Вы находитесь на странице: 1из 6

ave It Your Way" (Burger King), "You're the

Marketing Occupational
Therapy
H Boss" (United Airlines), and "To Do All in
Our Power to Pack the Customer's Dollar
Full of Value, Quality and Satisfaction" (J. C. Penney)
are but three examples of slogans or catch phrases
that reflect the successful implementation of the con-
Karen Jacobs cept of marketing. Carefully orchestrated marketing
programs sell today's food, clothes, movies, colleges,
hospitals, and health care services.
Key Words: consumers. marketing of Although it was once thought to be inappropriate
health services or unprofessional to use marketing in health care, it
now appears to be the key to survival in the reality of
shrinking health care funds. Marketing can do the
following ("Marketing OT SerVices," 1984).
Marketing is emerging as an important aspect of the 1 Help you identify unserved needs
delivery of health care services, including occupa- 2. Help you determine which needs you can serve profitably
tional therapy_ An understanding of marketing and 3. Help you identify programs and services with declining
a knowledge of how to apply its princzples will per- profitability
mit therapists to keep pace with the changing health 4. Help you maximize tile advantages of new trends and
technologies
care environment. This article introduces 5 Serve as a key step in program development and expansion
terminology, strategies, and applications of (p. 4)
marketing.
Much can be learned from the marketing of commer-
cial products for application to the field of health
care Loubeau (984) describes six ways in which
health care services are identical to commercial prod-
ucts.
Health care services: (a) are developed to fill a market need
or want: the market could be consumers, physicians. or even
other hospitals; (b) reqUire a capital (research and develop-
ment) investment. an operating (production) budget, and a
communications (public affairs) effort; (c) have specific func·
tions, features. and benefits that are (or should be) packaged
for maximum acceptance; (d) are sold to selected market
segments; (e) determine revenue (sales volume) througll
direCt billings, reimbursements, and grants; or services are
carried as a loss to stimulate good will, image, or sale of Other
services; and (f) are imitative (the same as others), adaptive
(modified with improvements), or innovative (a trend·setter)
(p.40)

Marketing-What Is It?
Simply stated, "marketing consists of meeting peo-
ple's needs in the most efficient and therefore prof-
itable manner" ("Marketing OT SerVices," 1984, p. 4).
It is a management discipline that systematically
makes the customer the touchstone for information
gathering, strategic decision making, service design,
and profitability As Drucker (973) remarks, "Mar-
keting is what makes selling unnecessary. The aim
is to know and understand the custOmer so well that
the product or service fits him/her and sells" (p. 64)
Marketing is an orientation which makes satisfying
the customer's needs the integrating organization
principle. It enables one to stay in touch with the
Karen Jacobs, MS, OTR/L, is DireclOr of Development,
needs, wants, and preferences of constituencies In-
Learning Prep School, 1507 WashinglOn Street, West New-
stead of designing services and then looking for cus-
ton, Massachusetts 02165. She is also an adjunct clinical
instructor at BoslOn University and the president of the tomers, marketing reverses the process. One first
Massachusetts Association for Occupational Therapy. looks at the market and listens carefully to potential
customers and then designs services or products to

