Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
The Paper describes the various works of the Northumbrian Water Authority's Kielder
water scheme which allow transfer of water from a regulated River Tyne at Riding Mill
(56 km downstream from Kielder Water) to the rivers Wear and Tees to also furtherregulate
these rivers for the purposeof water abstraction.
Introduction
The background to the development of the Kielder water scheme is described in a
previous paper.' That part of the scheme known as the transfer works extends
from Riding Mill on the River Tyne approximately 25 km upstream of Newcastle
to the River Tees near Eggleston-a distance of about 40 km. This will allow the
transfer of up to 1,180 X 106 m3/d of water from the River Tyne to the rivers Wear
and Tees.
2. The pumping station site at Riding Mill is 13 km upstream of the tidal limit
and was the most suitable location for abstraction. At Eggleston the River Tees
starts to flow in a more southerly direction than before. The target route for the
transfer works was therefore a straight line between Riding Mill and Eggleston,
which also avoids the coal-mining areas to the east of this line. Geological and
hydraulic considerations, together with a desire to phase as much of the works as
possible, led to a pumping main for6.2 km discharging intoa gravitational
system. Most of the aqueduct length is in tunnel, with balancing storage at Airy
Holm (Fig. 1).
3. Following the execution of minor works to give access to the Tees portal in
1974, the first of the tunnelling contracts (13 km from Derwent to Wear and
14.4 km from Wear to Tees)was let in 1975. The second tunnelling contract
(4.5 km from Letch House to Derwent) was let in early 1977. Construction of the
Riding Mill pumping station and the pumping main also started in 1977. The
contract for the construction of Airy Holm dam was let towards the end of 1977.
Finally, a contract for construction of a weir on the River Tyne to improve
abstraction conditions waslet in 1980. The transfer works are expected to be
operational in 1982.
Ordinary meeting, 2.30 p.m., 18 May 1982. Written discussion closes 15 July 1982 for
publication in Proceedings, Part 1.
* Senior Partner, Babtie Shaw and Morton, Consulting Engineers.
t Partner, Babtie Shaw and Morton.
$ Associate, Babtie Shaw and Morton.
177
Downloaded by [ UNIVERSITY OF SHEFFIELD] on [16/09/16]. Copyright © ICE Publishing, all rights reserved.
COATS, BERRY AND BANKS
0 5 35 t o 30 1525 20 40
Kilometres
Fig.1 . Transfer works
170
Downloaded by [ UNIVERSITY OF SHEFFIELD] on [16/09/16]. Copyright © ICE Publishing, all rights reserved.
KIELDER TRANSFER WORKS
Scale of metres
0 40
180
Downloaded by [ UNIVERSITY OF SHEFFIELD] on [16/09/16]. Copyright © ICE Publishing, all rights reserved.
KIELDER TRANSFER WORKS
about 2.0 m above originalriver bed level and 1.4 m above lowest weir crest level
of the right bank section.
6. When the tilting gates are r a i d the weir creates intake pond storage of
about 110000 m’ capacity above lowest weir level. In future this storage may be
increased to 214000 m3 by raising the level of the weir Crest by 0.65 m either by
increasing theheight of the concretecrest o r adding longtilting gates. This storage
provides a balancebetween natural river flows, releasesfrom Kielder Waterwhich
take time to arrive, and abstractions usingfixed speed pumps (i.e., stepped instead
of variable speed pumping). Normally the tilting gates will be kept fully lowered
and will be raised slowlyto create storagebefore pumping commences. Thereafter
they will be, adjusted so that necessary downstream flows can be maintained.
7. It was originally intended to include flow-measuringweirs and fish passes at
both sides of the river, but those beside the left bank were removed because the
model study indicated a tendency for river bed material to depositin this area (Fig.
5). During lowflows the fish can use the fish pass to bypass the tilting gates,
although at high flows the gateswill be partly or fully lowered and fish will be able
to swim over thegates. A fish counter is installed on theCrump weir.
8. The weir is of reinforced wncrete construction with a cut-off of 1.2 m din.
Secant interlocking wncrete piles extending to rockunderthe weircrest.
Sandstone lies at about 5 m below river bed level with sand, gravel and boulders
overlying. During construction of the weir not more thanone third of the normal
river channel was obstructed as the weir was constructed in four sections within
steel sheet pile cofferdams. Because of densely packed large boulders in the river
bed the sheet piling had to be driven through a preexcavated trench which had
been backfilled withgranular material.
-m-%-*;%-*- . .‘W
Fig. 5. Riding Mill model Showing leh bank bayssilted up
181
Downloaded by [ UNIVERSITY OF SHEFFIELD] on [16/09/16]. Copyright © ICE Publishing, all rights reserved.
COATS,BERRYANDBANKS
z
a
1
a
U
0
S
LL
a:
W
a
a
3
182
Downloaded by [ UNIVERSITY OF SHEFFIELD] on [16/09/16]. Copyright © ICE Publishing, all rights reserved.
