Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
Introduction
A second possible solution to urban transport problems was identified and analysed
in the previous unit.
In unit 6 the concepts of accessibility and mobility will be explored and transport
problems in rural areas will be addressed. Finally the initiatives to address rural
transport problems will be highlighted.
Introduction:
Unit 5 identified a second possible initiative to reduce the negative effects of urban
transport problems. In unit 6 mobility and accessibility will be defined and rural
transport problems will be identified alongside a brief summary of long-distance
transport.
The concepts of mobility and accessibility are straightforward. The dictionary defines
mobility as "the ability to move or be moved" and accessibility as “the ability to be
reached". (In recent years the term “accessible” has also been applied to the need
for vehicles and facilities to be able to cater for physically challenged users).
In present circumstances, the car is the most comfortable and convenient method of
travel for nearly all journeys. It provides protection from unpleasant weather, well-
upholstered and assured seats, personal control of heating and ventilation and the
opportunity of travelling in privacy. For family outings, journeys can be made in a
more relaxed way than by public transport. Extra passengers do not have to pay an
extra fare.
The car possesses the characteristics of a mobile living room, with a choice between
comparative quiet and a radio programme. The car also fulfils a psychological
function as a status and prestige symbol. There is considerable satisfaction in
knowing that a trip can be made relatively effortlessly because it is "in attendance" in
the driveway or on the road, and that for instance a friend living 50 km away can be
reached in an hour. In addition, the range of opportunities for leisure or shopping is
substantially widened.
Any point on the road network can be considered as the destination for a particular
trip, provided there is room to park. As a particular result of this flexibility, there is a
wide choice of home and work locations. This gives car transport a "seamless"
quality, against which public transport will be compared.
While a car is available on a 24 hour basis, public transport operates only during
certain hours or on certain days. Someone without a car has to judge whether a trip
can be made by public transport and must find out whether a service is available for
both outward and return journeys. Trips are restricted by the routes on which public
transport is available and by the time available for the trips. There is also less
flexibility as journey times have to be planned to meet bus or train schedules;
services outside rush hours are infrequent, all-night or late-night services absent in
most areas, and normal services reduced during holiday periods. Added to these
difficulties is the psychological deterrent of the unreliability of public transport
services and the inconvenience and potential frustrations when transfers are
necessary. Since individuals usually have to pay separate fares, family (or group)
travel is also discouraged.
Public transport lacks the exclusiveness of the car, mainly because it is less
independent and personalized. Public transport trips involve uncertain lengths of
time standing at stops. Once on the vehicle it may be crowded and stuffy, frequent
acceleration and deceleration can be uncomfortable or even dangerous, and there
may be no vacant seats. The risk of violence at stops and in vehicles is also a
factor. On the other hand, the public transport passenger has the advantage of not
being involved in the strain of driving, and does not have to find a parking space.
Journeys made by train are free from the frustration of congested roads affecting bus
and car alike, and except in rush hours, a train can be used in comparative comfort,
and with a fairly precise knowledge of the time it will take to reach the destination.
The vast difference between the levels of mobility provided by private cars and public
transport respectively has significant implications for urban transport policy, since
one of the objectives of the government's transport policy is to introduce a certain
degree of "equity" between all citizens. This means that the users of public transport
should not be unduly disadvantaged when compared with the users of private cars.
As suggested, a major criterion for mobility in most areas (including rural areas)
should be that most journeys by public transport should not take more than three
times longer than the same journey by private car. The authorities should,
nevertheless, be required to consider the need for minimum levels of public transport
in all parts of the urban area in order to achieve this objective.
Once a policy decision has been taken to provide minimum levels of mobility for the
population, a number of parameters must be adopted in order to achieve them.
Three basic parameters can be identified, under the following headings
Before discussing each of these parameters it should be borne in mind that it will in
all likelihood be necessary to enter into a contractual relationship with providers of
public transport (by way of contracts and concessions) to ensure that they are
provided.
This measure of performance relates to how near the population lives to a public
transport route. Different transport studies have found that, in general, walking times
of more than 15 minutes (roughly equivalent to 1 000 meters) are regarded as
unacceptable. The community will tend not to use public transport under these
circumstances unless it has no choice. A possible measure for a transport network
could be that, say, 80% - 90% of the community should live within 15 minutes
(1 000 meters) of a public transport route. The use of an 80% - 90% measure allows
the use of a sparser route pattern in areas of low population density. In areas where
road surfaces are unsuitable the routes may also have to be spaced further apart.
Availability consists of two elements - (a) frequency of service, and (b) spread of
service.
(a) Frequency
(b) Spread
This parameter relates to the number of hours over which the services operate.
Practically on routes this may mean a spread of services starting at 04:00 in the
morning and continuing until midnight. On other routes or over weekends the spread
may be narrower - say from 06:00 until 18:00 only.
