Вы находитесь на странице: 1из 10

Urban Water Management in Ancient Greece:

Legacies and Lessons


D. Koutsoyiannis1; N. Zarkadoulas2; A. N. Angelakis3; and G. Tchobanoglous4

Abstract: The evolution of urban water management in ancient Greece, beginning in Crete during the early Minoan period, resulted in
Downloaded from ascelibrary.org by RMIT UNIVERSITY LIBRARY on 03/14/13. Copyright ASCE. For personal use only; all rights reserved.

a variety of remarkable developments on both the mainland and islands of Greece. Important developments include the implementation of
hygienic living standards, advanced hydraulic technologies for water transportation, constructions for flood and sediment control, and
sustainable urban water management practices, which can be compared to modern-day practices. The evolution of water management was
also related to sociopolitical conditions. During oligarchic periods the emphasis was on the construction of large-scale hydraulic projects,
whereas in democratic periods the focus of water management was on sustainable small-scale, safe, and cost-efficient management
practices and institutional arrangements related to both the private and public sectors. Such practices and institutions are relevant even
today, as the water-related problems of modern societies are not very different from those in antiquity.
DOI: 10.1061/共ASCE兲0733-9496共2008兲134:1共45兲
CE Database subject headings: Aqueducts; Dams; Historic sites; Hydraulic structures; Urban development; Water management;
Water supply; Greece.

Introduction and management practices related to urban water systems in an-


cient Greece and their relevance to modern times. In the follow-
Differences between ancient Greek civilization and the earlier ing sections we illustrate that such technologies were practiced as
Mesopotamian and Egyptian civilizations are not confined to cul- early as in the Minoan civilization and continued at a similar level
tural or mental issues, but also extend to infrastructure conditions in other places during prehistoric Greek civilization, reaching a
related to water. While Mesopotamia and Egypt relied on the technological peak in the sixth century B.C., well before the cul-
exploitation of the water of large rivers 共i.e., Tigris, Euphrates, tural peak of classical Athens. What is remarkable in classical
and Nile兲, developments in Greece have been characterized by Athens is the advancement in terms of sustainable and cost-
limited and often inadequate natural water resources. Some efficient water management practices. A second peak, this time
smaller-scale rivers and lakes exist in Greece, but, paradoxically, manifesting improved understanding of hydraulic principles, oc-
Greeks avoided the establishment of their major cities close to curred during the Hellenistic period. The examples of technolo-
them. Although the reasons are not well understood, it can be gies and management practices given in this article 共not widely
hypothesized that protection from floods and water-related dis- known among engineers兲 may have some importance for water
eases 共e.g., malaria兲, as well as a more convenient life style in a engineering even in modern times, as discussed in the last section
dry climate, were among the reasons. Water scarcity due to the before the conclusions.
dry climate and the distance from major water bodies led to the
development of advanced hydraulic systems for the collection and
transport of water as well as sustainable management practices. Minoan Civilization
The focus of this paper is on the technological developments
On the island of Crete, during the Minoan period 共3500–1200
1 B.C.兲, an extended period of technological development occurred,
Dept. of Water Resources, School of Civil Engineering, National
related to the capture, conveyance, and utilization of water.
Technical Univ. of Athens, Heroon Polytechneiou 5, GR-15780
Zographou, Greece 共corresponding author兲. E-mail: dk@itia.ntua.gr Elaborate water supply systems were developed in most Minoan
2
Dept. of Water Resources, School of Civil Engineering, National palaces. The types of systems varied according to local conditions
Technical Univ. of Athens, Heroon Polytechneiou 5, GR-15780 and involved various aspects of water resources engineering, in-
Zographou, Greece. cluding 共1兲 wells and groundwater exploitation; 共2兲 construction
3
National Foundation for Agricultural Research, Institute of Iraklio, and use of fountains; 共3兲 collection, storage, and use of rainwater;
32A Kastorias str., 71307 Iraklio, Greece. 共4兲 aqueducts and piping; 共5兲 bathrooms and other sanitary facili-
4
Dept. of Civil and Environmental Engineering, Univ. of California ties; and even 共6兲 recreational uses of water.
Davis, 662 Diego Place, Davis, CA 95616. The famous Minoan palace of Knossos is a good example with
Note. Discussion open until June 1, 2008. Separate discussions must which to understand the sources and methods for water supply of
be submitted for individual papers. To extend the closing date by one
the Minoan period. In the first stage of the Middle Minoan period
month, a written request must be filed with the ASCE Managing Editor.
The manuscript for this paper was submitted for review and possible 共ca. 1900–1700 B.C.兲, several wells were used for drawing drink-
publication on January 9, 2006; approved on January 2, 2007. This paper ing water. Their depth did not exceed 20 m and their diameter
is part of the Journal of Water Resources Planning and Management, was no more than 5 m 共Buffet and Evrard 1950兲. At least six such
Vol. 134, No. 1, January 1, 2008. ©ASCE, ISSN 0733-9496/2008/1-45– wells have been reported 共Evans 1921–1935兲. The inhabitants of
54/$25.00. the Knossos palace, however, did not depend on wells alone.

JOURNAL OF WATER RESOURCES PLANNING AND MANAGEMENT © ASCE / JANUARY/FEBRUARY 2008 / 45

J. Water Resour. Plann. Manage. 2008.134:45-54.


Downloaded from ascelibrary.org by RMIT UNIVERSITY LIBRARY on 03/14/13. Copyright ASCE. For personal use only; all rights reserved.