KIELDER TRANSFER WORKS
Downloaded by [ UNIVERSITY OF SHEFFIELD] on [16/09/16]. Copyright © ICE Publishing, all rights reserved.
COATS, B E R R Y A N D B A N K S
Downloaded by [ UNIVERSITY OF SHEFFIELD] on [16/09/16]. Copyright © ICE Publishing, all rights reserved.
KIELDER TRANSFER WORKS
All external opnings for air circulation fans are fitted with acoustic ballles. In
addition each pumpset is reassed within an acoustic enclosure consisting of an in
situ concrete walkway at high level with a removable dome cover and curved
sound-absorbent screensat the sides.
15. The pipework mabifold which runs thefull length of the pumphall (Fig. S)
is anchored only at its downstream end and,to allow for expansion, stainless steel
bellow unitsareincorporated in thebranchpipis for eachpump. All steel
pipework was designedto BS 5500. Butterfly valves whichhave replaceable rubber
inset seals and are designed for controlled openingare provided on each71 1 mm
d i a pump deliverypipe, together with non-return valves. The manifoldis
2220 mm dia. reducing to1016 mm d i a The theoretical and measured movements
of the external buried pipework under pressure were the subjectof a study by the
ConstructionIndustry Research and InformationAssociation? The surge
suppression and protection measures adopted both at the pumping station and
elsewhere on the transfer works are described by Ellis et al.’ Horizontal s u r e
vessels are located adjacent to the pumping station in a buried chamber. Each
vessel is 100 m3 in volume and is designed to provide surge protection for three
pumps using one pumping main.
16. Theadministrationarea at theupstreamendofthepumpingstation
contains the usual facilities, including, on the groundfloor, a telemetry room and
workshop. On the first floor the supervisor’soilice, conferenceroom to
accommodate at least 50 visitors, and control room all have clear views over the
river. The station has been designed for unattended automatic operation, with
regular visits for ‘housekeeping’ duties and maintenance work, althougb initially
there will be attendance when pumps are started.
Downloaded by [ UNIVERSITY OF SHEFFIELD] on [16/09/16]. Copyright © ICE Publishing, all rights reserved.
COATS, B E R R Y AND BANKS
Pumping main
20. The pumping main linking the pumping station to the tunnel system is
6.2 km long and rises about 200 m. A single pipeline has been provided initially
trench depth
Imported I
compacted Imported cushlon f d
Selected backfill
level
Downloaded by [ UNIVERSITY OF SHEFFIELD] on [16/09/16]. Copyright © ICE Publishing, all rights reserved.
KIELDER TRANSFER WORKS
but there is provision for this to be duplicated when demand justifies it. It follows a
fairly direct route to discharge at the required level into a tank at Letch House
(Fig. 1). This point is to the east of the target route for the transfer works but is
suitably located for the start of the tunnel gravitational system ($40). The pipeline
route is mainly through agricultural land or wooded areas, but at one point it
crosses over a railway line within prestressed concrete pipes on a bridge for a new
road which wasbeing constructed by the Northumbrian County Council at about
the same time as the pipeline was being laid. Old mining activity in the area was
investigated and where the route passed over shallow abandoned workings these
were filled withgrout.
21. The pipeline is designed for a maximum working head of 263 m. The
spirally welded 50B and 43A grade steel pipes were 2 m nominal diameter with
wall thicknesses of 10 mm, 12 mm and 14 mm. With large diameter steel pipes
there is always the problem of large gaps to be welded at joints. To overcome this,
a semi-spherical joint6 was developed. The pipe itselfwas manufactured to a
circumferential tolerance of f5 mm and at the joint a tolerance of f 1.6 mm on
diameter was achieved. This meant that the maximum gap to beweldedwas
2.7 mm. The semi-spherical joint allowed a deflexion of up to 13" without
encroaching on the internal mortar lining thickness. The pipes were delivered in
12 m lengths and specials were fabricated from plate up to 18 mm thick with
reinforcing doubler plates to withstand the high stresses at the large diameter Ts.
22. To lay the pipes the contractor fenced off a 61 m wide working width and
the pipe trench and bedding arrangement were generally as shown in Fig. 9. Over
about one third of the length, rock was found at depths upto the level of the top of
the pipe and the rock was preblasted prior to the removal of overburden. The
remaining length of the pipeline is in stiff boulder clay exceptfor a 500 m length in
sand and gravel. Spiders wereleft inside the pipes until backfilling had been
virtually completed, and laying rates of up to 84 m/d were achieved.
23. The pipeline is protected externally by 6 mm thick bituminous compound
reinforced with glass cloth, with cold tape application over the joints. After laying
and backfilling the pipeline was given an internal cement mortar lining of 11 mm
nominal thickness (Fig. 10).The mortar was of equal volumes of ordinary Portland
cement and sand with enough water added to give adhesion to the pipe walls. It
was applied to its required thickness in a single pass by a lining machine with
centrifugal spraying head and circumferentially sweeping spring-loaded trowels.
Cold-applled tape
Tapped hole for testing Steel pipe, wall thlckness
\ ,l 0-1 4 mm
Downloaded by [ UNIVERSITY OF SHEFFIELD] on [16/09/16]. Copyright © ICE Publishing, all rights reserved.
