Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
DOI: 10.1002/mus.26624
INVITED REVIEW
1
Department of Rehabilitation Medicine,
Changi General Hospital, Singapore Abstract
2
St Vincent's Clinical School, University of Peripheral nerve disorders are commonly encountered in clinical practice. Elec-
New South Wales, Darlinghurst, New South
trodiagnostic studies remain the cornerstone of the evaluation of nerve disorders.
Wales, Australia
More recently, ultrasound has played an increasing complementary role in the neuro-
Correspondence
muscular clinic. Ultrasound elastography is a technique that measures the elastic
Neil Simon, Suite 14a, Northern Beaches
Hospital, Frenchs Forest, NSW, Australia. properties of tissues. Given the histological changes that occur in diseased peripheral
Email: neil@nbneuro.com.au
nerves, nerve ultrasound elastography has been explored as a noninvasive way to
evaluate changes in nerve tissue composition. Studies to date suggest that nerve
stiffness tends to increase in the setting of peripheral neuropathy, regardless of etiol-
ogy, consistent with loss of more compliant myelin, and replacement with connective
tissue. The aim of this systematic review is to summarize the current literature on the
use of ultrasound elastography in the evaluation of peripheral neuropathy. Limita-
tions of ultrasound elastography and gaps in current literature are discussed, and
prospects for future clinical and research applications are raised.
KEYWORDS
carpal tunnel syndrome, nerve imaging, peripheral neuropathy, ultrasound elastography
Beyond conventional B mode ultrasound, ultrasound elastography between benign and malignant breast tissues, and also for the identifi-
techniques provide additional information on the elastic properties of cation of malignant axillary lymph nodes in combination with gray scale
tissues. Ultrasound elastography as an imaging method to detect ultrasound.17 There is now increasing interest in the use of ultrasound
changes in tissue stiffness was first described in the 1990s. 13
It is elastography for the evaluation of neuromuscular pathologies.18,19
known that tissue stiffness is altered in some pathological processes Elastic moduli are used to quantify the differences in tissue elas-
such as in some tumors and in the presence of an increase in connec- ticity (Figure 1). Essentially elastic moduli measure the relationship
tive tissue. Ultrasound elastography has predominantly been used for between the stress applied to a tissue and the deformation that
the evaluation of liver fibrosis and differentiation of malignant and occurs in response to that stress. Calculations of both elastic moduli
14,15 assume that the tissue is homogenous and isotropic. This is not the
benign neoplasms, particularly in the breast. Elastography assess-
ment of hepatic fibrosis is now routine in patients with chronic viral case in peripheral nerve, which adds a degree of variance to the calcu-
hepatitis, largely replacing liver biopsy.16 In breast cancer, various lated values. The shape and boundaries of the imaged tissue will also
ultrasound elastographic techniques have been used to discriminate impact these measurements.
Ultrasound elastography is broadly divided into strain elastography
and shear wave elastography (SWE), depending on the physical quan-
A B
tity measured (Figure 2). Strain elastography can be further subdivided
based on the method of tissue excitation. The first method of tissue
excitation is manual compression of tissue by means of the transducer
by the sonographer. The degree of manual compression may have sig-
nificant intra and interobserver variation. Mechanical devices have
been developed in an attempt to further standardize the force deliv-
ered to the tissues.20 However, such devices are cumbersome and
mainly limited to research settings. Because the force applied to the
tissues cannot be precisely quantified, rendering standardization diffi-
F I G U R E 1 The elastic moduli include Young's modulus (E) and cult, this technique provides qualitative information that is less useful
shear modulus (G).22 A, Young’s modulus measures the effect on a for research applications where serial studies are required, but may still
tissue of longitudinally applied forces. Elastic modulus is sometimes
have a role in some clinical applications.
used synonymously with Young’s modulus. B, Shear modulus is a
measure of the effect on the tissue of a shearwave (whereby a high The second method, known as ambient strain elastography, relies
intensity pulse generates a secondary (shear) wave that travels on tissue oscillations induced by vascular pulsations to cause tissue
perpendicularly through the tissue)69 distortion and then compares two areas to determine a strain ratio.
A B C
Strain elastography using external Strain elastography using internal Shear wave elastography
mechanical force mechanical stimulus (pulsations)
F I G U R E 2 Illustration of the ultrasound elastography techniques used in examination of nerves. A, Strain ultrasound elastography using
external manual compression to produce mechanical excitation. B, Ambient strain ultrasound elastography using cardiovascular pulsations to
produce mechanical excitation. Respiration may also be a form of mechanical excitation (not shown in diagram). Both forms of strain ultrasound
elastography report a ratio showing the deformation of the tissue of interest relative to an index tissue. C, Shear wave elastography (SWE), where
a focused acoustic radiation force is generated by the ultrasound transducer within a region of interest, which leads to the generation of shear
waves and tissue deformation. SWE reports a quantitative output in relation to the elasticity of the tissue such as shear wave velocity
WEE AND SIMON 3
This technique has an advantage compared with conventional strain Unlike strain elastography, which measures tissue displacement, in
elastography using external compression, as it allows a more consis- SWE, shear waves are generated after tissue excitation by an ARFI or
tent and reliable examination.21 by controlled external vibration.22 The shear wave velocity (SWV) is
Third, there is acoustic radiation force impulse (ARFI) strain imaging. In then measured providing a quantitative assessment of tissue stiffness.
