Вы находитесь на странице: 1из 6

15 (4): 2-xxx (2008) Preprint web release / Parution Internet préimpression

15 (4): 2-xxx
2008-10-31
(2008)

Correlations of biotic and abiotic variables


with ground surface temperature:
An ectothermic perspective1
Glenn M. CUNNINGTON2, James SCHAEFER, Joseph E. CEBEK & Dennis MURRAY,
Department of Biology, Trent University, 1600 West Bank Drive, Peterborough, Ontario K9J 7B8, Canada.

Abstract: Temperature is often an important determinant of species presence and activity patterns, but observations of
temperature at fine resolution and broad extents—scales relevant to individual organisms—are rare. We analyzed how biotic
and abiotic variables influence ground surface temperature (GST) using high-resolution thermal data for a 1900-ha area of
forest and field near Wasaga Beach, Ontario, Canada. Temperature was recorded at 2-h intervals from May to October, 2004
and 2005, from data loggers approximately 300 m apart. At the same sites, we recorded overstory and understory vegetation,
elevation, and distances to the nearest road and urban infrastructure. Correspondence Analysis (CA) indicated that thermal
conditions varied most strongly seasonally and diurnally. Canonical Correspondence Analysis (CCA) pinpointed which
biotic and abiotic variables were related to surface temperature. Canopy cover and leaf litter cover were positively related to
cool sites during both cool and warm periods. Sites close to urban areas and roads were warmer than those further away from
these features. As thermally variable environments affect the physiology, behaviour, and ecology of ectothermic species,
determination of variables that affect GST provides a more comprehensive depiction of habitat for these species.
Keywords: abiotic, biotic, ectotherm, ground surface temperature, habitat, urban heat island, hognose snake.

Résumé : La température est souvent un déterminant important de la présence d’espèces et de leurs patrons d’activité, mais
les observations de température à résolution fine sur de grandes étendues — les échelles appropriées aux organismes
individuels — sont rares. Nous avons analysé comment les variables biotiques et abiotiques influencent la température de
surface du sol en utilisant des données thermiques à haute résolution pour une aire de 1900 ha de champs et de forêts près
Wasaga Beach, Ontario, Canada. Des enregistreurs électroniques de données espacés d’environ 300 m ont mesuré la température
à chaque 2 heures entre mai et octobre en 2004 et 2005. Aux mêmes sites, nous avons noté la végétation de la canopée et du
sous-étage, l’élévation et la distance à la route et à l’infrastructure urbaine la plus proche. L’analyse des correspondances a
indiqué que les conditions thermiques ont varié de façon la plus importante au sein de la saison et de la journée. L’analyse
canonique des correspondances a identifié précisément quelles variables biotiques et abiotiques étaient reliées à la température
de surface. Le couvert forestier et la couverture de détritus de feuilles étaient reliés de façon positive aux sites frais durant les
périodes tant fraîches que chaudes. Les sites près des zones urbaines et des routes étaient plus chauds que ceux plus éloignés de
ces éléments. Puisque des environnements thermiques variables ont un effet sur la physiologie, le comportement et l’écologie
des espèces ectothermes, la détermination des variables influençant la température de surface du sol permet une description
plus complète de l’habitat de ces espèces.
Mots-clés : abiotique, biotique, couleuvre à nez retroussé, ectotherme, habitat, îlot de chaleur urbain, température de surface
du sol.

Introduction
Ecosystems are influenced by numerous biotic and driven interest in broad-scale GST (Nelson, Siegel & Yoder,
abiotic variables (Saunders et al., 1998). The realization of 2004). Expensive temperature data logger equipment in
conservation goals requires an understanding of the manner the form of national weather stations has been utilized for
in which these environmental variables influence the abil- decades (Changnon, 1999; Jarvis & Stuart, 2001; Arnfield,
ity of species to exist (Corney et al., 2004). Temperature 2003; Englehart & Douglas, 2003; Corney et al., 2004), but
is often included in studies of environmental variables technological advancements in the form of mobile thermal
that affect species presence and activity patterns; how- data loggers have allowed biologists to ask questions at fine
ever, Jarvis and Stuart (2001) indicated that there is a scales, pertinent to habitat use of some species. Such inves-
surprising lack of studies that focus on the determination tigations were logistically impossible in the past (Angilletta
of temperature at both high resolution and large extents. & Krochmal, 2003).
Climatic modeling and the determination of ground surface As GST varies both spatially and temporally, the deri-
temperature (GST) from satellite imagery historically have vation of spatially distributed models can be problematic
because of both theoretical complexity and data availability
1Rec. 2007-09-20; acc. 2008-04-14. (Jarvis & Stuart, 2001). Lewis (1998) indicated that differ-
Associate Editor: Christian Messier. ences in GST in a single year stemmed from both biotic and
2 Author for correspondence. Ottawa-Carleton Institute of Biology, Carleton