COATS, BERRY AND BANKS
The average daily output was 62 m, with 170 m lined in the best day. Some
cracking was experienced butafter filling a section of the pipeline with waterand
examining the lining after 6 weeks it became clear that the crack widths were
greatly reduced with the pipeline filledand that‘sell-healing’ wouldtake place. An
impressed currentsystem of cathodic protection has been incorporated.
24. About 100 m after leaving the pumping station the pipeline passes through
two reinforced concrete chambers,the first of which accommodates an 1800 mm
nominal diameter short Dall insert. In the s a o n d chamber there is a 1400 mm
butterfly valve, a removable section of pipe to allow a swab insert for cleaning
purposes, if necessary, and anaccess manway.The pipelineis anchored to the walls
of both chambers. Thereare no otherin-line valves. There are nine venting houses
(Fig. 1 I ) with 375 mm dia. orifice anti-vacuum valves and airvalves. There are also
eleven smaller chambers which accommodate only air valves. All the vent houses
and air valve chambers have random rubble masonry facings of local stone to
blend in withthe countryside.
25. Connection with the tunnelsystem was effectedthrough the tank andshaft
at Letch House (Fig 12) which was sizcd to ensure that large quantitiesof air do
not enter the tunnel during downsurge and that overspill does not occur during
upsurge?
26. To allow the pipeline to be drained in a reasonable time arrangements to
discharge into theRiver Tyne adjacentto the pumping station have been provided.
A 500 mm dia. drain from the main feeds two 300 mm dia. pipes in a concrete
chamber. In eachpipe. three orifice plates of increasing diameter dissipate energy
before dischargeis effectedin a submergeddischarge vertical stilling well.
Downloaded by [ UNIVERSITY OF SHEFFIELD] on [16/09/16]. Copyright © ICE Publishing, all rights reserved.
KIELDER T R A N S F E R WORKS
that reservoir, so that flow from Derwent Reservoir could not discharge from the
headpond. There also had to be a relationship between maximum water level in
the Airy Holm headpond and the controlling level at Letch House tank. The
overflow crest at Airy Holm dam was, therefore, determined at 223 m, giving a
useful reservoir capacity below crest level of 250 OOO m3.
29. The dam’ closes the valley of the Shotleyfield Burn which has a catchment
area of 3.84 km’. The burn was, however, permanently diverted in 450 mm pipes
to bypass the reservoir to allow at least # times the average daily flow to continue
downstream.
30. At the dam site, drift deposits mainly of boulder clay but including some
sandand gravel deposits anda buried channel overlie the rocks of the
Carboniferous Durham Millstone Grit series. Rockhead was exposed in the bed of
the burn and drift cover was up to 8 m deep on the flanks. Argillaceous strata
comprising siltstones, mudstones, thin coals and associated seat-earths overlie the
moderately strong Airy Holm sandstone. Bedding is horizontal or sub-horizontal
dipping to the north-west. The axis of the dam runs from south-west to north-east.
31. Drawdown of the pond could be up to 6 m in 4 h; this circumstance,
together with the doubt as to the availability locally of suitable material for an
earth embankment, suggested a composite structure for the dam, with the central
180 m being of mass concrete gravity section 20 m high above the lowest general
foundation level, and earth embankments forming the flanks to give a dam 500 m
21 600 mm
-i
long (Fig. 13). The a n t r a l U)m of the concretedam forms the ovcrRow which was
designed for 22.5 m3/s hut can accommodate a probable maximum flood of 37
m3/s. Fig. 14 illustrates the spillway section. The maximum inflow to the Airy
Holm pond from the tunnel system would he under 13 m’/s and it is extremely
unlikely that there will he pumping during a time of severe flood.
32. Inflowfrom and draw-off to the tunnel systemis by means of a shaft
connected to the reservoir floor, and a 600 mm d i a drain from this inlet/outlet
structure (Fig. 15) passes through the concrete dam to discharge into the stilling
basin. This allows removal of sediment which might otherwise enter the tunnel
system. A 600 mm dia. scour pipe also passes through the concretedam and each
of the pipelines is controlled by two 600 mm dia. gate valves located on the
downstream side of the dam. Shouldi t he necessary to drain the reservoir this can
he effected most readilyand very rapidly through the tunnel system.
33. Excavation for the foundationsof the concretedam c o m m e n d a tthe end
of April 1978 and a suitable foundation in the Airy Holm sandstone generally at
the predicted formationlevel was obtained, althoughat the south endof the dam,
pockets of dense but uncemented sandstone wererevealed. The upstream key
trench at that location was reduced in depth and the decomposed sandstonewas
sealed withconcrete to prevent weathering.
34. The concrete damwas constructed in blocks 15 m long with an interval of
at least 21 days between blocks. Two PVC water stops are included in all vertical
joints near to the upstream face and on the ovnflow sectionan additional water
190
Downloaded by [ UNIVERSITY OF SHEFFIELD] on [16/09/16]. Copyright © ICE Publishing, all rights reserved.
