Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
“I DECLARE THAT THIS ASSIGNMENT IS ALL MY OWN WORK AND THAT I HAVE
ACKNOWLEDGED ALL MATERIALS USED FROM THE PUBLISHED OR
UNPUBLISHED WORKS OF OTHER PEOPLE. ALL REFERENCES HAVE BEEN FULLY
CITED”
Table of Contents
1. Executive Summary 3
2. Introduction 4
3. Situation Analysis 6
4. SWOT Analysis 12
5. Marketing Strategy 13
6. Conclusion 19
7. References 20
2
1. Executive Summary
Starbucks Corporation is the world largest American coffeehouse chain, which has 29,324
stores more than 75 markets around the world by the end of 2018. It was founded by three
business partners in 1971, and is headquartered in the city of Seattle. Starbucks recorded
consolidated net incomes of $6.3 billion in 2018, up 11% over the prior year [ CITATION
Sta18 \l 1042 ]. There are 291,000 estimated employees, who work for Starbucks including
191,000 people in the U.S. as of September, 2018[ CITATION Abh18 \l 1042 ] , and many
subsidiaries including Seattle's Best Coffee, Teavana, and Tazo. Starbucks sells not only
coffee products, but other beverages, light refreshments, and merchandise in supermarket and
convenient stores as well as coffeehouses[ CITATION Sta195 \l 1042 ].
In this report, we will take a closer look at Starbucks in Korean market. Starbucks Coffee
Korea Co., Ltd. is the fourth largest number of stores in the world following after the United
States, China, Canada and Japan[ CITATION sta181 \l 1042 ]. The way in which stores are
operated in the United States and their vision are applied to the Korean market. Based on
humanity, they put much emphasis on special experiences in their stores as a part of the daily
routine. It has been combined with Korean unique culture and other environmental factors, so
Starbucks Korea became a unrivalled coffeehouse chain. Throughout this report, we will be
looking at its internal and external situation, and analyze the marketing strategies, which are
currently used in Korean market. Furthermore, it will be dealt with its implications and
improvement plans with new marketing mix.
3
2. Introduction
The first branch of Starbucks was opened in Seattle, Washington, U.S. in 1971, by three
partners, Jerry Baldwin, Zev Siegl, and Gordon Bowker who were the students of the
University of San Francisco. At first, it was a retail store that sold roasted coffee beans,
however, in 1987 it was acquired by Howard Schultz who was the CEO of Starbucks from
1986 to 2000 and from 2008 to 2017 and was reborn as a coffee shop. Starbucks has grown
rapidly since then[ CITATION Edi11 \l 1042 ].
As from early 2019, Starbucks operates approximately 30,000 locations around the
globe[ CITATION Sta19 \l 1042 ] . It is the largest beverage chain in the world and among the
food chain it has been ranked second-most valuable fast food brands worldwide in 2018 after
McDonald’s. When it comes to the number of Starbucks stores in the world, it had the most
stores over 14,000 in their home country. China had the second largest number of stores
accounting for 3,521 stores. Following countries are Canada, Japan, and Korea (Republic of
Korea). As a leading coffee chain, it recorded annual income of 24.72 billion (U.S. Dollars)
in 2018[ CITATION sta18 \l 1042 ]
4
2.2 Starbucks Coffee Korea
In Korea, Starbucks first opened its Seoul location in front of prestigious Ewha Womans
University in 1999. In December 2000, it established Starbucks Korea as a 50-50 joint
venture with Shinsegae which is one of the largest department chains in Korea. In July 2004,
it opened its 100th store in Itaewon and operates about 1,260 stores as of January
2019[ CITATION Mac19 \l 1042 ]. It is the fifth highest number after U.S., China, Canada and
Japan. According to research, the city with the most Starbucks locations in the world was
founded in Seoul, South Korea with 284 stores, followed closely by New York City, U.S.
with 277 as of May 2014[ CITATION sta181 \l 1042 ]. With regard to sales revenue of
Starbucks in Korea, it has gradually increased from 617 billion won (532 million dollars) in
2014 to 1.52 trillion won (1.3 billion dollar) in 2018 surging about 150% during the past five
years[ CITATION sta19 \l 1042 ].
Figure 2 Starbucks Sales revenue in Korea from 2014 to 2018[ CITATION sta19 \l 1042 ]
The success of Starbucks in Korean market is directly traceable to the consideration of both
organization’s objectives and Korean cultural demand. As economic growth has increased in
Korea, it has driven a growing demand for coffee. It enables people afford to spend
disposable income on a cup of Americano or Latte with a piece of cake. Also, in Korean
culture, there were many meeting places so called ‘Da-bang’, which means a tea room and
served tea or instant coffee in the 70s and 80s. The newly opened franchise coffee shops like
Starbucks replaced its traditional tea rooms. Many different social brackets not only business
men but also students and mothers waiting to pick up their children gather in its space for
different purpose[ CITATION Ede15 \l 1042 ].
