Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
by
Dr. H. T. Evdorides, EurIng
The University of Birmingham - School of Engineering– Dept Civil Engineering - MSc Road Management & Engineering 1
1
Contents
• Introduction
• Techniques
– Customers, Levels of Service and Performance Measures
– Demand Forecasting
– Condition Assessment and Monitoring
– Failure Mode Analysis
– Risk Assessment
– Maintenance
– Demand Management
– Valuation and Financial Issues
– Life-Cycle Analysis
The University of Birmingham - School of Engineering– Dept Civil Engineering - MSc Road Management & Engineering 2
2
Road Asset Management
• What is Asset Management ?
• What are Assets ?
• Why Asset Management ?
• Benefits from AM
• Asset Management Process
– Policy Making
– Strategy Network
– Programming
– Project Level Project
– Operations
The University of Birmingham - School of Engineering– Dept Civil Engineering - MSc Road Management & Engineering 3
3
What is Asset Management ?
Road Asset Management is a set of
procedures, projects and tools aimed to
provide for present and future customers a
required level of road transport services in
the most cost-effective way through the
creation, acquisition, maintenance,
operation, rehabilitation and disposal of
assets.
The University of Birmingham - School of Engineering– Dept Civil Engineering - MSc Road Management & Engineering 4
4
What are AM’s key elements ?
• Taking a life-cycle approach
• Log-term planning
• Performance monitoring (service and
assets)
• Consideration of failure and risks
• Sustainability
• Continuous improvement in practices
(feedback)
The University of Birmingham - School of Engineering– Dept Civil Engineering - MSc Road Management & Engineering 5
5
What are Infrastructure Assets ?
• Stationary systems that serve defined communities
and that are intended to be maintained indefinitely
as a desired level of service by the continuing
replacement and refurbishment of its components.
• One of the most important features of
infrastructure networks is the degree of inter-
dependency not only within a particular asset
network but also from another network to another.
A failure of one component within a network may
undermine the ability of other networks to
perform.
The University of Birmingham - School of Engineering– Dept Civil Engineering - MSc Road Management & Engineering 6
6
Why Road Infrastructure AM ?
• Road Infrastructure provides the platform for
economic and social development
• Good quality road infrastructure is necessary for
public services and safety
• Risk management practices safeguard long-term
returns to shareholders
• Infrastructure assets meet the needs of society
• Benchmarking condition and performance
promotes innovation and efficiencies.
The University of Birmingham - School of Engineering– Dept Civil Engineering - MSc Road Management & Engineering 7
Infrastructure networks provide the platform for economic and social development.
Before developing countries' economies can flourish they need a basic infrastructure to
provide the foundation for efficient distribution of services, particularly transportation,
telecommunications, energy, property, water supply and sanitation.
Good quality infrastructure is the cornerstone of public health and safety. It is
generally acknowledged that the development of safe drinking water supply, and waste
collection and treatment, has been the biggest factor in advancing the overall health of the
community and increasing individual longevity. Communication networks have become
fundamental to public safety because of their use in emergency response.
Risk management practices safeguard long-term returns to shareholders. Short-term
gains need to be balanced against longer-term security. Therefore understanding and
quantifying risk costs is necessary for informed decision making by stakeholders.
Infrastructure and property assets increasingly meet recreational and other needs of
the community.
Traditionally parks and open spaces have provided recreation opportunities to the
community. Buildings have provided communities with places to meet and celebrate, to
obtain information and access to community resources, and to enjoy the arts and cultural
activities. Other infrastructure such as telecommunication networks have become a medium
(through the Internet) for interaction, hobby pursuits and general recreation.
Benchmarking condition and performance promotes innovation and efficiencies.
By benchmarking the asset management activities of network organisations and developing
clear asset management plans linking current and future network condition and
performance, organisations have a basis for promoting innovation through
performance-based facilities management contracts.
7
Benefits from RAM
• Accountability to owners, customers, stakeholders
that services are being delivered efficiently and
effectively
• Value for money from investments, taxes, charges
etc.
