Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
2011
Proszkow Update: College Music Courses on the Internet Page | 1
Abstract
universities are including distance education as part of their state’s institutional effectiveness
reports as well as cost-cutting measures for severely underfunded budgets. This article discusses
the past history of distance learning in music education, the current offerings in music using
distance learning, and how we can expect distance learning in music to operate in the future.
The goal of this study is to compare current findings to those found in 2001 by McLain (2003)
and to update the music education community with current online music course offering trends.
The results showed a definite increased interest in online distance learning in higher
education music institutions. However, the field is still lagging behind national trends. Since one
third of the U.S. student population is currently involved in distance learning, it is imperative that
the music education field prepare and provide for students of the future (Parsad & Lewis, 2008).
Information on current state offerings in online music courses should be used as a baseline for
Distance education has been defined in a variety of ways over the course of the twentieth
communication, the use of two-way interactive communication, and the use of technology”
(Gunawardena & McIsaac, 2004, p. 358) “capable of interactive and individualized education at
Distance education has been adopted as a replacement for the aging label
between the instructor and student. Printed documents were sent through the mail, worked on by
the student, and returned to the instructor. The name change occurred in 1982, when the
International Council for Correspondence Education replaced correspondence with distance in its
title. Technological developments in the field of distance education, specifically the internet and
online classes prompted the need for the change. These developments also provided expanded
access to education through distance learning (Gunawardena & McIsaac, 2004). Distance
education now primarily utilizes two-way communication through devices connected to the
internet. Print-based media now supplements a diversely rich multimedia online classroom.
While online distance education is not a new concept, utilizing that format within the
realm of music is a relatively new endeavor. A literature search reveals no relevant articles
written about distance education and music before 1990. After 1990, and during the rise of the
World Wide Web, online educational courses in music began to develop for non-serious
musicians or hobbyists. During the past decade, pilot studies began to determine the availability
(McLain, 2003) and desirability (Bond, 2002) of distance learning in music. Web sites
In a video interview given in 2006, Lindsay discussed how Berklee College of Music
offered correspondence learning in addition to their normal school offerings as early as 1950
(2006). Their correspondence classes were designed for those who could not physically get to
the school in Boston, Massachusetts and to expand the college’s influence and student base. The
Proszkow Update: College Music Courses on the Internet Page | 3
program started with a 25 week “Berklee-by-mail” class in music theory and arranging.
Assignments were sent out weekly by the professor, completed by the student, and mailed back.
All the materials utilized were printed by Berklee Press. This course offered supplemental skills
for working musicians without necessitating time away from home. The professors involved
The explosion of internet availability in the United States in the 1990s provided a new
medium for music distance learning courses. Online courses provided amateur musicians with
lessons like learning how to play the piano. In 1996, Gregory Ramsey developed such a web-
course (2009). The web site provided instructor comments and audio clips to supplement the
written text on each of the web-lessons, with the addition of video instructions as internet
technology improved. The instruction was completely asynchronous and enabled musical skill
refinement as well as promoting a musical hobby. Additional courses were later made available
higher education institutions neglected distance learning in music, and not much research can be
found on the topic. McLain (2003) showed that music educators in the early 1990s were mainly
Building upon the few early web-course developments in music of the 1990s, many web
sites today offer distance learning in music, utilizing new technologies such as streaming audio
and video through internet advancements. RockFactory.US is one of the pioneers in utilizing
synchronous distance learning technology over the internet (2009). Each music lesson is
scheduled for a particular time where the student and instructor meet using proprietary web-
Proszkow Update: College Music Courses on the Internet Page | 4
based software for individual private lessons. WorkshopLive.com (2010) and Zebra Keys (2010)
are examples of online asynchronous distance learning in music. All of these sites cater to a non-
professional hobbyist musician or to trained musicians who need to improve specific skills.
Private instruction in music through distance learning has just begun to be investigated.
Students in remote locations of Western Australia were part of a pilot study on the effectiveness
of private instruction and distance education (Bond, 2002). Students were instructed through
audio-graphical programs from a CD-Rom disc and through supplemental internet messaging
between the instructor and other students in the program. Narrowband (dial-up) internet access
was used for the internet messaging portion of the study. The theory behind the study was to
develop an online distance learning curriculum, utilize asynchronous online flexibility, and to
promote the arts into the distance learning arena. The study showed that (then) current
technology impeded the success of the program, primarily because most of the actual instruction
was off-line through the use of physical media, and group collaboration among the participants
did not occur to any ideal amount. However, Bond also states this form of education has been
internet into private lessons with his students from both the Sydney Conservatorium of Music in
Australia and the Manhattan School of Music in the United States throughout his career (Bond,
2002).
