Вы находитесь на странице: 1из 10

See discussions, stats, and author profiles for this publication at: https://www.researchgate.

net/publication/317157736

The influence of affective, continuance and normative commitments on the


turnover intentions of nurses at Makassar's private hospitals in Indonesia

Article  in  African journal of business management · September 2012


DOI: 10.5897/AJBM11.1715

CITATIONS READS

16 1,137

3 authors, including:

Ria Mardiana
Universitas Hasanuddin
11 PUBLICATIONS   34 CITATIONS   

SEE PROFILE

Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:

The Influence of Leadership Integrity in Realizing Good Governance Practices within The Indonesian Constitutional Court Secretariat General of Constitutional Court View
project

Employer Branding as a Strategy to Attract Potential Workforce View project

All content following this page was uploaded by Ria Mardiana on 26 May 2017.

The user has requested enhancement of the downloaded file.


African Journal of Business Management Vol. 6(38), pp. 10303-10311, 26 September, 2012
Available online at http://www.academicjournals.org/AJBM
DOI: 10.5897/AJBM11.1715
ISSN 1993-8233 ©2012 Academic Journals

Full Length Research Paper

The influence of affective, continuance and normative


commitments on the turnover intentions of nurses at
Makassar’s private hospitals in Indonesia
Ria Mardiana Yusuf Guntur*, Siti Haerani and Muhlis Hasan
Economic Faculty of Hasanuddin University, Tamalanrea Street Km 10, Makassar, 90245, Indonesia.
Accepted 5 January, 2012

This study examined the effect of affective, continuance, and normative commitments on the turnover
intentions of nurses at Makassar private hospitals and the dominant aspect of these commitments. The
cross sectional study that involved 140 data was done with generic nurses, using stratified random
sampling. Data were collected by using questionnaires and analyzed with multiple regression analysis.
The result showed that affective, continuance and normative commitments have a simultaneously
negative significant effect on turnover intentions of the nurses at private hospitals in Makassar,
Indonesia. Another outcome discovered was that affective commitment had dominant effect on the
nurses’ turnover intentions. However, continuance commitment had no significant effect on turnover
intentions of the nurses at private hospitals in Makassar, a city in Indonesia.

Key words: Affective commitment, continuance commitment, normative commitment, turnover intention.

INTRODUCTION

Globalization drive has fundamentally changed the dominated by organizations that are able to give best
workforce of any organization. Cascio (1998) found out services and quality products. This condition will be faced
five kinds of changes faced by an organization: by all organizations and even hospitals and industries in
Indonesia (Armansyah, 2007).
1) Change in production market and services. Global issue forced almost all organizations to redesign
2) Change in technology. the structure of their organizations, technology and even
3) Change in structure and organizational design. organizational culture. Kiechel (1993) and Cascio (1998)
4) Change in character of managers' activity. recommended several adjustments for organizations to
5) Change in character of job itself. anticipate the effect of globalization. They are:

These organizational changes have become the 1) Redesign organization to downsizing.


triggering factor for pushing traditional research paradigm 2) Change the organizational hierarchy integration into
that focuses on achieving productivity and leaving other networking.
important factors such as quality behind. Furthermore, a 3) Rewarding the capability of employee in comparison
shift to focus on globalization issue and competition puts with their position.
forward the concepts of quality optimization in product 4) Change the business competition paradigm from
and services. This has a trickle down effect and productivity to service quality.
consequently moves global market mechanism to be 5) Direction of job is customer’s satisfaction.
6) Focus on organizational resources that can energize
organization to the battle of competition.

*Corresponding author. E-mail riamard67@gmail.com. Tel: As one of the biggest organizations, hospitals nowadays
(06241)585415-(062411)587218. have an urgent role as a public health institution that has
10304 Afr. J. Bus. Manage.

