Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
F
Atlanta Manufacturing
irst of all, industry has gained another Bateman Engineered Technologies
Bauer a Division of Hudaco Transmission
40 graduates of the Diploma in the
BMG (Bearing Man Group)
Design and Operation of Belt Convey- Bearings International
ors, thanks to the efforts of Graham Belt Reco RSA
Shortt and the rest of the CMA Qualifications Bonfiglioli Power Transmissions
organising team, and of course, thanks to Bosworth A Division of Hudaco Trading
the candidates own hard work in achieving Brelko Conveyor Products
a successful result in the examination. CKIT Conveyor Engineers
Continental Crushing & Conveying
The CMA Belting and Belt Splicing Working Conveyor Watch
Group completed its task when SABS published CMG Electric Motors South Africa
three new national standards in belt splicing: CPM Engineering
CT Systems
SANS 484 parts 1 and 2, SANS 485 and
David Brown Gear Industries
SANS 486 were all issued in 2009. With Delras Engineering
these standards now in place, belt splicing DRA Mineral Projects
Simon Curry construction companies are able to apply for Dunlop Belting Products
the SABS mark of accreditation and splice Dymot Engineering Company
construction training may be regulated. This ELB Engineering Services
is the next step in which the CMA intends to make Facet Engineering
Fenner Conveyor Belting (South Africa)
a big impact in 2010.
Flexible Steel Lacing SA
This is the next step in which the CMA intends to make Hansen Transmissions SA
Hosch - Fördertechnik (SA)
a big impact in 2010
M & J Engineering
Martin Engineering
In 2009, the CMA Handbook Working Group made Melco Conveyor Equipment
great strides in gathering material for the CMA Moret Mining
Handbook and when assigning tasks to everyone MS Conveyor Pulleys SA
involved, made a firm resolution that 2010 is to be Nepean Conveyors
the year in which it is to be published. The Hand- OE Bearings
book is being written specifically for South African Osborn Engineered Products SA
Read Swartman & Voigt
conditions – another first for our industry!
Rema Tip Top South Africa
Events Renold Crofts
The Calendar of CMA events in 2010 are as fol- Roymec
RSV ENCO Consulting
lows:
Sandvik Materials Handling SA
Members Meetings: 3 February, 14 April, 9 June, Schaeffler South Africa
13 October, all on Wednesdays at Bryanston Secrivest
Country Club. Senet
Annual Golf Day: Wednesday 17 February at Benoni SET Agencies
Country Club. SEW Eurodrive
Annual Dinner: Wednesday 19 May at Bryanston Shaft Engineering
Shaw Almex Africa
Country Club. Siemens Southern Africa
Please check the website www.cmasa.co.za regularly SKF South Africa
for information on CMA activities. Technique Avant Garde
ThyssenKrupp Materials Handling
All that remains is for me to wish each and every Transmission Components
one of you a happy, healthy, successful and pros- Unitek Engineers
perous New Year. Veyance Technologies Africa
Voith Turbo
Simon Curry Zest Electric Motors
Chairman
BULK HANDLING TODAY Jan 2010
COVER STORY
Reducing Risks
The concept of Total Cost of Ownership can be traced as far back as Napoleon’s time when engineers began to
pay close attention to issues like the effectiveness of cannons, how easily they were moved and repaired, and
how long they lasted in active service. In modern times, TCO (total cost of ownership) analysis was popularised
by the IT industry to determine the financial impact of deploying information technology products over their
lifecycle.
T
full service offering now comes from
oday there are a number of methodolo- Rema Tip Top.
gies and software packages to apply TCO
“We now supply the belting, splice it and install it
calculations to the business plan of vari-
together with our wide range of conveyor products
ous industry sectors. However, it basically
that make up a conveyor system,” explains Dries.
comes down to determining the additional costs
“When it comes to equipment we don’t manufacture
that must be added to the initial purchase price
ourselves, such as conveyor mechanicals, a number
of an item in order to calculate the total cost of
of equipment partners supply us so we can offer
ownership.
a full service. In terms of maintenance, however,
The end-user wins all the way because nobody we service all the equipment around the conveyor
understands a conveyor systems and all the equipment systems ourselves.”
around it better than us Products
Rema manufactures a wide range of product in-
South Africa cluding rubber linings, coatings, wear protection,
Rema Tip Top is an international company that corrosion protection, bonding systems, belt cleaning
has practiced TCO principles for many years across systems and vulcanising products. “Having such
the world and they’re now rolling out a model in a wide range of products which now includes all
South Africa specifically developed for the con- belting products and associated services, the end-
veyor industry. “Bulk Handling Today” speaks to user wins all the way because nobody understands
Managing Director Rema Tip Top South Africa, a conveyor systems and all the equipment around
Thorsten Wach. “Although Rema Tip Top has it better than us,” says Thorsten. “Also, we have
been doing this in Europe for many years, it is a worldwide resources to tap into within the group
relatively new development for the local conveyor to solve any eventuality that may arise around a
market,” he says. conveyor system.”
“We tapped into many TCO models applicable to Rema Tip Top’s dedicated TCO model can be
a diverse cross-section of industry to adapt and tailored to any of the various service applications,
Advantages
The advantages for the conveyor owner are numer-
ous, the main one being a significant reduction
in costly unexpected breakdowns due to poor or
neglected maintenance. “Having service staff on
site reduces the chances of an unexpected belt tear,
for example, because they have the experience to
notice fatigue in other components that may lead
to a belt failure,” says Thorsten in conclusion.
“Unlike mining staff, we’re always in touch with
new conveyor technology as it develops which is a
major advantage for the owner. We constantly bring
new technology, standards and freshly-trained staff
right onto his doorstep as part of our service. Not
only do the customers benefit but we also help to
set standards and maintain quality service levels
in the conveyor industry in general.”