Higher education music institutions still appear to be lagging behind in adopting distance
education, with one notable exception. From its history of pioneering correspondence education
in music, Berklee College of Music has also pioneered online distance learning in music as well
(2010). Both music professionals and undergraduate music students have access to their
Proszkow Update: College Music Courses on the Internet Page | 5
asynchronous classes through proprietary course management software. The school promotes
distance learning in music production, songwriting, arranging, voice, music business, bass,
keyboard, and music theory lessons through its BerkleeMusic website. The goal of the program
is to provide more students access to music instruction, promote the music industry, and expand
their influence outside of Boston, Massachusetts. Unfortunately, Berklee College of Music is not
nationally accredited by the National Association of Schools of Music (NASM), and thus was
not included in this study. The school is accredited through the New England Association of
The NASM online member list shows there are currently a few degree programs in the
United States that are offered through distance education (NASM, 2010). The NASM requires
that greater than forty percent (>40%) of courses for a degree program in music be given through
distance education to qualify for the distance learning label (NASM, 2009). The NASM
membership list makes no distinction between correspondence distance learning and online
distance learning. At the time of this publication, seven schools have a NASM labeled distance
In an effort to discover the content and number of music courses offered online in the
United States during 2001, McLain performed an internet search study (2003) that reported 155
online music courses were offered from 115 schools in 38 states. All of the courses found were
Proszkow Update: College Music Courses on the Internet Page | 6
taught online with minimal face-to-face interaction and qualified for college credit. Each course
Method of Research
This study was designed as a follow-up to the McLain 2003 study to find current higher
education music courses offered as distance learning through the internet. In order to be
included in this study, the distance learning courses were required to (1) qualify for college credit
and (2) be completely taught through the internet without any necessary face-to-face contact
between student and professor. Courses requiring some traditional face-to-face time (hybrid
There are currently 1,739 higher education music institutions in the United States
(College Music Society, 2009). The sample population for this study was drawn from the 634
NASM accredited schools in the United States. Of these, 92 percent (N = 590) were degree
granting institutions used as the sample population for this study (NASM, 2010). Accreditation
standards are identical for both distance learning degrees and traditional learning degrees
(NASM, 2009). Each state and the District of Columbia are represented except for the state of
Vermont, which currently does not have any NASM accredited institutions.
Online searches were conducted to discover online distance learning music courses for
each sample institution. The searches incorporated the main Universal Resource Locator (URL)
for each school found from the NASM online member list. In some instances, the NASM listing
was found to be incorrect and the URL was correctly modified for the search. For each of the
NASM sample schools, six Boolean search strings were used in combination with the school’s
URL:
These six search strings accurately found online courses from the seven currently listed
NASM distance learning programs. Searches were conducted using the Firefox web browser
version 3.6.2 and the Google search engine. All searches took place over a two week period to
The semester or year courses found were offered was not distinguished in this study.
However, most of the online course schedules found had a limited range of past, current, and
future class schedules. Graduate and undergraduate level courses were also not distinguished
due to differing numbering systems utilized by each sample institution. Courses found to be
online distance learning options were recorded and separated into the same ten subject categories
employed from the McLain 2003 study and an additional category for courses that did not fit into
Results
Of the sample NASM accredited schools in the United States (N = 590), internet searches
found 184 institutions from forty six states that offered online courses in music. A total of 644
online distance learning courses were found (See Table 1 and 2). This researcher cautions that it
is probable that some courses were not found using the variables in this study; however, those
In addition to the ten subject areas used in the McLain 2003 study, an additional category
of “new topics in music” was needed. This category included music classes which were not
Proszkow Update: College Music Courses on the Internet Page | 8
available online in 2001, such as music psychology, and courses which spanned multiple
A total of 23,872 search “hits” occurred from the 590 schools using the Boolean search
strings. Each hit was viewed by the researcher and links were investigated when they indicated
additional material regarding course syllabi or online course catalogs. Two thirds of the total
search “hits” (66.6%; N = 15,897) were found using the “distance learning” string.