the entire infrastructure needed for the health of the organization and desire to remain with the organization
society. This makes the objective of hospital (Luthans, 1998). To measure the organizational
management to emphasize more on social context. commitment, Allen and Meyer (1991) developed three
Unfortunately in the recent years, hospitals have become types of commitments namely: affective, continuance and
economic oriented, like being effective and efficient in normative. Affective commitment refers to the emotional
quality and also satisfying all customers. In Asian Medical attachment, identification with and involvement within an
Journal, we found that Sulastomo (2000) wrote that organization. Continuance commitment is based on the
almost all hospitals in South-east Asian countries underlying cost related with employees’ work termination.
acquired most of their medical equipment from USA. For Normative commitment relates to keeping membership in
this reason, management of hospitals must give attention an organization. Furthermore, Allen and Meyer (1991)
to capitalizing operational and maintenance of those found that affective commitment has a negative influence
equipment. The consequence is that hospitals must on turnover intentions and absenteeism of employee. On
transform their function into social-economic orientation. the contrary, affective commitment has a positive
Like other service industries, the only aspect that is influence on the acceptance of change.
concerned most is service quality (Sulastomo, 2000). The result of several investigations indicates that
Accordingly, the good management concerning all these employees with strong affective commitment work harder
quality of services cannot be separated from the problem and more effectively in their jobs than employees with
of managing the ability and capacity of employees’ weak affective commitment (Johnston and Snizek, 1991;
services, especially that of the nurses. Previous studies Meyer and Allen, 1997; Preston and Brown, 2004).
proved that nurses are supposed to be internal Guimaraes and Igbaria (1992) found that organizational
customers. Satisfaction among internal customers will commitment is an intervening variable of intentions of
lead to satisfying external customers (Rutledge et al., turnover and job satisfaction. Furthermore, Kathri et al.
1996). Fisher (2003) found that optimal performance will (2001) discovered that high employees’ turnover in
be achieved by the employees if they are satisfied with Singapore, Malaysia, South Korea and Taiwan occurs
their job, and then they will be retained in the because of the procedural justice and low organizational
organization (Zaghloul et al., 2008). commitment.
The common phenomena in almost all hospitals over Karsh et al. (2005) proposed that job satisfaction and
the world showed that the turn over level of nurses were organizational commitment are predictors of turnover
high (Laphalala, 2006), and turnover is almost the latest intentions. Wasti (2003) also proved that organizational
choice for the nurses, if they do not feel comfortable commitment is a predictor of turnover intentions in
anymore with their recent job. The consequence is that Turkey. Korunka et al. (2005) found a significant negative
the hospitals will be faced with high operational cost, if correlation between turnover intentions and job
they have to recruit another nurse (Laphalala, 2006). satisfaction. This is similar to the result of the research by
Generally, there are several reasons for nurses’ Harrell et al. (1986).
decision with regard to their turnover from one hospital to Howard and Homma (2001) found that job satisfaction
the other. Organizational commitment was found to be alone is not sufficient to predict the turnover intentions.
very critical in turnover intentions (Karsh et al., 2005; They suggested that organizational commitment should
Khatri and Homma, 2001; Guimaraes and Igbaria, 1992). also be included in the turnover model as another
Puspasari (2003) found that in the average turnover of independent variable. A research by Morrison (2004) also
employees in Puri Cinere hospital was 10.4% and all of found that organizational commitment is negatively
them were from nursery unit around 54.75%. correlated with turnover intentions. This study assessed
This research study provides an analytical review of all three components of board members’ commitment to
turnover intentions among nurses in seven (7) private the organization affected by turnover intentions of nurses
hospitals in Makassar City of Indonesia, and the at private hospitals in Makassar City of Indonesia.
commitment factors that significantly contributed to it. The Considering the previous research evidence, the
main objective is to analyze and verify whether hypotheses of this research are:
organizational commitment such as affective,
continuance and normative commitments influence 1) The organizational commitment (affective,
significantly the turnover intentions of hospitals’ nurses. continuance, and normative commitment) will be
negatively affected by turnover intentions of the nurses at
private hospitals in Makassar, Indonesia.
LITERATURE REVIEW 2) Among affective, continuance and normative
commitment, affective commitment will be dominantly
A long record of research has linked commitment affected by turnover intentions of the nurses at private
organization to turnover intentions of employees and also hospital in Makassar, Indonesia.
the reasons for high turnover at organizations.
Organizational commitment refers to the degree to which The following model depicts the relationship among the
employees believe in and accept the goals of an independent and dependent variables to form the
Guntur et al. 10305

Figure 1. The influence of affective, continuance and normative commitment toward


turnover intentions of private hospital’s nurses in Makassar Indonesia.