Juan Slabbert, Tel: (011) 813-2222, Email: juan.slabbert@
rematiptop.co.za
Service is Key
Earthmoving equipment hire and the purchasing of notably hydraulic hammers. Then in 2006, they
second-hand machines has picked up. In most instances, a secured the sole dealership for Southern Africa for
good second-hand machine can save on capital and still get the Komac brand of hydraulic hammers and attach-
the job done. ments. Komac, based in Korea, is a manufacturer
of hydraulic breakers and attachments.
“
Bulk Handling Today” speaks to Vaughan Ellis, Vaughan explains, “We’re particularly proud that
owner of Maximum Plant and Equipment. By we are a featured supplier of quality plant and ma-
way of background, Vaughan explains that chinery to many blue chip South African organisa-
Maximum started operations in 1997 with tions in the earthmoving, mining and construction
the sales and marketing of quality used equipment. industry. Our team of qualified staff attends to any
In 2005, they branched into the plant hire market mechanical or servicing queries that customers
specialising in excavators and attachments, most may require. We are small enough to care, yet big
enough to deliver. And our service ethos is
apparent throughout the company.
Much potential
“We offer a full range of tracked excavators
from 5 tonne through to 50 tonne with
trenching buckets, ripper buckets, general
purpose buckets and hammers. Backhoe
loaders come with trenching buckets, stan-
dard buckets and hammers. We believe that
our rates, service, delivery and back up are
second to none in the market which is why
our clients return time and time again.
There are some challenges, for
example, getting finance for the
machines
“On the attachment side we have been very
successful in the scrap metal and timber
industries with our brackets and grabs. Al-
though we are still small in this field, there is
a lot of potential in this market and because
we have a quality product, we are sure to
grow,” says Vaughan optimistically.
More lenient
We ask him if second-hand equipment sales
have picked up in the current economic
climate? “There is a marked increase in the
rental side and the purchasing of second-
hand machines. However, there are some
challenges, for example, getting finance for
the machines,” he says.
“This has been one of the biggest problems
but it appears that the banks are getting
a bit more lenient. To assist, we have put
together quite a few hire to purchase con-
tracts for customers.”
Having said that, the company has expe-
rienced five years of growth even in these
times. “Because we are so niche, especially
in the attachment market but also because
we have diversified, the economy has actu-
ally been quite kind to us. I do think that
2010 is going to be a lot better that 2009 which He goes on to says that they are still doing well
is something to look forward to,” Vaughan adds. mainly because they have a few blue chip clients
who have supported them through the year.
I believe this is where the men separate from the boys. “We have clients like Rumdel Cape, Quarry Cats
On the second-hand equipment side we tend to stick to (Group 5) and Fraser Alexander Bulk Mech. Another
what we know of our big clients is Protech Khuthele who has
placed a lot of business our way.”
Vaughan is a big believer in back up and
service. “I believe this is where the men
separate from the boys. On the second-
hand equipment side we tend to stick to
what we know and only sell machines that
we know we can service. All the machines
have warranties.”
For the future
Vaughan concludes by saying that they have
plans for expanding their rental fleet “We
would like to gain a bigger market share on
the attachment side and, otherwise, keep
on doing what we have been doing so far.
If it ain’t broke, don’t fix it!”
Vaughan Ellis, Owner, Maximum Plant and Equip-
ment, Tel: (011) 464-0930/1, Fax: 086-504-7119,
Email: info@maximumplant.co.za, Website: www.
maximumplant.co.za
W
success to its strong culture of
e speak to Morné Booij-Liewes, ‘support first and sale second’.
Communications Officer for Babcock “You must ensure your clients receive the highest
Equipment. level of technical and aftermarket support, and
He explains that the past year has only when this is achieved do we earn the right to
been a tough one but one with several highlights sell them equipment.”
including the local launch of the Volvo Road A hands-on team of skilled and experienced prod-
Machinery line as well as the delivery of the first uct specialists and technicians provide a 24 hour
L350F wheeled loaders, the biggest in the Volvo product support and technical information service.
product range. “We also have comprehensively equipped workshops
“The current market conditions are the toughest we throughout our branch network. Our product support
have yet seen, but in spite of many of our competitors services includes technical training, application
suffering record losses, Babcock Equipment has, analysis, operator training and warranty support.
for the trading year to date, remained in positive A centralised warehouse provides a personalised
figures. With the large population of Volvo machines, parts service and availability at first pick’s in
we have been able to harvest greater volumes of excess of 90%. We also run a very successful in-
house apprentice diesel earthmoving technician
programme and currently have 54 apprentices
Extremely conservative lending criteria by banks has
undergoing training,” says Morné.“
adversely impacted on equipment sales
Leading brands
“The company represents some of the lead-
ing brands in the industry including Volvo
Construction Equipment, Winget and Ponsse.
Babcock Equipment has sold more than
5000 Volvo CE units since being awarded
the exclusive Volvo CE distributorship for
South Africa, Namibia, Botswana, Zambia,
Swaziland, Lesotho, and most recently, Mo-
zambique. The company has also, during
the almost 10 years it has represented the
Volvo CE brand, been recognised as Top
Dealer for the International Region on three
occasions in addition to winning several
awards for sales success and after-market
service excellence.
Says Morné, “However we have definitely
been affected by the economy. The contin-
Be Legal, be Safe…
Any company that lifts goods on its prem-
ises should have a safe lifting programme
in place, not only to comply with the ba-
sic legal requirements, but also to ensure
control over the safety of the working
environment of their people. In addition
to lifting, lowering and stacking goods
properly, expensive lifting equipment and
tackle will last that much longer if well
taken care of.
