Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
net/publication/340698796
Meaning and Rituals of Death: An Insight into Selected Ethnic and Religious
Communities of Bangladesh
CITATIONS READS
0 688
1 author:
Saifur Rashid
University of Dhaka
72 PUBLICATIONS 11 CITATIONS
SEE PROFILE
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
A joint project of Google Arts & Culture, Paris and ICHCAP, South Korea on Visual Online Documentation of ICH Elements of South Asia View project
All content following this page was uploaded by Saifur Rashid on 17 April 2020.
1
Department of Anthropology, University of Dhaka, Bangladesh.
Email: saifur@du.ac.bd
Abstract: Bangladesh has been a place of religious harmony for centuries. The vast displays of
cultural and religious properties on show here have been shaped over the last 5,000 years, following
numerous political regimes including those of the Pal (Buddhist), Sen (Hindu), Mughal (Muslim), and
British (Christian). The centuries-long peaceful coexistence of different religious groups and sects has
led Bangladesh to be a place of varied religious beliefs and practices, associated with the life cycle
(Rights de Passage: birth, maturity and death) of people from various ethnic communities living in
different geographical and ecological locations. The lives of the local people have also been
intertwined with various tangible and intangible sacred cultural spaces, where people from different
religions interact with each other and perform various activities related to their death. Different
religious and cultural groups have different interpretations about the sacred practices (stories, rites,
customs, beliefs, and rituals) associated with death and funeral. Thus, the objective of this paper is to
see the variations of death and funeral-rituals and practices among a number of specific ethnic and
religious communities of Bangladesh, from a broader global context and from the perspective of
anthropology of death.
1. Introduction send to ask for whom the bell tolls; it tolls for
thee” - John Donne.
“Any man‟s death diminishes me, because I The tradition of the rites of death and
am involved in mankind, and therefore never funerals are as old as the human race itself.
75
Vietnam Social Sciences, No. 5 (193) - 2019
76
Saifur Rashid
of all biological functions) and the funerals Rituals” or “Anthropology of Ancestors” [1],
(the disposition of death: burying or burning). [45]. The study of death ranges from classic
It is concerned with both the conceptual and texts to contemporary ethnographies. It ranges
organizational aspects, that is, what people from the exotic mortuary cannibalism in the
believe about death and the afterlife, as well Amazon (Beth Conklin), head-hunting in the
as what they actually do when faced with the Philippines (Rosaldo) and “death by cop” in
crisis of death. Two main methodological the United States to more familiar and
approaches used in anthropology in dealing contemporary concerns with nursing homes,
with the death and funerals are: ethnographic funeral parlors, undertaking, and forensic
and the comparative. anthropology [53]. Major works in
The ethnographic approach examines how anthropology on death ranges from the classic
each of these cultures copes with the demise writings on death, loss, mourning, and
of their family members and close associates, remembrance by Bronislaw Malinowski,
while the comparative approach tries to make Ernest Becker, Robert J Lifton, Johannes
sense of the enormous cultural variations in Fabian, Sigmund Freud, Ellen Badone,
issues such as the disposing of the corpse, the Margaret Lock, Godfrey Lienhardt, Evans-
Pritchard, James Frazer, Emile Durkheim,
expected behavior of the bereaved, and the
Marcel Mauss, Van Gennep, Robert Hertz,
ongoing relations between the living and their
Clifford Geertz and others [14], [18], [20],
dead [44]. Many comparative ethnographic
[21], [26], [29], [34], [35]. Anthropology of
studies have revealed that death rituals which
death primarily explores the inventions and
are seen as a defining aspect of human reinventions of death over time and space, the
culture are not always universal in practices. conceptualizations of death (friendly death,
For example, the widespread practice of crying death as taboo, death sorcery and pollution),
at a funeral is strongly discouraged among the rituals and celebrations of death (wakes, wake
Balinese. Nevertheless, anthropologists have games and amusements, death meals),
uncovered a number of key metaphors, which common deaths (the good death, sudden death)
help to make sense of the enormous diversity and uncommon deaths (suicide, homicide,
of mortuary rituals. The anthropology of genocide, voodoo death, death by sorcery),
death takes as its task to understand the traumatic deaths and deaths before their time.
phrase: “All humans die”, yet in every It also looks at the historical transformations of
culture, each dies in their own way‟ [1]. the meaning and timing of death, from the
middle ages to the late modern period.
