Вы находитесь на странице: 1из 9

See discussions, stats, and author profiles for this publication at: https://www.researchgate.

net/publication/267641815

The Rogowski Coil Principles and Applications: A Review

Article  in  IEEE Sensors Journal · October 2014


DOI: 10.1109/JSEN.2014.2362940

CITATIONS READS
67 9,597

4 authors, including:

Mohammad Hamed Samimi Arash Mahari


University of Tehran University of Tehran
41 PUBLICATIONS   314 CITATIONS    17 PUBLICATIONS   273 CITATIONS   

SEE PROFILE SEE PROFILE

H. Mohseni
University of Tehran
106 PUBLICATIONS   1,252 CITATIONS   

SEE PROFILE

Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:

Power system diagnosis View project

estimation of aging state of transformers insulation View project

All content following this page was uploaded by Mohammad Hamed Samimi on 22 September 2016.

The user has requested enhancement of the downloaded file.


1

A Review on the Rogowski Coil Principles and


Applications
Mohammad Hamed Samimi, Arash Mahari, Mohammad Ali Farahnakian, Hossein Mohseni

Abstract—The Rogowski coil is an old device for current appropriate gadget for measuring high amplitude transient
measurement. It has been being modified and improved over a current [2], [10]–[12].
century and is still being studied for new applications. Rogowski
coil has various advantages over conventional magnetic current
transformers(CTs). Not only it can be used instead of CT, but The output of the Rogowski coil was insufficient in con-
also it has various utilizations in other fields. This paper provides ventional measuring methods, which was the main limit
a brief review on different aspects of the Rogowski coil and its in past decades. However, nowadays by developments of
advancement procedure, during last decades. In this literature, microprocessor-based measurement devices, Rogowski coils
the history of the coil is brifely reviwed and its bases and are more suitable for various applications. The nature of
applications are discussed. The Rogowski coil is analysed from
different points of view include, different integration techniques Rogowski coil measuring method, which measures the current
in the output stage, models for the Rogowski coil, experimental derivative, limits its usage in measuring DC currents [10].
methods for parameter measurement in models and method for The Rogowski coil has some significant features, which attract
determining the damping resistor. At last, a breif review over attentions in recent years. Some of the main advantages are
diffrent applications of the coil ends the paper. as follows [13]:
Index Terms—High-speed current measurement, Lumped and • Enduring large overloads without damage;
distributed model, Review, Rogowski coil, Specific applications.
• Measuring currents in an extensive range, without satu-
ration;
I. I NTRODUCTION • Easy to use, due to the flexibility and light weight;
HE Rogowski coil is an air-core coil, which measures
T both alternating and high speed impulse currents, based
on Ampere’s and Faraday’s law [1]. It was named after a
• Low cost;
• Nonintrusive nature (drawing no power from the main
circuit);
German physician Walter Rogowski [2]. Firstly, this type • Wide bandwidth, in a range of 0.1 Hz to 1 GHz;
of transducer proposed in 1887, when A. P. Chattock from • Excellent transient response;
Bristol University was working on the better types of dynamos • Safety (isolated from the main circuit, electrically).
[3]. He used a long coil on a plastic rod for measuring the This paper is a review on this fascinating device. The
magnetic reluctance. He attached the two ends of the coil to rest of this paper is organized as follows. In Section II,
each other, and calibrated the device based on Ampere’s law the basics of Rogowski coil are presented. Various ways of
[4]. In 1912, W. Rogowski and W. Steinhaus used Chattock’s integration in its output is discussed in Section III. The paper
technique for magnetic potential measuring. In this manner, proceeds with introducing different models of Rogowski coil
They performed various tests to ensure the validity of the coil and their features in section IV. Section V, reviews some
measurements [4], [5]. applications of Rogowski coil and finally, Section VI provides
the conclusion. This paper is a very good reference for the
The main limitation regarding the Rogowski coil engineers who want to recognize and utilize Rogowski coil
applications was about diminutive output in measuring and need a fast guide.
low amplitude currents [6]. In first stages, the coil usage
was limited for measuring the high amplitude currents, with
high variation rate, due to the fact that, the output of the
II. BASICS OF ROGOWSKI C OIL
coil is proportional to the derivative of the current [3], [7].
Nowadays, the Rogowski coils are able to measure low A typical Rogowski coil consists of toroidal form windings,
level currents, thanks to electronic devices [8]. This coil encircling the current path, as shown in figure 1 [14]. Referring
does not have ferromagnetic core, therefore, it has a linear the Ampere’s law, the relation between the current flowing
characteristic [9]. Linear characteristic together with accurate through the Rogowski coil and the intuitional magnetic, along
electronic devices, make it possible to measure currents, the axis of the torus, is as follows:
form milli-amperes to mega-amperes, using Rogowski coil. I
1 ⃗ · ds,⃗
Furthermore, the low cost of this device, comparing to the I(t) = B(t) (1)
µ0
other measurement methods, makes the Rogowski coil an
where s is the distance along the torus. Magnetic field B
Authors are with the Department of Electrical and Computer En- variations, induces voltage in the windings. Considering the
gineering, Faculty of Engineering, University of Tehran, Iran, e-mail:
m.h.samimi@ut.ac.ir. constant cross-section for windings and constant turns number
per length unit, a unique relation between the induced voltage,
Acta Polytechnica Hungarica
2

