Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
ViewCube
May 2019
Telecom
Troughed out
Revenue set to rebound with
7% growth this fiscal
Rural subscribers to drive
next leg of growth
ViewCube is a compilation of sector views expressed during CRISIL’s webinars.
These include CRISIL’s own views, that of stakeholders, and those emanating from a poll done during the
webinar.
Analytical contacts
Sachin Gupta Nitesh Jain Hetal Gandhi
Senior Director Director Director
CRISIL Ratings CRISIL Ratings CRISIL Research
sachin.gupta@crisil.com nitesh.jain@crisil.com hetal.gandhi@crisil.com
Editorial
Raj Nambisan, Director
Subrat Mohapatra, Associate Director
Nisha Prabhakaran, Lead Editor
Smitha Puthiyadan, Senior Editor
Design
Rajesh Gawade
Contents
Our view 4
Their view 10
Poll view 13
3
Our view Visible signs of recovery
After losing over Rs 40,000 crore revenue
in the past two years, the Indian telecom
industry is expected to see revenue
growth recover to ~7% on-year in fiscal
2020.
15 2,000
11
8 9 1,500
10 7
5 1,000
5 500
0
0 0
-5 -500
-1,000
-10 -13 -11 -1,500
-15 -2,000
FY13
FY14
FY15
FY16
FY17
FY18
FY19E
FY20P
Gross revenue (RHS) Growth rate
E: Estimated; P: Projected
Source: TRAI, CRISIL Research
ARPUs to inch up
Price wars sparked by the entry of
Reliance Jio led to a deterioration in the
incumbents’ ARPU, and thereby a decline
in their revenue market share. Indeed,
ARPUs of larger incumbents have almost
halved in the past two years. Smaller
incumbents found it difficult to sustain
at such low ARPUs and therefore exited
the market. This led to incumbents losing
~30% revenue market share to Jio as of
December 2018.
4
CRISIL believes the pricing aggression will remain ARPU to grow ~11% in FY20
moderate and selective in fiscal 2020 on account of Rs
the following: 200 180
180
• Jio has established its revenue market leadership 160 143
in 13 circles (7 B circles and 6 C circles), which 140
116 114
account for ~44% of the industry revenue. This 120 102
is led by higher ARPUs that Jio has been able to 100
command by targeting premium subscribers in 80
these circles 60
40
On the other hand, large incumbents such as 20
0
Airtel and Vodafone Idea have managed to retain
FY16 FY17 FY18 FY19E FY20P
their leadership in premium circles – metros and
E: Estimated; P: Projected
A circle. Thus, there is a probability that further Note: ARPU includes financials of Bharti Airtel, Vodafone Idea & Reliance Jio
downward revision in pricing, if any, would be Source: Company reports, CRISIL Research
selective and would remain a key monitorable
5
Rural subscribers: Low teledensity gaining Urban subscribers: Shift to primary SIM will
telcos’ attention check growth
Mn Mn
600 22 700 73
76 16 202 56
500 600
73
49 500
400 195
132 400
300 300
129 199
200 200
100 -63
100 62 -16 -50
0
0 -100
FY08
FY08-FY10
FY10-FY12
FY12-FY14
FY14-FY16
FY16-FY18
FY08
FY19E
FY20P
FY08-FY10
FY10-FY12
FY12-FY14
FY14-FY16
FY16-FY18
FY19E
India has emerged as the largest consumer of Given the rise in 4G adoption, with increased
data despite the fact that over 50% of the wireless availability of cheaper handsets, almost half the total
subscribers are yet to use data. wireless subscribers are expected to start using 4G
data SIM cards by March 2020. Thus, 4G will peak by
fiscal 2021. The average data usage per subscriber
per month has reached over 10 GB from ~1 GB two
50%
41% years back. Thus, the increase in data usage and
66% 60% users will drive data volume growth in India. CRISIL
74% 71% 69%
Research expects data volume to grow ~53% to
reach ~85 petabytes by fiscal 2020.
