Вы находитесь на странице: 1из 8

DOI: 10.1111/j.1471-0528.2008.02022.

x
www.blackwellpublishing.com/bjog
Gynaecological surgery

Prospective randomised trial comparing


gonadotrophin-releasing hormone analogues
with triple tourniquets at open myomectomy
N Al-Shabibi, L Chapman, S Madari, A Papadimitriou, P Papalampros, A Magos
University Department of Obstetrics and Gynaecology, Royal Free Hospital, London, UK
Correspondence: Dr A Magos, University Department of Obstetrics and Gynaecology, Royal Free Hospital, Pond Street, Hampstead, London,
NW3 2QG, UK. Email a.magos@medsch.ucl.ac.uk

Accepted 6 October 2008. Published Online 4 February 2009.

Objective To compare intra-operative blood loss with triple Results The two groups were similar in baseline characteristics. An
tourniquets to occlude uterine blood supply against preoperative average of 15 and 22 fibroids were removed from the GnRH
treatment with gonadotrophin-releasing hormone (GnRH) analogue and tourniquet groups respectively. Intra-operative
analogues at open myomectomy. estimated blood loss was significantly higher in the GnRH
analogue group (median 2482 ml, 75% percentile 1744–3151) than
Design A prospective randomised controlled trial.
when triple tourniquets were used (median 640 ml, 75% percentile
Setting University teaching hospital. 418–881), giving a difference between means of 1842 ml (P <
0.001). Similarly, significantly more women required blood
Population Forty women undergoing open myomectomy for
transfusion in the GnRH analogue group (70 versus 30%, P <
symptomatic fibroids.
0.025). Postoperative morbidity was similar between the two
Methods Women due to undergo open myomectomy were groups. There were two serious complications in the tourniquet
randomised to either 3 months pre-treatment with a GnRH group, but they were not considered to be directly related to
analogue or the intra-operative application of triple tourniquets occlusion of the uterine blood supply.
(number 1 polyglactin suture [VicrylEthicon Inc., Somerville, NJ,
Conclusions Triple tourniquets are significantly more effective
USA] tied around the cervix and a size 10 polythene suction
than preoperative treatment with GnRH analogues at reducing
catheter tied around the infundibulo-pelvic ligaments) to occlude
intra-operative blood loss at open myomectomy.
the uterine blood supply.
Keywords GnRH analogues, leiomyoma, myomectomy,
Main outcome measures The primary outcome measure was
tourniquets.
intra-operative blood loss. Secondary outcome measures included
postoperative blood loss, blood transfusion rate and postoperative
morbidity.

Please cite this paper as: Al-Shabibi N, Chapman L, Madari S, Papadimitriou A, Papalampros P, Magos A. Prospective randomised trial comparing
gonadotrophin-releasing hormone analogues with triple tourniquets at open myomectomy. BJOG 2009;116:681–687.

temporarily occlude the uterine blood supply at myomec-


Introduction
tomy has a long history,1,3 and we have shown previously in
Despite advances in minimal access surgery and interven- a randomised controlled trial that ‘triple’ tourniquets (tour-
tional radiological techniques, open myomectomy remains niquets applied to the uterine and ovarian vessels) are highly
the principal treatment for multiple, large uterine fibroids effective.4
when preservation of fertility is desired. Significant morbidity An alternative approach to reducing operative haemor-
is attached to the procedure, mainly due to intra-operative rhage at myomectomy involves pre-treating women with
haemorrhage.1 Several methods have been described to re- gonadotrophin-releasing hormone (GnRH) analogues.5 A
duce intra-operative bleeding at open myomectomy, includ- recent survey of UK consultant gynaecologists showed that
ing the use of vasoconstrictors (e.g. vasopressin), uterine 87% use this approach in contrast to a smaller percentage who
artery ligation, preoperative misoprostol and the use of use other methods to limit bleeding (35% use myomectomy
specific dissection techniques.2 The use of tourniquets to clamps, 23% tourniquets and 19% use vasoconstrictors).6

ª 2009 The Authors Journal compilation ª RCOG 2009 BJOG An International Journal of Obstetrics and Gynaecology 681
Al-Shabibi et al.

