Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
REPOR
Mayada Ibrahim
Contemporary
98119934
Teacher Assignment 1
Leadership
102098
1
Table of Contents_______
1. Executive Summary: 3
Objectives 3
Context of School and Curriculum Unit 3
Goals of Report 3
Recommendation List 4
2. Background Information on unit: 4
3. Comparative table: 6
4. Evidence-based Recommendations:
10
5. Reconstructed Unit: 14
Scope and Sequence 14
Concept map 15
Assessment Task and Marking Criteria 16
Redesigned Unit Outline Using UbD 20
6. References: 37
7. Appendences of Original Documents: 40
2
Executive Summary_________________________________________
Objective:
The objective of this report is to make authentic and practical recommendations for program improvement
based on evidence-based research. These recommendations aim to improve the teaching and learning
within the English faculty and classrooms at Malek Fahd Islamic school. The unit of work that has been
modified is the Film Study and Fairy Tales unit which I taught to year 7 in 2019 during my professional
practice. Following a summative evaluation of the unit, fundamental amendments were made in order to
improve literacy and numeracy, develop critical and creative thinking, and accommodate for the diverse
learning needs of students through differentiated instruction. Modifications to the unit were guided by the
three stages of the Understanding by Design (UbD) framework or ‘backward mapping’ as outlined by
McTighe and Wiggins (2012). These stages include: (1) identify desired results, (2) determine assessment
evidence and (3) planning learning experience and instruction.
3
The main goal of this report is to address the literacy concerns that are currently facing Malek Fahd and
make essential recommendations for the English faculty and in particular the Literacy Task Force, on how
to tackle this problem early on form year 7. This is extremely important considering that the latest NAPLAN
results have indicated a slump in literacy, with an alarming decline in writing skills. In view of this, the
evidence-based recommendations in this report will highlight practical strategies aimed at improving
literacy, particularly writing skills in year 7. The recommendations will also offer solutions on how to foster
critical and creative thinking and develop numeracy in the English classroom. They will further highlight the
importance of implementing differentiated strategies to meet the diverse learning needs of students. The
second goal of this report is to demonstrate to colleagues in the English faculty the value of applying the
UbD framework or ‘backward mapping’ to curriculum planning and assessment design. As the proposed
modifications will illustrate, the UbD framework is fundamental in identifying the “big ideas” that we want
students to understand deeply. It also guides teachers on how to design assessments that will allow
students to demonstrate their learning of these big ideas through transfer. Furthermore, the UbD
framework helps teachers plan lessons and experiences that will allow students to achieve the desired
results and succeed in their assessments (Wiggins & McTighe, 2005).
Recommendation List
The following recommendations help teachers at Malek Fahd Islamic School focus on the ‘big ideas’ or
transferable skills, concepts and processes, that they want year 7 students to understand and know how
to apply at the completion of the unit.
1.Focus on the various processes of writing to improve writing skills within literacy
2.Apply inquiry based and collaborative learning strategies to improve critical and creative thinking.
2.Develop numeracy skills by employing various mathematical tools to organise and present information
3.Blend Differentiated Instruction (DI) with the UbD framework to meet the diverse learning needs of
students.
5
6
Comparative Table
Area of Strengths of Concerns of the area of Suggested Changes to counteract concerns Research support for the changes suggested.
consideration the area of consideration
consideration
Comprehension The unit focuses too heavily on Provide students with opportunities to improve their Sawyer, (2010) argues that
Literacy is adequately comprehension questions, thus writing skills by encouraging them to view writing as a “the writing process (planning, drafting, editing,
addressed in the writing (both creative and process in which they plan, draft, edit and revise revising) Will gradually extend student’s
unit through persuasive) is neglected. Students their work in order to achieve clarity of expression and understanding of the language in use, and their
reading and are not provided with improve their overall literacy skills. capacity to judge and re-work their own writing
viewing. opportunities to transfer their with sensitivity” (pg. 226). Moreover, Heineke
understanding of the concepts Build on students’ reading skills by introducing the & McTighe, (2018) point out that
covered in the unit in a short story The Paper Bag Princess as a supplement ‘big ideas’ can take the form of processes such
meaningful way, through written text to the Film study. This is important as the only as drafting and revising written work to achieve
expression. other reading offered to students is through one or clarity of expression.
Speaking is also non- existent, two original fairy tales.
and students are not provided
with an opportunity to develop Foster speaking skills by providing students with
digital literacy as ICT is not opportunities to present their compositions to the
incorporated into the unit. class, also by conducting in class-debates.
N/A Numeracy was completely Provide students with opportunities to develop and Giger, Goos & Doyle, (2012) propose that the
7
Numeracy neglected in the original unit of apply their numeracy skills in English through the use of representational and digital
work. Students were not application of various mathematical tools including mathematical tools, helps to mediate and
provided with opportunities to digital tools such as internet and ICT for research and shape thinking across the curriculum
develop and apply numeracy online quizzes, plus representational tools such Steen (2007) also highlights the importance of
skills when organising and tables, Venn diagram and symbols for comparing and applying numeracy across the curriculum. This is
presenting information. contrasting texts and illustrating their understanding echoed in a national numeracy review by COAG,
of key themes in the texts. (2008) which states “the development of
students’ numeracy goes well beyond the
mathematics classroom and hence requires
an across the curriculum commitment”
Some Although some opportunities for Foster critical and creative thinking through inquiry Findings from research conducted by
opportunities critical analysis on the themes is based learning by providing students with open Arhern-Rindell, (1998) concludes that
Critical and for critical present , overall this unit was ended discussions and posing authentic questions applying inquiry-based learning strategies
Creative analysis under challenging in terms of that require them to think, not just respond to helps to promote critical thinking.
Thinking provided on the higher order thinking and posed questions . Similarly, Paul & Elder (2006) argue that
themes of the mainly superficial questions inquiry based strategies such as open ended
text through which neglected to engage Encourage students to pose their own inquiry discussions promote critical thinking
“suggested students with a critical analysis questions which they explore answers to then share because they are designed to explore
questions” on how for example, the fairy- their findings with their classmates through class
students’ understanding and reasoning.
tale genre is discussions.
In addition, Kennedy, (2007) argues that in
appropriated/subverted to
class debates are also beneficial for the
challenge certain social Foster critical and creative thinking through
development of critical thinking skills and the
stereotypes. collaborative learning. For example:
mastery of the content.
