray, DC, FACO, CCSP, CSCS
DISCLAIMER Charles Rudolph, DO
The opinions expressed in The Original Internist are Sidney Stohs, PhD, FACN, FATS, FASAHP
presented for the purpose of providing an open forum for Edward C. Sullivan, DC, PhD, Dipl Ac (IAMA), BCIAC,
unbiased case studies, contemporary ideas and discussion DAPA
of matters relevant to natural health care. Its primary Jon A. Sunderlage, DC, Dipl Ac (NCAOM)
mission is to educate and inform those especially interested Sharon A. Vallone, DC, DICCP
in promoting natural health care as a primary treatment. Steve Watterson, ATC
The opinions expressed in The Original Internist do not Michael Whitehead, DC, DACBR
necessarily reflect the opinions and policies of Clint David Wickes, DC, DABCI
Publications or The Original Internist. Jonathan V. Wright, MD

THE ORIGINAL INTERNIST DECEMBER 2009 177


CALENDAR OF EVENTS
FOR ALL DABCI SEMINARS ….. VISIT OUR NEW WEBSITE www.DABCIdiplomate.com
December 12-13, 2009 (Chicago, IL) February 13-14, 2010 (Kansas City, MO)
Reports, Clinical Documentation & Drug Reactions History Taking
GRADUATION Instructor: Jack Kessinger, DC DABCI
Instructor: Jack Kessinger, DC DABCI
February 13-14, 2010 (Dallas, TX)
January 9-10, 2010 (Dallas, TX) Malignant Diseases, AIDS, & Their Management
Facts of Neoplastic Process & Examining the & Treatment
Cancer Patient Instructor: Wayne Sodano, DC DABCI
Instructor: Jack Kessinger, DC DABCI
February 20-21, 2010 (Los Angeles, CA)
January 16-17, 2010 (Los Angeles, CA) Additional Blood Tests/Tumor Markers for Internal
Multi Channel Blood Chemistries, CBC, Thyroid Disorder Patient
Panel, TSH Instructor: Ben Bowers, DC DABCI
Instructor: Jack Kessinger, DC DABCI
February 27-28, 2010 (Portland, OR)
January 23-24, 2010 (Portland, OR) Chronic Degenerative Disease
Pharmacognosy (Herbal Therapy) Instructor: Bill Kleber, DC DABCI
Instructor: Bill Kleber, DC DABCI
March 6-7, 2010 (Hartford, CT)
January 30-31, 2010 (Kansas City, MO) History Taking
Introduction to Chiropractic Family Practice Wayne Sodano, DC DABC
Instructor: Jack Kessinger, DC DABCI
March 6-7, 2010 (Kansas City, MO)
February 6-7, 2010 (Hartford, CT) The General Examination and Associated Pathology
Introduction to Chiropractic Family Practice Ben Bowers, DC DABC
Instructor: Ben Bowers, DC DABCI

For more information on our 2009-2011 seminars


visit us online at
www.drkessinger.com
then click on ProHealth Seminars

178
THE ORIGINAL INTERNIST Spring 2006 THE ORIGINAL INTERNIST 05
DECEMBER 2009
of cancer screening tests can frequently produce false
positive outcomes that may result not only in anxiety
and additional potentially painful testing, but also
From the additional economic costs as well, according to research
conducted by scientists at the Henry Ford Health
Editor’s System, Detroit, Mich., and published in the December
14, 2004 issue of ” Cancer Epidemiology, Biomarkers

Desk & Prevention.”

This causes me to ponder, how many false positives are


thrown into the scientific data of “cancer cures?” Are
the survivor rates skewed by these “false positives?”
Have we really improved the survivor rate of this
by: Jack Kessinger, DC, ND, DABCI Dr. Jack Kessinger devastating disease, or do these numbers include the
jack@drkessinger.com results of women who never had cancer in the first
place?

It seems to me that a simple blood test like the CA 15-3


or CA 27-29 would be a much better screening option
I have long questioned why mammograms are often for the women affected. They are non-invasive and the
accepted to be the test of choice to diagnose breast answer is a clear yes or no. For a physician who is
cancer, rather than the much less invasive tumor required to read a mammogram and determine if a
markers, Cancer Antigen 15-3 (CA 15-3), and/or shadow is truly something to be concerned about.
Cancer Antigen 27-29 (CA 27-29). Now, with Wouldn’t the best answer be a solid negative or
healthcare reform looming, discussion is running positive? A tumor marker test returns a definitive
rampant and opinions are all over the place concerning answer, and erases the need for further testing; such as
the frequency of mammograms. painful biopsies which require, at a minimum, an out
patient situation. Many times this potentially life
One side of the mammogram issue argues that patients changing blood test is only done after a radical
should not be exposed to radiation annually. In 1977, mastectomy has been performed; to rule out the
the US National Cancer Institute held its first existence of cancer. If this test is considered accurate
“consensus” conference and the topic was mamm- after disfiguring a woman for the rest of her life, why
ography screening of healthy women for the early wouldn’t it be a required test before a mastectomy is
detection of breast cancer. Since that time, there have considered as the only option? Often, women are opting
been notable improvements in the imaging capabilities for mastectomies out of fear that the shadow on their
of the x-ray units and an appreciable lowering of mammogram may eventually turn into cancer.
radiation dose to breast tissue. One of the controversies
today surrounding the screening of healthy women is The opponents of “less mammogram testing” question
whether the radiation exposures are hazardous, and the reportedly successful treatment therapies of breast
whether young women, under the age of 50 benefit cancer. Touting that what we have been doing is
from mammograms. working, but is it really? Is exposing women as early as
age 30 to radiation for a base line test, and then
Everyone is exposed to ionizing radiation from natural annually after age 40 safe? More importantly does it
and medical sources. In fact, ionizing radiation may be provide information that can be used with confidence? I
the most studied cancer causing agent in humans with would hope that before one of your patients or family
scientific committees on radiation continuously re- members subject themselves to a mastectomy, that you
viewing and evaluating adverse health outcomes for would recommend a simple blood test to confirm the
over 70 years. The female breast is known to be highly existence or non-existence of cancer with certainty.
susceptible to the cancer causing effects of radiation
when exposure occurs before menopause. Dr. Kessinger has a local weekly radio program called
“A Healthy Concept” every Tuesday morning from
Recent reports say there are entirely too many false 9:30-10. The programs are available on his website
positives reported with mammograms, which result in www.drkessinger.com or go directly to
unwarranted anxiety for patients. The current standard www.drkessinger.com/radio.html ‹

THE ORIGINAL INTERNIST DECEMBER 2009 179


tance, or elevated androstenedione competing with tes-
tosterone receptor sites. Each one of the patterns would
dictate different clinical management for the patient.
Functional The traditional healthcare system is based on identifying

Endocrinology
pathology or naming the condition. The name given to
the set of symptoms will then establish treatment. The
treatment is focused on the diagnosis, not on the pa-
Philosophy for the tient’s specific physiological expression. On the other
hand, the functional approach is not based on treating the

Practicing Internist
name given to the set of symptoms, but rather on the
specific physiological shifts expressed by the patient.

by: Datis Kharrazian, DC, DHSc, MS, MNeuroSci, FAACP, DACBN, The goal of functional endocrinology is to assess the
DIBAK, CNS endocrine system and find the mechanisms for imbal-
ance. If a patient demonstrates a hormone imbalance, to
functional endocrinologists the first step is to identify the
mechanism. For example, if a 28-year-old female pre-
Functional Endocrinology Philosophy sents with depressed progesterone levels, the mechanism
for the deficiency must be evaluated rather than immedi-
In order to truly understand the philosophy of functional ately considering progesterone replacement. The func-
endocrinology, we must first compare and contrast func- tional endocrinologist will evaluate basic physiological
tional endocrinology to standard pathological-centered mechanisms first, identify the mechanism for the pattern,
models. Secondly, we must compare the functional en- and then consider the appropriate treatment. The patient
docrinology model to the pharmaceutical-based models that presents with low progesterone may have depressed
and models of hormone replacement therapy. To put it LH levels, defects of the corpus luteum, a diminished
simply, the functional endocrinology approach does not estradiol peak, suppressed follicle-stimulating hormone,
determine future clinical management based on the name or she may have an autoimmune response against her
of the condition, but rather on the unique physiologic follicles. The goal of the functional endocrinologist is to
expression of the patient. In addition, the functional en- identify the mechanism. Let’s say further evaluation of
docrinology approach does not simply identify defi- the 28-year-old patient identifies depressed LH. Since
ciency of hormones and prescribe replacement, but the LH is depressed, the possibility of corpus luteum
rather it attempts to find the mechanism of the hormone defect is unlikely. The next question must be, “Why is
imbalance and change its expression with diet, nutrition, the LH low?” A healthy estradiol peak midcycle triggers
and lifestyle change whenever possible. normal LH release. If the estradiol peak is normal, then
the focus is on the failure of the pituitary to release LH.
The functional endocrinology approach is physiology- If the estradiol peak is abnormal then the functional en-
based, not condition-based. The functional endocrinolo- docrinologist must continue his or her assessment and
gist does not determine treatment based on the ICD-9 find out why the estradiol peak is abnormal. Let’s say
diagnosis, but rather the patient’s unique phenotypic ex- that in this patient we determine that the estradiol peak is
pression. For example, if a male has low libido and erec- normal and the LH and progesterone are depressed. This
tile dysfunction in standard healthcare, he would be di- pattern clearly indicates that the low progesterone is re-
agnosed with erectile dysfunction (799.89) and placed lated to the release of LH. The next step would be to
on medications to stimulate the body to increase blood identify why the LH is suppressed, followed by strate-
supply to the genitals. He would follow the established gies to increase LH output. LH suppression is most com-
and published standard of care with a pharmaceutical monly related to cytokines such as interleukin-6 released
protocol. In the functional endocrinology approach, the during a chronic stress response, or a previous history of
name and identification of the condition would be con- exogenous progesterone overload. In this example, let’s
sidered in the clinical work-up, but the mechanism for say the patient is in an active stress response because she
their condition would be evaluated. A male with low is hypoglycemic and has adrenal exhaustion. Therefore
libido may have depressed testosterone, elevated estro- clinical management will include lifestyle changes to
gen, depressed luteinizing hormone (LH), elevated dihy- stabilize blood sugar imbalances and supplements to
drotestosterone creating androgen receptor site resis- help support adrenal function and glycemic stability. The
(Continued on page 182)

THE ORIGINAL INTERNIST


180 Spring 2006 THE ORIGINAL INTERNIST DECEMBER 2009
05
IODORAL®
Lugol solution in tablet form
Available in tablets of 12.5 mg packaged Now available also in tablets of 50 mg
in bottles of 90 tablets and 180 tablets packaged in bottles of 30 and 90 tablets

Based on the collective experience of U.S. physicians who used Lugol solution extensively
in their practice for iodine supplementation over the past century, the recommended
daily intake for iodine supplementation was 0.1 to 0.3 ml containing 12.5 to 37.5
mg elemental iodine (1-3). We recently confirmed the keen observation of our medical
predecessors: this is exactly the range of iodine/iodide intake required for whole body
sufficiency, based on a recently developed iodine/iodide loading test (3). For non obese
subjects, whole body sufficiency for iodine can be achieved within 3 months with daily
intake of 12.5 to 50 mg (4,5).
1) Abraham, G.E., Flechas, J.D., Hakala, J.C., Orthoiodosupplementation: Iodine sufficiency of the whole human body. The Original Internist, 9:30-41, 2002.
2) Gennaro, A.R., Remington: The Science and Practice of Pharmacy, 19th Edition, 1995, Mack Publishing Co., 976 & 1267.
3) Abraham, G.E., The safe and effective implementation of orthoiodosupplementation in medical practice. The Original Internist, 11:17-33, 2004.
4) Abraham, G.E., The concept of orthoiodosupplementation and its clinical implications. The Original Internist, 11:29-38, 2004.
5) Abraham, G.E., The historical background of the iodine project. The Original Internist, 12(2):57-66, 2005.

For further information on:


-
-
IODORAL ®
Reprints of relevant articles
- How to implement orthoiodosupplementation in your practice
- How to request kits for the iodine/iodide loading test
Vist our website at www.optimox.com
Or contact us at: OPTIMOX CORPORATION P.O. Box 3378 Torrance, CA 90510-3378
or Call Toll Free: (800) 223-1601 or Fax: (310) 618-8748 or Email: optimox@earthlink.net
mechanism for LH suppression is identified and sup- • Treatment and management is virtually identical for
ported. In addition, the functional endocrinologist will all patients.
use compounds like vitex to enhance the stimulation of • Diagnostic testing is used to establish the disease
LH release. process and is not unique to the patient’s physiologi-
Note that in this example progesterone was not used, cal expression.
because rather than providing exogenous support for low • Clinically, competency in the model is based on
progesterone, the mechanism of the imbalance was iden- following standard of care management.
tified and treated appropriately. As a matter of fact, if
progesterone were to be used in this example, it would FUNCTIONAL MODEL PRINCIPLES
actually further dampen LH and may cause long-term
dysregulation of LH-progesterone feedback loop coordi- • Based on understanding the physiological imbal-
nation. Although a deficiency of progesterone was iden- ances of the patient and not limited to identifying
tified, it was related to primary pituitary output, not a diagnosis. The diagnosis is established, but not used
glandular defect. This patient may end up with long-term exclusively to determine management.
dependency on progesterone replacement if her LH out- • Nutritional support is specific to the patient and not
put function becomes depressed. The outcome of this the diagnosis.
may be infertility and inability to have proper healthy • Diet and lifestyle management are strongly
and normally sequenced menstrual cycles after the pro- emphasized.
gesterone replacement protocol. • Management is different for virtually all individuals
with the same exact diagnosis.
In summary, the functional approach is “physiology-
based” and the traditional healthcare model is “condition • Diagnostic testing and monitoring is used to
-based”. The functional approach uses diet, nutrition, establish physiological process.
and lifestyle as tools to modulate the abnormal physiol- • Competency in this model is based on reviewing and
ogic expression of the patient, and is therefore “nutrition managing altered physiology versus diagnosis.
and lifestyle based.” The traditional model uses synthetic
agents and hormones as tools to manage the patient and Functional Endocrinology Clinical Applications
is therefore “pharmaceutical based.” Clinical compe- Three main attributes are necessary for functional
tency in the traditional model of healthcare is based on endocrinology. They include: (1) A detailed understand-
identifying the appropriate diagnosis and following the ing of physiological interactions, feedback loops, and
standard of care flow chart. Competency in the use of the biochemistry; (2) A detailed understanding of laboratory
appropriate drug is strongly emphasized, whereas diet, evaluation; and (3) A detailed understanding of the
nutrition, and lifestyle changes are ignored or not em- specific influence of natural compounds on physiologi-
phasized. In the functional model, competency in dis- cal systems. Mastery of all three attributes is critical for
secting and evaluating physiological pathways and rec- competence in the functional endocrinology approach. In
ommending nutrition, diet, and lifestyle change is addition, the functional endocrinologist must be
strongly emphasized, whereas drug therapy and hormone competent in areas outside of endocrinology, such as
replacement are not strongly emphasized. Lastly, it immunology, gastroenterology, neurology, and detoxifi-
should be made clear that not all conditions are amena- cation. The endocrine system must not be evaluated in
ble to the functional approach, and the appropriate iden- isolation from other physiological systems. An
tification of pathology must always be conducted and understanding of neuroendocrine-immune interactions is
managed medically when appropriate. critical for management of chronic metabolic disorders.
The intimate connections between these bodily systems
PATHOLOGICAL MODEL PRINCIPLES must be appreciated and evaluated clinically. Four
clinical priorities have been established in the functional
• Focused on establishing diagnosis (ICD.9 code). The endocrinology model when it comes to balancing the
primary goal is to label the series of symptoms and endocrine system without hormones, which include: (1)
signs into an established category. The diagnosis Balancing blood sugar and adrenal abnormalities; (2)
code name will be the indicator for management. Normalizing gastrointestinal function and decreasing
• Treatment and management is specific to the antigenic exposure to the gut; (3) Balancing essential
diagnosis and not the patient. fatty acid metabolism; and (4) Enhancing the detoxifica-
• Dietary and lifestyle management is weakly tion capacities of the individual. ‹
emphasized.

THE ORIGINAL INTERNIST


182 Spring 2006 THE ORIGINAL INTERNIST DECEMBER 2009
05
and what type of care individual patients will be able to
receive. The art of health care will potentially be

The
degraded to technical applications of prepackaged
protocols with the fundamental purpose of cost and
resource containment for the greater good of the
Legacy masses. No longer will the health care consumer be in
the authoritative position of employer, but they will be

Continues another subservient cog in the wheel of the bureau of


our governments’ new social health provision division.
by: A. Jay Kessinger IV, DC, ND, DABCI Of course, that will put you and I on the bottom of that
jay@drkessinger.com
Dr. Jay Kessinger
food chain. I don’t mind being employed directly by
those I’ve chose to serve, I understand the whole
employer/employee concept and I’m comfortable with
it; however, when the patient, the one we have the
privilege to serve, no longer has the last word, much
Someone once told me, “You can’t expect those that set less signs our paycheck, I wonder how this will effect
the rules to rule in your favor if you make them look our psyche/drive and bottom line, our ability to provide
foolish.” I took that as a fundamental lesson in politics; for them and our families.
i.e., Politics 101. Within my first year of practice I
realized that I was not in a good location for myself. I’ve gathered, the rift against the “nay sayers” of
Distraught, I remember telling Grandad, Dr. A. J. national health care, is that we complain about the(ir)
Kessinger II, “I thought I was entering the ‘living solution given, but we contribute no new ideas to solve
happily ever after’ portion of my life, but I’m just not the division in this country between the haves’ and
getting there.” He explained to me that there’s always have nots’. First, I’d like to point out that we do not
one major problem, sometimes three or four that simul- have anyone in this country so destitute that they are
taneously have to be dealt with, and a whole host of beyond receiving emergency and life continuing types
little ones that need to be taken care of at all times. I of health care, from before and including child birth to
recall thinking, “there are only glimpses of utopia this diabetic, cardiac and even cancer medical care. Most
side of heaven. So much for my short sighted idealistic importantly, I hope to illustrate our need for a paradigm
view of the post collegiate world I was now a part of.” shift in health care delivery, not in its payment system.
I took that as a fundamental lesson in life; i.e., Life It is true that the pharmaceutical companies appear to
101. have a strangle-hold on the health care industry, with
both its consumers and providers alike; however, this is
The current political climate consists of many capitalism at work. Curbing pharmaceutical appeal is
governmental corrections for the private sector. One what they did in New Zealand when television
such correction our federal government is fervently advertising of prescription medications was halted.
grappling to attain is within the health provisionary Let’s face it, when people can go to a prescribing
system. National health care, many have touted, may physician and eagerly accept and expect the side effects
very well have little to do with individual attainment of so they can enjoy the superficial benefits without the
the tools necessary to prevent disease, nor the freedom full understanding of the pathophysiology involved in
to receive all the necessary aspects of care needed to the treatment of their disorder and then, if serious
treat each persons’ diseased/injured/infected state of unknown complications arise, join a class action
unhealth. Rationing of governmental resources has lawsuit for damages incurred, there is an egregious
been sited as a potential problem with nationalized work of capitalism at play. Health care is by definition
health care as well. The health care consumers will to care for health, and not to be disregardent of it.
most assuredly be affected by many of the proposed
changes, as will their employers. The paradigm shift we really need of our health care is
in its provision, not in its payment. The answers to
The other side of the coin is how the proposed most health loss and the enhancing longevity dilemmas
nationalized health insurance plan will affect the are presently known; i.e., diet, exercise, and other
providers. Of course, as American citizens and em- healthy, life style habits; but are too often ignored and
ployers, this will affect us more than most, it appears. made unattainable for most through the advertising
This has the feel of a mandated federal HMO, where media. The proposed nationalized health care system
non-physicians will determine how often, how much, will not give this human touch we need. ‹

THE ORIGINAL INTERNIST DECEMBER 2009 183


GOT PAIN?
Experience Relief
Like Never Before

Curamin enhances the body’s


100% natural defense mechanisms for the
All-Natural
relief of PAIN due to overuse*

After suffering with severe knee pain, a friend of mine told me about this product.
Within 45 minutes I was able to walk without a limp, also was able to bend my right knee
while walking! I thought I was going to have to retire from working! This is amazing,
I am almost 90% pain free after only 40 minutes, God Bless you for this!
—Tom H, Galveston, TX

WOW! Holy Camoly!!!!! I used other pain pills and nothing has helped as well as
this Curamin, I just took it an hour ago! I was so impressed I had to write and tell you
immediately. I definitely will be buying this as my new “best friend” when I have pain.
—Janine T, Grand Blanc, MI

“From my clinical experience, I have found Curamin to be highly


effective. It is the #1 pain-relieving product that I recommend.”

Duke Liberatore and Jan McBarron, M.D.


