Вы находитесь на странице: 1из 18

 Each faculty must prepare course handout for each course that he/she is

allotted to teach 15 days before the start of the semester.

 Course handout will be submitted to programme chair and it must be


uploaded in LMS and ERP 10 days before the start of the semester.

 Course handout will contain (A template for course handout is given in


Appendix 4.1).

1. Course details

2. Vision

3. Mission of department

4. Programme educational objectives

5. Programme outcomes

6. Programme specific outcomes

7. Course outcomes

8. Evaluation scheme

9. List of teaching-learning pedagogy such as chalk/talk, flipped


classes, or field trips for each session.

10.Open hour for students

11.Link address for course materials

12.Additional information

13.Detail academic calendar of lecture topics (date, topic, learing


outcomes of each topic, related unit of topic, total number of
lecture in a unit and book/chapter to be read for the topic)
(format is provided with example data).

14.Entire syllabus (Appendix 4.2)

15.List of e-books

16.List of NPTEL,MOOC,SWAYAM Courses/Videos

17.List of content beyond syllabus as per session plan

18.List of mini-projects/projects
19.Students’ Presentation

20.List of technical trainings

21.Additional information

Course Handout
Course details
Faculty name Ms. Ashmika Agrawal, Dr. Sandhya Kumari, Dr. Azim Pathan
Programme BALLB/BBALLB/LLB
1 Semester IV/II
Section
Course code BALB/BBLB2025/BLLB1021
Course title CONSTITUTIONAL LAW II
Vision of the School of Law
To be globally recognized for Pragmatic Hands-on Experiential Legal Education,
2 emphasizing on Research, Innovation and Value Based Education. 

Mission of the School of Law


 Establish State -of-art facilities for world class legal education
and research.
 Make students industry ready, such that they are grounded
with legal knowledge and equipped with skills required for the
3 legal profession.
  Develop Students' critical analytical and legal reasoning skills
through students' centric approach and innovative pedagogy. 
 Prepare ethical professionals, emphasizing on Justice
Education. 

Programme educational objectives (PEOs)


PEO1 Ensuring inculcation of advocacy skills.

PEO2 Students will have Oral and Written Communication skills.


4
PEO3 Preparing them to be ethical and legal professionals who will be socially
responsible while meeting their own career goals.

PEO4 Will be industry-ready with strong legal research and problem solving skills.

5 Programme outcomes
PO1 Students will possess the knowledge and understanding of legal
theory, Substantive and Procedural laws. (K1 & K2)

PO2 Students will demonstrate proficiency in critical analysis and


legal reasoning. (K2, K4 & K6
PO3 Students will develop proficiency in legal research (K4)
PO4 Students will demonstrate proficiency in written and oral
communication (K2 & K3)
PO5 Students will develop skills to act with an informed awareness of
issues and participate in civic life through volunteering. (K4 &
K6)

PO6 Students will gain familiarity with the rules of professional ethics
towards clients. (K2)
PO7 Students will develop the professional skills of counseling and
negotiation needed. (K6)

Programme specifics outcome (PSO)


PSO1 Develop research aptitude using doctrinal and non-
doctrinal research.

6 PSO2 Inculcate argumentative skills through presentations,


student seminars, mock trials and moot courts.

PSO3 Integrate research with theoretical aspects of the subjects by


practical and drafting skills.
PSO4 Develop social and ethical values required to make a
budding lawyer responsible in their career.

Course outcomes (COs)


CO1 To understand the features of Indian Constitution.
CO2 To understand the role of executive in Indian Constitution and
administration of the state.

CO3 To understand the role of legislature and also the distribution of


legislative powers between Union and States; and to apply the
same before the Indian Court of Law;
7
CO4 To analyze the Nature and of Indian Judicial System focusing
on the role of higher judiciary and the role of Precedent in
governance of country;

CO5 To distinguish between the Basic Structure Features and other


features enabling them to identify which part of the Indian
Constitution is amendable.
8 Evaluation Duration Marks Date Nature of Evaluation
Component &Time Component Component
To be Closed Theory
First Class Test 1 hour 5
announced. Book Based.
Mid 50 As per
Closed
Semester/Term 2 hours (Converte Academic
Book
Examination d to 20) Calendar
Second Class 1 hour 5 To be Closed Application
Test announced. Book Based
Internal
Assignment
Research
Paper/Project To be
5
a. Abstrac announced.
t

Final Draft
b. Final
To be Submission
Submis 10 Internal
announced.
sion
Final Draft
To be Submission
c. Viva 5 Internal
announced.

