Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
Introduction
The Ummah is in grave condition. Presently the Ummah is being stepped on, humiliated,
ridiculed, massacred, colonized, robbed of its rich resources or defeated. It has been
called names such as terrorist, backward, fanatic, and other such demeaning names. The
Ummah is being attacked from within and without. The Muslims are being secularized,
westernized and de-Islamized. They are loosing their identity to foreign ideologies such
as hedonism, materialism, existentialism, and other isms. The worst scenario is the
Ummah is in continuous war with each other. The pictures that the Ummah paints for the
outside world are not pretty. This is made worst with the help of biased media which are
The irony is that the Muslims are the richest people in the world yet they died because of
starvation. They have in their possession rich natural resources yet the disparity between
the haves and the haves not is very great in the Muslims world. The rich has no
compassion toward the poor. They have the most realistic and practical method of living
in their possession but they change it to the very system that destroys their identity and
civilization. The colonial powers have succeeded in dividing the Muslims into several
small countries and turned them against each other. To ensure the perpetuation of their
ideologies, the colonialists appointed the local elites who were educated in western
institutions to lead the country after independence. These political leaders dance to the
tunes of their western masters. They oppressed their own brothers for the satisfaction and
1
Economically, the Muslims are backward. Most of them are illiterate. They depend on
the west to provide them with food and services. Western colonialists feed their mind
with consumerism, thus create vast markets for their consumer products. Western
imperialists are not concerned with developing the countries they invaded but they are
concerned with making more profits by ensuring that the Muslims are in constant demand
for their products. Even though physically the Muslims are independent, but their minds
are still being colonized. Western imperialists constantly feed the minds of Muslims with
the superiority of western cultures through the media. Such is the state of the Ummah.
The Ummah has lost its fine culture and civilization. Westernized political leaders did
not comprehend the very fact that the Ummah is in such sorry state is because they
abandon their own belief for secularism. They naively thought that the predicament that
they are in is because of they are not modern and developed yet. So they find ways to
delivering the Ummah from further destruction. One most effective way is through
education system. The education system prevalent in the Muslims world is the exact
copy of their western counterparts. The end result is the Ummah is experiencing a
progressive erosion of culture and civilization. The Ummah is in a hurry to emulate the
Therefore, it is imperative that the Ummah scrutinizes its education system and find
faults within the system. In order to make judgment on the current state of Muslims
2
education system, it is very significant to understand what education from Islamic
perspective is. Hence, the purpose of this paper is to expound the concept of education in
Islam. The confusion in the meaning of education will lead to the selection of wrong
aims and objectives of education which will affect the selection of contents of education.
The precise definition is crucial since it determines the framework of education. Thus, the
decision on content selections and programs of education becomes less problematic and
within the scope of Islamic education. Loose definition will allow irrelevant contents,
methods, and assessment to permeate into the framework of Islamic education which will
affect the outcomes of the education system. Hence this paper will first define education
from Islamic perspective followed by the aim and objectives of Islamic education. Then
this paper will compare the aim of Islamic education to the aim of secular education. The
subsequent discussion is on the root cause of the Muslims’ dilemma which is prevalent
through out the Muslim World. Before conclusion, this paper will present several
In his book titled The Concept of Education in Islam, Syed Muhammad Naquib Al-Attas
(1980) asserts that “education is something progressively instilled into man” (p. 13).
Education here is not a process but content. The “something” in the definition of
education is the content of education that is instilled into man. The word instill suggests
3
be the truth. Who and what determines the truth? From Islamic perspective, the truth is
determined through the signs of Allah which are the Qur’an and Sunnah, the open book
understand the definition of man, aql, meaning, amal, justice, and wisdom first since
these terms are related to the concept of education in Islam. This paper then will discuss
the Arabic word that denotes education which encompasses the comprehensive meaning
of education. The discussion about the concept of education will be based on Syed
Nature of Man
First we have to understand the meaning of man because man is the one who is being
educated. The contents of education will be determined by the nature of man. Man is
born with fitrah which means that he has recognized that Allah is his Creator innately but
with the potential of being a nonbeliever. Therefore, he has to protect himself from
external agents of misguidance with the help of external divine agents which are the
prophets and the revelation from Allah (Yasein 1998). Man has dual nature, the physical
(body) and the abstract (mind and soul). Man’s physical nature is an agent that feeds the
soul with information through sense perception and rational perception so that meaning
between heart and body because the heart depends on the body to provide them with
information through the sense faculties and reason; and the body depends on the heart to
4
liberate it from succumbing to its lower nafs. Concisely, both dimensions of man must
We have mentioned that rational perception and spiritual perception are done in two
separate faculties. According to Yasien (1998), rational perception is done in the mind.