P
some time now, is not a legal requirement and not
iet Otto of Phakamisa Safety Consultants, a recommended by lifting tackle manufacturers.
company that specialises in safety, training,
“The reason is straightforward,” Piet elaborates.
plant audits, registers and codes of practice
“Why apply a test load to lifting tackle if it is obvi-
for the lifting industry, speaks to “Bulk
ously damaged, worn or shows any defect during
Handling Today.” “Firstly you have to select the
a visual inspection? Rather just scrap it. On the
correct lifting equipment and then use it correctly,”
other hand, why apply a load test to lifting tackle
he says to outline what a safe lifting programme
if it does not show any sign of damage, abuse or
entails. “The records of lifting equipment on your
deterioration, rather use it. A proof load test is in
premises must always be up to date. They should
effect a 100% overload and, in fact, repetition can
not only contain copies of the certificates from
severely damage the lifting tackle or weaken it as
your suppliers, but also records of the inspections
a result of the overload applied thus reducing the
carried out on the equipment.
working life of the sling.”
A misconception in the lifting industry, spread by certain
Registers
service providers who want to make easy money, is that A while back Piet realised that keeping proper
a company’s LTI has to be a registered LMI records is a serious shortcoming in industry in
T
o learn more about the art of manufacturing
overhead cranes, “Bulk Handling Today”
speaks to Frikkie Henning, Service Manager
at East Rand Cranes. “It is crucial to first
ascertain the duty cycle of a crane before you decide
on building a light, medium or heavy duty crane,”
he says. “It is also important to consider future
expansion of the business so that you don’t run
out of capacity when the duty cycle of the crane
increases due to heavier lifting more frequently.
A common mistake is to underestimate the forecast
which means that clients run out of capacity very
quickly
“If, for example, you’re using the crane all day long
to lift three tonnes and only lift ten tonnes once in
a while, then a light duty crane will suffice because
you’re not working at full load all the time,” Frikkie
explains. “However, if this crane starts working at Frikkie Henning, Service Manager at East Rand
Cranes
For a long crane life, it is essential to service a crane of overloading, but because it is working hard
frequently more frequently and the duty cycle chosen was
incorrectly calculated.”
full load all the time, the customer should have
chosen a medium duty class from the beginning Building a crane
otherwise the crane simply won’t last, not because East Rand Cranes manufactures crane systems
either to supplied specifications
or they are designed to spec ac-
cording to the customers forecast
of the crane’s duties. “A common
mistake is to underestimate the
forecast which means that clients
run out capacity very quickly,”
Frikkie says. “Even if specifica-
tions are supplied, we will always
advise the customers to make sure
his or her forecasting is realistic
in terms of what he expects the
crane to do now as well as in
the future.
“The situation where the light
duty crane starts doing the work
of a medium duty crane before
long should be prevented from the
outset,” says Frikkie. “However, if
medium duty work is introduced
over a long period of time, it is
possible to upgrade the hoist and
A hoist in the workshop
the crane to a certain degree,
but it can be costly because all
the components including the gearbox on a crane
are designed to a specific duty cycle. On very
rare occasions you can mix the components and
use a 2M duty gearbox with a 1M duty motor, for
example.”
Structures
It is also important to assess the support structures
that the crane will be mounted on because one ten
tonne crane may weigh much more than another
and therefore the structures have to be inspected
beforehand as well. “Up to 3M duty the crane
design is pretty standard, but when it reaches the
4M duty class cranes, the crane itself becomes
much bulkier,” says Frikkie.
“For example, if you put a ten tonne 2M duty crane
and a 4M duty ten tonne crane next to each other
you’ll clearly see that the 4M class is of a much
bulkier construction than the other in spite of hav-
ing the same capacity. The girder and components
are built specifically to withstand the high stresses
associated with heavy duty craning. The class of
crane therefore determines the type of support
structures necessary for the rails.”
The workshop
Frikkie takes us through their workshop where
cranes of various sizes are in different stages
of completion. Hoists, motors, electrical control
panels and reels of steel rope are being fitted into
place on small and large girders with huge Demag
overhead cranes, for which East Rand Cranes are
the agents in South Africa. neglected, especially when times are tough like
Behind welding screens, the flare of arc welding now. But as we maintain service records for our
lights the place sporadically as we ask Frikkie about customers, it’s one less thing for them to worry
the actual construction procedures. “A completed about because we’ll call them up to advise when
crane has many of its sections hidden behind other a service or a load test is due.”
components and therefore we have very specific Linton Moodley, East Rand Cranes, Tel: (011) 817-3423,
holding points during construction,” he explains. Email: linton.moodley@eastrandcranes.co.za
“Our quality control procedure requires the inspec-
tion of all welds to check whether penetration is
correct, whether the stag-
ger is correct and so on.
Before any weld is covered
with something else, it
has to be inspected and
signed off by our internal
inspector.
We have very
specific holding
points during
construction
W
der, submitting statutory returns, controlling high
e speak to John Sprenger, Owner- cost areas, and administering arrangements with
Driver manager for Cargo Carriers insurance companies, financial institutions and
about their successful driver-owner other third parties.
programme.
