Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
Abstract—Transceiver hardware impairments (e.g., phase of these impairments can be mitigated by calibration methods
noise, in-phase/quadrature-phase (I/Q) imbalance, amplifier non- and compensation schemes at both sides, there still remains
arXiv:1507.04244v3 [cs.IT] 27 Nov 2015
linearities, and quantization errors) have obvious degradation residual hardware impairments due to estimation errors, inac-
effects on the performance of wireless communications. While
prior works have improved our knowledge on the influence of curate calibration methods and different types of noise.
hardware impairments of single-user multiple-input multiple- Recently, the large-scale (LS)-MIMO communication has
output (MIMO) systems over Rayleigh fading channels, an drawn a substantial interest from both academia and industry
analysis encompassing the Rician fading channel is not yet as a promising technology for 5G wireless systems, such
available. In this paper, we pursue a detailed analysis of regular as millimeter wave (mmWave) communications. LS-MIMO
and large-scale (LS) MIMO systems over Rician fading channels
by deriving new, closed-form expressions for the achievable rate systems are likely to operate in the mmWave band to ac-
to provide several important insights for practical system design. commodate many antennas within a small physical area. In
More specifically, for regular MIMO systems with hardware LS-MIMO systems, each base station is equipped with a
impairments, there is always a finite achievable rate ceiling, which large number of antennas to improve the spectral and energy
is irrespective of the transmit power and fading conditions. For efficiency. Understanding the fundamental theoretical limits
LS-MIMO systems, it is interesting to find that the achievable
rate loss depends on the Rician K-factor, which reveals that of the LS-MIMO system has been an active research area.
the favorable propagation in LS-MIMO systems can remove For practical implementation, it is very attractive to deploy
the influence of hardware impairments. However, we show that LS antenna elements with cheap, compact and power-efficient
the non-ideal LS-MIMO system can still achieve high spectral radio and digital-processing hardware. Thus, it is of profound
efficiency due to its huge degrees of freedom. importance to theoretically investigate how much hardware
Index Terms—Achievable rate, hardware impairments, large- impairments can the LS-MIMO system tolerate to achieve a
scale MIMO, Rician fading channels. certain achievable rate performance.
Motivated by these observations, some researchers have
I. I NTRODUCTION analyzed the impact of transceiver hardware impairments on
MIMO system performance. Specifically, experimental results
By employing multiple antennas at the transceiver, wireless to model the statistical behavior of residual hardware im-
systems can significantly increase the spectral efficiency and pairments on regular1 MIMO systems have been provided in
transmission reliability. The capacity of single-user MIMO pioneering works such as [4], [5]. Utilizing this impairment
systems has been well investigated in the literature [1], [2]. model, the authors of [6] and [7] analyzed the achievable rate
However, most prior works assume that ideal hardware is of regular MIMO systems in detail. With the rapid devel-
available at both the transmitter and receiver, which is unre- opment of LS-MIMO systems, people shift their interests to
alistic in practice, while the performance of practical MIMO hardware impairments of LS-MIMO systems. In this context,
systems is usually affected by transceiver hardware impair- the single type of impairments have been considered in [8]–
ments, such as phase noise, I/Q imbalance, amplifier non- [11] in terms of power amplifier nonlinearities, mismatched
linearities, and quantization errors [3]. Although the influence joint decoding, and phase noise. Moreover, [3], [7], [12]
examined in detail the achievable rate of LS-MIMO systems
Copyright © 2015 IEEE. Personal use of this material is permitted.
However, permission to use this material for any other purposes must be by taking into account the effects of transceiver hardware
obtained from the IEEE by sending a request to pubs-permissions@ieee.org. impairments.
This work was supported in part by the International Science & Technology The common characteristic of aforementioned works, how-
Cooperation Program of China (Grant No. 2015DFG12760), the National
Natural Science Foundation of China (Grant Nos. 61571270 and 61201185), ever, is that they consider Rayleigh fading channels. Although
and China Postdoctoral Science Foundation (No. 2014M560081). The work the assumption of Rayleigh fading extensively simplifies the
of X. Zhang was supported in part by the Swedish Governmental Agency performance analysis, its validity is often violated in practical
for Innovation Systems (VINNOVA) within the VINN Excellence Center
Chase, and the Swedish Foundation for Strategic Research. E. Björnson was wireless propagation scenarios with the line-of-sight (LoS)
supported by ELLIIT and the CENIIT project 15.01. path, where the Rician fading model is more general and
J. Zhang, L. Dai and Z. Wang are with Department of Electronic Engi- accurate [13]. To the best of our knowledge, a detailed
neering as well as Tsinghua National Laboratory of Information Science and
Technology (TNList), Tsinghua University, Beijing 100084, P. R. China (e- analysis of MIMO systems over Rician fading channels in
mails: {jiayizhang, daill, zcwang}@tsinghua.edu.cn). the presence of transceiver hardware impairments is missing
X. Zhang is with Department of Signals and Systems, Chalmers University
of Technology, Gothenburg, Sweden (e-mail: xinlin@chalmers.se). 1 In contrast to the LS-MIMO system, we use the terminology regular
E. Björnson is with Department of Electrical Engineering (ISY), Linköping MIMO for systems with small number of antennas at the transmitter and
University, Linköping, Sweden (e-mail: emil.bjornson@liu.se). receiver, e.g., smaller than 8 antennas.
2
in the literature. Only recently, the high-SNR capacity limit of variance, and K is the Rician factor denoting the power ratio
regular MIMO systems over Rician fading channels has been between H̄ and Hω . In this paper, we normalize the channel
established in [6]. In this paper, we aim to fill in this gap matrix H as E[tr(HHH )] = Nr Nt , where tr(·) denotes the
by investigating the impact of hardware impairments on the trace of a matrix.
achievable rate of regular and LS-MIMO systems over Rician In practical MIMO systems, the received signals will be
fading channels. Specifically, the contributions of this paper unavoidably distorted by impairments of transceiver hardware
are summarized as: components, such as filters, oscillators, converters, mixers and
• We derive a new analytical achievable rate expression amplifiers, in two different ways. First, the actually emitted
for regular MIMO systems subject to Rician fading and signals are different from the desired signals at the transmitter
hardware impairments. Although the expression is given due to transmitter hardware impairments [15]. Second, the
in infinite series, the truncation error has been obtained to received signals may suffer from distortion after the signal
demonstrate its fast convergence. Additionally, we present processing due to receiver hardware impairments. Although
asymptotic achievable rate expressions in the high-SNR several signal compensation algorithms have been proposed
regime, which coincide with the results of [6]. Moreover, and utilized at each antenna, there still remains some residual
based on our analysis, there is always a ceiling on the transceiver hardware impairments due to inaccurate model-
achievable rates of regular MIMO systems. ing, imperfect CSI, errors in the estimation of impairments’
• For LS-MIMO systems, asymptotic expressions for the parameters, and so forth [7]2 . Therefore, it is important to
achievable rate are presented for three typical types of analyze the impact of transceiver hardware impairments on the
antenna arrays. Assuming perfect channel state informa- performance of MIMO systems to provide useful guidance for
tion (CSI) at the receiver and no CSI at the transmitter, practical systems design.
it is interesting to find that the achievable rate ceiling
The aggregate transceiver hardware impairments can be
disappears by deploying a huge number of antennas
approximated by independent additive distortion noises at both
at the transceiver. Moreover, our results show that the
transmitter and receiver, which has been used and verified
achievable rate gap between hardware impairments and
by experiments in many previous works [3], [7], [12]. Based
perfect hardware increases with the value of the Rician
on the system model (1), the actually received signal can be
K-factor.
denoted as [12]
The remainder of the paper is organized as follows: In Sec-
tion II, the single-user MIMO channel model used throughout y = H(x + ηt ) + ηr + n, (3)
the paper is briefly introduced. Section III provides a detailed
where the additive distortion noise terms ηt and ηr are ergodic
achievable rate analysis of MIMO systems with transceiver
stochastic processes that describe the hardware impairments
hardware impairments over Rician fading channels. A set of
at the transmitter and the receiver, respectively. This model
numerical results is given in Section IV. Finally, Section V
is both analytically tractable, and matches experimental re-
concludes the paper.