KIELDER TRANSFER WORKS
225.1 m .
223 m ~ K r e c a s t concretewalkway
-
Scale of metres
n.7~ 0 5
L 1111'
m Pressure-relief
holes
\ Groutcurtain
7.5c
\
1
\
Fig. 14. Airy Holm dam overflow section
222.5
Ope
Tunnel from
-+ Derwent
Scale of metres
0 5 10
Downloaded by [ UNIVERSITY OF SHEFFIELD] on [16/09/16]. Copyright © ICE Publishing, all rights reserved.
COATS.BERRYANDBANKS
when this became difficult to obtain the mixwasredesignedwith a 75mm
maximum aggregate size. The PFA met sieving residual limits of 12.5% on 45 pm
and 2.5% on 150 pm, with a loss on ignition not exceeding 6.5%. Concrete was
placed in three 0.5 m layers to make 1.5 m lifts with an interval of 3 days between
lifts; the facing concrete, which was 1 m thick on the upstream face and 400 mm
thick on the sloping downstream face was placed without temporary separating
shutters. The coarse aggregate was Carboniferous limestone supplied from a
commercial quarry some 15 km distant and the fine aggregate was imported
natural sand. At horizontal construction joints a retarding agent was sprayed on
to the concrete after placing to enable the removal of surface laitance the following
day by air/water jetting.
35. Although water tanks were insulated, other methods for lowering the
temperatureof constituent materials were not economically possible, andthe
specified placing temperature of 12°C could not be achieved during the summer
months. With 120 simple thermocouples installed, the highest temperature rise of
26.5"C was recorded in the upstream facing concrete 0.2 m from the surface. The
ambient temperature during the pour was 20°C. In the same pour a temperature
rise of 23.5"C was recorded 0.5 m from the upstream surface. The lowest
temperature rise of 18°C in the facing concrete was recorded in concrete placed in
November 1978 whenthe ambient temperature was low.Some minor cracking did
occur and for a short time the PFA content was increased from 25% to 30%
cement replacement in an attempt to reduce temperature rise, but as no significant
reduction was recorded no general change was made to the mix.
36. Plasti-coated plywood formwork produced a satisfactory surface finish on
vertical faces but (as is not unusual) surface flaws caused by entrapped bubbles of
air or water were common on the sloping surfaces in spite of careful attention to
Hearting
I Facing
192
Downloaded by [ UNIVERSITY OF SHEFFIELD] on [16/09/16]. Copyright © ICE Publishing, all rights reserved.
KIELDER T R A N S F E R WORKS
vibration and mix design. By using a hardboard peg-board liner to the shutter
some improvement was achieved but this proved to be not only time-consuming
but costly and was not adopted generally. Flaws on the surface of the sloping
overflow were filled witha mortar containing asynthetic liquid rubber with better
curing properties than conventional cement mortar, but elsewhere no corrective
treatment was applied as the flaws were not considered to present a long term
durability problem.
37. Eightpneumatic disc piezometerswere installed at the concrete/rock
interface at two sections of the concrete dam to allow comparison with design
uplift assumptions which were a straight line distribution from full water head at
the upstreamface to tail waterhead at the downstream toe. Mildsteelmesh
reinforcement is included in the top 4 m of the overflow section to accommodate
ice loading.
38. Thetops of the non-overflowsections incorporatingthe walkway and
parapet walls are of precast concrete units 1.5 m long and were accurately set by a
simple levelling device cast into each unit and dowelled into the concrete of the
dam. Only thefloor sections of the 20 mm gap between precast units were filled.
39. The embankment flanks to the dam have a maximum height of 7 m above
general foundation level and Fig. 16 shows a typical cross-section. Steps between
the parapet walls of the concrete dam link the footpath on the embankmentcrest
to the walkway of the concrete dam. The clay fill was obtained from a borrow pit
upstream of and adjacent to the north side of the dam. A clay fraction of 21%,
moisture content of 13%, plasticity index of 18% and undrained shear strength of
155 kN/m2 were the average parameters obtained from tests on the fill. It was
assumed conservatively that 4' was 30". The clay was placed in 225 mm thick
layers and compacted by vibratory rollers producing average air voids of 4.5% as
measured by the sandreplacement method.
Tunnel route
40. The abrupt changein the direction of flow on the River Tees at Eggleston
(Fig. 1) determined the discharge point and level for the tunnel. The target route
for the transfer works passes through Derwent Reservoir and it was originally
thought that not only could the overall yield of the scheme have been augmented
by using that reservoir but also it could formpart of the transfer works with tunnel
portals at the north and south banks.However,because of the possibility of
eutrophication, an alternative headpond location was sought and finally located at
Footpath m
Granular 11 er
Scale of metres
5
-O
Downloaded by [ UNIVERSITY OF SHEFFIELD] on [16/09/16]. Copyright © ICE Publishing, all rights reserved.