• Improved communication with users
– Understanding of service requirements
– Consultation and agreement with users about level of
service
– Customer satisfaction, organisation’s image
The University of Birmingham - School of Engineering– Dept Civil Engineering - MSc Road Management & Engineering 8
8
Benefits from RAM
• Improved financial management
– Cost-benefit analysis
– Justification for works and funding requirements
– Recognition of all costs of owning and operating assets
over the life-cycle of analysis
• Improved risk management
– Probability and consequences of failure
– Ensuring continuity of service
– Interrelationships between networks
The University of Birmingham - School of Engineering– Dept Civil Engineering - MSc Road Management & Engineering 9
9
Techniques
• Customers, Levels of Service and Performance
Measures
• Demand Forecasting
• Condition Assessment and Monitoring
• Failure Mode Analysis
• Risk Assessment
• Maintenance
• Demand Management
• Valuation and Financial Issues
• Life-Cycle Analysis
The University of Birmingham - School of Engineering– Dept Civil Engineering - MSc Road Management & Engineering 10
10
Customers level of service
Performance measures
• Also known as “Standards”
• Objective: to match level of service with
customers expectations
• Usage:
– Inform customers about level of service
– Enable customers to assess the services offered
– Develop strategies
– Measure performance of the AM process
– Quantify costs & benefits of the services offered
– Enable customers to assess suitability, affordability and
equity of the services offered.
The University of Birmingham - School of Engineering– Dept Civil Engineering - MSc Road Management & Engineering 11
11
Factors affecting level of service
• Customers expectations and perceptions
• Legislation (environmental standards,
building regulations, health & safety) –
minimum
• The organisation’s mission and objectives
• Economic, financial issues (constraints)
The University of Birmingham - School of Engineering– Dept Civil Engineering - MSc Road Management & Engineering 12
12
Performance Measures
• Outcome related (technical)
These are related to the service provided by
the physical asset (road)
The University of Birmingham - School of Engineering– Dept Civil Engineering - MSc Road Management & Engineering 13
13
Outcome related performance measures
• Quality • Capacity
• Quantity • Environmental
• Availability impacts
• Legislative • Cost/affordability
requirements • Comfort
• Maintainability • Safety
• Asset reliability and
performance
The University of Birmingham - School of Engineering– Dept Civil Engineering - MSc Road Management & Engineering 14
14
Process related performance measures
• Tangibles (appearance of service facilities,
personnel)
• Responsiveness (to customers demands,
ease of communication, prompt service)
• Assurance (knowledge of employees, their
ability to convey trust and confidence)
• Empathy ( caring, individualised attention
to customers)
The University of Birmingham - School of Engineering– Dept Civil Engineering - MSc Road Management & Engineering 15
15
Developing and reporting
performance measures
• Outcome related (tool, e.g. HDM4)
• Process related
– Meaningful and easily understood
– Giving a clear picture of the performance for each
service
– Linked to an activity
– Linked to the objectives of the organisation
1. Qualitative through focus groups
2. Quantitative through surveys
The University of Birmingham - School of Engineering– Dept Civil Engineering - MSc Road Management & Engineering 16
16
Techniques
• Customers, Levels of Service and Performance
Measures
• Demand Forecasting
• Condition Assessment and Monitoring
• Failure Mode Analysis
• Risk Assessment
• Maintenance
• Demand Management
• Valuation and Financial Issues
• Life-Cycle Analysis
The University of Birmingham - School of Engineering– Dept Civil Engineering - MSc Road Management & Engineering 17
17
Demand forecast
• Objective
To identify factors and trends influencing demand for an
asset and the impact of these on the management and
utilisation of assets.
• Factors:
– Population growth
– Modes of transport
– Vehicle ownership
– Alternative transport
– Location of commercial areas
The University of Birmingham - School of Engineering– Dept Civil Engineering - MSc Road Management & Engineering 18
18
Demand forecast
• Key trends (that affect locality needs) :
– Economic
– Social
– Recreation/leisure
– Environmental
– Customer preferences
– Technological
The University of Birmingham - School of Engineering– Dept Civil Engineering - MSc Road Management & Engineering 19
Trends are not always obvious and may require some more detailed research
and collection of data over a period of time to establish trends.
