Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
net/publication/292452624
CITATIONS READS
8 160
1 author:
Mohamed Braham
University of Sousse
74 PUBLICATIONS 150 CITATIONS
SEE PROFILE
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
National biocontrol project against citrus leafminer Phyllocnistis citrella by the introduction of its endoparasitoid ageniaspis citicola
View project
All content following this page was uploaded by Mohamed Braham on 15 November 2016.
P[$rG0ilïn01
Management of the pistachioseedwaspEurytoma
plotnîkoyfNikolskaya(Hymenoptera/ Eurytomidae) in
Tunisia:Integrationof pesticidespraysand other means
of control
MohamedBraham*
Abstract: Trials were conductedto control E. plotnikovi in pista- chews a tiny exit hole through the nut shell and emergesas
chio orchards in Tunisia. In the field, the emergenceofadults from the adult wasp.Newly emergedfemaleslay their eggsin the
infested pistachio of the previous year was monitored in cagesas young developingpistachioin May and June.Only one larva
was the progress of the development of diapausing larvae through may develop inside a single pistachio seed. Young larvae
pupae and adults by collecting and splitting 100 nuts at regular hatch from eggs,become older larva that remain inside the
intervals fromApril 17 to June 16,2004. nut to overwinter completing the life cycle in one year. A
Field spray tests undertakenon May 6, May 18 and May 29, small percentageof the population, however, which varies
2004 using three chemical products, dimethoate (Daphene fort, at a from year to year, continuesthe diapause,completingits life
concentration of 0.1 %) and two formulations of deltamethrin cycle in up to three years (Jerraya,1977; Mehrnejad,l996 ;
(Decis expert at a concentrationof 0.015 % and Decis EC25 at a Basirat & Seyedoleslami,2000).
concentrationol 0.15 %) plus a bio-insecticide(spinosadat a con- In Tunisia, the frugivorous insects attacking pistachio
centration of 0.05 oÂ) were very effective; final infestations in comprise Megastigmuspistaciae, and E. plotnikovi. The last
August were 8 o/0,16 %, 14 o and 6 % for dimethoate, spinosad, is by far the most significant speciesdestroyingup to 70 Yo
deltamethrin (Decis expert) and deltamethrin (Decis EC 25) respec- of the crop in someregionsand it is presentin up to 90 Yoof
tively as compared to 36 oÂfor the untreated control. sitesprospected(Braham,in preparation).
A secondtrial aimed to test the systemic effects of dimethoate at The control of this pestis undertakenwith a wide rangeof
a concentrationof 0.1 o%and spinosadat a concentrationof 0.05 % chemical pesticides.Discrepancieson the optimal time to
was conductedon two trees. Four branchesper tree were treated treat, coupled with the diffrculty of monitoring the adult pop-
with a hand sprayer on May 22 and June 5, 2004. Results indicated ulation, haveresultedin severalinsecticidesprays,which are
that both insecticides showed little effect on the larvae of E. plot- often applied at unsuiiable times and are therefore ineffec-
nîkovi. tive.
Our data suggestedthat the pistachio seed wasp can be effec- The objectivesofthis researchare (1) to test two groups
tively controlled by conventional insecticides sprays (deltamethrin of insecticidesusually used by farmersin conventionalpro-
and/or dimethoate) against aduits and spinosad for organic farming duction; one organophosphorus,dimethoatewith trade name
providing that adult flights may be monitored. Daphene fort and a synthetic pyrethroid, delamethrin with
two formulations,Decis EC25 and Decis expert; (2) to test
l. lntroduction the efficacy of a bio-insecticidespinosad,trade name Tracer
Pistachio trees have been growing in arid and semi-arid con- 480, in contactwith or exposureto adults of E. plotnikovi.
ditions in the center and south east of Tunisia (regions of Spinosadis a product derived from the fermentation of a nat-
Sfax, Kasserine, Sidi Bouzid, Kairouan, Gafsa and Mahdia.). urally occurring organism Saccharopolysporaspinosa. It is
For a long time, they have occupied lands which are less activeby ingestionand contactexposureagainsta wide vari-
appropriate or even completely inappropriate for other crops ety of insectpests(Dow Agro Sciences2004.) and (3) to test
such as olive or almond trees. Pistachio is considered a the systemic efficacy of dimethoate and spinosad against
drought resistant species because it thrives in areas where young larvaeof the pistachioseedwasp in post adult flight.
water stress is frequent. In these regions pistachio cultivation In addition, we present data concerning the progress of
is considered to be of great economic importance, and adult emergencefrom pistachio nuts in situ in order to mon-
improvements have been permanently introduced affecting itor fruit infestati-onand eggs hatching.
agricultural techniques.