University, 1125 Colonel By Drive, Ottawa, Ontario K1S 5B6, Canada, e-mail: glenn.
abiotic features. Abiotic variables are often drivers of further
cunnington@gmail.com ecosystem and landscape-level processes, such as species
DOI 10.2980/15-4-3140 distributions, plant growth, and nutrient cycling (Saunders
ÉCOSCIENCE, vol. 15 (4), 2008

et al., 1999). Alteration of the landscape through natural or apart in a grid. The data loggers were deployed with a GPS
anthropogenic events may also influence the thermal condi- unit (Garmin 72, Olathe, Kansas, USA; accuracy ± 4 m),
tions at a site (Saunders et al., 1998). Determination of the and the iButton locations were mapped electronically using
variables that affect GST would thus provide a basis to infer ArcView 3.2 (Environmental Systems Research Institute,
potential ecological effects of both natural and anthropo- 1999a). To determine if the iButton temperatures accu-
genic processes. rately reflected ambient conditions a single iButton was
There have been few fine-scale studies that have uti- placed adjacent to the weather station. Data collected by the
lized small electronic devices to gather extensive thermal weather station and adjacent iButton were analyzed with a
data (Halley, Eriksson & Nunez, 2003). Newmark (2005) correlation analysis.
utilized a limited number of electronic data loggers to deter- Vegetation surveys were conducted in plots (of 1 and
mine differences in the diurnal thermal regime between 5 m radius) centred on each data logger location. These data
forest edge and interior. These devices are often expensive included elements assumed to affect the thermal conditions
(Angilletta & Krochmal, 2003) and utilized only in small on the ground surface (Table I; Nielson, 1985; Lewis, 1998;
numbers (Newmark, 2005). When such devices are not Halley, Eriksson & Nunez, 2003). Vegetation surveys were
available, fine-scale studies rely on point sampling in lim- conducted in June and July of 2004 and 2005.
ited quantities (Stabler, Martin & Brazel, 2004). Additional variables were determined with GIS (Table I).
Given that temperature plays a significant ecological ASPECT was calculated on a scale of 1 to 180, with 1
role in the life history of many species, especially ecto- representing north and 180 representing south; east and
therms, it is important to establish what variables affect west were given equal values (90). ELEVATION, ROAD,
surface temperature (Jarvis & Stuart, 2001). We tested the and URBAN were calculated with the ArcView 3.2
hypothesis that biotic factors, such as canopy cover and Geoprocessing extension. SLOPE was produced with Spatial
ground vegetation, lower GST, while abiotic factors, like Analyst (Environmental Systems Research Institute, 1999b).
urban features and roads, increase GST. Canopy cover may Multivariate statistical analyses were carried out using MVSP
act to reduce the effects of climatic heating events by shift- (Kovach Computing Services, 2006).
ing the thermally active surface vertically from the ground Temperature data collected by iButton data loggers were
surface (Oke, 1997). Thus, we anticipated that temperature analyzed with Correspondence Analysis (CA) to determine
at locations further from anthropogenic influences would be how season and time of day affected site-specific tempera-
driven by biotic variables and would be cooler, while areas tures in 2004 and 2005. To illustrate how CA extracted tem-
closer to anthropogenic features would experience higher poral variation in temperature, extreme sites were selected
temperatures than those farther away. We then considered confirm the axes interpretation. Data were also analyzed
the implications of these results for an ectotherm, the east- with Canonical Correspondence Analysis (CCA) to deter-
ern hog-nosed snake (Heterodon platirhinos), a threatened mine which biotic and abiotic variables were related to
species in our study area (Cunnington & Cebek, 2005).
Table I. Environmental variables used in the analysis of ground
Methods surface temperature.