Cargo Carriers assists the drivers by providing fuel
Due to the ongoing success of the Cargo Carriers’ and maintenance services, properly maintained
Swaziland Empowerment scheme, which includes trailers, infrastructure, systems, experience and
five Cargo Carriers Swaziland Truck drivers operating back-up.
as owner drivers, a further 11 existing Swaziland
drivers have been appointed as owner drivers. Working together
On the education front, the candidates receive inten-
The success of the programme depends on the owner sive training through Cargo Carriers’ four-day train-
drivers rendering the outsourced transport work to the ing programme. Two days are spent on contractual
satisfaction of Cargo Carriers and service provider issues, operating parameters,
accounting matters and budgeting principles, and
is conducted by John Sprenger. The remaining two
The aim of the programme is to empower drivers
days cover entrepreneurship, business management,
who would otherwise never have an opportunity
problem solving, and business communications
to become successful entrepreneurs. The most
and is conducted by LCC Capital.
important aspect of the owner-driver programme is
the identification and training of suitable candidates The first task for each of the drivers is to employ
and the experience they receive. a co-worker and two shared workers per branch to
ensure that they can provide a double shift, 24/7
Successful entrepreneurs operation for the 8,5 month crop season. The
The new owner-driver programme commenced at the owner-drivers must, therefore, strike a balance
start of the new 2009 Swaziland cane crop season. between both control and supervision measures.
Five of the 11 drivers are based at the Swaziland
Simunye branch, while the remaining six are based “The success of the programme depends on the
at the Swaziland Big Bend branch. owner drivers rendering the outsourced transport
work to the satisfaction of Cargo Carriers and its
“In terms of the service agreement with each of customers. Customer service cannot be compro-
the 11 new owner drivers, certain portions of two mised at any stage. It is vitally important that the
of the Cargo Carriers Swaziland contracts are out- drivers ensure that the correct product, of the right
sourced to the drivers. These include the hauling quality, is timeously delivered to the customers as
of infield cane from fields to the loading zone or per the daily delivery schedule,” adds John.
field edge, and the hauling of cane from the fields
to the mill,” explains John. Grassroots level
“This programme is all about a con-
tinuing partnership; where the drivers
are empowered to determine their own
success and the direction of their own
future. This is not boardroom empower-
ment, instead it is aimed at a grassroots
level because that is where true success
lies!” concludes John.
Elmarie Ollewagen, Business Development &
Communications Manager, Cargo Carriers,
Tel: (011) 485-8700, Fax: (011) 485-8781,
E-mail: elmarie@cargocarriers.co.za
Conveyor Idlers
Conveyor idlers are generally considered a consumable element of the conveyor. Their unit value is relatively
low when compared to the price of a pulley, plummer blocks or the conveyor belting. However, there are many
idlers within a conveyor system. Consider a typical in-plant conveyor, say 250 m long – typically this would
comprise 5 pulleys, 250 trough idlers and 80 return idlers, further broken down into 750 trough rolls and 80
return rolls (160 if V return idlers are used).
C
onsidering the possibility of damage re- required duty.
sulting from a failed idler roll (increased
An investigation of existing idler standards showed
friction, increased belt cover wear, pos-
that the idler load rating was specified in CEMA.
sibility of fire due to increased friction
This allowed the designer to specify a specific idler
and the possible catastrophic damage to the most
category to suit the required duty in accordance with
costly piece of equipment, the belt) it is clear that
the CEMA classification. One small problem was
a careful selection of the idler for a specific duty
that the CEMA standard was not readily available in
is required.
the old highly sanctioned South African market.
Selection The idler committee was again called together,
The failure of an idler roll is dependant on a mul- this time to update the standard to incorporate a
titude of factors including the initial specification method to allow for the selection of idlers to suit
based on the selection of the roll to suit specific specific duties. The committee decided to amend
design criteria, the inherent product quality and the standard by creating a Part 3 which would in-
the accuracy with which its components are manu- clude the performance criteria and testing methods
factured and assembled. previously incorporated in Part 1 as well as a duty
The committee decided to amend the standard by based selection method.
creating a Part 3 The development of Part 3 has been a continuing
project since 2004 and it is hoped that it will be
This paper reviews the development of SABS/SANS concluded in 2009.
1313, identifies in basic format the loads applicable
to idlers and defines the criteria used to select The basis for idler design
the idlers based on the identified maximum load Prior to discussing the creation of SANS 1313 Part
conditions. It then relates this to available selec- 3 it is worthwhile to review the factors affecting
tion standards and introduces the latest revisions idler design as well as idler selection criteria.
to SANS 1313, undertaken to ensure that the Idler loading
standard retains its relevance and high regard in The total load on an idler is established from the
the idler industry. following factors:
The available idler standards are: SANS 1313 • Burden or material load
PART 1, PART 2, PART 3 – 2009? • Mass of the belt
The first variation one notices is the change in • Self mass of the rollers
nomenclature from SABS (South African Bureau of • Secondary loads such as misalignment loads
Standards) to SANS (South African National Stan- (tension), loads due to dynamic effects (speed
dards), this being due to a realignment and creation and material dependant) , loads due to belt
of different business units within the SABS. geometry (curves)
Noticeable is the inclusion of a Part 3. The foregoing are well defined in most conveyor
The existing specifications and particularly SABS idler catalogues and in CEMA.