Duke and The Doctor The #1 Health Talk Radio Show in the Nation

Samples Available
www.Curamin.com
Call: 866-598-5487
* THIS STATEMENT HAS NOT BEEN EVALUATED BY THE FOOD AND DRUG ADMINISTRATION. THIS PRODUCT IS NOT INTENDED TO DIAGNOSE, TREAT, CURE OR PREVENT DISEASE. ©2008
acids of a protein in a redox reaction that disrupts its
ability to carry out its biological function. Metal ions can

The Toxicity
also remove an electron from the bases of DNA. Such
oxidative damage to these biological molecules is
implicated in the cumulative effects associated with

of Metals aging and in the mutations associated with cancer. 1

Are heavy metals the same as toxic metals?


by: E. Blaurock-Busch, PhD In short, the answer is no, as "heavy" refers to the atomic
weight of an element, not its tendency to behave as a
biological bully. While the heavy metals cadmium, lead
and mercury are toxic, molybdenum is a heavy but
essential metal, while beryllium is a light but very toxic
(the following is an unpublished excerpt from the metal.
not-yet published: Antidota-Handbook of Chelation
Therapies. 2007 MTM, Germany/USA) Heavy metals have always been present in the earth's
ecosystem, but since the Industrial Revolution there has
Any metal capable of disrupting essential physiological been a massive redistribution of metals on the surface of
processes is considered toxic. Examples of this are the earth. What has changed, is the relative availability
cadmium, lead and mercury. Other metals in the wrong and the forms in which metals are being dispersed.
form can be toxic. For example, chromium as the Cr+3
ion is an essential trace element important for The problem with certain heavy metals is that they tend
maintaining correct blood sugar levels, but as the Cr+6 to form very stable and long-lasting complexes with
ion, it is a known human lung carcinogen. sulphur in biological molecules, which can disrupt their
biological function. In some cases this allows these
The toxic effects of most metals can be traced to their metals to become concentrated at higher levels of the
ability to disrupt the function of essential biological food chain.1
molecules; such as proteins, enzymes and DNA. In some
cases this involves displacing chemically related metal Metals in Environmental Medicine
ions that are required for important biological functions; While some European countries enforce strict reg-
such as cell growth, division and repair. We have to ulations, the Asian countries, by comparison, are more
acknowledge that our present knowledge regarding relaxed about enforcing international standards. Overall,
metal toxicity is much greater than a century ago, but the World Health Organization (WHO) tries to oversee
will be regarded insufficient decades from now. that regulations are followed and holds workshops in
various parts of the world, regarding environmental
Proteins, in particular, play an astounding number and health. Several heavy metals have become of concern to
variety of roles in living organisms. They are used as countries, such as India, where arsenic in water has
structural elements, for sending signals both within and affected the health of large number of people. Cadmium
between cells, and as enzymes for the synthesis and in rice has been a concern, or mercury in fish near
degradation of other biological molecules. If a metal ion
binds to the amino acids of a protein, the resulting metal-
protein complex may lack the protein's original
biological activity.

One metal may also substitute for another similar metal.


For example, the toxic metal, cadmium, can substitute
for the essential metal, zinc, in certain proteins that
require zinc for their structure or function. This can lead
to alterations in that protein that can have toxic
consequences. In the same way, lead can substitute for
calcium in bone, and in other sites where calcium is
required.

Metal ions can also remove an electron from the amino


(Continued on next page)

THE ORIGINAL INTERNIST DECEMBER 2009 185


mining areas in Indonesia and other parts of the world.4 The CERCLA Priority List
ATSDR and the EPA prepare a list, in order of priority,
Just recently, Micro Trace Minerals under the direction ranking substances that are most commonly found at
of Dr. E. Blaurock-Busch tested hair and urine analysis, facilities on the National Priorities List (NPL) and which
before and after oral DMPS provocation. The majority are determined to pose the most significant potential
of the nearly 150 test persons included in the study were threat to human health due to their known or suspected
physically and mentally challenged children, many toxicity and potential for human exposure at these NPL
suffering from cerebral palsy. sites.

Unusually high hair levels of manganese, strontium and This CERCLA priority list is revised and published on a
uranium were seen in over 80% of the patients. Urine 2-year basis, with a yearly informal review and revision.
testing before and after DMSA chelation substantiated This priority list is based on an algorithm that utilizes the
these findings. The final test results are now statistically following three components: frequency of occurrence at
evaluated. Visit http://chelattherapie.blogspot.com for NPL sites, toxicity, and potential for human exposure to
more information. the substances found at NPL sites. This algorithm
utilizes data from ATSDR's HazDat database, which
The Toxicity of Metals in General Health Care contains information from ATSDR's public health
In the US, the Agency for Toxic Substances and Disease assessments and health consultations.
Registry (ATSDR), based in Atlanta, Georgia, is a
federal public health agency of the U.S. Department of It should be noted that this priority list is not a list of
Health and Human Services. ATSDR serves the public "most toxic" substances, but rather a prioritization of
by incorporating and reflecting on academic and medical substances based on a combination of their frequency,
knowledge, taking responsive public health actions, and toxicity, and potential for human exposure at NPL sites.
providing official health information to prevent harmful
exposures and diseases related to toxic substances.5 Of the 275 substances listed, only some are listed and
discussed here. Ranking is shown in the column on the
The World Health Organization (WHO) provides left i.e. Arsenic is ranked as Toxin #1; Sodium Arsenite
recommendations regarding the industrial and is ranked as #241. (see next page)
environmental use of potentially hazardous substances.
It also provides international standards regarding ex- References
posure and recommends reference ranges for human 1. Dartmouth Toxic Metals Research Program © 2001.
biomonitoring. http://www.dartmouth.edu/~toxmetal/TX.shtml
2. OSHA
European countries have their individual Environmental 3. Messeter A. Lunds University, Faculty of Medicine.
Health Protection Agencies, which govern use and Public health effects of exposure to toxic metals – a
exposure of toxic substances. Laboratory diagnostics and new study. http://www.med.lu.se/english/research/
reference ranges are based on these agencies recom- evaluation_of_research
mendations.6 4. Report of Environmental Health Impacts from
Exposure to Metals. 1-3 June 2005, Simla, India.
The Toxic Metal Information below is based on ATSDR WHO 2005
official toxic facts and covers only toxic metals with a 5. ASTDR
history of toxicity as recognized by governmental and 6. Blaurock-Busch E. Antidota-Handbook of Chelation
academic sources. Additional information can be Therapies. 2007 MTM, Germany/USA ‹
obtained by e-mailing: cdcinfo@cdc.gov

The information on chelation and the tables (graphs) ADVERTISE IN


listed, refer only to synthetic chelating agents and are
largely based on laboratory data from Micro Trace
Minerals, Germany/USA. For details and specifics
THE ORIGINAL INTERNIST
regarding Chelation Protocols see Chapter 5 and for
Call (573) 341-8448
information on non-synthetic chelation agents and
specific protocols are listed in Chapter 6 of my book.
e-mail: virginia@drkessinger.com
Website: www.drkessinger.com

THE ORIGINAL INTERNIST


186 Spring 2006 THE ORIGINAL INTERNIST DECEMBER 2009
05
2007 RANK SUBSTANCE NAME TOTAL POINTS 2005 RANK CAS #

1 ARSENIC 1672.58 1 007440-38-2


2 LEAD 1534.07 2 007439-92-1
3 MERCURY 1504.69 3 007439-97-6
7 CADMIUM 1324.22 8 007440-43-9
18 CHROMIUM, HEXAVALENT 1149.98 18 018540-29-9
42 BERYLLIUM 1046.12 40 007440-41-7
49 COBALT 1015.57 50 007440-48-4
53 NICKEL 1005.4 55 007440-02-0
65 CHROMIUM(VI) OXIDE 969.58 66 001333-82-0
74 ZINC 932.89 74 007440-66-6
77 CHROMIUM 908.52 77 007440-47-3
109 BARIUM 813.46 109 007440-39-3
117 MANGANESE 807.9 115 007439-96-5
123 METHYLMERCURY 806.39 121 022967-92-6
125 LEAD-210 805.9 124 014255-04-0
128 COPPER 804.86 133 007440-50-8
147 SELENIUM 778.98 147 007782-49-2
180 PALLADIUM 700.66 177 007440-05-3
187 ALUMINUM 688.13 186 007429-90-5
198 VANADIUM 651.7 198 007440-62-2
214 SILVER 612.19 213 007440-22-4
215 CHROMIUM TRIOXIDE 610.85 218 007738-94-5
219 ANTIMONY 605.37 222 007440-36-0
223 ARSENIC ACID 604.45 226 007778-39-4
224 ARSENIC TRIOXIDE 604.36 227 001327-53-3
234 ARSINE 602.42 237 007784-42-1
241 CALCIUM ARSENATE 601.45 244 007778-44-1
241 MERCURIC CHLORIDE 601.45 244 007487-94-7
241 SODIUM ARSENITE 601.45 244 007784-46-5

THE ORIGINAL INTERNIST DECEMBER 2009 187


Additionally, the comprehensive vitamin D system
exerts a cumulative effect on the immune response.
Immune Boosting Consequently, immune responses are exceedingly depen
-dent upon an adequate vitamin D status. Vitamin D has

Components to Arrest also been associated with the activation of toll-like


receptors (TLRs), specifically TLR2. Toll-like receptors

Colds and Flu


provide defense against pathogens, by virtue of their
response to “conserved pathogen-associated molecular
patterns derived from bacteria, mycoplasma, fungi or
viruses.”10 In light of epidemiological data, Cannell and
by : Rachel Olivier, MS, ND, PhD colleagues have proposed that the production of vitamin
Submitted by: Biotics Research Corporation
D elicits a “seasonal stimulus” which underlies the
seasonality of epidemic influenza.11,12,13 Cumulatively,
During this time of the year, our nutritional focus vitamin D’s specific response has been correlated with
typically spotlights the cold and flu season. Nutrients to an enhancement of innate immunity, coupled with
support the ramifications of such immune disturbances multifaceted regulation of adaptive immunity.14
are an important component of the nutritional arsenal.
This topic becomes especially pertinent this year in light Neonatal Thymus glandular
of the new H1N1 flu. It is well known in the alternative The thymus gland is the initial migratory place of the T
healthcare industry that keeping the immune system lymphocytes following their origination in the bone
healthy contributes significantly to the prevention of marrow. In the thymus, the T lymphocytes gain further
seasonal illnesses. In light of this, components noted to specificity, forming either helper T-cells (CD4) or
have a beneficial effect on the immune response, and to cytotoxic T-cells (CD8). The helper T-cells function in
aid in keeping the immune system healthy are discussed. aiding other cells of the immune system by promoting
their activation, while the cytotoxic T-cells act directly
Larch Arabinogalactans on infected or diseased cells. Epithelial cells of the
Arabinogalactans derived from the Western Larch, Larix thymic cortex express both class I and class II MHC
occidentalis consist of highly branched nondigestible antigens,15,16 which function in the development of T
polysaccharides, composed primarily of galactose and lymphocytes within the thymus.17
arabinose in a 6:1 ratio. In addition to the Larch, many
edible plants are also a rich source of arabinogalactans, In a study with children, oral consumption of thymus
including; among others carrots,1,2 pears,3 tomatoes,4 and glandular was demonstrated to result in a significant
maize.5 decrease in the frequency of recurrent respiratory in-
fections. Additionally, in the supplemented group a
The immune-enhancing properties of Larch arabin- statistically significant increase in the level of salivary
ogalactans suggest that it possesses an array of clinical IgA (P<0.02) was observed.18 The beneficial attributes
applications, both in preventive medicine, due to its of thymus glandular in this capacity was attributed to a
ability to build a more responsive immune system, and “restorative" effect.19 Other studies have concurred the
in clinical medicine, as a therapeutic agent in conditions beneficial attributes of thymus glandular extract, which
associated with lowered immune function, decreased NK included accelerated bone marrow recovery and
activity, or chronic viral infection.6 Its use has also been normalization of the peripheral blood count.20, 21, 22, 23
demonstrated to enhance the cytotoxicity of natural killer Intake has also been shown to benefit recurrent
(NK) cells,7 implying an additional benefit in immune respiratory tract infections, resulting in a lowered
support. In one cell culture study, the pretreatment of frequency of infection, a shortened time of infection
cells with arabinogalactan from Larix occidentalis was (mean = 3 days), and a diminished severity of re-
demonstrated to induce a moderately increased release of currences.24
TNFα, interleukin 1β (IL-1β), interferon gamma (IFN-γ)
and interleukin 6 (IL-6).8 Neonatal Bovine Trachea
Trachea tissue is a powerful immune modulator, whose
The cells involved in both innate and adaptive immune use was historically examined by John Prudden, MD of
responses, including macrophages, dendritic cells, T Harvard University. Trachea tissue has been specifically
cells and B cells, are known to express the vitamin D referred to as an “immunoregulator,” functioning to both
receptor (VDR) on the cell surface, and can both stimulate the immune system, as well as to repress it, as
produce and respond to vitamin D (1,25(OH2)D3).9 in instances of an overactive immune response. It is said
(Continued on next page)
THE ORIGINAL INTERNIST DECEMBER
SEPTEMBER2009
2008 119
189
to resemble fetal mesenchyme, which is the primordial were absent.39 A separate long-term trial (five years)
tissue from which muscle, bone, bone marrow, tendons, reported evidence of a 66% decrease in the common
ligaments, and skin develop.25 The antigen presenting cold with a daily 500 mg dose of vitamin C, compared
capacity (APC)26 of trachea tissue is well established, to a daily low dose (50 mg).40
with it demonstrating the ability to secrete IL-1 and to
express MHC class II antigens.27 Its action was also Echinacea
observed to result in an increase in the activation of Echinacea use for upper respiratory tract infections is
both macrophages and cytotoxic T cells, along with a well recognized. As a member of the aster family
stimulation of B cells, resulting in an increase in (Asteraceae), its primary components include poly-
immunoglobulins A, G and M, with an overall increase saccharides, glycoproteins, alkamides, volatile oils, and
in antimitotic activity.25 An immunostimulatory flavonoids. The roots contain a high concentration of
response to viruses has also been demonstrated, volatile oils, while the above-ground parts of the plant
resulting in viral resistance.28 Given the fact that the tend to contain a higher percentage of polysaccharide
entire respiratory tract contains dendritic cells, capable components, which serve in triggering an immune
of functioning in antigen presentation, it is hypo- activation. The above ground components are approved
thesized that these cells play an important role in the in Germany for the treatment of colds, upper
immune responses of the entire respiratory system,29 respiratory tract infections, urinary tract infections, and
including the thoracic cavity, the nasal cavity, the slow-healing wounds, while the root components are
pharynx, the larynx, as well as both the bronchi and approved for the treatment of flu-like symptoms.41 In a
alveoli. meta-analysis examining the effect of Echinacea on the
deterrence and management of the common cold, a
Vitamin A 58% decrease in the odds of developing the common
Vitamin A is directly involved in protein synthesis, cold was demonstrated (p<0.001), in addition to a
both at the transcriptional and translational level.30 In decrease in the duration by 1.4 days (p=0.01).42 It is
addition to these roles, it is also known to play a also approved by the German Commission E expert
functional role in gene activation.31 The immune panel as an adjunct therapeutic in influenza-like
supporting properties of vitamin A are well established, infections.43
including its ability to enhance natural killer (NK) cell
activity,32 as well as its ability to decrease bacterial Broad Spectrum Vitamin/Mineral Combination
adhesion to the respiratory epithelium.33 In addition to In addition to the products discussed above, immune
these attributes, it is also speculated that vitamin A protection may also be accomplished by the use of a
contributes to the immune response by virtue of its broad spectrum multi vitamin/mineral supplement, con-
"anti-infective" properties, specifically by contributing taining immune supporting nutrients. Immune
to both the maintenance and differentiation of the supporting components, which provide beneficial
intestinal and respiratory epithelium.34 In animals a attributes, include citrus bioflavonoids, Echinacea,
deficiency in Vitamin A was demonstrated to Capsicum annuum, chlorophyllins and a source of
drastically impair the secretory IgA (sIgA) response to methyl donors and acceptors, which serves to assist
influenza infection, with a corresponding modest with various metabolic conversions, including free
increase in the serum IgG.35 The sIgA-mediated radical conversion. Glandular components including
response is considered a “crucial step in achieving adrenal, thymus, spleen, liver, pancreas, parotid, lymph
efficient protection of the epithelial barrier,”36 while and placenta also serve to provide both organ and
IgG aids in the preparation of the antigen to the immune support.
phagocytic cells, thus enhancing phagocytosis.37
It is well documented that multiple factors, including
Vitamin C age, stress, and dietary insufficiencies can negatively
Leukocytes are known to contain a high concentration impact the immune system. Inadequate nutrition along
of vitamin C. Preventative trials utilizing 1 gram of with a poor diet makes one more susceptible to
vitamin C have shown that daily use reduces the succumbing to illnesses. The combined use of select
duration of colds in adults by 8% and in children by nutrients or combination thereof, as noted above,
14%.38 In a review of trials by Hemilä et al., it was provides support to strengthen the immune system, and
determined that supplemental vitamin C (average dose subsequently the immune response, making one less
of 1g/day) reduced the duration of colds by about 23%, susceptible to seasonal illnesses.
and ameliorated symptoms, although consistent effects (Continued on next page)

THE ORIGINAL INTERNIST


190 Spring 2006 THE ORIGINAL INTERNIST DECEMBER 2009
05
References
Expression of HLA antigens by human thymic
epithelial cells. Hum Immunol. 1982 5:21.
1. Pennell RI, Knox JP, Scofield GN, Selvendran RR, 16. Van Ewijk W, Rouse RV, Weissman IL: Distribution
Roberts K. A family of abundant plasma membrane- of H-2 microenvironments in the mouse thymus,
associated glycoproteins related to the lmmunoelectron microscopic identification of I-A and
arabinogalactan proteins is unique to flowering H-2K bearing cells. J Histochem Cytochem. 1980
plants. J Cell Biol. 1989 May;108(5):1967-77. 28:1089.
2. Baldwin TC, McCann MC, Roberts K. A Novel 17. Jenkinson EJ, van Ewijk W, Owen JJT. Major
Hydroxyproline-Deficient Arabinogalactan Protein histocompatibility complex antigen expression on the
Secreted by Suspension-Cultured Cells of Daucus epithelium of the developing thymus in normal and
carota (Purification and Partial Characterization). nude mice. J Exp Med. 1981 153:280.
Plant Physiol. 1993 Sep;103(1):115-123. 18. Fiocchi A, Borella E, Riva E, Arensi D, Travaglini P,
3. Chen CG, Pu ZY, Moritz RL, Simpson RJ, Bacic A, Cazzola P, Giovannini M. A double-blind clinical trial
Clarke AE, Mau SL. Molecular cloning of a gene for the evaluation of the therapeutical effectiveness of a
encoding an arabinogalactan-protein from pear (Pyrus calf thymus derivative (Thymomodulin) in children
communis) cell suspension culture. Proc Natl Acad with recurrent respiratory infections. Thymus. 1986 8
Sci USA. 1994 Oct 25;91(22):10305-9. (6):331-9.
4. Related Articles, LinksPogson BJ, Davies C. 19. Longo F, Lepore L, Agosti E, Panizon F. [Evaluation
Characterization of a cDNA encoding the protein of the effectiveness of thymomodulin in children with
moiety of a putative arabinogalactan protein from recurrent respiratory infections]. [Article in Italian]
Lycopersicon esculentum. Plant Mol Biol. 1995 Pediatr Med Chir. 1988 Nov-Dec;10(6):603-7.
May;28(2):347-52. 20. Skotnicki AB, Dabrowska-Bernstein BK, Dabrowski
5. Kieliszewski MJ, Kamyab A, Leykam JF, Lamport MP, Gorski A, Czarnecki J, Aleksandrowicz J.
DT. A Histidine-Rich Extensin from Zea mays Is an Biological properties and clinical use of calf thymus
Arabinogalactan Protein. Plant Physiol. 1992 Jun;99 extract TFX-Polfa, in Goldstein A L (ed): Thymic
(2):538-547. Hormones and Lymphokines, pp. 545-564, New York,
6. Kelly GS. Larch arabinogalactan: clinical relevance Plenum Press (1984).
of a novel immune-enhancing polysaccharide. Altern 21. Aleksandrowicz J, Blicharski J, Janicki K, Lisiewicz J,
Med Rev. 1999 Apr;4(2):96-103. Skotnicki A B, Sliwczynska B, Turowski G, Szmigiel
7. Hauer J, Anderer FA. Mechanism of stimulation of Z, Wazewska-Czyzewska M: Effect of the thymus
human natural killer cytotoxicity by arabinogalactan extract on congenital hypogamma-globulinaemia and
from Larix occidentalis. Cancer Immunol immunological deficiency accompanying the
Immunother. 1993;36(4):237-44. proliferative and aplastic haematological diseases, in
8. Hauer J, Anderer FA. Mechanism of stimulation of van Bekkum D K (ed). Biological Activity of Thymus
human natural killer cytotoxicity by arabinogalactan Hormones. Rotterdam, Kooyker. 1975 pp. 37-39.
from Larix occidentalis. Cancer Immunol 22. Skotnicki A B, Blicharski J, Lisiewicz J, Sasiadek U,
Immunother. 1993;36(4):237-44. Janik J, Wolska T, Zdunczyk A, Aleksandrowicz J:
9. Adorini L, Penna G. Control of autoimmune diseases Calf thymus extract TFX-Polfa in the treatment of
by the vitamin D endocrine system. Nat Clin Pract patients with secondary leukopenia. Ther Drugs. 1987
Rheumatol. 2008 Aug;4(8):404-12. Epub 2008 Jul 1. 37(95).
10. Liu PT, Krutzik SR, Modlin RL. Therapeutic 23. Zeromski J, Siowik-Gabryelska A, Krzysko R. The
implications of the TLR and VDR partnership. Trends preliminary evaluation of TFX administration in
Mol Med. 2007 Mar;13(3):117-24. Epub 2007 Feb 5. advanced bronchogenic carcinoma, in Seminar on
11. Cannell JJ, Vieth R, Umhau JC, Holick MF, Grant Cellular and Humoral Immunity in Lung Diseases.
WB, Madronich S, Garland CF, Giovannucci E. Poznan (1976). pp. 44-46.
Epidemic influenza and vitamin D. Epidemiol. Infect. 24. Stankiewicz-Szymczak W, Moszynski B, Dabrowski
2006 134:1129–1140. MP, Dabrowska-Bernsztein BK, Stasiak A. The initial
12. Cannell JJ, Zasloff M, Garland CF, Scragg R, results of TFX-Polfa application in patients with
Giovannucci E. On the epidemiology of influenza. chronic recurrent infections of upper respiratory tract.
Virol. J. 2008 5:Art 29. Pol J Otolaryng. 1986 2:350.
13. White JH. Vitamin D Signaling, Infectious Diseases, 25. Kriegel H. Dr. John Prudden and Bovine Tracheal
and Regulation of Innate Immunity. Infection and Cartilage Research. Alternative & Comp Therapies.
Immunity. Sept. 2008 76(9):3837–3843 April/May 1995. pp. 187-189.
14. Bikle DD. Vitamin D and immune function: 26. Holt P, Schon-Hegrad MA, Oliver J. MHC class II
understanding common pathways. Curr Osteoporos antigen-bearing dendritic cells in pulmonary tissues of
Rep. 2009 Jul;7(2):58-63. the rat. J . Exp. Med. 1988 167:262-274.
15. Rouse RV, Parham P, Grumet FC, Weissman IL: (Continued on next page)