Field data were collected over 2 seasons, May to Source Variable Description
October 2004 and May to October 2005, in a 1900-ha Plot1 CANOPY Canopy closure (%)
site near the town of Wasaga Beach, Ontario (44°  30' n, Plot1 LEAF Coverage (%) of leaf litter
80° 01' w). Wasaga Beach is located on Georgian Bay on Plot1 LOG Coverage (%) of downed woody debris
Lake Huron. Given its wide variety of vegetative communi- (> 5 cm diameter)
Plot1 VEG Coverage (%) of herbaceous vegetation
ties (Brunton, 1989) and nearby anthropogenic influences, Plot1 SOIL Coverage (%) of bare soil
our study area provided an excellent opportunity to study Plot1 STUMP Coverage (%) of stumps
the effects of biotic and abiotic variables on GST. Plot1 VEGDENS Number of herbaceous stems
Plot2 OVER D Presence or absence of deciduous
Ambient temperatures were collected by a weather sta- tree > 15 cm DBH3
tion equipped with a Stevenson Screen (Davis Instruments Plot2 UNDER D Presence or absence of deciduous tree
Weather Monitor II, Hayward, California, USA). Ground < 15 cm DBH
surface temperatures were collected by Thermochron iBut- Plot2 OVER C Presence or absence of coniferous tree
> 15 cm DBH
ton temperature data loggers (Maxim Dallas Semiconductor Plot2 UNDER C Presence or absence of coniferous tree
DS1921G, Sunnyvale, California, USA, accuracy ± 1 °C) < 15 cm DBH
placed throughout the park. To facilitate their retrieval, GIS4 ELEVATION Elevation at 5 m resolution
iButtons were taped to 0.75-m wooden stakes. The stakes GIS4 ROAD Reciprocal of Euclidean distance (m) to
were driven into the ground such that the iButton faced nearest paved road
GIS4 URBAN Reciprocal of Euclidean distance (m) to
south and was located at the ground surface. Temperatures nearest urban area
were collected every 2 h at the weather station and iButton GIS4 SLOPE Slope (%)
locations. The locations for data loggers in 2004 (n = 112) GIS4 ASPECT Aspect
were generated from random numbers. The locations of 1 1-m-radius plots.
data loggers that were successfully retrieved in 2004 were 2 5-m-radius plots.
reused in 2005. The remaining locations for 2005 (n = 325) 3 DBH = diameter at breast height.

were obtained by systematically placing data loggers 300 m 4 Calculated with Geographic Information System software.

3
Cunnington et al.: Variation in ground surface temperatures

surface temperature. CCA seeks to determine coefficients of 1512 temperature readings per data logger each year. One
environmental variables to obtain a site score to maximize hundred and twelve data loggers were placed in the field in
the variance of the average position of species (Schaefer, 2004, but only 79 were recovered at the end of the season.
Stevens & Messier, 1996) or, in this case, temperature. Similarly, only 259 of 325 data loggers were recovered
Twenty eastern hog-nosed snakes were opportunisti- in 2005. Thermal data collected by the weather station in
cally captured by hand and radio-tagged. Observations 2004 and 2005 indicated that the mean spring temperature
of behaviour and body temperature (T b) were obtained in 2005 (18.6 °C) was higher than in 2004 (10.7 °C); how-
by radio telemetry between May 2002 and October 2005. ever, the mean summer temperature was warmer in 2004
Only snakes with a body mass > 200 g were implanted (17.3 °C) than in 2005 (15.7 °C). Thermal data collected
(R.  Willson, unpubl. data) with a temperature-sensitive by the weather station and the adjacent iButton were cor-
radio transmitter (Holohill SI-2T, Carp, Ontario, Canada; related (r2 = 0.471).
9 g) with 0.5 °C resolution and 1.0 °C accuracy. To allow
Results from the 2004 CA indicated that 50.3% of the
snakes to return to their normal movement patterns, no
temporal variation in temperature was explained by the first
behavioural or Tb observations were included within 10
d of release. Snakes were classified as active (on ground axis and 14% was explained by the second axis (Figure 1).
surface) or inactive (below ground surface). Each time an To interpret Axis 1, CA scores were plotted against time of
individual was located by telemetry, Tb, behaviour (active day and month (Figure 2). This indicated that the first axis
or inactive), and ground temperature (Tg) were recorded. Tg ordered the sites based on diurnal variation and the second
was collected with a digital hygrometer (VWR International axis on seasonal variation (Figure 1). Data from 4 selected
35519-050, Mississauga, Ontario, Canada) by placing the locations (Figure 1 inset) showed that high CA1 values were
temperature probe on the ground surface within 5 m of the indicative of warmer conditions during daytime, especially
snake. Linear regression was used to test if Tg and Tb were from 1000 to 2000, but not during nighttime.
related. We also determined the percentage of snakes active Similarly, for the 2005 CA, 48.5% of the variation was
versus Tb. To maintain precision, only temperatures with > explained by the first axis and 12.7% was explained by the
20 observations were included. second axis (Figure 3). Diurnal variation, the first axis, was
represented by a gradient of cool days/warm nights to warm
Results days/cool nights (Figure 3). The second axis revealed a gra-
Temperatures were recorded every 2 h from May 30 at dient of cool spring/summer and warm fall to warm spring/
0000 to October 2 at 2200 in 2004 and 2005, resulting in summer and cool fall (Figure 3).

