14/03/2020 WhatsApp fake news during Brazil election ‘favoured Bolsonaro’ | World news | The Guardian

This article is more than 4 months old

WhatsApp fake news during Brazil election ‘favoured

Bolsonaro’
Analysis suggests vast majority of viral messages with false information were rightwing

Daniel Avelar
Wed 30 Oct 2019 16.00 GMT

The vast majority of false information shared on WhatsApp in Brazil during the presidential
election favoured the far-right winner, Jair Bolsonaro, a Guardian analysis of data suggests.

The analysis sheds light on the spread of misinformation on the Facebook-owned app, with
fears it could be poisoning political debate in one of the largest democracies in the world.

In a sample of 11,957 viral messages shared across 296 group chats on the instant-messaging
platform in the campaign period, approximately 42% of rightwing items contained
information found to be false by factcheckers. Less than 3% of the leftwing messages analysed
in the study contained externally verified falsehoods.

The figures suggest the spread of fake news was highly asymmetrical, accounting for much of
the content being spread by and to Bolsonaro supporters on WhatsApp.

The instant messaging app is very popular in Brazil, with more than 120 million users in a
population of about 210 million people.
https://www.theguardian.com/world/2019/oct/30/whatsapp-fake-news-brazil-election-favoured-jair-bolsonaro-analysis-suggests 1/4
14/03/2020 WhatsApp fake news during Brazil election ‘favoured Bolsonaro’ | World news | The Guardian

Much of the fake news shared on WhatsApp reflected the far-right values promoted by
Bolsonaro’s team during the two-month campaign. Almost all the major rightwing fake news
stories fell into four categories, the analysis reveals:

Up to 48% of the rightwing items containing externally verified falsehoods mentioned a

fictional plot to fraudulently manipulate the electronic ballot system, echoing conspiracy
theories promoted by Bolsonaro’s team and casting suspicion on the democratic process.
Another 19% of the messages promoted misleading information about a stabbing attack
against Bolsonaro in early September 2018. The stabbing, which forced the far-right leader to
spend most of the remaining weeks of the campaign in hospital, was a turning point in the
election.
Sixteen per cent of right-leaning false content tried to dismiss the political system and
mainstream media as corrupt, reflecting key elements of Bolsonaro’s anti-establishment
rhetoric.
A further 14% of the viral falsehoods targeted leftwing politicians and activists, often using
homophobic tropes and anti-feminist slurs.
Content exchanged on WhatsApp is protected with end-to-end encryption, so the study
collected a sample of messages from WhatsApp Monitor, a database of viral content shared in
hundreds of groups focused on political debate. Due to these sampling limitations, the
research cannot be generalised to explain the behaviour of all WhatsApp users in Brazil.

WhatsApp executives recently acknowledged Brazilian accounts were the target of massive
spamming operations by digital marketing agencies before the election, in a breach of the app’s
terms and conditions.

Inquiries in Brazil’s congress and superior electoral court are examining whether Bolsonaro’s
team was involved in these manipulative efforts. The investigations could potentially lead to
the annulment of the election result.

The Bolsonaro administration denies wrongdoing and has repeatedly dismissed media reports
on the issue as “fake news”.

Facebook, which has been under increasing pressure to do more to tackle misinformation,
announced an update of WhatsApp in January that reduced to the number of times users can
forward a single message to five.

Recent studies suggested the upgrades succeeded in slowing the spread of false content, but
failed to stop fake news reaching large audiences.

According to Caio Machado, a computational propaganda specialist at the Oxford Internet

Institute, social media platforms are struggling to cope with “democracy-hacking strategies”.

He added: “Tech companies have an immense power in their hands, and no one knows
whether or not they are actually capable of influencing election results.”

A WhatsApp spokeswoman pointed to changes such as labels showing forwarded messages,

the limit on forwarding messages, banning spam accounts using machine learning and
improved safety and privacy settings.

“WhatsApp has made significant product changes and worked with partners across civil
society to help address the harmful consequences of misinformation,” she said.

Since you’re here...

https://www.theguardian.com/world/2019/oct/30/whatsapp-fake-news-brazil-election-favoured-jair-bolsonaro-analysis-suggests 2/4
14/03/2020 WhatsApp fake news during Brazil election ‘favoured Bolsonaro’ | World news | The Guardian

… we’re asking readers, like you, to make a contribution in support of the Guardian’s open,
independent journalism. This is turning into a turbulent year with a succession of international
crises. The Guardian is in every corner of the globe, calmly reporting with tenacity, rigour and
authority on the most critical events of our lifetimes. At a time when factual information is
both scarcer and more essential than ever, we believe that each of us deserves access to
accurate reporting with integrity at its heart.

More people than ever before are reading and supporting our journalism, in more than 180
countries around the world. And this is only possible because we made a different choice: to
keep our reporting open for all, regardless of where they live or what they can afford to pay.

We have upheld our editorial independence in the face of the disintegration of traditional
media – with social platforms giving rise to misinformation, the seemingly unstoppable rise of
big tech and independent voices being squashed by commercial ownership. The Guardian’s
independence means we can set our own agenda and voice our own opinions. Our journalism
is free from commercial and political bias – never influenced by billionaire owners or
shareholders. This makes us different. It means we can challenge the powerful without fear
and give a voice to those less heard.

None of this would have been attainable without our readers’ generosity – your financial
support has meant we can keep investigating, disentangling and interrogating. It has protected
our independence, which has never been so critical. We are so grateful.

We need your support so we can keep delivering quality journalism that’s open and
independent. And that is here for the long term. Every reader contribution, however big or
small, is so valuable. Support The Guardian today from as little as £1 – and it only takes a
minute. Thank you. Support the Guardian from as little as $1 – and it only takes a minute.
Thank you.

https://www.theguardian.com/world/2019/oct/30/whatsapp-fake-news-brazil-election-favoured-jair-bolsonaro-analysis-suggests 3/4
14/03/2020 WhatsApp fake news during Brazil election ‘favoured Bolsonaro’ | World news | The Guardian

Support The Guardian

Topics
Jair Bolsonaro
Brazil
Americas
WhatsApp
Facebook
news

https://www.theguardian.com/world/2019/oct/30/whatsapp-fake-news-brazil-election-favoured-jair-bolsonaro-analysis-suggests 4/4