Facilitate in- class debating which also
Inquiry based teaching and
Gokhale. (1995) further proposes that
requires students to respond to question
learning not evident. deeply.
collaborative learning fosters the
Conduct a mock courtroom in which students development of critical and creative
Students are not given put a fairy-tale character on trial thinking through discussion, clarification of
opportunities to foster critical Book cover prediction, where students ideas, and evaluation of others’ ideas.
and creative thinking through examine and evaluate the book cover for The
collaborative learning. Paper Bag Princess by processing the images
they see
students were examined on the Conduct an interview with the main character
unit in the half yearly exam which form the short story.
discourages critical and creative
thinking. Change the assessment from a half yearly exam to a
8
take home assessment that requires student to
transfer their critical and creative thinking skills
through imaginative re-creation. (According to
ACCARA, students use critical and creative
thinking when they recreate and experiment with
literature).
Includes some The unit of work is not scaffolded Use backward mapping by creating a concept map to Heineke & McTighe (2006) explain that the
relevant into a weekly sequence and Identify the “big ideas” or the larger transferrable UbD framework is designed to help teachers
Understandin outcomes from outcomes are not effectively concepts that we want to students to learn and focus identify the big ideas that we want students to
g by Design the syllabus linked to teaching and learning the unit on these concepts.(e.g. literacy, numeracy understand on a deep level so that they can
sequence. An overarching goal is critical and creative thinking). This is in accordance transfer their learning to new situations.
not evident. Furthermore, a with stage one of the UbD framework.
concept map was not created for
the unit and the content was Replace the half -yearly exam with a take home Tomlinson & McTighe (2006) argue that
assessed in the half yearly exam, assessment task that caters to the diverse learning providing students with multiple and various
in which students were tested on needs of students and offers them an opportunity to assessment types, allows them to work to their
what they know ( film demonstrate their learning and understanding strengths and this ultimately leads to their
techniques, themes etc) rather through ‘transfer’. This is in accordance with stage success.
than what they understand . two of the UbD framework.
Therefore there is no evidence of Blend the UbD framework with differentiated According to Tomlinson & McTighe (2006)
transfer of understanding . instruction in order to meet the diverse learning Combining differentiated instruction with the
needs of students. This is in accordance with stage UbD framework will ensure that all students are
three of the UbD framework. learning at maximum levels.
9
10
Evidenced-Based Recommendations___________________________
Introduction
The English Faculty at Malek Fahd Islamic is strongly encouraged to consider the following
recommendations for the unit of work ‘Film Studies and Fairy Tales’. It is important to keep in mind that
the original unit lacks opportunities for critical and creative thinking, fails to adopt strategies that focus on
improving literacy – which is a major concern for the school - and overlooks the significance of
incorporating numeracy across the curriculum. The unit further offers little integration of differentiation
and inquiry -based learning, and there is no evidence of backward mapping given that a concept map had
not been created for the unit. Furthermore, students are superficially assessed on this unit in a summative
half -yearly exam which fails to adequately assess them on their understanding through “transfer”. For
students to be able to develop transferable skills, the unit of work has been redesigned with the following
recommendations in accordance with the UbD.
1.Focus on the various processes of writing to improve writing skills within literacy
The original unit of work fails to develop literacy in a meaningful way. Although it provides opportunities
for comprehension through reading and viewing, it is limited in developing students’ writing skills which is
an area of concern for the school. Considering this, the unit has been modified to ensure that the
curriculum and teaching is focused on developing a ‘big idea’ that is transferable to other situations in
accordance with stage one of the UbD framework. According to Heineke & McTighe (2018), such big ideas
can take the form of processes such as drafting and revising written work to achieve clarity of expression.
In view of this, the modifications are designed to encourage students to think of writing as a process that
involves various stages including planning, drafting, revising, and editing (Seow,2002). In the planning
stage, students brainstorm ideas to stimulate thoughts, and this helps them move past the blank page
paralysis. The editing stage of the writing process ensures that students apply the conventions of spelling,
grammar, punctuation, and syntax effectively and appropriately in order to produce a polished piece of
work (Sawyer, 2010). Equally important is the post writing stage in which students showcase their polished
product by reading it aloud to the class. This also promotes speaking skills within literacy and motivates
students by giving their writing a sense of purpose. (Seow,2002). The modifications also require teachers to
guide students through the writing process by providing checklists, scaffolds, and teacher modelling. This
is in accordance with stage three of the UbD framework which looks at designing lessons activities and
experiences that will lead to the achievement of the desired results (Wiggins & McTighe,2012). Overall, the
modifications draw on the UbD framework in order to focus the curriculum and teaching on improving
11
writing skills within literacy. This according to Roth, (2012) is an enduring concept that has value beyond
the classroom.
2.Apply inquiry based and collaborative learning strategies to improve critical & creative thinking.
The term ‘‘inquiry-based learning’’ generally refers to student-centred ways of teaching in which students
raise questions, explore situations, and develop their own ways towards solutions (Maab & Artigue,2013).
Unfortunately, the original unit outline does not provide students with many opportunities to find their
own paths to solutions because it is heavily teacher centred. To address this concern, the modifications will
allow teachers to facilitate the learning of students by incorporating inquiry based and collaborative
learning strategies, which according to Arhern-Rindell (1998) help to promote critical thinking. Fostering
critical thinking in year 7 is particularly important because the skills required to think logically and
abstractly begin during adolescence around the age of twelve (Piaget ,1997). The modifications encourage
critical thinking through collaborative learning which according to Vygotsky (1978), allows students to
perform at higher intellectual levels than individual work. Furthermore, research conducted by Gokhael
(1995) concludes that “collaborative learning fosters the development of critical thinking through
discussion, clarification of ideas, and evaluation of others’ ideas. Considering this, the modified unit of
work encourages students to work in groups to research and explore answers to inquiry-based questions.
Students are also encouraged to raise their own questions in which they explore answers to through
independent ICT based research. The modified changes also incorporate open ended class discussions
which according to Paul & Elder (2006) are designed to explore students’ understanding and reasoning. In
addition, modifications are also made to incorporate in- class debates as a collaborative tool, which
according to research undertaken by Kennedy (2007) “enhances learning by developing critical thinking
skills, oral communication skills, and empathy”. The modifications further encourage critical and creative
thinking thorough imaginative recreation. For example, students are encouraged to work in groups and
experiment with subverting a well know fairy tale by either changing the POV, adding a new character or
adapting it to a modern setting. Students also experiment with designing a book cover and blurb for their
subverted fairy tale in preparation for their assessment task. Such modifications are in accordance with
ACCARA’s (2019) definition of critical and creative thinking which states that “students use critical and
creative thinking when they recreate and experiment with literature”. Other modifications that embody
critical and creative thinking through inquiry based and collaborative learning include interviews with a
character and putting characters on trial. All the activities mentioned above are what stage two of the UbD
framework describes as ‘performance tasks. These are authentic tasks that allow students to transfer their
learning to new situations, as a way of providing evidence of understanding (Heinke & McTighe,2018).
12
2.Develop numeracy skills by employing various mathematical tools to organise and present information
Given that this is an English unit, some teachers may neglect to focus on developing students numeracy
skills, however according to COAG (2008) the development of students’ numeracy goes well beyond the
mathematics classroom and hence requires an across the curriculum commitment (p.g7). Similarly, Steen
(2007) argues the importance of engaging students with tasks that involve the use of numeracy in all
school subjects. The original unit outline failed to recognise the importance of numeracy across the
curriculum by neglecting to employ numeracy strategies. The proposed modifications address this issue by
using mathematical tools to obtain ‘evidence of understanding’ in accordance with stage two of the UbD
framework. This includes digital tools such as ICT and internet for promoting student engagement and for
providing supplementary assessments such as online quizzes - which according to stage two of the UbD
framework, provides additional evidence of students’ knowledge acquisition and skill proficiency (Heinekin
& McTighe, 2018). Other mathematical tools incorporated into the unit of work include representational
tools such as tables, symbols, and Venn diagrams to compare texts and to represent ideas (Giger, Goos &
Doyle,2012). These numeracy-based activities are authentic performance tasks that help students make
3. Blending Differentiated Instruction (DI) with the UbD framework to meet the diverse learning needs of
students.
The third stage of the UbD framework looks at designing experiences for learners to reach and
demonstrate attainment of goals (Wiggins & McTighe,2005). In order to do this, teacher must examine
how the unit will be differentiated to optimise achievement for all learners (Heineken & McTighe,2018).
Differentiated instruction is fundamental when planning and designing a unit of work because It is based
on the premise that all students bring different gifts and challenges to the classroom and they learn best
when teachers accommodate for their differences. (Tomlinson,2001). Furthermore, combining
differentiated instruction with the UbD framework, ensures that all students are learning at maximum
levels (Tomlinson & McTighe, 2006). Although the original unit of work provides some opportunities for
extension activities, accommodations for lower ability students is non -existent. The modified changes
address this concern by adjusting the curriculum content, assessment methods and teaching strategies. For
example, the curriculum content is modified to accommodate for the diverse needs of students by
13
providing them with choices for topics to explore (King,2010). Students are also given the option of
listening to the prescribed texts as an alternative to reading. The modified assessment task also
accommodates for diverse learners by providing students with choices for their writing prompts. It also
allows them to transfer their understanding of the concepts and skills taught in different and engaging
ways. Moreover, teaching strategies are differentiated by incorporating collaborative learning and ICT into
the lessons. Complex ideas are also taught through teacher modelling, scaffolds, and visual aids such as
PowerPoint presentations and YouTube videos. Given that the UbD framework helps to guide teachers on
“what” to teach and what assessment evidence to collect, differentiated instruction is essential for guiding
teaches on “how” to teach. (Tomlinson and McTighe, 2006). Therefore, Understanding by Design and
Differentiated Instruction are mutually supportive of one another and must be blended into the planning
and designing a unit of work in order to maximize the growth of individual learners.
Conclusion
The recommendations proposed above are designed to improve literacy in year 7 with a focus on
developing writing skills that can be transferred to other curriculum units and year groups. The
recommendations will also help to foster critical and creative thinking through inquiry based and
collaborative learning while also developing numeracy skills in English through the application of various
mathematical tools. In addition, the recommended changes help to meet the diverse learning needs of
students by blending differentiated instruction with the UbD framework. These recommendations are
made in accordance with the UbD framework to ensure that the goal of the unit is to have students
transfer their learning to new situations. By integrating a concept map into the unit design, teachers will be
able to determine more easily, the larger transferable concepts that they want students to understand and
be assessed on. Overall, the recommended changes ensure an improvement in the teaching and learning
of the original unit.
14
Reconstructed Scope and Sequence - Stage Four English Year 7 2020
Content outcomes
TERM 1 EN4-1A
60,000 Years and Counting (Weeks 1-11) EN4-2A
(Sub-focus – persuasive writing) EN4-3B
EN4-6C
Text Types (Fiction & Non-fiction): EN4-7D
- Indigenous Speeches EN4-8D
- Indigenous Poems
- Media
Digital texts
TERM 2 EN4-2A
EN4-4B
NOVEL: Not Another Hero (Weeks 1-10) EN4-5C
(Sub-focus – creative writing) EN4-6C
EN4-7D
Focus Text: Percy Jackson and the Lightning Thief by Rick
Riordan
Text Types:
- Fiction
- Film
- Digital texts
Multimedia
TERM 3 EN4-3B
Happily Never After (Weeks 1-10) EN4-5C
EN4-6C
EN4-7D
Focus texts: EN4-8D
Sleeping Beauty by Brothers Grimm, The Paperbag
Princess by Robert Munsch & Maleficent (2014)
Text Types:
- Fiction
- Film
Print texts
TERM 4 EN4-1A
EN4-2A
Shaking Up Shakespeare (Weeks 1-8)
EN4-3B
Focus Text: Macbeth the Graphic Novel: Plain Text EN4-4B
(graphic novel by Jon Haward & John MacDonald – 2008) EN4-9E
Text Types:
- Fiction
- Visual texts
- Print texts
- Multimedia
15
fantasy Fable Concept Map
Setting Predictable
Include folktale Good vs evil
language
legends s
Morals/lesson
Short story Conventions s
Genre
myths Introduce a character
Example
Film Form
16
Stage 4 Year 7
English
EN4-3B uses and describes language forms, features and structures of texts appropriate to a range of
purposes, audiences and contexts
EN4-5C thinks imaginatively, creatively, interpretively and critically about information, ideas and
arguments to respond to and compose texts
EN4-6C identifies and explains connections between and among texts
EN4-7D demonstrates understanding of how texts can express aspects of their broadening world and
their relationships within it
EN4-8D identifies, considers and appreciates cultural expression in texts
TASK DESCRIPTION
Rationale:
In class, you examined the way fairy tales reinforce certain social stereotypes and
how these stereotypes are challenged in appropriations like the film Maleficent and
the short story The Paper Bag Princess. You experimented with the language form
and features of the fairy tale genre and applied your critical and creative thinking
skills to compose your own appropriation of a fairy tale studied in class. You further
experimented with producing polished written compositions through the application
of the various stages of the writing process (planning, drafting, revising, editing). This
task requires you to transfer the skills and processes that you developed through
your learning of this unit.
Your Task:
17
Part A: Subverting a Fairy Tale. (15%)
(You are required to subvert a well-known Bother’s Grimm fairy tale (not examined in
class) by changing the perspective/POV that it is traditionally told from
You may select from ONE the following choices:
18
Year 7 Marking Criteria
19
PART B: Book Cover and Blurb /10
PART B-Book Cover/Blurb Marks
The book cover is creative and vividly depicts the story 13-15
Effectively conveys elements of the fairy-tale genre A
Uses language in the Blurb that is sophisticated, precise and has persuasive flair
The book cover is creative and thoroughly depicts the story 10-12
Thoroughly convey elements of the fairy-tale genre B
Uses language in the blurb, which is mature, precise with some persuasive elements
20
KEYS
Black font = original text
Red Font = adjustments to original
Green Font = literacy
Blue Font = Critical & Creative Thinking
Light Blue Font = Numeracy
Yellow Highlight = UbD
Purple Font = Differentiation
UNIT OUTLINE
Subject ENGLISH Stage: 4 Number of Weeks 6
Unit title: Film Studies and Happily, Never After
Fairy Tales
Outcome 1
Introduction to unit
recognise, reflect on, differentiation through collaborative
interpret and explain
Inquiry based learning- using their ICT devices, students are divided into
groups of three and research the following: learning /Differentiation through ICT
the connections
between their own o What is a fairy-tale?
experiences and the o How have fairy tales been told?
world in texts
o What is genre? What is a fairy-tale genre?
o Students devise THREE additional questions on their own
about what else they want to learn about fairy tales-
students research the answers to their questions. And
present their findings to the class in class discussion
Outcome 1 ICT
Class discussion Inquiry Based learning
consider and analyse
the ways their own o Discuss whether the fairy tale genre teach us important
experience affects lessons?
their responses to o What does it mean to live happily ever after?
texts
Differentiation through explicit instruction
23
and visual aid through PowerPoint
New vocabulary (Literacy) presentation imbedded with short YouTube
videos. PowerPoint is also accompanied with
Students use their ICT devises to look up the following words and write their
guided notes for student to fill out as they go
definitions in their books through each slide. The guided notes will
(Moral, Genre, Form, Content, Style Convention) contain all the information in the PowerPoint
presentation for them to paste in their
Explicitly teach the conventions/features of fairy tales through an books.
**Teachers can access this resource on the
interactive PowerPoint presentation (Literacy) English Drive
The text type appears as a short story
There is a hero/heroine (the ‘good’ character)
An ‘evil’ or ‘bad’ character
It includes magical objects, events and characters
There is a moral message
The use of predictable language (e.g. “Once upon a time”, “and they lived
happily ever after”)
A predictable plot structure (e.g. Overcoming evil and a happy ending).
The inclusion of royalty (e.g. princes and princesses) and poverty (e.g. a
poor working girl/boy) Differentiation through collaborative learning
Setting (e.g. cottage, castle, town, forest, village) and choice
Outcome 1 Students, in groups of three or pairs, read a different fairy-tale from the following
explore and choices (Literacy)
appreciate the The Frog Prince,
aesthetic qualities in Sleeping Beauty,
their own and other Differentiation through collaborative learning
texts and the power
Puss in Boots,
/Class discussion /choice
of language to Rapunzel,
24
communicate Princess and the Pea,
information, ideas, Little Red Riding Hood,
feelings and The girl the fish and the crown,
viewpoints The Ainu and the Fox, Crow and Waterhole.
outcome 4
recognise and On an A3 paper, the groups take notes on the characters and key events in the
appreciate the ways fairy-tale. They also answer the following questions: (Inquiry Based Learning)
a wide range of texts Who is telling the story?
communicate by
When was it written?
using effective
language choices Whose point of view is represented?
Whose perspective is not heard?
Who is the intended audience?
What elements of the fairy tale genre can you observe?
outcome 4 INQUIRY BASED LEARNNG -CLASS DISCSUSION
What do these fairy tales reveal about the nature and purpose of fairy
explore and analyse
the ways purpose, tales? (students should consider the social values emphasized)
audience and
context affect a
composer's choices
of content, language Appropriation & Subverted Reading
forms and features
and structures of
texts to creatively Inquiry Based Learning
shape meaning In groups of three or pairs, students use their ICT devices to research the
following terms
Outcome 5 Appropriation
Understand and
apply knowledge of
Subverted
language forms and Fractured Fairy Tales
features Students formulate their own definitions and present to the class
use imaginative texts
Differentiation through visual aid (PowerPoint
as models to
replicate or subvert Teacher then explains and demonstrates to the students (through an presentation embedded with YouTube video
examples of appropriated fairy tales.
textual conventions interactive PowerPoint presentation) the concepts of appropriation and
PowerPoint is also accompanied with guided
to create new texts subverted reading. Teacher explains To subvert something is to change or
notes for student to fill out as they go
25
through each slide. The guided notes will
twist the conventions (what usually occurs/what you expect to occur) or the
contain all the information in the PowerPoint
stereotypes of a well-known text. For example, stories change the setting, presentation for them to paste in their books
characters, plot and point of view that you are familiar with. The most **Teachers can access this resource on the
common convention of fairy tales to be subverted is the happy ending, for English Drive
example, in The Three Little Pigs the ending could have the wolf climb down
the chimney and capture the three little pigs (Which is a happy ending for
the wolf!)