The Americanjoumal a/Occupational Therapy 315


Downloaded from http://ajot.aota.org on 07/21/2020 Terms of use: http://AOTA.org/terms
match the needs and desires of these potential ministrators) or an external focus (e.g., developing
customers (Kotler, 1983a). new referral sources, educating the public, recruiting
The market is defined as all actual or potential students into the profession or therapists into the
buyers of a product, service, or idea and can be professional organizations). Each of these desired
considered in its entirety or divided into relevant outcomes determines which approach is to be used.
segments by variables such as age and location or by
specialized interest with reference to a focal point, Analysis of Other Providers of Similar Services
for example, legislators. In other words, to define a To have an effective marketing plan, an analysis of
market, one places individuals with similar character- other providers of similar services is needed. A com-
istics into a group so that the members of the group petitive analysis will provide an understanding of how
receive specific information or incentives designed adequately the needs of the marketplace are being
to appeal to their common characteristic. In occupa- satisfied, what areas are not being served, where
tional therapy, each group affects occupational ther- duplication and overlap are occurring, and where
apy practice in a unique way. Thus specific marketing opportunities for collaboration or joint venture exist.
strategies need to be employed for each. Information on what competitors are planning can be
Successful marketing management begins with gained by contacting them or reading their publica-
an idea that serves as the framework for all marketing tions (e.g., newsletters, annual repons). Getting on
efforts ("Conducting Preliminary Market Research," their mailing lists is very helpful.
1984). For example, the idea might be to establish a
work program for learning-disabled adolescents, to Environmental Assessment
hire a marketing agency to perform a marketing anal- An environmental assessment describes changes and
ysis for a state occupational therapy association, to trends that may have an impact on one's future. These
recruit more students, or to bring part-time occupa- changes may be occurring in the community, the
tional therapists back in by promoting job sharing. government, the economy, the labor market, con-
Once the idea is selected, the process consists of (a) sumer needs, the service area, services offered, and
analyzing market opportunities; (b) selecting appro- reimbursement sources and practices. An environ-
priate target markets; (c) developing an effective mar- mental assessment includes the review of the follow-
keting mix; and (d) managing the market effort ing areas:
effectively. 1. Demographics. Demographic information in-
cludes changes in and a current breakdown of the
Analyzing Market Opportunities population of service area by age, sex, race, national
In assessing the demand of a market, all actual and origin, employment, education, income, and religion.
potential buyers of the product (in our case, occupa- For example, a demographic factor that may affect
tional therapy services) are identified. The analysis occupational therapy services is that the median age
includes of the U.S population is increasing.
1. A self-audit 2. Political and regulatory ::,ystems. "The politi-
2. Consumer analysis cal environment shows substantial business regula-
3. An analysis of other proViders of similar ser- tion, strong government agency enforcement and the
vices growth of public interest groups" (Kotler, 1983a, p.
4. An environmental assessment 115) .
3. The cultural environment. "Culture is the
Self-Audit most fundamental determinant of a person's wants
Performing a self-audit, that is, reflecting on our and behaviors" (Kotler, 1983a, p. 122). The core
strengths, weaknesses, opportunities, and threats beliefs, values, and norms of a culture/subculture are
helps us to understand how well or poorly prepared highly persistent (e.g., most Americans believe in
we are to meet marketplace demands. work) whereas the secondary beliefs and values are
more open to change and undergo shifts through time
Consumer Analysis (e.g., in the area of health, increasing numbers of
An analysis of consumers, that is, of those who use people value physical fitness and preventive med-
our products, would include diverse audiences such icine) (Kotler, 1983a).
as current clients, potential clients, referral sources, 4. Financial/economic environment. Reim-
health team members, administrators, insurance bursement variables and changes (e.g., the purchase
proViders, and legislatOrs. of health care, copayments), developments in the
Depending upon which consumer group is being capital markets or local economy are likely to
analyzed, marketing can have an internal focus (e.g., influence the service delivery in a community.
educating and convincing physicians, nurses, or ad- 5. Geographies. Geographics provide commu-