77
Vietnam Social Sciences, No. 5 (193) - 2019
78
Saifur Rashid
79
Vietnam Social Sciences, No. 5 (193) - 2019
80
Saifur Rashid
81
Vietnam Social Sciences, No. 5 (193) - 2019
warfare, and various forms of accidents. one may speak of “celebrations of death”
When death is caused by sickness, there are [32]. In most cultures, the impact of the
two broad types: normal and unclean. The death is related directly to the social status
cause of death determines the rites and of the deceased. For example, in American
rituals that are to be performed. In many culture, people spend a smaller proportion
cultures, death is considered as a journey to of their resources on funerals, while the
the ancestral world [50]. Those undertaking Berawan or the Malagary spend a lot for
that crucial journey must be prepared for it. their death rituals.
This explains why often a dead person will Deaths of peoples with different age, sex
be buried with different objects to assist and position also have different impacts on
them, such as weapons, tools, food, drink, different cultures. The seminal work of the
and even money to be presented as a gift to great French sociologist, Emile Durkheim
the ancestral spirits. Almost in every (1995) shows how death and mourning
culture, before being buried, the corpse rituals in different cultures can help to
must be prepared by washing, shaving and reinforce the cohesiveness and core values
cutting the fingernails. The body may be of the social group [14], [17]. Walter
dressed as well. In some communities, the (1994) shows how some death of the most
body is buried within the compound; in fearful kind can draw people together‟ [52].
others, far enough away. The funeral rules In some cultures, death is seen as
also differ between communities. In some particularly disruptive when it strikes
societies, there are some strict prescriptions persons who are most relevant for the
on how a deceased person should be functional and moral activities of the social
handled [33]. order. The dramatic sudden death of high-
profile individuals (e.g., President
Kennedy, Princess Diana) may temporarily
6. Death and funeral rituals: Identity, recreate the solidarity of an “imagined
status and the politics community” of mourners who vicariously
participate in traditional ceremonies via
television and the Internet. In some
In different societies and cultures, people cultures, the death of a spouse often leads
have different beliefs and rituals related to to a long period of taboos and restricted
death. In many cultures, death rituals stand activity, while the death of a stranger, slave
at the center of their social life. There are or child goes almost unnoticed or arises no
some cultures, where people use expensive emotion, no occasion and ritual‟ [29, p.76].
and elaborate mortuary ritual as a way of In regions of high mortality, the death of an
demonstrating their status and power. Such infant who is not yet considered a “social
expenses of these societies sometimes person” may have no formal ritual or
become enormous financial burden for mourning [28]. Bereaved parents often
them. In some cultures, the atmosphere of experience their loss privately, without
death is not always sad or somber, but may ceremony, what has been called “death
even take on a festive atmosphere so that without weeping” [46]. The simple funerals
82
Saifur Rashid
of some hunter-gatherers, such as the Baka 7. Beliefs and rituals associated with
Pygmies of the Central African rain forest, death: The case of the ethnic communities
are notable exceptions to the widespread of Bangladesh
pattern of elaborate and complex mortuary
rituals [6]. Thus, a central task for both Bangladesh as a country of cultural, ethnic,
sociologists and anthropologists is to religious and language diversities, has
explore how death in one hand can threaten about160 million people with more than 40
the basis of society or, on the other hand ethnic communities belonging to Islam,
can enhance its solidarity. According to Hinduism, Christianity, Buddhism, animism
Blauner, “the impact of mortality is very and tribal believe systems. Islam is the
much dependent on the age and social official religion of Bangladesh and is
situation of those who die. The extent of practiced by some 88-90% percent of the
the social vacuum created as a consequence country's inhabitants. The second largest
of death thus depends upon how deeply the religious group is the Hindu (9-12%) who
deceased has been engaged in the activities belongs to different caste groups (Brahman,
of the family and society” [51, pp.378- Khatrya, Baishya, and Sudra). Followed by
394]. In modern society, death is Hindu, other religious groups are Buddhists
characteristically a phenomenon of the old (making up of 0.5-1%) the followers of the
who have retired from work, have Theravada school of Buddhism and mostly
completed parental tasks, and are living in reside in the Chittagong Hill Tracts, and the
relative isolation. Their death, therefore, Christians who makes up another 0.5-1% of
does not interrupt the business of life. In Bangladesh‟s population and mostly belong
primitive society, relatively more people to the Roman Catholic Church. Another
die in the middle years, necessitating the prominent church is the Church of
reallocation of socially essential roles and Bangladesh, a united church formed by
rights in an institutionalized manner. several protestant churches. Beside these,
Different societies have different facets there is a small group of Animists, who
for collectively dealing with death: the makes up to 0.1%.