be noted that, Lω ≪ R is the necessary condition in (4) and


(5). In measuring pulse shape currents, this condition is not
fulfilled, due to the high frequency components in the current
wave spectrum. In such a condition, where the sum of coil
resistance, r, and external resistor, R, is less than Lω, and
R ≪ 1/ωC, as well, then (3) can be written as follows:
dϕ di ϕ µ0 N AI/s I
≈L ⇒i= = =
dt dt L µ0 N 2 AI/s N (6)
R
⇒ uR (t) = iR = I.
N
Fig.1 A Rogowski coil with a RC integrator [5].
Fig. 1. A sample Rogowski coil with an RC integrator [15]. In this case, the output of the coil is proportional to the
flowing current, Thus, it has linear characteristic, like a
conventional CT [10], [15]. According to the equations, the
in the terminal of the Rogowski coil u(t) and the flowing lowest measurable frequency is determined from r + R ≪ Lω
current I(t) can be written based on Faraday’s law [15]: condition and the highest measurable frequency is depend
∫ on the LC resonance frequency of the coil itself. Therefore,
dϕ ⃗˙ ⃗ = A µ0 I(t),
˙
u(t) = = B(t) · dA (2) in high frequency measurements, the Rogowski coil has an
dt Fig. 2 s
Equivalent circuit of a single-turn winding with a RC integrator [5]. intrinsic integrator and does not need external integration
where A is the windings cross-section and s is the number of
block [3].
turns per length unit.
Formula (2) is independent of the current distribution. For
The other problem relates to the capacitive coupling
deriving the current value from induced voltage u(t), an inte-
between coil windings and the casing. This coupling causes
grator block is necessary at the coil output terminal. A simple
error in the output signal and should be omitted for increasing
RC circuit can acts as integrator block, as shown in figure 1.
the accuracy, in most of the cases. This coupling effect is a
Figure 2 shows a simple RC circuit which is configured as
source of considerable error in high frequency measurements.
an integrator. The self-inductance of each winding is modeled
In this situation, the coil acts like a transmission line and
as L in figure 2. R and C are the resistor and capacitor of
the induced voltage of different spots reach the coil terminal
integrator circuit, respectively. If the current i flows in this
with different delay time, which result in pulse distortion.
circuit one can write:
∫ Moreover, uneven excitation of different windings can cause a
Acta Polytechnica Hungarica u(t) = dϕ = L diFigure 3 1 t ′ remarkable oscillation in the output of the coil. Consequently,
A Rogowski coil + for
Ridecreasing
+ idt , (3)
dtwith twodt paths C 0intruder flux [5]. the output has direct relation with the current distribution in
ω is assumed as the highest frequency in the Fourier transform the torus.
spectrum of the source current. By setting Lω ≪ R then the
(3) can be rewritten as follows: Regardless of the mentioned problems, if the Rogowski
∫ coil is in closed loop structure, the coil can have any shape.
dϕ 1 t ′ This posture refers to the ampere’s law essence which says,
u(t) = = Ri + idt . (4)
dt C 0 the closed loop integral of the magnetic field around a current
Considering the measurement time, t, much less than RC path is equal to the current. In other words, the trajectory of
value, then the below formula can be derived for us (t) [15]: flowing current has no effect on the output. This fact results
∫ ∫ t in a outstanding feature of the Rogowski coil as flexible
1 t ′ 1 ′ ′
u(t) = Ri(t); us (t) = idt = u(t )dt device for current measurement. Hence, the Rogowski coil is
C 0 RC 0 (5) the best and only choice in most cases, where other devices
Aµ0 NA 1 such as CTs do not have the desired flexibility [16].
= I(t) = µ0 I(t),
sRC Sm RC
where N is the number of windings, A is the cross-section Despite simple structure of Rogowski coil, in utilizing
of the coil, and Sm is the mean length of the coil. It should stage, it needs some special considerations. One of the
problems is related to the large magnetic flux between two
Fig.1 A Rogowski coil with a RC integrator [5].
ends of the coil. For decreasing this flux and increasing the
immunity of the coil versus stray fields, the Rogowski coil
should include two electric paths which are connected to each
other in reverse direction [13]. Windings can be either both
of the paths or just one of them. When both of the paths are
in winding form, they should be wound reversely, in order
to intensify the output [17], [18]. While, when one path is
winding and the other is a simple wire, the second wire can
be returned through inside of the first wound path. In this
Fig. 2
Fig. 2. Equivalent circuit of a single-turn winding with an RC integrator [15]. case, the coil can be separated from one end. Easy separation
Equivalent circuit of a single-turn winding with a RC integrator [5].
M. H. Samimi et al. A Review on the Rogowski Coil Priciples and Applications3

structure is suitable for measuring in cases where the primary


path cannot be opened. This configuration is shown in figure
4(a).

III. O UTPUT INTEGRATION IN THE ROGOWSKI COIL


As it stated earlier, in normal operation mode, an integrator (a) (b)
circuit is required at the output of the Rogowski coil.
Figure 4
One of the intrinsic advantages of this integrator is noise
Fig. 3.(a) OpAmp
Basic opamp cicuit for(a)
integrator integration and (b) itscircuit
Basic OpAmp frequency
(b) characteristic [7].
Frequency character-
reduction because of low-pass frequency characteristic, which istic [22].
is important in high precision measurements [7]. There
are various approaches for implementing this integrator.
The RC integrator has been discussed in the previous The basic OpAmp integration circuit is shown in figure
section. The self-integrating mode of Rogowski coil in 3 (a), however, there are other advanced integration OpAmp
high frequency measurements presented, as well. Another circuits which their design is based on this structure [24], [25].
group of methods for designing integration circuit is based Ignoring the R1 , the gain of integrator would be (1 + G)R2 C,
on using operational amplifier (OpAmp). As mentioned, in which G is the open-loop gain of OpAmp. In this case, any
RC-base integrator is appropriate for high frequencies noise in the input enforce the output into the saturation con-
( > 100M Hz ), while, OpAmp-based integration method C I R E DAdding R
dition. to the basic
19th1International circuit,
Conference decreases
on Electricity Distribution the DC gain Vienna, 21-24 May 2007

is useful in low frequency ( < 100M Hz ) measurements [19]. of integrator down to R1 /R2 . The frequency (b)
(a) characteristic of Paper 0207-
this circuit is shown in figure Figure 5
3 (b). In figure 3 (b), the f1 and
(a) A Rogowski coil structure, (b) lumped model of Rogowski coil [8]. OF THE ROGOWSKI COIL
Another applicable integrating method is based on using fPulse
0 are as
calibrator
1 P follows: P 2
TABLE I. GEOMETRY