The local production of pistachio nut in Tunisia is cur- 2. Materialsand methods
rently increasing to satisfy the increasing need, but the yield 2.1. Generalities
is low because ofthe attack ofpests and pathogens. The study was carried out during the spring- summer of 2004
The pistachio seed wasp, Eurytoma plotnikovi in CFRA (Centre de formation et de recyclage agricole)
(Hymenoptera, Eurytomidae) is a common pest of pistachio. Jammel locatedin easterncentral Tunisia in a 6500 m' plot.
The species is univoltine and strictly monophagous. It over- No pistachioorchardwas found with a diameterof six kilo-
winters as a full grown diapausing larva within the infested meters. The Jammel area is characterizedby a typical
pistachio.In March-April,the larvapupatesshortlybefore Meditenanean climate with hot summers and cool winters.
adult emergenceand the nymphtransformsto an adult that The orchard numbered three lines and 15 rows of 38 (30
femalesand 8 maleswith 7 missed)well developedpistachio
treesof the'Mateur'variety,separatedby 12 metersfrom one
" lnstitutde I'Olivier.Pôle de Recherchedu Centre-Est de Chott- another.
Mariem,Routetouristique4042,Chott-Mariem,Sousse,Tunisia.Tel The treeswere 19-20yearsold andwere well tendedwith-
: + 216-73-348543;Fax : + 216-73-348543. out irrigation;no pesticideswere applied.The orchardis bor-
E-Mailaddress:m_braham 2000@yahoo.fr deredby olive trees on two sides,the third side by a row of
2005
November/December 319
cypress and the fourth side by an open field. The trees were chio nuts from sprayed and unsprayed branches on August
2-4 meters high. The pistachio fruits of the previous year 14, when larvae were fully grown. The numbers of filled
(2003) were left on and under the trees and were not collect- seeds,empty seedsand seedsinfested by insect larvae were
ed due to a severe attackof E. plotnikovi. counted.
In early spring, before the beginning of the study a sample Data were submitted to one way analysis of variance
of 200 pistachionuts showeda high percentage(> 95%) of (ANOVA) and the LSD test was used when significant dif-
nut infestation with one hundred oercent of old larva of Ë. ferenceswere detectedwith SPSSSoftware(Version 10.0).
plotnikovi.
3. Results
2.2. Emergencefrom feld bottles ("cages") 3.I . Monitoring the adult emergencefrom field bottles
An empty plastic mineral water bottle with two openings Table I shows the number of emergedadults. The first adults
each of about 5 cm diameter and covered by wire mesh was appeared on May 3 with an average of 0.66 per bottle and
used to house 50 pistachionuts collected from hees of the lastedtill June2 with an averageof 0. 16.The maximum was
2003 season.Six boftles were suspendedin six different observed between May l0 and May 22 suggestingthe high-
trees,at a height of 1.2 - I .6 m abovethe ground.The bottles est flight of adults in that period. The peak was observed on
were placedonApril 3,2004 beforeadultsof the naturalpop- May l8 with an averageof three emergedimagos per bottle.
ulation started emerging from the nuts. They were checked
regularly to record adult emergence.Imagos were collected
100
and removed.
80
o
2.3. Monitoring the infestation and adult emergence o 60
Samplesof 100 pistachionuts remaining on the trees flom ù
40
the previous seasonwere collectedand immediatelysplit to d
monitor (1) the number of filled nuts (2) the number of empty 20
nuts (3) the number of mature larvae, pupae and adults and
nuts with exit holes. iF sh rù sF il. sN
ÆF "ôts .CF .s! 3F
The development stages of the pupa were divided into *P**,**P**P"-P*"f -f *1,s-i,*^d"*J,*
three categories:(l) white-yellowpupae(2) lightly-coloured Sl ^.S(- .f- o^J"df (}q-
^qf "tr oqf ".È
pupae and (3) mostly-colouredpupae. Dates
Â
0.16
I \.4
J 1
N
o
0.08
A^l \n
/t\\iÀ V L
I, \i,/
- y \\ 016
tibv t0 ns/ B l|r/ 3É Jr re 3 J rt e J at ê Ar 9 r r t
t0 ta
/ \-"f"*-----
Dates
è
$ùe E Y. l-aNaetr O.Lârvae
Fig 2. Mean number of eggs and larvae per nut Fig.3. Trendof eggs and juvenile slages of E. plotnikoviaccording
to dates (in %)
0.083) due probably to the low infestation level. However, 245 ;P= 0.000),on June23 (F= 6.80 df4,245; P:0.000)
plots treated with deltamethrin show no eggs followed by and on June30 (F: 3.39df 4,245 ; P : 0.010).
spinosad with one egg per 50 fruits and two eggs for On August 14, a significant difference was detected
dimethoate compared with the check plot with four eggs per regardingold larvae (F =5.65 df 4,245 P: 0.000) (table 9).
50 nuts. A significant difference was detected regarding the The nuts in the unheated plot were highly infested.
young larva(F= 2.679df : 4,245, P:0.032).