The locus of the mind is the brain. It is “capable of reasoning which is the projection of
aql on the mental plane” (p. 92). We know that man differs from other animals because
man is bestowed with the ability to reason and communicate using language through
speech. The process of articulating words in meaningful structures is done in the aql
(mental plane). Al-Attas (1980) defines aql as “an innate property that binds and
withholds the objects of knowledge by means of words” (p. 14). He claims that aql and
qalb (heart) are synonymous. Spiritual perception is done in the aql. Aql is capable of
both reasoning and intellection i.e. comprehending revealed knowledge. Qalb (heart) is
the locus of aql. This means that the function of the heart is not only to pump blood to
the entire body but also as an organ of spiritual cognition (Acikgenc 1996). The Qur’an
Have they not traveled through the land so that they have hearts to think with, and
ears to hear with? It is not the (physical) eyes that are blind, but the hearts within
5
From this exposition, we conclude that man is dual in nature; however both the physical
Man is equipped with reason and aql so that he is capable of making judgment and
formulating meaning. Language is the tool that man use to make judgment and
understand meaning. What does it mean when we say that we understand the meaning of
anything in a system which occurs when the relation a thing has with others in the system
becomes clarified and understood” (p. 15). What he means by this statement is that we
cannot understand the meaning of a thing without recognizing its different position in
relation to other things and without making connection and association with other things.
For example, we can only understand the meaning of an object called “pen” when we
associate it with writing. To know the object “pen” is merely information, to understand
the meaning of a pen is to recognize its position in relation to writing. Therefore, the
meaning of a thing is the purpose of that thing. Furthermore, if we ask a person who
never heard of the word “axiology” before, he could not understand its meaning because
he could not make the connection between axiology and other concepts that are stored in
his memory. He does not know where to place axiology in his mind and he does not
6
Meaning has close connection with knowledge because we acquire knowledge after the
transform or change a person for the better. Information without meaning is mere speck
of data contained in one’s brain. When information is related and associated with other
information in the brain which resulted in using the information for specific purposes,
then the information contains meaning which makes it knowledge. Hence, information
that gives meaning to one’s soul can only be considered as knowledge. Al-Attas (1980)
defines knowledge as “the arrival in the soul of the meaning of a thing or an object of
knowledge” (p. 17). We have clarified that meaning of a thing is not the thing
independent of reality but the meaning of a thing is other than what the thing really is.
Thus, the meaning of knowledge is not knowledge for the sake of knowledge but the
meaning of knowledge is the purpose of seeking the knowledge. The true purpose of
We have demonstrated that we understand meaning of a thing when the relationship the
thing has with other things is understood. To understand the meaning of knowledge, we
have to understand it in relation to man and education. Knowledge is the method or tool
to discipline the body, mind and soul of a man. We have also established that is
knowledge. Thus, knowledge that should be the content of education is knowledge of the
alone does not make education complete. To render education an education, recognition
7
of the knowledge must be followed by acknowledgement of the knowledge. In other
words, after one recognizes his "proper place in the order of creation, such that it leads to
the recognition of the proper place of God in the order of being and existence” (p. 18),
that it leads to the recognition and acknowledgement of the proper place of God in the
Ontologically, things are arranged hierarchically in their proper places. For example, in a
family the father is the leader. The leader of all prophets is Prophet Muhammad (SAW).