THE ORIGINAL INTERNIST DECEMBER 2009 191


27. Sertl K, Takemura T, Schachler T et al. Dendritic cells
with antigen presenting capability reside in airway
epithelium, lung parenchyma and visceral pleura. J Exp
Med 1986;163:436–451
28. Rosen J, Sherman WT, Prudden JF, Thorbecke GJ.
“Dear Jim Long, This product
is amazing!!! I’ve had toe nail Immunoregualtory effects of catrix. J Biol Response
fungus on my big toe for about 20 Modifiers. 1998 7:498-512.
years. My nail was thick, yellow 29. Sertl K, Takemura T, Tschachler E, Ferrans VJ,
and until I found your product I
thought I was destined to have Kaliner MA, Shevach EM. Dendritic cells with antigen
a thick yellow toe nail forever. presenting capability reside in airway epithelium, lung
I also had cracked heels and parenchyma, and visceral pleura. J. Exp. Med. 1986
athletes foot. Both have cleared
up dramatically. Thank you 163 :436.
so much for such a wonderful 30. Berdanier CD. Advanced Nutrition Micronutrients.
product.” ... Cathy G., Ohio
CRC Press. 1998 p. 33.
“The Nail Fungus Soak has made 31. Semba RD. Vitamin A, immunity, and infection. Clin
an improvement on my feet! Infect Dis. 1994 Sep;19(3):489-99.
I’ve referred you to 5 others.
Gracias!” ...Delia M., New 32. Goldfarb RH, Herberman RB. Natural killer cell
Mexico reactivity: regulatory interactions among phorbol
esters, interferon, cholera toxin, and retinoic acid.
$12.9
“My husband bought your Nail
Fungus Soak. It worked great! Journal of Immunology. 1981 126:2129-2135.
5 Thank you for having such a
great product.” ...Ellen P., Iowa
33. Chandra, RK. Increased bacterial binding to respiratory
epithelial cells in vitamin A deficiency. British Medical
If you want a safe, Journal. 1988 297:834-835.
natural way to be rid 34. Stephensen CB, Blount SR, Schoeb TR, Park JY.
Vitamin A deficiency impairs some aspects of the host
of ugly nail fungus,
response to influenza A virus infection in BALB/c
our formula works... mice. J Nutr. 1993 May;123(5):823-33.
GUARANTEED! 35. Stephensen CB, Moldoveanu Z, Gangopadhyay NN.
Vitamin A deficiency diminishes the salivary
Works on fingernails immunoglobulin A response and enhances the serum
and toenails. Also immunoglobulin G response to influenza A virus
works on persistent
athlete’s foot. infection in BALB/c mice. J Nutr. 1996 Jan;126(1):94-
102.
One box is 36. Phalipon A, Cardona A, Kraehenbuhl JP, Edelman L,
enough for about Sansonetti PJ, Corthésy B. Secretory component: a
2 months of new role in secretory IgA-mediated immune exclusion
treatment. The in vivo. Immunity. 2002 Jul;17(1):107-15.
average patient 37. http://pathmicro.med.sc.edu/mayer/IgStruct2000.htm
starts seeing new 38. http://lpi.oregonstate.edu/infocenter/vitamins/
nail growth in vitaminC/
about 5-6 weeks. 39. Hemilä H, Chalker E, Treacy B, Douglas B. Vitamin C
for preventing and treating the common cold. Cochrane
Single trial box, $14.95, postpaid Database of Systematic Reviews 2007, Issue 2. Art.
For Wholesale, 6 box minimum with free display, $46 including postage N o . : C D 0 0 0 9 8 0 . D O I :
(Wholesale price $6.25 each, retails $12.95) 10.1002/14651858.CD000980.pub3
Herbal Nail Fungus Soak 40. Sasazuki1 S, Sasaki S, Tsubono Y, Okubo S, Hayashi
M, Tsugane S. Effect of vitamin C on common cold:
Long Creek Herbs randomized controlled trial. EJCN. 2006 60:9–17.
P.O. Box 127 41. http://www.umm.edu/altmed/articles/echinacea-
Blue Eye, Missouri 65611 000239.htm
417-779-5450 42. Shah SA, Sander S, White CM, Rinaldi M, Coleman
Questions? CI. Evaluation of echinacea for the prevention and
Check our Q & A button, on the Nail Fungus page of our website. treatment of the common cold: a meta-analysis. Lancet
Infect Dis. 2007 Jul;7(7):473-80.
www.LongCreekHerbs.com 43. http://www.naturalstandard.com/monographs/ ‹
(Phones answered Mon. - Fri. 8 - 5, CST)
Major Credit Cards Accepted

THE ORIGINAL INTERNIST


192 Spring 2006 THE ORIGINAL INTERNIST DECEMBER 2009
05
grapefruit juice, Epsom salts, and olive oil. It was to be
administered over six days monthly.

Liver Flush: He followed the procedure. Stones of various densities,


colors, and amounts were produced monthly. Mr.
Help or Hoax? Hanson screened, washed and photographed them for 15
months. (There was no further stone excretion after the
14th Treatment.) some floated in water and some sank.
by: Dr. E. W. McDonagh, DO
He stated that his fatigue is gone, energy has increased,
digestion is now normal, cholesterol is lowered, and
vision is sharper.
Reprinted with permission: Townsend Letter October
2009, www.townsendletter.com I have been aware of various recipes that might flush out
liver stones for at least 30 years. Stories, anecdotal at
I am submitting the case history of my patient Lyle best, never offered proof of effectiveness, or it was
Hanson for Publication. Mr. Hanson wants more people scanty, indeed. Monthly treatments until no more stones
to learn about the benefits of liver flush. Perhaps his appear is crucial.
experience will stimulate interest.
Treatment contraindications might include intestinal
Mr. Hanson is a 62-year-old overweight, caucasian man diseases such as duodenal ulcers, ulcerative colitis, and
with diabetes. In 1994, he had a nephrectomy. During other medical problems. Please seek doctor’s advice if
the work-up for kidney surgery, the radiologist contemplating this procedure.
discovered several stonelike densities in the liver and
gallbladder. The patient refused surgery for these stones. Further details can be had by reading the Timeless
Several years later during a follow-up MRI, stones were Secrets of Health and Rejuvenation, by Andreas Motitz,
again seen in his liver area. an expert practitioner of Ayurvedic medicine.

Mr. Hanson discovered a book at a health food store that Experienced readers’ comments are encouraged and
outlined a procedure purported to eliminate liver/ requested to be sent to me at DrMcDonagh@aol.com.‹
gallbladder stones. The regimen included apple juice,

Month 1 Month 5

Month 4

Month 6

(Continued on next page)


THE ORIGINAL INTERNIST DECEMBER 2009 193
Month 7 Month 11

Month 8 Month 12

Month 9 Month 13

Month 10 Month 14

THE ORIGINAL INTERNIST


194 Spring 2006 THE ORIGINAL INTERNIST DECEMBER 2009
05
NEW
HCG
Human Chorionic Gonadotropin

Now Available From


Professional Health Products ®

®
®

Homeopathic HCG eliminates the need for daily


injections and is a more cost effective form for
patients.

Phone: (800) 955-1769 Fax: (817) 467-7567


Introduction
Utility of an Oral Few substances have been so neglected and misunder-

Presentation of HCG stood regarding its potential therapeutic actions as hCG,


the acronym for Human Chorionic Gonadotropin.

(Human First discovered by Ascheim and Zondek as far back as


1927 in the urine from pregnant women2, thousands of
Choriogonadotropin) for articles were published regarding its action on gonads,
but comparatively quite a few investigated its vast
the Management of Obesity: therapeutics potentialities, encompassing Kaposi sar-
coma,34 asthma,20,66 psychoses,22 artheriopaties,14 thalas-
semia,57,7,19 osteopenia,57 glaucoma.54
A Double Blind Study
hCG is the glycoproteic hormone normally secreted by
by: Dr. Daniel Oscar Belluscio, MD trophoblastic cells of the placenta during pregnancy.67 It
Dr. Leonor Ripamonte, MD consists of two dissimilar, separately, but most presuma-
Dr. Marcelo Wolansky, PhD
bly coordinately translated chains, called the alpha and
Reprinted with permission: Dr. Daniel Oscar Belluscio, MD beta sub-units.12,26,47,27,18,30
Abstract The three pituitary hormones LH (Luteinising Hor-
Female obese volunteers participating in a double blind mone), FSH (Follicle Stimulating Hormone) and TSH
study, and submitted to the administration of an oral (Thyroid Stimulating Hormone) are closely related to
presentation of hCG (Human Choriogonadotropin) plus hCG in that all fours are glycosilated and have a dimeric
a VLCD (Very Low Calorie Diet), decreased specific structure comprising the alpha and beta chains as
body circumferences and skinfold thickness from well.31,35,79
conspicuous body areas more efficiently than
Placebo+VLCD -treated subjects. The amino acid sequence of the alpha chain of all four
human glycoproteic hormones is nearly identical. The
Since a significant fat proportion from total body fat is amino acid sequence of the Beta subunits differs and
subcutaneously located (50 to 65 percent, depending on accounted for by the unique immunological and biologi-
sex and fat distribution), this hCG metabolic activity cal activities of each glycoproteic hormone.63 Beta hCG
would result in a reduction of the total body fat mass, the contains a carboxylic residue of 30 amino acids charac-
main cause for obesity. We suggested that the combina- teristic to hCG.11,52
tion of a VLCD and oral hCG could not only trigger
clinically significant changes in subcutaneous fat stores Its denomination; (Human Chorionic Gonadotropin)
but simultaneously decrease body weight and modelate dates back from the early days, when it was found. hCG
body contour. rendered mature infantile sex glands in experimentation
animals (Gonadotropin) and it was secreted by the pla-
hCG oral administration proved to be a safe and centary chorion (Chorionic).2,91
effective procedure on obese treated volunteers. No side
effects were observed during the study. There are no However, recent data suggest both terms can be
reports in the literature regarding this administration misleading: normal human tissues from non-pregnant
route to compare our findings. subjects,88,74,48,86,87 trophoblastic and non-trophoblastic
tumors,33,6,90 bacteria,49 and plants46,69 express hCG or a
Compared to placebo treated subjects, volunteers who hCG-like substance.
were managed with an oral administration of hCG coped
more efficiently with daily irritating situations, were in a The first report on hCG and obesity was published back
better mood, and handled home conflicts without as 1954 in The Lancet, by a British physician, Dr.
stepping up family discussions. A.T.W. Simeons.70 After its publication, hCG was advo-
cated for several years as a useful approach to obesity.
KEYWORDS: Gonadotropin(s), Chorionic; Obesity; The pendulum of its popularity swang back and forth
Adipose tissue metabolism; fat; overweight; beta-
(Continued on next page)
endorphin; lypolisis; lipogenesis.

THE ORIGINAL INTERNIST DECEMBER 2009 197


until a series of studies1,3,8,17,36 but three concluded hCG Patients were Caucasian, ages ranging from 23 to 73
was of no use to manage the disease.3,25,80 y.o. (group P: 41 ± 13; group G1: 42 ± 12; group G2: 41
± 14), a range of heights of 162 cm. to 181 cm., and
According to basic pharmacological postulates, the overweight ranging from 25 to 499 on BMI Tables.
administration route may influence the biological
activity of a drug. All previous studies were performed Since there were no published reports on the oral use of
with a hCG preparation administered by injections. One hCG, except for one study posted by D.B. and L.R. on
of the authors of this study (DB) theorized that an the Internet (http://indexmedico.com/obesitv/hcg.htm),
increase in dose and a shifting in hCG administration to group G2 was administered twice the dose of G1, to
a sublingual-enteral route may modify the pharmacologi- assess if hCG concentration may affect obtained results.
cal activity of hCG.
The pharmacist prepared two types of vials: one
The purpose of this study was to assess the utility of an containing saline solution (Na Cl 0,9% w/v), and the
oral presentation hCG for the management of obesity. other containing a diluted solution (saline) of commer-
cial, standardized hCG (from Gonacor, Massone
Materials and methods Pharmaceutical Industry). HCG Solution was prepared
buffering the drug with Sodium Bicarbonate and
The study design was of the double-blind type: neither glycerin.
treating physician nor patient knowing who was
receiving hCG, or an inert substance (placebo). Female Notice: after uploading this report to the Internet, further
patients for the study were selected, since the clinic research we have performed on oral hCG preparations
where the study was performed specializes in the demonstrated that the addition of certain diluents, de-
diagnosis and treatment of gynecologic disorders. grades hCG molecule, partially inactivating its activity.
Details of the protocol were explained to eighty-three
volunteers, who were solicited through a written Therefore, we have reverted to the use of saline solutions
announcement. Before entering the study, they signed an instead. Our results have significantly improved since
informed consent in front of a neutral witness. then.

Inclusion criteria Vials were randomly labeled, each number correspond-


We required selected volunteers to meet the following ing to a patient. The pharmacist kept the codes in a
criteria: being at least 25% BMI (Body Mass Index), sealed envelope. They were opened after completing the
overweight, and in general healthy condition. If taking protocol.
medication for obesity, such as anorectics or
amphetamines, they should discontinue the medication Volunteers from group G1 were administered a diluted
at least one month prior the initiation of the study. Drugs solution of hCG (125 IU) b.i.d. (twice daily; total: 250
to control their clinical diseases (hypertension, hypothy- IU). One of the doses was taken before breakfast
roidism, etc.) were allowed. No patients under steroid, (fasting). The remaining was administered 1 hr before
diuretics or hormones were entered the study. During the dinner.
study, volunteers were also asked about starting the use
of medical prescribed drugs or pharmaceutical prepara- Volunteers from group G2 were given twice the
tions during the trial period. amount of group G1: 250 IU b.i.d. (a total of 500 IU
daily).
Exclusion criteria
Patients were advised to maintain the solution at least
No teenagers or patients over 75 y.o. were admitted to two minutes in the oral cavity before swallowing
the study. No patients with severe and/or uncontrolled (sublingual, to profit from the rich venous plexus exist-
clinical diseases (cancer, IDDM, heart attacks, infarcts ing in this region, also bypassing the liver). They were
sequelae) were accepted. After applying the inclusion/ also told that medication has to be maintained under re-
exclusion criteria, we counted on 70 subjects to divide in frigeration at all times.
treatment groups. These women were randomly assigned
to groups Placebo (P, N=26) or hCG (N=44) by a simple Diet plan
randomized sampling method. This latter group was in
turn split in two subgroups: G1 (N=36) and G2 (N=8), The same Very-Low-Calorie-Diet (VLCD), specific and
according to the hCG dose administered (see below). detailed, was prescribed to all groups.
(Continued on next page)

THE ORIGINAL INTERNIST


198 Spring 2006 THE ORIGINAL INTERNIST DECEMBER 2009
05
Breakfast: tea or coffee in any quantity without sugar. III. Skinfold thickness. Using a Lange Skinfold Caliper
Only one tablespoonful of milk allowed in 24 hr. (Cambridge Scientific Industries, Cambridge,
Saccharin or other sweeteners could be used. Maryland), the following folds were examined:
• Tricipital (TRI), arm midline, posterior region and
Lunch: 100 grams. of veal, beef, chicken breast, fresh tricipital muscle zone;
white fish, lobster, crab or shrimp. All visible fat was • Anterior Axilar line (AXA), at the fold created when
carefully removed before cooking, and the meat weighed pinching the skin region at the level of the pectoralis
raw. Salmon, tuna fish, herring, dried or pickled fish was muscle extending to the arm;
not allowed.
• Subscapular (SCA (i)): inferior scapular spine;
• Thoracic (TOR): at the fold created when pinching
The chicken breast was removed raw from the bird. One
the region located immediately below the ribs, at the
type of vegetable could be only chosen from the
level of an imaginary line extending from anterior
following: spinach, chard, chicory, beet-greens, green
axilar line;
salad, tomatoes, celery, fennel, onions, red radishes,
cucumbers, asparagus, and cabbage. One breadstick • Suprailiac (ILI), at the fold created 4 cm above the
(grissini) or one Melba toast was allowed, and an apple anterior superior iliac spine;
or an orange, or a handful of strawberries or one-half • Supraumbilical (UMB(u)), 3 cm above navel;
grapefruit. • Infraumbilical (UMB(i)), 3 cm below navel;
• Thighs (THI), internal aspect of thighs, eight cm
For dinner: The same four choices as lunch. below the pubic area;
• Patellar area (ROT), at the fold created when
The juice of only one lemon daily was allowed for all pinching the region located 6 cm medial to the
purposes. Salt, pepper, vinegar, mustard power, garlic, internal patellar border.
sweet basil, parsley, thyme, marjoram, etc., could be
used for seasoning, but no oil, butter or dressing. Tea, IV. Bioelectrical impedance. Using Tetrapolar Bioelec-
coffee, plain water, mineral water were the only drinks trical Impedance (TBI) with a body fat analyzer Maltron,
allowed, but they could be taken in any quantity and at model BF-905 (Maltron International Ltd., Rayleigh,
all times. Essex).

Clinicometric controls Volunteers voided previous to the evaluation, placed on


supine position, and allowed to rest half an hour before
Volunteers assisted twice weekly at the clinic to be determination. Self-adhering electrodes were placed on
controlled and weighed. The following evaluations were extremities. Every determination was performed with a
completed once a week: separate set of electrodes, discarded after single use.
I. Height and Weight, performed on a medical scale. The following TBI determinations were assessed:
Volunteers were weighed using normal underwear.
1. Fat weight (FW)
II. Body circumferences. Using a flexible, non elastic 2. Lean weight (LW)
metric tape, the following anatomic areas were assessed: 3. Water weight (WW)
• Wrist (WRT), at the level of flexion fold (wrist- 4. Calories (CAL)
forearm);
V. ß-hCG determinations: all subjects enrolled in the
• Breast (BRE), submammary fold; trial were studied for plasmatic ß-hCG levels by an
• Waist (WAT): at the hypogastric region level; ELISA test (64) on 0-15-30 study days.
• Abdominal (ABD), at the navel level;
• Hips (HIP): pubic line; VI. Mood questionnaire: from the first study week on,
• Thighs (THI): 8 cm. below pubic line; patients were given weekly self-administered
• Suprapatelar (ROT), at the patella upper border; questionnaires to be completed at home. It consisted of
twenty-four questions related to their mood changes in
• Ankle (ANK), at the flexion fold (peroneal protuber-
the course of the study, plus four questions related to
ance).
adverse drug effects. They returned the data at the time
of the subsequent visit to the clinic.
(Continued on page 201)

THE ORIGINAL INTERNIST DECEMBER 2009 199


MICELLIZED
Study Conducted By:

VITAMIN D3 Average Percent Increase in 25(OH) (Vitamin D)

100
During 30 and 60 day Supplementation

79.9%

75 45.4%
Recent Study Shows Approximately 5 Times 50
15%
3.7%
25
More Absorbtion Than Emulsified D. 0 30 60 30 60
Days Days Days Days

A recent double blind study by The Great Plains Laboratory, Emulsified Micellized D3™
(Oil suspension)
Inc. showed Micellized D3™ had approximately 5 times greater Vitamin D

increase in serum 25(OH) Vitamin D levels versus emulsified vitamin D.