1313 Part 1 incorporated only a ‘series’ in differ- Selection criteria
entiating between idlers of different load carrying Once the total load on the idler has been calculated
capacity. Part 2 followed the part 1 format, but for the idler may be specified and selected on the basis
different styles of idlers (eg. fixed and linked sus- of the following criteria:
pended idlers). The idler series basically specifies
the diameter of the shaft at its ends (implying that • Roller diameter in terms of belt speed
this equates to the bearing inner diameter). • Roller bearing types and size
• Shaft diameter
Calculating the load on the idler and hence the • Idler base materials
most highly loaded roll carrying capacity within
the idler set was left up to the conveyor system Selection criteria for idler rolls
designer. The designer would typically select the Once the total load on the idler has been calculated
roll shaft diameter and bearing type to suit the the load applicable to individual loads can be cal-
culated by applying a Burden Factor (Burden Factor vantages of the use of taper roller bearings, in that
is the proportion carried by the most highly loaded under conditions of heavy load the significantly
roll) to the total load to obtain the individual roller higher load rating (when compared to a deep groove
loads. Typical burden factors on 3 roll trough idlers bearing) is reduced exponentially by the effect of
is 0.7, i.e. 70% of the total load is carried on the misalignment of the bearing components.
centre roll. The Burden Factor is dependant on the
Selection criteria for idler bases
idler type, trough angle, the material characteristics
Having calculated the total load on the idler, the
and the belt fill ratio.
main load carrying member of the idler base (typi-
The committee believes that it took the process further cally a rolled steel angle section) is selected on the
by including the shaft deflection criterion within the load basis of the following typical criteria:
rating • Maximum bending stress – dependant on type of
construction – typically 100MPa – 165MPa.
Having calculated the load on the most highly
• Maximum deflection at centre of 1/360 of
loaded roll, the roll is selected on the basis of
the mounting centres but limited to 5mm
three criteria
maximum
• Bearing life
• Shaft deflection
SANS 1313 ratings
The CEMA procedure gave the committee an indi-
• Shaft bending stress
cation of the way forward.
The bearing life and shaft deflection criteria are
The committee believes that it took the process
somewhat interdependent in that the formula for
further by including the shaft deflection criterion
calculating bearing life is only applicable in cases
within the load rating.
where the alignment between the inner and outer
cages (equivalent to the generically termed ‘shaft The process followed is as follows:
deflection’) remains within pre-defined limits. The bearing life criterion was selected as 40,000h
to match the requirements of SANS 1313.
Typical values for these selection criteria
are: The maximum load to achieve the 40,000h bearing
• Bearing life (as calculated using the L10 formula) life was calculated for different types of bearings
between 30,000 hours and 60,000 hours. based on the individual bearing Dynamic Load
• Shaft deflection dependant on bearing type. Rating at a roll rotating speed of 750rpm (the limit
Typical values for deep groove ball bearings set by SANS 1313).
are between 6-15 minutes of arc, highly de- The maximum load to limit the deflection to that
pendant on the type of cage material used. specified by the bearing manufacturer (dependant
Typical values for taper roller bearings are on bearing type and with due cognisance given to
between 2-6 minutes of arc dependant on the manufacturing tolerances) was then calculated.
geometry of the rolling elements. This was applied to all the roll lengths defined in
• Shaft bending stress of 110 MPa. SANS 1313 using a generic roll seal to determine
The values quoted for shaft deflection are the the ‘overhang’ dimension.
maximum allowable bearing value onto which it The lower of these two values (life and deflection
is practical to allow the idler manufacturer some dependant) was then selected as being the roll
leeway for manufacturing inaccuracies – hence rating for a specific roll face length.
typically the limits for deep groove ball bearings
Using the standardized sealing system and the
are set at between 5-10 minutes, again dependant
abridged data shown in the tables below a series of
largely on the bearing cage construction.
tables giving the maximum load carrying capacity
The foregoing illustrates one of the major disad- of a specific roll were created.
Bearing details Note that the life crite-
Bearing reference: 420204 420205 6205 6206 6305 6306 6307 6308 rion is based purely on
Static load rating: 5 11 7.8 11.2 11.6 16 19 24 kN a maximum roll rotating
Dynamic load rating: 10.4 12.7 14 19.5 22.5 28.1 33.2 41 kN speed and thus the need
Revs per minute: 750 750 750 750 750 750 750 750 RPM to replicate the tables for
Required bearing life: 40000 40000 40000 40000 40000 40000 40000 40000 hrs
different roll diameters is
Maximum bearing load in N: 855 1044 1151 1603 1850 2310 2729 3370 N
not required.
Maximum bearing load in kg: 87 106 117 163 189 235 278 344 kg The tables to be presented
Table 1: Data Used for Life Criterion in SANS 1313 Part 3 will
include:
Bearing ref: 420204 420205 6205 6305 6206 6306 6307 6308
Allowable bearing deflection to DIN: 14.0 14.0 15.0 15.0 15.0 15.0 15.0 15.0 min• 3 roll Trough
Basic allowance for manufacturing inaccuracies 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 min and Impact
Allowable deflection for calculation purposes: 8.0 8.0 9.0 9.0 9.0 9.0 9.0 9.0 min• 5 roll Trough
and Impact
Table 2: Data Used For Deflection Criterion
• 2 Roll V and Flat Return It will continue to ensure that the South African
• Separate tables for 3 and 5 roll link suspended idler manufacturing sector retains its good stand-
(garland) idlers. This is necessary to account ing amongst the worldwide materials handling
for the larger dim. Normally encountered with fraternity.
this type of roller. This paper has been condensed due to space constraints.
Two typical tables, for 3 roll Trough and Impact and The author is Adriano Frittella. This paper was first
for 2 roll Vee and Flat return are included below. presented at Beltcon 15 held in Johannesburg on Sep-
tember 2 and 3, 2009 and copyright is vested with the
Utilising CEMA without taking note of IMHC. Enquiries can be made through the website; www.