funeral, the memorial, and the wake. In The majority of the Muslim populations
some societies, funeral is often religious in of this country are the Sunni, whilst small
nature, where prayers are uttered and groups are - Shia, and Ahmadiyya. The
hymns are sung, and the dead body is small ethnic communities (indigenous/
buried or ashes entombed. The memorial is adivasi/ tribal) who constitute about 1 per
reflective, where the dead person's family, cent of its total population belong to
friends, and associates (may be enemies) different religions and comprise a very
come together to say prayers, recall important part of the country‟s religious and
experiences with the deceased, and cultural heritage. Most of these
generally speak well of the person who is communities (ethnic minorities) live in the
gone. In some memorials, living people greater Rajshahi, Chittagong, Sylhet and
celebrate the life of the dead through party Mymensingh region. A few live in some
by getting drunk and having fun. other districts of Bangladesh. In terms of
83
Vietnam Social Sciences, No. 5 (193) - 2019
Name of Present Idea about Main Death Ritual Ritual Main festival/
Communities Religion death related to ritual
(Past deceased
religion) body
Santals Christianity The deceased Celebrates (Kutum) Cremated/ Vandem
(Animism person will go Buchi Shime Buried
based on to heaven in (chicken Festival)
spirit/ the afterlife and chants mantra
Hinduism) in the deceased
name on the
eighth day of
his/her death
Munda Sanatan/ Dead person Eldest son of the Cremated/ Kankathi
Converted needs money deceased performs Buried
Christian to cross Ashchua ritual,
(Sarnaism: different ports where he shaves
folk form of afterlife. off his hair and
of keeps distance
Hinduism) from other people
Lahara Hinduism Cremation Performs Hobisha Cremated/ Kathura (after
provides dead for first 13 days Buried 13 days)
person with
full blessing
Bhumijo Sanatan/ In cases of Collects the Cremated/ Shraddoho
84
Saifur Rashid
85
Vietnam Social Sciences, No. 5 (193) - 2019
86
Saifur Rashid
Case 1: Santal (Christian/ Sanatani, approx. Bhumij people generally burn the dead
200,000 in number) body. According to Bhumij custom, when
When someone dies in the Santal someone dies, they wash the dead body
community, the news is first given to the first. Then, they take the body to the
local boatman or Haram. The boatman, cemetery while singing hymns together.
then, spread the news around with the help The eldest son of the deceased touches fire
of an informer locally known as Goddeth. on his/her face. A Brahman priest helps in
Upon hearing the news, important villagers performing the burning ritual. When the
come to the deceased‟s home and organise body is burnt, they collect the unburned
to notify his or her relatives. body parts of the dead person and his/ her
The general custom for Santals is to burn family members quickly put the body parts
the deceased‟s body. But, now a day, Santals in a bamboo tube and bury it under a Tulsi
bury the body because of the scarcity and (a sacred tree in Hindu religion) tree.