Rogowski coil dimensions Specifications


a microprocessor based devices with an analog to digital 1 1
Inner diameter a 162.4 mm
converter [20]. In these methods, a signal processing 6 m
f0 =
17.7 m
, C
f1 = .
Outer diameter b (7) 191mm
2πR1 C5.51 m 2πR C
Transducer2diameter
1 d rc 14.3 mm
software operates as an integrator. In signal processing based Ground
Length of the wire l w 25 m
approaches, additional block like digital filters can result The Figurecircuit actsdiagram
2. Single-line as foran integrator
PD monitoring system in bandwidth between f0 and
Radius of the wire d 1 mm
in better outputs. Also, adaptive algorithms are useful for fHIGH
1 . Reference
FREQUENCY [22] proposed
BEHAVIOR OF aTHE combinational method which
Length of the coil l 600 mm
ROGOWSKI COIL
precise waveform reconstruction [20], [21] which is important does the integration process in three different bandwidth, with l
In this study, Rogowski coil is used to measure PDs, which Rl = ρ c ⋅ w2 (1)
for wideband measurements. This method is appropriate for three
typically different methods.
last few nanoseconds. Theitsintegration
Therefore, high in low frequencies πd
frequency behavior is of paramount importance. There is a
mid-frequencies. is done using an OpAmp circuit; in mid-frequencies
trade-off between the bandwidth and the sensitivity of the µ Nan 2
d rc RCb
Ll = 0 log (2)
circuit is theutilized;
coil. Moreover, bandwidth andand in high
susceptibilityFigure 6frequencies the coil utilized
of the coil 2π a
to high frequency oscillations are significantly influenced by
in Experimental
the self-integration setup for parameter measurement of the Rogowski coil [6].
impedance. If the coilmode.
geometry isTherefore, a widerC frequency 2
the termination not 4π ε 0 (b + a)
When there is a low impedance resistor, in series with coil, symmetrically positioned around the conductor, the l = (3)
bandwidth is supported using the proposed scheme. log b + a 
experimental results are logically influenced, however, no
the Rogowski coil acts as a self-integrator [10]. However, in significant effect has practically been found in the time or
b−a
this situation the gain of the coil is very low. One option to frequency domain behavior of the measurements [6]. where Rl , Ll , and C l are the lumped resistance,

intensify the coil sensitivity is using multiple coils in series. IV. R


Up to now, two different modelsOGOWSKI C
of Rogowski coil have
OIL Minductance,
ODELING and capacitance of the coil, respectively. ρ c is
been developed; the distributed and the lumped parameter
the copper resistivity; µ 0 and ε 0 are the air permeability
In fact, if the mentioned low impedance resistor is much less model [7-10]. The distributed model can help calculating
A. Lumped Model
the sensitivity H (V/A) of the Rogowski coil used in ATP and permittivity, respectively; and N=431, are the number
of turns of the coil [6]. The terminating impedance of the
than Lω, then the coil works in linear mode. In the other simulations, and the transfer function can be extracted from
In this subsection, the lumped model of Rogowski coil is Rogowski coil Z can be approximately calculated as given
the lumped model to analyze its bandwidth [6,11].– 2 –
hand, if the termination resistor is much more than Lω, then reviewed. The lumped model of Rogowski coil is acceptable in reference [6, 7].
The equivalent circuit of the Rogowski coil, based on the
the coil works in derivative mode. The self-integrating mode SIMULATION PARAMETERS CALCULATION
for low frequency analysis [25]. It includes a resistor, an lumped parameters, is drawn in Fig. 4, where i (t ) is the
Rogowski coil parameters
is suitable for impulsive current measurement [2]. inductor, andoperates
a capacitor. Figure current flowing in the conductor, v rc (t ) is the induced
The Rogowski coil on the basic principle of the 4 depicts this model. The
voltage in the coil, v out (t ) is the coil output voltage, and
Faraday’s
parameterslaw. The
inconstruction
this of
figure the high
are frequency
computable M asis thefollows [23],of [26]:
mutual inductance the coil (200 nH).
Rogowski coil is depicted in Fig. 3. The geometric
The perfect integrator should satisfy some requirements. characteristics of the circular cross section Rogowski coil
The measured parameters of the Rogowski coil lumped
model are given in Table II. The Rogowski coil parameters
are given in Table I. For a toroidal coil having circular cross
Not only it should have a wide frequency bandwidth, but also, section, the lumped parameters can be calculated as follows
are measured at a frequency of 1 KHz with the help
Agilent 4263B LCR Meter. As the high frequency beha
it should have a time constant, which is multiple times greater [6, 7, 11]:

than the main circuit time constant [22]. The RC integrator


faces with variety of rigid limitations, which are hard to
satisfy. For example, in power frequency measurement (50-60
Hz), both R and C have high values. Thus, the integrator
(a)
does not have a suitable frequency performance, as a result
of stray capacitances, parallel with resistor and the capacitor
dissipation. Furthermore, the output to input ratio is very
small which results in low sensitive measurements. Because
of these problems and amplification necessity, the integrator
with OpAmp circuits are preferred in power frequency (a) (b)
measurement. Some researches have suggested compound
integrators with wider bandwidths [23]. Fig. 4. (a)
CIRED2007 A 1Rogowski coil structure,
Session Paper No(b)
0207Lumped model of Rogowski coil Page 2 / 4
[26], [27].
of coil head which senses the primary current as shown in
Fig. 1(b). There are two more external components which
complete the design of RC system as a current measuring 4
device.
(a)
lw
F. Terminating Resistance Rl = ρc 2 , (8)
πd
Termination has very significant effects on response of RC
[17]. A terminating µ0 N 2 dRrc is bconnected
Ll resistor
= t log , across (9)the
terminals T 1 and T2 of the coil 2πfor proper a damping of the RC
output signal. The resistance should
4π 2 ε0 (b + a) necessarily be non-
inductive and its value Cl = is determined , (10)
b + a based on the electrical
parameters of RC. A method log(for the )selection of terminating
b−a
resistance is also presented to provide an oscillation free signal
where ρc is the stage.
for integration electricalIn resistivity
section V,of proper wire, lw of
the coilselection is
the length of
termination coil wire,
resistance d is the inradius
is analyzed detail.of this wire, drc is (b)
the diameter of each loop in the coil, N is the number of
G. Integrator Fig. 5. Experimentla setup for measuring parameters of the Rogowski coil
turns, and a, b are the internal and external radius of the [19].Fig. 3. (a) Test setup for identification of RC parameters. (b) Electrical
The
coil, output of RC
respectively. Z isisvoltage
modeled proportional
as an external to theimpedance
derivative inof equivalent circuit of test setup for identification of RC parameters.
the coil
the primary currentincludes
terminals, signal. damping
For our designed coil, a digital
resistor, coupling cable
capacitor
integratorand measurement
is added instrument
at the output impedance.
of a properly The experimental
becomes
terminated RC maximum, issetup made
the first for identification
resonance frequency of of thethe
to obtain the output of RC proportional to primary current. parameters is shown in Fig. 3(a). Targeted parameters for
system.
Different integration
The equations are techniques
credible in are thedescribed
ideal mode, in section identification in the RC system are L c, Cc, Cp and Ccab. A pulse
while, I.in the
construction, there are some imperfections; e. g. distribution is Determining
injected fromthe thefirst
PD resonance
calibrator into the circuit
frequency of the andsystem
RC is
of turns along IV. P ARAMETER
the coil is not even, IDENTIFICATION isconnected
the return path is not in the useful inaround
lumped themodel
conductor in the circuit.
parameter Output At
measurement. of RCfirst,is
center of windings, and the cross-section
Non-uniform turn density, imperfect central is notposition aobtained
capacitorbyCconnecting
circle, ideally
of the T1 is added coil
to terminal
the system usingand low-capacitance
the resonance
and active differential probe (ADP) Then, toanother
LeCroycapacitor
Wavesurfer CT24Xs
return loop, non-uniformity of core or deformationofofthese
it turns to an ellipse due to bending. Because frequency
the is determined. 2 is
imperfections, the above oscilloscope. Duenewto airresonance
core, RC frequency
has relatively low sensitivity
circular cross section into formulas
oval due to arebend
not ofaccurate replaced
flexible[19].
coil For
can and the is determined, √ as
high-frequency applications, deviation
exact parameter and care must be taken to maintain the integrity
fres = of 1/2πmeasured
Ll C
cause some geometrical betweendetermination
well.
a RC at For resonance frequency, the formula
is important, since the bandwidth and choosing signal.
can
the damping be The
useduse of ADP greatly
considering C = reduces
Cl + Cthe +loop
C currents
. Since and
the
manufacturing time and use. At high frequencies, the T p
resistor in the common voltages
frequencyatisthe terminals
with oftwoRC as it decouples
CT one can the
phenomena liketerminal
skin and is proximity
related to effect
these cause
parameters values.
resonance
non-uniform defined different
Furthermore, RC from ground. A commercial √ HFCT is used for reference
distribution ofissues currentlike proximity
within the wires andandskin hence write:
effect
causecause
the
the erratic distribution of current in the coil, hence, measurements offres1
some primary currentCl + Cpulses.
p + CT 1
This HFCT with the
presence of parasitic inductance and capacitance. Using
parasitic inductors andformulascapacitors primary windowf of 15=mmChas a specified . bandwidth from (11)
simple mathematical canshould
causebemiscalculations
considered in the for res2 l + Cp + CT 2
model [19]. Defining these parameters with 0.5-80 MHz [19], which makes it an accurate reference device
computational
determining the inductance and capacitance of RC. Hence it is
methods The resonance
for high frequency frequencies,
current waveform CT 1 measurement.
and CT 2 are known,
justified is to not accurate
consider theseenough, while as
parameters it needs
functions remarkable
of coil
time In this C
therefore, l + Cstage
double p value testisreported
calculable.below ByCcknowingand C p theare
geometry and frequency [8]. Furthermore, the RC is
owing to large computational size. Hence, it better to
behavior is
measure these parameters after the coilcomponents
construction. resonance
determined. frequency
Tests areand capacitors
carried out byvalues,
observingthe the
inductance
RC output of
also determined by external physical andHowever,
devices.
reference [11],measurements
[28] has proposed the coil is calculable.
waveforms and theWhen Cp and frequency
oscillation Cl are required whileseparately,
different
Identification can be aused computational
to determine method
exact
based the
knownexperiment can be repeated
testing capacitors with two across
CT are connected different the C p , e.g.
terminal
values for connecting wires, measurement device which
on PEEC (Partial Element Equivalent Circuit), input
is fast and the results has acan great two different
of coil as shownprobes, thus3(b).
in Fig. with Two
two equations Cp and Cl can
sets of measurements are
characteristics etc. which beaccordance
very difficult with tomeasured
specify
parameters. be determined
planned separately
to develop [19]. The equations
mathematical model parameters
to determinecan also
two
analytically. Measuring the lumped model parameters is
discussed in the next subsection. be determined
unknown using impedance
capacitances Cc and Cp asanalyzers
follows: [2]. Specifically,
Resonant frequency is a clear reflection of the
this method is suitable for defining distributed model validity.
electromagnetic components of an induction sensor system
1) Parameter Measurement: First set of measurements: Two measurements are carried out
[18]. Here, a simple but useful There are different
technique methods
of comparing the
for measuring the lumped model parameters of the Rogowski by2)first
Damping Resistor
connecting Determination:
capacitor CT1 = 10.5The pF lumped model
and on second
resonant frequencies of RC is used for different known
coil. One of them is reviewed here. The measurement circuit of the Rogowski
round CT2 = 33.7coil pF isacross
valid, RC.
in measurements
Response of below the firstis
RC system
capacitors connected across.
is shown in figure 5. Cp is the capacitor of measurement unit resonance captured frequency
using single of theADP.coil. Two
Based resonance
on the lumped model
frequencies
and CT is an external capacitor added to the system. Cl and the f11 =transfer
34.18 MHzfunctionand of thef12coil can be
= 22.61 MHz driven [28]:
respectively are
Ll are the parameters, which should be determined. In this obtained by performing
Vcoil fast Fourier
s.M transform (FFT) of the
method, the first resonance frequency of the system should be Hcoil = = . (12)
i Ll Rl
measured. This frequency is measurable using two different Ll Cl .s2 + (Rl Cl + ).s + 1 +
Z Z
techniques [19]. In first method, a pulse using a pulse
The resistance of the coil is negligible. Therefore, the transfer
generator (e.g. the partial discharge calibration instrument) is
function can be rewritten as follows:
applied to the primary circuit. Afterwards, the output voltage
Copyright (c) 2011 IEEE. Personal use is permitted. For any other purposes, permission must be obtained from
is recorded and the first frequency in voltage waveform can Vcoil s.M pubs-permissions@ieee.org.
the IEEE by emailing
Hcoil = = . (13)
be determined using the Fourier spectrum. Due to the low i Ll
Ll Cl .s2 + .s + 1
coupling between the primary and the secondary sides, the Z
measurement setup should be precise enough. The transfer function shows that, the output voltage is
proportional to the derivative of the current. Denominator is
The second technique is based on using a signal generator a second order polynomial function. Hence, without damping
in the primary and controlling the secondary voltage, resistor, √ an overshoot occurs near the resonance frequency
simultaneity. As the frequency of generator is increased ω0 = 1/ Ll Cl . This condition cause no problem for power
gradually, the first frequency, in which the output voltage frequency measurements, however, if the primary current
5

contains frequencies components, near the coil resonance The coil sensitivity, travelling time of the wave in the coil,
frequency, the overshoot may affect the operation of the front time of the wave, and pulse width of the current are most
system. For example, in protection functions, high-frequency important factors that should be considered in measuring
components of the current, may cause overshoot, which result currents with severe variations. Moreover, for achieving
in the relay maloperation. This phenomenon is noticeable self-integrating mode, the termination resistor should be
in protecting the power electronic instruments [29], owing considered equal to the least possible value. Theoretically, the
to high frequency transients during switching times [28]. best state for self-integrating mode is short circuit condition
Consequently, a damping resistor is necessary in most of the of the terminal. However, it is not practically true, since for
cases. measuring output voltage, the resistance existence is necessary.

In case of using an integrator block in the output stage, the In manner of obtaining best transient response, the shunt
simplified transfer function for the integrator output can be and inter-turn capacitances should be minimized [7]. In fact,
written in the following form: the shunt capacitor is the stray capacitance between the coil
ω02 windings and the primary conductor, while the inter-turn
H(s) = K. . (14) capacitor is the capacitance of coil loops between each
s2 + 2ζω0 .s + ω02
other. Various techniques are suggested for decreasing these
Thus, the resistor value derived using following formula [11], capacitances. One of these techniques is based on putting
[25]: √ a shield around the Rogowski coil, to decline the shunt
1 Ll 1 capacitors [13], [32]. This shield can also be used as a return
Rd = = πLl fres , (15) path. Changing the space between the coil windings and the
2ζ Cl ζ
shield sheet leads to different shunt capacitors. It is necessary
where ζ = 1 is a good value for resistor determination to consider an overall slot through the sheet; otherwise the
[30]. This resistor should be an inductance-free resistor, coil cannot work properly due to magnetic shielding of the
otherwise it origins new oscillations. Damping resistance sheet.
value is calculable, based on root locus analysis or Bode
diagram, accurately [2]. However (15) accuracy is sufficient
for not-highly precision measurement. The inter-turn capacitance is related to the windings
density. As the winding density increase, the inter-turn
capacitance become higher, as well. Thus, larger space
between windings result in less capacitance [32]. Another
B. Distributed Model technique for decreasing this capacitance is based on inserting
As discussed in previous part, the lumped model is not valid an extra winding between the main coil windings. In the
in high-frequency measurements, thus it should be replaced manner of decreasing the overall coupling capacitance, the
with a distributed model. One of the distributed model of extra winding should be connected to the shield. This method
the Rogowski coil is based on transmission line model theory causes considerable reduction in the inter-turn capacitance
[31]. The model based on transmission line theory is used for value [13]. Figure 7 shows some of these techniques.
achieving following purposes: METWALLY: SELF-INTEGRATING ROGOWSKI COIL FOR HIGH-IMPULSE CURRENT MEASUREME

• Optimization of the coil parameters, particularly the shunt


capacitance in order to reach self-integration mode;
• Determining the effect of termination resistance, on the
output voltage of the coil; The perf
• Decreasing the adverse effect of reflection by declining using the hi
the stray capacitances. three stage
In this model, the electrical distance of the coil is separated generator w
into n divisions. Each division contains series inductance, impulse cu
L = Ll /n , modeling the inductance of the division, a shunt voltage sur
the reconfig
capacitor C = Cl /n , modeling the stray capacitance of the
current gen
division, a resistor R = Rl /n , and a voltage source e = ut /n
can be cont
modeling the front and backward travelling wave [23]. The
the value a
distributed model of the Rogowski coil is shown in figure 6.
times of th
4 IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON INSTRUMENTATION AND MEASUREMENT, VOL. 59, NO. 2, FEBRUARY 2010 standard w
by means o
1000×, 75
Fig. 2. (a) Construction details of the new self-integrating Rogowski coil:
Fig. 7. (a) and
Details
maximum d
1—inner outerofaluminum
a self-inegrating
shields Rogowski coil for measuring
(return conductor); 2—insulated currents
coil The disc
with intensive
conductor variation.
(varnished 1) inside
wire); and outside
3—longitudinal aluminum
thin cuts on theshield (return
return path),
conductor
g. 1. Transmission-line equivalent circuit of the coil [8].
2)shields;
insulated conductor of the coil, 3) longitudinal slots on the return
4—interturn capacitance shielding conductor, five-coil former (plastic), path, load was m
4)and
shielding
six- PVCconductor
protectivefor inter-turn
tape. capacitance.
(b) Connection (b) atthe
diagram connections
both coil ends. at both Pearson Ele
w [5]–[13]. ApplyingFig. 6. Distributed
Ampere’s law formodela coil of the Rogowski
wound on a and coil [13].spurious effects of reflections byends
3) avoid of the coil
minimizing the [13].
onmagnetic former and having a cross-sectional area A yields stray capacitances. band clam
 Rogowski coils under impulse conditions show a good self- TABLE I 0.1 V/A +1

 dl integrating response for a current impulse of duration less than DESIGN DATA OF THE COIL
i(t) = H. (1) rent transfo
twice the transit time of the coil [9]–[14]. To measure longer
pulses, the transit time is optimized by increasing the coil former (ICT
he induced electromotive force (EMF), i.e., e , in a differen-
6

Increasing the number of windings loops in the coil, been used vastly for current measurement in Gas Insulated
intensifies the sensitivity, however, raises the coil inductance Substations (GIS) by great industries [7].
and decreases resonance frequency, as well. As mentioned
before, in applications which need a wider bandwidth, the The Rogowski coil can be used in differential protection
resonance frequency should be higher. In fact, specifying the of furnace transformers. These transformers conduct tens of
number of loops is a trade-off between coil sensitivity and kilo amps in the secondary for electrowinning applications.
its usable bandwidth [19], [31]. With less number of turns, The conventional protection of these transformers utilizes
it is possible to identify the coil parameter using analytical the measurements of primary side. However, the differential
equation [1], [31], [33]. Termination resistor value has impact protection is the best option for transformer protection.
on the coil output, in high frequencies. The best measurement Since, CTs which are able to measure high level currents
performance in high frequencies can be derived from shunt are expensive, the differential scheme is not economical. The
resistors, but they are rather expensive. However, optimal Rogowski coil can measure high amplitude currents, without
setting of the termination resistance, which cost much lower problems such as saturation. Consequently, differential
than shunt resistor, results in appropriate output, very similar protection schemes are executable for furnace transformer
to the shunt resistor [16], [34]. More details about setting the [17]. Referring to the same considerations, the Rogowski
termination resistance value, in high frequency applications, coil is the best choice for high current measurement in high
is available in [13], [32], [34]. power laboratories [37].