1% 40% 51%
11% 24%
5% 9% 13%
11%
21% 20% 17% 9% 2G/3G on decline, 4G to peak by FY21
12% 5% 4%
7% 5% 4%
FY14
FY15
FY16
FY17
FY18
FY19E
FY20P
E: Estimated; P: Projected
Source: CRISIL Research
6
OTT, gaming to drive data volume High investment need may restrict 5G
growth; telcos bet big on content launch to metros & A circles initially
More than 70% of the data usage in India is on Given that 4G is still evolving in India, we believe 5G
watching videos, and the trend has only increased is at least two years away. Players would need to
in the past year or so. The vast array of content look at development of an enabling infrastructure
available on over-the-top (OTT) platforms is driving ecosystem first. Fiberisation, one of the pre-
data usage. requisites for 5G launch, is still less than 30%, and
we believe an investment of over Rs 1 lakh crore
We believe curated, customised and regional content would be needed to reach the ~70% fiberisation
will see significant viewership going forward. mark necessary for leveraging 5G use cases.
Another emerging trend is mobile gaming. In line Further, the 5G device ecosystem in India is still at a
with the global trend, mobile gaming has picked up nascent stage. The price of 5G-enabled smartphones
in India. For instance, PUBG saw over 100 million would depend upon the magnitude of adoption
downloads (~10% of wireless subscribers) within a in the US, China, etc, which can give significant
year of its launch. headroom to reduce pricing here. Also, higher debt of
~Rs 4.3 lakh crore requires significant deleveraging
Data traffic to increase 1.5x on-year by FY20 before players can go for next level of capacity
Petabytes GB additions.
100 11.2 12
90 The reserve price recommended by the Telecom
80 8.5 87 10
Regulatory Authority of India (TRAI) for 5G spectrum
70 8
60 56 bands is too high compared with the UK and South
50 5.1 6 Korea. For instance, reserve price recommended by
40 TRAI for India is ~$0.23/MHz/population (for metros)
27 4
30
20 1.3 compared with the reserve price of ~$0.16/MHz/
2
10 0.2 0.3 population in the UK, during the auction in June 2018.
0 0 This may force telcos to bid only in metros and A
FY13 FY14 FY15 FY16 FY17 FY18 FY19E FY20P circles, which are more likely to use high-speed fibre
Data traffic Data usage per sub per month (RHS) services, amidst their weak debt profile.
E: Estimated; P: Projected; Sub: Subscriber
Source: TRAI, company reports, CRISIL Research
New entrant
Pricing/Sub
New entrant
Pricing/Sub
FY16
FY17
FY18
FY20P
Opex
Opex
FY19E
Opex
7
ARPU growth to drive profitability Capex intensity to moderate from
FY20
The industry has witnessed significant consolidation,
with the top three players now accounting for The industry witnessed significant ramp-up in
92-93% of the revenue market share. As the network capex during fiscals 2018 and 2019 as large
industry is characterised by large fixed operating incumbents made hefty investments to enhance
costs, viz., network operations and employee costs, their 4G coverage and counter the threat from the
consolidation aids improvement in ARPUs and new entrant. As a result, the network capex-to-
profitability. revenue ratio is estimated to have increased to 61%
during fiscal 2019 from 44-46% during fiscals 2016
CRISIL estimates combined profitability from and 2017.
the mobility business of the top three players to
increase by 300 bps to 26% in fiscal 2020 from 23%
Network investments to moderate in FY20
as of fiscal 2019.
1,600 70%
1,400
Large incumbents (Bharti Airtel and Vodafone Idea) 60%
witnessed significant pressure on their operating 1,200
610 50%
Rs '00 cr
profit over fiscals 2018 and 2019 as the industry 1,000
320 40%
ARPU declined 26% and 19% on-year, respectively. 800
However, with the expected uptrend in ARPU, the 30%
600
industry profit is likely to increase by ~Rs 8,000 914
1,034
20%
400 799 847
crore in fiscal 2020. 790 773
200 10%
180 15%
80
143 had been up-fronted, CRISIL estimates the capex
116 114 114 114 10%
40
102 intensity to moderate to Rs 84,700 crore for fiscal
5% 2020. The network capex-to-revenue ratio is
0 0% estimated to moderate to 46% from 61% in fiscal
Scenario 1
Scenario 2
FY16
FY17
FY18
FY19E
FY20P
2019.