Fig. 1. Minoan water supply pipes 共terracotta pipe sections兲: 共a兲 cross
section and dimensions in meters; 共b兲 modern view 共Photograph
courtesy of M. Nikiforakis, Hellenic Photographic Association of
Crete, Iraklio, Greece, with permission兲

There are indications that the water supply system of the palace of Fig. 3. Remnants of the fresco showing the Minoan fountain 共jet
Minos at Knossos depended on the spring water of Mavrokolybos d’eau兲 from the “House of Frescos” of the Knossos palace
共450 m south of the palace兲 and later on the springs of Fundana 共Archaeological Museum of Iraklio, Greece. Photograph courtesy of
and Mt. Juctas 共about 10 and 5 km, respectively, from the palace兲. M. Nikiforakis, with permission.兲
Water supply in the palace was provided through a network of
terracotta piping located beneath the palace floors 共Fig. 1兲. The
pipes were constructed in sections of about 600 to 750 mm each.
Savvakis, unpublished report兲; 10 were built during the Minoan
These pipes with their expertly shaped, tightly interlocked sec-
period. Furthermore, hydraulic understanding was advanced
tions, date from the earliest days of the building and were of
enough to allow for the development and construction of foun-
quality similar to modern standards.
tains and a “jet d’eau” 共Evans 1921–1935兲, as revealed from rem-
As evidenced by these findings, Minoan engineers had a prac-
nants of a fresco depicting it 共Fig. 3兲. There are no natural geysers
tical knowledge of basic hydraulic principles that enabled them to
or sulphurous boils on the island, and such fountains were entirely
convey water from relatively large distances in a mountainous
foreign to ancient Egypt and Mesopotamia 共Angelakis and
terrain. More than 50 old aqueducts, one of which is shown in
Spyridakis 1996兲.
Fig. 2, have been identified in Crete 共A. N. Angelakis and Y.

Cycladic and Mycenaean Civilizations

Advanced techniques were also developed in the Aegean islands


during the Cycladic period 共ca. 3100–1600 B.C.兲. The archaeo-
logical investigation of the island of Thera 共also known as
Santorini兲, in the Cyclades island complex, found at least five
terracotta bathtubs. All of them must have been in use until the
great eruption of the Thera volcano around 1600 B.C. 关according
to the latest chronology, Friedrich et al. 2006兴. There was a great
variation among them. They were found in several places during
the excavations; one was in a room that must have been a bath-
room, equipped with an advanced sewage system 共Marinatos
Fig. 2. Parts of the aqueduct in the Tylissos archaeological site: 共a兲 1999兲. In Delos, another island of the Cyclades, where important
central conduit located in the entrance of the three villas and before remains of that period have been found, the water supply largely
the little cistern and secondary conduit; 共b兲 small lithic cistern, depended on rainwater collected and stored in cisterns. Most
probably used for removal of suspended solids of water before its houses on the island had underground cisterns in their yards for
storage to the main cistern storm-water storage. In addition, water from the Inopos ephem-

46 / JOURNAL OF WATER RESOURCES PLANNING AND MANAGEMENT © ASCE / JANUARY/FEBRUARY 2008

J. Water Resour. Plann. Manage. 2008.134:45-54.


Downloaded from ascelibrary.org by RMIT UNIVERSITY LIBRARY on 03/14/13. Copyright ASCE. For personal use only; all rights reserved.

Fig. 4. Terracotta bathtub in fixed position in Mycenaean pylos


共Photograph courtesy of Z. Philip Ambrose, from the Ambrose
Collection, Univ. of Vermont Classics Dept., 具http://www.uvm.edu/
%7Eclassics/mainpagelinks/ambrose.html典, with permission兲

eral stream was collected in a large cistern with a length of 43 m


and a width of 8 – 10 m 共Papademos 1975兲.
On mainland Greece, during the Mycenaean period 共1600– Fig. 5. Tunnel of Eupalinos: 共a兲 longitudinal section; 共b兲 horizontal
1100 B.C.兲, massive hydraulic works were built, including plan view; and 共c兲 view of tunnel and sloped channel 共and at points
polders, dams, and artificial reservoirs for floodwater retention second tunnel below the main tunnel兲 on the right side 共Photograph
and storage 共Koutsoyiannis and Angelakis 2004兲. Houses in sev- courtesy of Tracey Rihll, copyright Tracy Rihll, from “Greek and
eral cities, especially the luxurious ones, were equipped with Roman Science and Technology,” 具http://www.swan.ac.uk/grst/
bathrooms and in some cases bathtubs. The ancient Greek word What’s%20what%20Things/eupalinos.htm典 with permission兲
“␣’ ␴␣´ ␮␫␯␪o␵” 共asaminthos兲, meaning bathtub, is found in Hom-
er’s epics several times, as well as in works by later authors. A
terracotta bathtub shaped like present-day bathtubs, in a house in 2,800 m. Its construction started in 530 B.C., during the tyranny
the Mycenaean Pylos, a site in the southwestern Peloponnesus of Polycrates, and lasted 10 years. It was in operation until the
occupied at least as early as the Middle Bronze Age, is depicted in fifth century A.D.
Fig. 4. Its palace compares in size and richness with the palace of Eupalinos’s work is both remarkable and admirable for the
Mycenae and is believed to be the home of Nestor, the second following reasons:
most powerful Mycenaean king. Although the bathtub was in a 1. He constructed the first-known deep tunnel in history; shal-
fixed position, it must have been filled and emptied by hand rather low tunnels are much easier to construct by means of shafts,
than being connected directly to the sewers 共similar to the Minoan and their technology was developed in earlier civilizations.
bathtubs兲. 2. As done in modern construction practice, he started from two
openings 共N and S兲; it is evident that the two construction
lines met at point E.
Aqueduct of Samos: Peak of Ancient Hydraulic 3. To carve segments of the same straight line 共NA and SF兲
Technology from two points in a mountainous terrain, he must have had
a good working knowledge of geometry and geodesy. There
In the later archaic 共750–500 B.C.兲 and classical 共500–336 B.C.兲 is evidence that Eupalinos solved the problem with simple
periods, both historical sources and archaeological excavations means and in an accurate manner by walking over the moun-
provide evidence that urban water technologies were advanced tain and putting poles up along the path in a straight line 共a
and widespread in Greece. The advancement of urban water tech- simple method used even today in engineering geodesy, but
nology and management is illustrated in this section through the for simpler problems, not for the construction of tunnels兲.
extraordinary example of the water supply of the island of Samos. Then he lined up the workers in the tunnel segments with
The water supply system of ancient Samos 共located at the site of these poles.
the modern-day village of Pythagoreio兲 was admired both in an- 4. Simultaneously, he showed that from an engineering point of
tiquity and in modern times 共Angelakis and Koutsoyiannis 2003兲. view a straight line may not necessarily be the best path.
The most amazing part of the water supply system is the Thus, at point A he left the straight line NA and followed the
“E␷´ ␲␣␭␫␯⑀␫o␯ ’ó␷␥␮␣” or “Eupalinean digging,” more widely direction AB, a plausible explanation for this being that he
known as the Tunnel of Eupalinos, named after the engineer from found a natural fracture or rift, and by broadening this he was
Megara who designed and constructed it. The aqueduct includes able to proceed much faster 共Tsimpourakis 1997兲.
the 1,036 m long tunnel 共part NS in Fig. 5兲 and two additional 5. He found a clever geometrical way to eliminate the impact
parts 共PN and SQ in Fig. 5兲, so that its total length exceeds of uncertainty in position and direction 共magnified due to