shaft deflection can lead to significantly beltcon.org.za
reduced roller life
Discussion
It is noted that the examples are merely 3 Roll troughing and impact
a direct comparison of tabulated values Belt width: Gauge: Allowable load on the centre roller in kg *
not reflecting the full design process, 400 180 174 213 235 377 327 471 556 687
however they give a clear indication 450 200 174 213 235 377 327 471 556 687
of the basic difference in approach 500 210 174 213 235 377 327 471 556 687
proposed by the two codes. 600 250 174 213 235 377 327 471 556 687
It is clear from the above that the major 750 300 174 213 235 377 327 471 556 687
difference between CEMA and SANS 900 350 164 213 235 370 327 471 556 687
1313 is the non-adherence in the CEMA 1050 400 139 213 235 312 327 471 556 687
code to the shaft deflection criterion. 1200 460 119 213 235 263 327 471 556 687
This becomes increasingly significant 1350 510 105 213 235 232 327 440 556 687
as the roll length increases. 1500 570 93 213 221 204 327 385 556 687
1650 620 85 207 201 185 327 349 556 687
Utilising CEMA without taking note of 1800 670 78 190 184 169 327 319 553 687
shaft deflection can lead to significantly 2000 750 69 168 163 149 315 281 486 687
reduced roller life. 2100 775 66 162 157 144 304 270 468 687
When considering SANS 1313 a note 2200 810 63 154 149 137 289 257 445 687
to the tables stipulates that ‘shafts are 2400 880 58 141 136 125 264 234 405 637
plain and not stepped’ i.e. the shaft Allowable load on 1019 2243 1590 2365 2283 3262 3874 4893
diameter is the same throughout its centre roller
length. Bearing ref: 420204 420205 6205 6305 6206 6306 6307 6308
Series: 20 25 25 25 30 30 35 40
There is clearly an economical case for The above loads do not include the rotating mass of the roll.
reducing the shaft diameter at its ends The rotating mass of the roll should be subtracted from the above roller load.
(depending on loading) and utilising * shafts are plain and not stepped
a bearing of smaller diameter. This Table 3: Roll Selection - 3 Roll Trough and Impact
may however create problems when
specifying replacement parts as the 2 Roll vee & flat return
user can only readily see the shaft Belt width: Gauge: Allowable load on one roller in kg *
end and will use this as the selection 600 310 174 213 235 377 327 471 556 687
dimension. 750 410 135 213 235 303 327 471 556 687
900 485 112 213 235 247 327 468 556 687
Conclusion 1050 570 93 213 221 204 327 385 556 687
In conclusion, the idler committee of 1200 645 81 198 192 177 327 333 556 687
the CMA is constantly reviewing the 1350 730 71 173 168 154 324 289 501 687
idler standard SANS 1313 with the 1500 810 63 154 149 137 289 257 445 687
aim of maintaining it as the premier 1650 895 57 139 134 123 259 230 397 625
worldwide specification. 1800 975 52 127 122 112 236 209 361 567
The soon to be issued revised specifica- 2000 1085 46 113 109 99 210 186 321 504
tion comprising three sections 2100 1156 43 106 102 93 196 174 300 470
2200 1195 42 102 98 90 190 168 289 453
• Part 1 – defining the dimensional
requirements of all rolls and of 2400 1308 38 93 89 81 172 152 262 410
‘foot mounted’ idlers Allowable load on 1019 2243 1590 2365 2283 3262 3874 4893
centre roller
• Part 2 - defining the specific require- Bearing ref: 420204 420205 6205 6305 6206 6306 6307 6308
ments for under-slung idlers Series: 20 25 25 25 30 30 35 40
• Part 3 – defining the performance The above loads do not include the rotating mass of the roll.
requirements and load ratings of The rotating mass of the roll should be subtracted from the above roller load.
idlers * shafts are plain and not stepped
Supply
that have gone above and be-
yond the call of duty to enhance
the
environment in which they oper-
Chain
ate.
Awards
enjoyed a wonderful response
from the supply chain community
and everything is on track to make
this year’s event one of the indus-
try’s most prestigious accolades.
24
30 BULK HANDLING
Supply TODAY
Chain Today Jan 2010
Jan 2010
HARBOURS & PORTS
D
uring the 1980’s, the South
African company Rocon intro-
duced the concept of loading
ships using a standard GP
container with a tipping device. Unfor-
tunately information with regards to this
pioneering development is scarce and
it is unknown if any Rocon devices are
still in operation at present.
The uniqueness of this handling
solution may necessitate some
explanation
Containers are used as the primary medium for storage, transport and handling of bulk Once the material is discharged the in-
materials within a handling system of this type ner frame, together with the container,
returns to its original orientation and the
whole unit travels back to the quay. The
unit is lowered to the rail platform where
the twistlocks are disengaged and the
system is ready for the next cycle. The
operating cycle is therefore similar to the
handling of standard containers.
Container tippler (prototype) – 1st
generation
Bulk Connections Terminal in Durban
was the user of the first unit which was
delivered in 2003. As it was a novel
concept, the entire system was closely
monitored for the duration of the first
year of operation. During this period the
system handled 580 000 tons of sized
coal. The average load per cycle was
25 tons and a loading rate of 18-20
tips per hour was maintained. A daily
output of 10 000 tons of the sized coal
was achieved.
The introduction of the system proceeded
Tipping the load
without any major technical problems. Some minor has come under the spotlight. The entire clamping
modifications were required to resolve teething is- philosophy was reviewed and an improved clamp-
sues, mainly the introduction of guards to protect ing concept was developed. This necessitated
the electrical and hydraulic equipment that was changes to the shape and guiding installation of
liable to be damaged during the operation of the the clamping beam, which have subsequently been
unit. When the first unit was recently overhauled, introduced. The new clamping method will reduce
no trace of fatigue cracking was recorded. Some the chances of impact when lowering the tipping
impact damage was found on the clamping beams device onto the container.
which probably stems from rough operational
practices. Technical parameters of the 2nd generation of the tippler:
- container type 20” open top or 20” GP (top removed)
Container tippler - 2nd generation
The experience gained from monitoring the opera- - capacity 35.0 ton (excl. container mass),
tion of the first unit was employed to improve the - typical cycle time 120-150 seconds,
design of the second generation device. The main - clamping time 4 seconds,
objective of the design review was a mass reduc- - tilting time 15-19 seconds,
tion. Originally the mass of the tipping unit was
- twistlock lock/ unlock 1 second,
approximately 21 ton. As a result, the combined
weight of the tippler, container and payload in some - twistlocks ISO universal,
cases exceeded the loads normally encountered - weight 12.0 tons excl. head block,
in container terminals. This limited the use of - material handled no limitation.
the device, as standard cranes required structural
modifications.