The condition of things being in their proper places is called justice (adl). Hence, when
we leveled the Prophet (SAW) at the same level with other men, we are doing injustice to
ourselves and others. Injustice brings disorder and chaos. In order for a man to make the
correct judgment of the proper places of things, he must have wisdom. Wisdom is the
knowledge given by God so that man who has wisdom can evaluate things justly. It is
the purpose of education to produce man of wisdom who perpetuates the condition of
how to be just to the self, family, society, the environment, and to Allah. Furthermore, if
we replace the phrase ‘the proper places of things in the order of creations’ with the word
8
justice, such that it leads to recognition and acknowledgement of Allah as the source of
justice. If man has recognizes and acknowledges justice, the end result is man of
wisdom.
All the concepts that this paper has discussed is related closely with the meaning of
education in Islam. Now that we understand those concepts, we can conclude that the
man, of the proper places of things in the order of creation, such that it leads to the
recognition and acknowledgment of the proper place of god in the order of being and
existence” (Al-Attas 1980, p. 21). Our next task is to match this definition to the accurate
Arabic word.
We have established that the content of education is the knowledge of the purpose of
recognizes and acknowledges his proper place in the order of creation, such that he
recognizes and acknowledges Allah’s proper place in the order of being and existence. It
means that man who practices what he had learnt and knows his station in relation to
Allah. After he bears witness that Allah is his Creator, he acknowledges it through right
actions. The right actions are determined by the Qur’an and Sunnah. In other words,
man who uses wisdom to generate the condition of justice. Therefore, according to Al-
Attas, the correct word to represent this is adab since adab is the discipline of the body,
the mind, and the soul so that it brings the condition of justice.
9
Adab
Adab is the discipline that ensures the recognition and acknowledgement of one’s station
in the hierarchical order of creation; the discipline that enables man to recognize his
position in relation to Allah. In other words, the discipline that ensures man to say in
wisdom” (p. 22). Adab includes both iman and amal. Therefore adab is the knowledge
of the purpose of seeking it which is the same with the content of education. Hence we
can conclude that education is ta’dib – the noun of the word adab. This claim is strongly
‘My Lord educate (addaba) me and made my education (ta’dib) most excellent’
(reported by Al-Askari).
وأحسنواأدبهم أدبواأولدكم
“Educate (addibu) your children and improve their adab” (reported by Ibnu Majah
The term ta’dib is encompassing both the education of body and the soul. The discipline
of the body does not mean the physical strength or health education only but includes all
education which will ensure man’s sustenance in this world such as means of generating
10
income, social responsibilities, environmental responsibilities, and etc. In other words, to
discipline the body, one has to have knowledge on how to manage the system; which is
physical self through mental faculty which is located in the brain. Thus, Allah has
bestowed upon man reason in order to understand the knowledge of fardh kifayah.
Ta’dib also refers to the discipline of the mind and soul. Man is endowed with
intellection faculty which is located in the heart so that he could understand revealed
knowledge in order to discipline his soul. Thus, man could discipline his mind and soul
through the knowledge of fardhu ain which is received through the heart (qalb). Since
heart is the king in man’s little kingdom, heart must be disciplined first. This is in line
الوهي القلب
“Behold, within the body is a lump of meat, if it is good the whole body is good,
and if it is rotten the whole body is rotten. Behold, that lump of meat is the heart”
(reported by Bukhari and Muslim from Abu Abdillah An-Numan ibnu Basyir).
The Prophet (SAW) said that if the heart is disciplined to recognize and act according to
what is ordained by Allah, the physical body will be saved from destruction of following
the lower nafs. Therefore, to have knowledge on how to discipline the heart is obligatory
to every Muslim man and woman. This revealed knowledge is called knowledge of fardh
ain. Thus when ta’dib is used to denote education, it means that education which include
11
both knowledge i.e. knowledge of how to manage self so that man can become an abd
(servant); and knowledge of how to manage the system so that man can fulfill his
disciplines; hence, the end result of ta’dib is man of adab or man who brings justice with
his wisdom.
The aim of Islamic education is to produce good man. Good man means man of adab.
Man who recognizes his station in relation to Allah, his society, his self, and other beings;
and act accordingly so that he produces the condition of justice with his wisdom. Man
who recognizes and acknowledges his role as servant and vicegerent in this world. Good
man is a man who possesses the knowledge to manage his self and the system that he
lives in. In other words, man who recognizes that Allah is his Creator and manifests his
conviction through right actions. Right actions are determined by the Qur’an and the
Prophet’s (SAW) traditions. Concisely, good man is a man who emulates the Prophet
(SAW) as close as possible. To be good man is to be good both to the self and the
society.