5
3. Situation Analysis
6
as organic cultivation and fair trade, so it is easy to shift to other brands that meet the latest
trends with low switching costs.
Nevertheless, Starbucks has the largest loyal customers among Korean coffee franchise.
Starbucks received the highest score in the coffee shop satisfaction survey of the Korea
Consumer Agency. According to the report, Starbucks ranked 3.83 out of the total score 5
among the top 7 coffee chains[ CITATION KCA17 \l 1042 ]. When it comes to psychological
traits, human beings are irrational and unreasonable so people have tendency not to change
once they get used to something[ CITATION Dan08 \l 1042 ]. Therefore, the bargaining power
of buyers is not that high strategic issue in Korea.
However, looking into the number and kind of coffee stores in Korean market, it seems
reaching saturation point. There are already many giant coffee franchise companies like
Starbucks, Coffee Bean, Ediya, etc. Also, many coffee shops that have been opened easily
due to the relatively low barriers to entry have difficulties maintaining it. According to
comparative study between opening and closing rate of new coffeehouses for the last three
years, it can be seen that many coffee shops are not easy to overcome competition. New
opening rate is gradually falling and closure rate is increasing [ CITATION Bor18 \l 1042 ].
Thus, Porter’s Five Forces analysis shows that Starbucks faces the moderate threat of new
entry in Korean market.
3.1.2 PEST
• Political Factors
It is clear that coffee house chains can be affected by various political factors. Since
Starbucks is an American coffee chain company, it is necessary to consider not only the
relationships between U.S. and coffee bean producing countries, but also the political
situation in Korea. Regarding to the level of political situation within Korea, it is relatively
stable. Also the attitude of government and consumers towards American companies,
Starbucks is not hostile[ CITATION KCA17 \l 1042 ].
However, in Korea there is growing concern over the fact that Starbucks dominates the main
commercial markets by taking advantage of the law that company-operated stores are not
restricted and limited by distance. The small business organization resists this phenomenon
and there is the bill under consideration by the National Assembly[ CITATION Jeo19 \l 1042 ].
• Economic Factors
According to economic indicators, the GDP of Korea is ranked 12 th in the world. Looking at
the unemployment rate (3.80%) and inflation rate (0.40%), these indicators imply that Korean
economy is relatively stable[ CITATION TRA19 \l 1042 ]. The economic growth of Korea
enabled people to afford disposable income on coffee products. Due to rapid economic
development and rising income levels demand for coffee has skyrocketed and coffee
consumption in Korean comprises about 6% of the total Asia Pacific market. In terms of its
imports, Korea is the seventh largest coffee importer in the world[ CITATION ICO19 \l 1042 ].
Nevertheless, this is not just optimistic situation and upbeat mood since there is problems
about rising labor costs and high rents. In Korean market, despite remarkable
8
accomplishment that the sales reached over 1 trillion won (855 million dollar) for the first
time in 2017, Starbucks Korea's operating margin (operating profit to sales ratio), which
represents the company's profitability, stood at 9%, the lowest level in the past decade. By
comparison, its operating margin in the Americas in the same year was 22.9%, which was 2.5
times that of Korea. The biggest causes are rent and labor costs and the increase costs in both
segments exceeded the operating profit growth rate (25.3%). According to Starbucks Korea,
rents and labor costs are increasing around 30% each from the previous year [ CITATION
Sta19 \l 1042 ].
• Socio-Cultural Factors
Korea, which is ranked the 7th largest importing country in the world and consumes about 512
cups of coffee per capita per year, is a country with a large coffee market that is no
exaggeration to say "Coffee republic". In Korea, coffee has become not just a drink but a
social and cultural activity that cannot be missed in everyday life. Along with economic
growth, lifestyle has been changed in many ways. It became common modern daily life that
people start a day with a cup of coffee and have a chat with their friends or a meeting with
coworkers in a Coffee shop[ CITATION Lee16 \l 1042 ]. Also another social reason for coffee
consumption is attributed to increasing health consciousness. Many studies have shown that
an adequate amount of coffee per day may beneficial to both physical and psychological
health[ CITATION Bae14 \l 1042 ]. Caffeine included in coffee was successfully combined
with the workaholic culture, which has contributed to become the world’s 12th largest
economy. Coffee became a necessity as a drink, which gives tension and vigor in our daily
life. These traits related to social and cultural factors indicate opportunities for Starbucks in
Korean market.