theoretical framework (Figure 1). correlation from the research is bigger than the critical value. Result
of validity test of the instrument consisting 27 items exceeded the
lower limit of correlation coefficient of 0.4140. Because the
METHODOLOGY instruments have high validity, it proves that the data collected are
valid.
Population and sample technique The test of reliability was done using Cronbach’s alpha. The
conclusion is that all item explaining organizational commitment
Population of this research consists of generic nurses of the private (such as affective, continuance and normative) is reliable because
hospitals in Makassar Indonesia. The names of the hospital were all alpha of the variables exceeded the lower limit of alpha
Grestelina Hospital, Stella Maris Hospital, Hikmah Hospital, Cronbach’s alpha standard > 0.60. The alpha coefficient of affective
Akademis Hospital, Ibnu Sina Hospital, Faisal Hospital and commitment is 0.679; the continuance commitment is 0.691;
Luramay Hospital. The sample was chosen by using the normative commitment is 0.633; and the turnover intention is 0.744.
proportionate stratified random sampling on the size of nurses’ The following is the reliability test table of the questionnaire items of
population in each hospital. According to the method, the whole affective, continuance, normative commitments and turnover
sample was 140 respondents of nurses. Source of data was taken intentions (Table 1).
from respondent using questionnaire and secondary data from the After conducting validity and reliability test among the items of
hospital being studied. Model testing was developed in this the questionnaires, we conducted a test of classical assumption on
research via a multiple regression. the data’s range. Table 2 is the result of the normality test, which
enables us to see through curve or scatter diagram. The following
scatter diagram from the test is depicted in Exhibit 1.
Data collection technique As seen in Exhibit 1, plots of the entire data are long between the
line, and the line itself tends to be on the upper right side. It means
Data were collected through personally administered that the data are distributed normally. Subsequently, multicolinearity
questionnaires at the workplace to save time, survey and interview was tested and the value shows through variance inflation factors
guidance. The questionnaire included items to measure affective (VIF). So, if VIF value < 10 with coefficient of tolerance > 0.1 or on
commitment, continuance commitment and normative commitment. the contrary (Hair et al., 1998), it means that there is no
Affective commitment was measured by 9 items of organizational multicolinierity between independent variables. The result of
ccommitment questionnaires (OCQ) of Allen and Meyer. (1990). multicolinearity is shown in Table 3.
Continuance commitment was determined by 7 items OCQ of Allen Table 3 shows that all coefficient of VIF is smaller than 10 and all
and Meyer (1990). And normative commitment was measured by 6 coefficient of tolerance is bigger than 0.1. This means that there is
items OCQ of Allen and Meyer (1990). To collect the turnover no multicolinierity between all independent variables.
intentions data, we employed the Mobley (1979) questionnaire, Heteroscedasticity is a kind of classical assumption test used to
which consists of 5 items. Closed questions are used in these observe the normality of range data through the spreadness of
questionnaire, and the options to answering the questions, Likert data. This means that if the data were spread and did not make a
scale model was used. certain configuration, data will be categorized and normally
distributed. The earlier mentioned Exhibit showed the result of
heteroscedasticity test.
Data test of validity and reliability According to Exhibit 2, configuration of scatter plot diagram was
spread into various directions, yet, there are some data, which are
Test of validity and reliability is conducted before the instruments far away from the center of diagram, and spread randomly above
are used to gather data. The test of validity uses Pearson and below zero digits,Therefore,the conclusion of data category
correlation. The value of the correlation is then compared to the and below zero digits. Therefore, the conclusion of data category
critical value. The instruments are valid when the value of the was normally distributed statistically.
10306 Afr. J. Bus. Manage.

Table 1. Reliability statistics.

Variable Cronbach’s alpha No. of items


Affective commitment 0.679 9
Continuance commitment 0.691 7
Normative commitment 0.744 5
Turnover intention 0.633 6

Table 2. The result of multicolinearity test.

Coliniearity statistics
Independent variable Coliniearity VIF
tolerance
Affective commitment 0.832 1.202
Cognitive commitment 0.773 1.294
Continuance commitment 0.736 1.358

Dependent Variable: IT
1.0

0.8
Expected Cum Prob

0.6

0.4

0.2

0.0
0.0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0
Observed Cum Prob

Exhibit 1. The scatter plot.

Table 3. The result of multicolinearity test.

Independent variable Colinearity statistics tolerance Coliniearity VIF


Affective commitment 0.832 1.202
Cognitive commitment 0.773 1.294
Normative commitment 0.736 1.358

RESULTS emotion connected with their present hospital


organization, and to be a part of it. They have a high
The description of affective commitment, sense of belonging there, and also they are very proud
continuance commitment, normative commitment being nurses in these hospitals. The distribution of
and turnover intentions frequent affective commitment variable is shown in Table
4.
1) Affective commitment is classified as high. It means 2) Continuance commitment is classified as sufficient. It
that nurses gave a high appreciation to the feeling of conveys that the nurses find it very difficult to quit from
Guntur et al. 10307

Table 4. Respondents profile (n=104).