Differentiation through collaborative
Class Discussion – teacher facilitates class discussion on different ways learning/class discussion
that our favourite fairy tales can be subverted
WEEK
2 Courtroom rules/ procedures/roles found on
As a class, Students examine the subverted story of Little Red Riding Hood, English Drive
Outcome 5 The Wolf's Story: What Really Happened to Little Red Riding Hood and fill
understand and out comprehension activity sheet (found on English Drive)
use conventions Fairy-tale courtroom-The wolf Vs Little Red Riding Hood-
26
of storytelling in
a range of modes
students split up into two or three groups and engage in mock courtroom
to determine whether the Wolf is guilty or innocent- teacher provides
and media, eg
digital students with courtroom procedure and rules
storytelling groups share their deliberations with the class and explain why they
reached their verdict
Outcome 5
Students to read /listen to The Paperbag Princess by Robert Munsch as a class. Teachers may wish to play the read aloud
understand and use
conventions of In groups of three or pairs, students should annotate for version for lower ability students which
storytelling in a also contains visuals.
range of modes and https://youtu.be/0bxWnzqVXHw
media, eg digital (1) subversion,
27
storytelling
(2) fairy tale genre references and for
28
Creative Writing Revision
Teachers should revise creative writing conventions covered in term TWO
i.e. structure (exposition, complication, resolution)
figurative language techniques
**Teacher projects on the smart board a piece of persuasive writing composed by Differentiation through modelling by
teacher with deliberate mistakes, and asks students to use conventions of editing using a teacher composed example with
such as a red pen, circles, asterisks to make corrections and select areas of deliberate mistakes that students can
improvement edit -in order to demonstrates to them
Students present their composition to the class and receive informal importance of editing in the stages of
peer feedback writing – this can also make them feel
empowered.
Differentiation through collaborative learning
Outcome 3
engage with the
language and
structures of texts Informal in- CLASS DEBATE:
in meaningful, Students split up into two groups and give the following statement:
contextualised and ‘GIRLS CAN DO ANYTHING THAT BOYS CAN” Debate scaffold provided
authentic ways
Students use their ICT devices to engage in Kahoot quiz on film Differentiation through engaging ICT
techniques. (Literacy) based resources and activities(Kahoot)
Extension: Students in pairs create a movie poster based on their reading Differentiation through extension activity
of Sleeping Beauty and incorporate visual techniques in their poster.
Differentiation through Visual aids
31
Students to view the theatrical trailer of Maleficent (2014) and identify https://www.youtube.com/watch?
film techniques used. Teacher to discuss with class. v=JIIgXEGAZgE
WEEK compose a range of After Viewing : Beauty and the Beast/ Maleficent
5 visual and Students compile a list of similarities and differences between the written
multimodal texts
using a variety of version and the film in relations to characters; plot; themes; setting. (using Differentiation through engaging
visual conventions, a Venn Diagram) resources/activities (venn diagrams, story
including Students to complete a plot diagram OR storyboard summary (Literacy) boards, plot diagram – scaffolds provided
composition, vectors, Teacher select scenes/camera shots from the film to identify to the class
framing and reading
the film techniques and analysis. How film techniques contribute to
pathway
setting, characterisation, plot, understanding of scenes, etc.? (Literacy)
Whose identities change during the course of the film? Whose stay the
same?
Outcome 5 compose
a range of visual and
WEEK Pair work poster analysis Differentiation through collaborative
multimodal texts
6 using a variety of learning /visual representation
visual conventions, Students should create a poster in pairs which reflects on their
including understanding of ONE traditional fairy tale genre element and how/why it
composition, vectors,
framing and reading
has been subverted in Maleficent. Students may choose to represent this Students provided with an exposition
pathway using a compare/contrast table. (Numeracy) scaffold ( located on English Drive)
Eg. Teachers can break up pair tasks using the following elements:
Outcome 5 The text type appears as a short story : How does the mode of film allow
critically analyse the
for powerful subversion?
ways experience,
knowledge, values There are ‘good’ characters. Reflect upon characters such as the old king
and perspectives can (who passed away), King Stefan, the three fairies, Aurora, Diaval
be represented
through characters,
(Maleficient’s servant),
situations and The prince and Maleficient. Have they all been ‘good’ consistently? What
concerns in texts and Differentiation through collaborative
does it tell us about the complexity of people?
how these affect
There are ‘evil’ characters à How does subverting the original villain in learning/choice
responses to texts
Sleeping Beauty allow for critical reflection? Reflect upon Maleficient’s
backstory and her development. What about Stefan? Does he remain
33
‘good’ by the end? Is there really such thing as ‘evil’ people? What do we
learn about why people do things?
A predictable plot structure à How do plot twists and subversions in plot
structure allow for rethinking of different perspectives? What is the
purpose of this?
Typical characters/Archetypes à Which characters are not typical? How do
they enrich the film? Consider why the beautiful characters in traditional
tales represent virtuosity and morality. How are the characters’
appearance (such as Maleficent and Diaval) NOT indicative of their true
selves? And how does this reflect the subverted nature of the film?
The Setting
Beauty and the Beast is set in a small town in France called Villeneuve. Class
discuss how they may have guessed that this film was set in France. Study
some of the names using a dictionary find out the meaning of Lumière, Le
Fou and Belle.
Maleficent: How is the setting of the film significant to the fairytale genre?
Suggested activity Students create a collage of different settings in their
chosen film and identify how each setting affects the story. It can help set the
mood, influence the way characters behave, affect the dialogue, foreshadow
events, invoke an emotional response, reflect the society in which the
characters live, and sometimes even plays a part in the story. Teacher
displays collages around the room
The Themes of Beauty and the Beast and Maleficent
In groups Students identify the themes of their chosen film
B&B: love, appearances, identify and exile.
Maleficent: power, greed, love (familial)
Next to each theme they should write down at least two incidents from the
film that illustrate that theme. And draw symbols to represent each theme
34
(Numeracy)
Suggested Questions Relating to the film’s themes:
The film suggests that real love means seeing the true person within instead
of just what's on the outside.
In what specific ways do the characters express their love for each other
in this film?
Why is Gaston's idea of love actually not close to love at all? What
aspects make it different from the Beast's love for Belle? Do the
servants love the Beast? How? Does that differ from Belle's love?