JOURNAL OF WATER RESOURCES PLANNING AND MANAGEMENT © ASCE / JANUARY/FEBRUARY 2008 / 47

J. Water Resour. Plann. Manage. 2008.134:45-54.


already abandoning the straight-line route兲 and ensure the
intersection of the two construction lines. By deliberately
abandoning the straight-line routes at points D and F and
changing direction to the left and right, respectively, he made
it mathematically certain that the two lines would intersect
共Kienast 1995兲.
6. He also found an especially clever engineering solution for
the hydraulic principle that water needs a gradient 共i.e.,
slope兲 to flow. In the horizontal tunnel he achieved the nec-
essary gradient by excavating a sloping channel along one
side of the floor 共Fig. 5, lower portion兲; in places where due
to slope the depth of the channel would be very high, a
Downloaded from ascelibrary.org by RMIT UNIVERSITY LIBRARY on 03/14/13. Copyright ASCE. For personal use only; all rights reserved.

second small tunnel below the main tunnel was built. The
choice of a horizontal main tunnel was dictated by the fact
that a sloping one would be impossible to construct from
two sides, given the technological means of the time; note
that the accumulation of groundwater in the upper 共viz.
downsloping兲 segment would not allow its construction. Fig. 6. The wall blocks of Kladeos stream in ancient Olympia
It is certain that the tunnel Eupalinos constructed was not the 关Photograph courtesy of Ken Wright, from Lapp and Wright 共2003兲,
only solution to the problem of conveying water to Samos. A with permission兴
simple alternative solution could have been the construction of a
chain of open channels and tunnels at shallow depths with shafts,
following a route around the mountain. This solution, already with four stone courses 共Fig. 6兲 and has a uniform slope of ap-
well known 共cf. Peisistratean aqueduct; see below兲, would cer- proximately 0.077. The obvious purpose for its construction was
tainly have been easier technically, faster, and less expensive. The to constrain Kladeos River flow to the western side of the wall,
reasons that led to the construction of such a costly structure are preventing erosion of the Olympic site’s western margin. Its con-
not obvious. Probably Eupalinos and the tyrant Polycrates pre- struction date is unknown but most probably was in the classical
ferred this unorthodox and breakthrough solution because they period, when the place took its final form 共Lapp and Wright
wished to build a monument of technology rather than simply 2003兲.
solving a specific water transportation problem. Obviously this The ancient city of Alyzia is located in Western Greece, on the
solution also has the advantage of being more secure in case of coastline of Akarnania. Close to the city, in the fringes of the
war because it was not exposed to enemies. As will be discussed Akarnanika Mountains, lies a unique example of a hydraulic work
later, security was an essential element in Greek designs. Some of Greek antiquity: a stone dam, equipped with a stone carved
authors 关e.g., Apostol 共2004兲兴 suggest security as a motivation for lateral spillway 共Fig. 7兲. The exact date of its construction is
the choice of Eupalinos. In our opinion, this is not a sufficient unknown, but because of the city’s prosperity during the fifth
reason, because the alternative solution of a shallow tunnel would century B.C., this period is the most probable for the construction
provide same advantages 共subterranean construction not exposed of the dam.
to enemies兲 in a cheaper and technically simpler way. The body of the dam has two zones. The bottom zone is char-
acterized by more squared blocks, irregularly placed, with smaller
blocks filling the gaps between them. In the upper zone, where the
Stream Control Works: Olympia and Alyzia Cases slope of the dam becomes softer, stones are uniformly shaped and
regularly placed, with smaller gaps, which did not require filling
The protection of urban areas from the destructive action of with other, smaller stones. The structure impresses the observer
streams 共floods, erosion, sedimentation兲 is another case of appli- with its overall technological and constructional quality. Accord-
cation of hydraulic and water management technologies. Such ing to Murray 共1984兲: “This is the clearest, largest, and most
techniques are also necessary in the development of agricultural technologically advanced ancient specimen yet known in the
areas, given that the most fertile areas are the flood plains of whole country.”
rivers. As mentioned above, large-scale projects 共massive or Such a structure certainly required a considerable investment
Cyclopean type兲 of the latter type date back to the Mycenaean from the city. Various scenarios have been suggested for the
period. Here we present two other examples from the classical reasons that led to its construction. Most of these approaches
period, related to urban or suburban development: the flood pro- conclude that the dam was built to collect drinking or irrigation
tection works of Olympia, and the dam of ancient Alyzia. water, or even to wash the wool of sheep. A recent study
Olympia is one of the most important sanctuaries of antiquity, 共Zarkadoulas 2005兲 proposes a different scenario: Floods in the
dedicated to the father of the gods Zeus 共Jupiter兲. It is the birth- valley of ancient Alyzia were exceptionally intense, leading to
place of the Olympic Games and the place where they were held. serious problems in the urban and suburban areas of the city. To
The sanctuary of Olympia spreads around the feet of the Kronion mitigate the floods and hold back the coarse sediments that inun-
hill, where the rivers Alpheios and Kladeos meet. To control the dated the valley, the inhabitants of Alyzia constructed the dam in
flow of the rivers and mitigate their destructive consequences, the most suitable site of the watercourse. Even today this is one of
massive walls were constructed. The Kladeos wall runs roughly the most effective solutions for flood and sedimentation control.
the length of the ancient Olympic site, parallel to and west of it, The current condition of the dam is excellent. The stones of
beginning upstream at the upper end of the Gymnasium and end- which it is composed are in their initial place and only slightly
ing not far from the discharge of the Kladeos into the much larger smoothed, giving us the clue that the spillway has always been
Alpheios. It is a 2.7 m high, 800 m long Cyclopean conglomerate operating effectively, protecting the dam from floods. The dam of