• Technological Factors
With the advancement of science and technology, people can easily enjoy the same quality
coffee by touching of one button at home without going to a coffee shop and waiting in a
long queue. Newly produced home coffee machines come in wide variety of types such as
manual, automatic and capsule machines or accessories. This external factor could be threat
for Starbucks business. However, many coffeehouses also take advantage of technology and
set up high end coffee machines that guarantee high quality and stable taste. Buyers are
willing to pay for relatively expensive coffee, as coffee shops offer the best flavors of coffee
9
by skilled baristas. Besides, coffee industry has been associated with various science and
technology for customer services. For instance, Starbucks Korea invented an application
about an order system, which is called ‘Siren Order’ for the first time in 2014, and it is widely
used in many other countries. Furthermore, Starbucks Korea came into the spotlight with
upgraded Siren Order system connecting with Bixby, voice recognition programs of Samsung
Electronics on April of 2018. In addition, they make full use of new technology such as drive-
through system with facial image and vehicle plate recognition software. These technological
factors might be threats for Starbucks, but they could turn crisis into opportunities by IT
skills.
Picture 2 Siren order, Drive Thru video ordering system, and Air quality management
(adopted from Starbucks Korea, 2019)
10
Besides, various cakes, regional or seasonal products, and merchandises became the ‘Stars’
with steady sales growth. As illustrated below, if the introduction of other products in
Question marks would be successful in Korean market, the products could shift to the Star
category, and further to the Cash Cow.
Figure 3 BGC Matrix applied to Korean Starbucks Products (created by author, 2019)
11
4. SWOT Analysis
STRENGTHS WEAKNESSES
OPPORTUNITIES THREATS
• Stable domestic political environment • Growing concern about its market dominance
• Amicable attitude towards American companies without regulations
• Increasing coffee consumption • Soaring rent and labor costs
• High ranked GDP and low unemployment rate • Saturated coffee market
• Lifestyle change and growing health awareness • Increasing demand for other beverages
• Unique Korean ‘tea-room’ culture • Development of home coffee machines
• Introducing of high-end coffee machines • Unstable prices of subsidiary materials
12
5. Marketing Strategy
• Price
Starbucks tries to sell not just a cup of coffee, but their brand image through the
differentiation strategy. They adhere to its premium pricing policy which has been a success
strategy especially in Asian countries. It is targeting certain age brackets, twenty to thirty
career women with both high and moderate income. Compared with other countries, in
Korea, Starbucks affords high rent and labor costs, so it might be reflected in its pricing
policy[ CITATION Sta191 \l 1042 ].
• Place
They have expanded coffeehouses in large commercial areas, which have relatively many
floating population rather than small stores focusing on take-out menus according to Korean
sedentary culture and lifestyle[ CITATION Sta192 \l 1042 ] . When it comes to the other
channels to reach its products, people can find a bottle beverage or a canned drink in grocery
shops[ CITATION Sta15 \l 1042 ] . Also, thanks to information technology, people can use
mobile application to pick up their tailored coffee without waiting in the long
queue[ CITATION Sta193 \l 1042 ].
13
• Promotion
Starbucks has known as the company which spends not so much money on its advertising.
According to statistics, Coca-Cola, PepsiCo and McDonald’s have spent billions of dollars
annually on their advertising, however, Starbucks spent a tenth on it[ CITATION sta183 \l 1042
]. Instead, they put much effort into other activities for better customer satisfaction and
building trust through word of mouth marketing. As another promotion activity, there are
various seasonal or regional products and merchandise. Starbucks Korea sells limited goods
every year bringing about 10% profit of total revenue. They introduced a design team to
differentiate merchandise in 2013. Korea is the only country with this team among the 75
countries that Starbucks has entered. Furthermore, the corporation uses online tools such as
social network service and the application[ CITATION Sta191 \l 1042 ].
• People
The founder and former CEO of Starbucks, Howard Schultz always emphasized ‘Human
Marketing’ and its first target was internal employees. Starbucks deems employees as their
first customers and endeavors to give them customer oriented mindset. As a customer, one
staff represents the organization and the service itself, and acts as a marketer for Starbucks.
That is why Starbucks call their employees ‘Partners’. They have had certain concepts of
talent for Starbucks as 3C, Coffee Man, Culture Man and Customer Man. When people join
Starbucks, all employees are hired as full-time employees and receive welfare benefits
including health coverage, education support, and bean stocks[ CITATION Sta194 \l 1042 ].
• Process
Starbucks Korea unveiled innovative services using IT technology which led many loyal
customers. Based on IT, the Siren Order and Drive Thru face to face ordering systems were
first developed at Starbucks Korea and even exported to overseas stores. The Siren Order
service is integrated with its mobile application, so customers can order and pay for the
beverages through their mobile devices. It is also a good localization case to introduce the
first video ordering system to the Drive-Thru in consideration of the characteristics of Korean
people. Besides, this in-car pickup service is linked to a plate number recognition camera, so
it enables drivers to pay automatically with a registered credit card. These processes make
Starbucks more robust in the marketplace[ CITATION Sta193 \l 1042 ].