Figure 1. Correspondence Analysis ordination of 2004 temperatures at data logger sites. Black symbols represent sites selected for illustrations of diurnal
temperature profiles (mean temperature versus time of day for May 31; inset).

4
ÉCOSCIENCE, vol. 15 (4), 2008

The 2004 CCA indicated that distances to urban areas (Figure 5). Canopy and leaf cover continued to be related
and roads had the greatest effect on surface temperature to diurnally cool sites; however, overstory and understory
(Figure 4). Deciduous overstory and understory cover, soil, deciduous were related to diurnally cool sites as well
and elevation were related to warm sites both seasonally and (Figure 5). Urban area was not a driver of either seasonal or
diurnally (Figure 4). Coniferous overstory and understory, diurnal thermal variation in 2005.
leaf, and canopy cover were related to diurnally cool sites. A total of 1964 observations of snake behaviour, Tb,
The 2005 CCA produced somewhat different results. and Tg were obtained from 20 adults between 2002 and
While roads and soil were still related to diurnally warm 2005. Linear regression with T b as the dependent vari-
sites, proximity to urban areas was no longer a factor able and Tg as the independent variable generated a slope

Figure 2. Interpretation of CA axes for 2004. a) CA axis 1 scores plotted against time of day and b) mean CA axis 2 scores plotted against month.

Figure 3. Correspondence Analysis ordination of 2005 temperatures at data logger sites. Black symbols represent sites selected for illustrations of diurnal
temperature profiles (mean temperature versus time of day for May 31; inset).

5
Cunnington et al.: Variation in ground surface temperatures

size and limited spatial extent studies and understand the fine
scale thermal dynamics of the landscape.
The 2 y of study differed markedly. This provided us
with an opportunity to compare not only which variables
affect GST, but also how those variables vary in years with
contrasting ambient conditions. In 2004 (cooler spring,
warmer summer), anthropogenic variables such as proxim-
ity to urban areas and roads had the greatest influence on
diurnal variation in temperature (Figure 4). Given the urban
heat island effect (Oke, 1979), it is not surprising that these
variables contributed to increases in GST. It is of interest
then that in 2005 (warmer spring, cooler summer) distance
from urban areas did not greatly influence GST (Figure 5).
The vector representing URBAN does not appear in Figure 5
as it is too short to be visible in conjunction with the other
environmental variables. We propose that the effects of some
variables, like urban areas, interact with prevailing ambi-
ent conditions in complex ways that need further inquiry.
Previous studies have indicated that natural processes do
Figure 4. Axis 1 and 2 of canonical correspondence analysis (CCA) not have as great an impact on GST as anthropogenic distur-
associating site temperature conditions and environmental variables for bances (Lewis, 1998; Saunders et al., 1998).
2004. See Table I for definitions of variables.
Biotic variables such as percent canopy cover and leaf
litter were related to cool sites (both seasonally and diur-
Warm Spring/summer

nally) in 2004 (Figure 4). Plant canopies have been shown


Axis 2 to provide a climatic buffer for the ground surface, provid-
ELEVATION ing shading from extreme temperatures during the day and
cool fall

a downward flux of heat at night (Oke, 1997). The effects


of canopy and leaf litter cover were accentuated in 2005
OVER C (Figure 5); it is likely that the shading provided by these
SLOPE variables decreased GST. While this result is intuitive, it
ROAD D echoes Lewis (1998), who found that deforestation resulted
LEAF
A VEG in an immediate and long-term increase in GST.
Axis 1
Seasonal
variation