19
Techniques
• Customers, Levels of Service and Performance
Measures
• Demand Forecasting
• Condition Assessment and Monitoring
• Failure Mode Analysis
• Risk Assessment
• Maintenance
• Demand Management
• Valuation and Financial Issues
• Life-Cycle Analysis
The University of Birmingham - School of Engineering– Dept Civil Engineering - MSc Road Management & Engineering 20
20
Condition assessment and monitoring
Condition assessment allows and organisation to
understand the remaining life of its assets. This
understanding drives future expenditure patterns.
• Effective life:
– Design life
– Economic life
– Physical end of life
– Minimum level of acceptable service
– Limit of capacity of an asset
The University of Birmingham - School of Engineering– Dept Civil Engineering - MSc Road Management & Engineering 21
21
Condition assessment and monitoring
• Frequency of condition assessment
– Criticality of asset
– Type of asset
– Relative age of the asset
– Rate of deterioration
– Economic value of the outcomes to the business
The University of Birmingham - School of Engineering– Dept Civil Engineering - MSc Road Management & Engineering 22
22
Condition assessment methodology
• Consider existing practices
• Consider impact on organisation services
• Consider and evaluate available options
• Identify resources
• Identify size of survey (sampling)
• Determine assessment frequency
• Estimate cost
• Estimate benefits
– Tangibles (technical, economic, operational)
– Intangibles ( corporate image)
• Evaluate using investment criteria (and associated
economic parameters)
The University of Birmingham - School of Engineering– Dept Civil Engineering - MSc Road Management & Engineering 23
23
Condition assessment methodology
• Monitoring the overall condition of assets
• Relating suitability to condition of an asset
• Combine functionality (customers) and
condition assessment (engineers)
The University of Birmingham - School of Engineering– Dept Civil Engineering - MSc Road Management & Engineering 24
24
Techniques
• Customers, Levels of Service and Performance
Measures
• Demand Forecasting
• Condition Assessment and Monitoring
• Failure Mode Analysis
• Risk Assessment
• Maintenance
• Demand Management
• Valuation and Financial Issues
• Life-Cycle Analysis
The University of Birmingham - School of Engineering– Dept Civil Engineering - MSc Road Management & Engineering 25
25
Failure mode analysis
• Define the critical failure mode of the asset
• Performance monitoring (condition
assessment)
• Develop deterioration curve and predict
future timing
• Develop maintenance, rehabilitation and
reconstruction strategies
• Condition monitoring
The University of Birmingham - School of Engineering– Dept Civil Engineering - MSc Road Management & Engineering 26
26
Failure mode analysis
Failure Modes Analysis Types
The University of Birmingham - School of Engineering– Dept Civil Engineering - MSc Road Management & Engineering 27
27
Techniques
• Customers, Levels of Service and Performance
Measures
• Demand Forecasting
• Condition Assessment and Monitoring
• Failure Mode Analysis
• Risk Assessment
• Maintenance
• Demand Management
• Valuation and Financial Issues
• Life-Cycle Analysis
The University of Birmingham - School of Engineering– Dept Civil Engineering - MSc Road Management & Engineering 28
28
Risk assessment and management
• Core functions of risk management
– Set the framework
• Objectives
• Stakeholders
• Criteria against which can be evaluated
• Key issues
– Risk identification
– Risk evaluation and analysis
– Risk treatment
– Monitor and review
The University of Birmingham - School of Engineering– Dept Civil Engineering - MSc Road Management & Engineering 29
29
Risk identification
• Types of risks that may be encountered
– Safety
– Competition for services
– Corporate and asset level issues
– Financial and investment risks
– Public and general liability (negligence, third party damage)
• Cause of risks
– Natural events
– External impacts (other organisation, materials)
– Physical failure risks
– Operational risks
• Impact of failure
The University of Birmingham - School of Engineering– Dept Civil Engineering - MSc Road Management & Engineering 30
30
Risk evaluation, analysis and treatment
• Risk evaluation and analysis
– Probability
– Consequences (repair costs, loss of income, loss of
life/injuries, failure to meet statutory requirements, loss
of image)
– Risk ranking