48 / JOURNAL OF WATER RESOURCES PLANNING AND MANAGEMENT © ASCE / JANUARY/FEBRUARY 2008

J. Water Resour. Plann. Manage. 2008.134:45-54.


Downloaded from ascelibrary.org by RMIT UNIVERSITY LIBRARY on 03/14/13. Copyright ASCE. For personal use only; all rights reserved.

Fig. 7. The dam of Alyzia; the spillway with its irregular shape formed by erosion through centuries is shown on the right of left photo and in
operation in the right photo

ancient Alyzia is an impressive work of infrastructure, not only not to provision the idle. 共Plutarch, Solon, 23; translation
for its scale or for the overall quality of its design and construc- adapted from Bernadotte Perrin; http://hydra.perseus.tufts.
tion, but also for its continuous and successful operation for 2,500 edu/兲
years.
In the sixth century B.C., large public works were built under
the tyranny of Peisistratos 共who seized power in 546 and ruled
until his death in 527兲 and later of his sons. The most important
Water Management in the City of Athens
hydraulic project was an aqueduct, named after him, which car-
ried water from the foothills of the Hymettos Mountain to the
Athens has never had sufficient natural water resources. The two
center of the city near the Acropolis. On the outskirts of the city
main streams, Ilisos and Kephisos, have intermittent flow. Water
the aqueduct branched out to supply fountains and reservoirs. The
supply has been a never-ending challenge for the city. Spring
greatest part of it was carved as a tunnel at a depth reaching 14 m.
water in the area could not meet the demand, so most people
In other parts it was constructed as a channel, either carved in
relied on artificial wells for their water supply. During the exca-
rock or made from stone masonry, with a depth of 1.30– 1.50 m
vation of the ancient agora by the American School of Classical
and a width of 0.65 m 共Papademos 1975兲. In the bottom of the
Studies at Athens, over 400 wells were found, which represented
tunnel or channel, a pipe made of ceramic sections was placed.
both public and private projects. There was a great variation in
The pipe sections had elliptic openings in their upper part, cov-
depth, which ranges from 2.5 to 37 m, with an average of about
ered by ceramic covers, for their cleaning and maintenance; the
10 m. In the sixth century B.C., wells were occasionally lined
ends of the sections were appropriately shaped, so that each could
with small-stone masonry, and, beginning in the fourth century
be tightly fitted into the next 共Fig. 8兲.
B.C., circular drums of terracotta were often used to form a shaft
Shortly after 共510–508 B.C.兲, democracy was established in
of great durability 共Lang 1968兲.
Athens and lasted up to 322 B.C., with few intervals of oligarchic
As population grew, the number of the wells increased. Solon,
the Athenian statesman and poet of the late seventh and early
sixth century B.C., made a law for the way the water from the
wells should be handled. Most of his laws were later described by
Plutarch 共47–127 A.D.兲, from whom we learn
Since the country was not supplied with water by ever-
flowing rivers, or lakes, or copious springs, but most of
the inhabitants used wells which had been dug, he made a
law that where there was a public well within a “hip-
pikon,” a distance of four stadia 共4 furlongs, 740 m兲, that
should be used, but where the distance was greater than
this, people must try to get water of their own; if, how-
ever, after digging to a depth of ten fathoms 共18.3 m兲 on Fig. 8. Parts of the Peisistratean aqueduct uncovered during the
their own land, they could not get water, then they might recent excavations for the Metro of Athens, as shown: 共a兲 in place
take it from a neighbor’s well, filling a six choae 共20 L兲 near the Syntagma Metro Station; 共b兲 in a show box in the
jar twice a day; for he thought it his duty to aid the needy, Evangelismos Metro Station

JOURNAL OF WATER RESOURCES PLANNING AND MANAGEMENT © ASCE / JANUARY/FEBRUARY 2008 / 49

J. Water Resour. Plann. Manage. 2008.134:45-54.


governance. During that period no major hydraulic works were this period 共Lang 1968兲. Private installations like wells and cis-
implemented, even though the need for potable water increased terns tended to be abandoned, signifying a water management
as the city continued to grow. What Athenians did, instead, attitude different from that of the classical period.
was to build small-scale constructions along with the develop-
ment of an institutional framework for the sustainable manage-
ment of water. From Plutarch’s Life of Themistokles 共XXXI,I兲, Hellenistic Period and the Pergamon Aqueducts
it is known that there was at least one public official concerned
with waterworks even in the early fifth century B.C., named The Hellenistic period 共323–146 B.C.兲 is characterized by signifi-
“␬␳o␷␯␻ ¯ ␯ ⑀` ␲␫␮⑀␭␩␶␩´ ␵” 共i.e., superintendent of fountains兲. He cant progress in mathematics 共particularly geometry兲, physics,
was appointed to operate and maintain the city water system, to and technology 关e.g., Koutsoyiannis and Angelakis 共2003兲兴. The
monitor enforcement of the regulation, and to ensure the fair dis- well-known water helix pump invented by Archimedes 共287–212
tribution of water. From Aristotle it is known that this was one of B.C.兲 is a characteristic example of how geometry, combined with
Downloaded from ascelibrary.org by RMIT UNIVERSITY LIBRARY on 03/14/13. Copyright ASCE. For personal use only; all rights reserved.