We wished to determine if triple tourniquets are as effective women with GnRH analogues as a matter of routine to cor-
as preoperative treatment with GnRH analogues in reducing rect the anaemia and to reduce the size of the uterus suffi-
blood loss. ciently to increase the likelihood of carrying out the surgery
via a low transverse skin incision.
Women were randomized in the outpatient clinic once it
Methods
was decided that open myomectomy was an appropriate
Forty women undergoing open myomectomy for symptom- treatment and informed consent had been obtained. Ran-
atic fibroids were recruited from the ‘Fibroid Clinic’ in our domisation was based on a random list of binary numbers
hospital for this study (Figure 1). Inclusion criteria included (1 GnRHa, 2 tourniquets). Women randomised to pre-treat-
symptomatic multiple (>3) uterine fibroids (with a uterine ment with GnRH analogues were prescribed either Zoladex
size which was the gestation equivalent of between 12 and 22 (goserelin acetate; AstraZeneca, London, UK) 3.6 mg by
weeks) in women who wished to preserve their fertility and intramuscular injection every 28 days or nafarelin nasal spray
who had opted for surgical treatment rather than uterine (Synarel; Searle, Chicago, IL, USA) 200 mg twice a day for 3
artery embolisation. The clinical diagnosis was confirmed months prior to surgery according to patient preference.
by imaging in all cases. Exclusion criteria included a history Women randomised to tourniquets were not given any pre-
of coagulopathy or treatment with anticoagulants, therapy treatment. Any woman whose haemoglobin was less than 11.0
with GnRH analogues within the previous 6 months and g/dl was prescribed ferrous sulphate 200 mg twice a day.
severe anaemia. Women with previous myomectomies were We have described the technique of using ‘triple’ tourni-
not excluded, but those with anaemia (haemoglobin less than quets previously.4 Briefly, the tourniquet group had a small
10.5 g/dl) or with a uterine size ‡24 weeks gestation equiva- incision made into the broad ligament through the avascular
lent were excluded as it was our practice to pre-treat such space just inferior to the insertion of the round ligament,

Assessed for eligiblity


(n = 254)

Excluded (n = 214):
Randomised Not meeting inclusion criteria (n = 179)
(n = 40) Refused to participate (n = 35)

Tourniquet group (n = 20) GnRHa group (n = 20):


Received allocated intervention (n = 20) Received allocated intervention (n = 20)

Lost to follow up Lost to follow up


(n = 0) (n = 0)

Analysed Analysed
(n = 20) (n = 20)

Figure 1. Consort flow chart.

682 ª 2009 The Authors Journal compilation ª RCOG 2009 BJOG An International Journal of Obstetrics and Gynaecology
Open myomectomy: triple tourniquets versus GnRHa

Table 1. Characteristics of the participants

GnRHa Tourniquets P value

No. participants 20 20
Age in years (SD) 39.4 (5.2) 40.2 (5.3) NS
Uterine size in 18.2 (2.9) 16.3 (3.9) NS
weeks (SD)
Previous myomectomy 5 5 NS
Preoperative Hb (g/dl)(SD) 13.1 (1.1) 12.6 (1.0) NS

NS, not significant.