COATS, B E R R Y AND BANKS
Airy Holm. The location of this headpond influenced the starting point for the
tunnel system at Letch House. It was at first intended that tunnelling from Letch
House would start at anormalportal and would discharge into Airy Holm
headpond, with normal draw-off facilities incorporated in the dam linking to a
tunnel driven to the Derwent valley. However, there were open-cast coal
operations at Letch House and decomposed sandstone in the Airy Holm area. To
avoid these features, it was economical to drop the tunnel invert level at Letch
House to give adequate rock cover, to tunnel underneath the Airy Holm pond in
sound rock below the decomposed sandstone andto link the tunnel to the
headpond by a simple inlet/outlet shaft (Fig. 15).
41. The tunnel portal site at north Derwent had considerable cover to rock,
and a short length of tunnel using soft ground techniques was necessary before
reaching a rock portal. A 2.89 m dia. buried pipeline links the north Derwent and
south Derwent portals. The direct route from the south Derwent portal to the
crossing of the River Wear valley would have passed under Waskerley Reservoir,
designed by Thomas Hawksley,* and the line was moved slightly to theeast where
an air shaft of 765 mm lined diameter and 135 m deep could be sunk to tunnel
level. In order to allow the tunnel to be driven from both the Derwent and the
Wear valleys on a rising grade an air shaft was necessary but for hydraulic reasons
only a very flat gradient of about 1 in 1000 was possible. The tunnel portals at the
Wear and Tees valleys are conventional rock portals with the tunnel line being a
straight line between them. Again for hydraulic reasons the tunnel gradients had to
be about 1 in l o o 0 and an air shaft was required at Sharnberry. The Ordnance
Survey established co-ordinated reference pedestals near each portal of the longer
tunnels from Derwent to Tees from which the tunnels were driven to line and level.
Experimental tunnel
42. It was considered in 1970, at a very early stage of development of the
scheme, that, with over 30 km of rock tunnelling envisaged, a specially constructed
experimental tunnel with trials in the three main rock types likely to be met in the
main tunnels would be justified in addition to normal site investigations. The
Northumbrian Water Authority, the Building Research Establishment and the
Water Research Centre collaborated in carrying out the experimental work and in
financing it.
43. An inclined adit was driven from the floor of a disused quarry near to the
odrd
line the main tunnel and horizontal tunnels were driven at three levels off it. Not
only this experimental tunnel allow useful research to be c a r r i e d o ~ t ~ -but
provided contractors tendering for the main tunnelling contracts with the
~ ' it
Site investigations
44. Before the start of a detailed site investigation a desk study was carried out
by the Institute of Geological Scienceswhenall relevant published data,
information from local mining activities and open-cast coal operations etc. were
examined. These indicated that the proposed line and level of the tunnels would
encounter rock suitable for tunnelling, with the Letch House to Derwent section
passing through the Lower Coal Measures and the Durham Millstone Grit with
sandstone
the predominant rock, and the Derwent-Wear-Tees tunnels
194
Downloaded by [ UNIVERSITY OF SHEFFIELD] on [16/09/16]. Copyright © ICE Publishing, all rights reserved.
KlELDER T R A N S F E R WORKS
l
0 5 10 15 20 25 30
Kllornetres
(4
Limestone
Sandstone
Mudstone
Mlxed beds
Dolerlte
Fault zone
1978
1980
1981
1982
(C)
Fig. 17. (a) Longitudinal section of tunnel works; (b) geology encountered in tunnel;
(c) time-way of driving and lining
54002400
43 000 mm
19000 mm
I
197-
Downloaded by [ UNIVERSITY OF SHEFFIELD] on [16/09/16]. Copyright © ICE Publishing, all rights reserved.
COATS,BERRY A N D B A N K S
W W W W rg
I W W W W W
m
l wl
h(
a z
3
m
0
ri
a
ri
PI
CI
8
W
S
ri
W
S
m
r-
A-
i
* 0 0 0
B$ E 2 2 2 ;0
+
+
S
S
S m
0
v) +
0
198
Downloaded by [ UNIVERSITY OF SHEFFIELD] on [16/09/16]. Copyright © ICE Publishing, all rights reserved.
K I E L D E R TRANSFER W O R K S
Tunnel driving
47.. The 6 m dia. by 22 m deep shaft at Letch House was sunk mainly through
competent, moderately jointed sandstone and a pre-splitting technique was used.
From Letch House to Derwent the tunnel lieslargelyin sandstone and the
contractor elected to drive by drill and blast methods to a D shaped profile before
lining to a circular profile.25The main driving equipment consisted of a Tamrock
twin-boom rail-mounted compressed air drilling jumboandan electrically
powered Hagloader together with Hagglund cars. Owing to the risk of
encountering methane from the old mine workings above the tunnel level it had
been specified that all equipment would be flame-proofed and this included the 5 t
and 10 t Clayton locomotives used for tunnel haulage. The main driving was
undertaken by the above equipment but two subsidiary drives from the shaft at
Airy Holm and a short section of the drive from north Derwent was undertaken
using conventional air legs and an Eimco loader together with small mine cars.