This term relates to the ability of the passenger to reach any destination served by
public transport in the area, within a certain period of time. Although proximity and
availability may be adequate, the routes may be such that users are forced to travel
in a roundabout way to reach their destinations. The effect of this can be seen in the
following diagrams which represent a route pattern in a city.
In figure 6.1 (a), for example, everyone may live within 1 000 meters of a route.
Frequencies and spread may also be good. However, anyone wishing to travel from
A to B must travel via the center of town, which could take as much as six times
longer than the direct route by car. It would probably be quicker to walk from A to B
than to go by public transport! In figure 5.1 (b), the introduction of a new route
(indicated by the dotted line) linking a number of suburban generators of traffic,
would substantially improve accessibility in the area. Few transport studies
specifically address this issue, but a general rule could be that passengers should
reach their destinations at an average speed of say 10 - 12 km per hour (measured
in a straight line) from the time they start their journeys on public transport. (This is
broadly similar to the rule that no journey on public transport should take more than
three times longer than a private car).
The effect of this requirement implies the introduction of more direct routes between
different parts of the city and region (particularly between major shopping centers,
office parks, etc.) and the operation of a minimum level of service on such routes at
all reasonable times.
Figure 6.1 Representation of a route pattern in a city
B
B
A A
(a) (b)
In virtually all South African cities there are examples of shopping centers and other
developments which are inadequately served by public transport. This contributes to
the lack of mobility experienced by a large percentage of the community.
6.1.5 Summary
In order to ensure that all residents of urban and rural areas enjoy adequate levels of
mobility and accessibility, it will be necessary to adopt parameters which will ensure
a minimum guaranteed level of public transport.
The adoption of the mentioned parameters will assist in achieving the requirement
that no journey on public transport should take more than, say, three times longer
than by private transport.
Requirements for transport in rural areas are no less pressing than in urban areas,
except that the extent of the problems vary from area to area. Obviously the
requirements for proximity, availability and coverage will be relaxed considerably. In
some cases routes may be as much as 15 to 20 km apart, while services may
consist of only one trip in the morning and another in the afternoon. In the section
that follows the concept of rural transport will be discussed.
Rural transport is aimed at serving communities outside of urban areas. The need for
rural transport has been associated with providing mobility and accessibility to
employment opportunities as well as goods and services. Rural transport also
increases the quality if living for residents as it provides access to employment,
schools, places of worship and social and recreational activities. In most cases,
access to public transport in rural areas are limited especially in terms of travel
times, distance covered and frequency of service offered (US Department of
Transport (2019).
Mobility articulates the ease or difficulty with which the rural population move around
and move their goods. The ease of mobility is affected firstly by the available
transport infrastructure and secondly by the means of transport.
Modes of rural transport most commonly used in Africa include walking, motorised
vehicles, however, walking is by far the prevalent mode of transport.
Table 6.1 (Connerley & Schroeder, 1996) represents rural access. In this table it is
evident accessibility depend on mobility as well as the quality of the available
transport facilities. Mobility is achieved by using the available means of transport
(e.g. walking, intermediate transport and motorised transport) on the available rural
transport infrastructure (e.g. community roads, paths, tracks, trails and tertiary
roads).
Water and fuel (e.g. wood) are the most basic items that the population in Sub-
Saharan Africa consume daily. Transporting these items can be costly. At the same
time the cost involved with consuming social services such as health care and
education is influenced by the transportation cost of moving between the residence
and the site where the service is offered.
ACCESSIBILITY
MOBILITY
Quality of
Facilities
Rural Transport Infrastructure Means of Transport
Community Walking
Intermediate Motorized
Roads, Paths, Tertiary (with and
Means of Transport
Tracks and Roads without
Transport Services
Trails loads)
Not a lot of research has been done on the everyday lives and transport challenges
faced by the rural population. According to Connerley & Schroeder (1996) the
average adult residing in a rural area in Africa spends at least one and a quarter
hours per day on travel. Travel is mostly done for the following reasons:
These trips take place a few times a day (e.g. frequent trips), follow a regular pattern
and are always close to the destination. Most of the time spent on travel is actually
spent on domestic task as previously described
People in rural areas make trips to buy agricultural inputs and after crops have been
harvested they travel to markets to sell it. These trips are made frequently and it is
mostly to nearby destinations.
Less than one percent of travel by the rural population is undertaken to visit health
facilities.
For social reasons people living in rural areas will travel making use of motorised
commercial transport. It is not essential travel but does contribute to the total number
of hours spent on travel.
Olayemi (2019) identified various types of rural transport problems or challenges and
these include:
Before moving on to the next section it is evident that the lack of effective transport
services in rural areas remains a challenge in many countries. All over the world and
especially in Africa, many poor live in rural areas and there is a need for basic
infrastructure, like roads, access to basic health care and education as well as
proper motorised transport services.
Topic 6.4 Initiatives to address the problems (Rural Transport Strategy SA)
The predicament of rural people has been highlighted by numerous policy studies
and considerable public awareness has been created via the media. In South Africa
50% of the population is rural. Rural areas contain 72% of those members of the
total population who are poor.