100 As per
End Term Closed
3 hours (converte Acedemic
Examination Book
d to 50) Calender.
9 List of teaching –learning pedagogy: Lecture/Chalk Duster/Blended Teaching/
PPT/Quiz
10 Open hour for students: Every Wednesday (2 pm - 4 pm)

11
Link address for course materials:

https://indianexpress.com/article/explained/collegium-system-supreme-court-how-
judges-are-appointed-and-transferred-the-debate-around-it-4375719/
https://indianexpress.com/article/india/tension-between-executive-judiciary-the-
current-conflict-and-its-fraught-resolution-supreme-court-cji-impeachment-5155435/
https://indianexpress.com/article/opinion/columns/govt-calling-the-supreme-court-
shots-narendra-modi-6070659/
https://indianexpress.com/article/opinion/columns/supreme-court-collegium-justice-
maheshwari-khanna-5543778/
https://indianexpress.com/article/opinion/columns/supreme-court-appointments-of-
judges-cji-5578913/
https://indianexpress.com/article/opinion/columns/judges-appointment-indian-
judiciary-all-india-judicial-service-3736041/
Powers and functions of President of India in hindi | Indian polity by Lakshmikant |
IAS | SSC CGL,https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=olmquCJr10M , Centre State
Legislative relations in Indian Constitution in hindi IAS | UPSC | SSC
CGL,https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MR7t-v2OXy0, President of India | Election,
Qualification, Oath, Impeachment | IAS | UPSC | SSC CGL
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JttM78M4luY

12 Recommended list of e-books:

13 Recommended list of online courses like SWAYYAM/NPTEL/MOOCS etc: None


14 Recommended list of mini projects / projects/ technical training etc.: Law
Commission of India Reports:
14th Report: Reforms of Judicial Administration
79th Report: Delay and arrears in High Courts and other Appellate Courts.
100th Report: Legislation by and against theGovernment: some recommendations for
reform.

88th Report, Governmental Privilege in Evidence: Sections 123-124 and 162, Indian
Evidence Act, 1872 and Articles 74 and 163 of the Constitution
120th Report: Manpower Planning in Judiciary: A Blueprint.
124th Report: The High Court Arrears – A Fresh Look.
125th Report: Supreme Court: A Fresh Look.
136th Report: Conflicts in High Court Decisions on Central Laws – How to foreclose
and how to resolve.
214th Report: Proposal for reconsideration of Judges cases I, II and III – SP GUPTA Vs.
UOI.
222nd Report: Need for JusticeDispensation through ADR etc.
229thReport: Establishing Division Benches in four regions: Delhi, Mumbai, Kolkata,
and Chennai.
230th Report: Reform in Judiciary: Some Suggestions

15 Students’ Presentation:
Features of Indian Constitution: A Critical Analysis
Basic Features of Indian Constitution: A Critical Analysis
Indian Form of Federalism: An Analysis
Constitutionalism: A Jurisprudential Analysis
Development of the Indian Constitution: A Historical Perspective
Privileges of a President: A Critical Approach
Privileges of a Governor: A Critical Approach
Separation of Power: The development of concept in India
Power and Functions of President
Impeachment of President
The Council of Ministers and its function
The President as a head of Executive
Fair Trial: Critical Analysis of Indian Constitution
Speedy Trial in Higher Judiciary: A Critical Study
Powers of Supreme Court: A Critical Study

16 List of e-books:

17 List of NPTEL/MOOCS/SWAYAM/Courses/Video:
1.UNNET University Course on Constitutional Law:
https://www.uninettunouniversity.net/en/mooc-program.aspx?
lf=it&courseid=3947&degree=166&planid=214&faculty=0

Youtube:
1. Key Features of Indian Constitution, RajyaSabha TV
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mG65VirfKp4
2. Powers and functions of President of India in hindi | Indian polity by Lakshmikant |
IAS | SSC CGL,https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=olmquCJr10M ,