this technique high intensity sonographic “push pulses” are generated, The velocity is related to tissue stiffness with stiffer tissues associated
causing underlying tissue displacement. Similar to ambient strain elasto- with faster shear wave propagation. Tissue stiffness may be reported
graphy, ARFI strain imaging provides a more objective and consistent tis- as SWV in meters/second (m/s) or as shear modulus in kilopascals
sue compression compared with compression strain elastography. (kPA).23 The relationship between shear modulus and SWV is G = ρc2,
F I G U R E 3 Ultrasound shear
wave elastography in carpal tunnel
syndrome. A, A longitudinal B-mode
image of the median nerve at the
carpal tunnel demonstrating a typical
location for elastography
measurement (above the lunate
bone). B, Elastography values in a
normal wrist. C, Demonstrates
increased median nerve stiffness in
mild carpal tunnel syndrome, which is
further increased in severe carpal
tunnel syndrome (D). D, Note that in
severe carpal tunnel syndrome there
is an increase in the stiffness of all of
the contents of the carpal tunnel,
which correlates with increasing
carpal tunnel pressure70
4 WEE AND SIMON
where G is shear modulus, ρ is tissue density (ffi1000 kg/m3) and c is pain. No further publications were identified from the bibliographies
SWV. Tissue density will vary for different types of soft tissues. of included articles. Included studies are summarized in Table 1.
Controlled external vibration is used in transient elastography,
which is an alternative form of SWE that is almost exclusively used
3 | RESULTS
for the assessment of liver fibrosis and has been widely validated for
this.24 The mechanical vibrating device is integrated within the trans-
3.1 | CTS and the median nerve
ducer, which is also used to measure the SWV.
Regardless of the type of ultrasound elastographic techniques used, Currently, the majority of studies on ultrasound elastography have focused
the results can be displayed qualitatively as a color elastogram which on the median nerve at the wrist. Several studies using both strain
shows the relative difference in tissue stiffness within the region of elastography and SWE have been published over the last 5 years. Table 1
interest (Figure 3). By convention, red represents greater stiffness while summarizes the studies of ultrasound elastography in the evaluation of nor-
blue represents lesser stiffness. B mode imaging is used to guide selec- mal median nerve and CTS. In healthy control subjects, the median nerve is
tion of the region of interest as the elastogram is usually superimposed stiffer at the wrist than the forearm.25,26 However, there was no significant
on the B mode image. Hence, a good quality B mode image is the basic difference in the elasticity of the median nerve when between each side,
starting point for obtaining a good elastographic assessment. The excep- suggesting that contralateral limbs may serve as internal controls.25
tion is transient elastography where B mode images are not generated Most of the studies in CTS have demonstrated a difference in
and thus cannot be used to guide region of interest selection. nerve stiffness in patients with CTS relative to control wrists, regard-
A comprehensive review of the physics underlying ultrasound less of ultrasound elastography techniques (Figure 3).27-40 Relation-
elastography is beyond the scope of this review but is available ships between nerve stiffness and electrophysiological measures of
elsewhere. 22 CTS severity were demonstrated in some studies, with increasing
Both strain elastography and SWE have been studied in the field severity of CTS associated with increasing nerve stiffness.27-30 Vari-
of neuromuscular research. Study protocols are heterogenous; hence, ous cutoff values have been proposed for the diagnosis of CTS along
comparison of results is challenging. Although SWE has inherent with respective sensitivity and specificity values (Table 2).
advantages compared with strain elastography due to its quantitative Beyond single cutoff values, the ratio between the stiffness of the
results, the choice of technique is often determined by availability of median nerve at the carpal tunnel relative to the nerve in the forearm
elastography modes on the ultrasound machines, training, and famil- has been proposed as a more sensitive measure of CTS, akin to the
iarity with the individual techniques. nerve CSA ratios already commonly used in CTS and ulnar neuropa-
This review provides an overview of the various studies on ultra- thy.32 A ratio of 1.48 between median nerve stiffness measures at the
sound elastography of peripheral nerves, and the relevance of these wrist and forearm was proposed as a cutoff for the diagnosis of CTS,
studies to research and clinical practice. yielding a sensitivity of 97.7% and specificity of 100%. It is interesting
that this value approximates the diagnostic cutoff limit of the “swelling
ratio” described when comparing the CSA at the wrist and forearm.
2 | METHODS This raises the possibility that elastography and CSA are dependent.
This observation requires specific statistical analysis in future studies.
Inclusion criteria were publications (including publications ahead of Ultrasound elastography has also been studied in specific patient
print) on any form of ultrasound elastography performed on periph- populations with CTS such as pregnancy and hemodialysis (Table 3).
eral nerves or the brachial plexus, in any language with an English lan- Typically, these studies have identified similar findings to idiopathic
guage abstract available. Publications from June 2009 up to and CTS. Relative increase in median nerve stiffness was also found in
including January 27, 2019 were included. Further articles were iden- patients with systemic sclerosis, leprosy, and acromegaly without
tified by reviewing bibliographies of each included article. Articles reported clinical CTS, although only one of three studies reported
were excluded if they did not pertain to peripheral nerves. results of electrodiagnostic studies.41-43 Although the significance of
We performed a literature review by a systematic search of these studies is difficult to ascertain without baseline elec-
Pubmed and Medline. Search terms included (“elasticity imaging tech- trodiagnostic studies, given that the conditions may all be associated
niques” [MeSH Terms] OR (“elasticity” [All Fields] AND “imaging” [All with peripheral nerve injury, the results suggest that “cutoff” values
Fields] AND “techniques” [All Fields] OR “elasticity imaging tech- for the diagnosis of CTS will differ among patients with other medical
niques” [All Fields] OR “elastography” [All Fields]) AND nerve [All conditions affecting the peripheral nervous system, and should not
Fields]. Additional relevant studies not identified in the above search necessarily be stand-alone values to be applied blindly.