35
In what ways do the characters make sacrifices for others? Who are the
characters who don't make sacrifices and why?
Is there such a thing as a meaningless sacrifice in this film? If so, which
one?
3. Identity is ultimately defined by the characters themselves, who determine
what and who they are.
Whose identities change during the course of the film? Whose stay the
same?
Does the ability to change identities speak well or ill about the
characters who do? Why or why not
Suggested Extension Questions:
1. How is the written fairytale similar to Disney's movie? How are they
different? Why do you think there were differences between the movie and
the original fairytale?
2. When the townspeople hear a Beast is living outside their village, they are
quick to organize an angry mob who will march to the castle and harm the
Beast. Why do you think the townspeople were afraid of the Beast? Why
would they want to hurt him? What could the townspeople do instead of
use violence?
3. Bell is seen as "odd" and "strange" in her town. Why do you think the
villagers see Bell as different from them? When you meet someone who is
different from you, how do you make them feel comfortable and included?
36
References
Arhern-Rindell, A. (1998). Applying inquiry-based and cooperative group
learning strategies to promote critical thinking. Journal of College Science
Teaching, 28(3), 203-207.
Geiger, V., Forgasz, H., & Goos, M. (2015). A critical orientation to numeracy
across the curriculum. ZDM, 47(4), 611-624.
Goos, M. (2007). Developing numeracy in the learning areas (middle years). Keynote
address delivered at the South Australian Literacy and Numeracy Expo, Adelaide.
Kennedy, R. (2007). In-Class Debates: Fertile Ground for Active Learning and
the Cultivation of Critical Thinking and Oral Communication Skills. International
Journal of Teaching & Learning in Higher Education, 19:2, 183-190.
Seow, A. (2002). The Writing Process and Process Writing. In J. Richards & W.
Renandya (Eds.), Methodology in Language Teaching: An Anthology of Current
Practice (Approaches and Methods in Language Teaching, pp. 315-320). Cambridge:
Cambridge University Press. doi:10.1017/CBO9780511667190.044
37
Sahamid, H. (2014). Fostering Critical Thinking in the Classroom. Advances in
Language and Literary Studies, 5(6), 166-172.
Steen, L. A. (2001). Mathematics and numeracy: Two literacies, one language. The
Mathematics Educator, 6(1), 1016.
Piaget, J., & Cook, Margaret, tr. (1952). The origins of intelligence in children.
New York: International Universities Press.
Vygotsky, L., & Cole, Michael. (1978). Mind in society : The development of
higher psychological processes. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.
Wiggins, G., & McTighe, J. (2005). Understanding by design, expanded 2nd edition.
Retrieved from https://ebookcentral.proquest.com
38
Appendix A – Original Unit of Work
Summary Duration
Students are to study a relatively well known appropriation or subversion of a fairy tale story though the film Detail: Term 2
Beauty and the Beast (2017) or Maleficent (2014).
2019
The goal is to examine the gender stereotypes and atypical and typical hero references through a film study.
The film, its themes and those of related texts deal with the hackneyed themes of: true love, appearances and 6 Weeks (weeks 1-6)
identity, friendship and forgiveness, being true to yourself.
Through film text and complimentary written and visual texts and examination of themes the goal is to teach
the students film techniques and the use of cinematic manipulation through a film text.
39
Outcomes Assessment overview
Assessment for Learning: Create an
English K-10
imaginative response to stimulus which
› EN4-1A responds to and composes texts for understanding, interpretation, critical analysis, imaginative is reflective of the fantasy genre
expression and pleasure
Assessment for learning: investigation
› EN4-4B makes effective language choices to creatively shape meaning with accuracy, clarity and of series of still scenes from the core
coherence text of the Film Study. A close
connection to the cinematic techniques.
› EN4-5C thinks imaginatively, creatively, interpretively and critically about information, ideas and
arguments to respond to and compose texts Student reflection: COMPOSE one as
an online survey
› EN4-7D demonstrates understanding of how texts can express aspects of their broadening world and their
https://www.surveymonkey.com/survey
relationships within it
40
Content Teaching, learning and assessment Resources
Stage 4 - Outcome 1 Introduction Film: Shrek (Andrew Adamson, 2001)
Students:
1. Survey students’ prior knowledge through Think, Pair and
Engage personally with texts Share activity based on the following focus questions:
Online English Resources folder
recognise, reflect on, interpret and explain What is a fairytale?
the connections between their own (Greenacre) for Shrek
experiences and the world in texts How have fairytales been told?
What is genre? What is a fairytale genre? Titled - Introduction: suggested student
consider and analyse the ways their own
experience affects their responses to texts work & PPT
2. A) Students, in groups of three, read a different fairytale
explore and appreciate the aesthetic qualities Fairy Tales:
in their own and other texts and the power of The Frog Prince,
https://safeshare.tv/x/kPcrlj5OE7k
language to communicate information, ideas, Sleeping Beauty,
feelings and viewpoints
Puss in Boots, http://enjoy-teaching.com/enjoy-
Stage 4 - Outcome 4 Rapunzel, teaching-fairy-tales.html
Students: Princess and the Pea,
Little Red Riding Hood,
Engage personally with texts
Cinderella,
recognise and appreciate the ways a wide Goldilocks and the three bears, STEREOTYPING
range of texts communicate by using
Jack and the beanstalk, https://docs.google.com/viewer?
effective language choices
The girl the fish and the crown, a=v&pid=sites&srcid=ZGVmYXVsdGR
Develop and apply contextual knowledge
The Ainu and the Fox, Crow and Waterhole. vbWFpbnxm
explore and analyse the ways purpose, B) On an A3 paper, the groups take notes on the characters YW50YXN5ZmlsbXN0dWR5fGd4OjUx
audience and context affect a composer's
choices of content, language forms and and key events in the fairytale. They also answer the following MzUwMzMyZjQyNmRkOWU
features and structures of texts to creatively questions:
shape meaning
Who is telling the story?
Understand and apply knowledge of language forms Genre definitions:
and features When was it written?