Ethical approval was obtained for this study from the local
ethics committee (No. 6905). We estimated that we would
need 20 women in each arm based on the assumption that
40% of them would bleed >1 l in the GnRH analogue group
compared with 20% in the tourniquet group. Data were
Figure 2. Uterine size in the GnRH analogue and tournique group. analysed using the student t test or Mann–Whitney U test
depending the distribution of the data, and Fisher’s exact
fallopian tube and ovarian ligament into the uterus on each test for ordinal data. We used GraphPad Prism 4 software
side. A number 1 polyglactin suture (Vicryl) was threaded (GraphPad Software, San Diego, CA, USA) to analyse our
through the incisions and tied around the cervix above the results and assumed statistical significance at P < 0.05 level
level of the bladder to occlude the uterine arteries; we no at 80% power.
longer open the uterovesical fold as a matter of routine unless
the dome of the bladder is high and requires dissection off the
cervix. The uterine tourniquet was tied with a Roeder slip-
Results
knot and was re-tightened during the procedure as required. The two groups were similar in their baseline characteristics
Two 20-cm lengths of size 10 suction catheter tubing (Uno- including the number of women with a history of a previ-
medical A/S, Redditch, UK) were also passed through the ous open myomectomy (Table 1, Figure 2). All procedures
broad ligament incision on each side and tied around the were completed successfully and no woman required
infundibulo-pelvic ligaments to occlude the ovarian vessels. a hysterectomy.
At the end of the procedure, the ovarian ties were released There were no significant differences in the numbers of
while the uterine suture was left in situ to dissolve over the fibroids removed or in the total weight of fibroids between
following weeks. the two groups (Table 2, Figures 3 and 4). However, the mea-
Operative blood loss was carefully assessed by weighing all sured intra-operative blood loss was significantly higher in the
swabs and measuring blood collected by suction; special col- GnRH analogue group (median 2482 ml, 95% CI 1744–3151)
lecting drapes were put on either side of the laparotomy inci- compared with when triple tourniquets were used (mean 640
sion to facilitate accurate estimation. A 10-mm suction drain ml, 95% CI 418–881), giving a difference between means of
(Redovac 400; B. Braun, Melsungen, Germany) was left 1842 ml (P < 0.001) (Figure 5). Similarly, significantly more
in situ for 48 hours in all cases and haemoglobin was checked women required blood transfusion after GnRH analogues
on the first postoperative day. All women received antibiotic compared with tourniquets (70 versus 30%, P < 0.025). There
cover, usually in the form of amoxicillin/clavulanate potas- was no significant difference between the two groups in the
sium (Augmentin; SmithKlineBeecham, Worthing, UK) volume of drainage from the Redovac drains in the first
intraoperatively and for 5 days after surgery, as well as throm- 48 hours.
boprophylaxis with TED anti-embolic stockings and Enoxa- The overall incidence of postoperative complications was
parin (Clexane; Sanofi-Aventis, Guildford, UK). similar in the two groups (Table 2). Most complications were
Our primary outcome measure was intra-operative blood minor, with postoperative pyrexia accounting for most of the
loss. Secondary outcome measures included postoperative cases (7 and 4 cases in the analogue and tourniquet groups
blood loss, blood transfusion rate and postoperative morbid- respectively). One participant in the tourniquet group bled
ity. A decision was made to transfuse blood to women if their from the drain puncture site and had to return to the oper-
haemoglobin levels dropped below 8.0 g/dl. Women were ating theatre within 24 hours of her myomectomy for sutur-
discharged from hospital when clinically well enough. ing. Two other women from the tourniquet group sustained

ª 2009 The Authors Journal compilation ª RCOG 2009 BJOG An International Journal of Obstetrics and Gynaecology 683
Al-Shabibi et al.

Table 2. Operative details

GnRHa Tourniquets P value

Incision*
Midline 19 17 0.6050
Transverse 1 3
No. fibroids removed** 15.2 (9.3–21.3) 22.7 (14.9–30.5) 0.1295
Weight of fibroids (g)*** 429.5 (221–675) 384.5 (170–589) 0.6716
Estimated blood loss (ml)*** 2600 (1100–3150) 500 (295–700) ,0.001
Redivac drain at 48 hours (ml)*** 255 (50–410) 195 (60–639) 0.6894
Blood transfusion (n)*
Intra-operative 9 2 0.0256
Postoperative 8 5
Not at all 6 14
No. participants with a postoperative complication****,* 10 4 0.332
Hospital stay (days)*** 5 (5–8) 6***** (5–7) 0.6097

*Fisher’s exact test.


**Student’s unpaired t test (Mean [95% CI]).
***Mann–Whitney U test (median [25th to 75th percentile]).
****Mostly postoperative pyrexia .38C.
*****One participant stayed in hospital for 35 days.

serious complications. One woman developed disseminated Another woman undergoing her second open myo-
intravascular coagulation (DIC) and acute renal failure after mectomy developed severe uterine sepsis postoperatively
an otherwise uncomplicated myomectomy; the ovarian tour- because of a retained intra-cavity fibroid, which was
niquets were tied for 24 minutes, the operative blood loss was missed at the initial surgery, and subsequently developed
300 ml and three fibroids (total weight 502 g) were removed. Asherman’s syndrome.
She became oliguric within 48 hours but recovered fully. The Postoperative hospital stay was similar between the two
diagnosis was uncertain, but disseminated intravascular coag- groups and no woman was readmitted to hospital in the early
ulation or haemolytic uraemic syndromes are two possibilities. (£6 weeks) postoperative period.