316http://ajot.aota.org on 07/21/2020 Terms of use: http://AOTA.org/terms


Downloaded from May 1987, Volume 41, Number 5
nity characteristics. For example, geographical :ohifts successfully market its many varied treatment areas
in population will affect the demand for occupational all with the same methods" (p. 16). Therefore, it is
therapy in specific locations. It is predicted that over important to decide what specific product will be
the next decade the West and South will experience marketed. Ideally, the goal is to offer not just one
population growths of 17% and 14%, respectively. product but a product line, that is, a variety of products
Presently, these sunbelt states have 51 % of the US. associated with one another by an overall theme
population (Kotler, 1983a). (Olson & Urban, 1985; Como & Hagner, 1986) For
6. Psychographies. This category provides infor- example, the department of occupational therapy at
mation about the consumer's social class, life-style, Henry Ford Hospital in DetrOit, Michigan, has a "Re-
and personality characteristics. For example, social turn-to-Work Center." The overall theme is that "the
class has a strong influence on a person's preference Center assists in the recovery of the injured patient
in leisure activities. by helping bridge the gap between the health care
7. Technological developments. This category provider and business, the hospital and workplace,
would include new treatment modalities, for exam- and the person as a patient and as an employee"
ple, innovational opportunities such as robotics and ("Return-to-Work Center," 1986, p. 2). The product
biotechnology (Kautzmann, 1985) line of this center includes a work capacity evaluation,
From an overall marketing analysis, a written a work hardening program, physical tolerance
marketing plan is developed, which includes a mis- screening, and a job-site evaluation.
sion statement, as well as goals and objectives. The Price is the exchange value, usually monetary, of
objectives are presented in terms of the eight most the product. Pricing is based on cost, competitive
important priorities. Ideally, the directors of the facil- factors, and what the consumer is Willing to pay
ity or senior management staff members develop the (Clopton, 1986) It is important for the price to be
priorities. Each plan must be specific for each target commensurate with perceived value.
market and include information on budgeting, The manner in which the product is made acces-
staffing, and the time frame. sible to the target consumer is the place component
of the marketing mix. The goal is to get the product
Selecting Appropriate Target Markets into the consumer's hands in the most efficient
Target marketing is the process of identifying the manner possible.
most favorable or advantageous segments of a specific Promotion is the communication of information
market and directing efforts to meet the needs of to the audience: The target market is told about the
these segments. For example, the American Occupa product's merits, place, and price. Arguments are
tional Therapy Association (AOTA) became aware of presented to persuade the consumer to purchase the
the need to develop a marketing approach in occu- product. The instruments of marketing communica-
pational therapy when AOTA restructured the certifi- tions or promotion are advertiSing, sales promotion,
cation program and separated it from the membership publicity, and personal selling. The first three are
program. To develop target markets, AOTA could mass marketing tools.
cluster people with similar needs into specific groups.
The Instruments Described
Developing an Effective Marketing Mix Advertising Advertising involves a paid message
presented in a recognized medium, by an identified
The Four P's sponsor. with the purpose to inform, persuade, and
The marketing mix strategy includes the development remind. Advertising employs the use of the follOWing
of objectives for each identified target market and vehicles to relay its message:
their implementation. Commonly known as the four Print ads are found in newspapers, journals, and
P's-product, price, place, and promotion-this strat- magazines. Brochures and direct mail are additional
egy should cover everything that can be done to vehicles. Broadcasts are advertisements carried by
influence the demand for the product (Clopton, 1986; radio stations and television networks. Transits are
Olson & Urban, 1985) the posters or car cards found on mass transit vehicles.
Our prOducts are what we do as occupational Billboards are the large attention getters seen from
therapists and need to be defined at a level that the highways. Point-o/Purchase refers to the counter
consumers will understand. Simply stated, occupa- and aisle displays found in most stores. Point-of-
tional therapy assists individuals to become as inde- purchase is commonly used to promote "impulse"
pendent as possible. However, Clopton (1986) notes buying (Geibel, 1986). A 5-ft-high cardboard poster
that "just as Hershey Chocolate company does not depicting occupational therapy next to a rack of oc-
promote Hershey Kisses, Kit Kat, and Chocolate Syrup cupational therapy license plate covers in a hospital
all in a single campaign, Occupational Therapy cannot gift shop would be an example of this kind of adver-