were detected by reviewing the references of included studies. Nerve ultrasound elastography has also been used to evaluate
A total of 106 publications were identified from the literature sea- changes in the median nerve following decompressive surgery for
rch and 42 articles were included. Sixty-four publications were CTS. Median nerve stiffness decreases significantly after carpal tunnel
excluded as they were deemed irrelevant by the authors after release, associated with reduction in symptoms.20,44 It was also shown
reviewing the abstracts. We have also excluded publications in rela- that the elastographic parameters improved more consistently before
tion to peripheral nerve tumors and sciatic nerve in patients with back changes in nerve morphology, indicating that nerve ultrasound
WEE AND SIMON 5
TABLE 1 Summary of studies on the use of ultrasound elastography in the evaluation of normal median nerve and carpal tunnel syndrome
TABLE 1 (Continued)
Abbreviations: CTS, carpal tunnel syndrome; SWE, shear wave elastography; SWV, shear wave velocity.
TABLE 2 Cutoff values in median nerve elasticity in the diagnosis of carpal tunnel syndrome
n Severity
Study C CTS Cutoff Mild Moderate Severe Sen Spe PPV NPV
Kantarci et al30 2014 36 60 40.4kPa 55.1kPa+/−12.9 101.4kPa+/−26.7 93.3 88.9 93.3 88.9
Cingoz et al27 2018 18 59 38.25kPa 44.0kPa 82.0kPa 78.6 62.5 88.8 43.4
(32.5-59.5) (64.0-95.5)
Paluch et al32 2018 34 87 79kPa NA 96.6 100 100 91.9
28
Zhang et al 2017 46 72 3.0m/s 3.25m/s +/−0.41 5.24m/s+/−0.55 83.3 91.3 93.8 77.8
Arslan et al29 2018 21 96 3.23m/s 3.65m/s+/−0.53 4.01m/s+/−0.68 5.09m/s+/−0.57 81 82 95.1 50
Note: Note that direct comparison of the results is not valid given the differences in technique used (refer to Table 1).
C, controls; CTS, carpal tunnel syndrome; NA, not available; NPV, negative predictive value; PPV, positive predictive value; Sen, sensitivity; Spe, specificity.
elastography may be a more sensitive measure of nerve recovery than studies are typically around 70-80% sensitive for the diagnosis of UNE,
CSA.20 Similar changes were identified after treatment with low level and adding in B-mode ultrasound assessments increases the diagnostic
laser energy and splinting.45 As such, median nerve ultrasound sensitivity. There is presently only sparse data regarding the use of ultra-
elastography may be a potential objective measure useful to deter- sound elastography as a diagnostic modality in UNE. Like CTS, the stud-
mine the effectiveness of CTS treatments in clinical practice and clini- ies have shown increased nerve stiffness at the site of injury but a
cal trial design. There is a distinct advantage in having an objective relationship between the severity of ulnar neuropathy and ultrasound
measure to determine treatment effect given the prominent influence elastography values was not established.46,47 Increased nerve stiffness
of the surgical placebo effect on measures of clinical response. How- has also been identified in patients with ulnar neuropathy in Guyon’s
ever, with any observation performed before and after an interven- canal at the wrist.48 Based on currently published data, the role of
tion, it is critical to confirm the reproducibility of the techniques being
elastography in the diagnosis of ulnar neuropathy remains unclear.
used, particularly in the case of strain elastography techniques.
It is relevant to consider whether performing elastography in addi-
tion to standard ultrasound imaging enhances the diagnostic evalua- 3.3 | Peripheral polyneuropathy
tion of patients with CTS. Elastography improved the diagnostic
accuracy of ultrasound studies when used in combination with con- Evaluation of peripheral polyneuropathy is a common reason for
ute to the sonographic grading of severity of the CTS, which may be studies are generally effective at detecting large-fiber peripheral neu-
of relevance to treatment selection. ropathies. B-mode ultrasound studies are useful to identify inflamma-
tory and some genetic etiologies of peripheral polyneuropathy;
however, standard ultrasound studies add less value in patients with
3.2 | Ulnar neuropathy
axonal neuropathy.1 Axonal neuropathies are associated with loss of
UNE is traditionally more difficult to confirm than CTS, and further clinic myelinated axons and relative increase in intraneural connective tis-
based diagnostic tools would be welcome. Detailed electrodiagnostic sue. As such, serial measurement of nerve stiffness using ultrasound
T A B L E 3 Summary of studies on the use of ultrasound elastography in the evaluation of carpal tunnel syndrome/median nerve in relation with other conditions or following therapeutic
intervention
publication year Study type controls) Region/diagnosis technique Imaging plane Key findings
41
Ogur et al 2015 Prospective case 30:25 CTS in pregnant women Strain Longitudinal Stiffness of median nerve varies along the
control carpal tunnel, greater at the middle and
distal carpal tunnel. Higher in pregnant CTS
than pregnant controls.
Xin et al42 2017 Prospective case 49:22 CTS in hemodialysis. Strain Axial Higher strain ratio in patients with CTS
control compared to controls. Combined strain
ratio and CSA increases sensitivity of CTS
diagnosis.