Therefore, good man subsumes good citizen. Good man is a man who is successful in
this world and in the hereafter because he removes every obstacle that comes between
him and Allah. According to Al-Ghazali, the purpose of man’s life is to gain happiness
in this world and in the hereafter. Therefore, he concludes that the aim of Islamic
education is to cultivate man so that he follows the teaching of the Qur’an and the Sunnah
12
to ensure eternal happiness in the hereafter (Nofal 1993). Good man defines himself as
an abd which assures eternal relationship with Allah; and accepts the role as vicegerent
which makes him the manager of the systems that ensure justice is done to the occupants
of the earth and to the planet earth itself. Man who does justice to himself, to society he
belongs to, to other creatures of Allah, and to the environment he lives in is the man who
serves Allah in totality. Therefore, the ultimate aim of Islamic education is to actualize
I have only created Jinns and men, that they may serve Me (Az-Zariyat (51): 56).
Man who lives his entire life to submit to Allah alone is a man who is responsible and
amanah when they manage the system. Therefore justice will prevail in the society;
Secular education comes in many forms such as liberal education, democratic education,
existentialism, and other isms. The common aim of these types of education is to
equipped students for worldly life. Their utmost concern is to transfer as much
information as possible so that students can be marketable in the job market or to give
them skill to function in a given society. For example, one form of secular education is
13
This paper will illustrate a brief overview of Dewey’s aim of education. In his book
titled Democracy and Education, Dewey (1916) asserts that in an ideal democratic
society where everybody has equal opportunity “the aim of education is to enable
individuals to continue their education -- or that the object and reward of learning is
continued capacity for growth” (Chapter 8 p. 1). He further claims that since an ideal
state of democracy is not possible, aim of education must come within the education
process not from the without which is clearly stated in the statements below:
In our search for aims in education, we are not concerned, therefore, with finding
whole conception forbids. We are rather concerned with the contrast which exists
when aims belong within the process in which they operate and when they are set
up from without. And the latter state of affairs must obtain when social
relationships are not equitably balanced. For in that case, some portions of the
whole social group will find their aims determined by an external dictation; their
aims will not arise from the free growth of their own experience, and their
nominal aims will be means to more ulterior ends of others rather than truly their
own (Chapter 8 p. 1)
He believes that aim of education must appear from internal i.e. within the education
system which means he advocated learner centered design of education system. The
society has no influence in manipulating the aim of education. The danger of this
philosophy is that it will create unbalanced individuals who could not perform well
man does not know what is good for him, what more young students. If man knows what
14
is good and what is bad for him, there will be no destruction in this world. The truth is
only Allah knows what is good and what is bad for man. Therefore, letting the students
to dictate what they want to learn is letting them to do injustice toward themselves. This
philosophy will also produce students who are concerned with their own personal growth
Democracy from Islamic perspective is only to decide particular issues when the
available choices are permissible according to Islamic jurisprudence. For example, one
can practice democracy in deciding whether to use problem based learning or contextual
obligatory for every Muslim man and woman, therefore it must be included in the content
of education. Muslim students cannot vote this subject out of the content of education.
Dewey’s concern is to produce individuals who possess the capacity to grow. The aim of
education are not determined by the market forces but by the students’ own interest.
Conversely, the aim of education which has been practiced almost every where in the
world today is to produce citizens who are able to develop their country economically.
Content of education are determined by industrial needs. Therefore, more and more
subjects on values are sidelined; sometimes discarded all together from the content of
education. This is the reality that one cannot deny because it happens ubiquitously. The
utmost concern of today’s education is to produce individuals who can produce more
15
products effectively, therefore bring more profits to the organizations that they work for.