CANOPY
UNDER D SOIL The presence of deciduous understory and overstory
C
OVER D trees was positively related to warm sites in the cool year;
LOG B however, these same variables were positively related to
Cool Spring/summer

cool sites in the warm year. This result is somewhat con-


fusing. Nielson (1985) found similar temperatures existed
warm fall

below both deciduous and coniferous canopy; however,


light penetration was less when coniferous trees were pres-
Cool days Diurnal Warm days ent. Our result was likely caused by seasonal variation in
warm nights variation cool nights deciduous canopy cover, while coniferous canopy cover is
essentially static. It would appear that the amount of bare
Figure 5. Axis 1 and 2 of canonical correspondence analysis (CCA) soil at a site affects GST in a similar manner; shorter dis-
associating site temperature conditions and environmental variables for
2005. See Table I for definitions of variables. tance to nearest road in both 2004 and 2005 was associated
with warm sites (Figures 4 and 5).
(95% CI: 0.85 < b1 < 0.91) that was significantly less than Our regression analysis of Tg and Tb indicates that
unity and an intercept (2.02 < b0 < 3.59) greater than zero ground temperature is related to a snake’s body tempera-
(y = 0.877x + 2.805, r2 = 0.477, F1,1014 = 924). This indicat- ture; however, it is not a simple relationship. The lack of
ed that while Tg successfully predicted Tb, there was much strong fit (r2 = 0.477) implies that snakes may have mod-
variation not explained by Tg. Snakes were not active when est scope to modulate body temperature (Brattstrom, 1965;
Tb was below 14 °C or above 37 °C. Snakes were always Huey et al., 1989). The eastern hog-nosed snake Tb data
observed active when Tb was above 21 °C. allow for an interesting assessment of the landscape thermal
data. The upper lethal limit for eastern hog-nosed snakes is
Discussion 41.4 ± 1.8 °C, and these snakes seek cooler body tempera-
tures when they reach 36.1 ± 1.2 °C (Figure 5; Kroll, 1973).
The results of our study supported our hypothesis that The thermal limits of the species demonstrate that under-
biotic factors, such as canopy cover and ground vegetation, are standing the variables that affect GST can provide insight
associated with lower GST and that abiotic factors, like urban into the habitat requirements for an ectotherm. Given the
features and roads, are linked to higher GST. Furthermore, our strong effects of urbanization and roadways on GST (Oke,
study methodology allowed us to move beyond small sample 1973), it is apparent that the impacts of these anthropogenic