Aslan et al62 2018 Prospective case 24:24 Median nerve in post stroke patients with Shear wave Longitudinal Chronic flexed wrist posture may cause
control (contralateral flexed wrist posture. median nerve compression and atrophy
wrist with increased stiffness. Excellent
serve as interobserver agreement.
control)
Burulday et al43 2018 Prospective case 30:40 Median nerve and acromegaly. Strain and Axial and Increased median nerve stiffness in
control shear wave longitudinal acromegaly.
Nogueira-Barbosa Prospective case 18:18 Median nerve and leprosy Strain Axial Increased median nerve stiffness in leprosy.
et al44 2017 control Moderate intraobserver and fair
interobserver agreement.
Yagci et al45 Prospective case 47:53:38a Systemic sclerosis versus idiopathic CTS and Strain Axial Increased median nerve stiffness in systemic
2017 control healthy volunteers. sclerosis. No significant difference between
CTS and controls.
Yoshii et al20 Cross-sectional 22 CTS post carpal tunnel release. Strain Axial Nerve swelling and stiffness may recover post
2017 carpal tunnel release with recovery of
elasticity more consistent.
Asadov et al46 2018 Prospective case 43:33 CTS post steroid injection. Strain Axial Carpal tunnel strain ratio improved post
control treatment but not median nerve strain
ratio. Strain ratio different in group
benefitting from treatment.
Tezcan et al47 Retrospective case 19:18 CTS post low level energy laser. Strain Axial Stiffness and CSA of the median nerve
2018 control decrease after low-level laser therapy for
CTS.
Aslan et al53 2018 Prospective case 25:32 Median and posterior tibial nerves in Shear wave Axial and Median and posterior tibial nerves are stiffer
control adolescents with T1DM. longitudinal in adolescents with T1 DM without DPN.
Interobserver agreement better in
longitudinal axis.
Abbreviations: CSA, cross-sectional area; CTS, carpal tunnel syndrome; DM, diabetes mellitus; DPN, diabetic peripheral neuropathy.
a
Systemic sclerosis:CTS:controls.
7
8 WEE AND SIMON
TABLE 4 Summary of studies on the use of ultrasound elastography in the evaluation of diabetic polyneuropathy
Abbreviations: CSA, cross-sectional area; DM, diabetes mellitus; DPN, diabetic peripheral neuropathy; NCS, nerve conduction studies.
elastography may provide an additional means to measure the pro- seen in more distal nerve trunks. As such, echotextural analysis is limited
gression of peripheral neuropathy (Table 4). and detecting pathology is limited to identifying focal or diffuse nerve
Using SWE, patients with type 2 diabetes mellitus with clinical dia- enlargement. SWE findings in electrodiagnostically confirmed brachial
betic peripheral neuropathy (DPN), with or without electrodiagnostic plexopathy in patients with breast cancer after radiotherapy
evidence of peripheral neuropathy, demonstrated greater stiffness of (RT) showed a marked increase in stiffness in the irradiated brachial
the tibial nerve at the ankle compared with diabetic patients without plexus relative to the un-irradiated contralateral plexus.53
49-52
DPN and normal subjects. The increase in nerve stiffness was Overall, performing ultrasound elastography on the brachial plexus is
greater as the severity of neuropathy increased.52 Of interest, there is technically challenging due to the nature of the anatomy of the area. The
increased tibial nerve stiffness in diabetic patients without DPN reliability and reproducibility is accordingly low.55 Prominent vascular
suggesting that elastography may be able to detect DPN before it structures and respiratory movements may potentially contribute to vari-
becomes evident clinically or on nerve conduction studies. ability in results. However, the results above demonstrate the potential
These studies reflect the potential of SWE to detect both clinical clinical applications of ultrasound elastography in brachial plexopathy.
DPN and subclinical DPN that was not evident on standard elec-
trodiagnostic studies. Ultrasound elastography has potential as a
4 | DISCUSSION
screening tool for early DPN in both type 1 and type 2 diabetes
mellitus, and has the advantage of less discomfort and potentially a
This systematic review has analyzed the role of ultrasound
shorter examination time compared with a standard electrodiagnostic
elastography as a tool to study peripheral nerves both in healthy and
examination. However, ultrasound elastography is not currently rec-
disease states. In many areas, application of the technique is in its
ommended as a standalone tool to diagnose DPN. The diagnosis of
infancy, although there appear to be emerging roles in the evaluation
DPN should be made in the appropriate clinical context, supported by
of peripheral polyneuropathy and entrapment neuropathy.
relevant clinical examination and neurophysiological findings.
to be under least tension is with the shoulder abducted to 30 degrees, found that different machines yielded different SWV when the same
elbow flexed to 90 degrees, and the wrist in maximum flexion. Maxi- elastographic phantom was used.63 The differences were also present at
mum tension appears when the shoulder is abducted to 90 degrees different acquisition depths and when different transducers were used.
with maximum wrist and elbow extension.56 Similar influences of On the other hand, another study demonstrated minimal variability
lower limb positioning on tibial nerve elastography have been identi- across imaging method/transducer combinations, imaging depths and
fied in most studies, although the magnitude of nerve stiffness change operators.65 Although only 2 ultrasound systems were included in this
is less. The lowest stiffness is seen with the hip and foot in the neutral study, which may limit the generalization of the study, the chosen sys-
position and the knee slightly flexed, and the highest stiffness is seen tems are widely used in clinical and research settings.
