Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
A Geographic Analysis
Jason P. Block, MD, MPH, Richard A. Scribner, MD, MPH, Karen B. DeSalvo, MD, MPH, MSc
Background: Environmental factors may contribute to the increasing prevalence of obesity, especially in
black and low-income populations. In this paper, the geographic distribution of fast food
restaurants is examined relative to neighborhood sociodemographics.
Methods: Using geographic information system software, all fast-food restaurants within the city
limits of New Orleans, Louisiana, in 2001 were mapped. Buffers around census tracts were
generated to simulate 1-mile and 0.5-mile “shopping areas” around and including each
tract, and fast food restaurant density (number of restaurants per square mile) was
calculated for each area. Using multiple regression, the geographic association between
fast food restaurant density and black and low-income neighborhoods was assessed, while
controlling for environmental confounders that might also influence the placement of
restaurants (commercial activity, presence of major highways, and median home values).
Results: In 156 census tracts, a total of 155 fast food restaurants were identified. In the regression
analysis that included the environmental confounders, fast-food restaurant density in
shopping areas with 1-mile buffers was independently correlated with median household
income and percent of black residents in the census tract. Similar results were found for
shopping areas with 0.5-mile buffers. Predominantly black neighborhoods have 2.4
fast-food restaurants per square mile compared to 1.5 restaurants in predominantly white
neighborhoods.
Conclusions: The link between fast food restaurants and black and low-income neighborhoods may
contribute to the understanding of environmental causes of the obesity epidemic in these
populations.
(Am J Prev Med 2004;27(3):211–217) © 2004 American Journal of Preventive Medicine
W
hile obesity has a range of causes from ge-
in the United States.10 U.S. spending on fast food has
netic to environmental, the environment is a
risen from $6 billion to $110 billion over the last 30
key factor in the rapid development of the
years.11
obesity epidemic.1– 4 Increased food consumption may
Fast food is notably high in fat content,12 and studies
be the most important of recent changes leading to an
have found associations between fast food intake and
obesogenic environment.5 Despite stable physical activ-
increased body mass index (BMI) and weight gain.13,14
ity patterns during the last 20 years,6,7 Americans are
eating more,8 portion sizes have increased substantial- These same studies reported increased consumption of
ly,9 and inexpensive, high-calorie food is now fast food among nonwhite and low-income popula-
ubiquitous. tions. Despite these relationships between income,
The growth of the fast-food industry has been an race/ethnicity, obesity, and fast food, limited research
important environmental inducement for increased to date has examined such associations on an ecologic
food consumption. In the last 20 years, the percentage level. Morland et al.15 examined the relationship be-
tween fast-food restaurants, race/ethnicity, and wealth
as an ancillary analysis in a large ongoing study based in
From the Tulane University School of Medicine, Department of
Internal Medicine (Block, DeSalvo), New Orleans, Louisiana, and
the United States, and discovered no consistent rela-
Louisiana State University Health Sciences Center, Department of tionship between wealth, measured with census tract
Public Health and Preventive Medicine (Scribner), New Orleans, median home values, and fast-food restaurants. Addi-
Louisiana
Address correspondence to: Karen DeSalvo, MD, MPH, MSc, tionally, they found no difference between the num-
Department of Internal Medicine, Tulane University School of Med- bers of fast-food restaurants in black and white neigh-
icine, 1430 Tulane Avenue, SL 16, New Orleans LA 70112. E-mail: borhoods. Reidpath et al.16 found diverging results in a
kdesalv@tulane.edu.
The full text of this article is available via AJPM Online at study addressing fast-food restaurant density and me-
www.ajpm-online.net. dian individual income in Melbourne, Australia. Resi-
neighborhoods (i.e., 80% black) have one additional let density, presence of highways, and median home
fast-food restaurant per square mile compared with values. Second, they did not utilize shopping areas as
predominantly white neighbohoods (i.e., 80% white). the area of geographic exposure for a neighborhood.
These findings suggest that black and low-income pop- This method is important because many census tracts
ulations have more convenient access to fast food. More do not have any fast food restaurants; however, people
convenient access likely leads to the increased con- residing in these tracts are still geographically exposed
sumption of fast food in these populations,13,14 and to restaurants that are nearby but not within the tract
may help to explain the increased prevalence of obesity boundaries. By creating shopping areas, geographic
among black and low-income populations. exposure is more effectively modeled. Third, the mea-
Researchers chose to evaluate geographic associa- sure of wealth in the current study was median house-
tions with FFRD in shopping areas with 1-mile and hold income. No consistent relationships between
0.5-mile buffers because of an uncertainty of how far FFRD and median home value (the measure of wealth
individuals were willing to routinely travel outside their used by Morland et al.15) were found in this study
census tract to purchase food. The use of shopping either.
areas defined by 1-mile buffers seems more justified Other geographic research has shown associations
based on reports regarding McDonald’s strategy for between neighborhood demographics and exposure to
franchise locations. McDonald’s has established a res- consumer goods that contribute to negative health
taurant within a 3- to 4-minute trip for the average consequences. As previously discussed, Reidpath et al.16
American.19 Under the assumption that an individual found similar results to this study when comparing fast
drives 25 miles per hour, a McDonald’s should be food restaurant density to median household income
located within approximately 1.5 miles of the average among neighborhoods in Melbourne, Australia.
American’s home. This distance is more consistent with LaVeist and Wallace,20 as well as Scribner et al.,21 found
shopping areas with 1-mile buffers than those with that liquor stores are more commonly located in pre-
0.5-mile buffers, thereby potentially explaining the dominantly black and low-income neighborhoods.
more powerful results for the 1-mile buffer analysis. Other studies have found links between higher densi-
ties of alcohol outlets and increased rates of alcohol-
Geographic Associations related outcomes, such as motor vehicle crashes22 and
Morland et al.15 reported contrasting results from the assaultive violence.23 For food availability, Morland et
current study, but their study diverged from this study al.15 found that wealthy and predominantly white
in several ways. First, they did not adjust their analysis neighborhoods have more supermarkets and fewer
for other environmental factors that might influence neighborhood grocery stores than poor and predomi-
the placement of fast food restaurants. In the bivariate nantly black neighborhoods, an important finding be-
analysis, a significant (although weak) relationship be- cause research indicates that supermarkets have more
tween FFRD and the percentage of black residents “heart-healthy” foods when compared to neighborhood
existed, which increased substantially after controlling grocery stores and convenience stores.24 Still others
for environmental confounders, including alcohol out- have demonstrated a positive association between in-