On May 14, a significant difference regarding eggs was 3.4. Systemiceffectsof spinosad and dimethoate
detected between all the treatments and the check plot (F= No significant systemic effect was shown between the two
5.323 df 4, 245 ; P<0.0001). No difference was shown treatmentsand the check - for spinosad(F=1.54 df 1,3 ; P:
regardingyoung larvae (F : 2.192, df 4,245 P: 0.070). 0.302) and for dimethoate(F : 0.140 df l, 3 ; P :0.733).
On May l8 a signihcant difference was detectedregarding
eggs(F: 26.872 df 4,245 P< 0.001) but not young larva (F 4. Discussion
: 1.824; df 4, 245; P: 0. 125). The period of egg laying startedat the beginning of May and
Four days after the second treatment, significant differ- shows two maxima; on May 6 and May 18 till the end of the
enceswere detectedregardingeggs (F : 2.77; df 4,245;, P: month. After that, a sharp drop was observed and numbers
0.028)andyoung larvae(F : 2.89; df 4,245 P: 0.023).On remained low till the end of the third week in June. The
averagethe nuts in the check plot contained three times more young larvae begin to emerge on May 6, three days or per-
eggs and larvae than those in the treated plots. haps a little more after the first egg is laid. Their number
On May 26, eight days after the secondtreatment, no sig- increasesto reach a maximum by May 26 andthen drops and
nificant differenceregardingeggswas detected(F: 0.591 df remain low till the end of June (Fig 2).
4, 245 ; P: 0.06); however, a highly significant difference Fig. 3 shows the proportion of eggs, young larvae and old
was detectedconcerningyoung larvae(F:9.114; df 4,245 larvae. The periods of the three treatments (May 6, May 18
P= 0.000). Nuts in the untreatedplot contained four to 11 and May 29) coincided with maximum eggs laying (Fig 2). If
more young larvae than plots treated with deltamethrin or we assumethat the effrcacy of the insecticides and spinosad
spinosad. last 12 to 15 days, all the duration of adults flight may be
On May 29, a significant differencewas detectedregard- covered and hence the treatmentmay be effective.
ing eggs(F:3.66 df 4,245 P:0.006). The samesignificant In the field, the first adults ofE. plotnikovi appearedin the
difference was detectedregarding young larvae (F: 16.79 df beginning of May till the end of the month with a peak on
4,245 P:0.000). May 18, 2004; these data agree with our early observations
On June 2, four days following the third treatment, a sig- in the regions of Sidi Bouzid, Gafsa, Sfax and Mahdia.
nificant difference was detected regarding small larvae (F: Jarcaya(1977) indicates that in nature, the emergence and
33.69df 4,245 ;P:0.000). Nuts in the checkplot were high- flight of the pistachio seedwasp begins after May 15 till June
ly infested (Table 7). The same difference was detected nine 20. The difference in adult emergence and flight may be
daysafterthe third treatment(F: 19.05 df 4,245 ; P: 0.000) related to pistachio phenology and/or climatic conditions.
with a maximum of young larvae in the nuts of the untreated The author has worked in the Tunis region about 150 kilo-
plot. On June l0 (12 days after the third treatment), this dif- metersfrom our study site where climatic conditions are a lit-
ferenceremained(F:7.49 df 4,245 ; P: 0.000). tle different. He also concluded that the variation in the date
The following dates of conhol after the third treatment of adult emergenceis related to biological features of the
show significant differences regarding young larvae with speciesnot to the geographical location. We agreewith him
high infestationin the checkplot; on June 15 (F: 13.82df 4, because,the larvae can only develop in the pistachio nut and
Table 3. Qualitative composition of the natural population ol E. plotnikoyi from 100 nuts collected from trees of the previous
year.
Dates Em.Nuts Fi. nuts Ol.L Wh.pup Co.pup Pup. Adults Ex.holes Total
03-04-2004 30 12 58 100
17-04-200l. 28 zo 42
24-04-20@. 14 1 34 45 100
03-05-2004 38 11 17 19 100
06-05-2004 19 2 10 10 17 20 18 100
10-05-2004 39 10 o 16 29 100
18-05-2004 40 11 0 2 44 100
22-05-2004 39 14 45 100
26-05-200é. 28 11 55 100
29-05-2004 33 17 45 100
02-06-2004 38 l u l 48 't00
05-06-2004 41 Âi
100
10-06-2004 39 12 49 100
15-06-2004 34 12 51 100
Table 6, Mean number of eggs and young larvae per nut after the second treatment (For detailssee table 5)
Mean juvenilestage Per nut
#1
Deltamethrin 0ade 0a 0.04a 0b 0.04a
Deltamethrin# 2 0.02ad 0.06a 0.02 0.14a 0b 0.06a
Untreated 0.06ace 0.18c 0.02 0.44b 0.04ab 0.42b