NuMedica®’s Micellized D3™ is far superior in reaching and maintaining This Study Showed Micellized D3™
optimal levels of vitamin D3 over other forms of Vitamin D. Absorption Was Clinically Significant
Studies have been conducted on micelle vitamin preparations to compared to Emulsified Vitamin D.*
*Each participant received 3,000 I.U. by mouth
determine the effectiveness of this new delivery system when compared once a day (p.o.q.d.).
with both standard oil forms and other emulsified forms. The studies were
conducted with normal healthy individuals varying in sex and age. The data
DIRECTIONS: Take one drop daily ®
shows that these
mixed micellized
in 1-2 oz. waterforms of orfat-soluble
or juice as micronutrients increased
Serving Size: 1 drop (0.05 ml)
directed by your healthcare practitioner.
plasma levels greater than the oil forms and emulsified forms.* Servings Per Container: 600
Micellized D3 is a natural form of Amount %DV*
Vitamin D provided in a water-soluble
Average form.Increase in 25(OH) Vitamin D Vitamin D3 600 IU 150%

Micellized D3
micellized The micellization
process produces tiny droplets (as cholecalciferol)
30 days
(micelles) that are then formed into 60 days
* Percent Daily Value based on a
highly absorbable aggregate 2,000 calorie diet.
Micellizedstructures.
Vitamin D3™ Micellization greatly
10 ng/ml
increases the solubility, absorption
18.5 ng/ml
Water-Soluble Other ingredients: Deionized water,
ethoxylated castor oil, glycerine, citric acid,
and bioavailability of our vitamin D3
Emulsifiedover
Oil oil or emulsified forms.* Soy-Free grapefruit seed extract and potassium sorbate.
0.4 ng/ml 3.4 ng/ml NuMedica®
Suspension Vitamin D 866-787-5175 • www.numedica.com
*These statements have not been evaluated
by the Food and Drug Administration. This
*25(OH)
product measured
is not intended in nanograms
to diagnose, treat, Dietary Supplement
per milliliter.
cure or prevent any disease. Pharmaceutical Grade
Professional Use Only 8 12527 01117 5
CAUTION: Keep out of reach of children.
STORAGE: Keep tightly closed in a cool, dry place. 1 FL OZ (30 ml)

Micellization is the process of creating easily assimilated, completely


water-soluble clusters out of fat soluble nutrients.

*These statements have not been 9503 E. 55th Place, Tulsa OK 74145
evaluated by the Food and Drug
Administration. This product is not
intended to diagnose, treat, cure or
Toll Free 1-866-787-5175
prevent any disease.
www.numedica.com
Data Analysis Questionnaire responses were converted into percentages
and submitted to a chi-square (2%) test to compare
Variables were split as follows for a better data
between-groups and within-groups (pairing off final vs.
processing and statistical results presentation:
initial data) statistic results.
• Category I, BW plus four bioelectrical impedance
records (FW, LW, WW and CAL), To attenuate the natural source of within-subject
variation, inherent to all assessments of subjective
symptoms, we averaged data results from identical ques-
• Category II, eight anthropometrical measurements
tionnaires completed weekly during the initial first two
(corporal circumferences WRT, BRE, WAT, ABD,
study weeks. Thus, we obtained a more precise "initial
HIP, THI, ROT and ANK).
questionnaire" (avoiding the potential "adaptation effect"
common to any VLCD regime in the first treatment
• Category III, nine skinfold assessments (TRI,
week).
AXA, SCA (i), TOR, ILI, UMB(u), UMB(i), THI,
ROT) (see long names and definitions for the
To obtain the final mood behavior results over the last
studied variables at the beginning of this section).
two treatment weeks, they were averaged using the same
schema as detailed before. Criteria for significance was
Each set was analyzed with a two-way multivariate
p<0.05. Statistica 4.2 (from StatSoft, Inc.) for Windows
analysis of variance (MANOVA), comparing the
software was used in all processing.
obtained Wilks-lambda' F with the corresponding critical
value. Results

TREATMENT (VLCD diet plus group-specific All volunteers were submitted to the same VLCD
pharmacological intervention) was considered the schedule lasting five weeks. The objective of this work
between-subject factor with three levels (P, G1, G2), and was to gather data on the potential synergism between
WEEK of clinicometric control served as an additional hCG administration and a VLCD plan. At the end of the
within-subject factor with six levels: weeks 0 to 5. study we counted a total of 4.3 % missing data due to
the absence of subjects in control days (no one absent in
To estimate how the differences between treatment more than two opportunities) as a consequence of per-
groups depended on the trial time elapsed since week sonal situations not associated with the experimental
zero (comparison of pattern trend changes in function of conditions. No statistic differences were obtained be-
treatment time) we obtained the MANOVA result for the tween Placebo and hCG groups regarding missing data.
effect of the INTERACTION (also displayed in the text No statistic differences were obtained among Placebo
as TREATMENT x WEEK). and hCG groups regarding missing data.

Moreover, to prevent any possible influence of acute 1. Regarding weight loss, similar results (with/
effects specifically associated to any VLCD program in without hCG administration) were obtained. Bioelec-
the adaptation phase (first 5-7 days), we additionally trical impedance exhibited discrete modifications in
evaluated with separate MANOVA analyses the differ- tested groups.
ences between groups and within subjects in the course
of the last four treatment's weeks. As expected, for all types of clinicometric assessments,
significant results were obtained through MANOVA
After obtaining a statistically significant multivariate test analysis on factor WEEK. Figures 1 and 2 (bioelectrical
for a particular main effect or interaction, we further impedance and anthropometrical data, respectively)
examined the univariate F tests for each dependent show that the time-dependent changes were uniformly
variable. When parameters from these tests displayed present in all tested groups. We therefore estimated that
significant modifications, data were further analyzed to the decreasing observed patterns were the consequence
ascertain which group (P, G1 or G2) was responsible for of VLCD acting on overweight patients. However, re-
the previous p values obtained. We also compared data garding skinfold thickness findings (Figures 3 and 4), we
basal values from each group against those obtained in detected in P group a noticeable tendency to attenuation
subsequent weeks (e.g., records of week 0 against week of the within-subject variation during the last (third to
1, thereafter against week 2, and so on). These pain/vise fifth) study weeks. The data suggested us that this latter
comparisons were statistically assessed applying post period might be the focus of our interest).
hoc Scheffé F tests. (Continued on next page)

THE ORIGINAL INTERNIST DECEMBER 2009 201


Figure 1 (see page 209) shows data patterns resulting in groups [as representative examples, see ABD (p=0.35)
all groups from three representative variables (BW, FW and HIP records in panels B and C, respectively].
and LW) of the variable category I. The MANOVA When the records of weeks 0-1 were subtracted from
analysis revealed nearly significant differences for the MANOVA analysis, almost all p values were slightly
INTERACTION (TREATMENT x WEEK) [F(50,58) affected. WAT and ABD measurements demonstrated
=1.35, p=0.13] without statistical significance on analy- to still be more affected by the INTERACTION: for
sis of TREATMENT as main effect [F(10,98)=1.22, WAT, p<0.003; for ABD, p<0.08. The INTERAC-
p=0.29]. TION significance increased when P controls were
compared to subjects from group G2: comparing P vs.
When all groups were submitted to multivariate and G2, and considering data from weeks 0-5, we obtained:
univariate analyses taking exclusive data from weeks 2- F (5,140)=2.87 (p<0.02) for WAT, and F(5,140)=1.80,
5, we observed no significant difference result for the (p=0.12) for ABD. But when we analyzed data from
INTERACTION among group P and hCG-treated weeks 2-5, we found the following: for WAT, F (3,84)
groups. This finding could be related to differences in =3.43 (p<0.02), for ABD, F (3,84)=2.73 (p<0.05).
mean basal body weights and treatment-dependent
responses to the acute effects of VLCD during former 3. Weak effects of hCG on a series of skinfold thick-
weeks. ness reduction patterns.
Figures 3-4 show results from subcutaneous fat
When the post hoc Scheffé test was applied to compare
evaluations, as assessed by skinfold thickness, on nine
the result from each weekly record (weeks 1-5) to it's
selected skinfolds. Figure 3 presents three representa-
corresponding basal value (week zero), we found
tive folds [TRI, SCA (i), ILI (U)3 out of five (those
similar patterns for all groups concerning analysis of
previous mentioned plus AXA and TOR)] that demon-
BW and TBI records (compare P vs. hCG-treated
strated to be slightly affected by the pharmacological
groups in every panel of Figure 1).
treatment.
However, regarding the analysis of FW and BW data,
Analyzing skinfold data from weeks 0 to 5, the main
we detected significant differences for the effect of the
effect TREATMENT showed statistical significance (F
INTERACTION (p<0.005 and p<0.05, respectively).
(10,98)=2.39, p<0.02). However, prevailing higher
Comparing FW patterns from groups P and G1: F
basal records in group G2 might account for this statis-
(5,230)=4.55, p<0.001. For the comparison P vs. G2,
tical significance. After studying the effect of the IN-
(BW and FW data), we obtained: F(5,140)=4.20 and
TERACTION on skinfold results, statistics were as
2.97, respectively (p<0.01 for both cases).
follows: TRI (see panel A), p<0.08; AXA, p=0.98;
SCA(i) (see panel B), p<0.005; ILI (see panel C),
2. hCG+diet significantly decreased more waist
p=0.23; TOR, p=0.35.
and abdominal circumferences than diet alone.
Figure 2 shows the results for three (category II) body Performing pairwise comparisons between control P
circumference assessments (WAT, ABD and HIP). and hCG-treated groups, we observed that the higher
MANOVA analysis showed significant differences for significances obtained for SCA (i) and TRI skinfolds
factor TREATMENT as main effect [F (16,92)=1.92, derived mainly from the comparison between P and
p<0.04], which we do not consider relevant due to the G2: for TRI, F (5,140)=2.55, p<0.04, for skinfold SCA
presence of higher basal records in group G2 when (i), F (5,140)=6.02, p<0.0001. MANOVA analyses run
compared to the rest of the studied groups. on weeks 2-5 data resulted in a significance increase
for TREATMENT as main effect [F (10,98)=2.55,
As a whole, the effect of the INTERACTION did not p<0.009]. In addition, the INTERACTION was en-
reveal statistical significance. hanced on data from SCA(i) assessment (p<0.00005):
by comparing data from groups P and G2 during weeks
Nevertheless, significant differences were obtained 2 to 5: for TRI, F (3,84)=2.08 (p<0.04), for SCA(i), F
after further analysis for the effect of the INTERAC- (3,84)=9.31.
TION on variable WAT [F (10,265)=2.44, p<0.01, see
panel A]. 4. Higher response rates in a different skinfold
series by treatment with hCG plus a VLCD.
Data assessments from other circumferences did not
In Figure 4 we display skinfold thickness results
show statistical differences for this effect among
(Continued on next page)

THE ORIGINAL INTERNIST


202 Spring 2006 THE ORIGINAL INTERNIST DECEMBER 2009
05
obtained from another series of four examined skin- by computing the ratio between decrease percentages,
folds [UMB (U), UMB ^ THI, ROT(U)]. MANOVA G2 had over twice (for UMB (u), see panel A) to over
analysis resulted in a nearly significant INTERAC- four-fold (for THI, see panel D) the skinfold records
TION [F (40,68)=1.55, p<0.06] in the absence of statis- drops observed in group P (see each actual percentage,
tical significance for TREATMENT as main effect [F group by group, in Fig. 4).
(8,100)=1.43, p=0.20].
Most of the differences among hCG-treated subjects
When the specific effect of the INTERACTION was and P controls regarding skinfold reduction rates were
evaluated for each skinfold, highly significant differ- enhanced when data corresponding to week five was
ences were found. By computing F (10,265) values, we compared to records of week two instead week zero
obtained the following results: UMB (U) (see panel A), (data not shown).
p<10-3; UMB (U) (see panel B), p<10-5; ROT (see
panel C), p<0.05; THI (see panel D), p<10-6. When we 6. Improvement in mood-related parameters by
restricted the data analysis from weeks 2 to 5, we found hCG.
nearly significant results for factor TREATMENT as
In Figure 5, we display the responses to four represen-
main effect [F (8,100)=1.75, p<0.1] and for the effect
tative questions asking about the occurrence frequency
of the INTERACTION [F (24,84)=1.55, p<0.06]. The
for specific mood-related events, according to a multi-
INTERACTION was further studied pairing P group
ple choice designed questionnaire completed every
against each hCG-treated group in separate multivariate
treatment week by all the subjects enrolled in the trial.
analyses.
Panels A to D display the initial and final questionnaire
By comparing P vs. G1, we found: for UMB(i), p<0.04,
results, expressed as percentages for each optional
and for RQT , p<0.03 (UMB(U) and THI achieved
response (covering a four-option frequency scale from
nearly significant p values). Again, the strength of the
never to frequent).
INTERACTION [TREATMENT x WEEK] was higher
when group G2 was selected for the comparison.
Using this procedure, we expected to find, in tested
volunteers, skewness towards either sense concerning
From the obtained data, it becomes clear that skinfolds
their behaviors and feelings in response to a diet and a
determinations in Q2 subjects showed a differential
pharmacological intervention. For all these questions,
response to VLCD schedule with respect to that of P
and compared to control subjects, hCG-treated volun-
controls (for INTERACTION, in these points of skin-
teers (G1+G2) showed a trend to improvement of inter-
fold assessment, p<0.0005).
personal contacts and mood control when confronting
upsetting or conflicting situations. Pairing off final (f)
5. Selective response of some skinfolds to hCG was
vs. initial (i) distribution of percentages for optional
dependent on dose.
responses, we particularly found statistical significance
The experimental design of this investigation was not in two of these questions in group G (after\test:
2
intended to determine the dose-response curve for hCG X3=16.3, p<0.002, and 2X3=7.82, p<0.05; see right
acting on diet-induced effects. sectors of panel A and B, respectively).

However, the effects of hCG on some of these skin- P group-subjects did not present temporal differences
folds seemed to be dependent on dose, significant dif- (see panel A), or were adversely affected in their mood
ferences for the effect of the INTERACTION after the during the trial 2X3=14.4, p<0.002 (compare in panel B
comparison between G1 vs. G2 groups for UMB (u) corresponding initial and final values for group P and
(p<0.001) and UMB (i) (p<0.005), and a nearly signifi- G).
cant p value for THI (p=0.11).
Furthermore, group P exhibited, in two other questions,
Figure 4 also displays the percentages of skinfold thick- certain skewness to the impairment of its mood (see left
ness reduction from the beginning to the end of the half of panels C and D, p<10-5 ); for group G we
clinical trial. We found skinfolds decreases for group obtained the 2X3 values 1.51 and 3.98, respectively
G1 ranging from over 22% (for UMB (u), see panel A) (p>0.3), showing the absence of temporal mood
up to over 115% (for THI, see panel D) over respective changes.
decreases in P group. These differences were still
higher when G2-subjects were compared to P controls: For all other mood-related questions, no statistical sig-
(Continued on next page)

THE ORIGINAL INTERNIST DECEMBER 2009 203


nificant difference among groups was found (data not sults. Also, when comparing SKF to body contour as-
shown). sessments, some data suggest that the pattern of fat
thickness body distribution measured over several spe-
We also included some questions intended to evaluate cific sites by one method of measurement is unlikely to
the potential occurrence of treatment-dependent clinical be duplicated by of the other method on the same indi-
anomalies regarding hormonal, physiological or vidual.40,41
metabolic disorders. We found no significant difference
after final vs. initial records' comparison (data not Adipose tissue patterns show great variability, showing
shown). the importance of using skinfold caliper readings from
a variety of different anatomic sites including upper
7. No detectable ß-hCG plasmatic levels in all tested limbs, lower limbs and trunk.30,65
groups.
According to the above conclusions from several
On treatment days 0, 15 and 30 we have tested all authors,72,13,60, 25,73,62 we would like to suggest that
volunteers, screening for the presence of plasmatic former studies on hCG and obesity lacked of sufficient
p-hCG. Concentrations were undetectable in all cases data to estimate accurately the modifications of adipose
(data not shown). tissue distribution in tested volunteers. Consequently
we designed the study to assess as many variables as
Discussion possible .
Concerning hCG and its utility for the management of
obesity, this study introduces two new aspects, and As far as our study concerns, we subjected each
adds new data for a third: volunteer enrolled in the trial to four bioelectrical
impedance, eight anthropometrical plus nine SKF
I. This is the first report assessing variables not evaluations. Performing this multiple site determina-
included in previous reports;38,51,68,89 tions, our results show that specific SKF are highly
responsive to hCG pharmacological intervention (upper
II. We report a new administration route for hCG and lower umbilical). The greater response was
management of obesity, the oral approach, obtained in those regions where the corresponding
which has never been reported before; circumference assessments resulted in nearly signifi-
cant or significant decreases through the trial period
III. We have detected mood changes in hCG treated (see waist and abdomen records in Fig. 2 and the above
patients, regarding a better confrontation of detailed description of statistical results for the effect of
daily emotionally conflicting situations. the interaction).
I) Skinfold thickness (SKF) and Tetrapolar
II) Oral hCG is an valuable alternative administra-
Bioelectric Impedance (TBI) records.
tion route.
Both approaches have been extensively discussed in the
No data appear on the scientific literature regarding an
literature. It was shown that the correlation between the
oral administration of hCG in humans. But results from
values obtained with the two methods to be linear and
this study suggests hCG may be used by the sublingual-
highly significant for both sexes.42,81,27
enteral route. Despite plasmatic, ß-hCG remained
undetectable both in Placebo and hCG groups
There is general agreement that skinfolds calipers are
throughout the study, an oral administration of hCG
particularly useful in the clinical setting,56,82,16,76,10,65,
9,15,75 proved to possess therapeutic activity.
particularly in view of the fact that measurement
of subcutaneous body fat at different body sites is
Since commercial preparations of hCG contains
becoming increasingly important for the characteriza-
ß-endorphin, it may be tempting to hypothesize that
tion of risk of certain disease states.55
this pentapeptide might account for the pharmacologi-
When comparing skinfold assessments to body circum- cal activity observed on mood stability during the Pro-
ference estimates, some data suggests that the latter tocol.
approach appears to be more sensitive in the determina-
tion of subcutaneous body fat,53 this procedure is in our III) Volunteers treated with hCG coped better with
opinion subjected to clinical variables (bloating syn- daily irritating situations.
drome after a meal, premenstrual water retention, etc.) As can be seen on Figure 5, hCG-treated groups
that may affect negatively on the final estimate’s re- (Continued on page 206)
THE ORIGINAL INTERNIST
204 Spring 2006 THE ORIGINAL INTERNIST DECEMBER 2009
05
’Tis the season to be healthy.
Vital Nutrients is proud to offer a variety of products aimed at supporting the
most important tool in fighting illness, the immune system. Our products
support defense against those health challenges found during cold and flu
season.* At Vital Nutrients, nothing is more important than the quality of
our supplements. Using U.S. laboratories, we test every finished product and
conduct comprehensive testing on all raw materials before we bring them
together. When it comes to offering superior quality and clinically effective
supplements, nobody beats Vital Nutrients.* Call (888) 328-9992. See
monographs under research at www.vitalnutrients.net.

THE LEADER IN QUALITY ASSURANCE


Vital Nutrients products are independently tested in the U.S. for authenticity, potency, heavy metals, solvent
residue, herbicide and pesticide residue, aflatoxins, stability and bacteria, yeast, and mold counts.
NUTRIENTS Compliant with FDA GMPs

*This statement has not been evaluated by the Food & Drug Administration. This product is not intended to diagnose, treat, cure or prevent any disease.
handled better their irritability, their mood at home, and sized that the p-endorphin fraction present in commer-
were less prone to episodes of extreme nervousness cial preparations of hCG might account for the activity
capable of provoking violent discussions. Several observed regarding mood control.
reports proposed hCG might be used for the treatment
of psychoses or neurosis.29,61,24 Our study appears to Additional studies remain to be performed to test the
corroborate these proposals. validity of this hypothesis.