3.Centre State Legislative relations in Indian Constitution in hind, IAS, UPSC , SSC
CGL,https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MR7t-v2OXy0,

4. President of India | Election, Qualification, Oath, Impeachment | IAS | UPSC | SSC


CGL
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JttM78M4luY
5. Basic Structure of Indian Constitution : In 7 Steps, Indian Polity
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ri-EiseLQBs&t=25s
6. RSTV Vishesh – 27 January 2020 : Legislative Council : विधानपरिषद; RajyaSabha
TV
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TMRDlkTbclE
7. संविधान - सफर 70 बरसका | Constitution@70 | Episode – 1. (Whole series must be
watched) RSTV
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=24e8sfzDjGA
8. RSTV Vishesh – 01 January 2020 : Rights of Assembly : विधानसभाओंकेअधिकार;
RSTV
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Vyi_AVWqfT0
9.Centre-State Relations : Article 245 - 255 of the Indian Constitution, Legislative
Relations, Finology Legal
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jN_IVXQr3DQ
10.The Big Picture: Article 131 - Special Powers of Supreme Court, RSTV
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BdLb_HMiEGU

18 Content beyond Syllabus: Module 1


1.1 Meaning and Nature of Constitutional Law
1.2 Preamble and Basic Features of Indian Constitution
1.3 Federalism: Nature of Indian Polity, Cooperative Federalism
1.4 Doctrine of Separation of Power

19 List of mini projects/projects: As stated above

Mapping of Cos with POs:

CO PO1 PO2 PO3 PO4 PO5 PO6 PO7 PSO1 PSO2 PSO3 PSO4
CO1 √ √
CO2 √ √
CO3 √ √ √ √ √ √ √ √
CO4 √ √ √ √ √ √ √
CO5 √ √ √ √ √ √ √
Topics and Reference
Lectur Course Total
Date Learning Objectives Sub Topics to Chap./Sec.
e No. Module Lectures
be covered (Book)
Meaning and
Nature of Granville Austin,
1.
Constitutional The Indian
Law Constitution:
Preamble and Cornerstone of a
Basic Nation, Oxford
2. Features of Module –I University Press,
Indian Indian 1999
Student will learn
Constitution Constitution:
about Indian 6
Federalism: Basic M. P. Singh,
Constitution.
Nature of Features Federalizing India
3. Indian Polity, in the Age of
Cooperative Globalization, 1st
Federalism
Edition, 2013
Doctrine of
4. Separation of
Power
Student will get to Election of Module- 6 M. P. Jain, Indian
5.
know about Union President IIUnion constitutional
6. Executive Vice President Executive Law, 8th Edition
Qualification
and eligibility,
7.
Power and
Functions
8. Power to grant
pardon,
Ordinance
-Making
Power,
Impeachment
The Council of
9.
Ministers
Functions of
10. the Council of
Ministers D. D. Basu,
Students will aware Collective
11. Introduction to
about Council of responsibility Module-
4 the Constitution
Ministers/Collective Confidentiality III :Union
of India, 23rd
12. responsibility of Cabinet Cabinet
Edition, 2018
Decisions
13. Duties of PM