Progress on the highly mechanized drive averaged just under 38 m/week and on
the Eimco drives averaged 23/m week.
48. Although the general rock types encountered in the Letch House to
Derwent tunnel were very much as forecast, the degree of weathering of the rock
significantly slowed down progress, causing a large number of misfires, the need to
use relatively short pulls and continual problems with slurry in the tunnel invert.
Support where required was almost entirely colliery arches and the contractor’s
ambitious plan at the time of tender to use rock-bolting extensivelynever
materialized. However,just over 50% of the tunnel required no support at all. Fig.
18 shows a typical view of the tunnel before lining.
49. For the long tunnels between Derwent and Tees, contracts were advertised
in Europe aswell as in the UK and tenders were invited from consortia which were
required to include at least one UK firm. In preparing their tenders, tenderers were
entitled to take into account all the geological and site investigation information
provided, and excavation for tunnels wasbilled by the lineal meter with the
contractor required to cover all temporary or primary support inhis rate for
excavation. The lowest tender was submitted by a consortium of two German
firms and one UK firm and they proposed a rock classification system based on
temporary supportcriteria which isnot uncommon on the Continent.
50. Following discussion with them, a classification system26was agreed based
essentially on the type of rock encountered in the roof of the tunnel and not on the
actual support installed. The six classifications agreed can be approximately
summarized as follows :
Class 1 Good quality sandstone or limestone
Class 2 Poor quality sandstone or limestone; very good quality mudstone
or shale
Class 3 Good quality mudstone or mixed beds
Class 4 Poor quality mudstone or mixed beds; fault boundary conditions
Class 5 Fault conditions
Class 6 Rock conditions in which excavation by full-face machine was not
possible.
(Class 6 was subsequently deleted from the contract as it was agreed by both the
Contractor and the Engineer that all the forecast rock conditions could be dealt
with by the tunnelling machines and hence rock which could not be excavated by
machine would be a circumstance covered by clause 12 of the ICE conditions of
199
Downloaded by [ UNIVERSITY OF SHEFFIELD] on [16/09/16]. Copyright © ICE Publishing, all rights reserved.
COATS. BERRY AND BANKS
- N m
S v ?
ov,
W
N
200
Downloaded by [ UNIVERSITY OF SHEFFIELD] on [16/09/16]. Copyright © ICE Publishing, all rights reserved.
KIELDER TRANSFER WORKS
contract.) The bill rates for excavation would be adjusted by pre-agreed amounts
depending on rock classification.The system is described more fully el~ewhere~~.~*
and although it operated satisfactorily on this contract it is appreciated that its
success was largelydue to awillingness by both Engineer and Contractor tomake
the system work.
51. Thecontractor elected to use full-face
tunnelling machine^.^'*^^-^^
Initially it was intended to use two DemagTBM 34-38 full-face machines (Fig. 19)
but owing to the slower than anticipated progress with the Demag machines the
contractor brought in a Robbins 123-133 tunnelling machine (Fig. 20) and this
was eventually usedon two of the four drives. The average rate of progress on the
drivesfromthe Wear. valleyusingthe Demag machineswas just under
200 m/month whereas on the 8 km long Tees drivethe Robbins machine averaged
over
300 m/month. Even more striking, however, is the rate of nearly
600 m/month attained on the short 3 km section of the Derwent to Waskerley
drive driven bythe Robbins machine whenthe contractorused a three-shift system
instead of the two-shift system operated on the rest of the contract. An excellent
excavated profile was generally obtained with full-face tunnelling machines (Fig.
21).
52. The use of shotcrete was discussed extensively with the contractor before
the tunnel driving started, particularly in the light of the very successful trials with
shotcrete in the experimental tunnel. However,in practice shotcrete was used only
to a very limited extent and the main support system used in about 80% of the
tunnel was rock bolts and mesh. Steel arches were used extensively in the portal
area and combined with Bernold sheets were used in faults and other difficult rock
conditions. Rather surprisingly, less than 10% of the tunnel was driven without
any supportin comparison with over 50% unsupported in the drill and blast Letch
House to Derwent tunnel. The primary reason for this is of course the need to
supportthe shouldersin a circulardriventunnelwhereasinsimilarrock
conditions in a tunnel driven bydrill and blast the shoulder blocks fallout, leaving
the typical square profile.However, theinstallation of rockboltswashighly
mechanized and had little effect on progress.
53. The machinescopedwithvaryingdegrees of successwithdifficultrock
~ o n d i t i o n s . ~ The
~ , ~Demag
~ . ~ ~was
, ~ particularly
~ susceptible to roof problems
owing to the difficulty of installing early support, whereas the Robbins, with its
provision for installing bolts or steel arches a few metres from the machine head,
was able to copevery successfully withall the rock conditions encountered.
54. In order to provide capacity for air during surge conditions, enlargements
(Fig. 22) wereconstructed at the air shafts at both Waskerley and Sharnberry. The
air shafts had been excavated to 900 mm dia. by a Wirth LA drilling rig equipped
for both conventional and reverse circulation drilling and were lined to 750 mm
dia. by steel casing, with the annular space grouted from the bottom before tunnel
driving reached them.