with the hip in maximum flexion, knee at maximum extension, and With respect to reliability, studies of peripheral nerve elastography
ankle at maximum dorsiflexion.56-58 have demonstrated excellent inter- and intra-observer agreement when
Overall, these studies are important because they contribute to SWE was used in the examination of median nerve in normal subjects.25
our understanding of the effect of biomechanical forces of perineural In disease states, similar inter- and intra-observer agreement was also
tissues on nerve excursion during movements. Given these findings in reported in studies using SWE in patients with CTS and
healthy subjects, it is likely that chronic limb posture associated with DPN. 27,28,40,49,50
However, technical factors, such as the degree of pres-
disease (such as contracture or spasticity) may have an impact on
sure applied through the probe, the angle of insonation, and the amount
nerve stiffness and hence elastography results. This has been con-
of gel under the probe all affect elastography studies. As such, a careful
firmed in poststroke patients with chronic flexed wrist posture where
approach in the clinic is needed to translate the excellent inter- and
the median nerve stiffness on the affected side was significantly
intra-observer agreement seen in controlled research setting into clinical
increased compared with the unaffected side.60 The authors postu-
practice.
lated that spastic flexion of the wrist had the potential to compress
the median nerve within the carpal tunnel, resulting in chronic ische-
mia and fibrosis of the median nerve, thus leading to increase in nerve 4.1.4 | The effect of transducer orientation
stiffness.
Some authors reported ultrasound elastography assessment with the
Limb position is also known to influence results of nerve conduc-
nerve in axial orientation while others used the longitudinal view.
tion studies.61 As such, like in other diagnostic studies, consistent limb
Authors have commented that it was more difficult to obtain reliable
positioning is an important methodological consideration in studies of
results when performing ultrasound elastography on nerves in the
nerve ultrasound elastography.
axial view in their preliminary studies,25,56,66 which is also the experi-
ence of our own laboratory. Elastography values tend to be higher
4.1.2 | The effect of different anatomic regions when taken in longitudinal axis compared with transverse axis.51
standardized and uniform excitatory force is required, such as is used in of nerve running in close proximity to bones such as the median nerve
SWE. While strain elastography may still provide satisfactory results, in the carpal tunnel and ulnar nerve at the cubital tunnel.
additional rigor regarding the choice of technique is required. Besides bone, other structures adjacent to the peripheral nerve
may influence the elastographic parameters obtained using SWE if
they are included in the selected region of interest. Specifically, fluid-
4.1.3 | The effect of ultrasound machine transducers containing structures such as blood vessels and cysts will be associ-
It is unclear at this point whether results are comparable across ated with signal drop out on elastograms. Stiff tissues such as tendons
machines made by different manufacturers even when similar tech- and ligaments may contaminate regions of interest and, hence, artifi-
niques are used as the results from studies of elasticity of tissue phan- cially elevate measurements. For this reason, regions of interest must
63-65 be carefully selected to only include peripheral nerve tissue. It has also
toms (ultrasound models with standardized elasticity) were mixed.
The use of different transducers within the same ultrasound machine not yet been established whether the region of interest should
can result in a statistically different ultrasound elastography results using exclude the epineurium, as is done with CSA measurements on B-
63
phantoms for image acquisitions set at the same depth. One study mode ultrasound.
10 WEE AND SIMON
Furthermore, the size of the region of interest may influence the RE FE RE NCE S
resulting values. While this has not been specifically studied in periph-
1. Gallardo E, Noto Y, Simon NG. Ultrasound in the diagnosis of periph-
eral nerves, studies of breast lesions indicate that a smaller region of eral neuropathy: structure meets function in the neuromuscular clinic.
interest may result in the best diagnostic performance.68 J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry. 2015;86(10):1066-1074.
Finally, there are many technical considerations in performing 2. Borire AA, Visser LH, Padua L, et al. Utility of maximum perfusion
intensity as an ultrasonographic marker of intraneural blood flow.
ultrasound elastography, such as transducer pressure and patient
Muscle Nerve. 2017;55(1):77-83.
positioning, which may all influence the final results. 3. Kerasnoudis A, Tsivgoulis G. Nerve ultrasound in peripheral neuropa-
thies: a review. J Neuroimaging. 2015;25(4):528-538.
4. Simon NG, Talbott J, Chin CT, Kliot M. Peripheral nerve imaging.
4.2 | Recommendations for further research Handb Clin Neurol. 2016;136:811-826.
5. Hobson-Webb LD, Padua L. Ultrasound of focal neuropathies. J Clin
Several technical factors still need to be resolved. Specifically, the Neurophysiol. 2016;33(2):94-102.
reliability of nerve ultrasound elastography using the various tech- 6. Simon NG, Kiernan MC. Precise correlation between structural and elec-
niques needs to be established. There is significant regional variabil- trophysiological disturbances in MADSAM neuropathy. Neuromuscul Dis-
ord. 2015;25(11):904-907.
ity in the ultrasound elastography of peripheral nerves, and as such 7. Gallardo E, Sedano MJ, Orizaola P, et al. Spinal nerve involvement in
further studies on healthy control subjects are required to delineate early Guillain-Barre syndrome: a clinico-electrophysiological, ultraso-
the nature of normal nerve stiffness in various anatomical regions. nographic and pathological study. Clin Neurophysiol. 2015;126:
810-819.