Tbe Americanjournal a/occupational Therapy 317


Downloaded from http://ajot.aota.org on 07/21/2020 Terms of use: http://AOTA.org/terms
tising. Advertising messages can be presented in dif- to focus publicity on specific target markets. One key
ferent styles, such as testimonial, technical or scien- to success in this area is a well-conceived and -exe-
tific evidence, fantasy, fact-of-life (Kotler, 1983a). The cuted media relations program. To obtain media ex-
follOWing examples use a character to personify the posure, become acquainted with the media and once
product (Kotler, 1983a). a rapport is established, be accessible, responsive,
The use of Americana (patriotic symbols) to sell and easy to work With.
products has become widespread since the 1984 To develop awareness among the media, become
Olympics and has been used creatively in health care. familiar with editors, staff writers, and free-lance writ-
For example, New England Memorial Hospital in ers. Comparable people in broadcasting would be
Stoneham, Massachusetts, in trying to broaden its program producers and assignment editors. Before
profile and promote its Center for Plastic Surgery, contacting these people prepare a media (press) kit
used a public domain subject, the Statue of Liberty. and news (press) releases. The media kit is a set of
The advertisement, which was used both as a print ad documents that provide background on the product
and broadcast, shows the head of the Statue of Liberty and proVide other useful items (e.g., photograph with
surrounded by scaffolding with the line "Even the caption). Public Service Announcements (PSAs), brief
most beautiful woman in America can look better" messages of 20 to 60 seconds, are used for broadcasts.
("Facelift," 1986) (Schaeffer & Lefkowitz, 1980). They are the equiva-
Linking a product with a well-known licensed lent of advertising for low-budget organizations.
character is another possible advertiSing strategy These announcements are provided free, but there
(Oberlink, 1986) are content restrictions and specific submission re-
There is speculation that technological advances quirements, and the announcements are regulated
will lead advertising from an era of mass media to an under federal law. However, one must have a reason
era of individualized mass media. For example, print- to contact the media, such as prOViding a story idea,
ing technology will enable magazines to carry ads follow·up, or commentary. And contacts should be
that are personaUy directed to their readers (Jackson, limited to once every 3 months to avoid overuse.
1986) Imagine opening Occupational Therapy News Participation in special events such as a shopping
and coming across an ad that addresses you by name mall show on prevention, wellness, and educational
and mentions a subject you are interested in. activities, which are open to the public and in the
Sales promotion. Sales promotion is the use of a public interest, is another form of publicity. Addi-
wide variety of short-term incentives to encourage the tional examples of publicity are as follows: participat-
pu rchase of the product. This approach is most effec- ing in radio and television talk shows or cable tele-
tive when used in conjunction with advertising. Typ- vision programs (which can offer you more control
ical consumer promotion incentives may include cou- in the designing of your message but reach a more
pons (newspaper coupons for free blood pressure limited audience); inclusion in community calendar
and diabetes screening), discounts, samples, premi- listings of events; and writing a letter to the editOr
ums (trading stamps), price packs (cents-off deals on (the most highly read part of a newspaper) (Springer,
the regular price of an item), and contests. However, 1985)
recent strategies have gone beyond the use of incen- Personal selling Personal selling, face-to-face
tives to build a relationship with the customer. For communication between you and your audience, is
example, American Express, to aid in the restoration the most expensive yet also the most effective form
of the Statue of Liberty, made a donation to the of promotion. It is also the method used by most
restOration each time an American Express card was occupational therapists. Kautzmann (1985) provides
used by a customer. This "cause-related" promotion the follOWing examples of personal selling:
not only helped make money, but also made people
1. Serving as a paid or unpaid lecturer or 'guest expert' in
feel good about the sponsor (American Express). It
health care education.
might be of interest in this context that the company 2. Participating in health fairs or Mall shows.
has expanded its audience to include the health care 3. Serving on boards or commiuees of public health agencies.
4. Conducting health screenings.
industry. In 1986, 16,000 doctors and hospitals 5 Participating in cominuing educarion and inservice pre·
accepted the card for payment (Foltz, 1986) sentations with other health professionals. (p. 98)
Publicity. Publicity is another means of getting
public attention "Publicity is often described as a The possibilities in this area are Virtually unlimited.
marketing stepchild because it is relatively underused Two other important ones would be holding an open
in relation to the real contribution it can make" (Kot- house and meeting with a physician to ask for a
ler, 1983b, p. 112). The basic positive aspect of pub- referral on a patient.
licity is that it is free. However, one has little control If we consider the fact that most individuals who
over the placement of it and thus it becomes difficult choose the field of occupational therapy do so be-