55. The lengths of tunnels driven and lined from each portal are given in Table
2. The steel lining was at theportals.
Tunnel lining
56. The lining of the Letch House to Derwent tunnel and the Derwent to Tees
tunnel is described in detail by FawcettZ5 andMa~terton.~" The lining of tunnels
wasdesigned as a nominal200mmthickness of 30 MN/m2 concretewith a
circular profile (Fig. 23), and in all sections thecontractors elected to line
201
Downloaded by [ UNIVERSITY OF SHEFFIELD] on [16/09/16]. Copyright © ICE Publishing, all rights reserved.
COATS, BERRY AND BANKS
continuously, the concrete being placed using Schwing concrete pumps through a
150 mm dia. steel placer pipe. The telescopic shutters used were 60 m long in the
drill-and-blast-driven Letch House to Derwent tunnel and 54 m long in the largely
machine-driven Derwent to Tees tunnels. The specified minimum striking time for
theshutters was 12 h but on the machine-driven tunnels it was on occasion
reduced to 10 h. However, care had to be taken to avoid damage to the concrete
surface if shutters were struck too early. Table 3 shows how sensitive the volume of
concrete required for tunnel lining is to changes in the effective driven diameter
and shape of the tunnel. The increased volume of concrete required in a drill and
blast tunnel is quite significant when a comparison of costs is being made between
driving by full-face machine and driving by drill and blast. As could reasonably
have been expected, the grout take inthe drill and blast tunnel is also substantially
greater than in the machine-driven tunnel.
57. The time interval between tunnel driving and the lining varied as shown in
Fig. 17. Before lining, the rock profile either was self-supporting or appeared to
have been stabilized by temporary supports. However, in machine-driven sections
of the tunnel instrumentation was installed in the concrete lining at four locations
to try to assess rock loading on the permanent lining. Three of these locations were
at fault zones; the fourth was in a self-supporting limestone. observation^^'.^^
showed that some rock loading of the concrete lining had takenplace inthe faulted
zones but very little, if any, short term loading of the lining had taken place at the
unsupported section of tunnel. The measurements also show that grouting
operations have a significant loading effect on the tunnel lining where large voids
have beenfilled andgrouting also has the desirable effectof inducing a
compressive stress into the lining, thus reducing any tensile strains that may have
developed.
58. As is not uncommon in cast-in-situ concrete tunnel linings, circumferential
cracks developed. A detailed survey was carried out in three lengths of the tunnels,
each about l o o 0 m long. The first length was in a section excavated by drill and
blast methods where the average crack spacing was about 10 m and all cracks
went round the complete circumference of the tunnel. The other two sections
surveyed were both in machine-excavated lengths of tunnel and cracking was
observed to be less, although the pattern of cracking in these two sections was
202
Downloaded by [ UNIVERSITY OF SHEFFIELD] on [16/09/16]. Copyright © ICE Publishing, all rights reserved.
KIELDER TRANSFER W O R K S
dissimilar. No clear conclusions cquld be reached other than that cracking is more
likely the greater the lining thickness.
Valley crossings
59. The aqueduct crosses the Derwent and Wear valleysin2.89 m nominal
diameter buried steel pipelines whichgenerally have concrete surrounds because of
the risk of flotation in the river valley sections. The steel pipe is taken into the
tunnel until the rock cover is adequate to resist the full water head. The final
section of the aqueduct at Tees is also 2.89 m dia. steel pipe. The steel pipes,
including the sections in the tunnels, were lined throughout with 12.5 mm thick
cement mortar.
Discharge works
60.An unusual feature of the Kielder transfer works is the total absence of
in-line valving, allcontrol being effected by the discharge valve at the rivers Wear
and Tees. The general arrangement of the Tees works is shown in Fig. 24 and the
works at Wear are similar. The submerged discharge valves allow both the control
of the flow and the dissipation of head through the valve and into a reinforced
concrete sump which is protected by a double coating of reinforced glass fibre.The
valves are ported to give linear discharge characteristics over their entire range of
operation and the electrical operation is arranged to ensure that the operating
time (15 min in the case of the Tees discharge works) is long enough to minimize
surge problems.
61. For security and aesthetic reasons the size of the structures was kept to a
minimum, and apart from the discharge channel the only above-ground works are
the small reinforced concrete buildings required to accommodate the telemetry.
The magnetic flowmeters and the protecting upstream butterfly valves are
accommodated in separate underground chambers.
62. In order to deal with the discharge of very small flows of water which may
be required in order to keep water in the tunnel from becoming deoxygenated,
203
Downloaded by [ UNIVERSITY OF SHEFFIELD] on [16/09/16]. Copyright © ICE Publishing, all rights reserved.
C O A T S , BERRY AND BANKS
provision has also been made for 300 mm dia. in-line flow control valves capable
of discharging up to23 000 m3/d into thetunnel drain system.