Containers
A FEM based optimisation process, combined Containers are used as the primary medium for
with the benefits of an improved control system, storage, transport and handling of bulk materials
has helped to lower the mass of the design to within a handling system of this type. The selection
12 tons. This is close to the mass of a standard and design of these units is therefore an important
single–lift telescopic spreader, which is the basis aspect from a systems perspective. It should be
on which most of the container handling equip- noted that such containers are only used on land
ment is rated. within the confines of the handling terminal and
Further attention was given to reducing power are therefore not subject to marine standards in
consumption. Torque requirements for various pay- terms of strength and rigidity.
loads throughout the tipping range were simulated The use of an open-top container system provides a
to find the optimal geometry of rotation. Installed terminal operator with great flexibility
power and the size of the tilting cylinders could
thereby be optimised. When the original unit was commissioned, Bulk
Due to the impact damage which was observed Connections decided to opt for modified secondhand
on the clamping beams, the clamping procedure containers to minimise the cost. The modifications
included the re-
moval of the upper
wall of the contain-
ers and welding
the doors closed.
It was found that
these secondhand
containers had a
service life of ap-
proximately 5 000
cycles.
Four new contain-
ers were also built
and operated in
parallel with the
older units. These
units exhibited no
trace of fatigue
damage after 12
months of opera-
tion. Data collected
during this period
gives an indication of the most economical container to be handled. Container terminals are no longer
selection for specific operational philosophies, cycle restricted to the handling of containerised cargo
times and duration of operation and storage. The but are also able to deal with bulk materials. The
capital invested for different container types can be process of stacking containers for bulk materials
weighed against each other considering the number is not significantly different from stacking general
of units in circulation and the lifespan of each. purpose dry containers. Handling of containers
carrying bulk materials can therefore be done using
Great flexibility
standard container infrastructure.
The use of an open-top container system provides a
terminal operator with great flexibility. There are no The material can also be stored in the containers,
restrictions to the quantity and variety of materials depending on the requirements of the port opera-
tor. The need for capital outlay associated with
Due to the universality of the system components and conventional stockyards, stockyard equipment and
operation, it lends itself for use in diverse fields of rail tipplers is therefore eliminated.
application Diverse fields
Due to the universality of the system
components and operation, it lends
itself for use in diverse fields of ap-
plication. For example, ThyssenKrupp
is investigating the use of a derivative
system for supplying coal to power
stations during emergencies. A com-
plete handling system can be set up
in a few months based on standard
container handling equipment such
as reach stackers, straddle carri-
ers, container cranes and overhead
cranes.
Such machines are also readily
available on the secondhand market.
Because the entire system is based
largely on the “off the shelf” equip-
ment, it can be financed for long or
short term operation on an equipment
lease basis.
More information can be found on Thys-
senKrupp, Website:www.thyssenkrupp-
materialshandling.co.za
When
you talk about a bulk
coal terminal in KZN, most people as-
Terminal with
a Difference
sume you’re talking about the coal
handling operation in Richards Bay. In
the meantime, the port of Durban has
a very active ‘boutique’ bulk terminal
tucked away on the Bluff where dry
bulk is handled with kid gloves.
“Our main prod-
uct line now is
sized coal, steam
I
or unsized coal,
ain Geldart, managing director of Bulk Connec- copper concen-
tions, a Bidvest company that owns this bulk trates, manganese
operation in Durban’s port speaks to “Bulk and metallurgical
Handling Today”.“During a privatisation initia- coke, but we also
tive in the late eighties, we took over this operation do other commod-
purely as a coal handling terminal but over the ities in smaller
years the facility has been diversified to include a quantities,” adds
variety of dry bulk products,” he says. Iain. “We used
to do grain un-
Soft handling literally entails handling the product very til the facility in
carefully so that it’s not broken down to smaller sized Durban port at
chunks Maiden Whar f
was upgraded
with ship loaders
and unloaders spe-
cifically to handle Iain Geldart, managing director, Bulk
grain through this Connections
port.”
Unique equipment
Although Bulk Connections leases the 4-berth site
from the National Port Authority, all the equipment,
developed specially for the ‘soft’ handling of bulk
commodities, belongs to them. “The ship loaders,
for example, are quite unique in that we converted
the old type 30 tonne container cranes to 50 tonne
capacity specifically for our purposes,” Iain says.
“A thorough finite element analysis on these old
cranes showed that by simply strengthening the
front legs, they could be modernised with new
motors, gearboxes and brakes. We also converted
the drive system from DC to AC to accommodate
variable speed drive control.”
Sized coal
Soft handling literally entails handling the prod-
uct very carefully so that it’s not broken down to
smaller sized chunks which would happen if it were
dropped from a certain height. This is crucial as
sized coal, for instance, ends up as unsized coal
which is an inferior grade.