Background variable Frequency (people) Percentage (%) Cumulative (%)


Gender 104 100
Male 16 15.40 15.40
Female 88 84.60 100.00

Age 104 100


21 – 30 years old 72 71.20 71.20
31 – 40 years old 24 23.10 94.20
> 40 years old 6 5.80 100.00

Educational level 104 100


Senior high school 23 22.10 22.10
Diploma 73 70.20 92.30
College 6 5.80 98.10
Other 2 1.90 100.00

Marriage 104 100


Married 47 45.20 45.20
Not married 57 54.80 100.00

Work length 104 100


Below 2 years 26 25.00 25.00
2 – 4 years 34 32.70 57.70
above 4 years 44 42.30 100.00

Nursing room 104 100


Intencive care unit 15 14.40 14.40
ICCU 30 28.80 43.30
Pregnant 6 5.80 49.00
Interna 18 17.30 66.30
Surgery 17 16.30 82.70
Other 18 17.30 100.00

Dependent Variable: IT

4
Regression Studentized Residual

-1

-2

-3 -2 -1 0 1 2
Regression Standardized Predicted Value

Exhibit 2. The scatter plot ZPRED and SRESID.


10308 Afr. J. Bus. Manage.

Table 5. Frequent distribution score of affective commitment.

Frequency Percentage Category


Interval
Scores (people) (%)
Low 9 – 20 0 0.00
Middle 21 – 33 42 40.38
High 34 – 45 62 59.62
Total 104 100.00 100

Table 6. Frequency distribution of continuance commitment.

Interval Frequency Percentage


Frequency
Scores People (%)
Low 7 –15 2 1.92
Middle 16 – 25 73 70.19
High 26 – 35 29 27.88
Total 104 100.00

Table 7. Frequent distribution scores of normative commitment.

Interval Frequent Percentage


Frequency
Scores (people) (%)
Low 6 – 13 3 2.88
Middle 14 – 22 60 57.69
High 23 – 30 41 39.42
Total 104 100.00

Table 8. Frequent distribution scores of turnover intention.

Interval Frequent Percentage


Frequency
Scores (people) (%)
Low 5 – 11 56 53.85
Middle 12 – 19 48 46.15
High 20 – 25 0 0.00
Total 104 100.00

their present hospital organization before they get a new the nurses will respond very well if there is possibility or
job. They do not have enough courage to leave, and alternative work outside their present hospital. The
have no choice to leave the hospitals. The description of description of frequent distribution scores of nurses’
continuance commitment frequent distribution is seen in turnover intention is shown in Table 7.
Table 5.
3) Normative commitment is classified as sufficient. It Table 8 shows the analysis of different turnover intention
means that the nurses feel loyal enough to remain in their of nurses based on demographic factors such as gender,
current hospital; therefore, they will not leave the hospital educational level, age, marriage status, and length of job
even though there is a new job waiting for them. And they by using analysis of variance. Table 9 is the summary of
feel that in this hospital, they have enough duty to take ANOVA test of turnover intention.
care of. The frequent distribution of normative According to the ANOVA test, it was found that the
commitment of nurses at Makassar is seen in Table 6. differences on the intention of nurses’ turnover are based
2
4) Turnover intentions is classified as low. It conveys that on their age. It showed by the coefficient of adjusted R =
Guntur et al. 10309

Table 9. Summary of ANOVA test of turnover intentions.

Demografic factor’s R Squared Adjusted R squared df F Sig.


Gender 0.010 0.000 1 1.028 0.313
Education 0.068 0.040 2 2.440 0.069
Age 0.069 0.050 2 3.726 0.027
Marriage status 0.020 0.011 1 2.121 0.148
Length of job 0.017 -0.002 2 0.879 0.418
a
Dependent variable: Turnover intention.

Table 10. The summary of multiple regression tests.

Variable* Coefficient Standard error T Sig.


Constant 21.443 1.543 13.896 0.000
Commitment affective (X1) -0.081 0.038 -2.120 0.036
Commitment continuance (X2) -0.061 0.053 -1.138 0.258
Commitment normative (X3) -0.074 0.049 -1.266 0.027

Multiple R = 0.570
2
R Square (R ) = 0.325
F Value = 16.053
Significant = 0.000
*Dependent variable: IT.