high cost of wood. Santal‟s funeral ritual According to Bhumij custom, the unburned
begins by washing the dead body and then body parts are required to be thrown in the
covering it with a white sheet. Then, the Ganga River. But that is not always
relatives of the dead person soak, as much immediately possible. So, the family
money they can afford, in oil mixed with members temporarily bury the remains under
turmeric; and they tie those with the white a Tulsi tree. Families, which will never be
sheet. They believe that the deceased person able to toss the remains in the Ganga River,
will go to heaven in the afterlife and will throw the remains in any river or deposit
need these things. Santals use a bamboo
them on the Chandranath hill in Chittagong.
made platform to carry the dead body in the
The family and close relatives of the
burial ground and throw popped rice along
deceased person continue their mourning
the way to the burial ground.
for 11 days. During this period, they have to
The Santals celebrate (Kutum) Buchi
stay barefooted and they can only take seat
Shime (Chicken festival) and chant mantra
on a wooden base. They, also, have to sleep
in the deceased name on the eighth day of
on the floor and have to eat food, prepared
his/her death. This proves that Santals
in their own home, which are cooked
believe in the afterlife. At present, Santals
also hold a new celebration in the without any spices or onion or garlic. This
deceased‟s name called Vandan. Here, the food is known as Habishanna.
family of the dead person feed others in the Although traditionally Bhumij people burn
name of the dead. This celebration can be their dead, they bury dead children under the
held after 6 months or even after 10 years age of 6 months. Now a day, they are
following the event of death. But, it is following the custom of burying the dead
mandatory to be done. Otherwise, the people of their community. But in cases of
deceased won‟t find peace in the afterlife. abnormal deaths, they still burn the body.
Case 2: Bhumij (Sanatani/Nature Worship/ Case 3: Munda (Animistic/ Sanatani/
Hinduism, 15,000 approx. in number) Christainity, 90,000 approx. in number)
87
Vietnam Social Sciences, No. 5 (193) - 2019
Munda people both bury and burn their Polau rice (scented) to the guests depending
dead. But, now a day, they prefer burying on the family‟s economic ability.
the dead body because they can‟t afford the Case 4: Kshayriyas (A caste in Hinduism)
cost of burning the body. They call their According to Kshatriyas, the cremation
burial grounds Samman. Immediately after takes place within 24 hours after death. The
the death of a person, they carry the dead body of the dead person has to be washed
body out of the house. They wash the dead by family members and closed friends
body with soap and then cover it with a while the head of the dead body should be
white cloth. Then, they lay the body on a faced southward. A lighted oil lamp and a
bamboo made carrier and wrap the body picture (if possible) of the deceased‟s
with a mat. They call this process giving favorite deity need to be kept in front of the
Thir. Afterwards, they respectfully carry the deceased‟s head. Traditionally, the body is
body to the burial ground. They place some washed with water in a mixture of milk,
coins with the dead body, as they think this ghee (clarified butter), yogurt and honey.
will come in handy when the dead person Mantras should be recited during washing.
needs to cross different ports of afterlife. After the body is cleaned properly, the big
Munda people deliver food for the dead toes should be tied together, the hands
person till seven days after death. Also, the should be placed palm-to-palm in a position
eldest son of the dead person is the first one of prayer, and the body should be shrouded
to lay soil on the grave. He has to lay the in a plain white clothes.
soil from behind and needs to keep his back Before cremation, “Vibuti” (ash) or
on the grave. Then, everyone else lays soil “chandan” (sandalwood) is needed to be
on the grave. Members of the deceased‟s applied to the forehead of a man, and
family do not cook anything on that day and turmeric should be applied to the forehead
they are forbidden to eat anything of a woman. A mala (garland of flowers) is
(especially rice and water). The eldest son placed around the neck, and holy herbs
of the deceased has to perform a ritual should be placed in the casket. Martras are
called Ashchua. He has to shave off his hair chanted to pacify and to purify the soul.
and keep his distance from other people. He After that, “Pinda” (rice balls) are placed
also has to eat Atap rice. After eight days a near the casket of the dead. Then the casket
program, which Mundas refer to as is removed for cremation. Traditionally, all
Kankathi, is held where the deceased family Hindus except babies, children, and saints
feeds their neighbors and relatives. Within are cremated.