In addition to the seven schools currently listed by NASM as offering distance learning
States which have no online music course offerings include Connecticut, New
Hampshire, South Carolina, and Vermont in addition to Washington, DC. States without online
course offerings are not included in the following summary. Texas has the largest number of
NASM accredited schools (N = 34) while Delaware, Hawaii, and Wyoming have the least (N =
1). Texas also has the largest number of schools offering online music classes (N = 15) while
Alaska, Arkansas, Delaware, Hawaii, Maryland, Nevada, New Mexico, North Dakota, Rhode
Island, and Wyoming have the least (N = 1). Texas also has the largest number of online music
courses (N = 50) while Arkansas, Nevada, and Wyoming have the least (N = 1) (See Table 2).
The State University of New York system, the University of Wisconsin system, and the
University of Texas system have shared distance learning resources within their respective
schools.
Proszkow Update: College Music Courses on the Internet Page | 9
Some schools searched did not provide “hits” for any of the Boolean search strings
(3.6%; N = 21). The web site for each school was checked for operational status, and each
homepage was found operational at the time of searching. Factors for a zero hit result were most
likely due to an absence of any distance learning program in music from those schools. Other
factors may include missing web page meta-data, a lack of online documentation of distance
education programs within the university, or a search engine data collecting error.
Discussion
Out of the sampled higher education music institutions in the U.S., thirty one percent
were found to offer online music courses for credit. Compared to the seven percent found by
McLain in 2001 (2003), the interest in distance learning in music is building. However, this
result also shows that the current music education field is lagging behind the national trends from
2006-2007 where fifty eight percent of the estimated 2,400 four-year U.S. institutions offered
distance learning courses online for credit (Parsad & Lewis, 2008).
The total number of classes found in 2010 (N = 644) versus those found in 2001 (N =
155) shows an increase in online music classes of 415 percent, or an average growth rate of
seventeen percent per year. Using an Analysis of Variance (ANOVA) calculation, the
distribution of categorized courses offered in 2010 is significantly different from those offered in
2001 (p = .005). The most dramatic distribution change occurs in the category of music
appreciation (See Table 2). In 2001, music appreciation accounted for forty one percent of
online learning in music while only accounting for eleven percent in 2010. The category of
music education showed the greatest increase. It accounted for only eight percent of online
learning in music in 2001 and grew to nineteen percent of online learning in 2010. The results of
this study indicate a shift from providing the majority of distance education in generalized
Proszkow Update: College Music Courses on the Internet Page | 10
courses aimed at non-music majors to music education specific courses. This shift shows that
technology and understanding of online learning has improved enough within music institutions
to offer these courses to their music degree seeking students. Additionally, higher education
professors becoming more comfortable with the online format may be less skeptical of
The distribution of “hits” using the various Boolean search strings indicates the term
“distance learning” is becoming the default term used to describe college music courses given
through the internet. However, many search “hits” also occurred when the string “online course”
was used. It is possible that some music institutions and courses were not found using the
research Boolean search strings. Unfortunately, course list access and databases vary widely
between institutions. A list of online music institutions throughout the U.S. and the world would
be a very beneficial future endeavor to aid in tracking, analysis, and comparison of online
programs in music.
All of the online music courses found and tabulated in this research are offered for
collegiate credit. The skills and knowledge gained from these courses is expected to be equal to
or surpass those from traditional courses. There are, however, some online courses that do not
qualify for college credit. During the course of this study, music classes offered through a
program called Ed2Go were promoted as distance learning courses, but only for personal
enrichment and not for college credit. It is imperative that all potential degree-seeking distance
education students thoroughly evaluate each institution they are interested in, as well as with
traditional learning environments. When choosing an online distance education degree program,
national accreditation is a great way to ensure knowledge and skills are maintained throughout
the program. Without proper accreditation or learning standards, the online institution may be
Distance education in the United States has grown substantially since its inception in the
1990s. Higher education music institutions have been lagging behind national trends, but the
gains made between 2001 and 2010 show an ongoing interest in providing online access for
music instruction. Using 2007-2008 data from The Sloan Consortium (Allen & Seaman, 2010)
we can predict that today, 34 percent of students in higher education are currently involved with
distance learning in the United States. If this trend continues, 69 percent of the student
Technology like mobile computing, augmented reality displays, and gesture based
computing along with media advances like open content, e-books, and connected visual data
analysis (Johnson, Levine, Smith, & Stone, 2010) will become available in the near future.