0.050, significant at the level of confidence of 95%. the model studied, even though the determination
Which means that the fluctuation of turnover intention is coefficient is above 50%.
significantly influenced by the age factor of about 50%; Partially, the negative significant influence of affective
meanwhile, the other demographic factors (such as commitment on turnover intentions is as much as -0.081
gender, education, marriage status and length of job) or -8.1%. The negative influence of continuance
have no significant influence to differentiate the nurses’ commitment is as much as -0.061 or -6.1%. But the
turnover intention, because the significant level is above influence of this continuance commitment on turnover
standard (0.05%). This finding is relevant to the findings intentions is insignificant. It is proved by the point of
of Mowday et al. (1982) and Zeffane (1994), that age has significant of 0.258 > 0.005. Also the negative significant
a negative significant correlation due to employees’ influence of normative commitment on turnover intentions
intention to turnover. Therefore, the fact is that almost all is as much as -0.074 or -7.4%.
nurses are in the age range of 21 to 30 (about 72%), Generally, interpretation of the multiple linear
which means that at these ages, the nurses are regression showed that if affective commitment,
categorized as young and role tryouts. Luthans (1998) continuance commitment and normative commitment
found that the stages of 20 to 35 are the stages that increase, it will make the turnover intentions to decrease.
usually result in taking a number of different jobs, and in Furthermore, among those three variable commitments,
general are very unstable and restive unproductive period the affective commitment has a dominant negative
in the person’s career. The indication is the younger the significance on turnover intentions.
employee’s age is, the bigger the employee’s intention to
leave.
The result of the influence of affective, continuance and DISCUSSION
normative commitments on turnover intentions of private
hospitals’ nurses in Makassar, Indonesia is summarized The result of the test shows that in a simultaneous
in Table 10. method, increase of affective, continuance and normative
The analysis showed that affective, continuance and commitments gave a negative effect on turnover
normative commitments of private hospital nurses have a intentions of the nurses at private hospitals in Makassar.
negative significant influence on turnover intentions. It is This result is in congruence with previous studies done
2
proved by coefficient determination (R ) that 0.325 or by scientists. Porter et al. (1991), Dole and Schroder
32.5 and 67.5% are influenced by other factors outside (2001), Necowits and Roznowski (1994) and Zeffane
10310 Afr. J. Bus. Manage.

