Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
IN THE EARLY 1970s, the first doctoral level clinical phar- medication cost per day, and outpatient costs, including
macist was hired by the Kansas City General Hospital outpatient medical cost, were among the kinds of in-
(now called Truman Medical Center-West) to assist the formation collected for these monthly reports. In an ef-
medical staff in developing sound therapeutic programs fort to identify the docent clinical pharmacist's specific
for the management of disease. Dr. Edward J. Twin was contribution to these cost figures in the inpatient area,
the executive medical director for the Kansas City the following study was designed, using an infectious
General Hospital and for the affiliate Jackson County disease model.
Hospital (now called Truman Medical Center-East). Ac- The purpose of this two-phase, retrospective study
cording to Twin, these doctors of pharmacy were as- was to determine the influence of the clinical phar-
signed to various medical teams (called docent teams) macists on the management of streptococcal
and were responsible for drug therapy on their respec- (pneumococcal) pneumonia. Streptococcal pneumonia
tive units.' They were called docent clinical pharmacists was chosen as the model disease state for several
and were accountable for the selection of therapy ac- reasons: it has a 5-10 percent per year incidence of mor-
cording to considerations of efficacy, safety, and cost. tality in the U.S.; there is a recognized problem with
Numerous programs were developed to evaluate the inappropriate antibiotic utilization;' use of antibiotics
quality of care provided by these multidisciplinary do- is associated with tremendous expense (often consum-
cent teams. For example, under the direction of the ing from Y4 to Y3 or more of the hospital pharmacy's
Department of Medicine, a multidisciplinary commit- budget); and well-documented standards for ap-
tee was charged with the responsibility of developing propriate drug therapy for this disease have been
audit criteria for the common diseases seen at the two published in the medical literature. 3 Additionally, the
institutions. These audits provided the objective indices emergence of antibiotic-resistant bacteria has been
for evaluating the quality of patient care on the in- reported at numerous institutions.':" Finally, the Joint
dividual units. Additionally, data were collected on a Commission on Accreditation of Hospitals has required
monthly basis to evaluate the activities of the various the development of formal programs to review antibiotic
units by examining the efficiency with which hospital usage in hospitalized patients. For these reasons, the
personnel, facilities, and resources were utilized in review of an infectious disease provided an optimal
providing patient care. Inpatient costs, including model for evaluating the contribution of the docent
clinical pharmacist to an area of patient care that re-
JOEL O. COVINSKY, Pharm.D., is Associate Professor and quired further study.
Director of Clinical Pharmacology Program, Schools
of Medicine and Pharmacy, University of Missouri-
Kansas City, and Docent Clinical Pharmacist, Clinical Methods
Pharmacology Section, Truman Medical Center;
STEPHEN C. HAMBURGER, M.D., is Associate Professor Truman Medical Center consists of two hospitals,
and Vice-Chairman, Department of Medicine, School Truman Medical Center-West (TMC-W) and Truman
of Medicine; KIM L. KELLY, Pharm.D., atthetimeofthis Medical Center-East (TMC-E). Since 1971, there have
study, was Associate Professor, Schools of Medicine been full-time docent clinical pharmacists at TMC-W.
and Pharmacy, University of Missouri-Kansas City, and TMC-E did not have a clinical pharmacist until 1974.
Docent Clinical Pharmacist, Clinical Pharmacology Sec- Thus, this study was divided into two parts: a two-year
tion, Truman Medical Center; he is now Director of
Professional Education for Syva Company, and Clinical study of the treatment of streptococcal pneumonia at
Professor of Medicine at the University of Missouri TMC-W and TMC-E prior to 1974, and a two-year
School of Medicine. BONNIE PASTEWSKI, Pharm.D., is study of the treatment of streptococcal pneumonia at
Assistant Professor of Clinical Pharmacy, Philadelphia TMC-E after a clinical pharmacist was hired.
College of Pharmacy and Science; NANCY ROBERTSON, The Medical Records Department retrieved the
Pharm.D., is Assistant Professor of Clinical Pharmacy, records of all patients admitted at either TMC-W or
College of Pharmacy, Medical University of South TMC-E between June 1972 and June 1974 who had a
Carolina; ROGER ESKRIDGE, Pharm.D., is Assistant primary diagnosis of streptococcal pneumonia. In ad-
Director of Pharmacy Services, Trinity Lutheran dition, the Medical Records Department at TMC-E
Hospital, Kansas City; GLEN PARK, Pharm.D., at the retrieved the charts of all patients admitted with a
time of this study, was Clinical Pharmacist, Department
of Pharmacy Services, University Hospitals of primary diagnosis of streptococcal pneumonia between
Cleveland; he is now a faculty member at the Universi- June 1975 and June 1977. To be included in this study,
ty of Iowa; EDWARD J. TWIN, M.D., is Professor and all patients had to meet the Department of Medicine
Senior Docent, School of Medicine, University of audit criteria for the diagnosis of streptococcal
Missouri-Kansas City, Kansas City, MO. pneumonia. They could not have (1) postoperative
jections or medications administered by intravenous Raw Cost of 7.83 6.80 2.13 28.26
Additive S.D. 9.39 5.0.5.29 S.D. 4.25 S.D. 36.12
push, and $0.60 for all oral medications. The results of
this study reflect the system currently used to determine Total Raw Cost 17.0 14.11 37.41 408.69
S.D. 17.71 5.0.7.73 5.0.65.80 S.D. 592.94 •
patient medication charges. Raw Cost of 1.24 1.46 1.06 8.11
Statistical comparisons were made between TMC- Drug Per Day S.D. 1.03 5.0.0.99 S.D. 0.87 S.D. 7.51 •
E, both with and without physician exposure to a clinical
pharmacist, and TMC-W.