These advancements will make distance education not only a viable option, but may make
distance education more popular than traditional education. Research in developing technology
such as virtual reality also shows an increased interest in distance education by higher education
institutions (Pham, et al., 2008; Gerald & Antonacci, 2009). Texas State Technical College was
the first university to have a complete virtual graduate, receiving their diploma in May, 2009
(PRWeb, 2009).
Studies show mixed results regarding the differences between distance learning courses
and traditional courses. Reuter (2009) and Verduin and Clark (1991) show that students
achieved better grades through distance learning, and learning is just as effective if not more so
than traditional learning. However, Urtel (2008) and Thomerson and Smith (1996) argued that
students receive better grades through the traditional format, and the physical learning
environment and overall course enjoyment is better than through distance learning.
A cause of mixed results in educational medium may lie in the instructors of these
courses. Many instructors teach in a traditional style they learned from their own educational
Proszkow Update: College Music Courses on the Internet Page | 12
experiences. These styles, many very effective in a traditional classroom, may not transfer to
efficient teaching through distance learning. McLain (2005) found that student interaction with
the instructor through distance learning is very different from traditional education. Traditional
set office hours altered to continuous contact throughout a course gives the illusion that workload
is higher with a distance education class. Her results refute that perception, showing that online
course preparation time is not higher than tradition course preparation time.
Technology and communication advances are pushing educators and institutions to provide
better, cheaper access to more students now more than ever in our history. Music education, as
well as all other educational areas, must embrace this new format of learning as well as keeping
learning and knowledge standards high. A continued examination of the types of online music
courses and how they are being offered will benefit the music education community by providing
information on what is currently being offered online and what other courses are needed to
Proszkow Update: College Music Courses on the Internet Page | 13
Table 2. 2010 Distribution of Sampled Online Schools and Music Courses by State.
States with Sample Sample Sample Music Music Courses
Online Distance Schools Schools Schools Courses Online (N) /
Learning in (N) Online Online Online Schools Online
Music (N) (%) (N) (N)
Alabama 16 3 18.8% 48 16.0
Alaska 2 1 50.0% 3 3.0
Arizona 3 3 100.0% 18 6.0
Arkansas 13 1 7.7% 1 1.0
California 33 4 12.1% 8 2.0
Colorado 12 3 25.0% 5 1.7
Connecticut 5 0 0.0% 0 0.0
Delaware 1 1 100.0% 2 2.0
Florida 18 2 11.1% 12 6.0
Georgia 22 3 13.6% 5 1.7
Hawaii 1 1 100.0% 12 12.0
Idaho 5 3 60.0% 15 5.0
Illinois 24 3 12.5% 6 2.0
Indiana 17 5 29.4% 26 5.2
Iowa 11 2 18.2% 9 4.5
Kansas 14 6 42.9% 23 3.8
Kentucky 11 7 63.6% 28 4.0
Louisiana 15 4 26.7% 6 1.5
Maine 2 2 100.0% 17 8.5
Maryland 5 1 20.0% 3 3.0
Massachusetts 12 4 33.3% 22 5.5
Michigan 17 9 52.9% 19 2.1
Minnesota 18 5 27.8% 9 1.8
Mississippi 11 8 72.7% 34 4.3
Missouri 19 5 26.3% 10 2.0
Montana 3 3 100.0% 11 3.7
Nebraska 7 2 28.6% 22 11.0
Nevada 2 1 50.0% 1 1.0
New Hampshire 2 0 0.0% 0 0.0
New Jersey 8 3 37.5% 6 2.0
New Mexico 3 1 33.3% 4 4.0
New York 16 5 31.3% 15 3.0
North Carolina 19 6 31.6% 28 4.7
Proszkow Update: College Music Courses on the Internet Page | 15
Table 2 (Continued). 2010 Distribution of Sampled Online Schools and Music Courses by
State.