14. CASE STUDY

Students will Composition Module- 6 M. P. Singh, V N


understand about the of the IV:The Shukla’s
15. Parliament and its Parliament, Parliament Constitution of
functioning Term of office
India, 13th
of members
Edition,2017 with
Qualification
and Supplement 2019
16.
disqualification
of members
Privileges and
17. Immunities of
Parliament
18. Procedure on
Ordinary Bill,
Money Bill
and Financial
Bill of Union
and State
Legislature
Nature of
Indian Judicial
19. System with its
distinctive
feature M. P. Singh, V N
Supreme Court Shukla’s
20.
Evolve Students of India
Constitution of
awareness regarding Supreme
Module-V: India, 13th
21. recent development in Court’s various
Union 6 Edition,2017 with
regard to powers
Judiciary
JAC/Independence of Special Leave Supplement 2019
22.
judiciary appeals
Independence
23.
of Judiciary
Judicial
Appointment
24.
Commission
(JAC).
25. Case study
26. Revision
Governor of a
27.
state D. D. Basu,
28. To become familiar Qualification Module VI: Introduction to
with the Governor and of Governor State 6 the Constitution
its role. Appointment Executive of India, 23rd
29.
of Governor Edition, 2018
30. Term of
Governor
Power and
Functions of
Governor,
31.
Issue
Ordinance of
Governor
Council of
Ministers of
Governor,
32.
Power to grant
pardon of
Governor
To get acquainted Constitution Module VII: 6 M. P. Singh, V N
with the under State Shukla’s
Unicameral/Bicameral Unicameral Legislature Constitution of
33.
System/Bill and Bicameral India, 13th
Legislative Edition,2017 with
system Supplement 2019
Qualification
&
34.
disqualification
of members
Power and
35.
function
Procedure on
36.
Ordinary Bill
37. Special
Procedure on
Money Bill &
Financial
matters
38. Case study
Judicial system
39.
in the States
Judicial system
40.
in the States
Appointment
41. and conditions
of office
Various M. P. Singh, V N
42. Powers of Module
To develop Shukla’s
High Court VIII: High
understanding on the Constitution of
Courts & 6
Courts and its Establishment India, 13th
Subordinate
43. hierarchy of Common Edition,2017 with
Courts
High Court Supplement 2019
Transfer of a
44. judge of High
Court
Transfer of a
45. judge of High
Court
46. Case study
To develop broader Legislative Module IX: 6 M. P. Jain, Indian
47.
understanding on Powers, Distribution constitutional
various doctrines of Delegated of powers Law, 8th Edition
48.
Constitution as well legislation between
as Interpretation of Delegated Centre and
49. Statutes States
legislation
50. Territorial
nexus,
Harmonious
construction
Pith and
51.
substance
Repugnancy,
52. Colorable
Legislation.
Proclamation
53.
of Emergency
Kinds of
54.
Emergency
Kinds of
55.
Emergency
Grounds of
56.
Emergency
To understand the Grounds of Module X :
57. constitutional Emergency
Emergency M. P. Jain, Indian
provisions related to Effect of Provisions &
58. 8 constitutional
Emergency/Effects Emergency Amendment
Law, 8th Edition
and Amendment of Amendment of of
59. Constitution Constitution
Constitution
Doctrine of
60.
basic Structure
Doctrine of
61.
basic Structure
62. Case study
63. Case study
64. Revision
Appendix 4.2

Catalog Description

India i.e. Bharat is a Union of States.  It is a Sovereign Socialist Democratic Republic with a
parliamentary system of government.  The Republic is governed in terms of the Constitution
of India which was adopted by the Constituent Assembly on 26 th November 1949 and came
into force on 26th January 1950.
The Constitution of India is the cornerstone of a country’s governance system. It stipulates
where power lies within the state, what the institutions of government are, and how they are
intended to operate. Good governance emerges from its structural provisions, such as
separation of powers and statement of explicit rights that guard against authoritarian control.
As the highest legal norm within the hierarchy of norms, the constitution also becomes a
reference point for the legality of administrative and legislative actions. In sum, constitutional
reform ultimately embodies governance reform. Therefore the Constitution is a document that
contains the dos and don'ts of a country. It also stipulates the organs of the government and
this leads to its importance in the governance of a country. Since most constitutions are
people driven, it therefore gives the rights of its citizens amongst which is a component of
democratically electing its leaders who function through the three arms of government as
Executive, Legislature and Judiciary.
Text Books
1. M. P. Jain, Indian constitutional Law, 8th Edition
2. M. P. Singh, V N Shukla’s Constitution of India, 13th Edition,2017 with Supplement
2019
3. D. D. Basu, Introduction to the Constitution of India, 23rd Edition, 2018

Reference Books
1. Granville Austin,The Indian Constitution: Cornerstone of a Nation, Oxford University
Press, 1999
2. DD Basu, Commentary on the Constitution of India, 9th Edition, 2016
3. H.M.Seervi Constitutional Law of India, 4th Edition
4. M. P. Singh, Federalizing India in the Age of Globalization, 1st Edition, 2013

Course Content

Unit 1:Indian Constitution: Basic Features 6 lecture hours


 Meaning and Nature of Constitutional Law
 Preamble and Basic Features of Indian Constitution
 Federalism: Nature of Indian Polity, Cooperative Federalism
 Doctrine of Separation of Power