(1994) had found that the antecedent of turnover intensions. This result encouraged previous studies done
intentions is organizational commitment. Khatri and by Porter et al. (1991), Dole and Scroeder (2001),
Homma (2001) discovered that organizational Necowits and Roznowski (1994) and Zeffane (1994).
commitment was found to be very critical in turnover Negative commitment involves the employee’s feelings of
intentions. obligation to stay with the organization (Allen and Meyer,
The study conducted by Karsh et al. (2005) assumed 1990). The emerging of employee’s feeling is similarity
that turnover intention is not predicted alone by value between norm and culture among nurses, since the
organizational commitment, but also by job satisfaction. norms that they should maintain is the reason why they
Guimares and Igbaria (1992) discovered that hold on to the hospital. Furthermore, the nurses are
organizational commitment can be an intervening convinced that loyalty is the most important matter, since
variable of job satisfaction and turnover intentions. it is their moral obligation to the hospital. To
Similar with other researchers, Howard and Homma accommodate the proof of this normative commitment,
(2001), Samad (2006), and Moncrief et al. (1997) found a hospital management must be able to support nurses
negative correlation between organizational commitment through clear mission statement, values and culture.
and turnover intentions.
Partial testing proves that there is strong negative and
significant influence of affective commitment on turnover Conclusion
intentions. It supports Burton et al. (2005). They found
that the high affective commitment will decrease the The influence of organizational commitment refers to
turnover intentions of nurses to leave the hospital. In this affective, continuance and normative commitments. The
research, we also found that the high affective influence of affective and continuance commitments of
commitment of the nurses is as a result of the positive private hospitals’ nurses in Makassar Indonesia is
perception of nurses about the hospital. They felt glad significantly negative. Partially, affective commitment has
and proud to be a part of the hospital. a dominant negative significant effect on turnover
Furthermore, they felt that their values are the same as intentions of nurses at private hospitals in Makassar,
hospital’s values; and ‘hospital’, according to those Indonesia.
nurses, ‘is their second home’.
These origins encourage the finding of Allen and Meyer
(1990). They said that psychological aspect initiates RECOMMENDATION
affective commitment through individual feelings to be
part of the organization. Different from other studies Since affective, continuance and normative commitments
which showed that continuance commitment has an influence turnover intentions, it is necessary to pay
influence on turnover intentions (Porter et al., 1991; Dole attention to these three kinds of commitments; and they
and Schroder, 2001; Necowits and Roznowski, 1994; should be managed simultaneously to optimize the
Zefanne, 1994), this research discovered that nurses’ nurses’ affective, continuance and normative
continuance commitment has an insignificant influence commitments.
on turnover intentions. The difference of these findings is In view of the fact that there is a dominant influence of
because of the differences observed in respondents’ affective commitment on turnover intentions, it is
characteristics. The previous study used employee of essential for hospital management to compose the
business organization. In the mean time, this study uses hospital culture, which is more family relational, and pay
nurses as respondents. According to the theory of Allen attention to the psychological need of the nurses like the
and Meyer (1990), continuance commitment was the financial aspect.
costs that the employee associates with leaving the For further study, we need to observe other antecedent
organization, which means that employees will be factors affecting turnover intentions, such as motivation,
committed to the organization due to cost and benefit for job satisfaction and job characteristics.
not leaving the organization. Insignificance of
continuance commitment is based on the social strength
REFERENCES
of the mind of job nurses. They will persevere in a
hospital even though they are offered another job with Allen NJ, Meyer J (1990). Organizational commitment see LaMastro,
more return. Valery, 1997. Commitment and perceived organizational support.
The negative insignificant influence of continuance Hispanic J. Behav. Sci. 19(9):152-173.
Allen NJ, Meyer JP (1991). A three-component conceptualization of
commitment on turnover intentions of nurses should be
organizational commitment. Hum. Resour. Manage. Rev. 1:61-98.
taken care of by hospital management with increase in Angle HL, Perry JL (1981). An empirical assessment of organizational
the intrinsic return and planning of the employee’s career commitment and organizational effectiveness. Admin. Sci. Quart.
path (Angle and Perry, 1981). 26:1-14.
Burton James P, Lee Thomas W, Holtom Brooks C (2002). The
This study also found out the negative significant influence of motivation to attend, ability to attend and organizational
influence of normative commitment on turnover commitment on different types of absence behaviors. J. Manage.
Guntur et al. 10311

Issues, Summer, 181-197. Luthans F (1998). Organizational Behavior. International Edition. Irwin
Cascio WF (1998). Applied Psychology in Personel Management. 3ed. McGraw-Hill, USA.
New Jersey. Prentice Hall, Inc. Moncrief WC (1996). Examining the antecedent and consequences of
Dole C, Schoeder R (2001). The impact of various factors on the sales person job stress. European J. Market. 31(11/12):786-798
personality, job satisfactiomn and turn over intentions of professional Mowday RT, Porter LW, Steers RM (1982). Employee-organization
accountants. Managerial Auditing J. 16:4234-245. linkages: the psychologi of commitment, absenteeism, and turnover.
Guimares T, Igbaria M (1992). Determinants of Turnover Intentions: IC Academic Press, New York.
and IS Personnel. Inform. Syst. Res. 3(3):273-303. Puspasari P (2003). The Relation of Job Satisfaction of Nurses to
Hair Jr. JF, Anderson RE, Tatham R, Black WC (1998). Multivariate Organizational Commitment, Faculty of Public Health,
Analysis, 5th edition. Prentice Hall International, Inc., Upper Sadle http://www.digilib.ui.ac.id opac-the html document.
River, New Jersey. Samad S (2006). Predicting turnover intentions: the case of Malaysian
Howard MH, Homma M (2001). Job satisfaction of Japanese career government doctors. J. Am. Academy Bus. Cambridge, 8(2):113-119.
woman and it’s influence on turn over intention. Asian J. Soc. Zeffane R (1994). Understanding Employee Turnover: The Need for a
Psychol. 4:23-38. Contingency Approach. Int. J. Manpow. 12:4.
Khatri N, Homma M (2001). Explaining employee turnover in an Asian
context. Hum. Resour. Manage. J. 11(1):54-74.
Kiechel W (1993). How We Will Work in The Year 2000, Fortune, May
17. pp. 38-52.

View publication stats

Вам также может понравиться