The optimal methodology of ultrasound elastography requires broad
8. Hobson-Webb LD. Neuromuscular ultrasound in polyneuropathies
refinement. and motor neuron disease. Muscle Nerve. 2013;47(6):790-804.
Further studies comparing different ultrasound machine manufac- 9. Noto YI, Shiga K, Tsuji Y, et al. Nerve ultrasound depicts peripheral
turers are required to ascertain whether values are comparable between nerve enlargement in patients with genetically distinct Charcot-
Marie-Tooth disease. J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry. 2015;86:
systems.
378-384.
With respect to the various clinical scenarios, most work has been 10. Hobson-Webb LD, Massey JM, Juel VC. Nerve ultrasound in diabetic
undertaken in CTS. Further studies of other compressive neuropathies polyneuropathy: correlation with clinical characteristics and elec-
are required to confirm the relevance of ultrasound elastography out- trodiagnostic testing. Muscle Nerve. 2013;47(3):379-384.
11. Borire AA, Arnold R, Pussell BA, et al. Effects of hemodialysis on
side CTS. In addition, further studies are needed to replicate the origi-
intraneural blood flow in end-stage kidney disease. Muscle Nerve.
nal CTS studies given the concerns about artifactual increase in 2018;57(2):287-293.
ultrasound elastography values at the wrist and the influence of 12. Borire AA, Issar T, Kwai NC, et al. Correlation between markers of
closely associated structures described above. peripheral nerve function and structure in type 1 diabetes. Diabetes
Metab Res Rev. 2018;34(7):e3028.
There have been only limited studies in patients with peripheral
13. Sigrist RMS, Liau J, Kaffas AE, Chammas MC, Willmann JK. Ultra-
polyneuropathy, and it would be of relevance to both clinical prac- sound elastography: review of techniques and clinical applications.
tice and clinical trial design to examine nerves in patients with axo- Theranostics. 2017;7(5):1303-1329.
14. Dietrich CF, Bamber J, Berzigotti A, et al. EFSUMB guidelines and
nal neuropathy and compare them with patients with inflammatory
recommendations on the clinical use of liver ultrasound elastography,
and hereditary demyelinating neuropathies, as well as correlating update 2017 (Long Version). Ultraschall Med. 2017;38(4):e48.
the findings with other diagnostic techniques and clinical severity 15. Cosgrove D, Piscaglia F, Bamber J, et al. EFSUMB guidelines and rec-
scales. ommendations on the clinical use of ultrasound elastography. Part 2:
clinical applications. Ultraschall Med. 2013;34(3):238-253.
16. Ferraioli G. Review of liver elastography guidelines. J Ultrasound Med.
5 | CO NC LUSIO NS 2019;38(1):9-14.
17. Lowes S, Leaver A, Cox K, Satchithananda K, Cosgrove D, Lim A.
Evolving imaging techniques for staging axillary lymph nodes in breast
Nerve ultrasound elastography is a new and rapidly developing field. cancer. Clin Radiol. 2018;73(4):396-409.
It has shown potential to add value to conventional ultrasound studies 18. Brandenburg JE, Eby SF, Song P, et al. Ultrasound elastography: the
but requires more work to be undertaken to develop it as a reliable new frontier in direct measurement of muscle stiffness. Arch Phys
Med Rehabil. 2014;95(11):2207-2219.
and useful technique. The role of ultrasound elastography in the eval-
19. Harmon B, Wells M, Park D, Gao J. Ultrasound elastography in neuro-
uation of peripheral nerve disorders is yet to be clearly defined muscular and movement disorders. Clin Imaging. 2019;53:35-42.
although it appears to be promising as an adjunct to other diagnostic 20. Yoshii Y, Tung WL, Ishii T. Strain and morphological changes of
median nerve after carpal tunnel release. J Ultrasound Med. 2017;36
studies and as a potential measure of treatment response. Further-
(6):1153-1159.
more, well-designed studies are required to advance applications of 21. Martin MJ, Cartwright MS. A pilot study of strain elastography in the
the technique to peripheral nerve disorders. diagnosis of carpal tunnel syndrome. J Clin Neurophysiol. 2017;34(2):
Ethical Publication Statement: We confirm that we have read the 114-118.
22. Shiina T, Nightingale KR, Palmeri ML, et al. WFUMB guidelines and
Journal’s position on issues involved in ethical publication and affirm
recommendations for clinical use of ultrasound elastography: Part 1:
that this report is consistent with those guidelines. None of the basic principles and terminology. Ultrasound Med Biol. 2015;41(5):
authors has any conflicts of interest to disclose. 1126-1147.
WEE AND SIMON 11
23. Taljanovic MS, Gimber LH, Becker GW, et al. Shear-wave 43. Yagci I, Kenis-Coskun O, Ozsoy T, Ozen G, Direskeneli H. Increased
elastography: basic physics and musculoskeletal applications. Radio- stiffness of median nerve in systemic sclerosis. BMC Musculoskelet
graphics. 2017;37(3):855-870. Disord. 2017;18(1):434.
24. Dhyani M, Anvari A, Samir AE. Ultrasound elastography: liver. Abdom 44. Asadov R, Erdal A, Bu gdaycı O, Gündüz OH, Ekinci G. The effective-
Imaging. 2015;40(4):698-708. ness of ultrasonography and ultrasonographic elastography in the
25. Zhu B, Yan F, He Y, et al. Evaluation of the healthy median nerve elas- diagnosis of carpal tunnel syndrome and evaluation of treatment
ticity: feasibility and reliability of shear wave elastography. Medicine response after steroid injection. Eur J Radiol. 2018;108:172-176.