To conclude, this study poses several still unanswered Conclusions


questions:
1. Female obese volunteers participating in a double
1. hCG absorption. We have tested all volunteers, blind study, and submitted to the administration of
screening for the p-hCG in plasma. Concentrations an oral presentation of hCG plus a VLCD,
were undetectable in all cases. decreased specific body circumferences and skin-
fold thickness from conspicuous body areas more
Therefore, which hCG fraction is responsible for efficiently than Placebo+VLCD-treated subjects.
the pharmacological activity observed in our study?
hCG’s molecular size (alpha chain -14,500 KD; Since a significant fat proportion from total body fat is
beta chain -22,200 KD) makes it highly improbable subcutaneously located (50 to 65 percent, depending on
that the entire molecule has been absorbed. Our sex and fat distribution), this hCG metabolic activity
hypothesis is that only a fraction of the entire hCG would result in a reduction of the total body fat mass,
molecule is absorbed through this administration the main cause for obesity. We suggested that the com-
route. bination of a VLCD and oral hCG could not only
trigger clinically significant changes in subcutaneous
2. hCG and lipid metabolism. We do not know pre- fat stores but simultaneously decrease body weight and
cisely how hCG acts on adipose tissue metabolism. modulate body contour.
However, some reports32,84,85,83 suggest hCG
possesses a metabolic activity on adipose tissue 2. hCG oral administration proved to be a safe and
(i.e. decrease lipogenesis). These actions are not effective procedure on obese treated volunteers. No
directly exerted on adipocytes, since fat cell mem- side effects were observed during the study. There
branes have no receptors for hCG.32 are no reports in the literature regarding this
administration route to compare our findings.
3. hCG and mood. A stable mood and lack of attri-
tion characterized the hCG-treated group. 3. Compared to placebo treated subjects, volunteers
managed with an oral administration of hCG coped
It is well known that VLCD's are associated with more efficiently with daily irritating situations,
mood changes, particularly attrition78 during the were in a better mood, and handled home conflicts
dieting period. In one study, disinhibition and hun- without stepping up family discussions.
ger were significantly related to anxiety and de-
pression while restraint was not.44 Another study This study appears to contradict former conclusions on
concluded that elevated levels of anxiety persist in the issue of hCG and obesity. We attribute those differ-
female patients throughout a VLCD course of treat- ences to a different approach, including variables not
ment.45 assessed in former publications.

Also many patients complain about fatigue during a Acknowledgements:


VLCD.4
One of the authors of the report (Dr. Belluscio, Daniel)
Conversely, our data suggest that hCG-treated was granted with a staying period at the Bellevue
volunteers rather improved their attitude towards their Klinik, Zurich, Switzerland, to be trained on the
environment, in the sense of an enhanced well-being, clinical management of the hCG method. He would
less irritability and lack of fatigue. Since commercial like to thank Dr. Trudy Vogt (Clinic Director) for her
preparations of hCG contains 3-endorphin39 and this generous contribution through this grant to part of the
neuropeptide has been demonstrated to affect the func- ongoing Research Program performed at her Institu-
tion of limbic-emotional circuits,21,58,5,28 we hypothe- tion.
(Continued on next page)

THE ORIGINAL INTERNIST


206 Spring 2006 THE ORIGINAL INTERNIST DECEMBER 2009
05
References ters in adolescents with thalassemia major. Eur J Pedi-
atr. 1989 Jan;148(4):300-3
1) Albrink MJ. Chorionic gonadotropin and obesity? Am J 20) Bradley P. Human chorionic gonadotrophin [letter].
Clin Nutr 1969 Jun;22(6):681-5 Med J Aust Sep 25;2(13):510-1 1976
2) ASCHEIM S; ZONDEK B. Die Shwangerschafts Diag- 21) Brambilla F. et al., beta-Endorphin and beta-lipotropin
nose aus dem Harn durch nachweis der Hypophysovor- plasma levels in chronic schizophrenia. primary affec-
derlappenhormone. Klin. Wochschr. 7:1401-1411. 1928 tive disorders and secondary affective disorders. Psy-
3) Asher WL. Harper HW. Effect of human chorionic go- choneuroendocrinology. 1981 Dec;6(4):321-30
nadotrophin on weight loss. hunger. and feeling of well- 22) Bujanow W. Hormones in the treatment of psychoses.
being. Am J Clin Nutr 1973 Feb;26(2):211-8 Br Med J Nov 4;4(835):298 1972
4) Astrup A.. VLCD compliance and lean body mass. Int J 23) Bujanow W.Letter: Is oxytocin an anti-schizophrenic
Obes 1989;13 Suppl 2:27-31 hormone? Can Psychiatr Assoc J. 1974 Jun;19(3):323.
5) Atkinson JH. et al., Plasma measures of beta-endorphin/ 24) Cairella M.. Drug therapy of obesity. Clin Ter. 1978
beta-lipotropin-like immunoreactivity in chronic pain Mar 31;84(6):571-92
syndrome and psychiatric subjects. Psychiatry Res. 1983 25) Canfield RE. et al., Studies of human chorionic gonad-
Aug;9(4):319-27 otropin. Recent Prog Horm Res. 1971;27:121-64
6) Bagshawe KD. et al., Pregnancy beta1 glycoprotein and 26) Cole LA. Immunoassay of human chorionic gonadotro-
chorionic gonadotrophin in the serum of patients with pin. Its free subunit and metabolites. Clin Chem. 1997
trophoblastic and non-trophoblastic tumors. Eur J Can- Dec;43(12):2233-43
cer. 1978 Dec;14(12):1331-5 27) Emrich HM. Endorphins in psychiatry. Psychiatr Dev
7) Balducci R. et al., Effect of hCG or hCG+ treatments in 1984 Summer;2(2):97-114
young thalassemic patients with hypogonadotropic hy- 28) Ferrari C. Use of a testosterone-gonadotropin combina-
pogonadism. J Endocrinol Invest. 1990 Jan;13(1):1-7 tion in the treatment of pathological syndromes in adult
8) Ballin JC. White PL. Fallacy and hazard. Human chori- males. Minerva Med. 1972 Jun 2;63(42):2399-408
onic gonadotropin-500-calorie diet and weight reduc- 29) Fiddes JC. et al., Structure. expression. and evolution of
tion. JAMA 1974 Nov 4;230(5):693-4 the genes for the human glycoprotein hormones. Recent
9) Bastow MD. Anthropometrics revisited. Proc Nutr Soc Prog Horm Res. 1984;40:43-78
1982 Sep;41(3):381-8 30) Fiddes JC. et al., The gene encoding the common alpha
10) Berry JN. Use of skinfold thickness for estimation of subunit of the four human glycoprotein hormones. J Mol
body fat. Indian J Med Res 1974 Feb;62(2):233-9 Appl Genet. 1981;1(1):3-18
11) Birken S. et al., Isolation and amino acid sequence of 31) Fleigelman R. Metabolic effects of human chorionic
COOH-terminal fragments from the beta subunit of hu- gonadotropin (HCG) in rats. Proc Soc Exp Biol Med
man choriogonadotropin. J Biol Chem. 1977 Aug 1970 Nov;135(2):317-9
10;252(15):5386-92 32) Gailani S. et al., Human chorionic gonadotrophins
12) Birken S.. Chemistry of human choriogonadotropin. (hCG) in non-trophoblastic neoplasms. Assessment of
Ann Endocrinol (Paris). 1984;45(4-5):297-305 abnormalities of hCG and CEA in bronchogenic and
13) Birmingham CL. et al., Human chorionic gonadotropin digestive neoplasms. Cancer. 1976 Oct;38(4):1684-6
is of no value in the management of obesity. Can Med 33) Gallo RC. Bryant J. Antitumor effects of hCG in KS. Nat
Assoc J. 1983 May 15;128(10):1156-7 Biotechnol Mar;16(3):218 1998
14) Bonandrini L. et al., Chorionic gonadotropin (HCG) in 34) Giudice LC. et al., Glycoprotein hormones: some as-
the therapy of chronic peripheral obliterating arteriopa- pects of studies of secondary and tertiary structure.
thy (CPOA) of the lower extremities caused by arterio- Monograph. 1979 May 23
sclerosis. Minerva Chir. 1970 Mar 15;25(5):368-83 35) Greenway FL. et al., Human chorionic gonadotropin
15) Borkan GA et. al., Comparison of ultrasound and skin- (HCG) in the treatment of obesity: a critical assessment
fold measurements in assessment of subcutaneous and of the Simeons method. West J Med 1977 Dec;127
total fatness. Am J Phys Anthropol 1982 Jul;58(3):307- (6):461-3
13 36) Grzonkowski S. Analysis of the results of the measure-
16) Borkan GA, Hults DE, Gerzof SG, Burrows BA, Rob- ments of adipose tissue in the human body based on the
bins AH. Relationships between computed tomography study of skinfold thickness. Przegl Epidemiol 1989;43
tissue areas, thicknesses and total body composition. (3):272-82
Ann Hum Biol. 1983 Nov-Dec;10(6):537-45. 37) Gusman HA. Chorionic gonadotropin in obesity. Fur-
17) Bosch B. et al., Human chorionic gonadotrophin and ther clinical observations. Am J Clin Nutr 1969 Jun;22
weight loss. A double-blind. placebo-controlled trial. S (6):686-95
Afr Med J 1990 Feb 17;77(4):185-9 38) Hashimoto TK. Chorionic gonadotropin preparation as
18) Bousfield GR. et al., Structural features of mammalian an analgesic. Arch Intern Med 1981 Feb;141(2):269
gonadotropins. Mol Cell Endocrinol. 1996 Dec 20;125 39) Hayes PA. Sub-cutaneous fat thickness measured by
(1-2):3-19 magnetic resonance imaging, ultrasound , and calipers.
19) Bozzola M. et al., Effect of human chorionic gonadotro- Med Sci Sports Exerc 1988 Jun;20(3):303-9
pin on growth velocity and biological growth parame- (Continued on next page)

THE ORIGINAL INTERNIST DECEMBER 2009 207


40) Weiss LW, Clark FC. Three protocols for measuring 58) Pierce JG.. Eli Lilly lecture. The subunits of pituitary
subcutaneous fat thickness on the upper extremities. Eur thyrotropin--their relationship to other glycoproteic
J Appl Physiol. 1987;56(2):217-21. hormones. Endocrinology. 1971 Dec;89(6):1331-44
PMID: 3552659; UI: 87190331 59) Rabe T. et al., Risk-benefit analysis of a hCG-500 kcal
41) Heitmann BL et al., Evaluation of body fat estimated reducing diet (cura romana) in females. Geburtshilfe
from body mass index, skinfolds and impedance. A com- Frauenheilkd. 1987 May;47(5):297-307
parative study. Eur J Clin Nutr 1990 Nov;44(11):831-7 60) Reiss M.. Stunted growth and the mechanism of its
42) Hermans P. Clumeck N. Picard O. et. al., AIDS-related stimulation in mentally disturbed adolescents. Int J Neu-
Kaposi's sarcoma patients with visceral manifestations. ropsychiatry. 1965 Aug;1(4):313-7
Response to human chorionic gonadotropin prepara- 61) Rivlin RS.. Therapy of obesity with hormones. N Engl J
tions. J Hum Virol Jan-Feb;1(2):82-9. 1998 Med. 1975 Jan 2;292(1):26-9
43) LaPorte DJ. Predicting attrition and adherence to a very 62) Ross GT.. Clinical relevance of research on the struc-
low calorie diet: a prospective investigation of the eat- ture of human chorionic gonadotropin. Am J Obstet
ing inventory. Int J Obes 1990 Mar;14(3):197-206 Gynecol. 1977 Dec 1;129(7):795-808
44) LaPorte DJ. Treatment response in obese binge eaters: 63) Sanders S, Norman AP. Chorionic gonadotrophin in
preliminary results using a very low calorie diet (VLCD) male growth-retarded adolescent asthmatic patients.
and behavior therapy. Addict Behav 1992;17(3):247-57 Practitioner. 1973 May;210(259):690-2.
45) Leshem Y. et al., Gonadotropin promotion of adventi- 64) Sarma JM. Houghten RA. Enzyme linked immunosor-
tious root production on cuttings of Begonia semper- bent assay (ELISA) for beta-endorphin and its antibod-
florens and Vitis vinifera. Plant Physiol. 1968 Mar;43 ies. Life Sci 1983;33 Suppl 1:129-32
(3):313-7 65) Sarria A et al., Skinfold thickness measurements are
46) Lustbader JW. et al., Structural and molecular studies of better predictors of body fat percentage than body mass
human chorionic gonadotropin and its receptor. Recent index in male Spanish children and adolescents. Eur J
Prog Horm Res. 1998;53:395-424 Clin Nutr 1998 Aug;52(8):573-6
47) Malkin A. The presence of glycosilated, biologically 66) Scaffidi A. Data on the pathogenesis and therapy of
active chorionic gonadotropin in human liver. Clin Bio- bronchial asthma in patients with secondary hypo-
chem 1985 Apr;18(2):75-7 gonadism. Minerva Med Dec 1;65(86):4473-6 1974
48) Maruo T. et al., Production of Choriogonadotropin-like 67) Segal SJ (ed.). Chorionic Gonadotropin. Plenum Press:
factor by a microorganism. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. NY. 1980
1979 Dec;76(12):6622-6 68) Shetty KR. et al., Human chorionic gonadotropin
49) McGarvey ME. Tulpule A. et. al., Emerging treatments (HCG) treatment of obesity. Arch Intern Med. 1977
for epidemic (AIDS-related) Kaposi's sarcoma. Curr Feb;137(2):151-5
Opin Oncol Sep;10(5):413-21 1998 69) Shomer-Ilan A. et al., Further evidence for the presence
50) Miller R. et al., A clinical study of the use of human of an endogenous gonadotrophin-like plant factor:
chorionic gonadotrophin in weight reduction. J Fam "phytotrophin."Isolation and mechanism of action of the
Pract. 1977 Mar;4(3):445-8 active principle. Aust J Biol Sci. 1973 Feb;26(1):105-12
51) Morgan FJ. et al., Chemistry of human chorionic gonad- 70) Simeons ATW. The action of chorionic gonadotropin in
otropin. Monograph. 1976 May 25 the obese. Lancet II:1954: 946-947
52) Mueller WH. Relative reliability of circumferences and 71) Simeons ATW.. Pounds and Inches: A new approach to
skinfolds as measures of body fat distribution. Am J obesity. Private Printing (1976)
Phys Anthropol 1987 Apr;72(4):437-9 72) Stein MR. et al., Ineffectiveness of human chorionic go-
53) Niebroj TK. et al., Effect of chorionic gonadotropins nadotropin in weight reduction: a double-blind study.
administration on water metabolism in glaucomatous Am J Clin Nutr. 1976 Sep;29(9):940-8
women. Endokrynol Pol. 1971 May-Jun;22(3):251-5 73) Stern JS. Weight control programs. Curr Concepts Nutr.
54) Orphanidou C. Accuracy of subcutaneous fat measure- 1977;5:137-55
ment: comparison of skinfold calipers. ultrasound, and 74) Suginami H. et al., Immunohistochemical localization of
computed tomography. J Am Diet Assoc 1994 Aug;94 a human chorionic gonadotropin-like substance in the
(8):855-8 human pituitary gland. J Clin Endocrinol Metab. 1982
55) Orphanidou CI, McCargar LJ, Birmingham CL, Belz- Dec;55(6):1161-6
berg AS. Changes in body composition and fat distribu- 75) Tagliabue A et al., Application of bioelectric impedance
tion after short-term weight gain in patients with ano- measurement in the evaluation of body fat. Recenti Prog
rexia nervosa. Am J Clin Nutr. 1997 Apr ; 65 (4) :1034- Med 1989 Feb;80(2):59-62
41 76) Talbot LA et al., Assessing body composition: the skin-
56) Perniola R. et al., Human chorionic gonadotrophin ther- fold method. AAOHN J 1995 Dec;43(12):605-13
apy in hypogonadal thalassaemic patients with os- 77) Tavio M. Nasti G. Simonelli C. et. al., Human chorionic
teopenia: increase in bone mineral density. J Pediatr gonadotropin in the treatment of HIV-related Kaposi's
Endocrinol Metab. 1998;11 Suppl 3:995-6 sarcoma. Eur J Cancer Sep;34(10):1634-7 1998
57) Pickar D et al., Clinical studies of the endogenous opioid 78) Torgerson JS et al., VLCD plus dietary and behavioral
system. Biol Psychiatry 1982 Nov;17(11):1243-76 support versus support alone in the treatment of severe
(Continued on next page)

THE ORIGINAL INTERNIST


208 Spring 2006 THE ORIGINAL INTERNIST DECEMBER 2009
05
obesity. A randomised two-year clinical trial. Int J Obes 84) Yanagihara Y. Carbohydrate and fatty acid metabolism
Relat Metab Disord 1997 Nov;21(11):987-94 in pregnant albino rats simultaneously loaded with fat
79) Vaitukaitis JL. Glycoprotein hormones and their sub- emulsion and sex stimulating hormones during starva-
units--immunological and biological characterization. tion. Nippon Sanka Fujinka Gakkai Zasshi 1967 Jan;19
Monograph. 1979 May 23 (1):8-14
80) Veilleux H. et al., Gonadic and extragonadic effects in 85) Yanagihara Y. Carbohydrate and lipid metabolism in
humans of 3.500 I.U. of HCG (human chorionic gonad- pregnant albino rats during starvation after loading
otropin) in fractional doses. Vie Med Can with gonad-stimulating hormones. Nippon Sanka Fu-
b) Vogt T, Belluscio D. Controversies in plastic surgery: jinka Gakkai Zasshi 1966 Dec;18(12):1379-84
suction-assisted lipectomy (SAL) and the hCG (human 86) Yoshimoto Y. et al.. Human chorionic gonadotropin--
chorionic gonadotropin) protocol for obesity treatment. like material: presence in normal human tissues. Am J
Aesthetic Plast Surg. 1987;11(3):131-56. Review. Obstet Gynecol. 1979 Aug 1;134(7):729-33
81) Wattanapenpaiboon N. et al., Agreement of skinfold 87) Yoshimoto Y. et al.. Human chorionic gonadotropin-like
measurement and bioelectrical impedance analysis substance in nonendocrine tissues of normal subjects.
(BIA) methods with dual energy X-ray absorptiometry Science. 1977 Aug 5;197(4303):575-7
(DEXA) in estimating total body fat in Anglo-Celtic Aus- 88) Young RL. et al., Chorionic gonadotropin in weight
tralians. Int J Obes Relat Metab Disord. 1998 Sep;22 control. A double-blind crossover study. JAMA. 1976
(9):854-60 Nov 29;236(22):2495-7
82) Weits T. et al., Comparison of ultrasound and skinfold 89) Zakut H. et al.. hCG as tumor marker in non-
caliper measurement of subcutaneous fat tissue. Int J trophoblastic neoplasms. Harefuah. 1985 Jan 15;108
Obes 1986;10(3):161-8 (2):82-5
83) Yanagihara Y. Carbohydrate and lipid metabolism in 90) Zondek B. Sulman F. The mechanism of action and me-
pregnant albino rats during hunger after loading with tabolism of gonadotrophic hormones in the organism.
gonad-stimulating hormones. Nippon Sanka Fujinka Vit Horm 1945 3:297-336 ‹
Gakkai Zasshi 1966 Nov;18(11):1293-301

(Continued on next page)

THE ORIGINAL INTERNIST DECEMBER 2009 209


More photos are available at
http://hcgobesity.org/hcg_obesity_photographs.htm

THE ORIGINAL INTERNIST


210 Spring 2006 THE ORIGINAL INTERNIST DECEMBER 2009
05
Coronary artery bypass operations are a huge stress for
an elderly person. This major operation produces
profound immuno-suppression in the body. This means
that the body will not be able to do a good job fighting
BLOOD off infections and the spread of cancer cells for several
months after this surgery.

TRANSFUSIONS Of even greater importance are the adverse effects of


transfusion itself. What are these transfusions doing to

ARE VERY
the human body? Some undesirable effects of transfu-
sion include:
• The infections seen are not at the operative site but

DANGEROUS are randomly scattered throughout the body suggest-


ing the immune system is not capable of preventing
serious infections. Something has injured the
by: Dr. James A. Howenstine
immune system.