FY20P
FY20P
8
The increase has been against a backdrop of
Rs 1.6 lakh crore of deleveraging, including asset
sale and equity infusion during the period.
3,000 150 27
55 3
2,500
2,206
2,635 2,867 3,117 3,565 3,122
2,000 -
Others
Others
Others
Others
Others
Capex
Accrual
Equity
Capex
Accrual
Capex
Accrual
Equity
Capex
Accrual
Capex
Accrual
Equity
Debt
Debt
Debt
Debt
Asset Sale
Debt
Asset Sale
Debt
Equity
Equity
FY16 FY17 FY18 FY19E FY20P Mar-20P
E: Estimated; P: Projected
Note: Consolidated debt for Bharti Airtel, Vodafone Idea and Reliance Jio has been factored in, including deferred spectrum payment liabilities
Source: Company reports, CRISIL Ratings
9
Their view On one-year outlook for
the industry in terms of
tariff and ARPU
Views excerpted from a panel discussion during the
Operators now acknowledge that a
CRISIL webinar on the telecom sector.
The webinar was attended by 215 external participants
pure business-to-consumer (B2C)
representing 115 organisations. approach, which has characterised
the voice and data revenue streams,
just leads to a high-volume, low-
The panelists were: margin business.
10
On whether investors have the In India, there needs to be clarity on the spectrum
side first. Once that is sorted, it should take
confidence to take a medium-to-long- 6-12 months of trials, followed by commercial
term call on the sector deployment.
11
sharing as well. With towers being shared, some years, the capex numbers can take the telecom
efficiencies are already there. Taking the entire operators’ debt to a significantly higher level.
operating cost structure into account, players will Auctions keep coming up as well, making it very
continue to see benefits from these areas. difficult to peg how much debt the company will take
to put in new spectrum.
On the regulatory side, the government is aware that
operators are looking at the implications of Goods Conventionally, it was assumed that it is relatively
and Services Tax and the redefinition of adjusted easy to predict EBITDA for the telecom sector. But,
growth revenue on which licence fees and spectrum when Reliance Jio entered the fray last year, it proved
usage charges are paid, which implies more offsets. how a new entrant can become a game changer.
The National Digital Communication Policy, 2018,
has all these factors built-in. Hopefully, the new Moreover, operating leverage is significantly high in
government will begin to start acting on that in the telecom. Therefore, a mild increase in ARPU can have
next 6-9 months. So, when the total operating cost a significant impact on EBITDA.
structure is considered, there are opportunities for
improving margins. However, there do not seem to Yet, though debt and EBITDA can be predicted more
be any further opportunities from pure headcount easily for roads and renewables, they also offer lower
reductions. yields.
12
Poll view What is your view about the telecom industry
revenue growth in fiscal 2020?
40 participants 10-15%
16%
Positive
39%
Stable
Negative
45%
13
Do you expect ARPUs to go up in fiscal 2020? Will the profitability in fiscal 2020 be better
than fiscal 2019?
12%
27%
Yes
Yes
No
No
73%
88%
When do you expect the rollout of 5G in India? Do you expect capex intensity to moderate in
fiscal 2020, vs fiscals 2018 and 2019?
21%
30% April 2019-March 2020
Yes
45%
April 2020-March 2021
55% No
April 2021-March 2022
49%
14
CRISIL-rated telecom service providers
Company name
15
Customer Service Helpdesk
Toll free: 1800 22 1301
Email: ratingshelpdesk@crisil.com
It is India’s foremost provider of ratings, data, research, analytics and solutions with a strong track record of growth, culture of
innovation, and global footprint.
It has delivered independent opinions, actionable insights, and efficient solutions to over 100,000 customers through businesses
that operate from India, the US, the UK, Argentina, Poland, China, Hong Kong and Singapore.
It is majority owned by S&P Global Inc, a leading provider of transparent and independent ratings, benchmarks, analytics and data to
the capital and commodity markets worldwide.
CRISIL Privacy
CRISIL respects your privacy. We may use your contact information, such as your name, address, and email id to fulfill your request
and service your account and to provide you with additional information from CRISIL. For further information on CRISIL’s privacy
policy please visit www.crisil.com/privacy.