the few highest offices that were not filled by allotment but by understanding of physics 共gravity and hydraulics兲, aided techno-
election 共Tassios 2002兲. It is clear then that water management logical advances. Particularly in Alexandria, significant develop-
ments were made in hydraulics, which allowed the invention of
was of great importance for the city.
advanced hydraulic and pneumatic instruments and devices 共such
During the democracy period, wells were gradually comple-
as pumps, hydraulic clocks, musical instruments, steam boilers,
mented or replaced by cisterns. The construction of cisterns was a
and a reactive motor兲. All of these developments reflect a good
known practice since earlier times; for instance, several from the
understanding of the combined action of air and water pressure,
sixth century B.C. have been found inside the Acropolis wall to and particularly the function of a siphon and an inverted siphon.
the left of the Propylaea. Dug into the rock of the surface, with There are indications that the flow under pressure was known
rock-cut drainage channels, they were capable of holding several much earlier than this period, such as in the Minoan period 共cf.
months’ supply of water, which could be used for drinking if the jet d’eau described above兲. However, the Hellenistic period
necessary but usually was used for bathing and cleaning 共Crouch seems to be the first in history in which the pressure flow was
1993兲. But most of the cisterns date from the fourth to first cen- applied on a large technological scale for water conveyance. The
turies B.C. The main reason for the spread of cisterns at that characteristic example is the water supply system of the citadel of
period must have been the gradual drop in the elevation of the Pergamon. The ancient city of Pergamon is in western Anatolia
groundwater aquifer due to overextraction. The cisterns were pri- 共today Turkey兲, 30 km inland from the Aegean Sea. Little is
vate and usually small, averaging about 3 m in diameter at floor known of the city’s history before the Hellenistic period. The
level, and were filled by rainwater collected from the surrounding dynasty of the kingdom of Pergamon began with General Phile-
roofs and directed by pipe toward the cistern mouth. Cistern water tairos 共283–263 B.C.兲 and ended in 133 B.C. with its surrender to
was normally used for washing, and the well water for drinking the Romans on the death of the last king, Attalos III 共Ministry of
共Lang 1968兲. the Aegean 2006兲.
Although during democracy several public buildings 共e.g., the The first settlement of the town was on top of the high hill.
Parthenon兲 with monumental character were constructed in the The water needs of the city were met by rainwater stored in a
city, no serious hydraulic structures were implemented. A suffi- system of cisterns 共providing secure water supply in the event of
cient explanation can be obtained from Aristotle: war兲 and by a small spring at the foot of the hill. By 1993, 149
such cisterns had been found, which could support a population
…and it must possess if possible a plentiful natural supply of about 7,900 inhabitants 共Garbrecht and Garbrecht 2005兲. The
of pools and springs, but failing this, a mode has been city began to expand, and around 200 B.C. water demand ex-
invented of supplying water by means of constructing an ceeded the locally available water resources. Three aqueducts
abundance of large reservoirs for rainwater, so that a sup- were installed to transfer water from the mountains. One aque-
ply may never fail the citizens when they are debarred duct, transferring water from the Madradag Mountain, crossed the
from their territory by war. 共Aristotle, Politics, III, I330b; depression north of City Hill as an inverted siphon of length
translation from http://hydra.perseus.tufts.edu/兲 exceeding 3 km with a maximum pressure head of about 180 m
共Fig. 9兲. The inverted siphon was made of metal 共lead兲 and an-
Another reason for the absence of major hydraulic projects during
chored with big stone constructions 共Garbrecht et al. 2001兲. A
the democracy period, as opposed to the period of tyranny 共cf. sediment settling chamber was built at the upstream end of the
Polycrates and Peisistratos兲, must be that all decisions were taken inverted siphon to prevent it from being obstructed by sediments
democratically. Thus it is probable that Athenians would be reluc- 共Garbrecht and Garbrecht 2005兲. The great length of the construc-
tant to fund large-scale projects of this kind. The extent and cost tion and above all the unbelievably high pressure head, both of
of the solutions chosen had to be in absolute accordance with the which make any alternative 共e.g., water bridge兲 infeasible, is cer-
actual needs and the general economic status of the city. tainly a milestone of hydraulic engineering.
Later, when the Romans took control of the city, water became
a matter of luxury and prestige. Public water systems grew and
aqueducts were used to transfer water to public fountains. The Relevance to Modern Times
most important structure of this period was an aqueduct, built
under the reign of Emperor Hadrian 共117–138 A.D.兲, conveying To put in perspective the ancient water management principles
water from the mountains Parnes and Pentele to Athens, covering and practices discussed in this paper, it is important to examine
a distance of 25 km. This new aqueduct supplied the Athenians their relevance to modern times and to harvest some lessons
with large quantities of high-quality potable water. The increased learned. The relevance of ancient works will be examined in
supply completely changed the way the Athenians handled water, terms of the evolution of technology, technological advances, de-
as can be inferred from the larger overflow pipes constructed in sign principles, and management principles.

50 / JOURNAL OF WATER RESOURCES PLANNING AND MANAGEMENT © ASCE / JANUARY/FEBRUARY 2008

J. Water Resour. Plann. Manage. 2008.134:45-54.


Downloaded from ascelibrary.org by RMIT UNIVERSITY LIBRARY on 03/14/13. Copyright ASCE. For personal use only; all rights reserved.

Fig. 9. Sections of the Madradag aqueduct at Pergamon: 共a兲 longitudinal section indicating the 3 km long inverted siphon; 共b兲 typical cross
section showing an anchor stone of the leaden pipe 关dimensions in meters; sections constructed by data in Garbrecht et al. 共2001兲兴