6
ÉCOSCIENCE, vol. 15 (4), 2008

features extend beyond reduction in habitat in a purely Environmental Systems Research Institute, 1999b. Spatial Analyst.
structural sense. Version 1.1. Redlands, California.
Since temperature fluctuates both temporally and spa- Halley, V., M. Eriksson & M. Nunez, 2003. Frost prevention
tially, our analysis lends itself to the formation of a broader and prediction of temperatures and cooling rates using GIS.
definition of habitat. The dramatic seasonal and diurnal Australian Geographical Studies, 41: 287–302.
fluctuations of temperature require that habitat be redefined Huey, R. B., C. R. Peterson, S. J. Arnold & W. P. Porter, 1989.
as a dynamic variable. Thermally suitable habitat varies not Hot rocks and not-so-hot rocks: Retreat-site selection by garter
only on a seasonal basis, as conventionally treated, but even snakes and its thermal consequences. Ecology, 70: 931–944.
more markedly on a diurnal basis (Figures 1 and 2). The Jarvis, C. H. & N. Stuart, 2001. A comparison among strategies for
definition of an ectothermic species’ habitat may need to interpolating maximum and minimum daily air temperatures,
account for such thermal dynamics of the landscape at bio- Part I: The selection of “guiding” topographic and land cover
variables. Journal of Applied Meteorology, 40: 1060–1074.
logically meaningful spatial and temporal scales.
Kovach Computing Services, 2006. Multivariate Statistical
Package (MVSP), Version 3.13n. Anglesey, Wales.
Acknowledgements Kroll, J. C., 1973. Comparative Physiological Ecology of Eastern
We gratefully acknowledge the assistance of M.  Shoreman, and Western Hognose Snakes (Heterodon platirhinos and
M.  Beecroft, K.  Janke, C.  VanNess, and P.  Wilson. Research was Heterodon nasicus). Ph.D. thesis. Texas A&M University,
funded by the Ontario Ministry of Natural Resources, the Friends College Station, Texas.
of Nancy Island Historic Site, Ontario Parks, and a Natural Sciences Lewis, T., 1998. The effect of deforestation on ground surface tem-
and Engineering Research Council Discovery Grant to J. A. peratures. Global and Planetary Change, 18: 1–13.
Schaefer. This study was conducted following protocols approved Nelson, N. B., D. A. Siegel & J. A. Yoder, 2004. The spring bloom
by the Ontario Ministry of Natural Resources (MHFW1004).
in the northwestern Sargasso Sea: Spatial extent and relation-
ship with winter mixing. Deep Sea Research, 51: 987–1000.
Literature Cited Newmark, W., 2005. Diel variation in the difference in air tem-
Angilletta, M. J. & A. R. Krochmal, 2003. The Thermochron: perature between the forest edge and interior in the Usambara
A truly miniature and inexpensive temperature-logger. Mountains, Tanzania. African Journal of Ecology, 43: 177–180.
Herpetological Review, 34: 31–32. Nielson, E. T., 1985. Seasonal and diurnal leaf movements of
Arnfield, J. A., 2003. Two decades of urban climate research: A Rhododendron maximum L. in contrasting irradiating environ-
review of turbulence, exchanges of energy and water, and the ments. Oecologia, 65: 296–302.
urban heat island. International Journal of Climatology, 23: 1–26. Oke, T. R., 1973. City size and the urban heat island. Atmospheric
Brattstrom, B. H., 1965. Body temperature of reptiles. American Environment, 7: 769–779.
Midland Naturalist, 73: 376–422. Oke, T. R., 1979. Review of Urban Climatology, 1973–1976.
Brunton, D. F., 1989. Biological Inventory and Evaluation of Wasaga World Meteorological Organization Technical Note No. 169.
Beach Provincial Park and Adjacent Natural Areas, Simcoe Secretariat of the World Meteorological Organization, Geneva.
County, Ontario. Parks and Recreational Areas Section, Ontario Oke, T. R., 1997. Surface climate processes. Pages 21–43 in W. G.
Ministry of Natural Resources, Richmond Hill, Ontario. Bailey, T. R. Oke & W. R. Rouse (eds.). The Surface Climates
Changnon, S. A., 1999. A rare long record of deep soil tempera- of Canada. McGill-Queens’ University Press, Montreal, Quebec
tures defines temporal temperature changes and an urban heat and Kingston, Ontario.
island. Climatic Change, 42: 531–538.
Saunders, S. C., J. Chen, T. R. Crow & K. D. Brosofske, 1998.
Corney, P. M., M. G. LeDuc, S. M. Smart, K. J. Kirby, R. G. H. Hierarchical relationships between landscape structure and
Bunce & R. H. Marrs, 2004. The effect of landscape-scale
temperature in a managed forest landscape. Landscape Ecology,
environmental drivers on the vegetation composition of British
13: 381–395.
woodlands. Biological Conservation, 120: 491–505.
Cunnington, G. M. & J. E. Cebek, 2005. Mating and nesting Saunders, S. C., J. Chen, T. D. Drummer & T. R. Crow, 1999.
behavior of the eastern hognose snake (Heterodon platirhi- Modeling temperature gradients across edges over time in a
nos) in the northern portion of its range. American Midland managed landscape. Forest Ecology and Management, 117:
Naturalist, 154: 474–478. 17–31.
Englehart, P. J. & A. V. Douglas, 2003. Urbanization and seasonal Schaefer, J. A., S. D. Stevens & F. Messier, 1996. Comparative
temperature trends: Observational evidence from a data-sparse winter habitat use and associations among herbivores in the
part of North America. International Journal of Climatology, High Arctic. Arctic, 49: 387–391.
23: 1253–1263. Stabler, L. B., C. A. Martin & A. J. Brazel, 2004. Microclimates
Environmental Systems Research Institute, 1999a. ArcView GIS. in a desert city were related to land use and vegetation index.
Version 3.2. Redlands, California. Urban Forestry and Urban Greening, 3: 137–147.

Вам также может понравиться