Acknowledgements
63. The Authors thank MrW. F. Ridley, Chief Executiveof the Northumbrian
Water Authority for permission to publish this Paper. They also wish to thank
officers and staff of the authority and members of staff of BabtieShaw and
Morton, who havebeen most helpful in providing information and in other ways
assisting in the preparationof the Paper.
Downloaded by [ UNIVERSITY OF SHEFFIELD] on [16/09/16]. Copyright © ICE Publishing, all rights reserved.
KIELDER T R A N S F E R WORKS
Pumping main
Length 6200 m
Pipe ,diameter 2.020 m o.d., spirally welded
Grade of steel 50B and 43A to BS 4360
Wall thickness 14 mm to 10 mm
Internal protection 1 1 mm thick minimum Cement mortar lining
External protection 6 mm minimum bituminous compound to
BS 4147 type 2, grade A, reinforced
with glass tissue and glass cloth;
joint protection by cold-applied tape
Cathodic protection Impressed current system
Valve control No in-line valves but 375 mm orifice dia.
anti-vacuum valves at all major summits
and Apex air valves and drain valves
elsewhere
205
Downloaded by [ UNIVERSITY OF SHEFFIELD] on [16/09/16]. Copyright © ICE Publishing, all rights reserved.
COATS, BERRY AND BANKS
Downloaded by [ UNIVERSITY OF SHEFFIELD] on [16/09/16]. Copyright © ICE Publishing, all rights reserved.
KIELDER TRANSFER W O R K S
References
1. COATSD. J. and RUFFLEN. The Kielder water scheme. Proc. Instn Civ. Engrs, Part 1,
1982,12, May, 135-147.
2. HYDRAULICS RESEARCH STATION.Water abstraction station and control weir on the River
Tyne at Riding Mill. HRS. Wallingford, 1975,report EX 702.
3. Interaction of trench materials with a buried steel pipeline containing a single mitre
bend and remote anchorages. ConstructionIndustry Research and Information
Association, London, currentresearch project 286.
4. ELLISJ. et al. Surge protection of the Kielder water scheme transfer works. Proc. Instn
Ciu. Engrs, Part 1, 1978.64, May, 227-246.
5. BANKS D.J. et al. Riding Mill pumping station. J. Instn Wat. Engrs Sci., 1981,35, Nov.,
No.6,463482.
6. Semi-sphericaljoints for large diameter steel pipes. Pipes Pipelines, 1978, Nov., 763-766.
7. PERFECT H. G. Airv Holm dam-Kielder water scheme. Wat. Serv.. 1981. AuP.. 389-392.
8 BINNIEG. M. Eahy Victorian water engineers, Thomas Telford Ltd,’ Loidon, 1981,
149-153.
9 PRIEST S . D. and HUDSONJ. A. Rock quality in the Kielder experimental tunnel. Co.
Durham. Transport and Road Research Laboratory, Crowthorne, 1975,
supplementary report 173 UC.
10. WARD W. H. et al. Performance of tunnelsupport systems in the FourFathom
Mudstone. Tunnelling 76. Institution of Mining and Metallurgy, London, 329-340.
(Also Building Research Establishment current paperCP 25/76.)
11. HILLSD.L. Sprayed concrete-site trials. Building Research Establishment, Garston,
1976 (unpublished note).
12. HILLSD.L. Sprayed concrete-interim report No. 2. Building Research Establishment,
Garston, 1976(unpublished note).
13. HILLSD. L. Sprayed concrete-interim report No. I . Building Research Establishment,
Garston, 1975(unpublished note).
14. WARDW. H. and HILLSD. L. Sprayed concrete: tunnel support requirements and the
dry mix process. Shotcrete for ground support: proc. engineeringfoundation conference,
American Society of Civil Engineers and American Concrete Institute, 1977. ASCE, New
York, publication SP-54, 475-532. (Also Building Research Establishment current
paper CP18/77.)
15. WARDW. H. and HILLSD.L. Kielder trial tunnel: sprayed concrete extension. Building
Research Establishment, Garston, 1978, current paper CP73/78.
16. LONGWORTH T. I. and TWD P.Logging of joints in Carboniferous rocks in the Kielder
experimental tunnel. Building Research Establishment, Garston, 1978 (unpublished
note).
17. FREEMAN T. J. The behaviour offully-bonded rock bolts in the Kielder experimental tunnel.
Building Research Establishment, Garston, 1978,current paperCP64/78.
18. WARDW. H. Ground supports for tunnels in weak rocks. Giotechnique, 1978,28, No. 2,
133-171.
19. TEDD P. The BRE rock extensometer. Building Research Establishment, Garston, 1979
(unpublished note).
20. WARDW. H. et al. (Building Research Establishment and Bablie Shaw & Morton).
Kielder experimental tunnel: results of five years’ work. (In preparation.)
207
Downloaded by [ UNIVERSITY OF SHEFFIELD] on [16/09/16]. Copyright © ICE Publishing, all rights reserved.
COATS, BERRY AND BANKS
208
Downloaded by [ UNIVERSITY OF SHEFFIELD] on [16/09/16]. Copyright © ICE Publishing, all rights reserved.