1 to 3 years of a person‟s death, his/her After the cremation, the Korta/
family arranges a feast. On this day, they Kormodhari (first son, husband or senior
dig a hole on their yard and sacrifice a one) returns to the crematory and collects
black cock upon the hole. They have to be the ashes. Traditionally, the ashes should be
very careful not to spill any blood outside immersed in water. The Korta has to take
the hole. Then, they feed that cock meat to vegetables with meals and no meats/ fishes
everyone with rice. Sometime, they feed are allowed; which is for transforming to
88
Saifur Rashid
regular life from mourning in a gradual well-wishers to pass on their respects and
process and also a sign of sacrifice for the condolences. The Ahmadi Muslims of the
dead soul‟s peace. A ritual ceremony is community gather to offer their collective
held on the third, fifth, seventh, or ninth prayers for the forgiveness of the dead. This
day. During the time after death, the prayer has been generally termed as the
family of the deceased will stay at home Salat al-Janaja (Janaja prayer). In some
and receive visitors, though mourning circumstances, the prayer can be performed
rituals may differ depending on the without keeping the corpse in front of the
community and it occurs for 12 days. prayer hall. This is known as “Gayebana
Throughout the period of mourning, the
Janaja”. Both male and female members of
rite of “preta-karma” is performed. A plate
Ahmadiyya Muslim community can take
of the food is placed in front of the
part in “Janaja Prayer”.
deceased‟s photo. Afterward, the plate is
taken outside to a vacant place. On the The deceased is then taken for burial (al-
13th day, the home is cleaned and Dafin). The grave should be aligned
Shraddho takes place. People have to taste perpendicular to the Qibla (i.e. Mecca). The
Amish food (meats or fishes). Visitors are body is placed in the grave without a
expected to bring fruits and sweets. casket, lying on its right side, and facing the
Case 5: Death Rituals of Ahmadiyya Qibla. Grave markers should be raised only
Muslim Community (a small sect of up to a maximum of 30cm (12 in) above the
Muslim Community ground. Thus Grave markers are simple,
because outwardly lavish displays are
In Ahmadiyya community, the corpse is
discouraged in Islam. Many times graves
washed to cleanse physically, as a part of
may even be unmarked, or marked only
the Islamic Sharia. This should occur as
with a simple wreath. However, it is
soon as possible after death, preferably
becoming more common for family
within hours. The “washers” are commonly members to erect grave monuments.
adult members of the immediate family and
The orthodoxy expects those present to
of the same gender as the deceased. In the
symbolically pour three handfuls of soil
case of violent death, or accident where the
into the grave while reciting a Quranic
deceased has suffered trauma or mutilation,
verse in Arabic meaning "We created you
morgue facilities mend the body and wrap it from it, and return you into it, and from it
in a shroud to minimize fluid leakage prior We will raise you a second time". The
to surrendering it to mourners for washing. corpse is then fully buried by the
The corpse is wrapped in a simple plain gravediggers, who may stamp or pat down
cloth (the kafan). This is done to respect the the grave to shape. After the burial, the
dignity and privacy of the deceased with the gathered people pay their respects to the
family present. Men use only three pieces dead, collectively pray for the forgiveness
of cloth and women five pieces of cloth to of the dead. This collective prayer is the last
serve as the shroud. The deceased may be formal collective prayer for the dead.
kept in this state for several hours, allowing Unlike Sunni Muslim in Bangladesh,
89
Vietnam Social Sciences, No. 5 (193) - 2019
90
Saifur Rashid
[13] Emile Durkheim (1995), The Elementary Forms [28] Robert Hertz (1960), “A Contribution to the
of the Religious Life, Free Press, New York. Study of the Collective Representation of
[14] Émile Durkheim (1952), Suicide: A Study in Death”, Death and the Right Hand, R.
Sociology, Routledge & Kegan Paul, London. Needham, Aberdeen.