14
• Physical Evidence
Starbucks not just sells coffee but it sells space. The term of the Third Places was originally
introduced by an American sociologist in the book, The Great Good Place [ CITATION Ray99 \l
1042 ]. As the third realm and sociable place Starbucks has maintained consistent store design
with brown and its symbol logo color, green. In addition to interior design and the music
played in the stores also strictly controlled by its headquarters. In particular, after persuading
headquarters for a long time, Starbucks Korea hung a signboard written in Korean language,
Hangeul in representing stores. Besides, considering air pollution as the main problem in
Korea, Starbucks Korea has improved indoor air quality through the latest technology and
collaboration with Korean major company, LG Electronics[ CITATION Sta191 \l 1042 ].
Table 2 Top 10 business districts ranking in high rents in the world[ CITATION CUS18 \l 1042
]
This high rent level led to several uncovered problems such as high pricing policy and
relatively low wage level in Korean market. When it comes to Starbucks coffee pricing, it is
more expensive in Asian countries including Korea as compared with the States [ CITATION
Val16 \l 1042 ]. Even though it has many solid loyal customers, an extravagant price could
make people turn against Starbucks. On the contrary to high pricing of Starbucks, the wages
17
of Starbucks Korea are relatively low compared with other countries. According to Latte
Index that “measures how many cups of coffee minimum-wage earners in different cities can
buy with their hourly pay”[ CITATION Pau17 \l 1042 ], people cannot afford to buy two cups
of Starbucks latte with their minimum wage in Korea.
In order to improve profitability, they need to adopt a different strategy. Starbucks is known
as that the ‘Place’ variable has been considered as important factor and their stores have been
opened in good locations, so they had to manage skyrocketing rents in Korea. However, they
need to develop new market such as opening new branches in places where rents are not high
since Starbucks has been successful and had many loyal customers in Korean market. It will
enable to deal with rising rent and labor costs and revise their pricing policy.
6. Conclusion
Starbucks could be a good example of a corporation that has proved successful with their
marketing strategies. Especially, Starbucks Korea made various attempts to apply with new
technology such as Siren Order system, Drive-thru video telephony services and vehicle plate
18
recognition system. Instead of spending millions of dollars on advertising, they focused on
space and experience marketing, and have developed innovative menus for the younger
generation.
Nevertheless, corporate social responsibility should not be neglected. They should respond
more actively to the inevitable environmental and community issues facing currently. Also,
there are many unsolved problems such as roaring rent and labor costs in Korean. To be a
more stable and reliable company, sustainable management is recommended through creative
new marketing mix and continuous interaction with customers.
7. References
19
Bae, at al., 2014. Coffee and health. Integrative Medicine Research, 3(4), pp. 189-191.
CLEAN WATER ACTION, 2019. CLEAN WATER ACTION. [online] Available at:
<https://www.cleanwateraction.org/features/starbucks-and-our-plastic-pollution-problem>
[Accessed: 11 05 2019].
CUSHMAN and WAKEFIELD, 2017. CUSHMAN & WAKEFIELD. [online] Available at:
<http://blog.naver.com/PostView.nhn?blogId=cushwakekor&logNo=221403478101>
[Accessed: 12 05 2019].
Edel, et al., 2015. Starbucks Corporation: Leading Innovation in the 21st Century. Journal of
Alternative Perspectives in the Social Sciences, 7(1), pp. 23-38.
Gilbert, S., 2008. The Story of Starbucks. s.l. The Creative Company.
Goi, C. L., 2009. A Review of Marketing Mix: 4Ps or More?. International Journal of
Marketing Studies, 1(1), pp. 2-15.
Korea Consumer Agency, 2017. Korea Consumer Agency. [online] Available at: <www.kca.go.kr>
Kotler, P., 2000. Marketing Management. Millennium Edition. Custom Edition for University
of Phoenix: Prentice-Hall, Inc.
Lee and Kwon, 2018. South Korea's transition from imitator to innovator: The role of external
20
demand shocks. Journal of The Japanese and International Economies, 49, pp. 28-42.
Schultz, H., 1997. Pour Your Heart Into It. Hyperion Books.
Starbucks, 2018. Starbucks Reports Q4 and Full Year Fiscal 2018 Results. [online] Available at:
<https://investor.starbucks.com/press-releases/financial-releases/press-release-
21
details/2018/Starbucks-Reports-Q4-and-Full-Year-Fiscal-2018-Results/default.aspx>
[Accessed: 30 05 2019].
Time Out, 2011. Time Out San Francisco. s.l.:Time Out Guides.
22
TRADING ECONOMICS, 2019. TRADING ECONOMICS. [online]
Available at: <https://tradingeconomics.com/south-korea/forecast>
23