As mentioned, The Rogowski coil measures the current


derivative [39]. Therefore, it is useful in triggering
V. A PPLICATIONS OF THE ROGOWSKI C OIL
applications. For example, in the synthetic test circuit
Not only, the Rogowski coil is useful in conventional of high voltage circuit breakers, current is applied to the
applications, but also, there are other cases where the breaker from one circuit, and the transient recovery voltage
Rogowski coil is the best choice [7]. Because of non- is applied to the breaker after zero-crossing of the current
geometric structure and capability in measuring high by another circuit. In the first zero-crossing, the current
amplitude current and etc. it has various applications in should be interrupted. The moment of current interruption
testing laboratories, industrial measurement instruments, and and voltage creation should be synchronized as much as
unconventional measuring systems [29]. In following, a brief possible. For this purpose the moment of current initiation
overview of the Rogowski coil applications is presented. is measured and the voltage is applied after a certain time.
When the current flows, the current derivative is remarkable.
In the power system protection, conventional CTs are Thus, the Rogowski coil can sense this variation and prepare
being used for decades. These CTs were necessary for a voltage in its terminals for rest of the setup [40]. In the
electromagnetic relays operation, due to the large power same way the Rogowski coil can be used for protection of
demand of these relays for proper operation. Nowadays, the power electronic switches against high di/dt or short circuit
relays are numeric and work with low power signals properly. current [11], [41]. Detection of plasma ignition is possible,
As a consequence, the Rogowski coil can be used instead of with the same method, using the Rogowski coil [42]. The coil
CTs for fault detection in transmission lines and electrical has other applications in circuit breaker area. For decades,
machines [35]. Using Rogowski coil leads to fast response measurement of pre-arc and post-arc current in a circuit
of the relays and flexibility of protection schemes [8], [36]. breaker was impossible, due to the fact that the first one is
This matter has also opened new gates to the protection very large, while the latter is quite small. The point is that
schemes fields [35]. For example, the Rogowski coil owing the derivative of current during arc quenching in a breaker is
to wide frequency bandwidth can measure the travelling large and then the Rogowski coil has provided a possibility
wave variation, which enables using traveling wave based to measure these currents [7].
protection schemes [3]. Travelling wave based algorithms is
useful in fault location methods [23]. It is also possible to Moreover than wide bandwidth, capability of measuring
add the coil on distribution overhead lines without primary currents with high amplitude, makes the Rogowski coil one
separation for high-impedance fault detection [26]. of the best options for measuring large, sharp currents [25].
These currents are used vastly in pulsed power application,
Some of the CT problems, such as CT saturation, which and the Rogowski coil is one of the best measurement devices
lead to maloperations of the relays, are not the matter of in plasma and pulsed power technology [28], [42]. It is also
concern in the Rogowski coil. Recently, numerous researches a good choice as a measurement device in tests, dealing
are focused on using the Rogowski coil instead of CTs in with impulse currents [2], [12], [34]. It is used in high-tech
transmission and distribution substations [3], [7], [23]. The TOKAMAK fusion devices for normal and eddy current
Rogowski coil is useful as an electronic current transducer in measurements [43], [44] and in plasma setups, where the
smart substations for protection and monitoring applications, current does not flow in a conductor but in an area in the air
as well [24]. Owing to light weight and high precision [9], [42].
[33] the coil can be used for on-site calibration of CTs,
in substations [29], [37], [38]. Furthermore, the coil have Another application for the Rogowski coil is real-time
7

Partial Discharge (PD) measurement [39], [45]. The PD is VI. C ONCLUSION


a high frequency phenomenon and its measurement needs a
In this paper, different aspects of the Rogowski coil were
device with wide bandwidth [27], [32]. Detection of defects
presented. First, the history of the coil was brought up. Then,
in high voltage components and disconnecting them, from
the basics of Rogowski coil is discussed and different methods
grid before a serious damage can save money and time
about output integration block is reviewed. Afterwards, two
for power grid. One of the possible methods for detection
models of the Rogowski coil, lumped and distributed, were
of defects in high voltage components is PD measurement
discussed. Experimental methods for determining the lumped
of instruments. Generally, preceding a breakdown in high
model parameters were reviewed and a simple approach
voltage apparatuses, the rate of partial discharge rises [46].
for choosing appropriate damping resistor, in the terminal
Therefore, by monitoring the partial discharge, the apparatus
of the coil, was presented. At last, various applications of
status is determinable. The Rogowski coil can be used for
the Rogowski coil was reviewed and the requirement for
online and offline PD measurement, due to wide bandwidth
each application was discussed. Despite the fact, that this
[19], [20], [32]. In some cases, like in power cables, PD
coil is invented decades ago, there are different fields, in
detection based on voltage signals is quite difficult, because
which the research about the Rogowski coil is still continuing.
of stray capacitances. In such situations, the Rogowski coil
is a proper choice for PD measurement, based on measured
current signals [47], [48].
R EFERENCES