Figure 3. Number of fibroids removed from the GnRH analogue and Figure 4. Weight of fibroids removed in the tourniquet group and
tournique group. GnRH analogue group.

684 ª 2009 The Authors Journal compilation ª RCOG 2009 BJOG An International Journal of Obstetrics and Gynaecology
Open myomectomy: triple tourniquets versus GnRHa

logues in our current study experienced similar blood loss to


the control group in our previous study (2.6 and 2.3 l, respec-
tively).4 This confirms suggestions that not only is such pre-
treatment ineffective when there are relatively few fibroids to
remove, but also when there is considerable uterine enlarge-
ment secondary to numerous fibroids.
There are, of course, well known disadvantages to the use of
GnRH analogue pre-treatment prior to myomectomy. Fibrosis
between the tissue planes can result in more difficult surgery
after GnRH analogue treatment.7,11 Furthermore, GnRH ana-
logues are expensive and cause unpleasant oestrogen deficiency
symptoms. More worryingly, they are associated with an
increase in fibroid recurrence as early as 6 months after sur-
gery.11,12 Although statistically insignificant, on average seven
more fibroids per participant were removed from the tourniquet
group than those pretreated with GnRH analogues, a finding
which may be explained by the fact that small fibroids became
too small to be identifiable at surgery in the latter group.
Figure 5. Estimated blood loss in the tourniquet group and GnRH The intra-operative injection of vasopressin, an anti-diuretic
analogue group. hormone, and its derivates has been reported to produce a
significant reduction in blood loss during myomectomy.7,13
One study compared intramyometrial vasopressin with
Discussion
mechanical occlusion of uterine vessels with a Foley catheter
A recent randomized controlled trial from our unit and and found them to be equally effective in controlling surgical
Cochrane review confirmed that ‘triple’ tourniquets applied bleeding.14 There is, however, a concern about potential phar-
to the uterine and ovarian vessels significantly reduce oper- macological adverse effects associated with accidental intra-
ative blood loss, the need for blood transfusion and perio- vasation of these drugs, including bradycardia, hypotension,
perative morbidity at open myomectomy.4,7 This pulmonary oedema, myocardial infarction and even cardiac
intervention was considered to produce the largest beneficial arrest, to the extent that their use has been banned in some
effect on blood loss during myomectomy when compared countries.15–17 Another concern that we have with the use of any
with no treatment or placebo by a recent Cochrane review.7 injectable vasoconstrictor is that the effect may either not cover
We have now shown in this study that triple tourniquets are the entire procedure necessitating repeat injections, or worse, as
also significantly more effective than pre-treatment with pointed out by the studies from Jamaica,13,14 it will mask a bleed-
GnRH analogues in reducing operative blood loss and the ing vessel which will then become manifest postoperatively. The
need for transfusion. same may also apply to drugs which work by inducing myome-
Many gynaecologists use GnRH analogues prior to myo- trial contractions during surgery, such as misoprostol.18 Miso-
mectomy (and hysterectomy) in the belief that they will prostol can also induce unpleasant adverse effects such as chills,
reduce the size of the uterus, the incidence of anaemia and nausea and vomiting, diarrhoea, headaches and pyrexia.19,20 In
operative blood loss.6 There is good evidence that pre- contrast, haemostasis, or lack of it, is immediately apparent
treatment with GnRH analogues prior to hysterectomy or when vascular occlusion is reversed, and, of course, mechanical
myomectomy for uterine fibroids will reduce both uterine devices do not have adverse pharmacological effects.
volume and fibroid size and correct anaemia.5,8,9 However, The main concern with mechanical occlusion of the blood
the published literature is by no means unanimous on their supply to the uterus, particularly the use of ovarian tourni-
effect on operative blood loss. For instance, a recent random- quets, is that prolonged ischaemia may result in ovarian
ized controlled trial could find no benefit when comparing damage and reduced ovarian reserve. However, we could
depot triptorelin against no pre-treatment.10 The average find no evidence for this in our previously published study,4
blood loss in this study was considerably less than in our and despite using tourniquets regularly for the past 7 years,
study, but the average number of fibroids removed was 3 we are not aware of any women who have become meno-
per patient (in contrast to over 15 in our study), and the pausal unexpectedly. The woman in the tourniquet group
average uterine size was 12 weeks gestation equivalent com- who became amenorrhoeic following her myomectomy had
pared with 18 weeks in our study, differences which are likely a premenopausal ovarian hormone profile with proven
to explain the greater blood loss seen in our participants. It is Asherman’s syndrome secondary to an infected intra-
also worth noting that the women treated with GnRH ana- cavitary myoma, which was missed both at her initial