Evolution of Technology Sun and the Moon. For years it was thought that Copernicus
An important question to discuss is whether modern water tech- reinvented this theory 1,800 years later. Now we know that Co-
nologies were derived from ancient Greek technological achieve- pernicus was aware of Aristarchus’s theory, since his original
ments, or were Greek achievements totally forgotten 共during dark draft of De Revolutionibus has survived and features a passage
ages兲 and had to be reinvented in modern times. The latter thesis referring to Aristarchus, which Copernicus crossed out 共Weisstein
could be regarded as an extension of Crouch’s 共1993, p. 123兲 2006兲.
thinking about the evolution of technologies in ancient times. The tunnel of Eupalinos and its two lines of construction were
Specifically, she states “Because of the gap in the archaeological also not forgotten over long periods of time. Herodotus 共History,
record, we cannot be sure whether any of their 共e.g. the Myce- ⌫, 60兲 mentions the tunnel, calling it “␣` ␮␾␫´␴␶o␮o␯” or “bi-
naeans’ and Minoans’兲 knowledge about water management sur- mouthed,” indicating that it was constructed from two openings.
vived the collapse of these civilizations and the 400 years or so of
Four centuries after Eupalinos, the mathematician and physicist
the ‘Dark Ages’ that followed. 关. . .兴 we would not expect them
关sophisticated technologies兴 to survive but to be independently Hero 共Heron兲 of Alexandria 共Dioptra, II; 1st century B.C.兲, in-
reinvented when later Greek society reached technological so- spired by this tunnel, studied the problem of how “to dig a moun-
phistication.” tain on a straight line from two given mouths” 关his geometrical
The evolution of science and engineering is not linear but Problem #15; see also Apostol 共2004兲兴. The solution he proposed,
rather characterized by discontinuities and regressions. On the which is based on a route around the mountain, is technologically
other hand, it is not “Markovian” in the sense that only the inferior to that of Eupalinos—but the most essential point is that
present 共i.e., the state at a certain instant in time兲 and not the past the importance of the problem and the feasibility of its solution
共i.e., the entire history兲 influences the future. “Bridges” from the passed to the next generations and to history.
past to the future are always present, albeit some times invisible Hero was himself an engineer, and together with his predeces-
in the present. Thus, in addition to many constructions that have sors, Alexandrian engineers Ctesibius and Philon Byzantius, and
been continuously or intermittently in operation up to the present
the Syracusean mathematician, engineer, and philosopher
day, written information from ancient Greece has survived 关in-
Archimedes, offered the foundation and basic applications of hy-
cluding even detailed contracts between the public and construc-
tors of hydraulic works; Koutsoyiannis and Angelakis 共2003兲兴. A drostatics and hydrodynamics 共Koutsoyiannis and Angelakis
characteristic example of such a “bridge” comes from astronomy: 2003兲. As discussed above, the development of such a scientific
The heliocentric model of the solar system was first formulated framework in the Hellenistic period was a scientific basis for the
by the astronomer Aristarchus of Samos 共310–230 B.C.兲, who pressure aqueduct at Pergamon. In this case, it has been main-
also figured out how to measure the distances to and sizes of the tained that no other inverted siphon of this size was built for one

JOURNAL OF WATER RESOURCES PLANNING AND MANAGEMENT © ASCE / JANUARY/FEBRUARY 2008 / 51

J. Water Resour. Plann. Manage. 2008.134:45-54.


and a half millennia thereafter 共Garbrecht and Garbrecht 2005兲,
which may be interpreted as a case of discontinuity in the history
of technology.
However, this may be disputable because the Roman engineer
Vitruvius describes the inverted siphon 共Hodge 2002兲 and be-
cause siphons 共perhaps of smaller size兲 were found in Roman
aqueducts of later periods, for instance in Lugdunum 关Lyon;
Screen 共2005兲兴. Other advances of this period were in continuous
use through the centuries. The most characteristic example is
Archimedes’s helix pump, which is still used today, from large-
scale engineering applications 共e.g., in wastewater and storm
drain pumping stations兲 to medical procedures 共e.g., in surgery to
Downloaded from ascelibrary.org by RMIT UNIVERSITY LIBRARY on 03/14/13. Copyright ASCE. For personal use only; all rights reserved.

maintain blood circulation兲.

Fig. 10. The modern Athens aqueduct near the Delphi Oracle site
Technological Advances: What Progress? 共Photograph courtesy of Leonardos Michas, Water Supply and
Sewerage Company of Athens, with permission兲
Another issue that must be examined is the comparison of hy-
draulic technology in ancient times to that in modern times. Cer-
tainly many modern advances were not known in antiquity, such so that it was not exposed and its route not known to aliens. No
as the use of plastic and concrete pipes, the automated pressurized such considerations were made in the modern aqueduct of Athens,
urban water distribution systems, the use of electromechanical constructed in the second half of the twentieth century 共Fig. 10兲.
equipment such as pumps, and the effective mechanical equip- The storm-water cisterns, whose maintenance in ancient Athens
ment for the construction of hydraulic works. But to some extent must have been obligatory for citizens, is another provision for
these are differences in the apparatus and the scale of applications the maximization of system stability and safety. In addition to
and not differences in the fundamental principles used. Even the providing a source of water for private use and enhancing the
lifestyle related to the hygienic standards of a civilization may not security of the overall system, cisterns 共still in wide use in anhy-
be a recent development. For example, flushing toilets equipped drous Greek islands兲 also reduce the amount of storm water to be
with seats resembling present-day toilets and drained by sewers discharged.
existed from Minoan times 关e.g., in the Knossos palace; Ange- Lately, interventions such as the use of cisterns are being re-
lakis et al. 共2005兲兴. The essential progress of modern times is the assessed and are currently recommended as storm-water source
better understanding and mathematization of hydraulics, which control practices 共Maksimovic and Tejada-Guibert 2001兲. In mod-
allows better design and management of hydraulic works and ern Athens, such storm-water tanks would partly mitigate the
much larger scales of application. flood problem 共Xanthopoulos et al. 1996; Koutsoyiannis 2000兲,
but they do not exist.
Design Philosophy
Management Principles
Current-day engineers typically use a design period of structures
of about 40 to 50 years, which is related to economic consider- The Athenian example described earlier manifests admirable bal-
ations. Sustainability, as a design principle, has entered the engi- ances between 共1兲 structural and nonstructural 共institutional兲 mea-
neering lexicon within the last decade. It is difficult to infer the sures; 共2兲 large-scale 共e.g. the Peisistratean aqueduct兲 and small-
design principles of ancient engineers. Nevertheless, it is notable scale 共wells and cisterns兲 projects; and 共3兲 interests of the public
that several ancient works have operated for very long periods, 共for large-scale works兲 and the private 共for small-scale works兲
until contemporary times. For example, water for the modern city sectors. The latter is apparent even in Solon’s regulation discussed
of Athens was supplied primarily by the Hadrianian aqueduct up above, whose ultimate purpose was to balance public and private
to the 1920s and partly until the 1950s. The Peisistratean aque- interest for the construction and operation of wells. Today, similar
duct is still in operation today 共with some interruptions, the most solutions are often sought both in developed and developing
recent being caused 2 years ago by damage from the construction countries, as neither the public nor the private sector alone can
of a modern underground car park兲, albeit not for water supply provide sustainable solutions for water supply 共Maksimovic and
but for the irrigation of the National Garden in the center of Tejada-Guibert 2001兲. In modern Athens, the responsibility for
Athens. Athens can be regarded as an example of a sustainable the management of the water supply system was initially assigned
city, given that its history extends for more than 3,000 years 共even to the municipality and the central government; then 共in the
though the city’s sustainability, liveability, and beauty have wors- 1920s兲 it passed to a private company, which about 50 years later
ened in the second half of the twentieth century兲. Despite frequent became a public organization that was reprivatized 6 years ago.
earthquakes and war actions, several constructions have survived Some municipalities in the Athens area still play some role in
up to the present, reflecting the grandeur of the city’s history. water supply management. These forward and backward changes
With the events of the past few years, security of infrastruc- clearly indicate that such a balance between private and public
tures is now a concern for every country. However, because in the interests has been not established to date.
recent past security has not been considered properly, many urban
water supply systems are vulnerable in case of war or terrorist
actions or in case of natural disasters. Yet the concern for security Conclusion and Discussion
was a critical element of the system design philosophy in ancient
times, as discussed above. For example, the entire Peisistratean Beginning from Minoan Crete, fundamental technologies regard-
aqueduct in Athens was constructed as an underground aqueduct, ing water supply were developed in ancient Greece to a degree