Whose point of view is represented? https://dictionary.cambridge.org/dictionar
combine visual and digital elements to create
layers of meaning for serious, playful and Whose perspective is not heard? y/english/genre
Who is the intended audience?
humorous purposes
What do these fairytales reveal about the nature and
Stage 4 - Outcome 5 purpose of fairytales? (students should consider the
Students: social values emphasized)
3. Appropriation & Subverted Reading Dreamtime animation
Engage personally with texts
1. Teacher explains and demonstrates to the students the http://splash.abc.net.au/home#!/media/25
describe and explain qualities of language in
their own and others' texts that contribute to concepts appropriation and subverted reading. 70616/morning-stars
the enjoyment that can be experienced in
41
Content Teaching, learning and assessment Resources
responding to and composing texts
Appropriation is taking an image, character or technique
from one context and placing it in another or taking a
engage in wide reading of self-selected texts
for enjoyment and share responses stereotyped character out of their context and putting them
individually, in pairs and/or in small groups in a different setting. Another form of appropriation is https://www.teachingenglish.org.uk/arti
in a variety of relevant contexts, including
when the composer wants the audience to view the cle/product-process-writing-a-
digital and face-to-face contexts
conventional text through an unconventional perspective. comparison Possible products: posters,
share, reflect on, clarify and evaluate
opinions and arguments about aspects of
One example would be composing a fairytale where the and/or different film extracts/ trailers,
literary texts (ACELT1627) story, usually told from the knight’s point of view, is told youtube clips, postcards for identification
Develop and apply contextual knowledge from the dragon’s point of view. quiz
explore the ways individual interpretations Subverted readings and interpretations of texts involve
of texts are influenced by students' own
knowledge, values and cultural assumptions twisting the conventions (what usually occurs/what you
expect to occur) or the stereotypes of a well-known text. A Definitions:
critically consider the ways in which very common variety of subverted readings are so-called http://www.filmsite.org/filmterms1.html
meaning is shaped by context, purpose, fractured fairy tales. In these fairy tales the characters or
form, structure, style, content, language
choices and their own personal perspective conventions are changed. The most common convention
of fairytales to be subverted is the happy ending, for
Understand and apply knowledge of language forms example, in The Three Little Pigs the ending could have
and features Spot the Genre:
the wolf climb down the chimney and capture the three
https://www.tes.com/teaching-
understand and use conventions of little pigs (Which is a happy ending for the wolf!)
storytelling in a range of modes and media, resource/spot-the-genre-6130889
eg digital storytelling
use imaginative texts as models to replicate
or subvert textual conventions to create new 2. Students in their groups then rewrite their selected
Choice of graphic organisers to collect
texts fairytale by applying appropriation and subverted reading.
Students should consider using a storyboard or prose to brainstorm data on appropriations
present their adaptation. http://www.inspiration.com/visual-
learning/graphic-organizers
42
Content Teaching, learning and assessment Resources
Stage 4 - Outcome 7 what was the turning point. Forward, Izhar Cohen (Illustrator)
Students: Description of the main characters – use adjectives to
describe each character *provide a choice of graphic organisers
Engage personally with texts Description of the setting – use key adjectives to collect brainstorm data on
explore and analyse the ways in which Indicate the main morals or themes of the fairytale appropriations
personal experiences and perspectives shape using examples/quotes from the text. http://www.inspiration.com/visual-
their responses to texts
learning/graphic-organizers
draw on experience to consider the ways the
'real world' is represented in the imaginary 2. Teacher presents to the class PowerPoint detailing ‘Film Morning Star video and study guide
worlds of texts, including imaginative
literature, film, media and multimedia texts Techniques’. Students should compile a list of basic
http://splash.abc.net.au/home#!/media/25
techniques to establish their understanding of how film
techniques relay a visual story. 70616/morning-star
Understand and apply knowledge of language forms
and features 3. Homework: Students take three pictures of either people
analyse the ways that language features such or objects and identify three different visual techniques
as modality are used to represent individual, and there effect.
shared or disparate views of the world
4. Students in pairs create a movie poster based on their
analyse how combinations of words, sound
and images can create particular reading of their chosen text/ fairy tale and incorporating
perspectives of the same event or issue such visual techniques in their poster.
as environmental sustainability
analyse and understand the ways techniques
of representation in multimodal texts are Film Study: Beauty and the Beast/ Maleficent
used to present alternative views of the
world, people, places and events 1. Class watch the film Beauty and the Beast/ Maleficent
2. Students compile a list of similarities and differences http://en.copian.ca/library/research/plc/pa
between the written version of the fairy tale, for example, ge8.htm
as told in 1756, in French by Madame Le Prince de In a table with a comprehensive list of
Beaumont and the 2017 film. real and fictional characters classify
3. Make a list of the ways in which this story differs from the according to mythical or real.
film and a list of the ways in which it is similar - in
relations to characters; plot; themes; setting.
4. Teacher select scenes/camera shots from the film to http://en.copian.ca/library/research/plc/pa
identify to the class the film techniques and their effect. ge8.htm
Character Study In a table with a comprehensive list of
real and fictional animals classify
1. Teacher divides the class into groups of 3-4 and allocates
43
Content Teaching, learning and assessment Resources
according to mythical or real.
one character for the group to create a character profile.
(use A3 paper, once the groups complete their profile they
should then present their work to the class and the class
can take notes.) Characters that students can focus on:
Beauty and the Beast: Belle; Maurice; Beast; Gaston; This link focuses on film techniques. It
LeFou; Clothilde; Jean the Potter; Pere Robert; Lumiere; also includes a poster on Shrek and
Cogsworth; Mrs Potts questions about the fantasy genre.
Maleficent: Maleficent, Aurora, Stefan, Flittle, Knotgrass, http://cdn-
Diaval media.macmillan.com.au/mea/downloadp
dfs/ 9781420229882.pdf
Character Profile
Physical description (including dress, looks, voice)
Personality (friendly, happy etc.)
Actions of the character
Interaction with other characters
Comments on other characters
Identify one film technique (e.g. camera angle) and
the impression that it gave of their character.
The Setting
1. Beauty and the Beast is set in a small town in France
called Villeneuve. Class discuss how they may have
guessed that this film was set in France. Study some of the
names using a dictionary find out the meaning of Lumière,
Le Fou and Belle.
http://en.copian.ca/library/research/plc/pa
Maleficent: How is the setting of the film significant to ge8.htm
the fairytale genre?