Case-Laws and materials:


ShankeyAgarwal, Co-Operative Federalism in India An Analysis in Light of Recent
Trends, 8, RMLNLUJ (2016) 112
M. P. Singh, Federalism, Democracy and Human Rights Some Reflections, 47, JILI
(2005) 429
P IshwaraBhat, Why and How Federalism Matters in Elimination of Disparities and
Promotion of Equal Opportunities for Positive Rights, Liberties and Welfare?54 JILI
(2012) 324

 Unit 2: Union Executive: 6 lecture hours


 Nature of Executive in India
 Election of President,
 Election of Vice President and,
 term of office,
 qualificationandeligibility,
 Power and Functions,
 Power to grant pardon,
 Ordinance -Making Power, Impeachment.

Case Laws:
 Rao v. Indira AIR 1971 SC 1002;
 Ram Jawaya v. State of Punjab, AIR 1955 SC 549;
 State of Punjab v. Joginder Singh AIR 1990 SC 1396;
 Keher Singh v. Union of India AIR 1989 SC 653,
 Garg v Union of India AIR 1981 SC 2138,
 T.Venkata Reddy v State of Andhra Pradesh AIR1985 SC 551
 A.K Roy v Union of India,
 EpuruSudhakar v State of Andhra Pradesh]

Unit 3: Union Cabinet: 4 lecture hours


 The Council of Ministers;
 Functions of the Council of Ministers;
 Collective responsibility;
 Confidentiality of Cabinet Decisions / Art. 121;
 Duties of Prime Minister;

Case Laws:
 Samsher v. State of Punjab AIR 1974 SC 2192;
 S.P.Gupta v. Union of India AIR 1982 SC 149;
 K.M.Sharma v. Devi Lal AIR 1990 SC 528;
 State of Karnataka v.Union of India AIR 1978SC 68]
 S.P Anand v H .D. Devegoda,
 S.R. Chauhan v State of Punjab,
 Lily Thomas v Union of India,

Unit 4: The Parliament: 6 lecture hours


 3.1 Composition of the Parliament,
 3.2 Term of office of members,
 3.3 Qualification and disqualification of members,
 3.4 Privileges and Immunities of Parliament,
 3.5 Procedure on Ordinary Bill, Money Bill and Financial Bill of Union and State
Legislature.

Case Laws:
 Rao v Indira, AIR 1971 SC 1002,
 Indira v Rajnarayan AIR 1975 SC 2299
 Pashupati v Nem AIR 1984 SC 399,
 Dilip v State of MP AIR 1976 SC 133,
 Bhagwati v. Rajeev AIR 1986 SC 1534,
 Union v. Gopal AIR 1978 SC 694,
 Kiran v Sanjiva, AIR 1970 SC 1573,]

Unit 5: Union Judiciary: 6 lecture hours


 Nature of Indian Judicial System with its distinctive feature
 Supreme Court of India,
 Supreme Court’s various powers,
 Special Leave appeals,
 Independence of Judiciary,
 Judicial Appointment Commission (JAC).

Case Laws:
 In Re Presidential Reference, AIR 1999 SC 1,
 S.P.Gupta v Union AIR 1982 AIR SC 149,
 PeddaNarayana v UP AIR 1975 SC 1252,
 Rajan v State of Bihar AIR 1991 SC 1377,
 Mahesh v State of Delhi AIR 1991 SC 1108,
 Balakrishna v Matha (1991)2 SCC 203,
 J.RangaSwamy v AP AIR 1990 SC 535

Unit 6: High Courts & Subordinate Courts: 6 lecture hours


 Judicial system in the States,
 Appointment and conditions of office,
 Various Powers of High Court
 Establishment of Common High Court,
 Transfer of a judge of High Court

Case Laws:
 AshishHanda v Chief Justice, P & H High Court, AIR 1996 SC 1308,
 K Asoka Reddy v Government of India AIR 1994 SC 1207,
 Sodhi v Union of India (1991) 2 SCC 382,
 A.K.Roy v Union of India AIR 1982 SC 710,
 KanuSanyal v District Magistrate AIR 1973 SC 2684,
 S.P.Gupta v Union of India AIR 1982 Sc 149,
 Fertilizer Corporation v Union of India AIR 1981 SC 344]
 Rojer Mathew v South Indian Bank Ltd. Civil Appeal No. 8588 of 2019