318http://ajot.aota.org on 07/21/2020 Terms of use: http://AOTA.org/terms


Downloaded from May 1987, Volume 41, Number 5
cause of their personal contact with a therapist (J on three levels (a) They would help individual mem-
MacDonald, Executive Board, Massachusetts Associa- bers market their own services and achieve better
tion for Occupational Therapy, personal communi- professional self-definition; (b) they would define
cation, January 15, 1986), it becomes clear that per- MAOT as a professional organization that provides
sonal selling is crucial to solving the manpower concrete services and benefits; and (c) they would
shortage in occupational therapy. clarify and promote the occupational therapy profes-
sion under the name of MAOT, solidifying the orga-
Using the Instruments nization's position as the voice of occupational therapy
(McIntyre Group, 1984)
A Hypothetical Case
In conjunction with this analysis, the marketing
For clarification, the four major marketing tools are agency made several recommendations which MAOT
used to set up an occupational therapy student schol- implemented over the last two years:
arship fund by a state occupational therapy associa-
tion, for example the Massachusetts Association for 1. Recommendation: Develop a slogan or catch
Occupational Therapy (MAOT). MAOT could phrase to convey the essence of occupational therapy.
proceed as follows: Action: MAOT adopted the national slogan, "Occu-
Advertising. Perhaps the association would have pational Therapy: A Vital Link to Productive Living."
a raffle to raise some funds for this scholarship. They 2 Recommendation: Develop an occupational
could advertise the raffle in the local newspaper, therapy logo with a new MAOT typeface for a unified
radio, state association newspaper, Occupational heading to be used on stationery, brochures, fact
Therapy News, neighboring state association news- sheets, etc Action: MAOT solicited logo designs from
papers, and local university papers. its members and the general public These designs
Sales promotion. Incentives cou ld be planned in were placed on the MAOT Newsline for a member
conjunction with the advertised raffle. Perhaps those vote. A logo designed by a young graphiC arts student
supporting the scholarship fund would receive but- with special needs was selected.
tons, balloons, key rings, ribbons, and anything else 3 Recom mendation. Produce a series of printed
that would identify them as a supporter. materials with a consistent message tailored to the
Publicity. A scholarship fund could receive a needs of specific audiences. Action MAOT worked
great deal of media coverage, particularly from the with students at Boston University's ADLAB to de-
human interest standpoint. An additional contact velop a brochure on occupational therapy and the
could be the public relations department of the local state association.
occupational therapy programs. 4 Recommendation: Systematically develop
Personal selling. Executive board members could press releases and feature items for distribution to
solicit the support of occupational therapy students at appropriate newspapers. Action: The Public Relations
the local universities through speaking engagements Committee of MAOT developed media packets and
at these universities. In turn, these students could cultivated relationships with the local media. The
become sales representatives, selling raffle tickets annual celebration of occupational therapy month,
and asking for donations directly from consumers with the governor's proclamation of this occasion,
became one of the major activities of the committee.
An Actual Case 5. Recommendation. Collect existing photos of
In 1984, MAOT hired a marketing agency to conduct occupational therapists in various settings for use in
a detailed analysis of its marketing needs It was found projects and promotions. Action: MAOT is collecting
that MAOT's marketing needs were twofold. the as photographs on occupational therapy actiVities. Typ-
sociation needed to market itself to current and pro- ically these photographs are shared by members
spective members and to playa major role in pro- through the MAOT Newsline.
moting the profession to its varied audiences 6. Recommendation. Develop a portable, edu-
(McIntyre Group, 1984). cational exhibit about occupational therapy Action
Recommendations for action fell into four cate- The North Shore Occupational Therapy Group, one
gories: image building, increasing membership, im- of MAOT's 11 special interest groups, initiated the
proving services and programs, and making the inter- development of a portable mall exhibit and has suc-
nal operations more efficient. It became apparent that cessfully promoted occupational therapy at local
most recommendations served multiple purposes. shopping centers. The "how to's" and posters from
The process of implementing marketing strate- this exhibit are available free of charge on a loan basis
gies can be illustrated by reviewing the recommen- to MAOT members (Hamer, ]985)
dations for image building. According to the market 7. Recommendation: Establish and publicize an
analysis, image-building activities would be effective MAOT speaker's bureau Action The development of