Recently a Rogowski coil is constructed using PCB (Printed [1] M. Marracci, B. Tellini, C. Zappacosta, and G. Robles, “Critical pa-
rameters for mutual inductance between Rogowski coil and primary
Circuit Board) [49]. This type of coil is very accurate, due conductor,” Instrumentation and Measurement, IEEE Transactions on,
to precise sizing of windings. In this coil, top layer becomes vol. 60, no. 2, pp. 625–632, Feb 2011.
one edge of winding wire and the bottom edge plays as [2] Y. Li, Y. Guo, Y. Long, C. Yao, Y. Mi, and J. Wu, “Novel lightning
current sensor based on printed circuit board Rogowski coil,” in High
the other wire. The two other edges lay inside the board Voltage Engineering and Application (ICHVE), 2012 International Con-
connecting the top and bottom layer to each other via holes ference on, Sept 2012, pp. 334–338.
[50]. This type of Rogowski coil is used for partial discharge [3] C. Xianghu, Z. Xiangjun, D. Feng, and L. Ling, “Novel PCB sensor
based on Rogowski coil for transmission lines fault detection,” in Power
and impulse current measurement [11]. This type is a good Energy Society General Meeting, 2009. PES ’09. IEEE, July 2009, pp.
choice for precision measurement applications with digital 1–4.
wiring implementation and extensive automated production. [4] M. Rigoni, J. Garcia, A. Garcia, P. da Silva, N. Batistela, and P. Kuo-
Peng, “Rogowski coil current meters,” Potentials, IEEE, vol. 27, no. 4,
This type of Rogowski coil does not suffer from uneven pp. 40–45, 2008.
density or reshaped windings [2] and its precise characteristic [5] W. Rogowski and W. Steinhaus, “Die messung der magnetischen span-
is derived analytically in the literature [51]. Moreover PCB nung,” Electrical Engineering (Archiv fur Elektrotechnik), vol. 1, no. 4,
pp. 141–150, 1912.
coil can be designed in a way to have high temperature [6] C. Qing, L. Hong-bin, Z. Ming-ming, and L. Yan-bin, “Design and
stability which is important for industrial applications [7]. characteristics of two Rogowski coils based on printed circuit board,”
Instrumentation and Measurement, IEEE Transactions on, vol. 55, no. 3,
pp. 939–943, June 2006.
In applications where there is no normal geometrical [7] J.-P. Dupraz, A. Fanget, W. Grieshaber, and G. Montillet, “Rogowski
coil: Exceptional current measurement tool for almost any application,”
structure, the Rogowski coil is one of the best options, due in Power Engineering Society General Meeting, 2007. IEEE, June 2007,
to its flexibility [16]. For instance, one Rogowski coil can be pp. 1–8.
placed around the tower, for measuring the impulse current [8] L. Kojovic, “PCB Rogowski coils benefit relay protection,” Computer
Applications in Power, IEEE, vol. 15, no. 3, pp. 50–53, Jul 2002.
distribution in a wind turbine tower [12]. Measuring the [9] S. Richards, D. Chatrefou, D. Tholomier, and F. Gilles, “Non-
leakage current of a system, which placed on the earth, can be conventional instrument transformer solutions-experience of the process
done by placing big Rogowski coils around all of the legs of bus IEC 61850-9.2,” in The 9th International Conference on Develop-
ments in Power System Protection, March 2008, pp. 9–13.
that component. Using this method, the grounding resistance [10] A. M. Luciano and M. Savastano, “Wide band transformer based on a
of overhead line towers can be measured, individually [52]. split-conductor current sensor and a Rogowski coil for high current mea-
The coil can also be placed around high-voltage bushings, surement,” in Instrumentation and Measurement Technology Conference,
1995. IMTC/95. Proceedings. Integrating Intelligent Instrumentation and
for on-line monitoring [3]. It is also useful for eddy current Control., IEEE, April 1995, pp. 454–.
measurements in non-geometric structures [44]. [11] D. Gerber, T. Guillod, and J. Biela, “IGBT gate-drive with PCB
Rogowski coil for improved short circuit detection and current turn-
off capability,” in Pulsed Power Conference (PPC), 2011 IEEE, June
2011, pp. 1359–1364.
The Rogowski coil have intrinsic insulation from main
[12] K. Yamamoto, N. Ueda, A. Ametani, and D. Natsuno, “A study of
circuit. Using optical link between the coil and the lightning current distribution at a wind turbine foot: Influence on current
measurement system has strengthened the coil for using measurements using a Rogowski coil,” Electrical Engineering in Japan,
in high voltage applications [53], [54]. This area can be vol. 180, no. 4, pp. 10–17, 2012.
[13] I. Metwally, “Self-integrating Rogowski coil for high-impulse current
developed vastly in the future. Moreover than this field, measurement,” Instrumentation and Measurement, IEEE Transactions
increasing coil bandwidth, which is important in high- on, vol. 59, no. 2, pp. 353–360, Feb 2010.
frequency and precise measurement, is of great interest these [14] W. Li, C. Mao, and J. Lu, “Study of the virtual instrumentation applied
to measure pulsed heavy currents,” Instrumentation and Measurement,
days and needs further studies [25]. IEEE Transactions on, vol. 54, no. 1, pp. 284–288, Feb 2005.
[15] H. Bluhm, Pulsed power systems. Springer, 2006.
8