2. Students create a collage of different settings in their
chosen film and identify how each setting affects the
45
Content Teaching, learning and assessment Resources
story. It can help set the mood, influence the way
characters behave, affect the dialogue, foreshadow events,
invoke an emotional response, reflect the society in which
the characters live, and sometimes even plays a part in the
story.
The Themes of Beauty and the Beast and Maleficent
5. The characters' appearances always reflect their inner Shots - long, close up, medium,
46
Content Teaching, learning and assessment Resources
selves. establishment, point of view, over the
How do the characters' appearances reflect their true shoulder, panning, dolly,
natures? How do their appearances hide their true
natures? Angles - high angle, low angle, overhead,
Which features of the servants' new forms reflect their colour - monochrome, .....
true natures?
How is the Beast's animalistic appearance emphasized music/sound - diegetic, non-diegetic,
in his movements and demeanour? dialogue, body language, costuming,
What do the villagers' appearances tell us about them? props
OR Maleficent
https://www.google.com.au/search?
How are the characters’ appearance (such as q=film+techniques+crosswords&safe=strict&rl
Maleficent in particular) NOT indicative of their true z=1C1GGRV_
selves? And how does this reflect the subverted nature enAU753AU753&source=lnms&tbm=isc
of the film? h&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwihoMDN7fHX
6. Sacrifice is the essence of love in this story—the final AhXFXbwKHSNCA2YQ_AUICigB&bi
gesture that someone else means more than yourself.
w=1024&bih=472#imgrc=fE4ZchgJmof
In what ways do the characters make sacrifices for
msM:
others? Who are the characters who don't make
sacrifices and why? https://www.google.com.au/search?
Is there such a thing as a meaningless sacrifice in this q=venn+diagram+template&safe=strict&rlz=1
film? If so, which one? C1GGRV_enAU753AU753&tbm=isch&tbo
7. Identity is ultimately defined by the characters themselves, =u&source=univ&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEw
who determine what and who they are. ju5uyN7_HXAhUCkJQKHf8HC90QsA
Whose identities change during the course of the film? QIJw&biw=1024&bih=472#imgrc=iPMk
Whose stay the same? smJNm3xUcM:
Does the ability to change identities speak well or ill
about the characters who do? Why or why not
EDWARD de BONO
Suggested Extension Questions: http://www.debonogroup.com/six_thinki
4. How is the written fairytale similar to Disney's movie? ng_hats.php
How are they different? Why do you think there were
differences between the movie and the original fairytale?
5. When the townspeople hear a Beast is living outside their
village, they are quick to organize an angry mob who will
march to the castle and harm the Beast. Why do you think
47
Content Teaching, learning and assessment Resources
the townspeople were afraid of the Beast? Why would
they want to hurt him? What could the townspeople do
instead of use violence?
6. Bell is seen as "odd" and "strange" in her town. Why do
you think the villagers see Bell as different from them?
THE FROG PRINCE
When you meet someone who is different from you, how
do you make them feel comfortable and included? http://www.eastoftheweb.com/short-
7. In this film, "things aren't always what they seem to be". stories/UBooks/FrogPrin.shtml
Students write an exposition to argue the importance Scootle resources
looking beyond face value. Film study: school playground TFL-ID
8. Write an exposition on how Fairytales teach important L9933
values to children.
http://www.scootle.edu.au/ec/resolve/vie
w/L9933
48
Content Teaching, learning and assessment Resources
http://www.scootle.edu.au/ec/resolve/vie
w/L8471
Lights, camera, action: lighting TFL-ID
L2846
http://www.scootle.edu.au/ec/resolve/vie
w/L2846
Evaluation
49
Content Teaching, learning and assessment Resources
50
Appendix B original scope and sequence
51
200
CONTENT OUTCOMES
TERM 1 EN4-1A
DRAMA EN4-3B
NOTE: drama has been taking out of the reconstructed scope EN4-5C
and sequence because it is covered in year 8 and you only need EN4-7D
to cover drama once in stage 4
Focus Text: Scrambled Eggs by Sue Murray (Weeks 1-5)
Text Types:
- Play script
- Print texts - Digital texts
Heroes- Speeches (Weeks 6-11)
Text Types: EN4-2A
EN4-3B
- Print texts
EN4-5C
- Digital texts EN4-7D
- Media
- Visual texts - Multi-media
TERM 2
EN4-1A
(weeks 1-6) EN4-4B
FILM Studies and Fairy Tales EN4-5C
Text focus Beauty and the Beast or Maleficent EN4-7D
TERM 3
POETRY: Heal The World- Social and Environmental Stability in Poetry
EN4-5C
(Weeks 1-4) EN4-3B
Focus Text/s: It was Long Ago, Icarus Allsorts, Equal EN4-6C
Opportunity, Enjoy the Earth Gently, There’s a Dragon, We Must EN4-7D
Protect the Countryside, Our Tree, Death of a Tree, Rainforest, EN4-8D
My Moccasins have not Walked, Freedom and anti-war lyrics and
speeches.
Mode: Weighting:
Film Study: Fairy Tales
Reading and Writing 30%
Notification Date:
Assessment Date: Time:
7th May 2019 th
20 Monday, 2019 (Week 4) 1 hour 30 minutes
Tuesday
Appendix C Original
Assessment Notification
Stage 4 Year 7
English
53
Assessment Notification – 2019
› EN4-4B makes effective language choices to creatively shape meaning with accuracy, clarity and
coherence
› EN4-5C thinks imaginatively, creatively, interpretively and critically about information, ideas and
arguments to respond to and compose texts
› EN4-3B uses and describes language forms, features and structures of texts appropriate to a range of
purposes, audiences and contexts
› EN4-2A effectively uses a widening range of processes, skills, strategies and knowledge for
responding to and composing texts in different media and technologies
TASK DESCRIPTION
Your half-yearly exam will be 1 hour and 30 minutes in the school hall. You will be given 5
minutes reading time, and 1 hour and 25 minutes working time.
You will be assessed on your ability to apply your knowledge in persuasive techniques, film
techniques, fairy tales and your persuasive writing skills.
Important Notes:
TASK RUBRIC
You will be assessed on how well you:
54
Identify and analyse persuasive techniques
Identify and analyse film techniques
Understand and explain concepts regarding the fairy tale genre
Engage with the conventions and expectations of persuasive writing
55