The American Journal oJOccupational Therapy .'119


Downloaded from http://ajot.aota.org on 07/21/2020 Terms of use: http://AOTA.org/terms
a computerized speaker's resource bureau became an Conducting preliminary market research. (1984,
additional project of the same North Shore MAOT September) Occupational Therapy Newspaper, p. 6.
Drucker, P F (1973). Management: Tasks, responsi-
special interest group.
bilities, practices. New York: Harper & Row.
Facelift for hospital from ads by K&W [Kelley &
Managing the Market Effort Effectively Wallwork] 0986, july 7) Adweek, p. 4.
Foltz, K. (1986, May 5) Marketer of the year: American
One's marketing effort needs to be reexamined reg-
Express. Adweek, p. 4. [Special reprint)
ularly. A marketer's success is dependent not only on Geibel, j. P. 0986, july). Getting your name in the
the use of the "right" marketing mix but also on timely news: How to plan a media strategy. Micro Economics, pp.
responses to new trends and developments in the 1,4-5.
marketing environment. Hamer, D. H 0985, january) Bringing occupational
therapy to the public. Occupational Therapy Newspaper, p.
20.
Conclusion jackson, C. (1986, july 14) 2000: An advertising
Odyssey. Adweek, p. 8.
Marketing is a relatively new concept in health care, Kautzmann, L. N (1985). Marketing occupational ther-
but it can provide the health professions with an apy services. Occupational Therapy in Health Care, 2(2),
important strategy for achieving recognition. This ar- 91-101
ticle described how to analyze market opportunities, Kotler, P. (1983a) PrinCiples 0/ marketing (2nd ed.).
select appropriate target markets, develop an effective Englewood ClitIs, Nj: Prentice-Hall.
Kotler, P 0983b) Principles 0/ marketing-Instruc-
marketing mix, and managing the market effort effec- tor's manual with cases. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-
tively. Examples of how to use these principles in Hall.
occupational therapy were provided. Loubeau, P R. (1984) Marketing as a health care
A well-planned marketing approach can aid our concept. Nursing Economics, 2, 37-41
profession in remaining "a vital link to productive Marketing occupational therapy services. 0984,
August). Occupational Therapy Newspaper, p. 4.
living." The MCIntyre Group. (1984). Marketing analysis &
recommendations/or action prepared/or the Massacbusetts
Acknowledgments Association /01' Occupational Tberapy. Bedford, MA:
Author
I thank the Massachusetts Association for Occupational Oberlink. P (1986, August 4) Kids buy the darndest
Therapy for sharing its marketing analysis and Matthew D. things. Adweek, pp. 20-21.
Gold for his assistance in editing this manuscript. Olson, T., & Urban C. (1985). Marketing. Inj Bair &
M. Gray (Eds.), Tbe occupational tberapy manager. Rock-
References ville, MD: The American Occupational Therapy Association.
Retum-to- Work Center. (1986). Detroit, MI: Henry
Clopton, D. (1986, May 14) Marketing occupational Ford Hospital, Department of Occupational Therapy.
therapy. Occupational Therapy Forum, pp. 15, 19. [Brochure)
Como, P., & Hagner. D. (1986) Community work Schaeffer, B. & LefkOWitz, R. (1980, October) How to
development: A marketing model. Menomonie, WI: use the media, part 3. Community, p. 10.
University of Wisconsin-Stout, Materials Development Cen- Springer, I: (1985). Public relations workshop.
ter Brookline, MA: Brookline Adult Education.

320
Downloaded from http://ajot.aota.org on 07/21/2020 Terms of use: http://AOTA.org/terms May 1987, Volume 41, Number 5

Вам также может понравиться