ª 2009 The Authors Journal compilation ª RCOG 2009 BJOG An International Journal of Obstetrics and Gynaecology 685
Al-Shabibi et al.

surgery and subsequent laparotomy for a pelvic collection.


The other major complication in our study involved a pre-
References
viously healthy woman who became anuric following an 1 Thompson JD, Rock JA. Leiomyomata uteri and myomectomy. In: Rock
otherwise uncomplicated myomectomy but recovered fully JA, Thompson JD, editors. Te Linde’s Operative Gynaecology, 8th edn.
Philadelphia: Lippincott-Raven Publishers, 1997. pp. 731–70.
after dialysis. We have been able to find one case report of
2 Kongnyuy EJ, van den Broek N, Wiysonge CS. A systematic review of
a woman who was diagnosed with haemolytic uraemic syn- randomized controlled trials to reduce hemorrhage during myomec-
drome after open myomectomy, but we are not sure if this tomy for uterine fibroids. Int J Gynaecol Obstet 2008;100:4–9.
was the diagnosis in our participant.21 Whatever the true 3 Buttram VC Jr.Uterine leiomyomata—aetiology, symptomatology and
diagnosis, we do not believe that either of these two major management. Prog Clin Biol Res 1986;225:275–96.
4 Taylor A, Sharma M, Tsirkas P, Di Spies Sardo A, Setchell M, Magos A.
complications was related to the use of tourniquets.
Reducing blood loss at open myomectomy using triple tourniquets:
It is our current practice not to remove the tourniquet from a randomised controlled trial. BJOG 2005;112:340–5.
around the cervix at the end of the myomectomy. Although 5 Lethaby A, Vollenhoven B, Swoter M. Pre-operative GnRH analogue
we have been unable to confirm this in this study, there is therapy before hysterectomy or myomectomy for uterine fibroids.
some evidence that post-myomectomy bleeding from the Cochrane Database Syst Rev 2001;CD000547.
6 Taylor A, Sharma M, Tsirkas P, Di Spies Sardo A, Mastrogamvrakis G,
uterine incisions can be reduced if the uterine blood flow is
Buck L, et al. Surgical and radiological management of uterine
obstructed.22 Even if this effect is clinically small, inducing fibroids—a UK survey of current consultant practice. Acta Obstet
a degree of temporary uterine ischaemia may reduce the Gynecol Scand 2005;84:478–82.
chances of fibroid recurrence as seems to the case after uterine 7 Kongnyuy EJ, Wiysonge CS. Interventions to reduce haemorrhage
depletion and uterine artery embolisation prior to myomec- during myomectomy for fibroids. Cochrane Database of Syst Rev
2007: CD005355.
tomy.23,24 In contrast to permanent procedures such as embo-
8 Coddington CC, Collins RL, Shawker TH, Anderson R, Loriaux DL,
lisation and ligation of the uterine vessels, a peri-cervical Winkel CA. Long-acting gonadotropin hormone-releasing hormone
tourniquet produces only temporary occlusion of the main analog used to treat uteri. Fertil Steril 1986;45:624–9.
uterine blood supply, which we feel is theoretically at least an 9 Matta WH, Shaw RW, Nye M. Long-term follow-up of patients with
advantage in terms of future obstetric performance.25 uterine fibroids after treatment with the LHRH agonist buserelin. BJOG
1989;96:200–6.
In conclusion, our study confirms that the application of
10 Vercellini P, Trespı̀di L, Zaina B, Vicentini S, Stellato G, Crosignani PG.
‘triple’ tourniquets is more effective than preoperative treat- Gonadotrophin-releasing hormone agonist treatment before
ment with GnRH analogues at reducing intra-operative blood abdominal myomectomy: a controlled trial. Fertil Steril 2003;79:
loss at open myomectomy. This result is consistent with the 1390–5.