52 / JOURNAL OF WATER RESOURCES PLANNING AND MANAGEMENT © ASCE / JANUARY/FEBRUARY 2008

J. Water Resour. Plann. Manage. 2008.134:45-54.


never reached prior to that time 共Viollet 2003兲. Using these tech- Water Res., 39共1兲, 210–220.
nologies, impressive urban water supply systems appear to have Angelakis, A. N., and Spyridakis, S. V. 共1996兲. “Chapter 2: The status of
been implemented, initially without regard to cost criterion con- water resources in Minoan times: A preliminary study.” Diachronic
sideration. As a result, the water supply systems represent the climatic impacts on water resources with emphasis on Mediterranean
state of the art that was technically feasible at that time. Similarly, region, A. N. Ange lakis and A. S. Issar, eds., Springer, Heidelberg,
the aqueduct of ancient Samos is an important hydraulic monu- Germany, 161–191.
ment, proving that it was absolutely feasible in the ancient world Apostol, T. M. 共2004兲. “The tunnel of Samos.” Eng. Sci., 67共1兲, 30–40.
to design and construct technologically advanced water transpor- Buffet, B., and Evrard, R. 共1950兲. L’eau potable à Travers les ages,
tation projects on a large scale. Editions Soledi, Liege, Belgium.
Athenians, on the other hand, especially during the golden Crouch, D. P. 共1993兲. Water management in Ancient Greek cities, Oxford
period of the city, seem to have fully adapted urban water man- University Press, New York–Oxford, U.K.
agement principles to deal with the limited water resources, fol- Evans, S. A. 共1921–1935兲. The palace of Minos at Knossos: A compara-
Downloaded from ascelibrary.org by RMIT UNIVERSITY LIBRARY on 03/14/13. Copyright ASCE. For personal use only; all rights reserved.

