DETAILED TECHNICAL EVALUATION CRITERIA

PROVISION OF ENGINEERING AND EXECUTION FOR DH-1P-2P-3P WELL PLUGGING & ABANDONMENT, OFFSHORE VIETNAM

Criteria Bidder A
No. Evaluation Criteria Category Bidder Remarks
RED YELLOW GREEN RED YELLOW GREEN
Proposal
A. WELLS PLUGGING AND ABANDOMENT
A.1 BIDDER'S EXPERIENCE AND CAPABILITY
Experience and Capacity which are fully met with CLIENT GREEN
A.1.1 MAJOR
requirements as per SOW RED
GREEN
A.1.2 Local Agent/Office/Base in Vietnam. MINOR YELLOW
RED
METHODOLOGY, SOLUTION, PROGRAM &
A.2
SCHEDULE/PLAN
A.2.1 Methodology, solution & program

Propose detailed P&A program including procedures, key tasks,

contingent plans, equipment /tools and personnel which are met with GREEN
CLIENT requirements as per SOW after clarification process
MAJOR
Propose detailed P&A program including procedures, key tasks,
contingent plans, equipment /tools and personnel which are NOT met RED
with CLIENT requirements as per SOW after clarification process

A.2.2 Offshore Execution Schedule and Plan

Start date for the offshore P&A work not later than 15th October, 2018
GREEN
as per CLIENT required schedule in SOW

Start date for the offshore P&A work later (from 16th-30th October,
MINOR YELLOW
2018) than the CLIENT required schedule in SOW

Start date for the offshore P&A work later (from 1st November, 2018
RED
onwards) than the CLIENT required schedule in SOW
A.3 P&A UNIT REQUIREMENTS
P&A Unit Specifications which are fully met with CLIENT GREEN
MAJOR
requirements as per SOW RED
A.4 RELATED SERVICES TO P&A OPERATIONS

1 OF 3
 DETAILED TECHNICAL EVALUATION CRITERIA
PROVISION OF ENGINEERING AND EXECUTION FOR DH-1P-2P-3P WELL PLUGGING & ABANDONMENT, OFFSHORE VIETNAM

Criteria Bidder A
No. Evaluation Criteria Category Bidder Remarks
RED YELLOW GREEN RED YELLOW GREEN
Proposal

P&A Insurance and Wanranty which are fully met with CLIENT
GREEN
requirements as per SOW

A.4.1 P&A Insurance and Wanranty which are partially met (No P&A MINOR
insurance but have P&A warranty of 12 months) with CLIENT YELLOW
requirements as per SOW
P&A Insurance and Wanranty which are not met with any CLIENT
RED
requirements as per SOW
Key Personnel Requirements which are met with >=10 year experience
GREEN
for all required positions as per SOW
Key Personnel Requirements which are met with 7-9 year experience for
A.4.2 MINOR YELLOW
all required positions as per SOW
Key Personnel Requirements which are with less than <7 year
RED
experience for all required positions as per SOW
B. GENERAL HSE REQUIREMENT
GREEN
Refer to item I of HSE TECHNICAL EVALUATION CRITERIA
MINOR YELLOW
ATTACHMENT
RED

2 OF 3
 DETAILED TECHNICAL EVALUATION CRITERIA
PROVISION OF ENGINEERING AND EXECUTION FOR DH-1P-2P-3P WELL PLUGGING & ABANDONMENT, OFFSHORE VIETNAM

Criteria Bidder A
No. Evaluation Criteria Category Bidder Remarks
RED YELLOW GREEN RED YELLOW GREEN
Proposal
C. QUALITY ASSURANCE
Specify and provide the quality management plan/manual to meet the
GREEN
requirements
Specify and provide the quality management plan/manual to partially MINOR
YELLOW
meet the requirements
No submission or noncompliance with requirement RED
FINAL RESULT:
All "Major" items are avaluated as "GREEN", and all "Minor" items are
QUALIFIED
avaluated as "GREEN" or "YELLOW"
"Major" item is avaluated as "RED", and all "Minor" items are
DISQUALIFIED
avaluated as "RED"

3 OF 3