sults accurately. The experimental results have uncovered key
characteristics that ηt and ηr follow Gaussian distribution
II. S YSTEM AND C HANNEL M ODEL with variance proportional to the average signal power [4],
We consider a single-user MIMO system with Nt transmit [5]. Moreover, ηt and ηr can be analytically approximated by
antennas and Nr receive antennas, and assume that perfect the central limit theorem as ηt ∼ CN (0, δt2 diag(q1 , · · · , qNt ))
CSI is available at the receiver, while no CSI can be obtained and ηr ∼ CN (0, δr2 tr(Q)INr ) [12], where q1 , q2 , · · · , qNt
at the transmitter. The system model can be written as are the diagonal elements of the signal covariance matrix
Q. Note that the new system model (3) is more general
y = Hx + n, (1) than the canonical model (1), and captures dominant practical
Nr ×1 characteristics of transceiver hardware impairments. The pro-
where y ∈ C denotes the received signal vector, x ∈
CNt ×1 is the transmitted signal vector with zero mean and portionality parameters δt and δr are related to the error vector
covariance matrix E xxH = Q with E[·] being the ex- magnitude (EVM) metric, which is widely used to quantify the
pectation operator and (·)H being the Hermitian operation, mismatch between the expected signal and the actual signal
and n ∈ CNr ×1 denotes the vector of zero-mean complex in RF transceivers [16]. In practical wireless systems, such
circularly symmetric additive white Gaussian noise (AWGN). as long term evolution (LTE), the EVM requirements are in
Moreover, H ∈ CNr ×Nt represents the Rician channel matrix the range δt ∈ [0.08, 0.175] [16]. Note that larger values
modeling fast fading with a deterministic LoS path, which can of δt and δr indicate that the MIMO system experiences
be modelled as [14] higher levels of impairments caused by inaccurate transceiver
r r hardware components. Moreover, the case of δt = δr = 0
K 1 corresponds to ideal transceiver hardware components.
H= H̄ + Hω , (2)
K +1 K +1
where H̄ denotes the deterministic component, Hω denotes
the random fast fading component, which is composed of inde- 2 Among these residual transceiver hardware impairments, the phase noise
pendent and identically distributed (i.i.d.) circularly symmetric is probably the most severe factor in single-carrier transmission, while it is
complex Gaussian random variables with zero-mean and unit still not clear in multi-carrier systems [3], [9], [10].
3
III. ACHIEVABLE R ATE where 1 F1 (·) is the confluent hypergeometric function [18,
In this section, we present a detailed achievable rate analysis Eq. (9.21)].
of MIMO systems with transceiver hardware impairments over Proof: The marginal probability density function (PDF)
Rician fading channels. Recall that neither instantaneous nor of an unordered squared singular value of W is given by [19]
statistical CSI is available at the transmitter but perfectly q q
known at the receiver, we use equal power allocation on each Ge−λ(K+1) X X p−q+m
f (λ) = Dn,m ((K + 1) λ)
transmit antenna as Q = NPt INt with the total transmit power qλ n=1 m=1
P . Moreover, the average SNR per receive antenna is defined
× 0 F1 (p − q + 1; (K + 1) φn λ) , (10)
as ρ = E[tr(Q)]/N0 , where N0 denotes the noise variance,
which is normalized as N0 = 1 in the following analysis. The where 0 F1 (·) denotes the hypergeometric functions [18, Eq.
∞
new system model (3) considering hardware impairments can P ym
(9.14)] and can be expressed as 0 F1 (x, y) = m!(x) [20].
be written in the form of the canonical model (1) with noise m=0 m
TABLE I ′
R EQUIRED TERMS OF SERIES T0 TO ACHIEVE A SATISFACTORY the infinite series, the truncation error R0 is upper bounded as
ACCURACY (≤ 10−6 ) ′
′ T
′
Γ p − q + m + T0 + 1 φn0
R0 ≤
ρ Nt Nr δt δr K T0 ′
Γ T0 + 1 (p − q + 1)T ′
0
0 2 2 0.15 0.15 1 11 ′ ′
× 2 F2 p−q+m+T0 +1, 1; T0 +1, p−q+T0 +1; φn
′
0 2 2 0.15 0.15 5 15
10 2 2 0.15 0.15 1 10 (K+1)/a
′ K +1 (K+1)/b
′ K +1
× e E1 −e E1 . (16)
0 4 4 0.15 0.15 1 12 a′ b′
0 2 2 0.1 0.1 1 12
C. Asymptotic LS-MIMO Analysis
In the following, we consider the achievable rate of three
asymptotic antenna deployment in LS-MIMO systems. Note
of reasoning as in Lemma 1. Then, the asymptotic achievable that our analysis holds for any LoS model that satisfy the limit
a.s.