Compared to their urban counterparts, rural people also have vastly inferior access
to basic social services and the economic mainstream. Given this context, the
delivery of rural transport infrastructure and services can be a significant catalyst for
sustainable economic development, improved social access and poverty alleviation
in South Africa’s rural areas. For this reason a Rural Transport Strategy was
developed.
In this section the Rural Transport Strategy for South Africa (2007) will be looked at
as it proposes strategies to address the problems related to rural transport. This
document was initially compiled in 2007 and is currently in the process of being
reviewed.
The main aim of the strategy is to contribute to the growth of local and provincial
economies by improving people’s access to public transport. In doing this the
connectivity between urban and rural areas will be improved.
The full strategy document can be accessed on the internet, but for the purpose of
this unit only a few aspects of the document will be highlighted.
Rural transport infrastructure and services in South Africa include the following
categories and role players (Rural Transport Strategy, 2007):
Now that the most important actors in the rural transport environment have been
identified, it is necessary to analyse the key challenges that limit service delivery and
sustainable development in the rural areas of South Africa.
Wide diversity of rural areas: Rural areas vary widely in terms of climatic
conditions and population densities
Historical backlog: Under-investment in certain areas and types of
infrastructure continues whilst other areas have more infrastructure that
cannot be maintained
Reactive response to historical backlog: Provision of infrastructure such as
streets, water, sanitation and electricity have a tendency to to reinforce rural
settlement patterns and are not sustainable
High incidence of rural poverty: Rural areas tend to be very poor and there
are various barriers related to this, e.g. digital divide, where people do not
even have access to basic digital devices such as telephones
Physical remoteness and low population densities: Some rural areas are very
remote and accessibility and transport provision is problematic
Spatial dispersal of investment: Investments are mostly for central place
facilities or nodal facilities, e.g. schools and clinics, and this can increase the
logistical problems related to service delivery
Low economies of scale and high operating overheads: A good example of
this is when a clinic is built in an area but there is not sufficient staff to operate
and it has to be closed down after a while
Increasing need for resources: There is an increased need for resources to
deal with the effects of HIV-AIDS. This can place increased burden om
already unsustainable demands from local resources
Bottom-up participation and information empowerment: There is a big need to
have a process of bottom-up participation and information sharing in place. It
is important to attend to all the crosscutting issues as well
Technical and managerial weaknesses: Many rural and district councils and
municipalities are in need of capacity building to better technical and
managerial know how.
Flowing from the discussion on the challenges or rural transport, the Rural Transport
Strategy (2007) identified two strategic thrusts. These are:
The main aim should be to develop an effectively interlinked network of nodes and
linkages. To develop a balanced rural transport system, the following is required
(Rural Transport Strategy, 2007):
“The need for a sustainable rural transport system relates to the need to create
sustainable funding channels and procurement systems, address neglected road
maintenance requirements, and develop improved structures for the management of
storm water (which is the major cause of deteriorating road conditions in most “deep”
rural areas). The need for sustainability also requires that attention be given to the
impacts of the rural transport system on the wider social, economic and biophysical
environment” (Rural Transport Strategy, 2007:38).
The delivery of most rural transport infrastructure will be the responsibility of local
governments. The long term focus of strategy is on facilitation, coordination and
strengthening of service delivery in rural areas. In order to guide and support this
and act as mechanism for implementation of the strategy, a Rural Transport
Development Programme (RTD programme) will be created (Rural Transport
Strategy, 2007). This programme consist of 21 strategic actions and in order to
guarantee coherence, these actions have been grouped in terms of the following
“action areas”:
For the purpose of this unit only action area B, the High-leverage focus projects and
programmes, will be addressed. In this action area, the essential actions intended at
leveraging and enhancing the delivery of rural transport infrastructure and services
will be highlighted. The principal objective is to redress the imbalances in the
provision of rural transport services and provide an example of how a more balanced
rural transport system can be established.
The core set of strategic actions aimed at leveraging and enhancing the delivery of
rural transport infrastructure and services is depicted in table 6.2.
Table 6.2 Strategic actions aimed at leveraging and enhancing the delivery
of rural transport infrastructure and services
It would be unrealistic to expect rapid progress in a short period of time due to the
difficult operational environment of rural areas as well as the huge range of
imbalances that need to be corrected. However, the Rural Transport Strategy (2007)
aims leveraging existing public, private and community based activities to
accomplish noteworthy results in the foreseeable future.
In this unit the concepts of mobility and accessibility were defined. These are two
concepts that are significant when talking about rural transport. Furthermore this unit
explored rural transport. It looked at what rural transport encompass as well as the
transport challenges faced by rural communities on a daily basis. Lastly the Rural
Transport Strategy of South Africa was looked at to see what possible solutions
there are for the rural transport problems in South Africa. The unit that follows, and
the last unit for this module will deals with the topic of road safety and management.
REFERENCES: