Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
Questions 1. Can you recall any rivalry with others in your growing up years?
2. What new information does Jesus reveal in this prediction of his death? Why
does he predict his death more than once?
3. What behavior from the disciples shows their failure to accept or understand
Jesus’ warning to them of his approaching death?
4. What does Jesus mean when he asks the brothers James and John if they can
"drink the cup he will drink and be baptized with his baptism"? In what
sense do the disciples eventually share in his cup and baptism? In what sense, if
any, do we share in his cup and baptism?
5. How does biblical greatness differ from the way the world views greatness?
Why is it so hard to achieve the kind of greatness that Jesus speaks of? What
motivations are given us in this passage for pursuing this kind of greatness?
6. Give examples of relationships which require of you to become a better
servant. In what specific ways might you serve these people better?
7. What is meant when Jesus says he "came to serve and give his life as a
ransom for many?" What do we learn about his death here that we have not
been told elsewhere?
8. What is new in this healing account? What makes it significant?
9. What is Bartimaeus' response to being healed and what are the implications
for us?
Main Points Concluding a section which began at 8:31 this passage of Mark's gospel explains
not only that the Messiah had come to die but that the reason for his death was to
"ransom many". We have earlier learned that he would die and there has been
much focus on the implications for his disciples. Here we learn why he will die.
Christ's death as a sacrificial death is pre-eminent in this passage.
In the last miracle which Jesus performs, just before entering Jerusalem, he gives
sight to a blind man, who has identified him as the Messiah. The Messiah has
come to die. Interestingly, twice in this passage Jesus asks the question, "What
do you want me to do for you?" In keeping with his identity, he will not give
earthly glory (what the disciples wanted from him), but he mercifully will give
people eyes to see in order that they may know him and follow him.
Commentary on the 1. Can you recall any rivalry with others in your growing up years?
Passage and Notes on
the Questions
Approach question.
2. What new information does Jesus reveal in this prediction of his
death? Why does he predict his death more than once?
This prediction is far more detailed than any previous revelation about his death.
The chart below compares the three predictions:
8:31 Son of Man must 9:31 Man kills him 10:33-34 He dies a sinner’s
die death
As before, the main purpose of prediction is to remind us after its fulfillment that
it belonged to the purpose and plan of God and was no accident. That Jesus says
it three times helps us to grasp its impending reality. The threefold warning also
brings to a focus how central is his death to his identity and task. It is the reason
for his coming. The substitutionary nature of Christ's sacrifice fills much of the
remainder of the passage. We are told not only that he must die, but why he must
die. Jesus earlier spoke of the impossibility of salvation. In this passage, the
answer to how the impossible is possible with God is becoming clearer.
3. What behavior from the disciples shows their failure to accept or
understand Jesus’ warning to them of his approaching death?
The disciples are still operating under the popular conception of the Messiah. All
they can anticipate is triumphal. They imagine themselves in positions of power
when Jesus overthrows the enemies of the Jews, reveals himself as Messiah,
ascends an earthly throne and establishes his kingdom. They do not register that
when Jesus calls "he bids us come and die." They clutch a dream that is a
fantasy. That illusion prevented them from understanding Jesus' words.
Pathetically, they ask Jesus for a blank check. "We want you to do for us
whatever we ask." Jesus asks them, "What do you want me to do for you?"
Their expectations and desires are out of line with God's ways and purposes and
so Jesus tells them that their request cannot be fulfilled. By asking further
questions, Jesus seeks to give them an appropriate and realistic understanding of
what it means to be one of his followers.
4. What does Jesus mean when he asks the brothers James and John if
they can "drink the cup he will drink and be baptized with his baptism"? In
what sense do the disciples eventually share in his cup and baptism? In
what sense, if any, do we share in his cup and baptism?
The language of "drinking the cup" and being "baptized with the baptism"
which Jesus uses is Old Testament language which referred to the judgment of
God. The cup represents God's wrath at man's sin (Job 21:20; Ps. 60:3),
particularly pride (Ps. 75:8). The gentiles had to drink it but so did Israel, who
was no better (Is. 63:6; Jer 25:19-29; 49:12; 51:7; Lam.4:21; Obad 15-16 and
Ezekiel 23:31-34). It was this wrath which led to exile; for Israel to return, the
cup must be taken from her (Is. 51:17-23). Only then will Jerusalem become an
instrument of God's judgment rather than the one judged (Zech. 12:2).
Being overwhelmed with water is also an image of God's wrath (Gen. 6:13,17;
Ex. 14:24-28; Ps. 42:7-10) and of the judgment from which he saves us (Gen. 7:1;
Ex. 14:29,30; Is. 43:2; 54:9, Jonah 2:3-6). Using this language, Jesus referred to
his unique wrath-enduring death and subsequent resurrection. It is the ordeal
which he must soon undergo. This is a unique, once for all, sin-bearing death,
which cannot be shared by the disciples. It is a task for Jesus alone.
When Jesus spoke about his cup and baptism, perhaps James and John imagined
fellowship with him and whether or not they will be able to handle the glory of
reigning with him. Their understanding, proves far off the mark. Their quick
affirmative response to Jesus' question demonstrates their utter failure to
understand the severity of the metaphors which he has used. They have grossly
underestimated his words. They do not know what they are promising. Still
Jesus tells them that they will drink the cup he drinks and be baptized with his
baptism. How? We have said they could not bear the wrath of God. For fallen
human beings such a death would lead only to destruction.
First, we share in Jesus' cup and baptism by placing our trust in him. By
believing in Jesus, he becomes our representative. In that sense we share in
Jesus' death and resurrection (Rom. 6:1-5). Second, we share in those things not
by dying for sin but by suffering (and perhaps dying) for Jesus and the gospel. In
so doing, we imitate Jesus' death. In Col. 1:24 Paul writes, "I rejoice in what
was suffered for you (Christ's suffering to do away with sin), and I fill up in
my flesh what is still lacking in regard to Christ's afflictions for the sake of
his body, which is the church."
Paul is not saying that Christ's death was somehow insufficient as a sacrifice for
sin and that he has to make up for what is lacking in it. He simply explains that
the Church by its very mission to complete the calling of people out of darkness
will complete the sufferings of Christ. There will be resistance by the spiritual
powers of darkness until Christ Jesus returns. The victory won by Jesus is the
ground upon which Paul stands and it enables him to suffer the terrible abuses
that he did experience with hope rather than despair. This is the victory of faith.
5. How does biblical greatness differ from the way the world views
greatness? Why is it so hard to achieve the kind of greatness that Jesus
speaks of? What motivations are given us in this passage for pursuing
this kind of greatness?
By the indignant response of the others it was clear that the whole group of
Jesus disciples had aspirations of greatness. They were ticked off that if James
and John were granted their request, the rest might miss out. Therefore, Jesus
confronts them all in their desire for greatness. Power in the world is used
selfishly. Other peoples interests and concerns do not count. Only the self is
aggrandized as it manipulates others for its own advantage. But Biblical greatness
uses power in order to serve others. We attempt not to control others, but to set
them free to be who God intended them to be. Through our service to them we
seek to make them great. Only their goals and purposes really matter. We
concern ourselves for the reputation of God and others before ourselves. The
language of being "a slave of all" is especially powerful.
Slaves have no rights. They belong not to themselves, but to another. They exist
for the service of others. To be the slaves of "all" is the radical nature of Jesus'
example. We do not pick and choose those before whom we will give up our
rights. If we are to be "great" in the kingdom then we give up our rights before
all people, without exception. The costs of discipleship are great but the reward
for the investment is a glorious destiny. Pride is the obstacle to this destiny. We
always want credit for what we do. (Just try to do something in secret for
another person and see how hard it is to keep it to yourself). We also want
others to think highly of us. We want prestige and honor. We are afraid that if
we become "a slave of all", that audience we seek to impress will think less of
us.
Humility is the antidote if we are to become as a slave to others. Yet, it is
probably the least valued virtue in America. One writer put it this way: "What we
usually see is a stooping forward unattended with the slightest effort to
leave by a single inch the seat in which we are so firmly established. It is an
slaves under new ownership. We need not fear this owner, however. He loved
us so much that he died for us. What he asks us to do will be in keeping with his
loving purposes for us. Some Old Testament background information further
enables us to understand Jesus' words:
1)When Israel was redeemed from slavery in Egypt, Israel's firstborn only
escaped death because lambs were killed in their place. Otherwise they would
have been judged like the firstborn of Egypt. God commanded Israel to
remember this in the annual sacrifice of the Passover lamb (Ex. 11:1-12:42). The
lamb was the "ransom" price of redemption from God's wrath. Membership of
Israel in every generation depended upon payment of a ransom (Ex. 30:12).
2) In the annual ceremony of the day of atonement, God illustrated how men
could be rescued from death by the death of another. Israel's sins were "laid
on" one goat which carried them away, while another was killed as a substitute.
A substitutionary death atones for sin, satisfying the righteous wrath of God (Lev.
16). Jesus' death, which is the ultimate act of service for others, is to be
understood as a substitutionary sacrifice. When spoken of in the context of
"drinking the cup" and "being baptized" it becomes clear that Jesus was to die
a wrath-bearing death in our place. The Judgment meant to fall on us was going
to fall on him instead. He took the hit for us. He paid the price for us.
8. What is new in this healing account? What makes it significant?
This is the final miracle that Jesus performs in Mark's gospel. Jesus is for the
first time identified as the "Son of David". This was a title which was used of
the expected Messiah in the time of Jesus. Elsewhere in the New Testament,
Davidic descent is claimed for Jesus as evidence that he is the Messiah (Rom.
1:1-4; Matt. 1:1; 12:23; 2Tim.2:8; Rev. 3:7; 22:16). It is important to stress that
the Messianic expectations did not involve the belief that the Messiah would be a
divine person. The term in its usual Jewish sense referred simply to a great
leader endowed with righteousness who was going to be sent by God to rule over
Israel and restore the nation to spiritual and physical prominence. Therefore,
while Bartimaeus was correct in attaching this designation to Jesus, it did not
communicate sufficiently Jesus' true significance.
Secondly Bartimaeus cries for "mercy." He is asking for something he knows
he does not deserve. Such an attitude is exceedingly important in one's
relationship to God. There is a sharp contrast between his approach to Jesus and
that of the disciples. When Jesus asks Bartimaeus, "What do you want me to
do for you?" this contrast is furthered by the nature of the request. He does not
ask for greatness, but for his sight only. There is perhaps some significance in the
fact that Jesus' final act of healing is one which restores sight since he has all
along been trying to get his followers to see who he is. As Jesus approaches
Jerusalem he is now identified strongly as Messiah.
9. What is Bartimaeus' response to being healed and what are the
implications for us?
Bartimaeus follows Jesus along the road. The road leads to Jerusalem where
Jesus will soon die. Freed by Christ from one form of suffering, he takes the road
as a ransom for many: paying a price for us that we could never meet
ourselves (Ps. 49:7-9, Isa 53:11-12).
Jesus simply states that this is what he came to do. His instruction to us is even
simpler: "Follow me''.
v46-52. The last healing miracle in Mark illustrates once more Jesus' continuous
service, especially to those who are of "no account".
Bartimaeus' addressing Jesus as Son of David is unusual, found only here in
Mark. It was certainly a term of high respect and possibly messianic (Isa 11.11ff,
Eze 34:23ff, Jer 23:5, 33:17), in which case it is highly appropriate as the King
draws near to his city (11:1-10).
It is also useful to look at this story as an example of conversion (it works so
well, Peter may well have so used it). Note that he did not cry out to anyone but
found out who it was first, persisted despite opposition, knew his need, came to
Jesus, made an earnest request, was made whole and followed Jesus.