rate approaches the finite limit of p1 HHH −−→ Iq . If a uniform linear array (ULA) is adopted
q q ∞ at the transmitter, the (m, n)th entry H̄mn is given by
G XX X Γ (p − q + m + k) φkn
R∞ = Dn,m H̄mn = e−j(m−1)(2πd/λ) sin θn , (17)
ln 2 n=1 m=1 Γ (k + 1) (p − q + 1)k
k=0
p−q+m+k where d is the transmit antenna spacing, λ is the wavelength,
X
(K+1)/a
′ K +1
× e Ep−q+m+k−t+1 and θn is the arrival angle of the nth receive antenna. More-
t=1
a′ over, we set d = λ/2, which means that there is no correlation
! between receive antennas.
(K+1)/b
′ K +1
−e Ep−q+m+k−t+1 , (15) First, the number of transmit antennas Nt tends to in-
b′
finity while the number of receiver antennas Nr is fixed.
′ (1+δt2 ) ′ δ2 According to the law of large numbers, the correlation matrix
where a , and b , Nttδ2 , respectively.
Nt δr2 1 H a.s.
Nt HH − INr −−→ 0 [14, Lemma 2] as Nt → ∞, where
r
′ ′
The term e (K+1)/a
E1 a′ −e(K+1)/b E1 K+1
K+1
′ in a.s. denotes almost sure convergence. To take the limit inside
b
(15) becomes zero when k is large [18]. Therefore, the the expectation in (5) by the dominated convergence theorem
[21], the achievable rate reduces to
achievable rate of MIMO systems over Rician fading channels
with residual hardware impairments approaches a finite ceiling ρ
RNt →∞ = Nr log2 1 + 2 , (18)
in the high-SNR regime, which is also found in the case ρδt + ρδr2 + 1
of Rayleigh fading channels in [7] and the case of any which indicates that the achievable rate of LS-MIMO systems
fading channels with only transmitter impairments in [6]. This with infinite Nt depends on the transceiver distortions, trans-
effect can be explained as that the transceiver distortion will mit SNR and the number of receiver antennas Nr . Moreover,
increase with the transmit power. Accordingly, the equivalent as we increase Nr , the achievable rate grows linearly. How-
SNR, Nρt HHH Φ−1 , in (5) will not increase. However, the ever, if Nr is fixed but SNR is increased, the achievable rate
achievable rate R will increase to infinity with SNR if adopting asymptotically approaches the limit as we discuss in Section
the ideal hardware. Moreover, (15) reveals that the residual III-B. This fact suggests that the achievable rate will saturate
hardware impairments dominate on the achievable rate perfor- in the high-SNR regime for Rician fading channels.
mance of MIMO systems in the high-SNR regime. Then, we consider the second case, where the receiver
′
Moreover, assuming that the first T0 − 1 terms are used in employs large number of receiver antennas Nr but the number
∞ p−q+m+k
Γ (p − q + m + k) φkn X
X
(K+1)/a K +1 (K+1)/b K +1
R0 = e Ep−q+m+k−t+1 −e Ep−q+m+k−t+1
Γ (k + 1) (p − q + 1)k t=1
a b
k=T0
∞
X Γ (p − q + m + k + 1) φk
n K +1 K +1
< e(K+1)/a E1 − e(K+1)/b E1
Γ (k + 1) (p − q + 1)k a b
k=T0
∞
Γ (p−q+m+T0 +1) φTn0 X (p−q+m+T0 +1)s (1)s φsn
s=k−T0 (K+1)/a K +1 (K+1)/b K +1
======= e E1 −e E1
Γ (T0 +1) Γ (p−q+T0 +1) s=0 (T0 +1)s (p−q+T0 +1)s s! a b
Γ (p − q + m + T0 + 1) φTn0
= 2 F2 (p − q + m + T0 + 1, 1; T0 + 1, p − q + T0 + 1; φn )
Γ (T0 + 1) (p − q + 1)T0
K+1 K +1
× e(K+1)/a E1 − e(K+1)/b E1 , (14)
a b
5
0.26
ceiling vanishes by increasing both the number of transmit and
0.24 receive antennas in LS-MIMO systems. Finally, we conclude
that the achievable rate loss due to hardware impairments
0.22
increases with the value of the Rician K-factor.
0.2
0.18 R EFERENCES