Muslim world emphasizes contents and knowledge that can produce skilled and
professional citizens. Students are more concerned with filling up their minds with as
much information as possible so that they can excel in examination. Their motivation to
learn is not because they want to be good men and women but to enter into prestigious
higher learning institutions so that they could secure good jobs after they graduated. The
consequence is they learn what ever the market dictates them to learn. The result is
Muslims are lacking in knowledge to manage self, thus inflict injustice to themselves and
others. This is what Al-Attas called the condition of loss of adab. He defines loss of
adab as
the loss of capacity for discernment of the right and proper places of things,
resulting the leveling of all to the same level; in the confusion of the order of
nature as arranged according to their maratib and darajat; in the undermining the
Loss of adab is the result of confusion and error in knowledge. Erroneous knowledge
hierarchically. This mistake leads to one’s error in making correct judgment which leads
to leveling everything to the same level. For instance, one levels the Prophet (SAW) as
16
the same level as other men. The effect of this leveling is man considers the teaching of
the Prophet (SAW) is not relevant in modern times, there should not be taught in school
or should not be followed by modern men. Another example is that one considers the
law derives from the Qur’an as the same as law invented by man. This incorrect
judgment leads to injustice to oneself and others. Reality shows that man made law
cannot hinder man from indulging in criminal activities. Instead of solving the problems
of a society, man made law increases the problems that exist in the society. These errors
Another effect of loss of adab is the inability to recognize and acknowledge right
leadership in all spheres of life. Leadership in all spheres of life means leadership in all
politics, etc. For example, people who do not have the right knowledge will not
recognize the right leadership which will lead to electing or acknowledging the
unqualified leaders to lead the country. Unqualified leaders who have no adab lead the
country according to the erroneous knowledge that they have. Thus, bring chaos and
disharmony to the society. The condition of loss of adab nurtures the growth of false
leadership of the Muslim Community; leadership who does not know his proper place in
the hierarchy of things and beings. This leadership creates the condition of injustice
which will prolong the loss of adab since they do not have the knowledge of putting
things in their proper places. These leaders were elected by followers who have no adab
or wisdom, hence inflicted injustice to themselves and others by putting those corrupt
people in the wrong place. False leadership will advocate education system that produces
17
more people like them either out of ignorance or out of the need to ensure their continued
control of political power. This process goes round and round in the vicious circle. This
vicious circle as depicted in figure 1 will continue unless the right knowledge is made the
content of education.
Which lead to
unqualified
individuals being
appointed as leaders
who perpetuate the Loss of adab
condition of loss of
adab
Due to
Confusion and error
in knowledge
Holistic Education
Several measures can be made to break the vicious circle. One is through holistic
education which aims at producing good man; man of adab who knows how to manage
his self and how to manage the system. Man who understands the consequence of
18
recognizing is acknowledgement; and understands that Tawhid Uluhiyah is the
include both categories of knowledge. Al-Ghazali (cited in Nofal, 1993) asserts that the
curriculum of Islamic education should include both obligatory and optional sciences.
Obligatory sciences include religious science which is revealed and related or auxiliary
medicine, philosophy, human sciences, etc, are studied according to the wishes of the
students. The criterion for selecting optional sciences is that the sciences must bring
Al-Attas (1980) agrees that the curriculum of Islamic education should include both
knowledge to cultivate the soul and inner being of man and knowledge to cultivate man’s
body and physical faculties and senses. They are revealed knowledge which is obligatory
sciences (knowledge of fardh ain) and acquired knowledge which is optional sciences
(knowledge of fardh kifayah). Through both kind of knowledge, Islamic education will
be able to instill true knowledge in man, thus produce man of adab. Rashdan and Anis
Ahmad also have similar views on the content of Islamic Education. Rashdan asserts that
the content of education should include religious sciences, human and natural sciences.