[16] M. Chiampi, G. Crotti, and A. Morando, “Evaluation of flexible Ro- [37] E.-P. Suomalainen and J. Hallstrom, “Onsite calibration of a current
gowski coil performances in power frequency applications,” Instrumen- transformer using a Rogowski coil,” Instrumentation and Measurement,
tation and Measurement, IEEE Transactions on, vol. 60, no. 3, pp. 854– IEEE Transactions on, vol. 58, no. 4, pp. 1054–1058, April 2009.
862, March 2011. [38] “IEEE guide for the application of Rogowski coils used for protective
[17] L. A. Kojovic, “Applications of Rogowski coils for advanced power relaying purposes,” IEEE Std C37.235-2007, pp. c1–45, Feb 2008.
system solutions,” in Electricity Distribution, 2005. CIRED 2005. 18th [39] T. Eriksson, J. Blomgren, and D. Winkler, “An HTS SQUID pico-
International Conference and Exhibition on, June 2005, pp. 1–4. voltmeter used as preamplifier for Rogowski coil sensors,” Physica C:
[18] W.-z. ZHOU, G.-s. ZHAO, and H.-y. LI, “Error analysis and improved Superconductivity, vol. 368, no. 1, pp. 130–133, 2002.
method of Rogowski coil,” Power System Protection and Control, [40] R. D. Garzon, High voltage circuit breakers: design and applications.
vol. 20, no. 37, pp. 99–103, 2009. CRC Press, 2002.
[19] M. Shafiq, L. Kutt, M. Lehtonen, T. Nieminen, and M. Hashmi, “Param- [41] D. Bortis, J. Biela, and J. Kolar, “Active gate control for current bal-
eters identification and modeling of high-frequency current transducer ancing of parallel-connected IGBT modules in solid-state modulators,”
for partial discharge measurements,” Sensors Journal, IEEE, vol. 13, Plasma Science, IEEE Transactions on, vol. 36, no. 5, pp. 2632–2637,
no. 3, pp. 1081–1091, March 2013. Oct 2008.
[20] E. Hemmati and S. Shahrtash, “Digital compensation of Rogowski coil’s [42] R. De Alessandro, M. Velez Ibarra, and H. Brito, “Design of a current
output voltage,” Instrumentation and Measurement, IEEE Transactions measurement system in a plasma thruster with Rogowski coil,” Latin
on, vol. 62, no. 1, pp. 71–82, Jan 2013. America Transactions, IEEE (Revista IEEE America Latina), vol. 11,
[21] A. Marinescu and I. Dumbrava, “Validation of the software for dig- no. 1, pp. 119–125, Feb 2013.
ital processing of a Rogowski coil output signal,” in Optimization of [43] C. Qing, L. Hong-bin, H. Ben-xiong, and D. Qiao-qi, “Rogowski sensor
Electrical and Electronic Equipment (OPTIM), 2012 13th International for plasma current measurement in J-TEXT,” Sensors Journal, IEEE,
Conference on, May 2012, pp. 1189–1192. vol. 9, no. 3, pp. 293–296, March 2009.
[22] J. A. J. Pettinga and J. Siersema, “A polyphase 500 ka current mea- [44] N. R. Prakash, K. Flora, R. Babu, R. Gangradey, and H. Patel, “Design
suring system with Rogowski coils,” Electric Power Applications, IEE and development of Rogowski coil sensors for eddy currents measure-
Proceedings B, vol. 130, no. 5, pp. 360–363, September 1983. ment on toroidal vessel,” Journal of Fusion Energy, vol. 32, no. 2, pp.
[23] X. Minjiang, G. Houlei, Z. Baoguang, W. Chengzhang, and T. Chun, 263–267, 2013.
“Analysis on transfer characteristics of Rogowski coil transducer to [45] J. Zhu, L. Yang, J. Jia, and Q. Zhang, “The design of Rogowski
travelling wave,” in Advanced Power System Automation and Protection coil with wide band using for partial discharge measurements,” in
(APAP), 2011 International Conference on, vol. 2, Oct 2011, pp. 1056– Electrical Insulating Materials, 2005. (ISEIM 2005). Proceedings of
1059. 2005 International Symposium on, vol. 2, June 2005, pp. 518–521 Vol.
[24] S. Wang, X. Cao, and L. Chen, “Study of ECT based on Rogowski 2.
coil used in smart substation,” in Power Engineering and Optimization [46] J. Kuffel, E. Kuffel, and W. S. Zaengl, High voltage engineering
Conference (PEOCO), 2013 IEEE 7th International, June 2013, pp. 61– fundamentals. Newnes, 2000.
65. [47] Z. Zhang, D. Xiao, and Y. Li, “Rogowski air coil sensor technique
for on-line partial discharge measurement of power cables,” Science,
[25] Y. Liu, F. Lin, Q. Zhang, and H. Zhong, “Design and construction of
Measurement Technology, IET, vol. 3, no. 3, pp. 187–196, May 2009.
a Rogowski coil for measuring wide pulsed current,” Sensors Journal,
[48] P. van der Wielen, J. Veen, P. A. A. F. Wouters, and E. Steennis, “Sensors
IEEE, vol. 11, no. 1, pp. 123–130, Jan 2011.
for on-line PD detection in MV power cables and their locations in
[26] G. M. Hashmi, M. Lehtonen, and A. ELHAFFAR, “Modeling of
substations,” in Properties and Applications of Dielectric Materials,
Rogowski coil for on-line PD monitoring in covered-conductor overhead
2003. Proceedings of the 7th International Conference on, vol. 1, June
distribution networks,” Pulse, vol. 1, p. P2, 2007.
2003, pp. 215–219 vol.1.
[27] G. Hashmi, M. Lehtonen, and M. Nordman, “Calibration of on-line
[49] L. A. Kojovic, V. Skendzic, and S. E. Williams, “High precision
partial discharge measuring system using Rogowski coil in covered-
Rogowski coil,” Nov. 6 2001, uS Patent 6,313,623.
conductor overhead distribution networks,” Science, Measurement Tech-
[50] T. T. Z. Z. P. Qijun and T. J. Z. Yuanfeng, “Design of PCB Rogowski coil
nology, IET, vol. 5, no. 1, pp. 5–13, January 2011.
and analysis of anti-interference,” Transactions of China Electrotechni-
[28] T. Guillod, D. Gerber, J. Biela, and A. Muesing, “Design of a PCB cal Society, vol. 9, p. 021, 2011.
Rogowski coil based on the PEEC method,” in Integrated Power Elec- [51] T. Tao, Z. Zhao, W. Ma, and Q. Pan, “Precise mutual-inductance
tronics Systems (CIPS), 2012 7th International Conference on, March analysis of a novel clasp Rogowski coil with symmetrical double-printed
2012, pp. 1–6. imprints,” in Electromagnetic Field Problems and Applications (ICEF),
[29] A. Marinescu, “A calibration laboratory for Rogowski coil used in 2012 Sixth International Conference on, June 2012, pp. 1–4.
energy systems and power electronics,” in Optimization of Electrical and [52] “Methods for measuring the earth resistance of transmission towers
Electronic Equipment (OPTIM), 2010 12th International Conference on, equipped with earth wires,” Cigre Working Group C4.2.02-2005, pp.
May 2010, pp. 913–919. c1–45, June 2005.
[30] J. Ramboz, “Machinable Rogowski coil, design, and calibration,” Instru- [53] W. Yutian, Y. Jing, W. Huixin, and L. Jie, “Design and research of
mentation and Measurement, IEEE Transactions on, vol. 45, no. 2, pp. fiber optically powered Rogowski coil current transformer,” Procedia
511–515, Apr 1996. Engineering, vol. 15, pp. 886–890, 2011.
[31] V. Dubickas and H. Edin, “High-frequency model of the Rogowski coil [54] P. Orr, P. Niewczas, C. Booth, G. Fusiek, A. Dysko, F. Kawano,
with a small number of turns,” Instrumentation and Measurement, IEEE T. Nishida, and P. Beaumont, “An optically-interrogated Rogowski coil
Transactions on, vol. 56, no. 6, pp. 2284–2288, Dec 2007. for passive, multiplexable current measurement,” Sensors Journal, IEEE,
[32] E. Hemmati and S. Shahrtash, “Evaluation of unshielded Rogowski coil vol. 13, no. 6, pp. 2053–2054, June 2013.
for measuring partial discharge signals,” in Environment and Electrical
Engineering (EEEIC), 2012 11th International Conference on, May
2012, pp. 434–439.
[33] L. Ferkovic, D. Ilic, and R. Malaric, “Mutual inductance of a precise
Rogowski coil in dependence of the position of primary conductor,”
Instrumentation and Measurement, IEEE Transactions on, vol. 58, no. 1,
pp. 122–128, Jan 2009.
[34] Y. Zhang, J. Liu, G. Bai, and J. Feng, “Analysis of damping resistors ef-
fects on pulse response of self-integrating Rogowski coil with magnetic
core,” Measurement, vol. 45, no. 5, pp. 1277–1285, 2012.
[35] O. Poncelas, J. Rosero, J. Cusido, J. Ortega, and L. Romeral, “Motor
fault detection using a Rogowski sensor without an integrator,” Industrial
Electronics, IEEE Transactions on, vol. 56, no. 10, pp. 4062–4070, Oct
2009.
[36] Y. Hongwei, Y. Dahai, Y. Xianggen, and L. Weibo, “Study of a
novel CT for short-circuited current measurement,” in Transmission
and Distribution Conference and Exhibition: Asia and Pacific, 2005
IEEE/PES, 2005, pp. 1–5.

View publication stats

Вам также может понравиться