• Risk treatment
– Identify risk treatment options
– Select the optimum (cost/benefit analysis)
– Develop and implement future improvement plan
– Monitor and review
The University of Birmingham - School of Engineering– Dept Civil Engineering - MSc Road Management & Engineering 31
31
Emergency response planning
Management of risk within an organisation should
include development and maintenance of:
The University of Birmingham - School of Engineering– Dept Civil Engineering - MSc Road Management & Engineering 32
32
Management of natural hazard events
• Risk
define natural hazards, asset vulnerability and mitigation measures
• Reliability
minimum technical standards, service levels, asset performance risks,
long-term maintenance, renewals and upgrading needs that provide an
acceptable level of assurance to the community
• Response
emergency response plans including disaster recovery and business
continuance that will show how the asset manager will respond to
disaster situations and manage service and business recovery
• Resilience
using the above the asset manager adds to the resilience of the
community to withstand and react to the hazard event
The University of Birmingham - School of Engineering– Dept Civil Engineering - MSc Road Management & Engineering 33
33
Emergency response plan
• Defines :
– the physical sequences to be followed in the event of a
significant disaster
– Roles, responsibilities and authorities of personnel
involved
– actions to be undertaken or considered
• Addresses :
– Organisational issues
– Operational issues
The University of Birmingham - School of Engineering– Dept Civil Engineering - MSc Road Management & Engineering 34
34
Phases of emergency response planning
• Immediate response
to secure hazardous conditions, establish the control
organisation and provide initial status report (likely to last
24-48 hours)
• Service and business continuity
to restore basic, partial or limited services, review
effectiveness of initial response, begin to plan for full
recovery (up to several weeks)
• Disaster recovery
to provide an ordered programme for full restoration (6
months or longer)
Consider interdependency of infrastructure services.
The University of Birmingham - School of Engineering– Dept Civil Engineering - MSc Road Management & Engineering 35
35
Techniques
• Customers, Levels of Service and Performance
Measures
• Demand Forecasting
• Condition Assessment and Monitoring
• Failure Mode Analysis
• Risk Assessment
• Maintenance
• Demand Management
• Valuation and Financial Issues
• Life-Cycle Analysis
The University of Birmingham - School of Engineering– Dept Civil Engineering - MSc Road Management & Engineering 36
36
Maintenance Analysis & Management
• Types of Maintenance
• Frequency
• Works
• Planning
• Scheduling
The University of Birmingham - School of Engineering– Dept Civil Engineering - MSc Road Management & Engineering 37
37
Techniques
• Customers, Levels of Service and Performance
Measures
• Demand Forecasting
• Condition Assessment and Monitoring
• Failure Mode Analysis
• Risk Assessment
• Maintenance
• Demand Management
• Valuation and Financial Issues
• Life-Cycle Analysis
The University of Birmingham - School of Engineering– Dept Civil Engineering - MSc Road Management & Engineering 38
38
Demand management
• “non-asset solutions”
• Objective: to seek to modify customer demands
for services in order to
– Optimise utilization and performance of existing assets
– Reduce or defer the need for new assets
– Meet the organisation’s strategic objectives (including
social, environmental and political)
– Deliver a more sustainable service
– Respond to customer needs
The University of Birmingham - School of Engineering– Dept Civil Engineering - MSc Road Management & Engineering 39
39
Demand management methods
• Operation • Educational
– Traffic signal control – Travel blending
– Local area management – Change public attitude to using
(encourage use of alternative cars at peek hours (bus lanes,
routes) cycle paths)
• Regulation • Demand Distribution
– Road use restriction (heavy – Promote or provide alternative
vehicles in urban areas) transport modes (trains)
– Speed control – Working at home
– Parking restrictions – Freight substitution (shift to off-
• Incentives road modes)
– Subsidies for free travel on
public transport
– Parking levies
The University of Birmingham - School of Engineering– Dept Civil Engineering - MSc Road Management & Engineering 40