• Blood transfusions are placing an enormous burden


on the immune system in patients getting this
surgery.
Excessive use of blood transfusions is a major cause of
death that has generally been overlooked. Conservative • Every individual’s blood is unique. Each person’s
study of blood transfusions estimates that at least 25% blood contains dozens of antigens capable of
are unnecessary. Ten percent of all patients entering producing adverse responses in the blood recipient
hospitals are given blood transfusions. Blood transfu- [(inhaled antigens, poorly digested proteins that
sions are frequently given for anemia but their use may were able to be absorbed into the blood stream, tu-
cause greater problems than benefits. mor antigens, and antibodies directed against parts
of the body perceived as foreign (auto antibodies to
Why Are Blood Transfusions Dangerous? islet cells, bronchial epithelium, synovial mem-
branes etc.)] Blood may also contain residue from
In the United States there are about 500,000 heart bypass cigarette smoke, pesticides, herbicides, inhalant
operations performed each year. Researchers at the cleaning substances, chemicals etc.
University of Michigan studied 9218 persons aged 65 or
older who had coronary bypass surgery. They learned • We are all constantly fighting off infections.
that patients who had received blood transfusions were Donated blood may also contain viral, bacterial,
five times more likely to die2 within 100 days of the spirochetal, parasitic and fungal organisms the donor
surgery than patients who were not transfused. More was battling. It is estimated that one in every six
than 66% of the men having this operation and 88% of persons3 in the world is currently infected with
the women having this operation receive a blood transfu- Borrelia Burgdorfi spirochetes (Lyme Disease). This
sion. Women had a 9% death rate within 100 days of this means the person whose blood is given may have
operation but only 6% of men die in the same time pathogens in this blood capable of causing colds,
interval. The primary cause for death in these bypass gingivitis, sinusitis or even a serious infection
patients is infection at a site unrelated to the operative (Lyme Disease, Chaga’s Disease) in the recipient.
procedure. All blood can and does transmit infectious agents
(viral, bacterial, fungal, parasitic, mycoplaasma,
The odds on developing an infection were three times spirochetal) present in donated blood. Given to a
higher in bypass patients who had received a blood healthy person this would usually not cause a fatal
transfusion when compared to patients who were not problem but given to an immuno-suppressed patient
transfused during the surgery. The more units of blood trying to recuperate from a major operation it may
transfused the greater the risk of infection. If transfu- become the proverbial straw that broke the camel’s
sions are dangerous it is easy to understand why more back.
women die than men because their smaller blood volume
causes them to receive proportionally more blood. • The most important pathogen in blood is probably
Borellia Burgdorfi (Bb) which causes Lyme Disease.
(Continued on next page)
THE ORIGINAL INTERNIST DECEMBER 2009 211
Borrelia is not tested for in transfused blood. It is often treated with blood transfusions. These transfusions
easy to understand how a patient seriously ill after in cancer patients come with a price.
bypass surgery could be overwhelmed by the onset
of Lyme Disease postoperatively. Lyme Disease is In Holland, a study of colon cancer patients revealed that
rampant because it is easily spread person to person. only 48% of cases transfused were alive at 5 years
Most patients with Lyme Disease have a silent compared to 74% in non transfused patients. The results
infection that does not become evident until some for head and neck cancers are even worse.
serious incident damages their immune system
(major surgery, accident, infection, immune injury Cancer of the larynx had only 14% survivors at 5 years
from alcohol, drugs, insomnia, stress etc). This in transfused patients and 65% in non-transfused
means there are millions of persons walking around patients. In cancers of the oral cavity the cancer
whose blood would be dangerous to receive because recurrence rate was 31% without transfusions and 71%
they look healthy but have blood containing Bb with transfusions.
spirochetes. Lyme disease is now impossible to be
accurately diagnosed because the two best tests for A lung cancer study from Europe confirmed adverse
the disease are no longer available (blood culture results5 with transfusions. Thirty day mortality rose from
Dr. Lyda Mattman, QIRBb Dr. JoAnne Whitaker). 2.4 percent for patients not transfused to 10.9 percent for
These tests were fool proof because growing spiro- those getting 2 or less transfusions and to 21.9 percent in
chetes out of the blood or visualizing pieces of spiro- patients receiving more than 2 units of blood. Other
chetes in blood samples constitutes undeniable proof studies in patients with colon cancer have confirmed the
of diagnosis. Remember one in 6 persons has the Bb more blood transfused6 the worse the results.
spirochetes in their blood so if you receive six units
of blood you are probably getting Bb spirochetes. Hip Replacement Surgery
We will never know how many postoperative deaths
in transfused patients are being caused by undiag- Patients undergoing hip replacement, who had received
nosed Lyme Disease because there are no longer transfusions, had a 35% greater risk of a serious bacterial
reliable tests available to diagnose this disease. infection and a 52% greater risk7 of developing pneumo-
Chaga’s Disease (parasitic illness) from Latin nia. Surgeons and other physicians often do not hesitate
American citizens damages the heart and is certainly to order blood transfusions because they do not realize
being infused into unfortunate persons getting blood the real danger of transfusion.
transfusions. Neither Chaga’s Disease or Lyme
Disease is likely to be considered in the postopera- These undesirable results are not limited to cancer
tive period. patients and patients having hip replacement. All
transfusions are dangerous. The risk of serious infections
• Diagnosable transfusion reactions (chills, fever, skin goes along with transfusion therapy in general.
rash) occur in one out of every 100 transfused
persons. Can The Number Of Blood Transfusions Be Safely
Reduced?
A major operation like bypass surgery causes a
profound immuno-suppressive reaction. This damages Coronary artery bypass surgery is one of the principal
the body’s ability to kill bacteria and cancer cells for users of blood transfusions. There is an unrecognized
several months. The immuno-suppressive state follow- serious mortality from coronary artery bypass surgery
ing colon cancer surgery can be blocked by the use of when patients are followed 100 days for the full morbid-
the drug Tagamet taken before or started shortly after ity of blood transfusion damage to the immune system to
the colon operation. Patients treated with Tagamet for become manifest (9% deaths in women and 6% deaths in
one year have a significantly higher survival rate4 than men above age 65).
controls not receiving Tagamet.
In addition between 1.5% and 5.2% of patients have a
What Are The Results Of Blood Transfusions In stroke8 under anesthesia during coronary bypass surgery.
Other Health Conditions? Other patients experience loss of memory and difficulty
focusing attention following coronary bypass surgery.
Cancer Therapy These problems are probably due to brain cell injury and
Chemotherapy and radiation suppress bone marrow death from small emboli to the brain and reperfusion
production of red blood cells. The resulting anemia is acidosis following the surgery. Reintroduction of blood
(Continued on next page)

THE ORIGINAL INTERNIST


212 Spring 2006 THE ORIGINAL INTERNIST DECEMBER 2009
05
into the cerebral circulation after the bypass is completed Alternative health therapies (eliminating toxic metals
causes the rapid appearance of oxygen-deprived blood from endothelium with long term oral chelation,
containing free radicals which can damage the fat treating endothelial infections with tumeric, high doses
containing brain cells. The propolis from honey can of vitamin C and lysine{Linus Pauling}, N-acetyl cys-
protect9 the brain from this type injury by virtue of its teine, L-arginine, lowering homocysteine values with
strong antioxidant effects, but this is probably only pyridoxine, folic acid, B12 and trimethylglycine,
rarely used in the United States where hospitals rely on curtailing sugar intake, Vitamin K2 [removes calcium
drugs. from arterial plaque and places calcium in bone] and
use of Mediterranean diet) would promptly heal
A large population study disclosed that angioplasty patients with arteriosclerosis. Excessive sugar intake12
(forcible opening of narrowed heart arteries with a bal- is now regarded as the number one risk factor for heart
loon) performed 3 to 28 days after a heart attack failed to attacks in women and the number 2 risk factor in men.
prevent death,10 new heart attacks and heart failure.
Furthermore, in a four year follow-up of these patients Often the sales pitch that encourages patients to have
there were more new heart attacks in the patients who bypass surgery, angioplasties and stent placement is
received angioplasties than the group treated conserva- based on fear (You are a walking time bomb. You
tively without angioplasties. could drop dead any moment!!!). All decisions based
on fear are emotional rather than a rational considera-
Coronary bypass surgery has long had prominent tion of scientific truth. Frightened patients readily
detractors but has steadily grown in use until it has accept dangerous surgical therapies particularly when
become a huge industry in the USA. In 1977, the first they are unaware there is an alternative.
extensive evaluation of cardiac surgery for arteriosclero-
sis was done. This evaluation of 596 patients treated A major factor preventing the switch by the public to
with bypass surgery or drug therapy revealed that safer alternative health regimens is the fact that drugs
surgery was no better than drug therapy. Eugene and surgery are covered by health plans and alternative
Braunwald,11 highly respected Chief of Cardiology at therapies are not. Linus Pauling’s high doses of vitamin
Harvard Medical School, commented 30 years ago that, C and lysine can rapidly reverse anginal pain, hyperten-
“an industry is being built around this operation. It is sion and claudication. Dr. Julian Whitaker has seen
developing a momentum of its own, and as time passes it many patients with severe angina, positive treadmills
will be progressively more difficult and costly to curtail and dire warnings about impending death without
it.” In 1984, another large study involving 780 patients, bypass surgery become asymptomatic and so far
again disclosed no advantage for surgery over drug removed from arteriosclerosis they are able to partici-
therapy. pate in marathon races and other stressful activities,
after embarking on a rational program to eliminate
Natural therapies are far more effective than drugs arteriosclerosis. Dr. Garry Gordon often relates that he
which are unable to reverse arteriosclerosis. Knowledge has never seen a stroke or heart attack in 30 years in
of their existence has been systematically suppressed by those patients taking his long term oral chelation com-
the power of the pharmaceutical industry which controls bined with anticoagulation using the safe natural anti-
what is published in conventional medical journals and clotting substance (carrageenan {red algae} found in
by the news media which conveniently ignores health Natural Cellular Defense).
breakthroughs that would hurt the earnings of pharma-
ceutical companies. Nobel Prize winner Dr. Linus Any therapy based on mechanical repair of narrowed
Pauling proposed an effective new therapeutic program arteries is doomed to failure because it fails to deal
using lysine and Vitamin C that reverses arteriosclerosis with the root cause for arteriosclerosis which is a
in 6 to 8 weeks which remains largely unknown to U.S. degenerative metabolic disorder caused by toxic
citizens. metals, infections, vitamin C and K2 deficiency, excess
sugar, dietary transfats, gingivitis and dangerous levels
Coronary artery repair by angioplasty, stent placement, of homocysteine.
and coronary artery bypass are procedures that have
become routine in the United States. The reason that Harvard cardiologist Dr. Thomas Graboys believes that
surgery fails to improve the long-term results may be 90% of the 740,000 coronary bypass operations and
that surgery is treating the symptoms of arteriosclerosis 600,000 angioplasties performed annually in the US
(chest pain, heart attack), but not really reversing the are unnecessary. There would be significant declines in
causes for arteriosclerosis. the death rate13 from cardiovascular disease if all by-
(Continued on next page)
THE ORIGINAL INTERNIST DECEMBER 2009 213
pass, angioplasties and stents were replaced with effec- Bacteriologist Lida Mattman states “I’m convinced
tive natural therapies for arteriosclerosis. Lyme Disease is transmissible from person to person.”
In 1995 Dr. Mattman obtained positive cultures for Bb
If the general public became informed of the hazards of from 43 of 47 persons with chronic illness. Only 1 of 23
coronary artery surgery and switched to natural options control patients had a positive Bb culture. Dr. Mattman
for arteriosclerotic heart disease much less blood would has subsequently recovered Bb spirochetes from 8 out of
be used and many lives would be saved. This is not 8 cases of Parkinson’s Disease, 41 cases of multiple
likely to occur because this knowledge is not being sclerosis, 21 cases of amyotrophic lateral sclerosis and
transmitted to the public by media that serve the pharma- all tested cases of Alzheimer’s Disease. The complete
ceutical industry. recovery of several persons with terminal amyotrophic
lateral sclerosis after appropriate therapy shows the great
Important Information About Lyme Disease importance of establishing the diagnosis of Lyme
(Borrelia Burgdorfi Infection) Disease.
Lyme Disease was originally regarded as an uncommon Some very important information has recently become
illness caused by the spirochete Borrelia Burgdorfi Bb. available about the spread and magnitude of the problem
The disease transmission was thought to be solely by the with Lyme Disease. The severity of the disease is related
bite from a tick infected with this parasite. The Bb to the spirochete load in the patient. Few spirochetes
spirochete is able to burrow into tendons, muscle cells, produce mild or asymptomatic infection. A study from
ligaments and directly into organs. A classic bulls-eye Switzerland in 1998 pointed out that only 12.5% of
rash is often visible in the early stages of the illness. patients testing positive for Bb had developed symptoms.
Later in the illness the disease can affect the heart, nerv- A German boy developed Lyme arthritis 5 years after
ous system, joints and other organs. It is now realized his tick bite.
that the disease can mimic amyotrophic lateral sclerosis,
Parkinson’s Disease, Bell’s palsy, reflex sympathetic Often, mycoplasma infections remain without symptoms
dystrophy, neuritis, all psychiatric illnesses including until the victim suffers a traumatic event (stress, injury,
schizophrenia, chronic fatigue, heart failure, angina, accident, major surgery etc.) These stressing events
irregular heart rhythms, fibromyalgia, dermatitis, auto- enable the mycoplasma to begin consumption of choles-
immune diseases such as sclera-derma and lupus, eye terol in the neural sheath, and symptoms (ALS) may
inflammatory reactions, sudden deafness, SIDS, ADD begin to present as these nerve cells die. The mechanism
and hyperactivity, chronic pain and many other con- of this deterioration is thought to be suppression of the
ditions. immune system secondary to stress. Lyme Disease may
have a similar delayed presentation as many persons
Biology professor, Lida Mattman, author of Cell Wall experience the onset of Lyme symptoms after stressful
Deficient Forms: Stealth Pathogens, has been able to events.
recover live spirochetes of Bb from mosquitoes, fleas,
mites, semen, urine, blood and spinal fluid. A factor Dr. Jo Anne Whitaker relates that nearly every patient
contributing to making Bb so dangerous is that it can with Parkinson’s Disease (PD) has tested positive for
survive and spread without having a cell wall (cell wall- Bb. Dr. Louis Romero reports that 3 patients with
deficient (CWD). Many valuable antibiotics kill bacteria Parkinson’s disease are 99% better after TAO-free cat’s
by breaking down the cell wall. These antibiotics often claw (Uncaria tomentosa) therapy.
prove ineffective against Bb.
When Dr. Mattman cultured 25 patients with fibromyal-
Lyme Disease is now thought to be the fastest growing gia all subjects had positive cultures for the CWD Bb
infectious disease in the world. Even with a current lack which causes Lyme Disease. She relates that Bb can be
of good diagnostic tests, at least 200,000 new cases are found in tears and could thus easily appear on the hands
diagnosed each year in the U.S. and some experts think where touching could spread Lyme Disease. Several
as many as one in every 15 Americans is currently families are now documented where nearly every family
infected (20 million persons). Dr. Ralph Rowen knows a member is infected. How sick the individual patient
family where the mother’s infection spread to 5 of her 6 becomes relates to their initial spirochete dose, immune
children14 all of whom recovered with appropriate system status, detoxification capability and stress level.
therapy. It is difficult to believe that these children were
all bitten by ticks and seems more plausible that person Transmission of the disease has been clearly doc-
to person spread within the family caused this problem. umented after bites by fleas, mites, mosquitoes and ticks.
(Continued on next page)
THE ORIGINAL INTERNIST
214 Spring 2006 THE ORIGINAL INTERNIST DECEMBER 2009
05
There is compelling evidence that Lyme Disease (LD) Dr. Jo Anne Whitaker, a Lyme disease victim from
can be spread by sexual and congenital transfer. One childhood, has developed a reliable test for the presence
physician has cared for 5000 children with LD. 240 of of Lyme Disease. This test looks for the Bb organism,
these children were born with the disease. Dr. Charles not antibodies, and is able to identify pieces of the cell
Ray Jones, the leading pediatric specialist on Lyme wall deficient (CWD) form of the spirochete as well as
Disease, has found 12 breast fed children who have the actual Bb organism. Her test is called Q-RiBb which
developed Lyme Disease. Miscarriage, premature birth, stands for quantitative rapid identification of Bb. Dr.
stillborn, birth defects and transplacental infection of the Lida Mattman has confirmed that Dr. Whitaker’s test is
fetus have all been reported. Studies at the Univ. of sensitive and accurate because there has been a 100%
Vienna have found Bb in urine and breast milk of LD correlation between a positive blood culture of Bb by
mothers. Dr. Mattman’s lab and a positive Q-RiBb test from Dr.
Whitaker’s laboratory.
Researchers at the Univ. of Wisconsin have reported that
dairy cattle can be infected with Bb, hence milk could be Because 87.5% of patients incubating Lyme Disease
contaminated. Bb can also be transmitted to lab animals may not have symptoms, there is a huge pool of poten-
by oral intake such as food. tial blood donors who present serious danger to any
patient who will need blood transfusions for an elective
The Sacramento, California blood bank thinks that LD surgical procedure. Therefore potential surgical patients
can be spread by blood transfusions. The CDC (Center need to be certain that the risks of surgery and transfu-
for Disease Control) in Atlanta, Georgia states that their sion warrant proceeding with the operation.
data indicates that Bb can survive blood processing
techniques used for transfusions in the U.S. How To Protect Yourself From The Danger Of
Transfusions
Lyme Disease is the fastest growing epidemic in the
world. LD is grossly underreported so there are far more Elective surgery often provides sufficient time to place
than the 200,000 cases reported annually in the U.S. your own blood in reserve for your surgery. In the
Lyme Disease is thought to be a contributing factor in Michigan study those who banked their own blood and
50% of patients who have chronic disease. those who avoided transfusions had the lowest rates of
infection and the lowest risk of dying after bypass
surgery.
®
New surgical techniques save blood. Lost blood can be
saved, cleaned and recycled back to the patient during
LOWER BACK PAIN RELIEF the surgery. Lasers and cryotherapy can instantly stop
blood loss in the operating room. Drops of blood instead
QUANTITY PRICES of vials can be used to perform lab tests. Microsurgical
1 ................$285.00 ea. techniques minimize tissue trauma and blood loss. Hy-
2 ................$275.00 ea. perbaric oxygen chambers, drugs such as erythropoietin,
3-5 ............$259.00 ea. vitamins, iron, and hormones can be utilized to increase
In US Dollars red blood cell production before surgery.
SUGGESTED PATIENT PRICE $385.00
It is estimated that 75,000 surgeons have been trained to
30 Day conditional perform bloodless surgery in the USA. Many hospitals
Money back guarantee have become equipped to perform this type surgery.
Prices subject to change without notice
Check to learn if your local hospitals can provide this
care.

LASHAW DISTRIBUTORS LTD Continue to donate blood as properly used transfusions


9631 Bakerview Drive can be life saving. Healthy individuals are allowed to
Richmond, B.C., Canada V7A 2A2
donate as often as every 8 weeks.
Tel: ......................................(604)270-4263
Fax: .................................... (604)277-2154
Toll Free: ..........................1-800-667-7795 The danger of blood transfusions is real and not widely
C.O.D.
Or prepay Website: ......................www.invertrac.com appreciated by the general public and the medical
By cheque E-mail: ................invertrac@invertrac.com
profession. Try to be certain that the risks of transfusion
(Continued on next page)
THE ORIGINAL INTERNIST DECEMBER 2009 215
are exceeded by the benefits before accepting blood 5) Eur Respir J 06;Nov 1{Epub]
transfusions. 6) Dis Colon Rectum 06;49(8):1116-1130
7) Transfusion 99;39(7): 694-700
Dr. James A. Howenstine is a board certified specialist 8) Selnes Oa et al. Coronary artery bypass surgery and
in internal medicine who spent 34 years taking care of the brain New England Journal Of Medicine
hospital and office patients. For more information visit 2001Feb 8;44(6):451-2.
www.mynaturalhealthteam.com and by phoning 1-800- 9) CellBiochem Funct 03;21(3):283-9.
416-2806. Dr. Howenstine can be reached by email at 10) Hochman Js et al Coronary intervention for persis-
dr.jimhow@gmail.com and by writing Dr. James tent occlusion after myocardial infarction N Engl j
Howenstine, C/O Remarsa USA SB 37, P.O. Box 25292, Me 2006 Dec 7;355;2395-2407.
Miami, FL 33102-5292 11) Braunwald E. Coronary-artery surgery at the cross-
roads New England Journal Of Medicine 1977;297:
References (12) 661-3.
12) Grant WB Reassessing the role of sugar in the etol-
1) Williams, David G. Alternatives Feb 2007 Volume ogy of heart disease. J Orthomolecular Med 1998;13
11 No. 20 pg 153. (2): 95-104
2) Am Heart J 06;252(6): 1028-1034 Archiv Intern 13) Whitaker, Julian Coronary Artery Disease Back to
Med 06;166(4):437-443 Basics Health & Healing Feb 2007 Vol 12. No.2 pg
3) Harvey, W.T.M.D., Salvato, Patricia M.D. The 1-3.
History of Lyme Disease Focus Newsletter Allergy 14) Rowen, Robert If you have ANY chronic debilitat-
Research Group Breakthrough in Lyme Disease Oct ing disease, you could be the victim of a Monste
2003 pg 5 Epidemic! Second Opinion Vol X111 No. 11 Nov
4) The Lancet Dec 31,1994 pg 1768-1769 The Lancet 2003 ‹
July 8, 1995 pg 115

Use Dr. Jack Kessinger’s Health Care Lectures


for patient orientation or civic groups
♦ Nutrition & Maintaining Good Health: Each one-hour
lecture includes:
Risks and benefits of natural care vs drugs and surgery. • 20 professional
♦ Cholesterol & Heart Disease: •
PowerPoint slides
Guideline booklet
Natural therapies for preventing and reversing most CVD. for presentation
♦ Diabetes Mellitus: • Patient handouts
(Personalized
Management through natural means. with your clinic
♦ Osteoporosis: information)

Natural ways to prevent and reverse bone loss.


♦ Fibromyalgia, Chronic Fatigue & Arthritis:
Benefits of exercise and nutritional supplements.