(Baltimore). 2018;97(43):e12956. 45. Tezcan S, Ulu Ozturk F, Uslu N, Nalbant M, Umit Yemisci O. Carpal
26. Bedewi MA, Coraci D, Ruggeri F, Giovannini S, Gentile L, Padua L. tunnel syndrome: evaluation of the effects of low-level laser therapy
Shear wave elastography of median nerve at wrist and forearm. Het- with ultrasound strain imaging. J Ultrasound Med. 2019;36:113-122.
erogeneity of normative values. J Plast Reconstr Aesthet Surg. 2019;72 46. Lasecki M, Olchowy C, Pawlus A, Zaleska-Dorobisz U. The snapping
(1):137-171. elbow syndrome as a reason for chronic elbow neuralgia in a tennis
27. Cingoz M, Kandemirli SG, Alis DC, Samanci C, Kandemirli GC, player - MR, US and sonoelastography evaluation. Pol J Radiol. 2014;
Adatepe NU. Evaluation of median nerve by shear wave elastography 79:467-471.
and diffusion tensor imaging in carpal tunnel syndrome. Eur J Radiol. 47. Paluch L, Noszczyk B, Nitek Z, Walecki J, Osiak K, Pietruski P. Shear-
2018;101:59-64. wave elastography: a new potential method to diagnose ulnar neu-
28. Zhang C, Li M, Jiang J, et al. Diagnostic value of virtual touch tissue ropathy at the elbow. Eur Radiol. 2018;28:4932-4939.
imaging quantification for evaluating median nerve stiffness in carpal 48. Paluch Ł, Noszczyk BH, Walecki J, Osiak K, Kicin ski M, Pietruski P.
tunnel syndrome. J Ultrasound Med. 2017;36(9):1783-1791. Shear-wave elastography in the diagnosis of ulnar tunnel syndrome.
29. Arslan H, Yavuz A, _llgen F, et al. The efficiency of acoustic radiation J Plast Reconstr Aesthet Surg. 2018;71(11):1593-1599.
force impulse (ARFI) elastography in the diagnosis and staging of car- 49. Dikici AS, Ustabasioglu FE, Delil S, et al. Evaluation of the tibial nerve
pal tunnel syndrome. J Med Ultrason (2001). 2018;45:453-459. with shear-wave elastography: a potential sonographic method for
30. Kantarci F, Ustabasioglu FE, Delil S, et al. Median nerve stiffness mea- the diagnosis of diabetic peripheral neuropathy. Radiology. 2017;282
surement by shear wave elastography: a potential sonographic (2):494-501.
method in the diagnosis of carpal tunnel syndrome. Eur Radiol. 2014; 50. Jiang W, Huang S, Teng H, et al. Diagnostic performance of two-
24(2):434-440. dimensional shear wave elastography for evaluating tibial nerve stiff-
31. Orman G, Ozben S, Huseyinoglu N, Duymus M, Orman KG. Ultra- ness in patients with diabetic peripheral neuropathy. Eur Radiol. 2019;
sound elastographic evaluation in the diagnosis of carpal tunnel syn- 29:2167-2174.
drome: initial findings. Ultrasound Med Biol. 2013;39(7):1184-1189. 51. Aslan M, Aslan A, Emeksiz HC, et al. Assessment of peripheral nerves
32. Paluch L, Pietruski P, Walecki J, Noszczyk BH. Wrist to forearm ratio with shear wave elastography in type 1 diabetic adolescents without
as a median nerve shear wave elastography test in carpal tunnel syn- diabetic peripheral neuropathy. J Ultrasound Med. 2019;38:1583-
drome diagnosis. J Plast Reconstr Aesthet Surg. 2018;71:1146-1152. 1596.
33. Kesikburun S, Adiguzel E, Kesikburun B, Yasar E. Sonoelastographic 52. Ishibashi F, Taniguchi M, Kojima R, Kawasaki A, Kosaka A, Uetake H.
assessment of the median nerve in the longitudinal plane for carpal Elasticity of the tibial nerve assessed by sonoelastography was
tunnel syndrome. PM R. 2016;8(2):183-185. reduced before the development of neuropathy and further deterio-
34. Yoshii Y, Tung WL, Ishii T. Measurement of median nerve strain and ration associated with the severity of neuropathy in patients with
applied pressure for the diagnosis of carpal tunnel syndrome. Ultra- type 2 diabetes. J Diabetes Investig. 2016;7(3):404-412.
sound Med Biol. 2017;43(6):1205-1209. 53. Kültür T, Okumuş M, _lnal M, Yalçın S. Evaluation of the brachial
35. Yoshii Y, Ishii T, Tanaka T, Tung WL, Sakai S. Detecting median nerve plexus with shear wave elastography after radiotherapy for breast
strain changes with cyclic compression apparatus: a comparison of cancer. J Ultrasound Med. 2018;37:2029-2035.
carpal tunnel syndrome patients and healthy controls. Ultrasound Med 54. Bedewi MA, Nissman D, Aldossary NM, Maetani TH, El
Biol. 2015;41(3):669-674. Sharkawy MS, Koura H. Shear wave elastography of the brachial
36. Miyamoto H, Halpern EJ, Kastlunger M, et al. Carpal tunnel syn- plexus roots at the interscalene groove. Neurol Res. 2018;40(9):
drome: diagnosis by means of median nerve elasticity--improved 805-810.