40
Demand management strategies
• Focus planning on maximising customers
benefits
• Do not compromise the quality of service
• Broad demand management techniques are
best
• Encourage and enable customers to
participate in the process of selecting
services and standards
The University of Birmingham - School of Engineering– Dept Civil Engineering - MSc Road Management & Engineering 41
41
Techniques
• Customers, Levels of Service and Performance
Measures
• Demand Forecasting
• Condition Assessment and Monitoring
• Failure Mode Analysis
• Risk Assessment
• Maintenance
• Demand Management
• Valuation and Financial Issues
• Life-Cycle Analysis
The University of Birmingham - School of Engineering– Dept Civil Engineering - MSc Road Management & Engineering 42
42
Valuation and financial issues
• Asset valuation
• Methods and approaches used
• Useful life
• Life cycle analysis
The University of Birmingham - School of Engineering– Dept Civil Engineering - MSc Road Management & Engineering 43
43
Asset Valuation
• Is a management tool that assists in the
determination and allocation of costs and supports
performance/rate of return reporting, resource
allocation, shareholder equity and accountability.
• Is associated with
– Earnings potential (return on investment) for open
markets.
– Provision of services (emphasis on management and
maintenance).
The University of Birmingham - School of Engineering– Dept Civil Engineering - MSc Road Management & Engineering 44
44
Asset Valuation
• Necessitates the development of asset
management plans that detail the forecast
maintenance, enhancement or deterioration of
infrastructure assets.
• Expenditure types considered:
– Operational
– Maintenance
– Renewal
– Capital works
– Disposal
The University of Birmingham - School of Engineering– Dept Civil Engineering - MSc Road Management & Engineering 45
45
Reasons for Asset Valuation
• Financial reporting
• Measuring changes in service potential
• Determining appropriate pricing and funding
levels
• Determine shareholder equity
• Risk management (insurance)
• Taxation
• Decision making
• Benchmarking
The University of Birmingham - School of Engineering– Dept Civil Engineering - MSc Road Management & Engineering 46
46
Asset Valuation Methods
• Two approaches:
– Historical cost less depreciation
– An appropriate valuation method
• Asset related techniques
– Replacement cost
– Depreciated replacement cost
• Future earnings/cash flow
The University of Birmingham - School of Engineering– Dept Civil Engineering - MSc Road Management & Engineering 47
Replacement Cost
The replacement cost of an asset may be calculated by using the prevailing
market costs for supply and installation of similar assets in similar
conditions.
This is the most common method of valuation for non-commercial
infrastructure assets and requires detailed information on asset components.
Where there is commonality of components (e.g. pavement structures),
standard unit rates for replacement may be derived and applied to all the
asset components. These should take into account the location of the assets,
ground conditions and other factors affecting replacement costs. For
example, unit rates for replacing underground services will differ between
built- up urban areas and rural locations, between flat or hilly terrain, and
between sandy and rocky soils.
Future earnings/cash flow
This approach can be applied only to assets with a defined futur e revenue
stream. The value of the asset is assessed as the net present va lue of the
future net cash flows (revenues less the future upkeep costs).
47
Replacement cost
It is based on the prevailing market cost for
supply and installation of similar assets in
similar conditions.
The University of Birmingham - School of Engineering– Dept Civil Engineering - MSc Road Management & Engineering 48
48
Depreciated replacement cost
• Depreciation is the allocation of the cost of
an asset over its useful (economic) life.
• Depreciation is as much an expense as
repairs and maintenance.
• It has no impact on cash flows
• It is used to allocate costs over the useful
life
The University of Birmingham - School of Engineering– Dept Civil Engineering - MSc Road Management & Engineering 49
It is important to allocate all costs to obtain a true view of the costs of asset
use. If depreciation is not charged then the real costs will be understated.