Each ……. or Complete Set of 5 for $400

THE ORIGINAL INTERNIST


216 Spring 2006 THE ORIGINAL INTERNIST DECEMBER 2009
05
Me
nt
10 ion
% C
Di DID
sc 2
ou 009
nt
• What time of the day is it best to do the urine

Clinical Relevance
collection?
• How do different supplements affect urinary
neurotransmitter values?

of Neurotransmitter Urinary measurements reflect whole-body neuro-


transmitter production

Testing Following are my own opinions regarding some of


these issues. I choose to start with the misconception
that urinary neurotransmitter testing examines brain
by: Dr Scott Theirl levels of neurotransmitters only. I have never
Submitted by: NeuroScience, Inc. witnessed any reputable lab claim this. This claim only
comes from misguided clinicians and patients. Urinary
There are many differing professional opinions on the neurotransmitters are reflective of the entire physical
subject of urinary neurotransmitter testing and the system. With the many sources of neurotransmitter
subsequent use of amino acid supplements to help synthesis reviewed earlier, it is accepted that urinary
optimize neurotransmitter stores in the body. I believe measurements are reflective of total body neurotrans-
these varied opinions are simply due to the newness of mitter activity. Additionally, it has been observed that
the testing protocols and the debate will drive further urinary neurotransmitter measurements are correlated
research and development much more quickly. This with neurotransmitter activity in the central nervous
push for research and development will ultimately system.
benefit patients, but in the meantime, practitioners are Clinical observations regarding neurotransmitter
left to decide which side of the debate they choose to testing
be on. This can be both confusing and frustrating as Although there are studies supporting both sides of the
science continues to sort out the most efficient ways of argument of clinical correlation, I have found time and
helping our patients. again, a strong clinical correlation between urinary
Basic facts concerning neurotransmitters neurotransmitter levels and patient symptoms such as
depression, anxiety and insomnia. Urinary neurotrans-
• Neurotransmitters are very important for overall
health and specifically for nervous system function. mitter testing must be used in conjunction with a
detailed patient history and thorough physical examina-
• Urinary neurotransmitter measurement has existed
tion at the time of testing. It is only upon alignment of
for decades.
patient history, exam and laboratory testing that an
• Amino acids are the building blocks of neurotrans- appropriate treatment plan can be recommended and
mitters and some can cross the blood-brain barrier.
integrated. Urinary neurotransmitter values alone are
• Neurotransmitters are synthesized in many areas of of limited significance. For example, if one wants to
the body including the central nervous system, the define the value of urinary norepinephrine and epineph-
peripheral nervous system, the kidneys, the gas- rine to peripheral output from the adrenal medulla
trointestinal tract, and the adrenal glands. alone, this can still be of value to me as a clinician
• Intact neurotransmitters are filtered by the kidneys demonstrating hyper versus hypo adrenal neurotrans-
resulting in the ability to measure them in the urine. mitter function. But these high/low values must be
• Adding specific amino acid supplements can alter considered in the context of the patient’s history of
urinary neurotransmitter values. stress (physical, emotional, and/or cognitive). Only
• Adding specific amino acid supplements may when all of the elements are used together can a clini-
benefit patients by reducing neurologic symptoms. cian make appropriate recommendations to their
Primary considerations regarding neurotransmitter patients. Science will continue to illuminate the
assessment biochemical associations between urinary neurotrans-
• Where are the neurotransmitters in the urine mitter testing and central nervous system function, but
coming from? the clinical associations between urinary neurotransmit-
• Is there sufficient clinical correlation between ter testing and patient’s symptoms are promising and of
urinary neurotransmitter testing, patient symptoms, benefit to many patients.
and patient outcomes to support testing? Scientific evidence supporting neurotransmitter
• Is there sufficient scientific correlation between testing
urinary neurotransmitter testing, patient symptoms Neurotransmitters have been measured in academic
and patient outcomes to support testing? settings for decades. The argument concerning whether
(Continued on next page)
THE ORIGINAL INTERNIST
218 Spring 2006 THE ORIGINAL INTERNIST DECEMBER 2009
05
or not neurotransmitters exist in the urinary pool is The patient was a 41 year old male, married, father of
irrefutable. Recent advances in clinical laboratory two and self-employed. He presented to me with anxi-
technology now provide reliable, cost-effective, and ety, fatigue and various physical pain complaints. He
convenient methods for measuring neurotransmitters in reported the anxiety began one year previously, initiated
clinical settings. A brief review of scientific literature by a panic attack that involved elevated heart rate,
yields a plethora of studies investigating urinary neuro- elevated respiration, sweating and clammy skin. These
transmitters as correlates of a wide variety of neuro- symptoms were severe enough to require hospitalization
logical and psychiatric disease states. A comprehensive five times in the past year for similar panic attacks. He
review of the literature is beyond the scope of this arti- also stated that during these episodes, he was clear
cle, however, those interested in more information headed and did not feel anxious, but his body was
should contact NeuroScience, Inc. Visit clearly in “panic mode”. He detailed his energy levels as
www.neuroscienceinc.com for a concise review of evi- “feeling good only a few hours per day” and then feeling
dence pertaining to the clinical relevance of urinary neu- so fatigued that he wanted nothing more than to sleep.
rotransmitter measurements. He reported that his peak energy of the day was between
Timing neurotransmitter collection 9pm and midnight. He has a history of chronic asthma,
Neurotransmitter testing is not a “one-size-fits-all” treat- chronic sinusitis with year-round allergies and three
ment protocol, rather it serves as a tool to assess a nasal polyp surgeries in the last nine years. He also
patient’s individual biochemistry at that given moment reported irritable bowel syndrome and insomnia, and
in time. So if you, as a clinician, desire to assess a explained that falling asleep was easy but he would
patient’s daytime symptoms such as fatigue, anxiety, or wake 3-4 times per night. He stated that it was currently
attention difficulties, it is best to perform a morning difficult to lose weight even if he ate less and dairy-free.
urine sample, but if your patient suffers from insomnia, He had a full cardiac work-up, upper and lower GI scope
then a nighttime sample will be most helpful. As a clini- and a thyroid work-up which he reported were all nega-
cian I was always taught to examine, treat and then re- tive. His medications included Advair, Allegra D,
examine in order to observe objective and subjective Xanax, Paxil and Bisoprolol. He also commented that
changes, for better or worse. Consequently, I believe that he had taken prolonged antibiotics and nasal steroids
baseline neurotransmitter testing is helpful to clinicians seasonally for years secondary to his sinusitis, but was
to understand where a patient was prior to intervention not currently on either type of medication. His NeuroEn-
and where they are headed after follow-up neurotrans- docrine Panel results are on the next page.
mitter testing is performed. It is difficult to comprehend These reports can be viewed from three angles:
where a treatment plan is going if you do not know androgen hormones, adrenal hormones and neurotrans-
where you have come from. This is the value of a mitters: excitatory/inhibitory. Each of these three areas
detailed patient history and objective laboratory have the opportunity to present as optimal, low or
measurements at the beginning of any new therapeutic elevated. This information provides insight into a pa-
protocol. tient’s metabolic state. Is this patient experiencing acute
Amino acids influence neurotransmitter synthesis or chronic stress responses as evidenced by their bio-
and excretion patterns markers? Is it best to support this patient’s androgen
Amino acids, the precursors to neurotransmitters, hormones, adrenal hormones (DHEA and cortisol),
circulate both peripherally and centrally. Both the central adrenal neurotransmitters (epinephrine and norepineph-
and peripheral nervous systems produce neurotransmit- rine), or additional neurotransmitters (excitatory, Inhibi-
ters from the same common amino acids. Consequently, tory, or both)? Patients, such as with this example, who
supplementation with specific amino acids has the have experienced anxiety/panic attacks, fatigue, pain
ability to improve central and peripheral nervous system syndromes and insomnia can present with many differ-
neurotransmitter stores and support other neurotransmit- ent biomarker combinations depending on their individ-
ter synthesis sites including the intestine and adrenal ual severity of metabolic fatigue. This clearly illustrates
glands. I believe urinary neurotransmitter testing is the why it is so beneficial to practitioner and patient alike
best objective measurement we as clinicians currently to perform an initial test.
have available to guide amino acid supplementation With this patient I thought it best to support his DHEA
protocols. (15mg with breakfast), cortisol (Isocort-2 pellets with
Case Study breakfast), serotonin/GABA (Travacor 2 capsules at
The following case is an example of both the power of bedtime), adrenal neurotransmitter support (Adrecor-
neurotransmitter/hormone biomarker testing as well as work up to 2 capsules BID prior to breakfast and lunch).
the benefit of using specific amino acids to best support I also recommended 2-3 grams Omega-3 fish oils/day
your patients’ neurochemical balance. and 100 billion multistrain probiotics/day.
(Continued on next page)
THE ORIGINAL INTERNIST DECEMBER 2009 219
This patient followed up with me approximately seven puzzle need to be addressed specifically for your patient.
weeks later and reported his anxiety improved with some Having observed the positive outcomes in my patients
“good days” that did not require any Xanax, improved utilizing the testing that is currently available, I have
daytime energy that was “on and off day by day,” and become extremely enthused about the future of
still present but improved overall physical pain. He also neurotransmitter optimization. I look forward to the day
reported his efforts to lose weight were beginning to pay when we have clinical tests to objectively assess neuro-
off. Of additional clinical interest, is that these sympto- transmitter binding and uptake, enzymatic degradation
matic improvements happened at the same time as an and receptor sensitivity therapies. In the interim, I
additional three rounds of antibiotics that were advocate the use of urinary neurotransmitter testing and
prescribed for possible cellulitis. amino acid supplementation to optimize pre-synaptic
I modified his supplement routine and added GABA neurotransmitter stores.
support (Kavinace-maximum 6 per day) as needed to Lastly, recognize that the future of neurotransmitter
support anxious symptoms and further support healthy testing and optimization will do much more than just
sleep patterns. I also recommended catecholamine sup- objectively measure levels of neurotransmitters in the
port for daytime energy (ExcitaPlus 1 capsule BID prior urine. Incorporation of the immune and endocrine
to breakfast and lunch to be taken with his Adrecor). I systems is essential to understanding how to best support
moved cautiously on his excitatory support due to his the entire system. Thyroid hormones, adrenal cortisol,
history of anxiety. immune cytokines & antibodies, food sensitivities, and
During a telephone follow-up three weeks later, he environmental toxins are just some of the many compo-
reported continued improved anxiety levels with no need nents that will intersect with neurotransmitter testing for
for medication in over a week and improved sleep clinical application and improved patient outcomes.
patterns, but he had experienced increased daytime Neuroendoimmunology is in its infancy but the future is
fatigue following an additional sinus polyp surgery six very bright.
days prior to the conversation. Follow up testing was With the combination of objective testing and subjective
recommended in the near future and he was pleased with findings, a more accurate and complete picture of your
his progress to date, as am I. This was a very positive patient’s current condition can be constructed and allow
clinical response considering his additional medical for improved clinical applications. In the end, every
complications. practitioner must decide their own personal clinical
strategies. Urinary neurotransmitter testing and amino
Summary acid supplementation, coupled with a detailed patient
Imagine how exciting it will be when you can objec- history and physical examination, have been essential to
tively determine which parts of the neurotransmitter my ability to help my patients achieve optimal function. ‹

Test Parameter Result Optimal Range


Estradiol 2.1 0.8-1.5
Estrone 2.3 1.0-2.5
Progesterone 0.032 0.070-0.150
Testosterone 60.1 75-95
Dihydrotestosterone 19.1 20-40
DHEA 84.5 250-450
Cortisol AM 2.2 7.0-10
Cortisol Midday 3.6 3-6
Cortisol Afternoon 6.9 2-4
Cortisol PM 1.3 <1.5
Epinephrine 8.5 8-11 daytime
Norepinephrine 36.5 35-45 daytime
Dopamine 76.4 125-175 daytime
Serotonin 60.5 125-175 daytime
GABA 3.9 1.5-4.0 daytime
Glutamate 38.1 15-35 daytime
PEA 108.6 30-70 daytime
Histamine 19.5 10-20 daytime

220
THE ORIGINAL INTERNIST Spring 2006 THE ORIGINAL INTERNIST DECEMBER 2009
05
The Leader in
Neurotransmitter Testing
& Nutritional Solutions

“Therapies guided by this testing


have changed the lives of many
patients in my practice.”
Eileen Wright, MD-Asheville, NC

Have YOU tried


neurotransmitter testing?
Neurotransmitter assessment is effective for
assessing common clinical complaints including
Depression, Anxiety, ADHD, Insomnia, and Fatigue.

• Guides Therapeutic Decisions

• Objective Patient Management

• Insurance Reimbursable

Improving Health Through The Nervous System


888-342-7272 • www.neuroscienceinc.com

MeNTION AD CODe inte1209 FOR A COMPlIMeNTARy


NeuROTRANsMITTeR TesT PROFIle (New ACCOuNTs ONly).
calculated from before-and-after CT scans of the heart)

Abstracts
were measured at baseline and at the completion of the
trial.

Key Findings: As a function of the combined use of

of Interest
statins plus supplements, TC declined by 24%, LDL
declined by 41%, TG declined by 42%, and HDL
increased by 19%. Except for the increase in HDL
observed in female subjects (11 mg/dL), these changes
attained statistical significance.

After 18 months, 20 of 45 subjects experienced an


average CCS decline (improvement) of 14.5%, and all
Supplements plus Statins Reduce a Prime Indicator but three of the remaining subjects experienced either
of Atherosclerosis--a Finding not Associated with no change in CCS or a relatively slow rate of progres-
Stand-Alone Statin Therapy sion (averaging 12%). A substantial decline in CCS
occurred in 44% of subjects and a slowed plaque
Author: Steve Austin, N.D. growth occurred in an additional 49%. These changes
in CCS were statistically significant when subjects
Reference: Davis W, Rockway S, Kwasny M. Effect were divided into three subgroups based upon the rate
of a combined therapeutic approach of intensive lipid of change in CCS: “typical” progression (>29%
management, omega-3 fatty acid supplementation, and progression per year), “slowed” progression (<29%
increased serum 25(OH) vitamin D on coronary cal- progression per year), and the combination of subjects
cium scores in asymptomatic adults. Am J Therapeutics showing no progression and those experiencing actual
2009;16:326−32. regression.

Design: Unblinded retrospective analysis of data from Practice Implications: Increasingly, researchers are
clinical interventions accepting CCS as an indicator of coronary risk and,
more specifically, atherosclerotic progression. When
Participants: 45 adults with coronary calcium scores administered alone, statin drugs lower cholesterol but
(CCS) ≥50 have not been found to reduce CCS or even slow its
progression, suggesting that these drugs may not be
Study Medication and Dosage: Subjects were halting atherosclerotic plaque formation. Despite this
encouraged to eat a low saturated fat, high-fiber, low- limitation, statin therapy has been shown to reduce
glycemic index diet. Statins doses were individually both the incidence of myocardial infarction and death
tailored to reduce LDL levels to a maximum of 60 mg/ from coronary artery disease. Nonetheless, the apparent
dL. (To meet this criterion, all female subjects and 77% inability of statins to improve CCS suggests that their
of male subjects required at least some use of statins.) therapeutic effect may not be optimal.
Most subjects also received time-release niacin at un-
specified doses. And what triggered the inclusion of these particular
nutritional supplements? Vitamin D was added because
Additional supplementation consisted of 2,000 IU/day the principle investigator had previously observed that
vitamin D3 initially, increased as needed to achieve 25 supplementation with vitamin D improved insulin
(OH)D3 serum levels between 50 and 60 ng/mL sensitivity while reducing C-reactive protein and TG
(average dose of vitamin D: 3,590 IU/day). Fish oil was (unpublished data). Related findings have also been
supplemented in varying doses (4–10 g/day; average reported by other researchers. Fish oil was added
dose: 4.8 g/day) to lower triglycerides (TG) to ≤60 mg/ primarily because of its proven ability to lower TG
dL. Fish oil supplements contained a minimum of 30% levels. Niacin is known to lower TC and LDL while
omega-3 fatty acids. A mean of 18 months occurred raising HDL. Niacin has also been reported to reduce
between the initial and final CT scan reports. coronary disease morbidity and mortality.

Primary Outcome Measures: Total cholesterol (TC), We still lack firm proof that improvements in CCS that
low-density lipoprotein cholesterol (LDL), high-density appear to result from the addition of niacin, vitamin D,
lipoprotein cholesterol (HDL), TG, and CCS (as and fish oil would translate into reductions in myocar-
(Continued on next page)
THE ORIGINAL INTERNIST
222 Spring 2006 THE ORIGINAL INTERNIST DECEMBER 2009 05
dial infarction rates or cardiovascular mortality beyond levels (P=0.003) compared with trivial declines in the
those expected to occur when statins are used as placebo group. Total mortality also declined by 36% in
stand-alone therapy. That said, however, the intriguing the group receiving RYR (P=0.003).
findings of the new report suggest that such may well
be the case. Practice Implications: RYR extracts are known to
reduce cholesterol levels in humans and have been
These new findings do not tell us which component or traditionally used in China to treat people with
components (niacin, fish oil, and/or vitamin D) are key cardiovascular disease. RYR naturally contains the
to halting the progression of atherosclerosis. Given that same molecule found in the prescription drug lov-
heart disease remains the leading killer of Americans astatin. Previous RYR research has focused primarily
and that improvements in CCS appear likely to reduce on cholesterol reduction, though some evidence for
cardiovascular disease risk, until we know more, reduction in inflammatory markers has also surfaced.
healthcare practitioners may wish to consider admini-
stration of this combined-therapy approach in the treat- The current trial goes several steps further, showing
ment of patients with risk factors for (or a history of) clinically (and statistically) significant reductions in
cardiovascular disease. ‹ coronary disease incidence and mortality. Hidden in the
data is a near-statistically significant (P=0.06) 37%
Red Yeast Rice Extract Lowers M.I. Incidence and reduction in the risk of stroke and a statistically signifi-
Mortality from Coronary Disease cant (P<0.04) reduction in total cancer incidence when
compared with the placebo group. No current
Author: Steve Austin, N.D. understanding of the effects of RYR clearly explains
these additional positive findings.
Reference: Li J-J, Lu Z-L, Kou W-R, et al. Beneficial
impact of Xuezhikang on cardiovascular events and One caveat requires mentioning: a previous report
mortality in elderly hypertensive patients with previous studying the pharmacokinetics of a related statin drug
myocardial infarction from the China Coronary found that area-under-the-curve response was twice as
Secondary Prevention Study (CCSPS). J Clin Pharma- great in Chinese subjects compared with white subjects
col 2009;49:947–56. (Clin Pharmacol Ther 2005;78:330–41). Should further
investigations confirm these findings in regard to
Design: Randomized double-blind intervention trial monacolins found in RYR, white (and potentially
black) patients might require significantly higher doses
Participants: 1530 elderly (≥65 years of age) of RYR to achieve the same clinical outcomes that
hypertensive subjects with a history of myocardial in- occurred in the new report, which studied Chinese
farction (MI) subjects. ‹

Study Medication and Dosage: Subjects received Green Tea Polyphenols lower PSA Levels in
either Xuezhikang, a red yeast rice (RYR) extract, Prostate Cancer Patients
administered as 600 mg b.i.d., or placebo for an
average of 4.5 years. Each 600 mg capsule of RYR Author: Steve Austin, N.D.
contained 2.5–3.2 mg of monacolin K plus “a small
quantity of lovastatin hydroxyl acid as well as Reference: McLarty J, Bigelow RLH, Smith M, et al.,
ergosterol and some other components.” Tea polyphenols decrease serum levels of
prostate-specific antigen, hepatocyte growth factor, and
Primary Outcome Measures: Recurrent coronary vascular endothelial growth factor in vitro. Cancer
events Prev Res 2009;2:674–82.

Key Findings: Compared with the placebo group, there Design: Unblinded intervention trial
was a 38% reduced risk of suffering a coronary event
(primarily MIs) (P=0.0009). Similarly there was a 29% Participants: 26 men with recently diagnosed stage I,
reduced risk of dying from coronary disease during the II, or III prostate cancer (CA), all scheduled for radical
course of the trial (P=0.05). Secondary endpoints prostatectomy.
revealed a 21% decline in LDL levels in the RYR
group (P=0.0001) and a 12% decline in triglyceride Study Medication and Dosage: Polyphenon E, a green
(Continued on next page)
THE ORIGINAL INTERNIST DECEMBER 2009 223
THE SOURCE FOR
Integrative
Healthcare Professionals
Over 14,000 products from industry leading manufacturers
Vitamins • Herbs • Homeopathics • Nutritional Supplements
Acupuncture Products • Chinese Herbal Medicine
Medical Supplies and more

24/7 ordering available at www.emersonecologics.com

Nationwide delivery in 2 business days or less – Guaranteed

A commitment to quality and education

One call, one order. Saving you time and money!

1.800.654.4432

www.emersonecologics.com
Key Code: EOI39
tea extract that delivered 1.3 g/day total polyphenols virtually all markers tracked by these researchers
including 800 mg/day epigallocatechin-3-gallate moved in the direction of safety and most of these
(EGCG) was given to all subjects in the form of four changes attained statistical significance.
capsules taken during one meal each day up until the
time of surgery (a median of 34.5 days). What are clinicians to do with these new findings? As
long as liver enzymes are monitored to insure the same
Main Outcome Measures: Prostate-specific antigen level of safety reported in the current trial (though not
(PSA), insulin-like growth factor I, and additional in all previous reports), it may be time for healthcare
biomarkers of prostate CA status professionals to tell their prostate CA patients about
these new findings, which suggest the potential (though
Key Findings: PSA levels declined by 10.4% not yet proof of) significant anti-cancer effects from
(P=0.01). In the subgroup of subjects taking the extract green tea extracts containing appropriate amounts of
for longer than the median time (>34.5 days), 85% polyphenols.‹
experienced a decline in PSA compared with 64% of
those taking the extract for shorter periods of time, Nutrients for Migraine Prevention
though this difference did not attain statistical signifi-
cance. by Alan R. Gaby, M.D.