Total Raw Cost
Per Day S.D.
2.38
2.11
280
5.0.2.13
6.47
5.0.11.64 5.0
32.63
3961
.
Patient 149.60 112.69 41.50 520.35
The Mann-Whitney U test and the Kruskal- Wallis Charge S.D. 159.81 5.0.94.36 5.0.72.70 S.D. 600.13 •
test were utilized to compare, statistically, the costs
calculated in this study. The calculations were per- • Statistically significant with P < 0.05 (Kruskal Wallis test)
588
Table 2. Comparison of TMC-W with TMC-E Table 3. Comparison of TMC-W with Subgroup
before Hiring a Clinical Pharmacist at TMC-E with No Exposure to the
Docent Clinical Pharmacist
TMC-W TMC-East
Pharm.D No Pharm 0 TMC-E with
TMC-W No Pharm D
Pharm 0 Education
n 12 12
12 8
length of Stay 8.33 9.25
5.0.4.54 5.0.9.16 length of Stay 8.33 12.25
S.D. 4.54 S.D. 9.96
Raw Drug Cost 9.23 79.26
5.0.9.60 S.D. 131.55
Raw Drug Cost 9.23 116.43
Raw Cost for 7.83 19.55 S.D. 9.60 5.0.149.53*
Additive 5.0.9.39 5.0.31.63
Raw Cost for 7.83 28.26
Additive S.D. 9.39 S.D. 36.12
Total Raw Cost 17.02 284.10
S.D. 17.71 5.0.505.84
Total Raw Cost 17.02 408.69
Raw Cost of 1.24 5.76 5.0.17.71 S.D. 592.94 *
Drug Per Day S.D. 1.03 S.D. 6.94 *
Raw Cost of 1.24 8.11
Drug Per Day S.D. 1.03 S.D. 7.51 *
Total Raw Cost 2.38 23.91
Per Day 5.0 2.11 S.D. 34.66
Total Raw Cost 2.38 32.63
Per Day S.D. 2.11 S.D. 39.61 *
Patient Charge 149.60 361.57
S.D. 159.81 5.0.577.84
Patient Charge 149.60 520.35
5.0.159.81 5.0.600.13 *
• Statistically significant with Pe 0.05 (Mann Whitney U test)
..
• StatIstIcally SIgnifIcant wIth peO.05 (Mann WhItney U test)
590
TABLE OF CONTENTS
ABSTRACT I. General Principles - Therapeutic Use
This two-phase retrospective study was designed to evaluate 2. General Principles - Adverse Effects
the impact of the clinical pharmacist on prescribing practice 3. Antipsychotics
of physicians in an internal medicine service. Streptococcal 4. Antidepressants
(pneumococcal) pneumonia was chosen as the model disease 5. lithium
state. The drug of choice was used more frequently and 6. Antianxiety Agents
there was a statistically significant difference in raw cost 7. Hypnotics
of antibiotic, total cost for antibiotic administration, daily 8. Analgesics
raw cost for antibiotics; total raw cost for antibiotic adminis- 9. Agents for Treating Extrapyramidal Side Effects
tration, and patient charges when physicians were exposed to 10. Disulfiram
the clinical pharmacists' influence. I I. Drug Interactions
j 2. Management and Treatment of Drug Overdosage
13. Management of Withdrawal
References 14. Amy tal interview
15. Electroconvulsive Therapy
I. Dimond EG. The academic plan for the school of medicine.
16. Patient Instructions
Kansas City: University of Missouri-Kansas City, 1977.
2. Counts GW. Review and control of antimicrobial usage in 204 pages, soft cover, 41f2 x 6 3k inches.
hospitalized patients. A recommended collaborative approach. JAMA Send check, money order or credit card number
1977;238:2170-4. (MasterCard or Visa) to:
3. Simmons HE, Stolly PD. This is medical progress? Trends and
consequences of antibiotic use in the United States. JAMA HARVEY WHITNEY BOOKS PRICE $9.50
1974;227: 1023-8. . (plushandling and postage
P.O. BOX 42442 If not prepaid)
4. Sherris JC, The epidemiologyof drug resistance. In: Brachman Prepayment IS required
PS, Eickhoff TC, eds. Proceedings of the International Conference CINCINNATI, OH 45242 for individual orders.
of Nosocomial Infections. Baltimore: WaverlyPress, Inc., 1971: 50-60.
5. The medical letter on drugs and therapeutics. Handbook on
antimicrobial therapy. New Rochelle,NY: MedicalLetter, Inc. Revised Send _ _ copies at $9.S0 each of PSYCHOTROPIC DRUG
edition, 1976. HANDBOOK to:
6. Borrows SN. Anuria and acute tubular necrosis associated with Name
gentamicin and cephalothin. JAMA 1972;222:1546-7.
7. Fillastre lP, Laumonier R, et al. Acute renal failure associated Address _
with combined gentamicin and cephalothin therapy. Br Med J
1973;2:396.
8. Fanning WL, Gump 0, lick H. Gentamicin and cephalothin
associated rises in blood urea nitrogen. Antimicrob Agents Chemother City
1976;10:80-3. State/Country Z,p _
9. Luft FC, Patel V, Yum MN, Kleit SA. Nephrotoxicity of
cephalosporin-gentamicin combinations in rats. Antimicrob Agents o payment enclosed: 0 please bill 0 VISA D MasterCard
Chemother 1976;9:831-9. Exp. date Signature
10. Covinsky 10. The role of the clinical pharmacist in medical Acct.
education. J Clin Pharmacol 1981;21:198-200. No.