49
Depreciated replacement cost
• Methods
– Traditional depreciation :
asset cost less residual value/useful life
– Condition based
DRC = new cost – cost of bringing up to new
Traditional Depreciation
The traditional depreciation method allocates the asset cost (less residual
value) over the useful life of the asset.
Condition-Based Depreciation
Unlike traditional depreciation, which is based on a predetermined formula
(approximating the rate of value decline), condition-based depreciation is a
direct measure of the run down in asset value. Asset condition is measured
by its deviation from 'as new'. If the cost of bringing an asset up to as new or
fair working order is, say $200 million, and its new cost is $800 million,
then its written down value is $600 million.
By measuring the condition at periodic intervals, the change in value can be
ascertained and this change is the depreciation over the period. Importantly,
this change can be positive if major maintenance has just taken place.
Condition-based depreciation will also identify the loss of value resulting
from deferred maintenance.
When applied to infrastructure assets where annual condition measurement
is not cost-effective, e.g. underground assets, the depreciation calculations
will be forward- looking, i.e. a renewal depreciation approach. That is, a cash
flow profile of renewal over the planning period will be determined by
examining the residual life of components, and an estimate made of the net
present value of the renewal costs over the period. This estimate of renewal
costs is converted to an annual sum over that period (annuity) which is the
figure used for depreciation under the condition-based depreciation or
renewal annuities approach. If this approach is used, it is essential that the
renewal cost profiles are based on a cost-justified AM plan.
. 50
Useful life
• the period of time over which the future benefits embodied
in an asset are expected to be consumed
• the lesser of the physical and economic life
– Physical life: the period of time until an asset ceases to provide
the required service because of physical deterioration of the asset.
– Economic life: the period of time until the asset ceases to be the
lowest cost alternative to satisfy a particular level of service due to
other factors (demand, operational cost, renewal, replacement cost,
maintenance cost, regulatory restrictions)
• Design life
• Remaining/residual life
The University of Birmingham - School of Engineering– Dept Civil Engineering - MSc Road Management & Engineering 51
51
Useful life of road assets
Asset Type Life (years)
The University of Birmingham - School of Engineering– Dept Civil Engineering - MSc Road Management & Engineering 52
52
Useful life of road assets
Asset Type Life (years)
Cycle ways 50
Street lighting 20
Traffic signals 10
Unsealed roads -
Drainage
Drains (underground) 50-80
Culverts 50-80
Manholes/pits 20-50
The University of Birmingham - School of Engineering– Dept Civil Engineering - MSc Road Management & Engineering 53
53
Techniques
• Customers, Levels of Service and Performance
Measures
• Demand Forecasting
• Condition Assessment and Monitoring
• Failure Mode Analysis
• Risk Assessment
• Maintenance
• Demand Management
• Valuation and Financial Issues
• Life-Cycle Analysis
The University of Birmingham - School of Engineering– Dept Civil Engineering - MSc Road Management & Engineering 54
54
Life cycle costing
• A procedure to determine the total cost of
ownership over the life of an asset for the
purpose of:
– Building of new assets
– On-going management decision making
– Benchmarking of the actual cost performance
of roads.
• HDM4
The University of Birmingham - School of Engineering– Dept Civil Engineering - MSc Road Management & Engineering 55
55
Techniques
• Customers, Levels of Service and Performance
Measures
• Demand Forecasting
• Condition Assessment and Monitoring
• Failure Mode Analysis
• Risk Assessment
• Maintenance
• Demand Management
• Valuation and Financial Issues
• Life-Cycle Analysis
The University of Birmingham - School of Engineering– Dept Civil Engineering - MSc Road Management & Engineering 56
56
Road Asset Management
• What is Asset Management ?
• What are Assets ?
• Why Asset Management ?
• Benefits from AM
• Asset Management Process
– Policy Making
– Strategy Network
– Programming
– Project Level Project
– Operations
The University of Birmingham - School of Engineering– Dept Civil Engineering - MSc Road Management & Engineering 57
57
Questions
The University of Birmingham - School of Engineering– Dept Civil Engineering - MSc Road Management & Engineering 58
58