Insulin-like growth factor I declined by 11% (P=0.02). More than 10% of Americans suffer from migraines.
Other prostate CA markers declined by 3 –19% and Even the most effective medications prescribed for
each of these changes also attained statistical signifi- migraine prophylaxis reduce migraine frequency by no
cance (P values varying from 0.03 to <0.001). more than 50%, and many of these drugs are associated
with significant side effects. Safer and more effective
ways of preventing and treating migraines are therefore
Cases of hepatotoxicity have previously surfaced in
needed.
regard to green tea polyphenols. However, liver
enzymes and other markers of hepatic function (which
Mitochondrial energy production appears to be im-
were tracked because of this concern) actually declined
paired in people with recurrent migraines, and this im-
during the trial; five of these reductions reached statisti-
pairment might play a role in the pathogenesis of mi-
cal significance.
graines. Nutrients that are involved in energy produc-
tion might therefore be beneficial. Magnesium is a co-
Practice Implications: EGCG has inhibited prostate factor for the synthesis of adenosine triphosphate
CA cells in vitro. Though epidemiologic data remain (ATP), the body's main storage form of energy.
mixed, three years ago, an Italian research group Riboflavin (in the form of flavin adenine dinucleotide
reported that consumption of green tea polyphenols [FAD]) and coenzyme Q10 are cofactors in the electron-
delayed progression of high-grade prostatic intraepithe- transport chain, a biochemical cascade that culminates
lial neoplasia (Cancer Res 2006;66:1234–40). in ATP synthesis. Each of these three nutrients has
been shown in clinical trials to decrease the recurrence
Why might green tea polyphenols have anticancer ef- rate of migraines.
fects? Hepatocyte growth factor (HGF)/c-Met signaling
pathway is disturbed in a wide variety of cancers Magnesium
including prostate CA. Increasingly, researchers be-
lieve that inhibition of this pathway should increase life Eighty-one migraine sufferers were randomly assigned
expectancy in CA patients. Green tea polyphenols had to receive, in double-blind fashion, 600 mg per day of
an inhibitory effect in the current trial. magnesium or placebo for 12 weeks. During the last
four weeks of the study, as compared with baseline, the
Other markers of prostate CA status or progression mean frequency of migraines was reduced by 42% in
have also recently been found to either increase prolif- the magnesium group and by 16% in the placebo group
eration of CA cells or interfere with apoptosis. The (p < 0.04 for the difference in the change between
authors of the current trial measured these newer groups). Adverse effects of magnesium were diarrhea
markers along with PSA scores in hopes that green tea in 18.6% of patients and gastric irritation in 4.7%.1 In
polyphenols would alter markers in directions compati- other research, effective migraine prophylaxis was
ble with CA regression. It’s exciting to note that achieved with a magnesium dose of 360 mg per day,2
(Continued on next page)

THE ORIGINAL INTERNIST DECEMBER 2009 225


which is less likely than the higher dose to produce to lower homocysteine levels) resulted in a complete
gastrointestinal side effects. cessation of migraine attacks in 10 of 16 children and
substantial improvement in each of the others. Plasma
Riboflavin homocysteine levels became normal in all 16 patients.5
While it was not clear whether elevated homocysteine
Fifty-five migraine patients were randomly assigned to per se, was the cause of the migraines, another study
receive, in double-blind fashion, 400 mg of riboflavin also found that treatment with homocysteine-lowering
once a day or placebo for three months. In intent-to- nutrients (folic acid, vitamin B6, and vitamin B12)
treat analysis, riboflavin was superior to placebo in markedly reduced headache frequency in patients with
reducing attack frequency (p = 0.005) and number of elevated homocysteine levels. Based on these
headache days (p = 0.012). The proportion of patients observations, it would seem worthwhile to measure
who experienced at least a 50% reduction in the plasma homocysteine levels in migraine patients and to
number of headache days was 59% for riboflavin and recommend B-vitamin supplementation for those with
15% for placebo (p = 0.002). Three minor adverse elevated levels.
events occurred, two in the riboflavin group (diarrhea
and polyuria) and one in the placebo group.3 Other treatments

The dose of riboflavin used in this study was about 400 Other treatments that have been found to be effective
times as much as the amount present in a typical diet. for preventing migraines include identification and
Uncontrolled trials from the 1940s and 1950s suggest avoidance of allergenic foods, quitting smoking,
that lower doses of riboflavin (such as 5-10 mg three stopping the use of oral contraceptives, and administra-
times per day) can also prevent migraine recurrences. tion of certain herbal remedies (i.e., feverfew and
While high-dose riboflavin has not been associated butterbur).
with significant toxicity in short-term studies, it has the
potential to act as a photo-sensitizer or to cause References
imbalances of other nutrients. Therefore, it would seem
prudent to reserve high-dose riboflavin for patients who 1) Peikert A, Wilimzig C, Kohne-Volland R. Prophy-
do not respond to moderate doses. laxis of migraine with oral magnesium: results
from a prospective, multi-center, placebo-
Coenzyme Q10 controlled and double-blind randomized study.
Cephalalgia 1996;16:257-263.
Forty-two migraine patients were randomly assigned to 2) Facchinetti F, Sances G, Borella P, Gonazzani AR,
receive, in double-blind fashion, 100 mg of coenzyme Nappi G. Magnesium prophylaxis of menstrual
Q10 three times per day or placebo for four months. The migraine: effects on intracellular magnesium.
proportion of patients who had a 50%-or-greater Headache 1991;31:298-304.
reduction in attack frequency during the fourth month 3) Schoenen J, Jacquy J, Lenaerts M. Effectiveness of
compared with baseline was 48% in the coenzyme Q10 high-dose riboflavin in migraine prophylaxis. A
group and 14% in the placebo group (p = 0.02). The randomized controlled trial. Neurology
mean reduction in attack frequency was 27% in the co- 1998;50:466-470.
enzyme Q10 group and 2% in the placebo group 4) Sandor PS, Di Clemente L, Coppola G, Saenger U,
(p < 0.05 for the difference in the change between Fumal A, Magis D, et al. Efficacy of coenzyme
groups).4 Q10 in migraine prophylaxis: a randomized con-
trolled trial. Neurology 2005;64:713-715.
B Vitamins, Homocysteine, and Migraines 5) Di Rosa G, Attina S, Spano M, Ingegneri G, Sgro
DL, Pustorino G, et al. Efficacy of folic acid in
Polymorphisms of the 5,10-methylenetetrahydrofolate children with migraine, hyperhomocysteinemia and
reductase gene (mainly homozygosity for 677C → T) MTHFR polymorphisms. Headache 2007;47:1342-
that are associated with reduced enzyme activity and 1344.
moderate hyperhomocysteinemia have been found to be 6) Lea R, Colson N, Quinlan S, Macmillan J, Griffiths
common in migraine patients. In one study, 16 of 22 L. The effects of vitamin supplementation and
children with recurrent migraines without aura had one MTHFR (C677T) genotype on homocysteine-
of these polymorphisms. In those children, supplemen- lowering and migraine disability. Pharmacogenet
tation with 5 mg per day of folic acid (which is known Genomics 2009;19:422-428.‹

THE ORIGINAL INTERNIST


226 Spring 2006 THE ORIGINAL INTERNIST DECEMBER 2009
05
DABCIs and Where They Are
ALABAMA Dr. Rita Cummings IDAHO Dr. Frank Strehl Dr. H.M. Chalker
Dr. Reginald Hug* Denver, CO Dr. Uma Mulnick Wheaton, IL Meade, KS
Birmingham, AL McCall, ID
Dr. Paula Dechert Dr. Melanie Tiahrt* Dr. Dustin Cheney
ALASKA Denver, CO ILLINOIS Alton, IL Phillipsburg, KS
Dr. David Mulholland Dr. Delilah Anderson
Anchorage, AK Dr. Lewis Holm Sandwich, IL Dr. Steven Zaeske Dr. Rod Clements
Littleton, CO Orland Park, IL Eldorado, KS
Dr. Stan Throckmorton Dr. Jeffrey Bergin
Anchorage, AK Dr. William Kleber Lindenhurst, IL Dr. Alex Zevan,III Dr. Paul Hughes
Berthoud, CO Bloomingdale, IL Edgerton, KS
ARIZONA Dr. Stephen Boudro
Dr. R. Michael Cessna* Dr. Reiner Kremer Elmhurst, IL INDIANA Dr. Tobi Jeurink
Tucson, AZ Franktown, CO Dr. John Bernzott Gardner, KS
Dr. Sharon DeFrain Connersville, IN
Dr. Steven Lokken Peotone, IL Dr. Christena Nicholson
Dr. Laura Frey
Colorado Springs, CO Dr. Thomas Jansen Overland Park, KS
Tucson, AZ
Dr. Mete Durum Kendalville, IN
Dr. Duane Lowe Arlington Heights, IL Dr. Janie Pirner
Dr. Timothy Gerhart
Colorado Springs, CO Dr. William Lyden Wichita, KS
Glendale, AZ
Dr. Raymond Ferre Mishawaka, IN
Dr. David Paradiso Decatur, IL Dr. Ron Young
Dr. Kellie Gray
Colorado Springs, CO Dr. Brian McGuckin Salina, KS
Glendale, AZ
Dr. Mark Fredrick Valparaiso, IN
Dr. Michael Stone Dr. Philip Pollock Gurnee, IL LOUISIANA
Tucson, AZ Sterling, CO Dr. Robert Prather Dr. Robert W. Smith
Dr. David Hepler Indianapolis, IN Baton Rouge, LA
Dr. Deborah Riekman Lincoln, IL
ARKANSAS
Colorado Springs, CO IOWA MARYLAND
Dr. Lance Clouse
Dr. William Hogan Dr. Gary Bowden Dr. Wayne Sodano
Van Buren, AR Dr. Thomas Turner Lombard, IL McGregor, IA Bel Air, MD
Boulder, CO
Dr. Douglas Smiley* Dr. Lester Holze, Jr.
Siloam Springs, AR Dr. Darlene Ehlers MICHIGAN
Dr. Michael Vanaria Elgin, IL Tipton, IA Dr. Daniel M. McGregor
Boulder, CO
CALIFORNIA Prudenville, MI
Dr. Cindy Howard Dr. Robert Friedrichs
Dr. Jan Dooley Dr. Brian Wilson Orland Park, IL Mason City, IA MINNESOTA
Arcata, CA Englewood, CO
Dr. Frederick Hult Dr. Jeffrey Anderson
Dr. Jeffrey Greene Dr. Tracy A. Stomgren Edina, MN
CONNECTICUT McHenry, IL Glenwood, IA
Los Angeles, CA Dr. Paul DiDomizio
Dr. Grant Iannelli Dr. Robert Bergan
Dr. Jill Jordan Wolcott, CT Dr. Lynn Theesfield
Lombard, IL Minneapolis, MN
Carlsbad, CA Ames, IA
FLORIDA Dr. Timothy Bertsch
Dr. John Findlay Dr. Harry Jensen Dr. Zach Watkins
Dr. Andrew Lucas Champlin, MN
W. Palm Beach, FL Sterling, IL Johnston, IA
Riverside, CA
Dr. Thomas Jensen Dr. Linda Bowers
Dr. Kathleen Power Dr. David Frerking Dr. Anita Wubenna Bloomington, MN
Tavares, FL Sterling, IL Parkview, IA
Pasadena, CA
Dr. Theodore Johnson Dr. Russell DesMarais
Dr. Rowen Richardson Dr. Marguerite Gerger KANSAS St. Paul, MN
Clearwater, FL Chicago, IL
Glendora, CA Dr. Mark Albers
Dr. James McGinn, Jr. Wichita, KS Dr. Joel Eichers
Dr. Scott Soluk Dr. Janice Piro Chanhassen, MN
Palm Harbor, FL Crystal Lake, IL
Los Angeles, CA Dr. Lynn Betz
Dr. Anthony Pantanella Auburn, KS Dr. John Gerber
Dr. Sylvie Wellhausen Dr. Susan Player Blaine, MN
Clearwater, FL Hoffman Estates, IL
Loma Linda, CA Dr. Ben Bowers
Wichita, KS Dr. Timothy Gerhart
Dr. Kelly Worth Dr. John Podlaski Dr. Michael Poierier
Red Wing, MN
Orange, CA Ocala, FL Lombard, IL
Dr. Richard Brown
Olathe, KS Dr. Jedidiah Krauss
COLORADO GEORGIA Dr. Robert Pyne, Jr.
St. Louis Park, MN
Dr. John Baer Dr. Larry Haberski Palos Hills, IL
Dr. Susan Buchanan-Cheney
Englewood, CO Stone Mountain, GA Phillipsburg, KS Dr. Mac Beth Lindstrom
Dr. William Shelton
Slayton, MN
Dr. Debra Carpenter Dr. Edward Kaszans Lombard, IL
Dr. Ralph Cardin
Pueblo West, CO Brunswick, GA Overland Park, KS Dr. Todd McGillick
Dr. Douglas Stam
Gaylord, MN
Dr. Terry Collinson Bourbonnais, IL
Colorado Springs, CO (Continued on next page)
* Retired DABCI Practitioner
THE ORIGINAL INTERNIST DECEMBER 2009 227
DABCIs and Where They Are
Dr. Thomas Miller Dr. Robert Wiehe Dr. Mark Yeager Dr. Mark Homison Dr. Joe Lindley
Coon Rapids, MN West Plains, MO Charlotte, NC Cranberry Township, PA Houston, TX

Dr. Joseph Muldoon NEW JERSEY OHIO Dr. John LaHoda Dr. Tim McCullough
Slayton, MN Dr. Jon Mastrobattista Dr. Robert Gilbert Richboro, PA Houston, TX
Bernardville, NJ Mansfield, OH
Dr. Brenwyn Peddycoat Dr. Fredrick Osterberg Dr. Zachery McVey
White Bear Lake, MN Dr. Perry Ricci Dr. Mark McAdoo Red Lion, PA League City, TX
Egg Harbor City, NJ Athens, OH
Dr. Gregory Peterson SOUTH CAROLINA Dr. Gregory Mrozinski
Winona, MN NEW MEXICO Dr. Van Merkle Dr. Jon Bergrin Houston, TX
Dr. John Dalton Dayton, OH Florence, SC
Dr. Dane Roubos Roswell, NM Dr. Mike Prioux
Bloomington, MN OKLAHOMA Dr. Bruce Gwinnup Friendswood, TX
Dr. John H. Gelhot Dr. Stephanie Clay Charleston, SC
Dr. Sandra Spore Bartlesville, OK Dr. V.M. Thompsom
Albuquerque, NM
Stillwater, MN Dr. Peter Kfoury Arlington, TX
Dr. Shereen Jegtvig Dr. Gerry Langston Charleston, SC
Dr. Leslie Stewart UTAH
Albuquerque, NM Tulsa, OK
St. Paul, MN Dr. Morgan Kutzner Dr. Don Vradenburg
NEW YORK Dr. Richard Santelli Greenville, SC St. George, UT
Dr. Charles Strauman
Dr. Ronald Safko Bethany, OK
St. Louis Park, MN
New York City, NY Dr. Jacqueline McKool VIRGINIA
Dr. Michael Taylor Charleston, SC Dr. Robert Duca
Dr. Terese Tomanek
Dr. John Zilliox Tulsa, OK Dunn Loring, VA
Duluth, MN
Amherst, NY Dr. Robert Pascal
Dr. Timothy Whelan OREGON Charleston, SC Dr. Guntrang Khalsa
New Hope, MN NEVADA Dr. Daniel Beeson Herndon, VA
Dr. Howard Balduc Portland, OR Dr. Virginia Samuel
Dr. Jon Williams Las Vegas, NV Columbia, SC WASHINGTON
Bloomington, MN Dr. David Braman Dr. H. Earl Moore
Dr. Craig Roles Tuelatin, OR SOUTH DAKOTA Spokane, WA
MISSOURI Henderson, NV Dr. Roger Bommersbach
Dr. Kathleen M. Galligan Brookings, SD WISCONSIN
Dr. David Clark
NORTH CAROLINA Oregon City, OR Dr. Leslie Best
Oak Grove, MO
Dr. William R. Armstrong Dr. Roger Prill Madison, WI
Dr. Edward M. Geller Mitchell, SD
Dr. Charles Eckert Laurenburg, NC
Medford, OR Dr. Barbara Bradley
Raymore, MO
Dr. Phillip Arnone Dr. David Schwierert Wausau, WI
Dr. Usha Honeyman Rapid City, SD
Dr. Jack Kessinger Matthews, NC Corvallis, OR
Rolla, MO Dr. Kevin Branham
Dr. Stephen Button TENNESSEE Eagle River, WI
Dr. Steven Lumsden Dr. William Strauss
Dr. Jay Kessinger Mount Airy, NC Gresham, OR
Rolla, MO Lebanon, TN Dr. Bernie Finch
Dr. Karen Carrick Pepin, WI
Dr. Scott Northrup
Dr. Kelley Kirchner Raleigh, NC TEXAS
Brookings, OR Dr. Gwendolyn Gauerke
Kahoka, MO Dr. Edward Brown
Dr. Rick Davis Dallas, TX Iola, WI
Dr. Kristopher Peterson
Dr. Mable Leckrone Conover, NC Hermiston, OR
Dr. Ralph Burton Dr. Craig Gilbaugh
Liberty, MO
Dr. Nikolas R. Hedberg Kennedale, TX Ashland, WI
Dr. Thomas Richards
Dr. Duane Lowe Asheville, NC Beaverton, OR
Dr. Lance Carlton-Durrett Dr. Kathleen Maedke
Maplewood, MO
Dr. Dean Kenny The Woodlands, TX Milwaukee, WI
Dr. James Siegel
Dr. Terry Nelson High Point, NC Canyonville, OR
Dr. Janie Duke Dr. Cheryl Metzler
Independence, MO
Dr. Sandrine Martin Plano, TX Green Bay, WI
Dr. Mark Thomas
Dr. R Vincent Satterwhite Cornelius, NC Cottage Grove, OR
Dr. Steve Grimm Dr. Gina R. Schultz
Kansas City, MO
Dr. Barbara Saunders San Antonio, TX Blanchardville, WI
Dr. David Wickes
Dr. Jeremy Thornton Garner, NC Portland, OR
Dr. Doreen Lewis-Overstrom Dr. David A. Sommerfield
Stockton, MO Rice Lake, WI
Dr. Todd Smith San Antonio, TX
PENNSYLVANIA
Dr. Jeffrey S. Ware Winston-Salem, NC Dr. Bruce Fink Dr. Dean Willhite
Lake St. Louis, MO Coudersport, PA Manitowoc, WI

THE ORIGINAL INTERNIST


228 Spring 2006 THE ORIGINAL INTERNIST DECEMBER 2009
05
Douglas Laboratories Presents... ®

Ubiquinol-QH
With ®
technology

raising the standard for optimal cardiovascular support.†

Ubiquinol plays an important role in


antioxidant, energy and cardiovascular Coenzyme Q10 (CoQ10) is
function, and may be of special importance produced by the human body
for older adults in supporting the normal aging and is necessary for the basic
process. Ubiquinone (also known as coenzyme functioning of cells.
Q10) is typically converted in the body into
—Mayo Clinic
ubiquinol, but recent studies indicate that as
people age, the body’s ability to make this
conversion declines. To offset this decline,
our unique Ubiquinol-QH utilizes patented
VESIsorb technology to form a nano-colloid
®

delivery system that results in enhanced


solubility and absorption of ubiquinol.

† These statements have not been evaluated by the Food and Drug Administration. This product is not intended to diagnose, treat, cure, or prevent any disease.

Contact us today: at 1-888-DOUGLAB (1-888-368-4522) or 1-800-245-4440 (US) 1-866-856-9954 (CAN)


www.douglaslabs.com www.douglaslabs.ca
600 Boyce Road • Pittsburgh, PA 15205, U.S.A
CLINT PUBLICATIONS PRSRT STD
US POSTAGE
720 OAK KNOLL
ROLLA, MO 65401 PAID
ROLLA, MO
PERMIT NO. 2

STAY INFORMED
ON THE LATEST IN
NATURAL HEALTH CARE
Subscribe to The Original Internist for only $50 annually
Name _____________________________________________________________________________

Address ___________________________________________________________________________

City _________________________________________ State _________ Zip ___________________

Phone ______________________ Fax ______________________ E-mail ______________________

† Check enclosed † Bill my Visa/Master Card † Bill my American Express

Credit Card Number ________________________________________ Expiration Date ___________


Please return to Clint Publications, 720 Oak Knoll, Rolla, MO 65401 or call (573) 341-8448

Вам также может понравиться