lowing a rather advanced model that included large-scale public tive account of the successive stages of the early Cretan civilization as
illustrated by the discoveries, Vols. I–IV, Macmillan, London
works 共constructed earlier, during tyranny兲 but was mainly based
共reprinted in 1964 by Biblo and Tannen, New York兲.
on small-scale constructions 共cisterns and wells兲 and nonstruc-
Friedrich, W. L., Kromer, B., Friedrich, M., Heinemeier, J., Pfeiffer, T.,
tural measures 共Solon’s laws, institutions such as the superinten- and Talamo, S. 共2006兲. “Santorini eruption radiocarbon dated to
dent of fountains兲 imposing a remarkable balance of public and 1627–1600 B.C.” Science, 312共5773兲, 548.
private interests. It is evident that the system of democratic Ath- Garbrecht, G., Brinker, W., Fahlbusch, H., Hetch, K., and Thies, H.
ens must have worked exceptionally well for a long period. This 共2001兲. “Die Wasserversorgung von Pergamon.” Altertumer von Per-
approach is remarkably advanced, as modern water resource poli- gamon, Band 1: Stadt und Landschaft, Teil 4, Deutsches Archaeolo-
cymakers and hydraulic engineers are now reemphasizing the im- gisches Institut AvP I.4, herausgegeben im Auftrag des Institutes von
portance of nonstructural and small-scale structural measures in Wolfgang Radt, Verlag Walter de Gruyter, Berlin/New York.
urban water management 共Maksimovic and Tejada-Guibert 2001; Garbrecht, J. D., and Garbrecht, G. K. H. 共2005兲. “Water supply chal-
Angelakis and Koutsoyiannis 2003兲. lenges and solutions of the ancient city of Pergamon.” Proc., Okla-
Excavations at several other cities of Greek antiquity have homa Water 2005, Paper #6, Oklahoma Water Resources Research
brought to light urban water systems equally as advanced as those Institute, Stillwater, Okla.
described in this paper. The achievements of ancient Greece in Hodge, A. T. 共2002兲. “Roman waterworks 共G. De Kleijn: The water sup-
dealing with the hygienic and functional requirements and related ply of Ancient Rome: City area, water, and population兲.” The Classi-
hydraulic technologies and water management practices can only cal Review, 52共02兲, 346–348.
be compared to modern urban water systems, reestablished in Kienast, H. J. 共1995兲. Die Wasserleitung des Eupalinos auf Samos,
Europe and North America from the second half of the nineteenth Deutches Archäologisches Institute, Bonn, Germany.
century A.D. 共Angelakis et al. 2005兲 until the present day. It is Koutsoyiannis, D. 共2000兲. “Urban water systems management: Remarks–
reasonable to assume that, with a few exceptions, the basis for questions–opinions.” Water and Environment, Water Supply and Sew-
present-day progress in urban water management is clearly not a erage Company of Athens, Athens, Greece 共in Greek兲.
recent development. Koutsoyiannis, D., and Angelakis, A. N. 共2003兲. “Hydrologic and hy-
From the above discussion, it is useful to reflect on some les- draulic science and technology in ancient Greece.” The encyclopedia
sons learned from past history: of water science, B. A. Stewart and T. Howell, eds., 415–417, Dekker,
• The meaning of sustainability in modern times should be re- New York.
evaluated in light of ancient public works and management Koutsoyiannis, D., and Angelakis, A. N. 共2004兲. “Agricultural hydraulic
practices. works in ancient Greece.” B. A. Stewart and T. Howell, eds., Ency-
• Technological developments based on sound engineering prin- clopedia of water science, New York.
ciples can have extended useful lives. Lang, M. 共1968兲. “Waterworks in the Athenian Agora.” Excavations of
• Security, with respect to water, is of critical importance in the the Athenian Agora, Picture Book No. 11, American School of Clas-
sustainability of a population. sical Studies at Athens, Princeton, N.J.
• In water-short areas, development of an effective water re- Lapp, R. J., and Wright, K. R. 共2003兲. “Olympia floods sedimentation.”
sources management program is essential. WPI Technical Rep., Wright Paleohydrological Institute 共WPI兲,
Denver.
Maksimovic, C., and Tejada-Guibert, J. A., eds. 共2001兲. Urban water
management—Deadlock or hope, IWA Publishing, London.
Acknowledgements Marinatos, S. 共1999兲. Excavations at Thera VI–VII, 1972–1973 seasons,
2nd Ed., The Archaeological Society at Athens, Athens, Greece.
The encouraging comments and suggestions by two anonymous Ministry of the Aegean and Univ. of Athens. 共2006兲. Archaeological atlas
reviewers and the editor resulted in significant improvement of of the Aegean, 具http://www.ypai.gr/atlas/Default_uk.asp#典.
this article. Murray, W. M. 共1984兲. “The ancient dam of the Mytikas Valley.” Am. J.
Archaeol., 88共2兲, 195–203.
Papademos, D. L. 共1975兲. The hydraulic works in Ancient Greece (T␣
References Y␦␳␣␷␭␫␬␣´ ´E␳␥␣ ⌸␣␳␣´ ␶o␫␵ A␳␹␣␫´o␫␵), Vol. C, Ed. TEE, Athens,
Greece 共in Greek兲.
Angelakis, A. N., and Koutsoyiannis, D. 共2003兲. “Urban water resources Screen, B. M. 共2005兲. “Around the Roman world in 180 days.” MsA
management in Ancient Greek times.” B. A. Stewart and T. Howell, thesis, Univ. of South Africa, 具http://etd.unisa.ac.za/ETD-db/theses/
eds., The encyclopedia of water science, Dekker, New York, 999– available/etd-06122006-142238/unrestricted/dissertation.pdf典.
1007. Tassios, T. P. 共2002兲. “From Peisistratean to Evinos.” 共A␲ó ␶ó
Angelakis, A. N., Koutsoyiannis, D., and Tchobanoglous, G. 共2005兲. ⌸⑀␫␴␫␴␶␳␣´ ␶⑀␫o ␴␶o␯ E␷´ ␩␯o兲 Kathimerini, March 24, Athens,
“Urban wastewater and stormwater technologies in ancient Greece.” Greece 共in Greek兲.

JOURNAL OF WATER RESOURCES PLANNING AND MANAGEMENT © ASCE / JANUARY/FEBRUARY 2008 / 53

J. Water Resour. Plann. Manage. 2008.134:45-54.


Tsimpourakis, D. 共1997兲. 530 B.C., The digging of Eupalinos in Ancient Weisstein, E. W. 共2006兲. “Copernicus, Nicholaus.” World of biography,
Samos 共530 ␲ . X., To ´O␳␷␥␮␣ ␶o␷ E␷␲␣␭␫´␯o␷ ␴␶␩␯ A␳␹␣␫´␣ 具http://scienceworld.wolfram.com/biography/Copernicus.html典.
⌺␣´ ␮o兲 Ed., Arithmos, Athens, Greece 共in Greek兲. Xanthopoulos, T., Christoulas, D., Mimikou, M., Aftias, M., and Kout-
soyiannis, D. 共1996兲. “Flood protection of the Athens basin.” Monthly
Viollet, P.-L. 共2003兲. “The predecessors of European hydraulic engineers:
Technical Review, 48, 50–53 共in Greek兲.
Minoans of Crete and Mycenaeans of Greece 共2100–1200 B.C.兲.”
Zarkadoulas, N. 共2005兲. “The dam of ancient Alyzia 共To ␸␳␣´ ␥␮␣ ␶␩␵
XXX IAHR Congress, Theme E: Linkage between education research ␣␳␹␣␫´␣␵ A␭␷␨␫´␣␵兲.” Postgraduate thesis, Dept. of Water Resources,
and professional development in water engineering, Thessaloniki, Hydraulic and Maritime Engineering, National Technical Univ. of
Greece. Athens, Athens, Greece 共in Greek兲.
Downloaded from ascelibrary.org by RMIT UNIVERSITY LIBRARY on 03/14/13. Copyright ASCE. For personal use only; all rights reserved.

54 / JOURNAL OF WATER RESOURCES PLANNING AND MANAGEMENT © ASCE / JANUARY/FEBRUARY 2008

J. Water Resour. Plann. Manage. 2008.134:45-54.