Unit 7: State Executive: 6 lecture hours


 Governor of a state,
 Qualification of Governor
 Appointment of Governor
 Term of Governor
 Power and Functions of Governor
 Council of Ministers of Governor
 Power to grant pardon of Governor
 Power to Issue Ordinance of Governor

Case Laws:
 State of Punjab v Joginder AIR 1990 SC 1396,
 Satpal v State of Hariyana AIR 2000 SC 1702,
 Bharat Coal v State of Bihar (1990) 4 SCC 557,
 Pratap Singh Rane v Government of Goa AIR1999 Bom 53
 Rai Sahib Ram JawayaKapur v State of Punjab (1955) 2 SCR 225,
 A Sanjeevanaidu v State of Madras AIR 1979SC 1102

Unit 8: State Legislature: 6 lecture hours


 6.1 Constitution under Unicameral and Bicameral Legislative system,
 6.2 Qualification & disqualification of members,
 6.3 Power and function,
 6.4 Procedure on Ordinary Bill
 6.5 Special Procedure on Money Bill & Financial matters,
Case Laws:
 Sushil Kumar v Rakesh Kumar AIR 2004 SC 230,
 S.R. Bommai v Union AIR 1994 SC 1918,
 Election Commission v SubramaniumSwamy AIR 1996 SC 810
 Purushotham v State of Kerala, AIR 1962 SC 694,
 Bharat SevaAsharam v State of Gujarat AIR 1987 SC 494,
 State of Bihar v Kameswar Singh AIR 1952 SC 252

Unit 9:Distribution of powers between Centre and States 6 lecture hours


 8.1 Legislative Powers,
 8.2 Delegated legislation,
 8.3 RelevantDoctrines: Territorial nexus, Harmonious construction, Pith and
substance, Repugnancy, Colorable Legislation.
 8.4 Doctrine of Pleasure.
Case Laws:
 Governor General in Council v. Raleigh Investment Corporation Ltd.AIR 1944 FC
51,
 GVK Industries Ltd. v. ITO ,(2011) 4 SCC 36,
 Edward Mills Corporation Ltd.v. State of Ajmer, AIR 1955 SC 25,
 Harla v. State of Rajasthan, AIR 1951 SC 467,
 State of Bombay v. F.N.Balsara, AIR 1951 SC 318,
 State of Bihar v. Kameswar Singh, AIR 1952 SC 252

Unit 10: Emergency Provisions& Amendment of Constitution 8 lecture hours

 Proclamation of Emergency,
 Kinds of Emergency,
 Grounds of Emergency
 Effect of Emergency
 Amendment of Constitution,
 Doctrine of basic Structure.

Case Laws:
 State of Rajasthan v Union AIR 1977 SC 1361,
 A.N.Ray v Union of India AIR 1982 SC 710,
 S.R.Bommai V Union of India AIR 1994 SC 1918
 ShivKantShukla v A.D.M Jabalpur
 Indira Gandhi v Raj Narayan AIR 1975 SC 2299,
 Shankari Prasad v. Union of India AIR 1951 SC 455,
 Sajjan Singh v. State of Rajasthan AIR 1965 SC 845,
 L.C. Golakhnath v. Stae of Punjab AIR 1967 SC 1643,
 KeshavanandaBharati v State of Kerala, AIR 1973 SC 1461,
 Sampath Kumar v Union AIR 1987 SC 386,
 WamanRao v Union AIR1981271,
 Bhim Singh v Union AIR 1981 SC 234]
Appendix 4.3: Compliance report

School of LAW
Programme BA+LLB, BBA+LLB, LLB
Programme DrSeemaYadav
Chair
Compliance report of course handout
Course
Course handout Remarks by PC if
Sl No Course code Course title Section Taught by faculty Submission
coordinator any
date
1 BALB2025 CONSTITUTIONAL LAW II A
2 BBLB2025 CONSTITUTIONAL LAW II A
3 BLLB1021 CONSTITUTIONAL LAW II A

Signature of PC; Signature of Dean:

Review by IQAC:

Вам также может понравиться