[15] Émile Durkheim (1915), The Elementary [29] Robert Hertz (1960), "A Contribution to the
Forms of the Religious Life, George Allen & Study of the Collective Representation of
Unwin, London. Death", Death and the Right Hand, translated
[16] Émile Durkheim (1951), “The Social Element by Rodney and Claudia Needham, Free Press,
of Suicide”, Suicide: A Study in Sociology, Glencoe, IL.
pp.297-325. [30] George C. Homans (1941), "Anxiety and
[17] James George Frazer (1968), The Belief in Ritual: The Theories of Malinowski and
Immortality and the Worship of the Dead, Radcliffe-Brown", American Anthropologist,
Dawsons, London. Vol. 18, pp.164-172.
[18] James George Frazer (1933), The Fear of Dead in [31] Richard Huntington and Peter Metcalf (1991),
Primitive Religion, Biblio & Tannan, New York. Celebrations of Death: The Anthropology of
[19] Sigmund Freud (1989), “Mourning and Mortuary Ritual, 2nd edition, Cambridge
Melancholia”, The Freud Reader, Norton, New University Press, Cambridge.
York. [32] A. L. Kroeber (1927), “Disposal of the Dead”,
[20] Arnold van Gennep (1960), The Rites of Passage, American Anthropologist, Vol. 29, No. 3,
The University of Chicago Press, Chicago. pp.308-315.
[21] Arnoldvan, Gennep (1960), “Funerals”, The [33] Robert J. Lifton, (1979), The Broken Connection:
Rites of Passage, pp.146-165. On Death and the Continuity of Life, American
[22] Jack Goody (1962), Death, Property and the Psychiatric Press, Washington DC.
Ancestors: A Study of the Mortuary Customs of [34] Bronislaw Malinowski (1972), "The Role of
the Lo Dagaa of West Africa, Tavistock, London. Magic and Religion", Reader in Comparative
[23] Jack Goody (1977), “Against Ritual: Loosely Religion: An Anthropological Approach, Harper
Structured Thoughts on a Loosely Defined and Row, New York.
Topic”, Secular Ritual, Amsterdam. [35] Bronislaw Malinowski (1948), Magic, Science
[24] Barney G. Glaser and Anselm L. Strauss (1965), and Religion, Faber and West, London.
Awareness of Dying, Aldine, Chicago. [36] Bronislaw Malinowski (2008), Baloma: The
[25] Clifford Geertz (1976), The Religion of Java, Spirits of the Dead in the Trobri and Islands,
The Chicago University Press, Chicago. Forgotten Books Series, London.
[26] Clifford Geertz (1973), The Interpretation of [37] Bronislaw Malinowski (1949), “Death and the
Cultures, Basic Books, New York. Reintegration of the Group”, Magic Science
[27] H. Humphreys and H. King (eds.) (1981), and Religion, pp.29-34
Mortality and Immortality: The Anthropology and [38] Peter Metcalfand Richard Huntington (1991),
Archeology of Death, Academic Press, London. Celebrations of Death: The Anthropology of
91
Vietnam Social Sciences, No. 5 (193) - 2019
Mortuary Ritual, 2nd revised eds., Cambridge [47] Edward Burnett Tylor (1903), Primitive Culture,
University Press, Cambridge. John Murray, London.
[39] Peter Metcalf (1981), "Meaning and [48] Edward Burnett Tylor (1970), Religion in
Materialism: The Ritual Economy of Death", Primitive Culture, Peter Smith, Gloucester.
MAN, 16, pp.563-578.
[49] Victor Turner (1969), The Ritual Process,
[40] Jonathan P. Parry (1994), Death in Banaras,
Aldine, Chicago.
Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
[50] James Woodburn (1982), “Social Dimensions of
[41] Alfred R. Radcliffe-Brown (1952), Structure
and Function in Primitive Society, Free Press. Death in Four African Hunting and Gathering
Societies”, Death and the Regeneration of Life,
[42] Alfred R. Radcliffe-Brown (2014), Taboo,
Cambridge University Press. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge,
92