findings of the Cochrane Review group that of all the available 11 Fauconnier A, Chapron C, Babaki-Fard K, Dubuisson J-B. Recurrence of
leiomyomata after myomectomy. Hum Reprod Update 2000;6:
intra-operative techniques, triple tourniquets are associated
595–602.
with the greatest reduction in blood loss at open myomectomy.7 12 Lethaby A, Vollenhoven B. Fibroids (uterine moyamtosis, leiomyomas).
Clin Evid 2002;7:1666–78.
Disclosure of interest 13 Frederick J, Fletcher H, Simeon D, Mullings A, Hardie M. Intramyome-
There are none. trial vasopressin as a haemostatic agent during myomectomy. BJOG
1994;101:435–7.
14 Fletcher H, Frederick J, Hardie M, Simeon D. A randomized comparison
Contribution to authorship of vasopressin and tourniquet as hemostatic agents during myomec-
Ms Nawar Al-Shabibi performed the experiment, analysed the tomy. Obstet Gynecol 1996;87:1014–18.
data and co-wrote the paper. Dr Lynne Chapman performed the 15 Tulandi T, Beique F, Kimia M. Pulmonary edema: a complication of
experiment. Dr Sheethal Madari collected the data. Dr Angiliki local injection of vasopressin at laparoscopy. Fertil Steril 1996;66:
Papadimitrios collected the data. Dr Panos Papalampros performed 478–80.
the experiment. Mr Adam Magos conceived and designed the exper- 16 Martin JD, Shenk LG. Intraoperative myocardial infarction after
iment, analysed the data and co-wrote the manuscript. paracervical vasopressin infiltration. Anesth Analg 1994;9:1201–2.
17 Hung MH, Wang YM, Chia YY, Chou YM, Liu K. Intramyometrial injec-
tion of vasopressin causes bradycardia and cardiac arrest-report of two
Details of ethics approval cases. Acta Anaesthesiol Taiwan 2006;44:243–7.
Ethical committee reference number for this study was 04/Q0501/94 18 Celik H, Sapmaz E. Use of a single preoperative dose of misoprostol is
and the date of ethical committee approval 15 September 2004. efficacious for patients who undergo abdominal myomectomy. Fertil
Steril 2003;79:1207–10.
Funding 19 Elsheikh A, Antsaklis A, Mesogitis S, Papantoniou N, Rodolakis A,
Vogas E, et al. Use of misoprostol for the termination of second tri-
There was none.
mester pregnancies. Arch Gynecol Obstet 2001;265:204–6.
20 Graber DJ, Meier KH. Acute misoprostol toxicity. Ann Emerg Med
Acknowledgements 1991;20:549–51.
We acknowledge the help of Nikolaos Papadopoulos and Alex Taylor 21 Bravo JJ, Novoa D, Romero R, Sanchez-Guisande D. Sindrome hemo-
in this study. j litico uremico postmiomectomia. Nefrologia 2001;21:217.

686 ª 2009 The Authors Journal compilation ª RCOG 2009 BJOG An International Journal of Obstetrics and Gynaecology
Open myomectomy: triple tourniquets versus GnRHa

22 Sampaz E, Celik H, Altungul A. Bilateral ascending uterine artery liga- 24 Ngeh N, Belli A-M, Morgan R, Manyonda I. Pre-myomectomy uterine
tion vs. Tourniquet use for hemostasis in cesarean myomectomy. artery embolisation minimises operative blood loss. BJOG 2004;111:
J Reprod Med 2003;48:950–4. 1139–40.
23 Liu W-M, Tzeng C-R, Yi-Yen C, Wang P-H. Combining the uterine 25 Taylor A, Blackmore S, Tsirkas P, Magos A. Color Doppler evaluation of
artery depletion procedure and myomectomy may be useful for treat- changes in uterine perfusion induced by the use of an absorbable cervical
ing symptomatic fibroids. Fertil Steril 2004;82:205–10. tourniquet during open myomectomy. J Clin Ultrasound 2005;33:390–3.

ª 2009 The Authors Journal compilation ª RCOG 2009 BJOG An International Journal of Obstetrics and Gynaecology 687

Вам также может понравиться