States with Sample Sample Sample Music Music Courses
Online Distance Schools Schools Schools Courses Online (N) /
Learning in (N) Online Online Online Schools Online
Music (N) (%) (N) (N)
North Dakota 5 1 20.0% 19 19.0
Ohio 33 6 18.2% 42 7.0
Oklahoma 15 7 46.7% 12 1.7
Oregon 10 3 30.0% 6 2.0
Pennsylvania 28 9 32.1% 17 1.9
Rhode Island 2 1 50.0% 4 4.0
South Carolina 18 0 0.0% 0 0.0
South Dakota 5 2 40.0% 3 1.5
Tennessee 19 7 36.8% 16 2.3
Texas 34 15 44.1% 50 3.3
Utah 5 4 80.0% 23 5.8
Vermont 0 0 0.0% 0 0.0
Virginia 13 4 30.8% 5 1.3
Washington 10 3 30.0% 3 1.0
Washington, DC 4 0 0.0% 0 0.1
West Virginia 5 2 40.0% 5 2.5
Wisconsin 16 12 75.0% 10 0.8
Wyoming 1 1 100.0% 1 1.0
Totals 590 184 644
Mean: 11.6 3.6 39% 12.6 3.7
Proszkow Update: College Music Courses on the Internet Page | 16
References
Allen, I. E., & Seaman, J. (2010). Learning on Demand: Online Education in the United States,
2009. Babson Park, MA.: Babson Survey Research Group.
Berklee College of Music. (2010). Online Music Courses and Programs. Retrieved March 18,
2010, from Berkleemusic: http://www.berkleemusic.com/
Bond, A. (2002). Learning music online: An accessible learning program for isolated students.
Leabrook, SA, Australia: NCVER.
College Music Society. (2009). Facts and Figures Concerning Music and Higher Education in
the United States. Missoula, MT.: College Music Society.
Garrison, D. R., & Shale, D. (1987). Mapping the boundaries of distance education: Problems in
defining the field. The American Journal of Distance Education, 1 (1), 7-13.
Gerald, S., & Antonacci, D. M. (2009). Virtual World Learning Spaces: Developing a Second
Life Operating Room Simulation. EDUCAUSE Quarterly Magazine, 32 (1), 1.
Johnson, L., Levine, A., Smith, R., & Stone, S. (2010). The 2010 Horizon Report. Austin, Texas:
The New Media Consortium.
Lindsay, S. G. (2006, 8 25). Distance Learning. Retrieved 3 2, 2010, from Artist House Music:
http://www.artistshousemusic.org/articles/distance+learning+a+tradition+at+berklee+college+of
+music
McLain, B. (2005). Estimating Faculty and Student Workload for Interaction in Online Graduate
Music Courses. Journal of Asynchronous Learning Networks, 9 (3), 47-56.
McLain, B. (2003). From a Distance: College Music Courses on the Internet. Technological
Directions in Music Learning, 8.
NASM. (2010). Member Lists. Retrieved March 22, 2010, from National Association of Schools
of Music: http://nasm.arts-accredit.org/index.jsp?page=Member%20Lists
NASM. (2009). NASM Handbook 2009-10. Reston, VA.: National Association of Schools of
Musis.
Pham, B., Kodama, Y., Hino, Y., Kobayashi, H., Yana, K., & Tokiwa, Y. (2008). "Second Life"
as a Cyber Learning Environment for Higher Education and Research Collaboration. Distance
Learning and the Internet, (pp. 1-5). Tokyo.
PRWeb. (2009, May 18). PRWeb. Retrieved March 17, 2010, from TSTC Takes One Small Step
for Virtual Worlds, One Giant Leap for Virtual World Education:
http://www.prweb.com/releases/TSTC/virtual_education/prweb2419874.htm
Ramsey, G. D. (2009). Free On-Line Piano Lessons. Retrieved March 18, 2010, from
GoPiano.com: http://www.gopiano.com/
Reuter, R. (2009). Online Versus in the Classroom: Student Success in a Hands-On Lab Class.
American Journal of Distance Education, 23 (3), 151-162.
Thomerson, J. D., & Smith, C. L. (1996). Student perceptions of the affective experiences
encountered in distance learning courses. American Journal of Distance Education, 10 (3), 37-
48.
Urtel, M. G. (2008). Assessing academic performance between traditional and distance education
course formats. Educational Technology & Society, 11 (1), 322-330.
Verduin, J., & Clark, T. (1991). Distance Education: The Foundations of Effective Practice. San
Francisco, CA.: Jossey-Bass Publishers.
Zebra Keys. (2010). Free Piano Video Tutorials. Retrieved March 18, 2010, from
ZebraKeys.com: http://www.zebrakeys.com/