ES&T Comment: Seven ideas lost on AmericaEnvironmental Science & Technology

Online News
http://pubs.acs.org/subscribe/journals/esthag-w/2008/feb/policy/030108_comment.h
tml
Home Articles ASAP Online News Current Issue Search
Current IssueKey Links
Online Manuscript Submission & Review
Supporting Information
Meetings Calendar
Links to Environmental and Funding Sites
RSS Newsfeeds
Sample Issue (free)
Where are the A-Pages?
Research
Research ASAP
(As Soon As Publishable)
Current Issue
Author Index
Supporting Information
Online News
Latest News
Science
Technology
Policy
Business & Education
Archives
Key to Online News Icons
Authors/Reviewers
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Author Guidelines
Reviewer Guidelines
Ethical Guidelines
Copyright/Permissions
Feature Guidelines [PDF]
Subscribe
How to Subscribe
RSS Newsfeeds
E-mail Alerts
Recommend ES&T to your librarian (pdf)
Sample Issue (free)
Info for Advertisers
Advertising Information
Ad Rates (Print)
Ad Rates (Web)
A-Pages
Where are the A-Pages?
A-Page Archive
About ES&T
About the Journal
Website Guide
Site Map
Masthead (PDF)
Editors (PDF)
About News & Features Staff
Technical Support
Contact Us
 Online News: Latest News | Science | Technology | Policy | Business &
Education | Archives ES&T Comment February 13, 2008
Seven ideas lost on America
Americans aren't stupid. I have come to the conclusion that we are either in a
state of perpetual denial or in a fog of permanent confusion. Whatever the case,
we are overlooking some pretty important ideas that contribute to the current
environmental crisis.
1. Our unsustainability is immense. Americans don't realize how far out of whack
we are with respect to any measure of sustainability. We are so far off, we
don't know what the questions are. In recent Iowa caucuses, the presidential
candidates swooned over the promise of biofuels. But nobody mentioned that if we
were to devote all of the agricultural land in the country to biofuel crops, we
still couldn't produce the U.S. transportation fuels required. We use 3 4
gallons of petroleum for each person in the country every single day! We can't
hope to grow our way out of this we are so massively out of balance.
2. Tipping points are irreversible. Americans can't grasp that we are on the
path to an ice-free planet and that it would take centuries, or even millennia,
to reverse the process leading us to this point. We have warmed the earth by
emitting gases from the combustion of coal, oil, and gas that took 300 million
years to form, since the beginning of the Carboniferous Age, and we have been
releasing them into the atmosphere for the past 300 years. The earth has already
warmed somewhat (0.8 °C), causing the Arctic ice and permafrost to melt. If the
Greenland and Antarctic ice shelves begin to fall into the sea, we would have
"breached a dam" in sea-level rise that would require hundreds of thousands of
years to repair. People don't really believe that a severe storm or fire will
destroy their homes, yet they invest in insurance against that possibility why
can't we do the same when it comes to climate change?
3. Time lags bite. Americans like to believe that the cavalry will always come
to the rescue that it is just over the horizon. But what if the cavalry needed
to arrive long ago? Unfortunately, the CO2 emitted today will remain in the
atmosphere for more than 100 years. So it will take a long time, more than a
century, after we begin to cut emissions to stabilize the problem. We have
already set into motion 0.6 °C more warming even if we could level off CO2
tomorrow at today's level of 385 ppm. But we can't. Just to stabilize the
atmosphere at 450 ppm CO2 and to prevent dangerous interference with the climate
system will require an 80% cutback in emissions by 2050, and it must begin soon.
4. Species matter. Many Americans believe that the loss of species is an
inevitable consequence of economic growth. Species have always gone extinct and
will continue to do so. Who cries for a ferret? But humans have accelerated the
natural loss of species by more than 100-fold, and their demise alters the
planet in a myriad of ways. When crops are no longer pollinated by bees, when
coral reefs collapse to only a few species, and when disease vectors are no
longer kept under control naturally, we may begin to understand the
consequences.
5. Free markets aren't free. Republicans love markets, and Democrats love
markets. But our markets aren't free we fail to pay for the destruction of land,
water, and air. When populations were small and territory was immense, natural
capital didn't matter so much. But now it does. The environment itself is a
commodity and must be valued as a scarce resource. If one fills the atmosphere
with CO2, one should pay for it. Capitalism will fail if we can't comprehend
this idea.
6. Inaction can be more expensive than action. Americans are looking at the
prospect of reducing emissions in the wrong way. Instead of seeing it as
something onerous that will ruin the economy, people should realize that steps
to reduce emissions would create high-quality jobs in the future. It will cost
far more not to act. How many Hurricane Katrinas, droughts in Atlanta, and fires
in the coastal desert can society withstand?
7. Technology alone can't do it. Americans believe that technology will always
pull us through. From the Manhattan Project to the green revolution to putting a
man on the moon, technology has always been the savior. And technology will
certainly play a role in our transition from the fossil fuel age. But the human
dimension of how to organize ourselves to save the planet is the most daunting
challenge of all. The U.S. must provide leadership, compassion, and inspiration
to reverse this problem. It will require a change of heart, not simply a change
of mind.
Jerald L. Schnoor
Editor
est@uiowa.edu Home | Articles ASAP | Browse Issues | Online News | Search
Copyright © 2008 American Chemical Society