“The handling process basically consists of loading
the product from stockpile or other storage with a
front-end loader into an open top container which
is hauled by a special harbour-type tractor to the
ship loader,” explains Iain. “The ship loader picks
Bottom discharging coal the container off the high capacity trailer, over
the hatch of the ship and then through doors at The system
the bottom of the container which open up to let In their search for the best solution in soft handling
the product out softly. After trying various other worldwide, Bulk Connections sourced various
methods, we’ve found that this unique container bits and pieces of equipment from around the
design lets the product out gently.” globe and had this unique design engineered and
manufactured locally coming in lighter than the
In the morning it may be loading coal at one of our three
previous system they used. “The system works
loading berths and by the afternoon it could very well be exceptionally well for sized coal, but it’s also very
off-loading metallurgical coke good for concentrates because concentrates tend
to stick to the vertical sides of chutes
and transfer points, blocking everything
up,” adds Iain.
“With our container system, however, the
whole load simply slumps out, resulting
in exceptionally good load rates with
all the materials we handle. Another
difficult material to handle in bulk is
manganese ore, which is very lumpy
and highly abrasive. The bottom-open-
ing container system is very efficient in
that we’re loading an average of 24 000
tonnes of manganese a day compared
with a dedicated manganese loading
system that averages 12 to 15 000
tonnes a day.
Grab
“It’s a hybrid system in that the same
crane is simply fitted with a 25 cubic
An aerial view of the terminal in Durban port
metre grab mechanism in the place of
O
TH
R
AN
S
ES
IM
AL R
S I N DIS T
SO
CI ETY
FO
SHOW THEM YOU CARE BY MAKING A MONTHLY DONATION! SO
CI ETY F
O
E
E
TH
R
R
TH
As little as R50 a month, or whatever you can comfortably afford, can make a BIG difference in an animal’s life.
S
S
AN
AN
ES
ES
M
R
IM
AL AL
I
R
S I N DIS T S I N DIS
NAME : ______________________________________________________________________________________________
32 BULK HANDLING TODAY Jan 2010 Advanced Materials Today September 2007 39
Market Forum
An iron garden
Alpha Sand and Klip continue to service local
demand for sand and stone for a variety of
construction projects in and around Polok-
wane. This 36-year old business operates a
mixed fleet, but owner Jannie van Warveren
has thirteen Volvo trucks in his fleet.
“I’m married to machinery and I live in an
iron garden,” are some of the first words said
by Jannie as we sit across his boardroom
table in his family run business in Annadale,
Polokwane. His wife Cathy and his two sons
Niekie and Jannie work alongside him.
“Vehicles are my life,” he adds as he ex-
plains how he has been in the transport
business since 1973. He started his fleet
with a 1954 Albion which is still working
as a water bowser on the current site he is
processing for river sand and stone.
Jannie first operated Volvo’s in the 70’s and
was very pleased to hear of their return to
the market in 1994. “I went to find out what
was available and I was even more of a fan
when I began to experience the very high
service standards offered by Volvo that just
had no equal at the time.
“We are still happy with Volvo now and the
service we get locally and I hope before I
retire, I will be able to buy a Volvo 660hp
unit. I already have the low-bed trailer in Jannie’s 25 Volvo trucks transport sand,
my yard,” he adds with a laugh. stone and concrete products to the
construction and mining industries
Volvo (Southern Africa) (Pty) Ltd, Tel: (011) 842-
5000, Fax: (011) 842-5037, www.volvo.co.za
Top award
SEW Eurodrive South Africa was announced as the winner
of the Top Gender Empowered Company award in the Min-
ing, Engineering and Construction sector during a glamorous
Ute Bormann, GM Sales and Marketing receiving the award on behalf
awards ceremony held in Johannesburg on 18 November of SEW Eurodrive, from Connie Nkosi - Non Executive Chairman:
2009. First Technology, Gauteng; Chief Executive Officer: Lidonga Invest-
The awards form part of the Top Woman in Business and ment Holdings (Pty) Ltd
Government Awards which is held annually. This award goes
The company has appointed women in senior positions such
to the company that demonstrates the most success in tack-
as General Manager: Sales and Marketing, General Manager:
ling and improving gender empowerment in their respective
Operations, National Marketing Manager, Financial Manager,
sector. Important factors are measurable and accountable
National Stock Controller, Exports Co-Ordinator, Head of
leadership that is committed to developing women in the
Internal Sales and as a Non Executive Director.
company and the per capita expenditure on training, educa-
tion and development of women. SEW-Eurodrive Pty Ltd, Rene Rose, Tel: (011) 248-7000, Fax: (011)
248-7289, Email: rrose@sew.co.za, www.sew.co.za
Accepting the award on behalf of the company, Ms Ute
Box-container tipper
An all-new box-container tipper from Flexicon forms a dust-
tight seal between the container and the equipment, tips the
container, and discharges bulk material through a chute at
Celebration
Tip-Tite Box-Container Tipper from Flexicon forms a gasketted, dust-tight connection be- GIBB, one of Africa’s largest multi-dis-
tween the container and the equipment, tips the container to either 45, 60, or 90 degrees ciplined engineering and science con-
past horizontal, and discharges bulk material through a chute at controlled rates sulting companies celebrates the 11th
controlled rates. Trademarked Tip-Tite, the tipper accommo- anniversary of its Rail Division this year,
dates boxes including truncated corner boxes, from 915 mm and is right on track when it comes to handling the boom in
to 1 220 mm on a side,
and 990 mm to 1 117
mm overall height.
The container platform is
raised by a single hydraulic
cylinder, creating a dust-
tight seal between the top
edge of a box (or rim of a
drum) and the underside of
the containment hood. Twin
hydraulic cylinders then
pivot the platform-hood
assembly, with container
intact, to either 45, 60
or 90 degrees beyond
horizontal, including a mo-
tion-dampening feature at
the termination of container
rotation.
An optional, gasketted, top
discharge gate actuated by
twin pneumatic cylinders,
provides a large opening