diagnostic accuracy of US with sonoelastography. Radiology. 2014; 55. Aslan A, Aktan A, Aslan M, Gulseren Y, Kabaalioglu A. Shear wave
270(2):481-486. and strain elastographic features of the brachial plexus in healthy
37. Tatar IG, Kurt A, Yavasoglu NG, Hekimoglu B. Carpal tunnel syn- adults: reliability of the findings-a pilot study. J Ultrasound Med. 2018;
drome: elastosonographic strain ratio and cross-sectional area evalua- 37(10):2353-2362.
tion for the diagnosis and disease severity. Med Ultrason. 2016;18(3): 56. Greening J, Dilley A. Posture-induced changes in peripheral nerve
305-311. stiffness measured by ultrasound shear-wave elastography. Muscle
38. Ghajarzadeh M, Dadgostar M, Sarraf P, Emami-Razavi SZ, Miri S, Nerve. 2017;55(2):213-222.
Malek M. Application of ultrasound elastography for determining car- 57. Ellis R, Rohan M, Fox J, Hitt J, Langevin H, Henry S. Ultrasound
pal tunnel syndrome severity. Jpn J Radiol. 2015;33(5):273-278. elastographic measurement of sciatic nerve displacement and shear
39. Liao YY, Lee WN, Lee MR, et al. Carpal tunnel syndrome: US strain strain during active and passive knee extension. J Ultrasound Med.
imaging for diagnosis. Radiology. 2015;275(1):205-214. 2018;37:2091-2103.
40. Arslan H, Yavuz A, Ilgen F, et al. The efficiency of acoustic radiation 58. Andrade RJ, Nordez A, Hug F, et al. Non-invasive assessment of sci-
force impulse (ARFI) elastography in the diagnosis and staging of car- atic nerve stiffness during human ankle motion using ultrasound
pal tunnel syndrome. J Med Ultrason (2001). 2018;45(3):453-459. shear wave elastography. J Biomech. 2016;49(3):326-331.
41. Burulday V, Dogan A, Sahan MH, Arikan S, Gungunes A. Ultrasound 59. Neto T, Freitas SR, Andrade RJ, et al. Sciatic nerve stiffness is not
elastography of the median nerve in patients with acromegaly: a changed immediately after a slump neurodynamics technique. Mus-
case-control study. J Ultrasound Med. 2018;37:2371-2377. cles Ligaments Tendons J. 2017;7(3):583-589.
42. Nogueira-Barbosa MH, Lugão HB, Gregio-Júnior E, et al. Ultrasound 60. Aslan H, Analan PD. Effects of chronic flexed wrist posture on the
elastography assessment of the median nerve in leprosy patients. elasticity and crosssectional area of the median nerve at the carpal
Muscle Nerve. 2017;56(3):393-398. tunnel among chronic stroke patients. Med Ultrason. 2018;1(1):71-75.
12 WEE AND SIMON
61. Simon NG, Walker S. The role of limb position in the interpretation of 67. Bortolotto C, Turpini E, Felisaz P, et al. Median nerve evaluation by shear
nerve conduction studies. Muscle Nerve. 2017;56(3):353-354. wave elastosonography: impact of “bone-proximity” hardening artifacts
62. Simon NG, Ralph JW, Poncelet AN, Engstrom JW, Chin C, Kliot M. A and inter-observer agreement. J Ultrasound. 2017;20(4):293-299.
comparison of ultrasonographic and electrophysiologic 'inching' in ulnar 68. Moon JH, Hwang JY, Park JS, Koh SH, Park SY. Impact of region of
neuropathy at the elbow. Clin Neurophysiol. 2015;126(2):391-398. interest (ROI) size on the diagnostic performance of shear wave
63. Shin HJ, Kim MJ, Kim HY, Roh YH, Lee MJ. Comparison of shear elastography in differentiating solid breast lesions. Acta Radiol. 2018;
wave velocities on ultrasound elastography between different 59(6):657-663.
machines, transducers, and acquisition depths: a phantom study. Eur 69. Nowicki A, Dobruch-Sobczak K. Introduction to ultrasound
Radiol. 2016;26(10):3361-3367. elastography. J Ultrason. 2016;16(65):113-124.
64. Mulabecirovic A, Vesterhus M, Gilja OH, Havre RF. In vitro compari- 70. Kubo K, Zhou B, Cheng YS, et al. Ultrasound elastography for carpal
son of five different elastography systems for clinical applications, tunnel pressure measurement: a cadaveric validation study. J Orthop
using strain and shear wave technology. Ultrasound Med Biol. 2016;42 Res. 2018;36(1):477-483.
(11):2572-2588.
65. Dillman JR, Chen S, Davenport MS, et al. Superficial ultrasound shear
wave speed measurements in soft and hard elasticity phantoms:
repeatability and reproducibility using two ultrasound systems. How to cite this article: Wee TC, Simon NG. Ultrasound
Pediatr Radiol. 2015;45(3):376-385. elastography for the evaluation of peripheral nerves: A
66. Paluch L, Pietruski P, Walecki J, Noszczyk BH. Shear wave
systematic review. Muscle Nerve. 2019;1–12. https://doi.org/
elastography of median nerve at wrist and forearm. Heterogeneity of
normative values: Response to authors. J Plast Reconstr Aesthet Surg. 10.1002/mus.26624
2019;72(1):137-171.