The sources of the knowledge are from the revelation and the study of creation or nature
19
Curriculum Content of
Islamic (Holistic) Education
Human sciences
The Qur’an: recitation and tafsir
Natural sciences
The Sunnah: History and The
Applied sciences
Prophet’s traditions
Technological sciences
The Shari’ah: Fiqh and law
Etc
Theology (tauhid)
Arabic language
Islamization of Knowledge
The second measure that could be taken to resolve the confusion in knowledge and the
setting the knowledge free from secular interpretations and influences. It is the process
of filtering foreign elements out of every branch of knowledge especially human sciences
and infused the knowledge with Islamic elements and key concepts so that the knowledge
being instilled into man is true knowledge. Omar Kasule defines Islamization as a
process of modifying human knowledge so that it does not contradict with the basic
Islamic principles. The process does not suggest that the Muslims have to reformulate the
20
whole knowledge but suggests modification, correction and reorientation of the existing
into Muslim children is secularized knowledge. From the views of the various scholars
on Islamization, it is clear that what renders knowledge Islamic is the values, purposes of
seeking the knowledge and sources of the knowledge are not contradicted with the beliefs
and injunctions of Islam (as enunciated in the Quran and Sunnah) (Kasule 1996). When
the knowledge instilled in man is true knowledge, man is liberated from false and
erroneous knowledge. Therefore, man will be disciplined according to the truth revealed
by God which leads to a change in man’s behavior which is inline with the teaching of
Islam.
Hence, the most vital knowledge to be Islamized is human sciences with the priority
given to education and political science (Abu Sulaiman 1993). The priority is given to
education and political science since education is the knowledge that is used to transform
man from one state to another; and political science is important because without political
powers the changes that Muslims plan to implement will be challenged by the powers
that be. Through Islamization of knowledge, confusion and error in knowledge can be
rectified. The end result is the knowledge that is the content of education is true
21
Conclusion
We have established that the purpose of seeking knowledge is to discipline the body, the
mind and soul; that is seek knowledge to manage the self and knowledge to manage the
system to bring justice and harmony in this world. Sources of knowledge to discipline
the body, mind and soul is from the Qur’an and Sunnah, nature and reason. Nevertheless,
knowledge that is prevalent within the Muslims world has brought confusion instead of
peace and justice. Knowledge that is disseminated through the education system is
life and seeking knowledge for knowledge sake. In order to rectify this problem, one has
to understand the nature of man first so that all dimension of man is being educated.
Since ontologically nature of man is dual, man is obligated to develop both dimensions.
knowledge must be balanced. Balanced does not mean equal weight but proper division
according to the hierarchy of the knowledge. Leveling of all knowledge to the same level
in knowledge to manage the system will produce individuals who have no values, lack of
wisdom, corrupt, etc. Conversely, neglect in knowledge to manage the system will
produce individuals who are not able to develop the society thus, allowing outside forces
to develop the system using alien philosophy which is contradicted with Islamic
philosophy.
22
This paper has discussed the concept of ta’dib which encompasses education that
disciplines the body, the mind and soul. The aim of ta’dib is to produce man of adab who
has the knowledge to manage his self and the knowledge to manage the system he lives
in. In conclusion, when the true knowledge is inculcated into man, the education system
will produce man of wisdom who will become the leaders in all spheres of life which will
perpetuate justice (figure 3). Therefore man will achieve happiness in this world and in
the hereafter.
True knowledge is
instilled into man –
Qualified and no conflict between
quality leaderships reason and
perpetuate the revelation
condition of justice
produces man of
adab; man who
possesses wisdom
which enable him to
make correct
judgment
Figure 3: The effect of the right and true knowledge instilled into man
23
References
Abu Sulaiman, Abdul Hamid. (1993). Crisis in the Muslim mind. Herndon, Virginia:
principles and work plan (2nd ed). Herndon, Virginia: The International Institute of
Islamic Thought.
Ahmad, Anis. (1996). Value centric education system: lead-in paper presented at the
Al-Attas, Syed Muhammad Naquib. (1993). Islam and secularism. Kuala Lumpur:
Kasule, O.H. (1996). Islamization of disciplines: lead-in paper presented at the Sixth
Muhammad, Fajri (ed.). (2003). Hadits arba’in An-Nawawi (An-Nawawi: Forty hadith).
Mohamed, Yasien. (1998). Human nature in Islam. Kuala Lumpur: A.S. Noordeen.
24
Nofal, Nabil. (1993). Al-Ghazali (A.D. 1058 – 1111; A.H. 450 – 505). Prospects: The
Yusuf Ali, Abdullah. (1983). The Holy Qur’an: Text, translation and commentary.
25